S K Mondal’s

Strength of Materials Contents Chapter – 1: Stress and Strain Chapter - 2 : Principal Stress and Strain Chapter - 3 : Moment of Inertia and Centroid Chapter - 4 : Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram Chapter - 5 : Deflection of Beam Chapter - 6 : Bending Stress in Beam Chapter - 7 : Shear Stress in Beam Chapter - 8 : Fixed and Continuous Beam Chapter - 9 : Torsion Chapter-10 : Thin Cylinder Chapter-11 : Thick Cylinder Chapter-12 : Spring Chapter-13 : Theories of Column Chapter-14 : Strain Energy Method Chapter-15 : Theories of Failure Chapter-16 : Riveted and Welded Joint

Er. S K Mondal IES Officer (Railway), GATE topper, NTPC ET-2003 batch, 12 years teaching experienced, Author of Hydro Power Familiarization (NTPC Ltd)

Page 1 of 429

Note “Asked Objective Questions” is the total collection of questions from:20 yrs IES (2010-1992) [Engineering Service Examination] 21 yrs. GATE (2011-1992) and 14 yrs. IAS (Prelim.) [Civil Service Preliminary]

Every effort has been made to see that there are no errors (typographical or otherwise) in the material presented. However, it is still possible that there are a few errors (serious or otherwise). I would be thankful to the readers if they are brought to my attention at the following e-mail address: swapan_mondal_01@yahoo.co.in S K Mondal

Page 2 of 429

1.

Stress and Strain

Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) 1.1 Stress (ı) When a material is subjected to an external force, a resisting force is set up within the component. The internal resistance force per unit area acting on a material or intensity of the forces distributed over a given section is called the stress at a point.

x

It uses original cross section area of the specimen and also known as engineering stress or conventional stress. Therefore, T

x

P A

P is expressed in Newton (N) and A, original area, in square meters (m2), the stress ǔ will be expresses in N/ m2. This unit is called Pascal (Pa).

x

As Pascal is a small quantity, in practice, multiples of this unit is used. 1 kPa = 103 Pa = 103 N/ m2 1 MPa =

106

Pa =

106 N/

m2

(kPa = Kilo Pascal) =1

N/mm2

1 GPa = 109 Pa = 109 N/ m2

(MPa = Mega Pascal) (GPa = Giga Pascal)

Let us take an example: A rod 10 mm q 10 mm cross-section is carrying an axial tensile load 10 kN. In this rod the tensile stress developed is given by

Tt

x

P 10 kN 10q103 N    100N/mm2  100MPa 2 A 10 mm q10 mm 100 mm The resultant of the internal forces for an axially loaded member is normal to a section cut perpendicular to the member axis.

x

The force intensity on the shown section is defined as the normal stress. %F P T  lim and Tavg  %Al 0 %A A

x

Tensile stress (ıt)

If ǔ > 0 the stress is tensile. i.e. The fibres of the component tend to elongate due to the external force. A member subjected to an external force tensile P and tensile stress distribution due to the force is shown in the given figure.

Page 3 of 429

Chapter-1

x

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Compressive stress (Äąc)

If Ç&#x201D; < 0 the stress is compressive. i.e. The fibres of the component tend to shorten due to the external force. A member subjected to an external compressive force P and compressive stress distribution due to the force is shown in the given figure.

x

Shear stress ( U )

When forces are transmitted from one part of a body to other, the stresses developed in a plane parallel to the applied force are the shear stress. Shear stress acts parallel to plane of interest. Forces P is applied transversely to the member AB as shown. The corresponding internal forces act in the plane of section C and are called shearing forces. The corresponding average shear stress U

P Area

1.2 Strain (Ä°) The displacement per unit length (dimensionless) is known as strain.

x

Tensile strain ( F t)

The elongation per unit length as shown in the figure is known as tensile strain. Ç&#x2020;t = ĆŚL/ Lo It is engineering strain or conventional strain. Here we divide the elongation to original length not actual length (Lo + % L) Let us take an example: A rod 100 mm in original length. When we apply an axial tensile load 10 kN the final length of the rod after application of the load is 100.1 mm. So in this rod tensile strain is developed and is given by

Ft

x

%L L  Lo 100.1mm 100 mm 0.1mm     0.001 (Dimensionless)Tensile Lo Lo 100 mm 100 mm

Compressive strain ( F c) If the applied force is compressive then the reduction of length per unit length is known as compressive strain. It is negative. Then Ä°c = (-ÇťL)/ Lo

Let us take an example: A rod 100 mm in original length. When we apply an axial compressive load 10 kN the final length of the rod after application of the load is 99 mm. So in this rod a compressive strain is developed and is given by Page 4 of 429

Chapter-1

Fc

x

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

%L L  Lo 99 mm 100 mm 1mm     0.01 (Dimensionless)compressive 100 mm 100 mm Lo Lo Shear Strain ( H ): When a force P is applied tangentially to the element shown. Its edge displaced to dotted line. Where

E is

the lateral displacement of

the upper face of the element relative to the lower face and L is the distance between these faces. Then the shear strain is

(H )

E L

Let us take an example: A block 100 mm Ă&#x2014; 100 mm base and 10 mm height. When we apply a tangential force 10 kN to the upper edge it is displaced 1 mm relative to lower face. Then the direct shear stress in the element (U )

10 kN 10q103 N   1 N/mm2  1 MPa 100 mmq100 mm 100 mmq100 mm

And shear strain in the element ( H ) =

1mm  0.1 Dimensionless 10 mm

1.3 True stress and True Strain The true stress is defined as the ratio of the load to the cross section area at any instant.

x

TT

Where

T

and

F

T 1 F

is the engineering stress and engineering strain respectively.

True strain L

FT  Â¨ Lo

Â?LÂŹ Â?A ÂŹ Â?d ÂŹ dl  ln Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; Â­Â­Â­  ln 1 F  ln Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; o Â­Â­Â­  2ln Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; o Â­Â­Â­ Â&#x17E;Â&#x; Lo ÂŽÂ­ Â&#x;Â&#x17E; A ÂŽ Â&#x;Â&#x17E; d ÂŽ l

or engineering strain ( F ) = eFT -1 The volume of the specimen is assumed to be constant during plastic deformation. [ ' Ao Lo  AL ] It is valid till the neck formation.

x

Comparison of engineering and the true stress-strain curves shown below

Page 5 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondal’s

x

The true stress-strain curve is also known as the flow curve.

x

True stress-strain curve gives a true indication of deformation characteristics because it is based on the instantaneous dimension of the specimen.

x

In engineering stress-strain curve, stress drops down after necking since it is based on the original area.

x

In true stress-strain curve, the stress however increases after necking since the crosssectional area of the specimen decreases rapidly after necking.

x

The flow curve of many metals in the region of uniform plastic deformation can be expressed by the simple power law. ǔT = K(ǆT)n

Where K is the strength coefficient n is the strain hardening exponent n = 0 perfectly plastic solid n = 1 elastic solid For most metals, 0.1< n < 0.5

x

Relation between the ultimate tensile strength and true stress at maximum load The ultimate tensile strength Tu

Pmax Ao

The true stress at maximum load Tu T

Pmax A

 Ao ¬­ ­  A ®­

And true strain at maximum load F T  ln  Eliminating Pmax we get , Tu T

or

Ao  e FT A

Pmax Pmax Ao  q  Tu e FT A Ao A

Where Pmax = maximum force and Ao = Original cross section area A = Instantaneous cross section area Let us take two examples: (I.) Only elongation no neck formation In the tension test of a rod shown initially it was Ao = 50 mm2 and Lo = 100 mm. After the application of load it’s A = 40 mm2 and L = 125 mm. Determine the true strain using changes in both length and area. Answer: First of all we have to check that does the

(If no neck formation

member forms neck or not? For that check Ao Lo  AL

occurs both area and

or not?

gauge length can be used

Here 50 × 100 = 40 × 125 so no neck formation is

for a strain calculation.)

there. Therefore true strain

Page 6 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain L

S K Mondal’s

125 ¬­ dl  ln   0.223 100 ®­­ l

FT  ¨ Lo

 Ao ¬­  50 ¬ ­­  ln ­­­  0.223  40 ® A®

FT  ln

(II.) Elongation with neck formation A ductile material is tested such and necking occurs then the final gauge length is L=140 mm and the final minimum cross sectional area is A = 35 mm2. Though the rod shown initially it was Ao = 50 mm2 and Lo = 100 mm. Determine the true strain using changes in both length and area.

Answer: First of all we have to check that does the

(After necking, gauge

member forms neck or not? For that check Ao Lo  AL

length gives error but

or not?

area and diameter can

Here AoLo = 50 × 100 = 5000 mm3 and AL=35 × 140

be

= 4200 mm3. So neck formation is there. Note here

calculation of true strain

AoLo > AL.

at fracture and before

Therefore true strain

fracture also.)

used

for

the

 Ao ¬­  50 ¬ ­  ln ­­­  0.357  35 ®  A ®­

FT  ln L

But not FT  ¨ Lo

140 ¬­ dl  ln   0.336 (it is wrong) 100 ®­­ l

1.4 Hook’s law According to Hook’s law the stress is directly proportional to strain i.e. normal stress (ǔ) B normal strain (ǆ) and shearing stress ( U ) B shearing strain ( H ). ǔ = Eǆ and U  GH The co-efficient E is called the modulus of elasticity i.e. its resistance to elastic strain. The coefficient G is called the shear modulus of elasticity or modulus of rigidity.

1.5 Volumetric strain Fv

A relationship similar to that for length changes holds for three-dimensional (volume) change. For volumetric strain, Fv , the relationship is Fv = (V-V0)/V0 or Fv = ƦV/V0

P K

x

Where V is the final volume, V0 is the original volume, and ƦV is the volume change.

x

Volumetric strain is a ratio of values with the same units, so it also is a dimensionless quantity.

Page 7 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

x

ĆŚV/V= volumetric strain = Ç&#x2020;x +Ç&#x2020;y + Ç&#x2020;z = Ç&#x2020;1 +Ç&#x2020;2 + Ç&#x2020;3

x

Dilation: The hydrostatic component of the total stress contributes to deformation by changing the area (or volume, in three dimensions) of an object. Area or volume change is called dilation and is positive or negative, as the volume increases or decreases, respectively. e

p Where p is pressure. K

1.6 Youngâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s modulus or Modulus of elasticity (E) =

PL Äą = AÄŻ Â?

W PL 1.7 Modulus of rigidity or Shear modulus of elasticity (G) = = J AG

1.8 Bulk Modulus or Volume modulus of elasticity (K) = 

'p 'v v

'p 'R R

1.10 Relationship between the elastic constants E, G, K, Îź

E

2G 1  P

9KG 3K  G

3K 1  2P

[VIMP]

Where K = Bulk Modulus, N = Poissonâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Ratio, E= Youngâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s modulus, G= Modulus of rigidity

x

For a linearly elastic, isotropic and homogeneous material, the number of elastic constants required to relate stress and strain is two. i.e. any two of the four must be known.

x

If the material is non-isotropic (i.e. anisotropic), then the elastic modulii will vary with additional stresses appearing since there is a coupling between shear stresses and normal stresses for an anisotropic material.

Let us take an example: The modulus of elasticity and rigidity of a material are 200 GPa and 80 GPa, respectively. Find all other elastic modulus.

2G 1  P 3K 1  2 P

9KG we may find all other elastic modulus 3K  G

easily Poissonâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Ratio ( P ) : Bulk Modulus (K) :

1 P

3K

E 2G

E 1  2P

Â&#x;P

Â&#x;K

E 200 1  1 0.25 2G 2 u 80

E 3 1  2 P

200 133.33GPa 3 1  2 u 0.25

1.11 Poissonâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Ratio (Îź) =

Transverse strain or lateral strain  Â?y = Longitudinal strain Â?x

(Under unidirectional stress in x-direction)

x x

The theory of isotropic elasticity allows Poisson's ratios in the range from -1 to 1/2. Poisson's ratio in various materials

Page 8 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Material

Poisson's ratio

Material

Poisson's ratio

Steel

0.25 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 0.33

Rubber

0.48 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 0.5

C.I

0.23 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 0.27

Cork

Nearly zero

Concrete

0.2

Novel foam

negative

x

We use cork in a bottle as the cork easily inserted and removed, yet it also withstand the pressure from within the bottle. Cork with a Poisson's ratio of nearly zero, is ideal in this application.

1.12 For bi-axial stretching of sheet Â§L Âˇ Â?1 ln Â¨ f 1 Â¸ ÂŠ Lo1 Âš Â§L Âˇ Â?2 ln Â¨ f 2 Â¸ ÂŠ Lo 2 Âš

Lo  Original length L f -Final length

Final thickness (tf) =

Initial thickness(t o ) eÂ?1 u eÂ?2

1.13 Elongation

x

A prismatic bar loaded in tension by an axial force P For a prismatic bar loaded in tension by an axial force P. The elongation of the bar can be determined as

PL AE

G

Let us take an example: A Mild Steel wire 5 mm in diameter and 1 m long. If the wire is subjected to an axial tensile load 10 kN find its extension of the rod. (E = 200 GPa)

PL AE

Here given, Force (P) 10 kN Length(L) 1 m Area(A)

10 u 1000N

Sd2

S u 0.005

4

4

Modulous of Elasticity (E ) Therefore Elongation(G )

2

m2

1.963 u 105 m2

200 GPa 200 u 109 N/m2 PL AE

10 u 1000 u 1

1.963 u10 u 200 u 10

5

2.55 u 103 m

x

9

m

2.55 mm

Elongation of composite body

Elongation of a bar of varying cross section A1, A2,----------,An of lengths l1, l2,--------ln respectively.

G

l Âş P ÂŞ l1 l2 l3   n Âť ÂŤ  E ÂŹ A1 A2 A3 An Âź Page 9 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Let us take an example: A composite rod is 1000 mm long, its two ends are 40 mm2 and 30 mm2 in area and length are 300 mm and 200 mm respectively. The middle portion of the rod is 20 mm2 in area and 500 mm long. If the rod is subjected to an axial tensile load of 1000 N, find its total elongation. (E = 200 GPa). Answer: Consider the following figure

Given, Load (P) =1000 N Area; (A1) = 40 mm2, A2 = 20 mm2, A3 = 30 mm2 Length; (l1) = 300 mm, l2 = 500 mm, l3 = 200 mm E = 200 GPa = 200 u 109 N/m2 = 200 u 103 N/mm2 Therefore Total extension of the rod

G

P ÂŞ l1 l 2 l 3 Âş ÂŤ   Âť E ÂŹ A1 A2 A3 Âź ÂŞ 300 mm 500 mm 200 mm Âş 1000 N uÂŤ   Âť 3 2 200 u 10 N / mm ÂŹ 40 mm 2 20 mm 2 30 mm 2 Âź 0.196mm

x

Elongation of a tapered body

Elongation of a tapering rod of length â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; due to load â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Pâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; at the end

ÄŻ=

4PL S Ed1 d 2

(d1 and d2 are the diameters of smaller & larger ends)

You may remember this in this way, ÄŻ=

PL Â§S Âˇ E Â¨ d1 d 2 Â¸ ÂŠ4 Âš

i.e.

PL EA eq

Let us take an example: A round bar, of length L, tapers uniformly from small diameter d1 at one end to bigger diameter d2 at the other end. Show that the extension produced by a tensile axial load P is ÄŻ =

4PL . S d1 d 2 E

If d2 = 2d1, compare this extension with that of a uniform cylindrical bar having a diameter equal to the mean diameter of the tapered bar.

Answer: Consider the figure below d1 be the radius at the smaller end. Then at a X cross section XX located at a distance Ă&#x2014; from the smaller end, the value of diameter â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;dxâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; is equal to

Page 10 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

dx 2

d1 x Â§ d 2 d1 Â·  Â¨  Â¸ 2 LÂ© 2 2 Â¹ x or d x d1  d 2  d1

L d1 1  kx

d 2  d1 1 u L d1

Where k

We now taking a small strip of diameter 'd x 'and length 'd x 'at section XX . Elongation of this section 'd x ' length d G

PL AE

P .dx Â§ S d x2 Â· Â¨ Â¸uE Â© 4 Â¹

4P .dx 2

S .^d1 1  kx ` E

Therefore total elongation of the taper bar x L

G

Â³ d G

4P dx

Â³ S Ed 1  kx

2 1

x 0

2

4PL S E d1d 2 Comparison: Case-I: Where d2 = 2d1 Elongation G I

4PL S Ed1 u 2d1

2PL S Ed12

Case â&#x20AC;&#x201C;II: Where we use Mean diameter

dm

d1  d 2 2

d1  2d1 2

3 d1 2

Elongation of such bar G II

Extension of taper bar Extension of uniform bar

PL AE

2 16 9

Page 11 of 429

9 8

P .L

S Â§3 Â·

2

Â¨ d1 Â¸ .E 4Â©2 Â¹ 16PL 9S Ed12

Chapter-1

x

Stress and Strain

S K Mondal’s

Elongation of a body due to its self weight (i) Elongation of a uniform rod of length ‘L’ due to its own weight ‘W’

WL į= 2AE The deformation of a bar under its own weight as compared to that when subjected to a direct axial load equal to its own weight will be half. (ii) Total extension produced in rod of length ‘L’ due to its own weight ‘ X ’ per with

į=

length.

Z L2 2EA

(iii) Elongation of a conical bar due to its self weight

į=

1.14

U gL2

WL 2 Amax E

6E

Structural members or machines must be designed such that the working stresses are less

than the ultimate strength of the material.

Working stress V w

Vy n

V ult n1

½ n=1.5 to 2 ° ° ¾ factor of safety n1 2 to 3 ° °¿

Vp n

1.15 Factor of Safety: (n) =

Vp

Proof stress

V y or V p or V ult Vw

1.16 Thermal or Temperature stress and strain

x

When a material undergoes a change in temperature, it either elongates or contracts depending upon whether temperature is increased or decreased of the material.

x

If the elongation or contraction is not restricted, i. e. free then the material does not experience any stress despite the fact that it undergoes a strain.

x

The strain due to temperature change is called thermal strain and is expressed as,

H x

D 'T

Where ǂ is co-efficient of thermal expansion, a material property, and ƦT is the change in temperature.

x

The free expansion or contraction of materials, when restrained induces stress in the Page 12 of 429

material and it is referred to as thermal stress.

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

D E 'T

Vt x

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Where, E = Modulus of elasticity

Thermal stress produces the same effect in the material similar to that of mechanical stress. A compressive stress will produce in the material with increase in temperature and the stress developed is tensile stress with decrease in temperature.

Let us take an example: A rod consists of two parts that are made of steel and copper as shown in figure below. The elastic modulus and coefficient of thermal expansion for steel are 200 GPa and 11.7 Ă&#x2014; 10-6 per Â°C respectively and for copper 70 GPa and 21.6 Ă&#x2014; 10-6 per Â°C respectively. If the temperature of the rod is raised by 50Â°C, determine the forces and stresses acting on the rod.

Answer: If we allow this rod to freely expand then free expansion

D 'T L

GT

11.7 u10 u 50 u 500  21.6 u10 u 50 u 750 6

6

1.1025 mm Compressive

But according to diagram only free expansion is 0.4 mm. Therefore restrained deflection of rod =1.1025 mm â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 0.4 mm = 0.7025 mm Let us assume the force required to make their elongation vanish be P which is the reaction force at the ends.

