Star named Reward School, again
‘60 Minutes’ doesn’t understand newspapering
DK holds off MV to win cheer jamboree
See Story on Page 2
See Editorial on Page 4
See Story on Page 14
THE HASTINGS
VOLUME 160, No. 3
BANNER Devoted to the Interests of Barry County Since 1856
PRICE 75¢
Thursday, January 17, 2013
Hastings teachers, school board ratify contract NEWS
BRIEFS Chamber dinner reservations due
Final reservations are due tomorrow for the annual Chamber of Commerce dinner to be held Saturday, Jan. 26, at Yarrow Golf and Conference Center near Bedford. The “Winter Wonderland” themed event will begin with cocktails and hors d’oeuvres at 5 p.m., followed by dinner at 6 p.m. and member celebration and awards — including Athena Award recognition — at 7 p.m. Cost is $45 per person, and RSVPs are requested by emailing Carol Vogt, carol@mibarry.com or calling 269-9452454.
Seniors invited to COA’s mid-winter luau Area residents are encouraged to kick out the winter blahs with the annual mid-winter luau party at the Barry County Commission on Aging Thursday, Jan. 24, beginning at 10:30 a.m. Luau attire is encouraged to help melt away the winter blues. The Cost is $2.50 for anyone 60 years or better. Reservations are requested by calling the COA, 269-948-4856.
Cyber-bullying is topic of family workshop series The family workshop series that begins Jan. 21 will focus on cyber-bullying and the dangers of unsupervised Internet activity. Michigan State Police Trooper Kellie Summerhays will be the speaker for the evening, and will discuss the dangers of misuse of computers and cell phones. The family workshop series will be in Middleville Jan. 21 at the First Baptist Church and in Hastings Jan. 28 at the First Baptist Church. Participants should register by calling 269-945-5439. Free pizza dinner begins at 5:30 p.m. with class and child care from 6 to 7:30 p.m. All participants receive a certificate of participation for training.
Great Decisions discussion group forming The 2013 Great Decisions topics will be discussed in eight weekly meetings at the Hastings Public Library’s community room, beginning Feb. 5 and each Tuesday thereafter from 2 to 4 p.m. The eight topics for this year are Future of the euro; Egypt; NATO Myanmar (or Burma) and Southeast Asia; humanitarian intervention; Iran; China in Africa; and threat assessment. Each meeting will depend on participants reading a short but intensive 10 pages on the topic before class so they are prepared to discuss it, followed by viewing in class a 25-minute DVD in which experts will discuss the topic. The meetings are open to all interested persons, with discussion preference given to those who have registered and bought the materials for the course. For information on how to join, call moderator Eileen Oehler, 269-948-2347, as soon as possible so more books may be ordered before Feb. 5, as needed.
by Sandra Ponsetto Staff Writer After months of often contentious negotiations, the Hastings Education Association and the Hastings Board of Education have reached a contract agreement. The HEA ratified the contract Friday, and the board gave its approval Tuesday evening during its January work session. The board approved the contract unanimously with trustee Rob Longstreet abstaining because his wife is a member of the HEA. Negotiations began in April 2012 as part of the re-opening of a two-year contract settled in 2011 that allowed re-opening for financial situations. Because the school system ended the previous fiscal year with an audited deficit of $622,607, the district appealed to the HEA to re-open negotiations. However, talks became more heated in September after teachers rejected an “on-schedule” 6 percent salary reduction that negotiators had tentatively agreed on with the board. The onschedule reduction — or permanent pay
decrease as opposed to a limited-time reduction — became a sticking point, and negotiations entered mediation. The HEA and board reached a tentative agreement Dec. 20, 2012, and Jan. 9, the date scheduled for a fact finding session before state judge, the HEA announced the tentative agreement and plans to ratify the contract. The main components for the two-year contract for the 2012-13 school year are: A 6 percent off-schedule reduction in pay starting halfway through the year; one unpaid furlough day on which teachers will work but not receive pay; a reduction from $450 to $400 per month of the in-lieu-of allowance for teachers who opt out of the insurance; a cap on health insurance at the state rate for the duration of the contract; and no step increases for additional years of service. Staff will still receive increases for educational degree advances at their steps; and, the extra-duty pay schedule will remain at the reduced level agreed to in previous negotiations. Components of the contract for 2013-14
