Off the Shelf September/October 2011

Page 1

O ff the Shelf Alone Together by Sherry Turkle Basic Books Reviewed by Dale S. Kuehne Sherry Turkle wants to talk about technological attachments. Not files we attach to emails, not attachments that allow us to charge our iPod with our car’s cigarette lighter, not special lenses to attach to our iPhones. No, in her recent book, Alone Together: Why We Expect More from Technology and Less from Each Other, she wants to talk about the deep and potentially troubling attachments we form with our email accounts, music devices, and smart phones. As an MIT professor, Turkle has spent much of her career studying the psychological and social impact of technology on human life. Her particular interest is in studying how robotics and personal technological devices impact how we relate to others and ourselves. She approaches the subject with an appreciation and fascination with technology, and yet from that vantage point has discovered some chilling data concerning how technology is making it more and more difficult for us to be human. She speaks of how robotics have advanced to the point that children often prefer virtual pets to real pets and how the elderly can find such comfort in virtual pets or robots that they don’t feel as much need for human companionship, including their children. She lets us know that the technology is advancing so rapidly that we will soon be able to create human robots that are so “human” and personally engaging that Scientific American is exploring legal marriage between humans and robots. Turkle gives us a glimpse into how personal technology and social networking are changing our lives, and especially the lives of our children. For an increasing number of people the most important relationship in their life is with the device that gives them access to email, IMs, and Facebook. So significant is the attachment we have to our technology that we are often unaware that we have developed an attachment stronger than we have with any person. Alone Together is a well-written, widely accessible book that is a must read for anyone who wants to try to understand culturally where we are and where we are going, as well as understand how to work with the most at-risk group in our society—our children. Turkle explains why I can’t go to a gathering of adults without finding a significant number of people, including me, texting and writing email while someone else is talking. Many of us are so attached to our technology that our brains have developed a biochemical addiction to the electronic stimulation of our devices. When that occurs—and youth are especially vulnerable to this due to their stage of development—what drives us is not the desire to be closer

42 PRISM Magazine

Book Reviews to the people to whom we are texting but our brain demanding the stimulation the screen is providing. Millions of us are unaware we should be in a new kind of 12-step program. Turkle is not a Luddite. She appreciates the uses that can be made of the ever-advancing technology. She is trying to alert us to the danger that the technology presents, especially its addictive and antisocial dimensions. This is the greatest contribution of the book. If an essential part of what it means to be human is to love and be loved, to love God, neighbor, and self, Alone Together introduces us to the profound threat that smart phones, personal computers, and social networking pose for us. As the title implies, this technology can hypnotize us into believing we are relating to others when we are in fact connecting to a technological device. Moreover, social networking provides us with the ability to remake ourselves into who we wish we were and to relate to the fictions of others, thereby further complicating the already difficult task of knowing self and others. Turkle raises more questions than she answers, but they are the questions that help us put into perspective the challenge our culture faces. Dale S. Kuehne is the Richard L. Bready Chair in Ethics, Economics, and the Common Good at Saint Anselm College in Manchester, N.H., where he is also a professor of politics. He is the author of Sex and the iWorld: Rethinking Relationship beyond an Age of Individualism (Baker Academic, 2009). Bonhoeffer by Eric Metaxis Thomas Nelson Reviewed by John A. Sundquist In Bonhoeffer: Pastor, Martyr, Prophet, Spy, biographer Eric Metaxis tells with remarkable sensitivity the story of one man’s faithfulness to the gospel of Jesus Christ and the forces that shaped him. Its 31 packed chapters are informed by extensive quotations from correspondence between Bonhoeffer and his large circle of family, friends, and colleagues as well as excerpts from sermons he preached and lectures he delivered. The work surveys four major periods of Bonhoeffer’s life and work: his childhood and youth; his theological studies and early pastoral work in the ’20s; the rise of Nazism through the ’30s and Bonhoeffer’s opposition and leadership in the Confessing Church movement; and his involvement, in the early ’40s, in the conspiracy to assassinate Adolf Hitler, leading to his arrest in 1943 and his execution


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.