TUMBLEWEED FILM FESTIVAL
BULLS & BARRELS
ROLLING INTO OROVILLE
Tonasket Rodeo Grounds August 2 at 6:30 p.m.
See Page A5, A10
SERVING WASHINGTON’S
OKANOGAN VALLEY
SINCE 1905
GAZETTE-TRIBUNE WWW.GAZETTE-TRIBUNE.COM | THURSDAY, AUGUST 1, 2013 | 75 CENTS NEWSSTAND PRICE
More water must spill over Enloe, falls PUD, Dept. of Ecology contimplate next move BY GARY A. DEVON MANAGING EDITOR
OROVILLE – The ink was barely dry on Okanogan County PUD’s new federal license to operate Enloe Dam when the state Pollution Control Hearing Board said streamflow over the dam and Similkameen Falls must be considered and directed the Department of Ecology to do do an aesthetic study. “We are still processing what this means to our project,” said John Grubich, general manager of the public utility “Obviously this involves litigation and we are limited at this time to any comments we could make. It is also up to Ecology’s legal team to decide how they will proceed.” On July 23, 2013, the Washington State Pollution Control Hearings Board (PCHB) issued an order directing the
Ecology to do an aesthetic flow study if Okanogan PUD decides to build Enloe Dam project. The PCHB ruled that the water quality permit (called a “401 Certification”) does not protect the scenic and associated recreational values of the Similkameen Falls. A coalition of local, state and national river advocacy groups had challenged the permit for what they claim was a failure of the state agency to comply with federal and state Clean Water Act requirements that protect scenic values of rivers. A trial was held at the PCHB offices in Tumwater, Wash. on April 16-19 and May 15-16. “The Board’s decision could not be more clear: the Board held that the coalition proved that Ecology had simply failed to study and protect the proposed project’s impact on the scenic values of Similkameen Falls, and instead improperly chose flows based upon the Enloe Project’s economics,” said Suzanne Skinner of the Center for Environmental Law and Policy in arecent press release. The Board found that
Ecology’s “401 certification is deficient” to protect the Similkameen River “without further conditions” on aesthetics. The Board criticized Ecology’s afterthe-fact evaluation of the minimum flow regime, which reduces natural flows by more than 90 percent to 30 cfs during summer months, and 10 cfs from October through March each year. The Board stated that “selection of a minimum flow in this manner results in Ecology considering the impact of aesthetic flows on the operation of the (Enloe Dam) Project, rather than considering the Project’s impact on the aesthetic values of the flows. This is not the proper standard.” The PCHB noted that Similkameen Falls, although remote, is attracting an increasing number of viewers due to development of local and regional trail systems. The falls’ value as a scenic stop on the Similkameen River Trail is a factor to be considered in protection of flows over the dam as well as at the falls, according to the groups who appealed
the issuance of a 401 Certification. In making their ruling the PCHB said Ecology never considered flows greater than the minimum, reasoning that the aesthetic requirements only applied to populated areas such as around Spokane and Snoqualmie Falls. “The Similkameen River is a valuable resource to the community for recreation, scenic values, and fish and wildlife. This decision affirms that the Similkameen remains a multi-use river and is not for the sole use of power generation,” said Jere Gillespie, Columbia River Bioregional Education Project. The groups claim that the PCHB’s decision comes at a time of growing uncertainty about the PUD’s ability to finance the dam project given electrical rate increases to customers for the next several years. They say there is growing opposition by ratepayers to pursue Enloe Dam given its outdated cost and revenue projections. “Okanogan PUD customers are already feeling a big pinch with pro-
posed 30 percent rate increases,” said Rich Bowers of the Hydropower Reform Coalition. “Enloe Dam will take a big bite out of ratepayers’ pocketbooks. The PUD has failed to assess the economics of the project since 2007 despite an independent economic analysis showing the Project will be a big money-loser. The PUD spent nearly a million dollars in the last year, fielding attorneys and consultants in this appeal, all of which has resulted in an adverse decision for the PUD and the ratepayers who are footing the bill.” Joseph Enzensperger of Oroville, was among those who testified at the hearing. “I just let them know what a priceless place it is and what the price will be if we allow this project to impact the amount of water that flows over Similkameen Falls. It will have an incredible impact on the landscape,” Enzensperger said after hearing of the PCHB’s decision last week. The parties, including Ecology and and the PUD, have 30 days to appeal the PCHB’s decision.
