The Highlander December 2016 Vol VIII Issue III
Carlmont High School — Belmont, California
www.scotscoop.com
Twitter: @scotscoopnews
Mascots incite racial tension Megan Tao
CBS MINNESOTA
Carl Monty strides onto the football field. Screamin’ Scots erupt into cheers, “Scots, Scots, Scots!” A student dressed in a kilt plays the bagpipes. All is well, and no one sees anything wrong with an entire student body culturally appropriating the Scottish figure. With the rise in controversy over the appropriateness of Native American mascots, few have stopped to question whether having other race-related mascots like the Scots or the Celtics is just as bad as having a Native American mascot. Barbara Munson (Oneida), a member of the Oneida Tribe and the chairperson for the Wisconsin Indian Education Association “Indian” Mascot and Logo Taskforce, believes that one of the reasons why people aren’t questioning the appropriating of European mascots is because European immigrants make up the majority of the U.S. population. “A lot of the people who make up the mainstream of America right now are Scottish people, English people, and Irish people. A lot of the immigrant population makes up the mainstream now and the Native Americans, which were 100 percent of the population at the time of contact, are now less than 2 percent of the population in the Americas,” said Munson. Not only is there a lack of discussion about European mascots, but it also seems that this negativity towards racial mascots is only directed at mascots that represent a minority, specifically Native Americans. “Race-based Indian team brands stereotype 565 different cultural groups all of whom are Indians here in the United States, so it’s a huge racial stereotype. It is a racial issue, not a cultural issue; in fact, part of the problem is that it’s not a cultural issue,” said Munson. According to SFGate, in 2001, the Sequoia Union High School District board decided to retire the Cherokee mascot and image of Sequoia High School, but still keep the official title as the Sequoia Cherokees. “I think that it was changed for racial reasons. Some people thought that it was racist to be portraying Cherokees as the school mascot. It’s like the controversy with the Washington Redskins,” said Sequoia High School senior Kierstin Ikeda. The Native American mascot controversy seems to be dealing with the idea that it’s not politically right to culturally appropriate a race because they’re human beings that are a part of one culture and are being generalized to fit the overall Native American race. “It is a problem that this is all generalized and [people are] taking different cultures that represent different language groups, different cultural traditions, and dif -
GETTY IMAGES
See ETHNIC MASCOTS page 3
IZZY MITCHELL
INSIDE THIS ISSUE CAMPUS NEWS FEATURES HOLIDAYS LIFESTYLE SPORTS OPINION PARENTING
2 3 4-5 6-7 8 9 10-11 12
The secularism of Christmas
2016: The worst of them all
Reflecting on Obama’s legacy LAST PLACE
(PAGE 2)
(PAGE 5)
(PAGE 11)