G

Â§ PL Âˇ Â¨ Â¸ ÂŠ AE ÂšSteel

Â§ PL Âˇ Â¨ Â¸ ÂŠ AE ÂšCu

P u 500 P u 750  2Â˝ 2Â˝ Â­S Â­S 9 9 ÂŽ u 0.075 Âž u 200 u 10 ÂŽ u 0.050 Âž u 70 u 10

4 4 ÂŻ Âż ÂŻ Âż or P 116.6 kN or 0.7025

Therefore, compressive stress on steel rod

V Steel

116.6 u 103

P ASteel

S 4

u 0.075

N/m2

26.39 MPa

2

And compressive stress on copper rod

V Cu

P ACu

116.6 u 103

S 4

u 0.050

N/m2

59.38 MPa

2

Page 13 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

1.17 Thermal stress on Brass and Mild steel combination A brass rod placed within a steel tube of exactly same length. The assembly is making in such a way that elongation of the combination will be same. To calculate the stress induced in the brass rod, steel tube when the combination is raised by toC then the following analogy have to do.

(a) Original bar before heating.

(b) Expanded position if the members are allowed to expand freely and independently after heating.

(c) Expanded position of the compound bar i.e. final position after heating.

x

Compatibility Equation:

G

x

G st  G sf

G Bt  G Bf

Equilibrium Equation:

V s As

V B AB

Assumption:

1. L = Ls

LB

2. D b ! D s 3. Steel  Tension Brass  Compression

Where, G = Expansion of the compound bar = AD in the above figure.

G st = Free expansion of the steel tube due to temperature rise toC = D s L t = AB in the above figure.

G sf = Expansion of the steel tube due to internal force developed by the unequal expansion. = BD in the above figure.

G Bt = Free expansion of the brass rod due to temperature rise toC = D b L t = AC in the above figure.

G Bf = Compression of the brass rod due to internal force developed by the unequal expansion. = BD in the above figure. And in the equilibrium equation Tensile force in the steel tube = Compressive force in the brass rod Where, V s = Tensile stress developed in the steel tube.

V B = Compressive stress developed in the brass rod. As = Cross section area of the steel tube. AB = Cross section area of the brass rod.

Let us take an example: See the Conventional Question Answer section of this chapter and the of 429 question is â&#x20AC;&#x153;Conventional Question IES-2008â&#x20AC;?Page and14itâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s answer.

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

1.18 Maximum stress and elongation due to rotation UZ 2L2

(i) V max

8

(ii) V max

UZ 2L2 2

and G L

and G L

UZ 2L3 12E

UZ 2L3 3E

For remember: You will get (ii) by multiplying by 4 of (i)

1.18 Creep When a member is subjected to a constant load over a long period of time it undergoes a slow permanent deformation and this is termed as â&#x20AC;&#x153;creepâ&#x20AC;?. This is dependent on temperature. Usually at elevated temperatures creep is high.

x

The materials have its own different melting point; each will creep when the homologous temperature > 0.5. Homologous temp =

Testing temperature > 0.5 Melting temperature

A typical creep curve shows three distinct stages with different creep rates. After an initial rapid elongation Ç&#x2020;o, the creep rate decrease with time until reaching the steady state. 1) Primary creep is a period of transient creep. The creep resistance of the material increases due to material deformation. 2) Secondary creep provides a nearly constant creep rate. The average value of the creep rate during this period is called the minimum creep rate. A stage of balance between competing. Strain hardening and recovery (softening) of the material. 3) Tertiary creep shows a rapid increase in the creep rate due to effectively reduced crosssectional area of the specimen leading to creep rupture or failure. In this stage intergranular cracking and/or formation of voids and cavities occur. Creep rate =c1 V

c2

Creep strain at any time = zero time strain intercept + creep rate Ă&#x2014;Time = Â?0 Where,

c1 , c2 are constants V

c1 V c2 u t

stress

1.19 If a load P is applied suddenly to a bar then the stress & strain induced will be double than those obtained by an equal load applied gradually. Page 15 of 429

1.20 Stress produced by a load P in falling from height â&#x20AC;&#x2122;hâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;

Chapter-1

Vd

Stress and Strain

ÂŞ

V ÂŤ1  1 

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

2h Âş Â˝Â° ÂťÂž Äą, Â? L ÂťÂź Â°Âż

ÂŤÂŹ Â? being stress & strain produced by static load P & L=length of bar.

AÂŞ 2 AEh Âş ÂŤ1  1  Âť PÂŹ PL Âź

1.21 Loads shared by the materials of a compound bar made of bars x & y due to load W, Px

W.

Py

W.

1.22 Elongation of a compound bar, G

Ax Ex Ax Ex  Ay E y Ay E y Ax Ex  Ay E y

PL Ax Ex  Ay E y

1.23 Tension Test

i)

True elastic limit: based on micro-strain measurement at strains on order of 2 Ă&#x2014; 10-6. Very low value and is related to the motion of a few hundred dislocations.

ii) Proportional limit: the highest stress at which stress is directly proportional to strain. iii) Elastic limit: is the greatest stress the material can withstand without any measurable permanent strain after unloading. Elastic limit > proportional limit.

iv) Yield strength is the stress required to produce a small specific amount of deformation. The offset yield strength can be determined by the stress corresponding to the intersection of the stress-strain curve and a line parallel to the elastic line offset by a strain of 0.2 or 0.1%. ( H = 0.002 or 0.001).

Page 16 of 429

Chapter-1

x

Stress and Strain

S K Mondal’s

The offset yield stress is referred to proof stress either at 0.1 or 0.5% strain used for design and specification purposes to avoid the practical difficulties of measuring the elastic limit or proportional limit.

v) Tensile strength or ultimate tensile strength (UTS) V u is the maximum load Pmax divided by the original cross-sectional area Ao of the specimen.

vi) % Elongation,

Lf  Lo , is chiefly influenced by uniform elongation, which is dependent on the Lo

strain-hardening capacity of the material.

vii) Reduction of Area: q

x

Ao  Af Ao

Reduction of area is more a measure of the deformation required to produce failure and its chief contribution results from the necking process.

x

Because of the complicated state of stress state in the neck, values of reduction of area are dependent on specimen geometry, and deformation behaviour, and they should not be taken as true material properties.

x

RA is the most structure-sensitive ductility parameter and is useful in detecting quality changes in the materials.

viii) Stress-strain response

1.24 Elastic strain and Plastic strain The strain present in the material after unloading is called the residual strain or plastic strain and the strain disappears during unloading is termed as recoverable or elastic strain. Equation of the straight line CB is given by

V total uE  Plastic uE Elastic uE Carefully observe the following figures and understand which one is Elastic strain and which one is Plastic strain Page 17 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Let us take an example: A 10 mm diameter tensile specimen has a 50 mm gauge length. The load corresponding to the 0.2% offset is 55 kN and the maximum load is 70 kN. Fracture occurs at 60 kN. The diameter after fracture is 8 mm and the gauge length at fracture is 65 mm. Calculate the following properties of the material from the tension test. (i)

% Elongation

(ii)

Reduction of Area (RA) %

(iii) Tensile strength or ultimate tensile strength (UTS) (iv) Yield strength (v)

Fracture strength

(vi) If E = 200 GPa, the elastic recoverable strain at maximum load (vii) If the elongation at maximum load (the uniform elongation) is 20%, what is the plastic strain at maximum load?

Area at fracture Af

S

S 4

2

u 0.010 m2 2

4

u 0.008 m2

7.854 u 105 m2

5.027 u 105 m2

Original gauge length (L0) = 50 mm Gauge length at fracture (L) = 65 mm Therefore

(i) % Elongation

L  L0 u 100% L0

(ii) Reduction of area (RA) = q

65  50 u 100 30% 50 A0  Af u 100% A0

7.854  5.027 u 100% 7.854

(iii) Tensile strength or Ultimate tensile strength (UTS), V u (iv) Yield strength V y

Py Ao

(v) Fracture strength V F

55 u 103 N/m2 5 7.854 u 10 PFracture Ao

Pmax Ao

36%

70 u 103 N/m2 5 7.854 u 10

700 MPa

60 u 103 N/m2 5 7.854 u 10

764MPa

Pmax / Ao 891u 106 9 Page 18Eof 429 200 u 10

(vi) Elastic recoverable strain at maximum load H E

0.0045

891 MPa

Chapter-1 (vii) Plastic strain H P H total  H E

Stress and Strain

0.2000  0.0045 0.1955

1.25 Elasticity This is the property of a material to regain its original shape after deformation when the external forces are removed. When the material is in elastic region the strain disappears completely after removal of the load, The stress-strain relationship in elastic region need not be linear and can be non-linear (example rubber). The maximum stress value below which the strain is fully recoverable is called the elastic limit. It is represented by point A in figure. All materials are elastic to some extent but the degree varies, for example, both mild steel and rubber are elastic materials but steel is more elastic than rubber.

1.26 Plasticity When the stress in the material exceeds the elastic limit, the material enters into plastic phase where the strain can no longer be completely removed. Under plastic conditions materials ideally deform without any increase in stress. A typical stress strain diagram for an elastic-perfectly plastic material is shown in the figure. Mises-Henky criterion gives a good starting point for plasticity analysis.

1.27 Strain hardening If the material is reloaded from point C, it will follow the previous unloading path and line CB becomes its new elastic region with elastic limit defined by point B. Though the new elastic region CB resembles that of the initial elastic region OA, the internal structure of the material in the new state has changed. The change in the microstructure of the material is clear from the fact that the ductility of the material has come down due to strain hardening. When the material is reloaded, it follows the same path as that of a virgin material and fails on reaching the ultimate strength which remains unaltered due to the intermediate loading and unloading process.

Page 19 of 429

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondal’s

1.28 Stress reversal and stress-strain hysteresis loop We know that fatigue failure begins at a local discontinuity and when the stress at the discontinuity exceeds elastic limit there is plastic strain. The cyclic plastic strain results crack propagation and fracture. When we plot the experimental data with reversed loading and the true stress strain hysteresis loops is found as shown below.

True stress-strain plot with a number of stress reversals Due to cyclic strain the elastic limit increases for annealed steel and decreases for cold drawn steel. Here the stress range is Ʀǔ. Ʀǆp and Ʀǆe are the plastic and elastic strain ranges, the total strain range being Ʀǆ. Considering that the total strain amplitude can be given as Ʀǆ = Ʀǆp+ Ʀǆe

Page 20 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondal’s

OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Stress in a bar due to self-weight GATE-1.

Two identical circular rods of same diameter and same length are subjected to same magnitude of axial tensile force. One of the rods is made out of mild steel having the modulus of elasticity of 206 GPa. The other rod is made out of cast iron having the modulus of elasticity of 100 GPa. Assume both the materials to be homogeneous and isotropic and the axial force causes the same amount of uniform stress in both the rods. The stresses developed are within the proportional limit of the respective materials. Which of the following observations is correct? [GATE-2003] (a) Both rods elongate by the same amount (b) Mild steel rod elongates more than the cast iron rod (c) Cast iron rod elongates more than the mild steel rod (d) As the stresses are equal strains are also equal in both the rods PL 1 or G L f [AsP, L and A is same] GATE-1. Ans. (c) G L AE E G L mild steel ECI 100 ? G L CI ! G L MS EMS 206 G L C.I GATE-2.

A steel bar of 40 mm × 40 mm square cross-section is subjected to an axial compressive load of 200 kN. If the length of the bar is 2 m and E = 200 GPa, the elongation of the bar will be: [GATE-2006] (a) 1.25 mm (b) 2.70 mm (c) 4.05 mm (d) 5.40 mm

GATE-2. Ans. (a) G L

PL AE

200 u 1000 u 2 0.04 u 0.04 u 200 u 109

m 1.25mm

True stress and true strain GATE-3.

The ultimate tensile strength of a material is 400 MPa and the elongation up to maximum load is 35%. If the material obeys power law of hardening, then the true stress-true strain relation (stress in MPa) in the plastic deformation range is: [GATE-2006] 0.30 0.30 0.35 (b) V 775H (c) V 540H (d) V 775H 0.35 (a) V 540H GATE-3. Ans. (c) A true stress – true strain curve in tension V kH n k = Strength co-efficient = 400 × (1.35) = 540 MPa n = Strain – hardening exponent = 0.35

Elasticity and Plasticity GATE-4.

An axial residual compressive stress due to a manufacturing process is present on the outer surface of a rotating shaft subjected to bending. Under a given Page 21 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

bending load, the fatigue life of the shaft in the presence of the residual compressive stress is: [GATE-2008] (a) Decreased (b) Increased or decreased, depending on the external bending load (c) Neither decreased nor increased (d) Increased GATE-4. Ans. (d)

A cantilever-loaded rotating beam, showing the normal distribution of surface stresses. (i.e., tension at the top and compression at the bottom)

The residual compressive stresses induced.

Net stress pattern obtained when loading a surface treated beam. The reduced magnitude of the tensile stresses contributes to increased fatigue life. GATE-5.

A static load is mounted at the centre of a shaft rotating at uniform angular velocity. This shaft will be designed for [GATE-2002] (a) The maximum compressive stress (static) (b) The maximum tensile stress (static) (c) The maximum bending moment (static) (d) Fatigue loading GATE-5. Ans. (d) GATE-6.

Fatigue strength of a rod subjected to cyclic axial force is less than that of a rotating beam of the same dimensions subjected to steady lateral force because (a) Axial stiffness is less than bending stiffness [GATE-1992] (b) Of absence of centrifugal effects in the rod (c) The number of discontinuities vulnerable to fatigue are more in the rod (d) At a particular time the rod has only one type of stress whereas the beam has both the tensile and compressive stresses. GATE-6. Ans. (d)

Relation between the Elastic Modulii GATE-7.

A rod of length L and diameter D is subjected to a tensile load P. Which of the following is sufficient to calculate the resulting change in diameter? (a) Young's modulus (b) Shear modulus [GATE-2008] (c) Poisson's ratio (d) Both Young's modulus and shear modulus Page 22 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

GATE-7. Ans. (d) For longitudinal strain we need Young's modulus and for calculating transverse strain we need Poisson's ratio. We may calculate Poisson's ratio from E 2G (1  P ) for that we need Shear modulus. GATE-8.

In terms of Poisson's ratio (Îź) the ratio of Young's Modulus (E) to Shear Modulus (G) of elastic materials is [GATE-2004]

(a) 2(1  P )

1 (c) (1  P ) 2

(b) 2(1  P )

(d )

1 (1  P ) 2

GATE-8. Ans. (a) GATE-9.

The relationship between Young's modulus (E), Bulk modulus (K) and Poisson's ratio (Îź) is given by: [GATE-2002] (b) K (a) E 3 K 1  2P

3 E 1  2P

(c) E

3 K 1  P

GATE-9. Ans. (a) Remember

(d) K

E

2G 1  P

3K 1  2P

3 E 1  P

9KG 3K  G

Stresses in compound strut GATE-10. In a bolted joint two members are connected with an axial tightening force of 2200 N. If the bolt used has metric threads of 4 mm pitch, then torque required for achieving the tightening force is (a) 0.7Nm (b) 1.0 Nm (c) 1.4Nm (d) 2.8Nm GATE-10. Ans. (c) T

Fur

2200 u

0.004 Nm 2S

[GATE-2004] 1.4Nm

GATE-11. The figure below shows a steel rod of 25 mm2 cross sectional area. It is loaded at four points, K, L, M and N. [GATE-2004, IES 1995, 1997, 1998]

Assume Esteel = 200 GPa. The total change in length of the rod due to loading is: (a) 1 Îźm (b) -10 Îźm (c) 16 Îźm (d) -20 Îźm

GATE-11. Ans. (b) First draw FBD of all parts separately then

Total change in length =

PL

Â&#x153; AE

GATE-12. A bar having a cross-sectional area of 700mm2 is subjected to axial loads at the positions indicated. The value of stress in the segment QR is: [GATE-2006] Page 23 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

P (a) 40 MPa GATE-12. Ans. (a)

Q (b) 50 MPa

S K Mondal’s

R (c) 70 MPa

S (d) 120 MPa

F.B.D

V QR

P A

28000 MPa 700

40MPa

GATE-13. An ejector mechanism consists of a helical compression spring having a spring constant of K = 981 × 103 N/m. It is pre-compressed by 100 mm from its free state. If it is used to eject a mass of 100 kg held on it, the mass will move up through a distance of (a) 100mm (b) 500mm (c) 981 mm (d) 1000mm [GATE-2004] GATE-13. Ans. (a) No calculation needed it is precompressed by 100 mm from its free state. So it can’t move more than 100 mm. choice (b), (c) and (d) out. GATE-14. The figure shows a pair of pin-jointed gripper-tongs holding an object weighing 2000 N. The co-efficient of friction (μ) at the gripping surface is 0.1 XX is the line of action of the input force and YY is the line of application of gripping force. If the pin-joint is assumed to be frictionless, then magnitude of force F required to hold the weight is: (a) 1000 N (b) 2000 N (c) 2500 N (d) 5000 N

[GATE-2004] GATE-14. Ans. (d) Frictional force required = 2000 N Force needed to produce 2000N frictional force at Y-Y section = So for each side we need (Fy) = 10000 N force

Page 24 of 429

2000 0.1

20000N

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

Taking moment about PIN Fy u 50 Fy u 50 F u 100 or F 100

10000 u 50 100

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

5000N

GATE-15. A uniform, slender cylindrical rod is made of a homogeneous and isotropic material. The rod rests on a frictionless surface. The rod is heated uniformly. If the radial and longitudinal thermal stresses are represented by Ç&#x201D;r and Ç&#x201D;z, respectively, then [GATE-2005]

(a) V r

0, V z

0

(b) V r z 0, V z

0

(c ) V r

0, V z z 0

(d ) V r z 0, V z z 0

GATE-15. Ans. (a) Thermal stress will develop only when you prevent the material to contrast/elongate. As here it is free no thermal stress will develop.

Tensile Test GATE-16. A test specimen is stressed slightly beyond the yield point and then unloaded. Its yield strength will [GATE-1995] (a) Decrease (b) Increase (c) Remains same (d) Becomes equal to ultimate tensile strength GATE-16. Ans. (b)

GATE-17. Under repeated loading a material has the stress-strain curve shown in figure, which of the following statements is true? (a) The smaller the shaded area, the better the material damping (b) The larger the shaded area, the better the material damping (c) Material damping is an independent material property and does not depend on this curve (d) None of these GATE-17. Ans. (a)

[GATE-1999]

Previous 20-Years IES Questions Stress in a bar due to self-weight IES-1.

A solid uniform metal bar of diameter D and length L is hanging vertically from its upper end. The elongation of the bar due to self weight is: [IES-2005] (a) Proportional to L and inversely proportional to D2 (b) Proportional to L2 and inversely proportional to D2 (c) Proportional of L but independent of D (d) Proportional of U but independent of D Page 25 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

IES-1. Ans. (a) G

WL 2AE

WL 2u

S D2 4

?G u L uE

& Gu

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

1 D2

IES-2.

