Friday, 19 February, 2021 I 6 Rajab, 1442 I Rs 15.00 I Vol XI No 232 I 12 Pages I Karachi Edition
PPP, PML-N goiNg agaiNst Charter of DeMoCraCy by oPPosiNg oPeN baLLotiNg: CJP g
SECrECY IN THE PoLLS IS ABSoLuTE IN vIEw of CoNSTITuTIoN, SC ToLd
islamabad stAff RepoRt
C
HIEf Justice of Pakistan (CJP) Gulzar Ahmad on Thursday said that the Pakistan Muslim LeagueNawaz (PML-N) and Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) were going against the Charter of democracy by opposing open balloting in Senate elections. Sindh Advocate General (AG) Salman Talibuddin argued before the Supreme Court (SC) on Thursday that the presidential reference must be dismissed as it is not maintainable and that secrecy in the polls is absolute in view of the Article 226 of the Constitution. He said that accepting the reference would be akin to a constitutional amendment, adding that allegations of corruption in the Senate elections are hearsay as there is no evidence. “we can not say whether open balloting will eliminate horse-trading but it is disappointing that the PPP and the PML-N
have gone back on their earlier agreement,” responded CJP Gulzar, expressing his disappointment over the PPP and the PML-N going against the Charter of democracy, which calls for an end to secret balloting in Senate elections. To this, Justice umar Ata Bandial remarked that the best evidence of corruption is a traceable ballot of a voter and as the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP) cannot currently access the paper ballot, then Article 225 of the Constitution stands redundant. “If prima facie, there is [a] material of corruption, then a tribunal can order the examining of the ballot,” he maintained. Justice Ijazul Ahsan said on the occasion that “you can not shut [the] door to the opening of ballots.” In his arguments, Punjab AG Ahmad Awais agreed with Attorney-General for Pakistan (AGP) Khalid Jawed Khan’s perspective that parliamentarians were bound by their party’s code of discipline and in case of any violation, action can
CoroNavirus iN
PakistaN
CONFIRMED CASES:
567,261
LAST UPDATED AT 8:15 AM ON FEBRUARY 18, 2021
DAY'S DEATH TOLL:
52
RECOVERED:
NEW CASES:
1,272 DEATHS:
530,597 12,488 SINDH:
PUNJAB:
254,678
165,716
KP:
BALOCHISTAN:
AJK/GB:
ISLAMABAD:
70,306
18,958
9,629/4,945 43,029
be taken against them. He said, in response to a question, that a lawmaker can be held liable for selling or buying votes, but not for voting his party’s interests. The advocate generals of Islamabad, Balochistan, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KP) and Punjab all supported the arguments presented by the AGP. Justice Gulzar said that Article 63-A does not apply to the Senate elections whereas Article 59 does not mention secret balloting. The hearing was postponed till friday. A day earlier, during the hearing, Justice Ahsan had inquired how ECP would maintain proportional representation and if the votes could ever truly be secret. referring to electronic voting, he had pointed out that anything on the Internet could be traced. regarding proportionate representation, he had said that the ECP itself would be responsible if the party “does not get [a number of seats] in relation to its seats in the provincial assemblies”. The ECP in a response submitted to the SC on wednesday had maintained that the Senate elections should always be held through a secret ballot. The ECP’s counsel, citing Article 226 of the Constitution, had said that votes for the Senate elections would “always remain secret” and the votes that were cast could “not be shown to anyone”. The chief justice, on the occasion, had asked what steps the ECP would take to rectify a lack of proportional representation if it comes to pass, and if the election results should then be declared illegal. “vote-selling will result in tatters of proportional representation,” Justice Ahsan had remarked. “If any party gets seats [not in accordance] with its representation, the system will be destroyed,” he had added.