Tonasket applies for sidewalk grants Infrastructure discussions dominate meeting
BY BRENT BAKER BBAKER@GAZETTE-TRIBUNE.COM
TONASKET - In an effort to better connect the U.S. Armed Forces Legacy Park to downtown Tonasket, the Tonasket City Council authorized planner Kurt Danison to apply for a Transportation Alternative Project grant. The action took place at the Tuesday, July 23, city council meeting. The grant, if approved, would bring in about $92,000 to put in a sidewalk along Whitcomb Ave. (US-97) from Sixth St. to just short of the Bonaparte Creek bridge next to Shannon’s. That would set the stage for a second project that Legacy Park leaders have been planning: a foot bridge across the creek that would keep pedestrians from having to cross to the park on the highway bridge. “What we would get is 370 feet of sidewalk,” Danison said. “It involves replacing all of the curb, existing concrete and asphalt, and replacing it from the southwest corner of Sixth, and it would run down to the northern entrance of
Shannon’s parking lot. Any more than that you’d have to tear it out because when they do the pedestrian bridge it will have to be excavated. “I think the funding is in the ballpark and we have a reasonably good chance at it.” Council member Scott Olson said that it was important to keep the businesses that would be affected by the project Shannon’s, Whistler’s and the Chevron station - fully in the loop as things progressed. “We’ll write them a letter to let them know the city is applying for a grant,” said Mayor Patrick Plumb. “It may or may not happen, no guarantees. But if we can send a picture with the letter and let them know if they want to discuss any of it, they can come here (to a council meeting) or contact City Hall.” Originally Danison had been asked by the Legacy Park leadership team to apply for a grant for the pedestrian bridge itself. But at the July 9 council meeting, he said that with a deadline of July 24 for
SEE GRANT | PG A4
Gary DeVon/staff photo
New trees have been planted at Oroville Elementary School, keeping the district’s promise of planting more trees after it cut down nearly a dozen to make room for more parking. The trees are inside the fence now, instead of outside. They were looking a bit dry on Monday as the district was experiencing irrigation system problems and staff had to resort to hand watering.
Local teen recovering from horrific crash BY BRENT BAKER BBAKER@GAZETTE-TRIBUNE.COM
Brent Baker/file photo
Amanda Johnson, playing for the Tonasket Tiger’s Girls Soccer Team.
TONASKET - Amanda Johnson has touched quite a few people in her life. If she and her family ever doubted that, the outpouring of support she and her family have received since Amanda was involved in a serious car accident July 19 would put any such thoughts to rest. Amanda, about to begin her senior year at Tonasket High School, was scheduled to be transferred to St Luke’s Rehab Center in Spokane after a series of surgeries at Sacred Heart Hospital to repair the damage done after her one-car rollover accident near Riverside, in which she was ejected from her vehicle. Her injuries included fractured vertebrae in her neck and back, a fractured left foot; multiple fractures in her right hand (one of which required her middle finger to be amputated); a severe laceration to her head; and “road rash” over much of her body. “She’s doing remarkably well, all things considered,” said her mom, Tiffany Johnson. “Actually, she’s been pretty
OKANOGAN VALLEY GAZETTE-TRIBUNE Volume 109 No. 31
amazing. Even at the scene (of the crash), Meanwhile, social media filled with she’d lost consciousness but woke up and expressions of prayers and support for was able to give (first responders) my Amanda and her family. name and number “We’ve had quite to call.” a few visitors,” R e m a r k a b l y, Tiffany said. “That Fund set up for teen’s Tifffany said, has really helped. Medical Expenses Amanda never “Amanda is the lost movement in kind of person An account has been set up at her legs and arms that touches everyChase Bank for medical expensdespite the injuries one she’s ever met es. The “Amanda Jo Johnson to her back and somehow.” Benefit Trust,” for anyone wishing neck. One of those “She doesn’t visitors was close to make a donation to Amanda remember what friend Elizabeth and her family to help offset happened, which Jackson, a socexpenses. Donations can be sent is probably just cer and basketball to c/o Danna Grooms, P.O. Box as well,” she said. teammate. The two B, Omak, WA 98841 or dropped “She can’t rememjoined forces for off at Baines Title Company in ber if she swerved their senior projOkanogan to Kelly Townsend. to avoid a deer, fell ect to raise $3,800 asleep, or what.” to install an elecAmanda was tric scoreboard at kept under sedathe Tonasket High tion for four days she underwent mul- School soccer field, as well as rebuild tiple surgeries, largely because it was the team benches and repair some of the deemed to risky to remove and reinsert worn areas of grass on the field. the tube that was breathing for her. A car wash they had scheduled for
INSIDE THIS EDITION
CONTACT US Newsroom and Advertising (509) 476-3602 gdevon@gazette-tribune.com
Saturday, July 27, went on as scheduled, with Elizabeth getting help from Amanda’s sisters Ariana and Alex Perez, Michelle, Bo and Sarah Silverthorn, Lexi Gavin, Tyra Bell, Kjeld Williams and Elizabeth’s parents and brother Tim. “It’s been a bit stressful doing this without her,” Jackson said. “Mainly I’m just concerned about Amanda and her getting better. I had a lot of volunteers come to help, so I’m very thankful.” Amanda and Elizabeth had raised more than $1,100 prior to Saturday’s car wash. Tiffany Johnson said it’s still unclear how much of Amanda’s medical expenses will be covered by insurance. “We hope it covers a lot of it but we really don’t know at this point,” she said. “My aunt, Danna Grooms, set up an account at Chase Bank to help with medical expenses. “We’re very grateful for the support of everyone - family, friends, and my co-workers at Mid-Valley Hospital,” she added. “They’ve really done a lot for me. A lot of people have done so much for us, it’s been amazing.”
News A2-4 Letters/Opinion A5 Community A6
Upcoming Events A7 Classifieds/Legals A8 Real Estate A9
Art/Entertainment A10 Cops & Courts A11 Obituaries A12