The deformation of a bar under its own weight as compared to that when subjected to a direct axial load equal to its own weight will be: [IES-1998] (a) The same (b) One-fourth (c) Half (d) Double IES-2. Ans. (c) IES-3.

A rigid beam of negligible weight is supported in a horizontal position by two rods of steel and aluminum, 2 m and 1 m long having values of cross - sectional areas 1 cm2 and 2 cm2 and E of 200 GPa and 100 GPa respectively. A load P is applied as shown in the figure [IES-2002]

If the rigid beam is to remain horizontal then (a) The forces on both sides should be equal (b) The force on aluminum rod should be twice the force on steel (c) The force on the steel rod should be twice the force on aluminum (d) The force P must be applied at the centre of the beam IES-3. Ans. (b)

Bar of uniform strength IES-4.

Which one of the following statements is correct? [IES 2007] A beam is said to be of uniform strength, if (a) The bending moment is the same throughout the beam (b) The shear stress is the same throughout the beam (c) The deflection is the same throughout the beam (d) The bending stress is the same at every section along its longitudinal axis IES-4. Ans. (d) IES-5.

Which one of the following statements is correct? [IES-2006] Beams of uniform strength vary in section such that (a) bending moment remains constant (b) deflection remains constant (c) maximum bending stress remains constant (d) shear force remains constant IES-5. Ans. (c) IES-6.

For bolts of uniform strength, the shank diameter is made equal to (a) Major diameter of threads (b) Pitch diameter of threads (c) Minor diameter of threads (d) Nominal diameter of threads IES-6. Ans. (c)

[IES-2003]

IES-7.

A bolt of uniform strength can be developed by [IES-1995] (a) Keeping the core diameter of threads equal to the diameter of unthreaded portion of the bolt Page 26 of 429 (b) Keeping the core diameter smaller than the diameter of the unthreaded portion

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain (c)

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Keeping the nominal diameter of threads equal the diameter of unthreaded portion of the bolt One end fixed and the other end free

(d) IES-7. Ans. (a)

Elongation of a Taper Rod IES-8.

Two tapering bars of the same material are subjected to a tensile load P. The lengths of both the bars are the same. The larger diameter of each of the bars is D. The diameter of the bar A at its smaller end is D/2 and that of the bar B is D/3. What is the ratio of elongation of the bar A to that of the bar B? [IES-2006] (a) 3 : 2 (b) 2: 3 (c) 4 : 9 (d) 1: 3 PL IES-8. Ans. (b) Elongation of a taper rod G l

S ddE 4 1 2 G l A d2 B Â§ D / 3 Âˇ 2 or G l B d2 A Â¨ÂŠ D / 2 Â¸Âš 3 IES-9.

A bar of length L tapers uniformly from diameter 1.1 D at one end to 0.9 D at the other end. The elongation due to axial pull is computed using mean diameter D. What is the approximate error in computed elongation? [IES-2004] (a) 10% (b) 5% (c) 1% (d) 0.5% PL PL IES-9. Ans. (c) Actual elongation of the bar G l act Â§S Âˇ Â§S Âˇ Â¨ 4 d1d2 Â¸ E Â¨ 4 u 1.1D u 0.9D Â¸ E ÂŠ Âš ÂŠ Âš PL Calculated elongation of the bar G l Cal S D2 uE 4 G l act  G l cal Â§ Âˇ D2 ? Error %

u 100 Â¨  1Â¸ u 100% 1% G l cal ÂŠ 1.1D u 0.9D Âš

IES-10.

The stretch in a steel rod of circular section, having a length 'l' subjected to a tensile load' P' and tapering uniformly from a diameter d1 at one end to a [IES-1995] diameter d2 at the other end, is given (a)

Pl 4 Ed1d 2

(b)

pl.S Ed1d 2

IES-10. Ans. (d) Actual elongation of the bar G l act

IES-11.

(c)

pl.S 4 Ed1d 2

(d)

4 pl S Ed1d 2

PL Â§S

Âˇ Â¨ d1d2 Â¸ E ÂŠ4 Âš

A tapering bar (diameters of end sections being d1 and d2 a bar of uniform cross-section â&#x20AC;&#x2122;dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; have the same length and are subjected the same axial pull. Both the bars will have the same extension ifâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; is equal to [IES-1998]

a

d1  d 2 2

b

d1d 2

c

d1d 2 2

d

d1  d 2 2

IES-11. Ans. (b)

Poissonâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s ratio IES-12.

In the case of an engineering material under unidirectional stress in the xdirection, the Poisson's ratio is equal to (symbols have the usual meanings) [IAS 1994, IES-2000] Page 27 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain (a)

Hy Hx

(b)

Hy Vx

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s (c)

Vy Vx

(d)

Vy Hx

IES-12. Ans. (a) IES-13.

Which one of the following is correct in respect of Poisson's ratio (v) limits for an isotropic elastic solid? [IES-2004] (b) 1/ 4 dQ d1/ 3 (c) 1dQ d1/ 2 (d) 1/ 2 dQ d1/ 2 (a) f dQ d f IES-13. Ans. (c) Theoretically 1  P  1/ 2 but practically 0  P  1/ 2

IES-14.

Match List-I (Elastic properties of an isotropic elastic material) with List-II (Nature of strain produced) and select the correct answer using the codes given below the Lists: [IES-1997] List-I List-II A. Young's modulus 1. Shear strain B. Modulus of rigidity 2. Normal strain C. Bulk modulus 3. Transverse strain D. Poisson's ratio 4. Volumetric strain Codes: A B C D A B C D (a) 1 2 3 4 (b) 2 1 3 4 (c) 2 1 4 3 (d) 1 2 4 3 IES-14. Ans. (c) IES-15.

If the value of Poisson's ratio is zero, then it means that (a) The material is rigid. (b) The material is perfectly plastic. (c) There is no longitudinal strain in the material (d) The longitudinal strain in the material is infinite. IES-15. Ans. (a) If Poisson's ratio is zero, then material is rigid.

[IES-1994]

IES-16.

[IES-1992]

Which of the following is true (Îź= Poisson's ratio) (b) 1  P  0 (c) 1  P  1 (a) 0  P  1/ 2 IES-16. Ans. (a)

(d) f

P  f

Elasticity and Plasticity IES-17.

If the area of cross-section of a wire is circular and if the radius of this circle decreases to half its original value due to the stretch of the wire by a load, then the modulus of elasticity of the wire be: [IES-1993] (a) One-fourth of its original value (b) Halved (c) Doubled (d) Unaffected IES-17. Ans. (d) Note: Modulus of elasticity is the property of material. It will remain same. IES-18.

The relationship between the Lameâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s constant â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Ç&#x152;â&#x20AC;&#x2122;, Youngâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s modulus â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Eâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; and the Poissonâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s ratio â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Ç?â&#x20AC;&#x2122; [IES-1997]

a O

EP 1  P 1  2P

(b)O

EP 1  2P 1  P

c O

EP 1 P

d O

EP 1  P

IES-18. Ans. (a) IES-19.

Which of the following pairs are correctly matched? [IES-1994] 1. Resilienceâ&#x20AC;Śâ&#x20AC;Śâ&#x20AC;Śâ&#x20AC;Śâ&#x20AC;Ś Resistance to deformation. 2. Malleability â&#x20AC;Śâ&#x20AC;Śâ&#x20AC;Śâ&#x20AC;Ś..Shape change. 3. Creep ........................ Progressive deformation. 4. Plasticity .... â&#x20AC;Śâ&#x20AC;Śâ&#x20AC;Śâ&#x20AC;Ś.Permanent deformation. Select the correct answer using the codes given below: Codes: (a) 2, 3 and 4 (b) 1, 2 and 3 (c) 1, 2 and 4 (d) 1, 3 and 4 IES-19. Ans. (a) Strain energy stored by a body within elastic limit is known as resilience. Page 28 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondal’s

Creep and fatigue IES-20.

What is the phenomenon of progressive extension of the material i.e., strain increasing with the time at a constant load, called? [IES 2007] (a) Plasticity (b) Yielding (b) Creeping (d) Breaking IES-20. Ans. (c) IES-21.

The correct sequence of creep deformation in a creep curve in order of their elongation is: [IES-2001] (a) Steady state, transient, accelerated (b) Transient, steady state, accelerated (c) Transient, accelerated, steady state (d) Accelerated, steady state, transient IES-21. Ans. (b) IES-22.

The highest stress that a material can withstand for a specified length of time without excessive deformation is called [IES-1997] (a) Fatigue strength (b) Endurance strength (c) Creep strength (d) Creep rupture strength IES-22. Ans. (c) IES-23.

Which one of the following features improves the fatigue strength of a metallic material? [IES-2000] (a) Increasing the temperature (b) Scratching the surface (c) Overstressing (d) Under stressing IES-23. Ans. (d) IES-24.

Consider the following statements: [IES-1993] For increasing the fatigue strength of welded joints it is necessary to employ 1. Grinding 2. Coating 3. Hammer peening Of the above statements (a) 1 and 2 are correct (b) 2 and 3 are correct (c) 1 and 3 are correct (d) 1, 2 and 3 are correct IES-24. Ans. (c) A polished surface by grinding can take more number of cycles than a part with rough surface. In Hammer peening residual compressive stress lower the peak tensile stress

Relation between the Elastic Modulii IES-25.

For a linearly elastic, isotropic and homogeneous material, the number of elastic constants required to relate stress and strain is: [IAS 1994; IES-1998] (a) Two (b) Three (c) Four (d) Six IES-25. Ans. (a) E, G, K and Ǎ represent the elastic modulus, shear modulus, bulk modulus and Poisson's ratio respectively of a linearly elastic, isotropic and homogeneous material. To express the stress-strain relations completely for this material, at least [IES-2006] (a) E, G and Ǎ must be known (b) E, K and Ǎ must be known (c) Any two of the four must be known (d) All the four must be known IES-26. Ans. (c) IES-27. The number of elastic constants for a completely anisotropic elastic material which follows Hooke's law is: [IES-1999] (a) 3 (b) 4 (c) 21 (d) 25 IES-27. Ans. (c)

IES-26.

IES-28.

What are the materials which show direction dependent properties, called? (a) Homogeneous materials (b) Viscoelastic materials [IES 2007] (c) Isotropic materials (d) Anisotropic materials IES-28. Ans. (d) IES-29.

Page 29 of 429

An orthotropic material, under plane stress condition will have:

[IES-2006]

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

(a) 15 independent elastic constants (c) 5 independent elastic constants IES-29. Ans. (d)

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

(b) 4 independent elastic constants (d) 9 independent elastic constants

IES-30.

Match List-I (Properties) with List-II (Units) and select the correct answer using the codes given below the lists: [IES-2001] List I List II A. Dynamic viscosity 1. Pa B. Kinematic viscosity 2. m2/s C. Torsional stiffness 3. Ns/m2 D. Modulus of rigidity 4. N/m Codes: A B C D A B C D (a) 3 2 4 1 (b) 5 2 4 3 (b) 3 4 2 3 (d) 5 4 2 1 IES-30. Ans. (a) IES-31.

Young's modulus of elasticity and Poisson's ratio of a material are 1.25 Ă&#x2014; 105 MPa and 0.34 respectively. The modulus of rigidity of the material is: [IAS 1994, IES-1995, 2001, 2002, 2007] (b) 0.4664 Ă&#x2014; 105 Mpa (a) 0.4025 Ă&#x2014;105 Mpa (d) 0.9469 Ă&#x2014; 105 MPa (c) 0.8375 Ă&#x2014; 105 MPa 5 IES-31. Ans.(b) E 2G (1  P ) or 1.25x10 = 2G(1+0.34) or G = 0.4664 Ă&#x2014; 105 MPa

IES-32.

In a homogenous, isotropic elastic material, the modulus of elasticity E in terms of G and K is equal to [IAS-1995, IES - 1992] (a)

G  3K 9 KG

(b)

3G  K 9 KG

(c)

9 KG G  3K

(d)

9 KG K  3G

IES-32. Ans. (c) IES-33.

What is the relationship between the linear elastic properties Young's modulus (E), rigidity modulus (G) and bulk modulus (K)? [IES-2008] 1 9 3 3 9 1 9 3 1 9 1 3 (a)  (b)  (c)  (d)  E K G E K G E K G E K G 9KG IES-33. Ans. (d) E 2G 1  P 3K 1  2 P

3K  G

IES-34.

What is the relationship between the liner elastic properties Youngâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s modulus (E), rigidity modulus (G) and bulk modulus (K)? [IES-2009] (a)

E

IES-34. Ans. (d) E

KG 9K  G 2G 1  P

(b)

E

9KG K G

3K 1  2P

(c)

E

9 KG K  3G

(d)

E

9 KG 3K  G

9KG 3K  G

IES-35.

If E, G and K denote Young's modulus, Modulus of rigidity and Bulk Modulus, respectively, for an elastic material, then which one of the following can be possibly true? [IES-2005] (a) G = 2K (b) G = E (c) K = E (d) G = K = E 9KG IES-35. Ans.(c) E 2G 1  P 3K 1  2P

3K  G 1 the value of P must be between 0 to 0.5 so E never equal to G but if P then 3 E k so ans. is c IES-36.

If a material had a modulus of elasticity of 2.1 Ă&#x2014; 106 kgf/cm2 and a modulus of rigidity of 0.8 Ă&#x2014; 106 kgf/cm2 then the approximate value of the Poisson's ratio of the material would be: [IES-1993] Page 30 of 429 (a) 0.26 (b) 0.31 (c) 0.47 (d) 0.5

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

IES-36. Ans. (b) Use E

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

2G 1  P

The modulus of elasticity for a material is 200 GN/m2 and Poisson's ratio is 0.25. What is the modulus of rigidity? [IES-2004] (b) 125 GN/m2 (c) 250 GN/m2 (d) 320 GN/m2 (a) 80 GN/m2 E 200 80GN / m2 IES-37. Ans. (a) E 2G 1  P or G 2 1  P 2 u 1  0.25

IES-37.

IES-38.

Consider the following statements: [IES-2009] 1. Two-dimensional stresses applied to a thin plate in its own plane represent the plane stress condition. 2. Under plane stress condition, the strain in the direction perpendicular to the plane is zero. 3. Normal and shear stresses may occur simultaneously on a plane. Which of the above statements is /are correct? (a) 1 only (b) 1 and 2 (c) 2 and 3 (d) 1 and 3 IES-38. Ans. (d) Under plane stress condition, the strain in the direction perpendicular to the plane is not zero. It has been found experimentally that when a body is stressed within elastic limit, the lateral strain bears a constant ratio to the linear strain. [IES-2009]

Stresses in compound strut IES-39.

Eight bolts are to be selected for fixing the cover plate of a cylinder subjected to a maximum load of 980Âˇ175 kN. If the design stress for the bolt material is [IES-2008] 315 N/mm2, what is the diameter of each bolt? (a) 10 mm (b) 22 mm (c) 30 mm (d) 36 mm

IES-39. Ans. (b) Total load P

IES-40.

8 uV u

S d2 4

or d

P 2SV

980175 2S u 315

22.25 mm

For a composite consisting of a bar enclosed inside a tube of another material when compressed under a load 'w' as a whole through rigid collars at the end of the bar. The equation of compatibility is given by (suffixes 1 and 2) refer to bar and tube respectively [IES-1998]

(a) W1  W2

W

(b) W1  W2

Const. (c)

W1 A1 E1

W2 A2 E2

(d )

W1 A1 E2

W2 A2 E1

IES-40. Ans. (c) Compatibility equation insists that the change in length of the bar must be compatible with the boundary conditions. Here (a) is also correct but it is equilibrium equation. IES-41.

When a composite unit consisting of a steel rod surrounded by a cast iron tube is subjected to an axial load. [IES-2000] Assertion (A): The ratio of normal stresses induced in both the materials is equal to the ratio of Young's moduli of respective materials. Reason (R): The composite unit of these two materials is firmly fastened together at the ends to ensure equal deformation in both the materials. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is not the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IES-41. Ans. (a) IES-42.

The figure below shows a steel rod of 25 mm2 cross sectional area. It is loaded at four points, K, L, M and N. [GATE-2004, IES 1995, 1997, 1998]

Page 31 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondal’s

Assume Esteel = 200 GPa. The total change in length of the rod due to loading is (a) 1 μm (b) -10 μm (c) 16 μm (d) -20 μm IES-42. Ans. (b) First draw FBD of all parts separately then

Total change in length =

IES-43.

PL

 AE

The reactions at the rigid supports at A and B for the bar loaded as shown in the figure are respectively. (a) 20/3 kN,10/3 kN (b) 10/3 kN, 20/3 kN (c) 5 kN, 5 kN (d) 6 kN, 4 kN [IES-2002;

IAS-

2003] IES-43. Ans. (a) Elongation in AC = length reduction in CB

R A u 1 RB u 2 AE AE And RA + RB = 10 IES-44.

Which one of the following is correct? [IES-2008] When a nut is tightened by placing a washer below it, the bolt will be subjected to (a) Compression only (b) Tension (c) Shear only (d) Compression and shear IES-44. Ans. (b) IES-45.

Which of the following stresses are associated with the tightening of nut on a bolt? [IES-1998] 1. Tensile stress due to the stretching of bolt 2. Bending stress due to the bending of bolt 3. Crushing and shear stresses in threads 4. Torsional shear stress due to frictional resistance between the nut and the bolt. Select the correct answer using the codes given below Codes: (a) 1, 2 and 4 (b) 1, 2 and 3 (c) 2, 3 and 4 (d) 1, 3 and 4 IES-45. Ans. (d)

Thermal effect IES-46.

A 100 mm × 5 mm × 5 mm steel bar free to expand is heated from 15°C to 40°C. What shall be developed? [IES-2008] (a) Tensile stress (b) Compressive stress (c) Shear stress (d) No stress IES-46. Ans. (d) If we resist to expand then only stress will develop. IES-47.

Which one of the following statements is correct? [GATE-1995; IES 2007] Page 32 of 429 it will develop If a material expands freely due to heating,

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

(a) Thermal stress IES-47. Ans. (d) IES-48.

(b) Tensile stress

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

(c) Compressive stress

(d) No stress

A cube having each side of length a, is constrained in all directions and is heated uniformly so that the temperature is raised to TÂ°C. If Ç&#x201A; is the thermal coefficient of expansion of the cube material and E the modulus of elasticity, the stress developed in the cube is: [IES-2003] (a)

D TE J

(b)

D TE 1  2J

(c)

D TE 2J

(d)

D TE 1  2J

3

3 3 %V T  p a 1 BT  a IES-48. Ans. (b)   V K a3 P Or  3BT E 3 1 2H

IES-49.

Consider the following statements: Thermal stress is induced in a component in general, when 1. A temperature gradient exists in the component 2. The component is free from any restraint 3. It is restrained to expand or contract freely Which of the above statements are correct? (a) 1 and 2 (b) 2 and 3 (c) 3 alone IES-49. Ans. (c) IES-50.

[IES-2002]

(d) 2 alone

A steel rod 10 mm in diameter and 1m long is heated from 20Â°C to 120Â°C, E = 200 GPa and Ç&#x201A; = 12 Ă&#x2014; 10-6 per Â°C. If the rod is not free to expand, the thermal stress developed is: [IAS-2003, IES-1997, 2000, 2006] (a) 120 MPa (tensile) (b) 240 MPa (tensile) (c) 120 MPa (compressive) (d) 240 MPa (compressive)

IES-50. Ans. (d) D E't

12 u 10 u 200 u 10 u 120  20

6

3

240MPa

It will be compressive as elongation restricted. IES-51.