CONTINUED ON PAGE 05
Ali Sadpara, fellow missing mountaineers declared dead on K2 islamabad stAff RepoRt
Missing mountaineers Pakistan’s Ali Sadpara, 45, Iceland’s John Snorri, 47, and Chile’s Juan Pablo Mohr, 34, who were trying to return from their K2 climb, have been declared dead by the family and the government. After having been missing for more than 10 days, Ali Sadpara’s son, Sajid Sadpara, during a press conference in Skardu said that there was no hope of his father returning at this point. “Pakistan has lost a great mountaineer, my father and two other climbers are no more with us,” Sajid Ali Sadpara said. “To all the climbers who appreciate Ali Sadpara’s achievements and look up to him, I promise that I will carry on his dreams and missions and will continue to walk in his footsteps,” Sajid added. He also thanked Prime Minister Imran Khan, Chief of the Army Staff (CoAS) General Qamar Javed Bajwa and the courageous pilots of the Askari Aviation for conducting a thorough search and rescue operation amid the harsh weather for his father. It is pertinent here to mention that the first search and rescue operation was launched on february 6, hours after the mountaineers
Karachi by-polls: Bilawal says govt worried; PTI levels accusations lahore Akif RAshid
Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) Chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari has said that the ruling Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) is worried after the unofficial results were announced for the PS-88 byelections, while the PTI claims that the PPP used the police force to remove their candidate. Addressing a gathering in Karachi to celebrate Yousuf Murtaza Baloch’s victory in the PS-88 Malir by-election Bilawal said that the ruling party has gone against its own members by filing the presidential reference for open polls in the Senate, and now those members of National Assembly (MNAs) from the PTI were “happily coming to PPP” and switching their affiliation. He further said that the losers of by-elections are worried about the elections of the upper house of the parliament and the government is using the Election Commission of Pakistan (ECP). According to the unofficial results, PPP’s Baloch secured 24,251 votes while the runner-up Tehreek-e-Labbaik Pakistan’s Syed Kashif Ali Shah who got 6,090 votes. PTI’s Jan Sher Junejo bagged 4,870 votes and Muttahida Qaumi Movement-Pak-
were officially declared missing, however, rescue efforts had to be suspended multiple times owing to bad weather conditions. during the conference, GilgitBaltistan (GB) Tourism Minister raja Nasir Ali Khan said that, whilst considering the weather conditions at K2, Pakistan Army, government and family of the mountaineer have reached the conclusion that Ali Sadpara and his comrades have expired. The minister said, “Government pays tribute to the services of national hero Ali Sadpara, and he will be given civil award along with his son Sajid Sadpara. A mountaineering school will be established in the name of Ali Sadpara.” Sadpara’s son also broke the news on Twitter. Sajid tweeted, “My father Ali Sadpara and other climbers are no more in this world.” Sadpara, Snorri and Pablo Mohr had departed for their journey on february 3 after Sadpara’s birthday, asking fans and admirers to “keep us in your prayers”. The trio was attempting to reach the 8,611-meter (28,251 foot) Korakarum-2 summit, commonly known as K2, without supplemental oxygen to make history. They, however, lost contact with the base camp when they were only 411 meters away from the snow-capped top.
CONTINUED ON PAGE 05
more inside
Negotiated political settlement only way forward for Afghanistan: PM STORY ON PAGE 03
istan’s (MQM-P) Sajid Ahmed received 2,635, respectively. “PM Imran Khan has basically told his party workers that he doesn’t trust them,” Bilawal said on the occasion, claiming that the PTI workers were willing to give all their votes to the PPP in exchange for the chance to get tickets and become PPP candidates in the future. “The members of the PTI were approaching the PPP as they can see the government will be sent packing,” he said. Calling this move “an admission of no-confidence” by PTI’s own members, Bilawal questioned by the ruling party had to make “backdoor deals” to ensure victory if it was so confident of its majority in the Senate. He added that not only the secrecy of votes of MPAs was
being taken away but also their right to vote according to their choice, which he called “an attack on democracy”. Bilawal claimed that the incumbent government was using pressure tactics to “fire a gun” on the Supreme Court (SC) and the ECP. He accused the government of making “every state institution controversial”. “Sometimes it is the Election Commission, at others the Supreme Court,” he said. The PPP chairman boasted that whether open ballot or secret ballot, his party is ready for Senate elections but the rulers should prepare themselves as they will not allow anyone to rig the Senate polls.
CONTINUED ON PAGE 05
Next Covid vaccination phase to begin in March: SAPM STORY ON BACK PAGE
Senator Mushahidullah Khan passes away STORY ON PAGE 02
CAA to seek cabinet's nod to outsource pilots licencing exams to uK STORY ON BACK PAGE