BOOK OF THE SAN JUANS Available now on the ferries and at local businesses
ANNUAL MAG CONCERT Musicians come together for the kids Page 9
SOUNDER THE ISLANDS’
CRIME | Orcas Island man sentenced for assault [3] COMMENTARY | What’s next for the Exchange? [7] ARTS | Wagner’s classic to stream at Orcas Center [8]
Serving Orcas, Lopez and San Juan County
www.islandssounder.com
WEDNESDAY, February 27, 2013 VOL. 46, NO. 9 75¢
Help out hummingbirds
Level 3 sex offender moving to San Juan by SCOTT RASMUSSEN Journal editor
Amy Masters photo
Find out how to lend a hand to our small, feathered friends on page 8. Above is a rufous hummingbird.
Two years after his request to relocate to San Juan Island was denied by state corrections officials, a level 3 sex offender is expected to make the island his home sometime in the near future. Local authorities last week received a letter from David Franklin Stewart notifying his intent to relocate to San Juan Island, where he and his wife bought a home in the Bridal Vail neighborhood in 2004. The 60-year-old, convicted a year earlier of first-degree rape of a child, is no longer under supervision of the state Department of Corrections and is free to come and go, and live, where he chooses, said San Juan County Sheriff Rob Nou. “He’s served his time, so to speak,” Nou said. “Two years ago we had two community meetings that were well-attended and we
Parties square off over challenge to charter Ruling on merit of the case is expected ‘well before’ April election by STEVE WEHRLY Journal reporter
What’s the problem? In 2012, that question was asked again and again by critics as the Charter Review Commission fashioned its amendments to the county charter. Now, that same question was posed in legal language by San Juan County Prosecuting Attorney Randy Gaylord in support of the charter amendments and against a legal challenge filed days after the amendments were approved in November by the voters. Carlson, Gonce and Bossler versus San Juan County alleges seven causes of action and asks that the charter amendments be declared unconstitutional and that an injunction be entered terminating the current election for the three-person county council provided for in the charter amendments.
With Superior Court Judge John M. Meyer of Skagit County presiding – San Juan County Superior Court Judge Don Eaton recused himself from the proceedings – the case reached its climax Feb. 19 before a packed courtroom inside the San Juan County Courthouse. Although numerous legal and procedural issues were raised, the focus of plaintiffs' attorney Stephanie O’Day’s case was that “fundamental voting rights are affected” by residency districts of unequal population, even when, or perhaps especially when, all of the county's voters are allowed to vote for all candidates. “Because fundamental voting rights are affected, the court must apply a ‘strict scrutiny’ test,” O’Day said. “Strict scrutiny” is the highest standard for determining the constitutionality of a statute, often a statute dealing with the Bill of Rights (the First through Tenth Amendments) or the Fourteenth Amendment. O’Day argued that because residency districts violate the “one-man, one-vote” requirements of both the Washington state and U.S.
constitutions, the charter should be subject to strict scrutiny under Fourteenth Amendment principles of due process and equal protection of the law. She cited Washington and U.S. constitutions and constitutional cases as the basis for asking Judge Meyer to halt the election for the three-person council, scheduled for April 23. Gaylord countered with statutory and constitutional law citations of his own, asserting that because voting under the charter amendments is county-wide and because “all voters vote for all candidates,” the charter was “not an infringement of anybody’s fundamental right to vote.” The action of the CRC, according to Gaylord, is therefore “not a constitutional decision, but instead is a political decision,” that should be judged by the lesser standard of “rational basis” rather than strict scrutiny. Since the contentious CRC meetings of a year ago, local voters have approved the three charter amendments replacing the six-person
SEE CHARTER, PAGE 6
were very up-front at that time in saying that in 22 months he would no longer be under corrections’ supervision.” As a registered sex offender, Nou said that Stewart must notify the Sheriff ’s Department of his place of residency within three days after moving to a new location. Stewart, who, as a Level 3 sex offender, is considered at “highrisk” to re-offend, served seven and a half years in prison and two years of supervised probation following his conviction in 2003. He has lived in the Sultan area, located near the Monroe state penitentiary, following his release from prison. Nou said the letter from Stewart indicated that he could move to his San Juan Island home as early Monday, but that as of Tuesday, he had not been at the Sheriff ’s Office to register his place of residency. According to the San Juan County Sheriff ’s Department sexoffender website, Stewart admit-
SEE OFFENDER, PAGE 6
Sounder deadlines Display advertising: Friday at noon Classified advertising: Monday at noon Legal advertising: Thursday at noon Press releases, Letters: Friday at 3 p.m.
How to reach us Office: 376-4500 Fax: 376-4501 Advertising: advertising@ islandssounder.com Classified: 1-800-388-2527, classifieds@ soundpublishing.com Editor: editor@ islandssounder.com