A cube with a side length of 1 cm is heated uniformly 1Â° C above the room temperature and all the sides are free to expand. What will be the increase in volume of the cube? (Given coefficient of thermal expansion is Ç&#x201A; per Â°C) (b) 2 Ç&#x201A; cm3 (c) Ç&#x201A; cm3 (d) zero [IES-2004] (a) 3 Ç&#x201A; cm3 IES-51. Ans. (a) co-efficient of volume expansion J 3 u co  efficient of linear exp ansion D

IES-52.

A bar of copper and steel form a composite system. [IES-2004] They are heated to a temperature of 40 Â° C. What type of stress is induced in the copper bar? (a) Tensile (b) Compressive (c) Both tensile and compressive (d) Shear IES-52. Ans. (b) IES-53.

ÄŽ =12.5Ă&#x2014;10-6 / o C, E = 200GPa If the rod fitted strongly between the supports as shown in the figure, is heated, the stress induced in it due to 20oC rise in temperature will be: [IES-1999] (a) 0.07945 MPa (b) -0.07945 MPa (c) -0.03972 MPa (d) 0.03972 MPa

Page 33 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

IES-53. Ans. (b) Let compression of the spring = x m Therefore spring force = kx kN Expansion of the rod due to temperature rise = LD't Reduction in the length due to compression force = Now LD't  Or x

kx u L AE

kx u L

x AE 0.5 u 12.5 u 106 u 20

0.125 mm Â­ Â˝ Â°Â° Â°Â° 50 u 0.5 ÂŽ1  Âž 2 Â° S u 0.010 u 200 u 106 Â° 4 ÂŻÂ° ÂżÂ° kx 50 u 0.125 ? Compressive stress =   0.07945MPa A Â§ S u 0.0102 Âˇ Â¨ Â¸ 4 ÂŠ Âš

IES-54.

The temperature stress is a function of [IES-1992] 1. Coefficient of linear expansion 2. Temperature rise 3. Modulus of elasticity The correct answer is: (a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1, 2 and 3 IES-54. Ans. (d) Stress in the rod due to temperature rise = D't u E

Assertion (A): Ductile materials generally absorb more impact loading than a brittle material [IES-2004] Reason (R): Ductile materials generally have higher ultimate strength than brittle materials (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is not the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IES-55. Ans. (c) IES-56.

Assertion (A): Specimens for impact testing are never notched. [IES-1999] Reason (R): A notch introduces tri-axial tensile stresses which cause brittle fracture. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IES-56. Ans. (d) A is false but R is correct. Page 34 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondal’s

Tensile Test IES-57.

During tensile-testing of a specimen using a Universal Testing Machine, the parameters actually measured include [IES-1996] (a) True stress and true strain (b) Poisson’s ratio and Young's modulus (c) Engineering stress and engineering strain (d) Load and elongation IES-57. Ans. (d) IES-58.

In a tensile test, near the elastic limit zone (a) Tensile stress increases at a faster rate (b) Tensile stress decreases at a faster rate (c) Tensile stress increases in linear proportion to the stress (d) Tensile stress decreases in linear proportion to the stress IES-58. Ans. (b)

[IES-2006]

IES-59.

Match List-I (Types of Tests and Materials) with List-II (Types of Fractures) and select the correct answer using the codes given below the lists: List I List-II [IES-2002; IAS-2004] (Types of Tests and Materials) (Types of Fractures) A. Tensile test on CI 1. Plain fracture on a transverse plane B. Torsion test on MS 2. Granular helecoidal fracture C. Tensile test on MS 3. Plain granular at 45° to the axis D. Torsion test on CI 4. Cup and Cone 5. Granular fracture on a transverse plane Codes: A B C D A B C D (a) 4 2 3 1 (c) 4 1 3 2 (b) 5 1 4 2 (d) 5 2 4 1 IES-59. Ans. (d) IES-60.

Which of the following materials generally exhibits a yield point? [IES-2003] (a) Cast iron (b) Annealed and hot-rolled mild steel (c) Soft brass (d) Cold-rolled steel IES-60. Ans. (b) IES-61.

For most brittle materials, the ultimate strength in compression is much large then the ultimate strength in tension. The is mainly due to [IES-1992] (a) Presence of flaws and microscopic cracks or cavities (b) Necking in tension (c) Severity of tensile stress as compared to compressive stress (d) Non-linearity of stress-strain diagram IES-61. Ans. (a) IES-62.

What is the safe static tensile load for a M36 × 4C bolt of mild steel having yield stress of 280 MPa and a factor of safety 1.5? [IES-2005] (a) 285 kN (b) 190 kN (c) 142.5 kN (d) 95 kN W S d2 or W V u ; IES-62. Ans. (b) V c c 4 S d2 4 W V c u S u d2 280 u S u 362 Wsafe N 190kN fos fos u 4 1.5 u 4

IES-63.

Which one of the following properties is more sensitive to increase in strain rate? [IES-2000] (a) Yield strength (b) Proportional limit (c) Elastic limit (d) Tensile strength IES-63. Ans. (b) Page 35 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondal’s

IES-64.

A steel hub of 100 mm internal diameter and uniform thickness of 10 mm was heated to a temperature of 300oC to shrink-fit it on a shaft. On cooling, a crack developed parallel to the direction of the length of the hub. Consider the following factors in this regard: [IES-1994] 1. Tensile hoop stress 2. Tensile radial stress 3. Compressive hoop stress 4. Compressive radial stress The cause of failure is attributable to (a) 1 alone (b) 1 and 3 (c) 1, 2 and 4 (d) 2, 3 and 4 IES-64. Ans. (a) A crack parallel to the direction of length of hub means the failure was due to tensile hoop stress only. IES-65.

If failure in shear along 45° planes is to be avoided, then a material subjected to uniaxial tension should have its shear strength equal to at least [IES-1994] (a) Tensile strength (b) Compressive strength (c) Half the difference between the tensile and compressive strengths. (d) Half the tensile strength. IES-65. Ans. (d) IES-66. Select the proper sequence [IES-1992] 1. Proportional Limit 2. Elastic limit 3. Yielding 4. Failure (a) 2, 3, 1, 4 (b) 2, 1, 3, 4 (c) 1, 3, 2, 4 (d) 1, 2, 3, 4 IES-66. Ans. (d)

Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Stress in a bar due to self-weight IAS-1.

A heavy uniform rod of length 'L' and material density 'ǅ' is hung vertically with its top end rigidly fixed. How is the total elongation of the bar under its own weight expressed? [IAS-2007]

2G L2 g E

(a)

(b)

G L2 g E

IAS-1. Ans. (d) Elongation due to self weight = IAS-2.

(c)

WL 2 AE

G L2 g

(d)

2E G ALg L G L2 g 2 AE 2E

G L2 g 2E

A rod of length 'l' and cross-section area ‘A’ rotates about an axis passing through one end of the rod. The extension produced in the rod due to centrifugal forces is (w is the weight of the rod per unit length and Z is the angular velocity of rotation of the rod). [IAS 1994] (a)

Zwl 2 gE

(b)

Z 2 wl 3 3 gE

(c)

Z 2 wl 3 gE

IAS-2. Ans. (b)

Page 36 of 429

(d)

3 gE Z 2 wl 3

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondal’s

Elongation of a Taper Rod IAS-3.

A rod of length, " L " tapers uniformly from a diameter ''D1' to a diameter ''D2' and carries an axial tensile load of "P". The extension of the rod is (E represents the modulus of elasticity of the material of the rod) [IAS-1996] (a)

4 P1 S ED1 D2

(b)

4 PE1 S D1 D2

(c)

IAS-3. Ans. (a) The extension of the taper rod =

S EP1 4 D1D2

(d)

S P1 4 ED1D2

Pl §S · ¨ 4 D1D2 ¸ .E © ¹

Poisson’s ratio IAS-4.

In the case of an engineering material under unidirectional stress in the xdirection, the Poisson's ratio is equal to (symbols have the usual meanings) [IAS 1994, IES-2000] (a)

Hy Hx

(b)

Hy Vx

(c)

Vy Vx

(d)

Vy Hx

IAS-4. Ans. (a) IAS-5.

Assertion (A): Poisson's ratio of a material is a measure of its ductility. Reason (R): For every linear strain in the direction of force, Poisson's ratio of the material gives the lateral strain in directions perpendicular to the direction of force. [IAS-1999] (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is not the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-5. ans. (d) IAS-6.

Assertion (A): Poisson's ratio is a measure of the lateral strain in all direction perpendicular to and in terms of the linear strain. [IAS-1997] Reason (R): The nature of lateral strain in a uni-axially loaded bar is opposite to that of the linear strain. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is not the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-6. Ans. (b)

Elasticity and Plasticity IAS-7.

A weight falls on a plunger fitted in a container filled with oil thereby producing a pressure of 1.5 N/mm2 in the oil. The Bulk Modulus of oil is 2800 N/mm2. Given this situation, the volumetric compressive strain produced in the oil will be: [IAS-1997] (b) 800 × 106 (c) 268 × 106 (d) 535 × 10-6 (a) 400 × 10-6 P P 1.5 IAS-7. Ans. (d) Bulk modulus of elasticity (K) = or H v 535 u 106 Hv K 2800

Relation between the Elastic Modulii IAS-8.

For a linearly elastic, isotropic and homogeneous material, the number of elastic constants required to relate stress and strain is: [IAS 1994; IES-1998] (a) Two (b) Three (c) Four (d) Six IAS-8. Ans. (a) Page 37 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

IAS-9.

The independent elastic constants for a homogenous and isotropic material are (a) E, G, K, v (b) E, G, K (c) E, G, v (d) E, G [IAS-1995] IAS-9. Ans. (d) IAS-10.

The unit of elastic modulus is the same as those of [IAS 1994] (a) Stress, shear modulus and pressure (b) Strain, shear modulus and force (c) Shear modulus, stress and force (d) Stress, strain and pressure. IAS-10. Ans. (a) IAS-11.

Young's modulus of elasticity and Poisson's ratio of a material are 1.25 Ă&#x2014; 105 MPa and 0.34 respectively. The modulus of rigidity of the material is: [IAS 1994, IES-1995, 2001, 2002, 2007] (b) 0.4664 Ă&#x2014; 105 MPa (a) 0.4025 Ă&#x2014; 105 MPa 5 (d) 0.9469 Ă&#x2014; 105 MPa (c) 0.8375 Ă&#x2014; 10 MPa 5 IAS-11. Ans.(b) E 2G (1  P ) or 1.25x10 = 2G(1+0.34) or G = 0.4664 Ă&#x2014; 105 MPa

IAS-12.

The Young's modulus of elasticity of a material is 2.5 times its modulus of rigidity. The Posson's ratio for the material will be: [IAS-1997] (a) 0.25 (b) 0.33 (c) 0.50 (d) 0.75 E Â§ E Âˇ Â§ 2.5 Âˇ Â&#x; 1 P Â&#x;P Â¨  1Â¸ Â¨  1Â¸ 0.25 IAS-12. Ans. (a) E 2G 1  P

2G 2G ÂŠ Âš ÂŠ 2 Âš

IAS-13.

In a homogenous, isotropic elastic material, the modulus of elasticity E in terms of G and K is equal to [IAS-1995, IES - 1992] (a)

G  3K 9 KG

(b)

3G  K 9 KG

(c)

9 KG G  3K

(d)

9 KG K  3G

IAS-13. Ans. (c) The Elastic Constants E and K are related as ( P is the Poissonâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s ratio) [IAS-1996] (a) E = 2k (1 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2 P ) (b) E = 3k (1- 2 P ) (c) E = 3k (1 + P ) (d) E = 2K(1 + 2 P ) IAS-14. Ans. (b) E = 2G (1 + P ) = 3k (1- 2 P ) IAS-14.

IAS-15.

For an isotropic, homogeneous and linearly elastic material, which obeys Hooke's law, the number of independent elastic constant is: [IAS-2000] (a) 1 (b) 2 (c) 3 (d) 6 IAS-15. Ans. (b) E, G, K and Îź represent the elastic modulus, shear modulus, bulk modulus and poisons ratio respectively of a â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;linearly elastic, isotropic and homogeneous material.â&#x20AC;&#x2122; To express the stress â&#x20AC;&#x201C; strain relations completely for this material; at least any two of the four must be known. IAS-16.

E

2G 1  P 3K 1  3P

9 KG 3K  G

The moduli of elasticity and rigidity of a material are 200 GPa and 80 GPa, respectively. What is the value of the Poisson's ratio of the material? [IAS-2007] (a) 0Âˇ30 (b) 0Âˇ26 (c) 0Âˇ25 (d) 0Âˇ24

IAS-16. Ans. (c) E = 2G (1+ P ) or

P=

E 1 2G

200  1 0.25 2 u 80

Stresses in compound strut IAS-17.

The reactions at the rigid supports at A and B for the bar loaded as shown in the figure are respectively. [IES-2002; IAS-2003] (a) 20/3 kN,10/3 Kn (b) 10/3 kN, 20/3 kN (c) 5 kN, 5 kN (d) 6 kN, 4 kN

Page 38 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondal’s

IAS-17. Ans. (a) Elongation in AC = length reduction in CB

RA u 1 AE

RB u 2 AE

And RA + RB = 10

Thermal effect IAS-18.

A steel rod 10 mm in diameter and 1m long is heated from 20°C to 120°C, E = 200 GPa and ǂ = 12 × 10-6 per °C. If the rod is not free to expand, the thermal stress developed is: [IAS-2003, IES-1997, 2000, 2006] (a) 120 MPa (tensile) (b) 240 MPa (tensile) (c) 120 MPa (compressive) (d) 240 MPa (compressive)

12 u 10 u 200 u 10 u 120  20

6

IAS-18. Ans. (d) D E't

3

240MPa

It will be compressive as elongation restricted. IAS-19.

A. steel rod of diameter 1 cm and 1 m long is heated from 20°C to 120°C. Its

D 12 u106 / K and

E=200 GN/m2. If the rod is free to expand, the thermal stress developed in it is: [IAS-2002] (a) 12 × 104 N/m2 (b) 240 kN/m2 (c) zero (d) infinity IAS-19. Ans. (c) Thermal stress will develop only if expansion is restricted. IAS-20.

Which one of the following pairs is NOT correctly matched? [IAS-1999] (E = Young's modulus, ǂ = Coefficient of linear expansion, T = Temperature rise, A = Area of cross-section, l= Original length) ….. ( DTl  G ) (a) Temperature strain with permitted expansion G DTE (b) Temperature stress ….. DTEA (c) Temperature thrust ….. (d) Temperature stress with permitted expansion

…..

E (D Tl  G ) l

IAS-20. Ans. (a) Dimensional analysis gives (a) is wrong

Match List I with List II and select the correct answer using the codes given below the lists: [IAS-1995] List I (Property) List II (Testing Machine) A. Tensile strength 1. Rotating Bending Machine B. Impact strength 2. Three-Point Loading Machine C. Bending strength 3. Universal Testing Machine D. Fatigue strength 4. Izod Testing Machine

Codes: (a) (c) IAS-21. Ans. (d)

A 4 2

B 3 1

C 2 4

D 1 3

(b) (d)

Page 39 of 429

A 3 3

B 2 4

C 1 2

D 4 1

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Tensile Test IAS-22.

A mild steel specimen is tested in tension up to fracture in a Universal Testing Machine. Which of the following mechanical properties of the material can be evaluated from such a test? [IAS-2007] 1. Modulus of elasticity 2. Yield stress 3. Ductility 4. Tensile strength 5. Modulus of rigidity Select the correct answer using the code given below: (a) 1, 3, 5 and 6 (b) 2, 3, 4 and 6 (c) 1, 2, 5 and 6 (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4 IAS-22. Ans. (d) IAS-23.

In a simple tension test, Hooke's law is valid upto the (a) Elastic limit (b) Limit of proportionality (c) Ultimate stress IAS-23. Ans. (b)

[IAS-1998] (d) Breaking point

IAS-24.

Lueder' lines on steel specimen under simple tension test is a direct indication of yielding of material due to slip along the plane [IAS-1997] (a) Of maximum principal stress (b) Off maximum shear (c) Of loading (d) Perpendicular to the direction of loading IAS-24. Ans. (b) IAS-25.

The percentage elongation of a material as obtained from static tension test depends upon the [IAS-1998] (a) Diameter of the test specimen (b) Gauge length of the specimen (c) Nature of end-grips of the testing machine (d) Geometry of the test specimen IAS-25. Ans. (b) IAS-26.

Match List-I (Types of Tests and Materials) with List-II (Types of Fractures) and select the correct answer using the codes given below the lists: List I List-II [IES-2002; IAS-2004] (Types of Tests and Materials) (Types of Fractures) A. Tensile test on CI 1. Plain fracture on a transverse plane B. Torsion test on MS 2. Granular helecoidal fracture C. Tensile test on MS 3. Plain granular at 45Â° to the axis D. Torsion test on CI 4. Cup and Cone 5. Granular fracture on a transverse plane Codes: A B C D A B C D (a) 4 2 3 1 (c) 4 1 3 2 (b) 5 1 4 2 (d) 5 2 4 1 IAS-26. Ans. (d) IAS-27.

Assertion (A): For a ductile material stress-strain curve is a straight line up to the yield point. [IAS-2003] Reason (R): The material follows Hooke's law up to the point of proportionality. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is not the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-27. Ans. (d) IAS-28.

Assertion (A): Stress-strain curves for brittle material do not exhibit yield point. [IAS-1996] Reason (R): Brittle materials fail without yielding. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-28. Ans. (a) Up to elastic limit. Page 40 of 429

Chapter-1 IAS-29.

Stress and Strain

Match List I (Materials) with List II (Stress-Strain curves) and select the correct answer using the codes given below the Lists: [IAS-2001]

Codes: (a) (c) IAS-29. Ans. (b) IAS-30.

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

A 3 2

B 1 4

C 4 3

D 1 1

(b) (d)

A 3 4

B 2 1

C 4 3

D 2 2

The stress-strain curve of an ideal elastic strain hardening material will be as

[IAS-1998] IAS-30. Ans. (d)

IAS-31.

An idealised stress-strain curve for a perfectly plastic material is given by

[IAS-1996] IAS-31. Ans. (a) IAS-32.

Match List I with List II and select the correct answer using the codes given below the Lists: [IAS-2002] List I List Page 41 II of 429 A. Ultimate strength 1. Internal structure

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

B. Natural strain C. Conventional strain D. Stress Codes: A B (a) 1 2 (c) 1 3 IAS-32. Ans. (a)

C 3 2

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

2. Change of length per unit instantaneous length 3. Change of length per unit gauge length 4. Load per unit area D A B C D 4 (b) 4 3 2 1 4 (d) 4 2 3 1

IAS-33.

What is the cause of failure of a short MS strut under an axial load? [IAS-2007] (a) Fracture stress (b) Shear stress (c) Buckling (d) Yielding IAS-33. Ans. (d) In compression tests of ductile materials fractures is seldom obtained. Compression is accompanied by lateral expansion and a compressed cylinder ultimately assumes the shape of a flat disc. IAS-34.