include continuation of the 6 percent reduction in salary— 3 percent on schedule, and 3 percent off; no step increases for additional years of service; staff will still be eligible for educational degree increases at their step; the extra-duty schedule will remain the same; health insurance will remain capped at the state rate; and the in-lieu-of payment will remain $400 per month. Newly named board vice president Jon Hart said he appreciated the concessions the teachers made in the contract. “I want to first thank the teachers for their sacrifices to help repair the budget deficit,” he said. “It’s not easy. “The main reason I am voting in favor of this, to me, is that it does help move us to a better place financially, as a district. It’s a two-year agreement and it buys us some time to work together as a team to work on things like strategic planning,” said Hart. “Strategic planning, if we do it right, do it well, will lift us and move us forward as an entire community and a system. To me, that is actually big-
ger in the grand scheme of things.” Later in the public comment portion of the meeting, Hart said that some comments he had heard from a member of the public during one of the two previous board meetings revealed what he called a loser’s mentality. “Saying that we’re in an impossible situation, kind of a generality, I just want to say that to me that is a loser’s mentality, and I’m about winning,” said Hart. “Anybody that knows me, it’s about winning. And, to me, the best days of the Hastings school district are in front of us, not behind us. Our time is coming and it’s going to be sooner rather than later.” Past board president Kevin Beck said the contract was not one he would have chosen. “I am not saying this is an agreement that will not work,” he said. “This contract is a short-term solution. It begins to address, but not solve, the structural issues that we face. The Hastings teachers are in the top 25 percent statewide in average salary. With this
See CONTRACT, page 2
County board still looking for volunteers by Doug VanderLaan Editor Calling all volunteers ... urgently calling all volunteers. That’s the message from Barry County Commissioners who expressed confusion and frustration during Tuesday’s committeeof- the-whole meeting at the lack of response to open and advertised positions on two key countywide committees. “It’s costing the county money when we can’t fill openings because now we have to re-advertise,” said Vice Chair Ben Geiger. “We have a page full of people on the parks and recreation board in non-voting positions. Is there nothing in place to elevate them to voting positions on the board?” Geiger was referring to three open positions on that board for which only two applicants — Steve Shults and former commissioner Dan Parker — expressed interest. Currently, 35 citizens sit on the Parks and Recreation Board as members or non-county resident stakeholders. Only 12 carry voting privileges. When informed that no means exists to automatically elevate qualified members to voting status, a frustrated Geiger responded,
“Maybe they need to look at their bylaws.” The bafflement intensified when commissioners moved to fill four openings on the agricultural preservation board, for which only Larry Neil applied for reappointment. “Why is it so difficult to get people to apply for these openings?” asked Commissioner Joyce Snow, who, in this case, was told that because of the contention with which the agricultural preservation board has been involved recently, no one was likely to be interested in application. “We’re struggling with getting paperwork together,” explained Commissioner Jim Dull, the board’s assigned liaison to the agricultural preservation board, who cited the gift of the DeGroote Farm to the land preservation program as an example of past difficulties. “We received state and federal money for the purchase along with the DeGrootes’ gift of 25 percent of the cost,” related Dull, “but it still cost the county $2,500 for the paperwork. People can gift property, but it still costs the county money to accept it. We’re not looking at spending county money on this project.” The search for applicants to fill four open
positions between the two boards, however, apparently will cost additional county money. Fortunately, no additional money will be required to fill openings on the animal shelter advisory board and the Commission on Aging board. The county board recommended the appointments of Laura Satterfield to a oneyear appointment, Tamara Dickinson to a two-year appointment, and the reappointment of Mary Fisher to a full three-year appointment on the animal shelter advisory board. Satterfield and Dickinson will fill unexpired appointments on the board. Also recommended for approval by commissioners at next week’s official board meeting were the appointments of Janet Geukes and Kenneth Moore to three-year terms on the Commission on Aging board. Three candidates applied for the two openings. Current COA board member Debbie Massimino re-applied and was interviewed by telephone at her Lansing office where she is finance director for Hospice of Lansing. “This is a very difficult one,” said Geiger in choosing from three highly qualified applicants for two positions. “Debbie did say that, if she were not re-appointed, she would
