The Queen's Journal, Volume 143, Issue 1

Page 1

queensjournal.ca

Introducing the new

the journal Professor’s academic freedom violated, report finds

Vol. 143, Issue 1

T u e s day , J u n e 2 , 2 0 1 5

since

1873

Morteza Shirkhanzadeh brings 2005 Professor allegations of research misconduct to Queen’s

2011

Shirkhanzadeh banned from three campus buildings and email communications with Queen’s employees

creates a website to publish allegations 2012 ofShirkhanzadeh misconduct after University investigation ends

Queen’s accuses Shirkhanzadeh of harassment and 2014 threatens discipline if website not taken down

2015

CAUT report concludes that Queen’s violated Shirkhanzadeh’s academic freedom

CAUT report finds “pattern of retaliation” against professor alleging research misconduct J acob R osen News Editor According to a report published last month by a national union association, Queen’s has taken steps over the past 10 years to silence an engineering professor who attempted to expose evidence of research misconduct. Morteza Shirkhanzadeh, PhD, an associate professor in the Department of Mechanical and Materials Engineering, has provided Queen’s with alleged instances of plagiarism and fabricated or falsified data in scientific papers written by another Queen’s professor in 2005, who will remain unnamed due to legal concerns. The Canadian Association of University Teachers (CAUT), a nationwide union association, represents 68,000 university teachers. According to the report, “The behaviour of Queen’s Administration in this matter is a typical reaction of an organization that has to deal with issues brought to it by a whistleblower. Rather than deal with the allegations in a fair and impartial manner, it seeks

Letter from Provost and Vice-Principal Robert A. Silverman to Dr. Morteza Shirkhanzadeh, with Principal Daniel Woolf and Bill Young, chair of the Board of Trustees, copied.

to silence the whistleblower to preserve its own reputation. “We conclude that there is a pattern of retaliation against

Professor Shirkhanzadeh in response to his allegations of fraud and misconduct.” However, Queen’s Provost

SUPPLIED BY LITTLE OFFICE OF RESEARCH INTEGRITY (LORI)

Alan Harrison told The Journal that CAUT has no jurisdiction over matters of academic freedom due to the collective union agreement

between the Queen’s University and the Queen’s University Faculty Association (QUFA). Because of the agreement, Queen’s didn’t participate in the investigation. Instead, CAUT used materials provided by Shirkhanzadeh and QUFA for their report. Shirkhanzadeh said research misconduct had been occurring for years before a colleague brought it to his attention in 2005. Shirkhanzadeh brought his allegations to the University shortly after. “I thought that what I’m doing is good for the University, it’s good for the funding agencies, good for the students and public,” Shirkhanzadeh said. “My general feeling over the last 10 years is they don’t like that. They don’t want to investigate.” Shirkhanzadeh found multiple journal articles credited to the accused professor with research from a Queen’s physics experiment that he alleges contain plagiarism and falsified or fabricated data. “It was a clear case of research misconduct,” he said. His allegations of academic misconduct received media See CAUT, page 7

INSIDE THIS ISSUE NEWS

EDITORIALS

OP-ED

ARTS

SPORTS

Obituary: Queen’s mourns Madison Crich

RMC’s sexual violence culture runs deep

Canadian schools underprepare students

Students present stirring pieces in juried exhibition

Defensive back Brendan Morgan taken in CFL draft

page 2

page 9

page 10

page 12

page 15

Online:

queensjournal.ca

@queensjournal

facebook.com/queensjournal


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
The Queen's Journal, Volume 143, Issue 1 by The Queen's Journal - Issuu