Match List I with List II and select the correct answer using the codes given the lists: [IAS-1995] List I List II A. Rigid-Perfectly plastic

B.

Elastic-Perfectly plastic

C.

Rigid-Strain hardening

D.

Linearly elastic

Codes: (a) (c) IAS-34. Ans. (a)

A 3 3

B 1 1

C 4 2

D 2 4

(b) (d)

A 1 1

B 3 3

C 2 4

D 4 2

IAS-35.

Which one of the following materials is highly elastic? [IAS-1995] (a) Rubber (b) Brass (c) Steel (d) Glass IAS-35. Ans. (c) Steel is the highly elastic material because it is deformed least on loading, and regains its original from on removal of the load.

IAS-36. Assertion (A): Hooke's law is the constitutive law for a linear elastic material. Reason (R) Formulation of the theory of elasticity requires the hypothesis that there exists a unique unstressed state of the body, to which the body returns whenever all the forces are removed. [IAS-2002] (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is not the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-36. Ans. (a) IAS-37.

Page 42 of 429 Consider the following statements:

[IAS-2002]

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondal’s

1. There are only two independent elastic constants. 2. Elastic constants are different in orthogonal directions. 3. Material properties are same everywhere. 4. Elastic constants are same in all loading directions. 5. The material has ability to withstand shock loading. Which of the above statements are true for a linearly elastic, homogeneous and isotropic material? (a) 1, 3, 4 and 5 (b) 2, 3 and 4 (c) 1, 3 and 4 (d) 2 and 5 IAS-37. Ans. (a) IAS-38.

Which one of the following pairs is NOT correctly matched? [IAS-1999] (a) Uniformly distributed stress …. Force passed through the centroid of the cross-section (b) Elastic deformation …. Work done by external forces during deformation is dissipated fully as heat (c) Potential energy of strain …. Body is in a state of elastic deformation (d) Hooke's law …. Relation between stress and strain IAS-38. Ans. (b) A tensile bar is stressed to 250 N/mm2 which is beyond its elastic limit. At this stage the strain produced in the bar is observed to be 0.0014. If the modulus of elasticity of the material of the bar is 205000 N/mm2 then the elastic component of the strain is very close to [IAS-1997] (a) 0.0004 (b) 0.0002 (c) 0.0001 (d) 0.00005 IAS-39. Ans. (b) IAS-39.

Page 43 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question IES-2010 Q.

If a load of 60 kN is applied to a rigid bar suspended by 3 wires as shown in the above figure what force will be resisted by each wire? The outside wires are of Al, crosssectional area 300 mm2 and length 4 m. The central wire is steel with area 200 mm2 and length 8 m. Initially there is no slack in the wires E

2 u 105 N / mm 2 for Steel

0.667 u 105 N / mm 2 for Aluminum

[2 Marks]

Ans.

Aluminium wire FA1

FA1

FSt

Steel wire

60kN

P

a A1 ast EA1

Est

60 kN

300mm 2 l A1 200mm 2 lst

4m 8m

0.667 u 105 N / mm 2

2 u 105 N / mm 2

Force balance along vertical direction 2FA1  Fst 60 kN (1) Elongation will be same in all wires because rod is rigid remain horizontal loading

FA1 u l A1 a Al .EAl

Fst .lst ast .Est

(2)

Fst u 8

FA1 u 4 5

300 u 0.667 u 10 FA1 1.0005 Fst

200 u 2 u 105 (3)

Page 44 of 429

after

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

FA1

60 u 103 3.001

Fst

From equation (1)

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

19.99 kN or 20 kN

20 kN

FA1 Fst

20 kN Â˝ Âž Answer. 20 kN Âż

Conventional Question GATE The diameters of the brass and steel segments of the axially loaded bar shown in figure are 30 mm and 12 mm respectively. The diameter of the hollow section of the brass segment is 20 mm. Determine: (i) The maximum normal stress in the steel and brass (ii) The displacement of the free end ; Take Es = 210 GN/m2 and Eb = 105 GN/m2 Question:

As

S 4

u 12

A b BC

S

Ab CD

S

4 4

2

36S mm2

u 30

2

36S u 10 6 m2

225S mm2

u 302  202

225S u 106 m2

125S mm2

125S u 106 m2

(i) The maximum normal stress in steel and brass:

10 u 103 u 10 6 MN / m2 88.42MN / m2 6 36S u 10 5 u 103 u 10 6 MN / m2 7.07MN / m2 V b BC 225S u 10 6 5 u 103 u 106 MN / m2 12.73MN / m2 V b CD 125S u 10 6

Vs

(ii) The displacement of the free end:

Gl

G ls AB  G lb BC  G lb CD 88.42 u 0.15 7.07 u 0.2 12.73 u 0.125   9 9 6 6 210 u 10 u 10 105 u 10 u 10 105 u 109 u 10 6 9.178 u 105 m

Â§ Â¨ G l ÂŠ

Vl Âˇ E Â¸Âš

0.09178 mm

Distinguish between fatigue strength and fatigue limit. Fatigue strength as the value of cyclic stress at which failure occurs after N cycles. And fatigue limit as the limiting value of stress at which failure occurs as N becomes very large (sometimes called infinite cycle)

Conventional Question IES-1999

Page 45 of 429

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

List at least two factors that promote transition from ductile to brittle fracture. (i) With the grooved specimens only a small reduction in area took place, and the appearance of the facture was like that of brittle materials. (ii) By internal cavities, thermal stresses and residual stresses may combine with the effect of the stress concentration at the cavity to produce a crack. The resulting fracture will have the characteristics of a brittle failure without appreciable plastic flow, although the material may prove ductile in the usual tensile tests.

Distinguish between creep and fatigue. Fatigue is a phenomenon associated with variable loading or more precisely to cyclic stressing or straining of a material, metallic, components subjected to variable loading get fatigue, which leads to their premature failure under specific conditions. When a member is subjected to a constant load over a long period of time it undergoes a slow permanent deformation and this is termed as ''Creep''. This is dependent on temperature.

What different stresses set-up in a bolt due to initial tightening, while used as a fastener? Name all the stresses in detail. (i) When the nut is initially tightened there will be some elongation in the bolt so tensile stress will develop. (ii) While it is tightening a torque across some shear stress. But when tightening will be completed there should be no shear stress.

Conventional Question IES-2008 Question:

A Copper rod 6 cm in diameter is placed within a steel tube, 8 cm external diameter and 6 cm internal diameter, of exactly the same length. The two pieces are rigidly fixed together by two transverse pins 20 mm in diameter, one at each end passing through both rod and the tube. Calculated the stresses induced in the copper rod, steel tube and the pins if the temperature of the combination is raised by 50oC. [Take ES=210 GPa,

Bs  0.0000115 / o C ; Ec=105 GPa, Bc  0.000017 / o C ]

Tc Ts

%t (Bc  Bs ) Ec Es 2

Qd 2 Q Â?Â&#x17E; 6 ÂŹÂ­ 2 3 2 = Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; Â­Â­ m  2.8274 q10 m 4 4 Â&#x;100 ÂŽ 2 2 Qd 2 Q Â ÂĄÂ?Â&#x17E; 8 ÂŹÂ­ Â?Â&#x17E; 6 ÂŹÂ­ ÂŻÂ° 2 3 2 Area of steel tube (A s )  = ÂĄÂ&#x17E;Â&#x17E; Â­ Â&#x17E; Â­ m  2.1991q10 m 4 4 ÂĄÂ˘Â&#x;100 ÂŽÂ­ Â&#x;Â&#x17E;100 ÂŽÂ­ Â°ÂąÂ° Rise in temperature,%t  50o C Area of copper rod(A c )

Free expansion of copper bar=Bc L+t Free expansion of steel tube =Page +tof 429 Bs L46

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Difference in free expansion = Bc  Bs L+t

= 17-11.5 Ă&#x2014;106 q L q 50=2.75Ă&#x2014;10-4L m A compressive force (P) exerted by the steel tube on the copper rod opposed the extra expansion of the copper rod and the copper rod exerts an equal tensile force P to pull the steel tube. In this combined effect reduction in copper rod and increase in length of steel tube equalize the difference in free expansions of the combined system. Reduction in the length of copper rod due to force P Newton=

+L C

PL PL  m Ac Ec 2.8275 q103 105 q109

Increase in length of steel tube due to force P PL P .L  m +L S  As Es 2.1991 q103 210 q109

Difference in length is equated

+L c +L s  2.75 q104 L PL P.L

2.75 q104 L 3 3 9 9 q q q q 2.8275 10 105 10 2.1991 10 210 10

Or P = 49.695 kN

49695 P  MPa=17.58MPa 2.8275 q103 Ac P 49695  Stress in steel tube, Ts  MPa  22.6MPa As 2.1991q103 Stress in copper rod, Tc

Since each of the pin is in double shear, shear stress in pins ( U pin ) =

P 49695  = 79 MPa 2 q Apin 2 q Q 0.02 2 4

Why are the bolts, subjected to impact, made longer? If we increase length its volume will increase so shock absorbing capacity will increased.

Conventional Question IES-2007 Question:

Explain the following in brief: (i) Effect of size on the tensile strength (ii) Effect of surface finish on endurance limit. (i) When size of the specimen increases tensile strength decrease. It is due to the reason that if size increases there should be more change of defects (voids) into the material which reduces the strength appreciably. (ii) If the surface finish is poor, the endurance strength is reduced because of scratches present in the specimen. From the scratch crack propagation will start.

Conventional Question IES-2004 Question:

Mention the relationship between three elastic constants i.e. elastic modulus (E), rigidity modulus (G), and bulk modulus (K) for any Elastic material. How is the Poisson's ratio ( Č? ) related to these modulli? Answer: E

9KG 3K G

9KG 3K + G Page 47 of 429

E  3K (1 2Îź) = 2G(1 + Îź) =

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Conventional Question IES-1996 Question:

The elastic and shear moduli of an elastic material are 2Ă&#x2014;1011 Pa and 8Ă&#x2014;1010 Pa respectively. Determine Poisson's ratio of the material.

We know that E = 2G(1+ Îź ) = 3K(1 - 2Îź) =

or,1 Îź  or Îź

9KG 3K + G

E 2G

E 2 q1011 1  1  0.25 2G 2 q (8 q1010 )

Conventional Question IES-2003 Question:

A steel bolt of diameter 10 mm passes through a brass tube of internal diameter 15 mm and external diameter 25 mm. The bolt is tightened by a nut so that the length of tube is reduced by 1.5 mm. If the temperature of the assembly is raised by 40oC, estimate the axial stresses the bolt and the tube before and after heating. Material properties for steel and brass are:

ES  2q105 N / mm 2

BS  1.2q105 / o C and Eb= 1Ă&#x2014;105 N/mm2 B b=1.9Ă&#x2014;10-15/oC

Ę&#x152; Area of steel bolt (A s )= q (0.010)2 m 2  7.854 q105 m 2 4 Ę&#x152; Area of brass tube (A b )= Â ÂĄÂ˘(0.025)2  (0.015)2 ÂŻÂ°Âą  3.1416 q104 4 Stress due to tightening of the nut Compressive force on brass tube= tensile fore on steel bolt or, Äąb Ab  ÄąS As

or , Eb.

Â ÂŻ ÂĄ Â° ÂĄ Äą Äą Â° ÂĄ' E=  Â° ÂĄ Â&#x2030; Â?Â&#x17E; +L ÂŹÂ­ Â° ÂĄ Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; Â­Â­ Â°Â° ÂĄÂ˘ Â&#x; L ÂŽÂą

(%l )b .Ab  Äąs As A

Let assume total length (A )=1m

(1.5 q103 ) q 3.1416 q104  Ts q 7.854Ă&#x2014;10-5 1 Ts  600 MPa (tensile )

Therefore (1Ă&#x2014;105 q106 ) q or

and Tb =Eb.

(%l )b (1.5 q103 ) MPa  150MPa (Compressive )  (1Ă&#x2014;105 ) q 1 A Page 48 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

So before heating Stress in brass tube (Äąb )  150MPa (compressive ) Stress in steel bolt(Äą s )  600MPa (tensile) Stress due to rise of temperature Let stress

Äą 'b & Äą 's

are due to brass tube and steel bolt.

If the two members had been free to expand, Free expansion of steel = Bs q+t q1 Free expansion of brass tube = Since

Bb q+t q1

Bb  Äąs free expansion of copper is greater than the free expansion of steel. But

they are rigidly fixed so final expansion of each members will be same. Let us assume this final expansion is ' ÄŻ ', The free expansion of brass tube is grater than ÄŻ , while the free expansion of steel is less than E . Hence the steel rod will be subjected to a tensile stress while the brass tube will be subjected to a compressive stress. For the equilibrium of the whole system, Total tension (Pull) in steel =Total compression (Push) in brass tube.

As 7.854 q105 ' ÄąS  0.25ÄąS'  Ab 3.14 q104 Final expansion of steel =final expansion of brass tube Äą 'b Ab  Äąs' As or , Äąb'  Äą's q

Bs (+t ).1

T' Äą s' q1  Bb (+t ) q1 b q1 Es Eb

or , 1.2 q105 q 40 q1

Äąs' Äą 'b 5  q q q   (ii ) (1.9 10 ) 40 1 2 q105 q106 1q105 q106

From(i) & (ii) we get Â 1 0.25 ÂŻ

11 Â°  2.8 q104 Äąs' ÂĄ 11 ÂĄ 2 q10 10 Â°Âą Â˘ or , Äą s'  37.33 MPa (Tensile stress) or, Äą b' = 9.33MPa (compressive) Therefore, the final stresses due to tightening and temperature rise

Stress in brass tube =Äą b +Äąb' =150+9.33MPa=159.33MPa Stress in steel bolt =Äą s +Äą 's = 600 + 37.33 = 637.33MPa. Conventional Question IES-1997 Question:

A Solid right cone of axial length h is made of a material having density S and elasticity modulus E. It is suspended from its circular base. Determine its elongation due to its self weight. See in the figure MNH is a solid right cone of length 'h' . Let us assume its wider end of diameterâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; fixed rigidly at MN. Now consider a small strip of thickness dy at a distance y from the lower end. Let 'ds' is the diameter of the strip.

1 Â? Ę&#x152;d 2 ÂŹ = Weight of portion UVH= Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; s Â­Â­Â­ y q Sg  (i ) 3 Â&#x17E;Â&#x; 4 ÂŽÂ­ Page 49 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

From the similar triangles MNH and UVH, A MN d   y UV ds or , ds

d .y   ( ii ) A

= Stress at section UV =

force at UV Weight of UVH  Â? Ę&#x152;d s2 ÂŹÂ­ cross  sec tion area at UV Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; Â­ Â&#x17E;Â&#x; 4 ÂŽÂ­Â­

1 Ę&#x152;d s2 . .y .Sg 1 3 4  y Sg = Â? Ę&#x152;d 2 ÂŹÂ­ 3 Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; s Â­ Â&#x17E;Â&#x; 4 ÂŽÂ­Â­ Â?1 ÂŹ Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; y Sg Â­Â­.dy Â&#x17E;Â&#x; 3 ÂŽÂ­ So, extension in dy= E h

= Total extension of the bar =Â¨ 0

1 y Sgdy Sgh 2 3  E 6E

From stress-strain relation ship E=

ÄŻ ÄŻ E.A or , d A   d A E Â&#x2030; A

Conventional Question IES-2004 Question:

Which one of the three shafts listed hare has the highest ultimate tensile strength? Which is the approximate carbon content in each steel? (i) Mild Steel (ii) cast iron (iii) spring steel Among three steel given, spring steel has the highest ultimate tensile strength. Approximate carbon content in (i) Mild steel is (0.3% to 0.8%) (ii) Cost iron (2% to 4%) (iii) Spring steel (0.4% to 1.1%)

If a rod of brittle material is subjected to pure torsion, show with help of a sketch, the plane along which it will fail and state the reason for its failure. Brittle materials fail in tension. In a torsion test the maximum tensile test Occurs at 45Â° to the axis of the shaft. So failure will occurs along a 45o to the axis of the shaft. So failure will occurs along a 45Â° helix

X

X 50 of 429 So failures will occurs according toPage 45Â° plane.

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Conventional Question IAS-1995 Question:

The steel bolt shown in Figure has a thread pitch of 1.6 mm. If the nut is initially tightened up by hand so as to cause no stress in the copper spacing tube, calculate the stresses induced in the tube and in the bolt if a spanner is then used to turn the nut through 90Â°.Take Ec and Es as 100 GPa and 209 GPa respectively. Given: p = 1.6 mm, Ec= 100 GPa ; Es = 209 CPa.

Stresses induced in the tube and the bolt, V c ,V s :

As As

2

S

Â§ 10 Âˇ uÂ¨ 7.584 u 10 5 m2 Â¸ 4 ÂŠ 1000 Âš 2 2 S ÂŞÂ§ 18 Âˇ Â§ 12 Âˇ Âş 5 2 u ÂŤÂ¨  Âť 14.14 u 10 m Â¸ Â¨ Â¸ 4 ÂŤÂŹÂŠ 1000 Âš ÂŠ 1000 Âš ÂťÂź

Tensile force on steel bolt, Ps = compressive force in copper tube, Pc = P Also, Increase in length of bolt + decrease in length of tube = axial displacement of nut

i,e or or or

G l s  G l c

1.6 u

Pl Pl  A sEs A cEc

90 360

0.4mm

0.4 u 103

0.4 u 10 3 m

 ls

lc

l

1 1 Â§ 100 Âˇ ÂŞ Âş PuÂ¨  Â¸ 5 5 9 9 Âť ÂŤ 14.14 u 10 u 100 u 10 Âź ÂŠ 1000 Âš ÂŹ 7.854 u 10 u 209 u 10 P 30386N P P 386.88MPa and 214.89MPa ? As Ac

0.4 u 103

Conventional Question AMIE-1997 Question:

A steel wire 2 m long and 3 mm in diameter is extended by 0Âˇ75 mm when a weight W is suspended from the wire. If the same weight is suspended from a brass wire, 2Âˇ5 m long and 2 mm in diameter, it is elongated by 4 -64 mm. Determine the modulus of elasticity of brass if that of steel be 2.0 Ă&#x2014; 105 N / mm2 Given, ls 2 m, ds = 3 mm, G ls 0Âˇ75 mm; Es = 2Âˇ0 Ă&#x2014; 105 N / mm2; lb 2.5 m, db =2 mm G lb

4.64m m and let modulus of elasticity of brass = Eb

Hooke's law gives, G l

Pl AE

[Symbol has usual meaning]

Case I: For steel wire:

Page 51 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

G ls

S K Mondal’s

Pls A sEs P u 2 u 1000

or 0.75

---- (i)

1 §S 2· 5 ¨ 4 u 3 ¸ u 2.0 u 10 u 2000 © ¹

Case II: For bass wire:

G lb 4.64

or

Plb A bEb P u 2.5 u 1000

---- (ii)

§S 2· ¨ 4 u 2 ¸ u Eb © ¹ P

1 §S · 4.64 u ¨ u 22 ¸ u Eb u 2500 ©4 ¹

From (i) and (ii), we get

1 §S · 0.75 u ¨ u 32 ¸ u 2.0 u 105 u 2000 ©4 ¹ 5 or Eb 0.909 u 10 N / mm2

1 §S · 4.64 u ¨ u 22 ¸ u Eb u 2500 ©4 ¹

Conventional Question AMIE-1997 Question:

A steel bolt and sleeve assembly is shown in figure below. The nut is tightened up on the tube through the rigid end blocks until the tensile force in the bolt is 40 kN. If an external load 30 kN is then applied to the end blocks, tending to pull them apart, estimate the resulting force in the bolt and sleeve.

