the
Hoboken Reporter
How far is too far?
NINE WEEKLY NEWSPAPERS SERVING HUDSON COUNTY • STORIES UPDATED CONTINUOUSLY AT WWW.HUDSONREPORTER.COM • A PUBLICATION OF THE HUDSON REPORTER
I
VOLUME 29, NUMBER 52 • SUNDAY, AUGUST 19, 2012
Lawsuit claims that Hoboken bloggers and internet commenters defamed local couple
By Al Sullivan
Reporter staff writer
n a case that could have far-reaching implications, two Hoboken activists are suing two Hoboken-based bloggers and 10 unnamed internet commenters for allegedly making “false and defamatory” posts about them. Hoboken resident Lane Bajardi and wife Kimberly Cardinal Bajardi filed the lawsuit on July 26 in Hudson County Superior Court seeking $2 million in damages, naming Hoboken-based bloggers Roman Brice and Nancy Pincus as well as 10 unnamed defendants – listed in the court documents by their on-line screen names – for allegedly posting remarks that allegedly interfered with the careers and future employment of the Bajardi family. Lane Bajardi is employed by WINS 1010 and has been a radio reporter for many years.
The lawsuit has the potential to become a national issue. Brice and Pincus’ blogs frequently focus on Hoboken politics and government, favoring the administration of Mayor Dawn Zimmer and taking aim at Zimmer’s critics, including Bajardi. Brice’s blog is known as the “Hoboken Horse” blog, while Pincus’ blog is called “Grafix Avenger.”
Pages from the lawsuit. The lawsuit includes a letter that Pincus allegedly e-mailed to Bajardi’s employer in January of 2012, saying that he spreads “bigotry and intolerance” in Hoboken as a political operative. The lawsuit also includes copies of posts that were made on the internet by the “Grafix Avenger” referencing the Bajardis’ child, who is a toddler. The posts about the toddler can still be found in the comments section of a local news web site. The same remarks were posted by “Grafix Avenger” three times in one morning under an article about Zimmer’s state of the union address in January, an article that doesn’t reference the Bajardis. Pincus, besides blogging, is a member of the Hoboken Zoning Board, allied with City Hall. Bajardi has no positions on city boards but has been a supporter of one of Zimmer’s most outspoken political opponents, Councilwoman Beth Mason. He also came to a Board of Education meeting in 2010 to publicly complain about the graphics on Pincus’ blog, including one of school board candidates in a punch bowl with floating turds.
Scores of stories and comments against the Bajardis have been posted on the blogs and in the comments sections of internet news sites for more than a year, some referring to their personal appearance and personal lives, others including photos of Lane Bajardi, and in one case, a photo appeared on Pincus’ blog of the couple’s residence in downtown Hoboken. The defamation suit cites numerous instances in which the comments and blog posts alleged that Lane Bajardi has engaged in various criminal behaviors. In the suit, Bajardi said the claims are all untrue. Last week, the bloggers charged on their blogs and in comments to the media that the lawsuit is attempting to silence their free speech. “This is a malicious use of the courts to suppress the political
Rattle and …. ho hum
D
see LAWSUIT page 8
A year ago, massive earthquake that wasn’t
By Vanessa Cruz Reporter Staff Writer
SHATTERING – The earthquake unnerved Hoboken residents.
Free speech issues
id you feel the earth move? Many people did, and it made for good conversation in Hobokena year ago – but little else. One year ago, on Tuesday Aug. 23, a rare East Coast earthquake centered in Virginia shook parts of New Jersey shortly after 2 p.m., causing buildings to sway and people to rush into the streets wondering what was happening. The quake ended up proving to be more of a conversation piece than a local tragedy, as there were few incidents of damage to area buildings and no major injuries reported. According to the U.S. Geological Survey, the earthquake’s magnitude was
around 5.9 with its epicenter located in the northwest of Richmond, Va.
Mad dash out of library
Last week, residents of Hudson County recounted their reactions to the event. Librarians at the Hoboken Public Library said that the building that has been “inspiring minds since 1890” inspired something like panic the day of the quake. “I felt the chair moving,” said Tara Weyouche. “Even my body felt weird after that.” “I saw the ceiling flex a little bit,” said Pat Fischetto. “I right away thought it was an earthquake.”
see EARTHQUAKE page 10
inside www.hudsonreporter.com Business Directory Classified Death Notices Health Letters Open House Directory Sports
p. p. p. p. p. p. p.
22 16 8 11 23 20 14