continue to be involved as a volunteer.” Board members, who voted 6-0 with Commissioner Jim DeYoung not in attendance to approve the appointment of Geukes and Moore, cited the direct and individual experience as being assets to coming COA challenges. Geukes has involved seniors in COA activities through work as a senior activity advisor for the Barry County Fair and as an participant in the Relay for Life Dinner for Survivors. As a licensed building contractor, Moore is expected to provide guidance on a possible future COA building reconstruction or redesign. The recommendations to appoint Shults and Parker to the parks and recreation board and Neil to the agricultural preservation board also were unanimously approved. In other business, the board: • Approved a recommendation that cat adoption fees be increased to $70 and adoption fees for dogs to $90, plus a license fee. Current fees are $10 for cats and $20 for dogs, but Animal Shelter Director Diana Newman proposed that all adoptable animals be spayed or neutered and vaccinated for
See VOLUNTEERS, page 2
City council names Tossava mayor pro-tem; sets calendar for year by Sandra Ponsetto Staff Writer Hastings Mayor Frank Campbell opened the Hastings City Council’s annual organizational meeting with a state of the city address in which he summarized highlights of last year, such the completion of the Michigan Avenue bridge, Art Park in the 1st Ward Park, Michigan State Housing Development Authority grants used to develop secondstory housing in downtown, new business development. He compared it to 10 years ago when a new bridge, a linear park along the Thornapple River and downtown revitalization were still in the planning stages. “We come a long ways,” he said. Prior to Monday’s meeting, council members joined the young men and women actively involved in the Hastings Skate Park for a pizza party, sponsored by Pastor Randall Bertrand of Woodgrove Brethren Christian to celebrate a $15,000 donation the city received in December for improvements the park. The donation is from a software developer in recognition of his business relationship with Hastings Mutual Insurance Company, which was the first local company to implement the software. The donor said he wanted the funds to benefit local youths. In 2012, the City of Hastings officially assumed responsibility for the maintenance of TangleTown the community-built play structure at Bob King Park, from the nonprofit
Circle of Friends, which had disbanded since the playground was built in 1997. During his report Monday evening, Hastings City Manager Jeff Mansfield said he had received a letter from a young man from the Grand Rapids area who recently visited Hastings and Bob King Park with his girlfriend who grew up here. He wrote that his girlfriend showed him the fence surrounding the play structure, which had the name of many community members engraved on them, including one in memory of her mother, who died seven weeks after his girlfriend’s birth. The young man asked if it was possible to have his girlfriend’s name inscribed on a picket. Mansfield and Hastings Community Development Director John Hart said they would look into developing a program that would once again allow groups and individuals to purchase pickets and have them engraved. Mansfield said funds raised from the sale of pickets could then be used for maintenance of the structure. In other business, the council: • Unanimously elected council member David Tossava as mayor pro-tem for 2013. • Set the schedule of regular council meetings for 2013 as 7:30 p.m. on the second and fourth Monday of each month, except Tuesday, May 28, in place of Monday, May 27, which is Memorial Day; and, Tuesday,
See COUNCIL, page 2
Former Tepper residence burned as training exercise The Middleville home where several dead dogs were found in October is destroyed Sunday as part of a firefighter training exercise. The home previously belonged to Marcie Tepper, a special animal control advisor to Barry County Sheriff Dar Leaf. Tepper was subsequently charged with animal cruelty. The new owner said the Finkbeiner Road residence was so contaminated with animal remains and feces, he needed to destroy the home; it could not be renovated. The fire was started by the Thornapple Fire Department at approximately 11 a.m. Sunday, and the house burned completely within 40 minutes. The fire crew left the premises at 2 p.m. Tepper is scheduled for a hearing on a misdemeanor animal cruelty charge Tuesday, Jan. 22.