2

§ 25 · 4.908 u 104 m2 ¨ 1000 ¸ © ¹ 2 2 S ª§ 62.5 · § 50 · º Area of steel sleeve, A s  «¨ » 4 ¬«© 1000 ¸¹ ¨© 1000 ¸¹ ¼» Area of steel bolt, A b

1.104 u 10 3 m2

Forces in the bolt and sleeve: (i) Stresses due to tightening the nut: Let V b = stress developed in steel bolt due to tightening the nut; and

V s = stress developed in steel sleeve due to tightening the nut. Tensile force in the steel bolt = 40 kN = 0·04 MN

Page 52 of 429

Chapter-1

Stress and Strain

V b u Ab

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

0.04

or

V b u 4.908 u 104

?

Vb

0.04

0.04 4.908 u 104

81.5MN / m2 tensile

Compressive force in steel sleeve = 0Âˇ04 MN

V s u As

0.04

or

V s u 1.104 u 103

?

Vs

0.04

0.04 1.104 u 10 3

36.23MN / m2 compressive

(ii) Stresses due to tensile force: Let the stresses developed due to tensile force of 30 kN = 0Âˇ03 MN in steel bolt and sleeve be V 'b and V 's respectively. Then, V 'b u A b  V 's u A s

0.03

4

V 'b u 4.908 u 10  V 's u 1.104 u 103

   (i)

0.03

In a compound system with an external tensile load, elongation caused in each will be the same.

V 'b

G lb

Eb

V 'b

or G lb

Eb

V 's

and G ls

Es

But G lb ?

V 'b Eb

or

u lb u 0.5

Given,lb

500mm

0.5

u 0.4

Given,ls

400mm

0.4

Gs V 's

u 0.5

V 'b

Es

u 0.4

0.8V 's

Given,Eb

Es

   (2)

Substituting this value in (1), we get

0.8V 's u 4.908 u 10 4  V 's u 1.104 u 10 3

V 's

gives and

V 'b

0.03

20MN / m tensile

2

0.8 u 20 16MN / m2 tensile

Re sulting stress in steel bolt,

V b r

V b  V 'b

81.5  16

97.5MN / m2

Re sulting stress in steel sleeve,

V s r

V s  V 's

36.23  20 16.23MN / m2 compressive

V b r u A b

Re sulting force in steel bolt,

97.5 u 4.908 u 104 Re sulting force in steel sleeve

0.0478MN tensile

V b r u A s 16.23 u 1.104 u 10 3

Page 53 of 429

0.0179MN compressive

2.

Principal Stress and Strain

Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) 2.1 States of stress

x

Uni-axial stress: only one non-zero principal stress, i.e. ǔ1

Right side figure represents Uni-axial state of stress.

x

Bi-axial stress: one principal stress equals zero, two do not, i.e. ǔ1 > ǔ3 ; ǔ2 = 0

Right side figure represents Bi-axial state of stress.

x

Tri-axial

stress:

three

non-zero

principal stresses, i.e. ǔ1 > ǔ2 > ǔ3 Right side figure represents Tri-axial state of stress.

x

Isotropic

stress:

three

principal

stresses are equal, i.e. ǔ1 = ǔ2 = ǔ3 Right side figure represents isotropic state of stress.

x

Axial stress: two of three principal stresses are equal, i.e. ǔ1 = ǔ2 or ǔ2 = ǔ3 Right side figure represents axial state of stress.

Page 54 of 429

Chapter-2

x

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondal’s

Hydrostatic pressure: weight of column of fluid in interconnected pore spaces. Phydrostatic = ǒfluid gh (density, gravity, depth)

x

Hydrostatic stress: Hydrostatic stress is used to describe a state of tensile or compressive stress equal in all directions within or external to a body. Hydrostatic

Or

stress causes a change in volume of a material.

Shape

of

the

body

remains

unchanged i.e. no distortion occurs in the body. Right side figure represents Hydrostatic state of stress.

2.2 Uni-axial stress on oblique plane Let us consider a bar of uniform cross sectional area A under direct tensile load P giving rise to axial normal stress P/A acting on a cross section XX. Now consider another section given by the plane YY inclined at T with the XX. This is depicted in following three ways.

Fig. (a)

Fig. (b)

Fig. (c) Area of the YY Plane = a shear stress

A ; Let us assume the normal stress in the YY plane is cos T

Vn

and there is

W acting parallel to the YY plane.

Now resolve the force P in two perpendicular direction one normal to the plane YY = P cos T and another parallel to the plane YY = Pcosș Page 55 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

Therefore equilibrium gives,

Vn

and

x

Wu

A cos T

P sin T

or

W

A cos T

P cos T

Note the variation of normal stress When T

Vn

P cos 2 T A

Vn

or

P sin T cos T A

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

W

or

P sin 2T 2A

and shear stress

0 , normal stress V n is maximum i.e. V n max

W with

P and shear stress W A

increased, the normal stress V n diminishes, until when T

T increased shear stress W increases to a maximum value W max diminishes to W

0 at T

the variation of T .

0, V n

0.

P at T 2A

S 4

0 . As T is But if angle

45o and then

90o

x

The shear stress will be maximum when sin 2T

x

And the maximum shear stress, W max

x

In ductile material failure in tension is initiated by shear stress i.e. the failure occurs across

1 or T

45o

P 2A

the shear planes at 45o (where it is maximum) to the applied load. Let us clear a concept about a common mistake: The angle T is not between the applied load and the plane. It is between the planes XX and YY. But if in any question the angle between the applied load and the plane is given donâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t take it as T . The angle between the applied load and the plane

Vn

is

90

-

T.

P cos2 (90  T ) and W A

In

this

case

you

have

to

use

the

above

formula

as

P sin(180  2T ) where T is the angle between the applied load and the 2A

plane. Carefully observe the following two figures it will be clear.

Let us take an example: A metal block of 100 mm2 cross sectional area carries an axial tensile load of 10 kN. For a plane inclined at 300 with the direction of applied load, calculate: (a) Normal stress (b) Shear stress (c) Maximum shear stress. Answer: Here T

90o  30o

60o Page 56 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain P 10 u 103 N cos2 T u cos2 60o 25MPa 2 100 mm A

(a) Normal stress V n

10 u 103 N u sin120o 2 2 u 100 mm

P sin2T 2A

(b) Shear stress W

x

10 u 103 N 2 u 100 mm 2

P 2A

(c) Maximum shear stress W max

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

43.3MPa

50MPa

Complementary stresses

Now if we consider the stresses on an oblique plane Yâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;Yâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; which is perpendicular to the previous plane YY. The stresses on this plane are known as complementary stresses. Complementary normal stress is

V nc

and complementary shear stress is

the four stresses. To obtain the stresses previous equation. The angle

T  900

V nc

and

W c . The following figure shows all

W c we need only to replace T

by

T  900 in the

is known as aspect angle.

Therefore

P cos 2 90o  T

A

V nc Wc

It is clear

P sin 2 90o  T

2A

V nc  V n

P A

and

P 2 sin T A 

P sin 2T 2A

W c W

i.e. Complementary shear stresses are always equal in magnitude but opposite in sign.

x

Sign of Shear stress

For sign of shear stress following rule have to be followed: Page 57 of 429

Chapter-2 The shear stress

W on

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

any face of the element will be considered positive when it has a

clockwise moment with respect to a centre inside the element. If the moment is counterclockwise with respect to a centre inside the element, the shear stress in negative. Note: The convention is opposite to that of moment of force. Shear stress tending to turn clockwise is positive and tending to turn counter clockwise is negative.

Let us take an example: A prismatic bar of 500 mm2 cross sectional area is axially loaded with a tensile force of 50 kN. Determine all the stresses acting on an element which makes 300 inclination with the vertical plane. Answer: Take an small element ABCD in 300 plane as shown in figure below, Given, Area of cross-section, A = 500 mm2, Tensile force (P) = 50 kN

Normal stress on 30Â° inclined plane,

Shear stress on 30Â° planes, W

P 50Ă&#x2014;103 N 2 Äą = cos Č&#x2122; = Ă&#x2014;cos2 30o =75MPa (+ive means tensile). n

2 A 500 mm 50 u 103 N u sin 2 u 30o 43.3MPa 2 u 500 mm 2

P sin2T 2A

(+ive means clockwise) Complementary stress on T

90  30 120o

Normal stress on 1200 inclined plane, V nc

P cos2 T A

50 u 103 N u cos2 120o 25MPa 500 mm 2 (+ ive means tensile)

Shear stress on 1200 nclined plane, W c

P sin2T 2A

50 u 103 N u sin 2 u 120o

2 2 u 500 mm

 43.3MPa

(- ive means counter clockwise) State of stress on the element ABCD is given below (magnifying)

Page 58 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

2.3 Complex Stresses (2-D Stress system) i.e. Material subjected to combined direct and shear stress We now consider a complex stress system below. The given figure ABCD shows on small element of material

Stresses in three dimensional element

Vx

and

Vy

Stresses in cross-section of the element

are normal stresses and may be tensile or compressive. We know that normal stress

may come from direct force or bending moment. comes from direct shear force or torsion and

W xy

W xy

is shear stress. We know that shear stress may

and

W yx

are complementary and

W xy = W yx Let

Vn

is the normal stress and

W

is the shear stress on a plane at angle T .

Considering the equilibrium of the element we can easily get

Normal stress V n

V x V y 2



V x V y 2

cos 2T  W xy sin 2T

and

Shear stress W

Äąx  Äąy 2

sin 2Č&#x2122; - W xy cos 2Č&#x2122;

Above two equations are coming from considering equilibrium. They do not depend on material Page 59 of 429

properties and are valid for elastic and in elastic behavior.

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

x Location of planes of maximum stress

V n max

(a) Normal stress,

Vn

For

wV n wT

maximum or minimum

or 

V

x

Vy

2

(b) Shear stress, For

wW wT or

V

0, where V n

W

x

 Vy

2



V

x

Vy

2

cos 2T  W xy sin 2T

u sin 2T u 2  W xy cos 2T u 2

0

or tan2T p =

2W xy (V x  V y )

W max

maximum or minimum

0, where W

Vx Vy 2

Vx Vy 2

sin 2T  W xy cos 2T

cos 2T u 2  W xy  sin 2T u 2

0

W xy

or cot 2T

Vx Vy

Let us take an example: At a point in a crank shaft the stresses on two mutually perpendicular planes are 30 MPa (tensile) and 15 MPa (tensile). The shear stress across these planes is 10 MPa. Find the normal and shear stress on a plane making an angle 300 with the plane of first stress. Find also magnitude and direction of resultant stress on the plane.

25MPa tensile , V y

Therefore, Normal stress V n

Shear stress W

V x V y

15MPa tensile , W xy

V x V y

10MPa and 400

cos 2T  W xy sin2T 2 2 30  15 30  15  cos 2 u 30o  10 sin 2 u 30o 34.91 MPa 2 2



V x V y

sin2T  W xy cos 2T 2 30  15 sin 2 u 30o  10cos 2 u 30o 1.5MPa 2

Resultant stress V r

34.91

and Obliquity I , tanI

W Vn

2

 1.52

1.5 Â&#x;I 34.91

34.94MPa 2.460

Page 60 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

2.4 Bi-axial stress Let us now consider a stressed element ABCD where W xy =0, i.e. only V x and V y is there. This type of stress is known as bi-axial stress. In the previous equation if you put W xy =0 we get Normal stress,

V n and shear stress, W

on a plane at angle T .

Vx V y

Vn



V x V y

cos 2T

x

Normal stress ,

x

Shear/Tangential stress,

x

For complementary stress, aspect angle =

x

Aspect angle â&#x20AC;&#x2DC; Č&#x2122; â&#x20AC;&#x2122; varies from 0 to

x

Normal stress

V x (T

2

W

2

V x V y 2

sin 2T

T  900

S /2

V n varies between the values

0) & V y (T

S / 2)

Let us take an example: The principal tensile stresses at a point across two perpendicular planes are 100 MPa and 50 MPa. Find the normal and tangential stresses and the resultant stress and its obliquity on a plane at 200 with the major principal plane Answer: Given V x

Normal stress, V n

Shear stress, W

100MPa tensile , V y

Vx Vy 2

V x V y

Resultant stress V r

2



V x V y

sin2T

942  162

50MPa tensile and T

200

100  50 100  50  cos 2 u 20o

2 2

cos 2T

2 100  50 sin 2 u 200 2

16MPa

95.4MPa

Â§W Âˇ Â§ 16 Âˇ Therefore angle of obliquity, I tan1 Â¨ Â¸ tan1 Â¨ Â¸ 9.70 ÂŠ 94 Âš ÂŠ Vn Âš

Page 61 of 429

94MPa

Chapter-2

x

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

We may derive uni-axial stress on oblique plane from

Vx V y

Vn and

2 Äąx  Äą y

W

2

Just put V y



V x V y 2

cos 2T  W xy sin 2T

sin 2Č&#x2122; - W xy cos 2Č&#x2122;

0 and W xy =0

Therefore,

Vn

Vx  0 2

and W



Vx  0

Vx  0 2

2

cos 2T

sin 2T

Vx 2

1 V x 1  cos 2T V x cos2 T 2

sin 2T

2.5 Pure Shear

x

Pure shear is a particular case of bi-axial stress where

Vx

V y

Note: V x or V y which one is compressive that is immaterial but one should be tensile and other

should

be

compressive

and

equal

magnitude.

V x 100MPa then

If

V y must be  100MPa otherwise if V y 100MPa then V x must be  100MPa .

x

In case of pure shear on 45o planes

W max x

rV x

; Vn

0 and V nc

0

We may depict the pure shear in an element by following two ways Page 62 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondal’s

(a) In a torsion member, as shown below, an element ABCD is in pure shear (only shear stress is present in this element) in this member at 45o plane an element AcBcC cDc is also in pure shear where V x

V y but in this element no shear stress is there.

(b) In a bi-axial state of stress a member, as shown below, an element ABCD in pure shear where V x

V y but in this element no shear stress is there and an element AcBcC cDc at

45o plane is also in pure shear (only shear stress is present in this element).

Let us take an example: See the in the Conventional question answer section in this chapter and the question is “Conventional Question IES-2007”

2.6 Stress Tensor

x

State of stress at a point ( 3-D)

Stress acts on every surface that passes through the point. We can use three mutually perpendicular planes to describe the stress state at the point, which we approximate as a cube each of the three planes has one normal component & two shear components therefore, 9 components necessary to define stress at a point 3 normal and 6 shear stress. Therefore, we need nine components, to define the state of stress at a point

V x W xy W xz V y W yx W yz V z W zx W zy For cube to be in equilibrium (at rest: not moving, not spinning) Page 63 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondal’s

W xy

W yx

If they don’t offset, block spins therefore,

W xz W yz

W zx W zy

only six are independent.

The nine components (six of which are independent) can be written in matrix form

V ij

§ V xx ¨ ¨ V yx ¨V © zx

V xy V xz · ¸ V yy V yz ¸ or W ij V zy V zz ¸¹

§W xx W xy ¨ ¨W yx W yy ¨W © zx W zy

W xz · ¸ W yz ¸ W zz ¸¹

§ V x W xy ¨ ¨W yx V y ¨W © zx W zy

W xz · ¸ W yz ¸ V z ¸¹

§ V 11 V 12 V 13 · ¨ ¸ ¨ V 21 V 22 V 23 ¸ ¨V ¸ © 31 V 32 V 33 ¹

This is the stress tensor Components on diagonal are normal stresses; off are shear stresses

x

State of stress at an element (2-D)

2.7 Principal stress and Principal plane x

When examining stress at a point, it is possible to choose three mutually perpendicular planes on which no shear stresses exist in three dimensions, one combination of orientations for the three mutually perpendicular planes will cause the shear stresses on all three planes to go to zero this is the state defined by the principal stresses. Page 64 of 429

Chapter-2 x

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Principal stresses are normal stresses that are orthogonal to each other

x

Principal planes are the planes across which principal stresses act (faces of the cube) for principal stresses (shear stresses are zero)

x

Major Principal Stress

V1 x

2

Vx V y 2

Âˇ 2 W  Â¸Â¸ xy Âš

Â§ V x V y  Â¨ Â¨ 2 ÂŠ

2

Âˇ 2 W  Â¸Â¸ xy Âš

Position of principal planes

tan2T p = x

Â§ V x V y  Â¨ Â¨ 2 ÂŠ

Minor principal stress

V2 x

Vx V y

2

2W xy (V x  V y )

Maximum shear stress

W max

V1  V 2 2

Â§ V x V y Â¨Â¨ ÂŠ 2

2

Âˇ 2 W  Â¸Â¸ xy Âš

Let us take an example: In the wall of a cylinder the state of stress is given by,

Vx

85MPa compressive , V y

25MPa tensile and shear stress W xy 60MPa

Calculate the principal planes on which they act. Show it in a figure. Answer: Given V x

85MPa,V y

25MPa,W xy

60MPa

Page 65 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

Major principal stress V 1

Vx Vy 2

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

2

Â§ V x V y Âˇ 2  Â¨ Â¸  W xy 2 ÂŠ Âš 2

85  25 Â§ 85  25 Âˇ 2  Â¨ Â¸  60 2 2 ÂŠ Âš

Minor principal stress V 2

Vx Vy 2

51.4MPa

2

Â§ V x V y Âˇ 2  Â¨ Â¸  W xy 2 ÂŠ Âš 2

85  25 Â§ 85  25 Âˇ 2  Â¨ Â¸  60 2 2 ÂŠ Âš 111.4 MPa i.e. 111.4 MPa Compressive

For principalplanes tan2TP or TP

2W xy

V x V y

2 u 60 85  25

240 it is for V 1

Complementary plane TP c T P  90 660 it is for V 2 The Figure showing state of stress and principal stresses is given below

The direction of one principle plane and the principle stresses acting on this would be V

1

when is

acting normal to this plane, now the direction of other principal plane would be 900 + T p because the principal planes are the two mutually perpendicular plane, hence rotate the another plane 900 + T p in the same direction to get the another plane, now complete the material element as T p is negative that means we are measuring the angles in the opposite direction to the reference plane BC. The following figure gives clear idea about negative and positive T p .

