The Highlander March 2019 Vol X Issue V
Carlmont High School — Belmont, California
www.scotscoop.com @scotscoop
Changing the body changes the mind Julia Rhodie In 2017, 229,000 cosmetic procedures were performed on girls between the ages of 13 and 19, the American Society of Plastic Surgeons (ASPS) reports. Living up to the Western standard of beauty has presented many challenges for modern society. This modern society idealizes a narrow prototype of the perfect woman. Young girls in particular fall victim to societal pressures of being “beautiful.” According to a study conducted by the Dove Self-Esteem Fund, 98 percent of girls feel there is an immense pressure from external sources to look a certain way based on their environment. Additionally, since plastic surgery can be costly and potentially dangerous, psychological implications are something to consider before proceeding with operations. “When assessing a client who is interested in getting plastic surgery, the first thing I consider is their mental health,” said Emily von Scheven, a licensed m a r riage a n d
family therapist (LMFT). “I think the person’s mental health is really important to keep in mind because you can have someone who has a stable ego [have] plastic surgery and respond in a really positive way. On the other hand, some people who have a very poor sense of self will never be satisfied with the results.” Such an obsession on a perceived flaw could lead to a diagnosis of body dysmorphic disorder, according to the Mayo Clinic, a nonprofit medical center located in Minnesota. It is believed that there are other reasons for people wanting plastic surgery. “I think there's a generational piece to it, too. I think that if you were to look at certain people's older female relatives, we would find a parallel between the way they addressed their insecurities and the way their children do,” von Scheven said. Toby Chasinov*, said, “When I was much younger, my mother got a nose job because she had what could be considered a ‘Jewish nose’ that she was insecure about. Later in my life, when addressing my insecurities, I partially modeled my decision to get plastic surgery after what I witnessed from my mom during my childhood.” But the generational pattern wasn’t the only reason Chasinov decided to get plastic surgery; she also saw the opportunity as a reward for her years of hard work. “I have been on a fairly restrictive weight loss, diet, and workout regimen for over six years. I got the procedures as a treat to myself that I deserved,” Chasinov said. Plastic surgery can either be a major self-esteem booster or a let-down; it is the patient’s prerogative to learn from the situation. “Everybody has their own insecurities that they are battling with. I think that it is important to embrace these insecurities and love yourself, but I am nobody to judge others’ decisions. It does not affect anybody but the person actually getting the surgery,” Oria Farkash, a senior, said. Adults who should be showing signs of aging are being praised for their artificially-devised vitality. However, teenage girls get attention from their peers for having physical features more mature than their age. As the ASPS reports, “Teens view plastic surgery as a way to fit in and look acceptable to friends and peers. Adults, on the other hand, frequently see plastic surgery as a way to stand out from the crowd.” Among the most popular procedures for teenagers between the ages of 13 and 19 are rhinoplasties (nose reshaping), otoplasty (surgical correction of protruding ears), breast augmentation, and correction of breast symmetry, according to the ASPS. However, before any work can be done, the plastic surgeon must evaluate several factors. While parental support is required, the teenager’s own desire for plastic surgery must be clearly expressed over a period of time. The teenager must also acknowledge and understand both the benefits and limitations of plastic surgery in order to avoid unrealistic expectations for its results. Lastly, the teenager must be in the position to tolerate
the discomfort and temporary disfigurement of a surgical procedure, the ASPS guidelines say. Furthermore, both von Scheven and the ASPS report that plastic surgery is not recommended for teens who are prone to mood swings, abusing drugs or alcohol, or being treated for clinical depression or other mental illnesses. “I think you need to be well-informed before putting yourself in any kind of potential danger,” Farkash said. “You need to make sure that it is actually something that you want to do.” Although plastic surgery appears to be a surface level change, the impacts on patients go deeper than the skin. “The appropriateness of the patient receiving plastic surgery entirely depends on the patient themself,” von Scheven said. “If somebody is not happy, ultimately, within themselves, they're never g o ing to find what they need.” *name has been c h an g e d for privacy
In This Issue
News Sports Lifestyle Features
Psychology of Change
Muscial Passions Students shape their lives around future careers in music. Page 9
Prom Season As prom season comes into full swing, the promposal competition begins. Page 13
Sojourn to the Past Carlmont's annual Soujourn trip inspires students to take action and make a change. Page 14
Campus Opinion Community Change my Mind
2-3 4-5 6-7 8-9 10-11 12-14 15-17 18-19 20