Page 66 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

2.8 Mohr's circle for plane stress x

The transformation equations of plane stress can be represented in a graphical form which is popularly known as Mohr's circle.

x

Though the transformation equations are sufficient to get the normal and shear stresses on any plane at a point, with Mohr's circle one can easily visualize their variation with respect to plane orientation Ç&#x2030;.

x

Equation of Mohr's circle

We know that normal stress,

And Tangential stress,

Ä˛

Â§

Rearranging we get, Â¨ V n  Â¨

Vn

Äąx  Äą y 2

2



V x V y 2

2

Äąx  Äą y

Ä˛

2

cos 2T  W xy sin 2T

sin2Č&#x2122; - Ä˛ xy cos 2Č&#x2122;

V x V y Âˇ V x V y

ÂŠ

and

Vx V y

Â¸Â¸ Âš

2

cos 2T  W xy sin 2T â&#x20AC;Śâ&#x20AC;Śâ&#x20AC;Śâ&#x20AC;Śâ&#x20AC;Ś(i)

sin2Č&#x2122; - Ä˛ xy cos 2Č&#x2122; â&#x20AC;Śâ&#x20AC;Śâ&#x20AC;Śâ&#x20AC;Śâ&#x20AC;Ś(ii)

A little consideration will show that the above two equations are the equations of a circle with

Vn

and U as its coordinates and 2Ç&#x2030; as its parameter. If the parameter 2Ç&#x2030; is eliminated from the equations, (i) & (ii) then the significance of them will become clear.

Vx V y

V avg Or

V

2 2

n

and R =

 V avg  W xy2

Â§ V x V y Â¨Â¨ ÂŠ 2

2

Âˇ 2 Â¸Â¸  W xy Âš

R2

It is the equation of a circle with centre,

Â§Vx V y

V avg ,0 i.e. Â¨Â¨ ÂŠ

Page 67 of 429

2

Âˇ ,0 Â¸ Â¸ Âš

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

R

Â§ V x V y Â¨Â¨ 2 ÂŠ

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

2

Âˇ 2 Â¸Â¸  W xy Âš

x Construction of Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circle Convention for drawing

x

A W xy that is clockwise (positive) on a face resides above the anticlockwise (negative) on a face resides below

x

V axis; a W xy

V axis.

Tensile stress will be positive and plotted right of the origin O. Compressive stress will be negative and will be plotted left to the origin O.

x

An angle

T on real plane transfers as an angle 2T

on Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circle plane.

We now construct Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circle in the following stress conditions

I. II.

Bi-axial stress when

V x and V y known and W xy = 0

Complex state of stress ( V x ,V y and W xy known)

I. Constant of Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circle for Bi-axial stress (when only V x and If

Vy

known)

V x and V y both are tensile or both compressive sign of V x and V y will be same and this state of

stress is known as â&#x20AC;&#x153; like stressesâ&#x20AC;? if one is tensile and other is compressive sign of

V x and V y will

be opposite and this state of stress is known as â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;unlike stressâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;.

x Construction of Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circle for like stresses (when V x and V y are same type of stress) Step-I:

Label the element ABCD and draw all stresses.

Step-II: Set up axes for the direct stress (as abscissa) i.e., in x-axis and shear stress (as ordinate) i.e. in Y-axis

Page 68 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Step-III: Using sign convention and some suitable scale, plot the stresses on two adjacent faces e.g. AB and BC on the graph. Let OL and OM equal to axis O

V.

V x and V y respectively on the

Step-IV: Bisect ML at C. With C as centre and CL or CM as radius, draw a circle. It is the Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circle.

T

Step-V: At the centre C draw a line CP at an angle 2 , in the same direction as the normal to the plane makes with the direction of

V x . The point P represents the state of

stress at plane ZB.

Page 69 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Step-VI: Calculation, Draw a perpendicular PQ and PR where PQ = W and PR = V n

OC

Vx  Vy

and MC = CL = CP =

Vx  Vy

2 PR = V

2

Vx  Vy n



Vx  Vy

2

PQ = W = CPsin 2T =

cos 2T

2

Vx  Vy

sin 2T

2 [Note: In the examination you only draw final figure (which is in Step-V) and follow the procedure step by step so that no mistakes occur.]

x Construction of Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circle for unlike stresses (when V x and V y are opposite in sign) Follow the same steps which we followed for construction for â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;like stressesâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; and finally will get the figure shown below.

Note: For construction of Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circle for principal stresses when ( V 1 and

V 2 is known) then follow the same steps of Constant of Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circle for Bi-axial stress (when only V x and V y known) just V 1 and V y V 2 change the V x

Page 70 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondal’s

II. Construction of Mohr’s circle for complex state of stress ( V x , V y and W xy known) Step-I:

Label the element ABCD and draw all stresses.

Step-II: Set up axes for the direct stress (as abscissa) i.e., in x-axis and shear stress (as ordinate) i.e. in Y-axis

Step-III: Using sign convention and some suitable scale, plot the stresses on two adjacent faces

V x and V y respectively on the axis O V . Draw LS perpendicular to oV axis and equal to W xy .i.e. LS=W xy . Here LS is downward as W xy on AB face is (– ive) and draw MT perpendicular to oV axis and equal to W xy i.e. MT=W xy . Here MT is upward as W xy BC face is (+ ive). e.g. AB and BC on the graph. Let OL and OM equal to

Page 71 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondal’s

Step-IV: Join ST and it will cut oσ axis at C. With C as centre and CS or CT as radius, draw circle. It is the Mohr’s circle.

Step-V: At the centre draw a line CP at an angle 2θ in the same direction as the normal to the plane makes with the direction of σ x .

Step-VI: Calculation, Draw a perpendicular PQ and PR where PQ = τ and PR = σ n Centre, OC =

σx +σy 2

2 ⎛ σ x −σ y ⎞ = ⎜ Radius CS = ( CL ) + (LS ) ⎟⎟ +τ xy 2 = CT = CP ⎜ 2 ⎝ ⎠ σ x +σ y σ x −σ y + PR = σ = cos 2θ + τ sin 2θ n xy 2 2 σ x −σ y PQ = τ = sin 2θ −τ xy cos 2θ . 2 2

2

[Note: In the examination you only draw final figure (which is in Step-V) and follow the Page 72 of 429

procedure step by step so that no mistakes occur.]

PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

Note: The intersections of

oV

S K Mondal’s

axis are two principal stresses, as shown below.

Let us take an example: See the in the Conventional question answer section in this chapter and the question is “Conventional Question IES-2000”

2.9 Mohr's circle for some special cases: i) Mohr’s circle for axial loading:

Vx

P ; Vy A

W xy

0

W xy

Tr ; Vx J

Vy

0

It is a case of pure shear iii) In the case of pure shear

(ǔ1 = - ǔ2 and ǔ3 =Page 0) 73 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

Vx

V y

W max

rV x

iv) A shaft compressed all round by a hub

ǔ1 = ǔ2 = ǔ3 = Compressive (Pressure) v) Thin spherical shell under internal pressure

V1

V2

pr 2t

pD (tensile) 4t

vi) Thin cylinder under pressure

V1

pD 2t

pr (tensile) and V 2 t

pd 4t

pr (tensile) 2t

vii) Bending moment applied at the free end of a cantilever

Only bending stress, V 1

My and V 2 I

W xy

0 Page 74 of 429

S K Mondal’s

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

2.10 Strain Normal strain Let us consider an element AB of infinitesimal length Ç&#x2026;x. After deformation of the actual body if displacement of end A is u, that of end B is u+

Â§ ÂŠ

is Â¨ u+

wu Âˇ .G x - u Â¸ wx Âš

wu .G x. This gives an increase in length of element AB wx

wu G x and therefore the strain in x-direction is H x wx

wQ and H z wx

Similarly, strains in y and z directions are H y

wu wx

ww . wz

Therefore, we may write the three normal strain components

Hx

wu ; wx

wQ ; wy

Hy

and

Hz

ww . wz

Change in length of an infinitesimal element.

Shear strain Let us consider an element ABCD in x-y plane and let the displaced position of the element be

AcBcCcDc .This gives shear strain in x-y plane as J xy v  E where v is the angle made by the displaced live BcCc with the vertical and E is the angle made by the displaced line A cDc with the

wu .G y wx Gy

horizontal. This gives v

wQ .G x wu and E = wx Gx wy

wQ wx

We may therefore write the three shear strain components as

J xy

wu wQ  ; wy wx

J yz

wQ ww and J zx  wz wy

ww wu  wx wz

Therefore the state of strain at a point can be completely described by the six strain components and the strain components in their turns can be completely defined by the displacement components u,Q , and w. Therefore, the complete strain matrix can be written as

Page 75 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain ÂŞw Âş 0 0Âť ÂŤ wx ÂŤ Âť w ÂŤ0 0Âť Â­H x Â˝ ÂŤ Âť y w Â° Â° ÂŤ Âť H Â° y Â° ÂŤ w Âť Â­u Â˝ 0 Â°H Â° ÂŤ0 wz Âť Â° Â° Â° z Â° Âť ÂŽX Âž ÂŽ Âž ÂŤ w Â°J xy Â° ÂŤ w 0 Âť Â°ÂŻ w Â°Âż Âť Â°J Â° ÂŤ wx wy Âť Â° yz Â° ÂŤ w wÂť Â°ÂŻJ zx Â°Âż ÂŤ0 ÂŤ wy wz Âť ÂŤ Âť w Âť ÂŤw 0 ÂŤÂŹ wz wx ÂťÂź

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Shear strain associated with the distortion of an infinitesimal element.

Strain Tensor The three normal strain components are

H x H xx

wu ; wx

Hy

H yy

wQ wy

and

Hz

H zz

ww . wz

The three shear strain components are

Â?xy

J xy 2

1 Â§ wu wQ Âˇ  Â¨ Â¸; 2 ÂŠ wy wx Âš

Â?yz

J yz 2

1 Â§ wQ ww Âˇ  Â¨ Â¸ 2 ÂŠ wz wy Âš

and

Â?zx

J zx 2

1 Â§ wu ww Âˇ  2 Â¨ÂŠ wz wx Â¸Âš

Therefore the strain tensor is

Â?ij

ÂŞÂ?xx Â?xy ÂŤ ÂŤÂ?yx Â?yy ÂŤ ÂŹÂ?zx Â?zy

Â?xz Âş Âť Â?yz Âť Âť Â?zz Âź

ÂŞ ÂŤÂ?xx ÂŤ ÂŤ J yx ÂŤ ÂŤ 2 ÂŤ J zx ÂŤ ÂŹ 2

J xy 2 Â?yy

J zy 2

J xz Âş

Âť 2 Âť J yz Âť Âť 2 Âť Âť Â?zz Âť Âź

Constitutive Equation The constitutive equations relate stresses and strains and in linear elasticity. We know from the Hookâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s law V

E.H

Where E is modulus of elasticity

Page 76 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

It is known that V x produces a strain of and Poissonâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s effect gives  P

Vx E

Vx

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

in x-direction

E

in y-direction and

P

Vx E

in z-direction.

Therefore we my write the generalized Hookâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s law as

1 1 ÂŞV y  P V z  V x Âş and Â?z ÂŞV z  P V x  V y Âş ÂŹ Âź Âź E EÂŹ It is also known that the shear stress, W GJ , where G is the shear modulus and J is shear strain. Â?x

1 ÂŞV x  P V y  V z Âş , Âź EÂŹ

Â?y

We may thus write the three strain components as

W xy

J xy

G

J yz

,

W yz G

and J zx

W zx G

In general each strain is dependent on each stress and we may write

Â­H x Â˝ Â° Â° Â°H y Â° Â°H Â° Â° z Â° ÂŽ Âž Â°J xy Â° Â°J Â° Â° yz Â° Â°ÂŻJ zx Â°Âż

?

ÂŞK11 K12 K13 K14 K15 K16 Âş Â­V x Â˝ ÂŤ Âť Â°V Â° ÂŤK 21 K 22 K 23 K 24 K 25 K 26 Âť Â° y Â° ÂŤK 31 K 32 K 33 K 34 K 35 K 36 Âť Â°Â°V z Â°Â° ÂŤ ÂťÂŽ Âž ÂŤK 41 K 42 K 43 K 44 K 45 K 46 Âť Â°W xy Â° ÂŤK K K K K K Âť Â° Â° ÂŤ 51 52 53 54 55 56 Âť Â°W yz Â° ÂŤÂŹK 61 K 62 K 63 K 64 K 65 K 66 ÂťÂź Â°W Â° ÂŻ zx Âż

The number of elastic constant is 36 (For anisotropic materials) For isotropic material

K11 K 22

K 33

K 44

K 55

K 66

K12

K13

K 21

1 E 1 G K 23

K 31

K 32



P E

Rest of all elements in K matrix are zero. For isotropic material only two independent elastic constant is there say E and G.

x 1-D Strain Let us take an example: A rod of cross sectional area Ao is loaded by a tensile force P. Itâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s stresses

Vx

P , Ao

Vy

0,

and V z

0

1-D state of stress or Uni-axial state of stress

V ij

Â§ V xx Â¨ Â¨ 0 Â¨ 0 ÂŠ

0 0Âˇ Â¸ 0 0 Â¸ or W ij 0 0 Â¸Âš

Â§ W xx Â¨ Â¨ 0 Â¨ 0 ÂŠ

0 0Âˇ Â¸ 0 0Â¸ 0 0 Â¸Âš

Â§V x Â¨ Â¨0 Â¨0 ÂŠ

0 0Âˇ Â¸ 0 0Â¸ 0 0 Â¸Âš

Therefore strain components are Page 77 of 429

Chapter-2

Â?x

Principal Stress and Strain

Vx E

; Â?y  P

Vx E

 P Â?x ;

P and Â?z

Vx E

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

 P Â?x

1-D state of strain or Uni-axial state of strain

Â§Hx Â¨ Â¨0 Â¨ ÂŠ0

H ij

0  PH x 0

x 2-D Strain (V z (i)

Â?x Â?y Â?z 

0 Âˇ Â¸ 0 Â¸  PH x ÂšÂ¸

Â§Vx Â¨E Â¨ Â¨ Â¨ 0 Â¨ Â¨ 0 Â¨ ÂŠ

0 P

Vx

0

Âˇ Â¸ Â¸ Â¸ 0 Â¸ Â¸ V  P x Â¸Â¸ E Âš 0

E

Â§ py Â¨ Â¨0 Â¨ ÂŠ0

0 qy 0

0Âˇ Â¸ 0Â¸ qy ÂšÂ¸

0)

1 ÂŞÂŹV x  PV y ÂşÂź E 1 ÂŞÂŹV y  PV x ÂşÂź E P

ÂŞV x  V y ÂşÂź EÂŹ

[Where, Â?x ,Â?y ,Â?z are strain component in X, Y, and Z axis respectively]

(ii)

Vx

E ÂŞÂ?  P Â?y ÂşÂź 2 ÂŹ x 1 P

Vy

E ÂŞÂ?  P Â?x ÂşÂź 2 ÂŹ y 1 P

x 3-D Strain (i)

Â?x Â?y Â?z

(ii)

Vx

1ÂŞ V x  P V y  V z ÂşÂź EÂŹ 1ÂŞ V y  P V z  V x ÂşÂź ÂŹ E 1ÂŞ V z  P V x  V y ÂşÂź EÂŹ E ÂŞ 1  P Â?x  P Â?y  Â?z Âş Âź 1 P 1 2 P  

ÂŹ Page 78 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Vy

E ÂŞ 1  P Â?y  P Â?z  Â?x ÂşÂź 1  P 1  2P ÂŹ

Vz

E ÂŞ 1  P Â?z  P Â?x  Â?y Âş Âź 1  P 1  2P ÂŹ

Let us take an example: At a point in a loaded member, a state of plane stress exists and the

270 u 10 6 ;

strains are H x

Hy

90 u 106

and H xy

360 u 10 6 . If the elastic constants

E, P and G are 200 GPa, 0.25 and 80 GPa respectively. Determine the normal stress V x and V y and the shear stress W xy at the point. Answer: We know that

Hx . Hy

H xy This gives V x

and V y

and W xy

1 ^V x  PV y ` E 1 ^V y  PV x ` E

W xy G

E ^H x  PH y ` 1 P 2

200 u 109 ÂŞ 270 u 106  0.25 u 90 u 106 ÂşÂź Pa 1  0.252 ÂŹ 52.8 MPa (i.e. tensile)

E ÂŞH y  PH x ÂşÂź 1 P 2 ÂŹ 200 u 109 ÂŞ 90 u 106  0.25 u 270 u 106 ÂşÂź Pa  4.8 MPa (i.e.compressive) 1  0.252 ÂŹ H xy .G 360 u 106 u 80 u 109 Pa 28.8MPa

2.12 An element subjected to strain components Â?x ,Â?y &

J xy 2

Consider an element as shown in the figure given. The strain component In X-direction is Â?x , the strain component in Y-direction is Â?y and the shear strain component is J xy . Now consider a plane at an angle T with X- axis in this plane a normal strain Â?T and a shear strain J T . Then

x

x

Â?T

JT 2

Â?x  Â?y 2 



Â?x  Â?y 2

Â?x  Â?y 2 sin 2T 

cos 2T 

J xy 2

J xy 2

sin 2T

cos 2T Page 79 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

We may find principal strain and principal plane for strains in the same process which we followed for stress analysis. In the principal plane shear strain is zero. Therefore principal strains are

Â?x  Â?y

Â?1,2

2

2

Â§ Â?x  Â?y Âˇ Â§ J xy Âˇ r Â¨ Â¸ Â¨ Â¸ 2 2 Âš ÂŠ Âš ÂŠ

2

The angle of principal plane

tan 2T p x

J xy (Â?x  Â?y )

Maximum shearing strain is equal to the difference between the 2 principal strains i.e

(J xy ) max Â?1  Â?2 Mohr's Circle for circle for Plain Strain We may draw Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circle for strain following same procedure which we followed for drawing Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circle in stress. Everything will be same and in the place of

V y write Â?y

and in place of W xy

write

J xy 2

.

Page 80 of 429

V x write Â?x , the place of

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

2.15 Volumetric Strain (Dilation) x

Rectangular block,

'V V0

Â?x  Â?y  Â?z

Proof: Volumetric strain

V  Vo V0

'V V0

L 1  H x u L 1  H y u L 1  H z  L3 L3

Before deformation,

Â?x  Â?y  Â?z

Volume (V)

Volume (Vo) = L3

= L 1  H x u L 1  H y u L 1  H z

(neglecting second and third order term, as very small )

x

In case of prismatic bar,

Volumetric strain,

dv v

H 1  2P

Proof: Before deformation, the volume of the bar, V = A.L After deformation, the length Lc

L 1  H

and the new cross-sectional area A c

Therefore now volume V c

After deformation,

A 1  PH

2

A cLc=AL 1  H 1  PH

Page 81 of 429

2

Chapter-2

'V V c-V V V 'V H 1  2P

V

?

x

Principal Stress and Strain 2 AL 1  H 1  PH  AL H 1  2P

AL

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Thin Cylindrical vessel

Â? 1=Longitudinal strain =

V1 E

Â?2 =Circumferential strain =

P V2 E

V2 E

P

V1 E

pr >1  2P @ 2 Et pr >2  P @ 2Et

'V pr [5  4Č?] Â?1 2 Â?2 2 Et Vo

x

x

Thin Spherical vessels

Â? Â?1 Â?2

pr [1  P ] 2 Et

'V V0

3 pr [1  P ] 2 Et

3Â?

In case of pure shear

Vx

V y

W

Therefore

Hx

W E

Hy



Hz

0

Therefore H v

dv v

1  P

W E

1  P

Hx  Hy  Hz

0

2.16 Measurement of Strain Unlike stress, strain can be measured directly. The most common way of measuring strain is by use of the Strain Gauge.

Strain Gauge

Page 82 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondal’s

A strain gage is a simple device, comprising of a thin electric wire attached to an insulating thin backing material such as a bakelite foil. The foil is exposed to the surface of the specimen on which the strain is to be measured. The thin epoxy layer bonds the gauge to the surface and forces the gauge to shorten or elongate as if it were part of the specimen being strained. A change in length of the gauge due to longitudinal strain creates a proportional change in the electric resistance, and since a constant current is maintained in the gauge, a proportional change in voltage. (V = IR). The voltage can be easily measured, and through calibration, transformed into the change in length of the original gauge length, i.e. the longitudinal strain along the gauge length.

Strain Gauge factor (G.F)

The strain gauge factor relates a change in resistance with strain.

Strain Rosette The strain rosette is a device used to measure the state of strain at a point in a plane. It comprises three or more independent strain gauges, each of which is used to read normal strain at the same point but in a different direction. The relative orientation between the three gauges is known as D , E and G The three measurements of normal strain provide sufficient information for the determination of the complete state of strain at the measured point in 2-D. We have to find out x , y , and J xy form measured value a , b , and c

Page 83 of 429

Chapter-2 General arrangement:

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

The orientation of strain gauges is given in the figure. To relate strain we have to use the following formula.

Â?T

Â?x  Â?y 2



Â?x  Â?y 2

cos 2T 

J xy 2

sin 2T

We get

Â?a

Â?b Â?c

Â?x  Â?y 2 Â?x  Â?y 2 Â?x  Â?y 2



 

Â?x  Â?y 2 Â?x  Â?y 2 Â?x  Â?y 2

cos 2D 

J xy 2

sin 2D

cos 2 D  E 

J xy 2

cos 2 D  E  G 

sin 2 D  E

J xy 2

sin 2 D  E  G

From this three equations and three unknown we may solve Â?x , Â?y , and J xy

x Two standard arrangement of the of the strain rosette are as follows: (i)

45Â° strain rosette or Rectangular strain rosette. In the general arrangement above, put

D

0o ; E

45o and G

45o

Putting the value we get

x Â?a Â?x Â?x  Â?x J xy  2 2 Â?c Â?y

x Â?b x (ii)

45

o

60Â° strain rosette or Delta strain rosette In the general arrangement above, put

D

0o ; E

60o and G

60o

Putting the value we get x Â?a Â?y x

Â?b

x

Â?c

60o

Â?x 3 Â?y

3 J xy  4 4 Â?x 3 Â?y 3 J xy  4 4

or

Solving above three equation we get

Page 84 of 429

1200

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Stresses due to Pure Shear GATE-1.

A block of steel is loaded by a tangential force on its top surface while the bottom surface is held rigidly. The deformation of the block is due to [GATE-1992] (a) Shear only (b) Bending only (c) Shear and bending (d) Torsion GATE-1. Ans. (a) It is the definition of shear stress. The force is applied tangentially it is not a point load so you cannot compare it with a cantilever with a point load at its free end. A shaft subjected to torsion experiences a pure shear stress W on the surface. The maximum principal stress on the surface which is at 45Â° to the axis will have a value [GATE-2003] (b) 2 W cos 45Â° (c) W cos2 45Â° (d) 2 W sin 45Â° cos 45Â° (a) W cos 45Â° Vx Vy Vx Vy GATE-2. Ans. (d) V n  cos 2T  W xy sin 2T 2 2 Here V x V 2 0, W xy W , T 45o

GATE-2.

GATE-3.

The number of components in a stress tensor defining stress at a point in three dimensions is: [GATE-2002] (a) 3 (b) 4 (c) 6 (d) 9 GATE-3. Ans. (d) It is well known that,

W xy

W yx, W xz

W zx and W yz

W zy

so that the state of stress at a point is given by six components V x ,V y ,V z and W xy , W yz ,W zx

Principal Stress and Principal Plane GATE-4.

A body is subjected to a pure tensile stress of 100 units. What is the maximum shear produced in the body at some oblique plane due to the above? [IES-2006] (a) 100 units (b) 75 units (c) 50 units (d) 0 unit V 1  V 2 100  0 50 units. GATE-4. Ans. (c) W max 2 2 GATE-5.

In a strained material one of the principal stresses is twice the other. The maximum shear stress in the same case is W max .Then, what is the value of the maximum principle stress? (b) 2 W max (a) W max

GATE-5. Ans. (c) GATE-6.

W max

V1  V 2 2

,

V1

2V 2 or W max

(c) 4 W max

V2 2

or

V2

[IES 2007] (d) 8 W max

2W max or V 1 2V 2 = 4W max

A material element subjected to a plane state of stress such that the maximum shear stress is equal to the maximum tensile stress, would correspond to [IAS-1998]

Page 85 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

GATE-6. Ans. (d) W max GATE-7.

V 1  ( V 1 )

2

2

V1

A solid circular shaft is subjected to a maximum shearing stress of 140 MPs. The magnitude of the maximum normal stress developed in the shaft is: [IAS-1995] (a) 140 MPa (b) 80 MPa (c) 70 MPa (d) 60 MPa

GATE-7. Ans. (a) W max GATE-8.

V1  V 2

V1  V 2 2

Maximum normal stress will developed if V 1

V 2

V

The state of stress at a point in a loaded member is shown in the figure. The [IAS 1994] magnitude of maximum shear stress is [1MPa = 10 kg/cm2] (a) 10 MPa (b) 30 MPa (c) 50 MPa (d) 100MPa

2

GATE-8. Ans. (c)

GATE-9.

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

W max

2

Â§Vx V y Â· Â¨Â¨ Â¸Â¸  W xy 2 = Â© 2 Â¹

Â§  40  40 Â· 2 Â¨ Â¸  30 = 50 MPa 2 Â© Â¹

A solid circular shaft of diameter 100 mm is subjected to an axial stress of 50 MPa. It is further subjected to a torque of 10 kNm. The maximum principal stress experienced on the shaft is closest to [GATE-2008] (a) 41 MPa (b) 82 MPa (c) 164 MPa (d) 204 MPa

GATE-9. Ans. (b) Shear Stress ( W )=

16 u 10000 Pa S u (0.1)3

16T Sd 3

Maximum principal Stress =

50.93 MPa

2

Vb

Â§V Â·  Â¨ b Â¸  W 2 =82 MPa 2 Â© 2 Â¹

GATE-10. In a bi-axial stress problem, the stresses in x and y directions are (Ç&#x201D;x = 200 MPa [GATE-2000] and Ç&#x201D;y =100 MPa. The maximum principal stress in MPa, is: (a) 50 (b) 100 (c) 150 (d) 200 GATE-10. Ans. (d) V 1

Vx Vy 2

2

Â§Vx Vy Â· 2  Â¨ Â¸  W xy 2 Â© Â¹

if W xy

Page 86 of 429

0

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain Vx Vy 2

Â§Vx Vy Â·  Â¨ Â¸ 2 Â¹ Â©

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

2

Vx

GATE-11. The maximum principle stress for the stress state shown in the figure is (a) Ç&#x201D; (b) 2 Ç&#x201D; (c) 3 Ç&#x201D; (d) 1.5 Ç&#x201D;

[GATE-2001] GATE-11. Ans. (b) V x ? V 1 max

V, Vy

Vx  Vy 2

V , W xy

V 2

Â§Vx  Vy Â· 2  Â¨ Â¸  W xy 2 Â© Â¹

V V 2



0

2

V2

2V

GATE-12. The normal stresses at a point are Ç&#x201D;x = 10 MPa and, Ç&#x201D;y = 2 MPa; the shear stress at this point is 4MPa. The maximum principal stress at this point is: [GATE-1998] (a) 16 MPa (b) 14 MPa (c) 11 MPa (d) 10 MPa GATE-12. Ans. (c) V 1

Vx Vy 2

2

Â§Vx Vy Â· 2  Â¨ Â¸  W xy 2 Â© Â¹

2

10  2 Â§ 10  2 Â· 2  Â¨ Â¸ 4 2 2 Â© Â¹

GATE-13. In a Mohr's circle, the radius of the circle is taken as: 2

(a)

2 Â§ V x V y Â· Â¨ Â¸  W xy

(c)

2 Â§ V x V y Â· Â¨ Â¸  W xy

(b)

V

x

V y

11.66 MPa

[IES-2006; GATE-1993]

2

2

 W xy

2

2

(d)

V

2

x

 V y  W xy

2

Where, Ç&#x201D;x and Ç&#x201D;y are normal stresses along x and y directions respectively and Ç&#x2022;xy is the shear stress. GATE-13. Ans. (a)

GATE-14. A two dimensional fluid element rotates like a rigid body. At a point within the element, the pressure is 1 unit. Radius of the Mohr's circle, characterizing the state of stress at that point, is: [GATE-2008] (a) 0.5 unit (b) 0 unit (c) 1 unit (d) 2 units GATE-14. Ans. (b)

Page 87 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

GATE-15. The Mohr's circle of plane stress for a point in a body is shown. The design is to be done on the basis of the maximum shear stress theory for yielding. Then, yielding will just begin if the designer chooses a ductile material whose yield strength is: (a) 45 MPa (b) 50 MPa (c) 90 MPa (d) 100 MPa GATE-15. Ans. (c) Given V 1

10 MPa,

V2

Vy

Â&#x; Vy

[GATE-2005]

100 MPa

Maximum shear stress theory give W max or V 1  V 2

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

V1  V 2

10  ( 100)

Vy

2 2 90MPa

GATE-16. The figure shows the state of stress at a certain point in a stressed body. The magnitudes of normal stresses in the x and y direction are 100MPa and 20 MPa respectively. The radius of Mohr's stress circle representing this state of stress is: (a) 120 (b) 80 (c) 60 (d) 40 [GATE-2004] GATE-16. Ans. (c) V x 100MPa, V y

20MPa

Vx Vy

100  20

2

2

60

Data for Q17â&#x20AC;&#x201C;Q18 are given below. Solve the problems and choose correct answers. [GATE-2003] The state of stress at a point "P" in a two dimensional loading is such that the Mohr's circle is a point located at 175 MPa on the positive normal stress axis. GATE-17. Determine the maximum and minimum principal stresses respectively from the Mohr's circle (a) + 175 MPa, â&#x20AC;&#x201C;175MPa (b) +175 MPa, +175 MPa (c) 0, â&#x20AC;&#x201C;175 MPa (d) 0, 0 GATE-17. Ans. (b)

V1 V 2

Vx

Vy

175 MPa

GATE-18. Determine the directions of maximum and minimum principal stresses at the point â&#x20AC;&#x153;Pâ&#x20AC;? from the Mohr's circle Page 88 of 429 [GATE-2003]

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

(a) 0, 90Â° (b) 90Â°, 0 (c) 45Â°, 135Â° GATE-18. Ans. (d) From the Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circle it will give all directions.

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s (d) All directions

Principal strains GATE-19. If the two principal strains at a point are 1000 Ă&#x2014; 10-6 and -600 Ă&#x2014; 10-6, then the maximum shear strain is: [GATE-1996] (b) 500 Ă&#x2014; 10-6 (c) 1600 Ă&#x2014; 10-6 (d) 200 Ă&#x2014; 10-6 (a) 800 Ă&#x2014; 10-6 GATE-19. Ans. (c) Shear strain emax  emin ^1000  600 ` u 10 6 1600 u 10 6

Previous 20-Years IES Questions Stresses due to Pure Shear IES-1.

If a prismatic bar be subjected to an axial tensile stress Ç&#x201D;, then shear stress induced on a plane inclined at Ç&#x2030; with the axis will be: [IES-1992]

a

V 2

sin 2T

b

V 2

cos 2T

c

V 2

d

cos 2 T

V 2

sin 2 T

IES-1. Ans. (a) IES-2.

In the case of bi-axial state of normal stresses, the normal stress on 45Â° plane is equal to [IES-1992] (a) The sum of the normal stresses (b) Difference of the normal stresses (c) Half the sum of the normal stresses (d) Half the difference of the normal stresses Vx Vy Vx Vy IES-2. Ans. (c) V n  cos 2T  W xy sin 2T 2 2 Vx Vy At T 45o andW xy 0; V n 2 IES-3.

In a two-dimensional problem, the state of pure shear at a point is characterized by [IES-2001] (b) H x H y and J xy z 0 (a) H x H y and J xy 0 (c)

Hx

2H y and J xy z 0

(d)

Hx

0.5H y and J xy

0

IES-3. Ans. (b) IES-4.

Which one of the following Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circles represents the state of pure shear? [IES-2000]

IES-4. Ans. (c) Page 89 of 429

Chapter-2 IES-5.

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

For the state of stress of pure shear W the strain energy stored per unit volume in the elastic, homogeneous isotropic material having elastic constants E and [IES-1998] Q will be:

W2

1 Q

E IES-5. Ans. (a) V 1 W , V2 (a)

U

W2

2W 2 (c) 1 Q

E

1 Q

2E W , V 3 0 (b)

1 ÂŞ 2 2 W  W  2PW W Âş V ÂŹ Âź 2E

(d)

W2 2E

2 Q

1 P 2 W V E

IES-6.

Assertion (A): If the state at a point is pure shear, then the principal planes through that point making an angle of 45Â° with plane of shearing stress carries principal stresses whose magnitude is equal to that of shearing stress. Reason (R): Complementary shear stresses are equal in magnitude, but opposite in direction. [IES-1996] (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IES-6. Ans. (b) IES-7.

Assertion (A): Circular shafts made of brittle material fail along a helicoidally surface inclined at 45Â° to the axis (artery point) when subjected to twisting moment. [IES-1995] Reason (R): The state of pure shear caused by torsion of the shaft is equivalent to one of tension at 45Â° to the shaft axis and equal compression in the perpendicular direction. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IES-7. Ans. (a) Both A and R are true and R is correct explanation for A. IES-8.

A state of pure shear in a biaxial state of stress is given by

Â§V1 0 Âˇ Â¸ ÂŠ 0 V2 Âš IES-8. Ans. (b) V 1 W , V2

Â§V1 0 Âˇ Â¸ ÂŠ 0 V 1 Âš W , V 3 0 (b) Â¨

(a) Â¨

(c)

Â§ V x W xy Âˇ Â¨ Â¸ ÂŠW yx V y Âš

[IES-1994]

(d) None of the above

IES-9.

The state of plane stress in a plate of 100 mm thickness is given as [IES-2000] Ç&#x201D;xx = 100 N/mm2, Ç&#x201D;yy = 200 N/mm2, Young's modulus = 300 N/mm2, Poisson's ratio = 0.3. The stress developed in the direction of thickness is: (c) 100 N/mm2 (d) 200 N/mm2 (a) Zero (b) 90 N/mm2 IES-9. Ans. (a) IES-10.

The state of plane stress at a point is described by

V x V y V and W xy

normal stress on the plane inclined at 45Â° to the x-plane will be:

a V IES-10. Ans. (a) V n IES-11.

b

Vx Vy 2



Vx Vy 2

2V

c

3V

0 . The

[IES-1998]

d 2V

cos 2T  W xy sin 2T

Consider the following statements: [IES-1996, 1998] State of stress in two dimensions at a point in a loaded component can be completely specified by indicating the normal and shear stresses on 1. A plane containing the point 2. Any two planes passing through the point Page 90 of 429 3. Two mutually perpendicular planes passing through the point

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

Of these statements (a) 1, and 3 are correct (c) 1 alone is correct IES-11. Ans. (d)

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

(b) 2 alone is correct (d) 3 alone is correct

Principal Stress and Principal Plane IES-12.

A body is subjected to a pure tensile stress of 100 units. What is the maximum shear produced in the body at some oblique plane due to the above? [IES-2006] (a) 100 units (b) 75 units (c) 50 units (d) 0 unit V 1  V 2 100  0 50 units. IES-12. Ans. (c) W max 2 2 IES-13.

In a strained material one of the principal stresses is twice the other. The maximum shear stress in the same case is U max . Then, what is the value of the maximum principle stress? [IES 2007] W W W (a) max (b) 2 max (c) 4 max (d) 8 W max

IES-13. Ans. (c) IES-14.

V1  V 2

W max

2

V x uV y

W xy

if V 2

(b)

2 Vx  Vy

IES-14. Ans. (c) V 1,2

2

V2 2

or

V2

2W max or V 1 2V 2 = 4W max

W xy

V x uV y

(c)

W xy

V x uV y

(d)

W xy

V x2 V y2

2

Â§Vx Vy Â· 2  Â¨ Â¸  W xy 2 Â© Â¹ 2

Vx Vy

Â&#x;

0

Â§Vx Vy Â· 2 Â¨ Â¸  W xy 2 Â© Â¹

2

Â§Vx  Vy Â· or Â¨ Â¸ 2 Â¹ Â©

2

2

Â§Vx Vy Â· 2 Â¨ Â¸  W xy or W xy 2 Â© Â¹

Vx uVy

The principal stresses Ç&#x201D;1, Ç&#x201D;2 and Ç&#x201D;3 at a point respectively are 80 MPa, 30 MPa and â&#x20AC;&#x201C;40 MPa. The maximum shear stress is: [IES-2001] (a) 25 MPa (b) 35 MPa (c) 55 MPa (d) 60 MPa

IES-15. Ans. (d) W max

IES-16.

2V 2 or W max

V1

In a strained material, normal stresses on two mutually perpendicular planes are Ç&#x201D;x and Ç&#x201D;y (both alike) accompanied by a shear stress Ç&#x2022;xy One of the principal stresses will be zero, only if [IES-2006] (a)

IES-15.

,

V1  V 2 2

80  ( 40) 2

60 MPa

Plane stress at a point in a body is defined by principal stresses 3Ç&#x201D; and Ç&#x201D;. The ratio of the normal stress to the maximum shear stresses on the plane of maximum shear stress is: [IES-2000] (a) 1 (b) 2 (c) 3 (d) 4

IES-16. Ans. (b) tan 2T

W max

V1  V 2 2

2W xy

Vx Vy

Â&#x;T

3V  V 2

0

V

Major principal stress on the plane of maximum shear = V 1 Page 91 of 429

3V  V 2

2V

Chapter-2 IES-17.

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Principal stresses at a point in plane stressed element are

Vx

Vy

500 kg/cm 2 .

Normal stress on the plane inclined at 45o to x-axis will be: [IES-1993] 2 2 (a) 0 (b) 500 kg/cm (c) 707 kg/cm (d) 1000 kg/cm2 IES-17. Ans. (b) When stresses are alike, then normal stress Ç&#x201D;n on plane inclined at angle 45Â° is 2

2

Â§ 1 Âˇ Â§ 1 Âˇ Vy Â¨ Â¸ Vx Â¨ Â¸ ÂŠ 2Âš ÂŠ 2Âš

2

V n V y cos T  V x sin T IES-18.

2

ÂŞ1 1Âş 500 ÂŤ  Âť ÂŹ2 2Âź

500 kg/cm 2

If the principal stresses corresponding to a two-dimensional state of stress are

V1

V2

and

is greater than

V2

and both are tensile, then which one of the

following would be the correct criterion for failure by yielding, according to the maximum shear stress criterion? [IES-1993]

(a)

V 1  V 2

r

2

V yp 2

(b)

V1

r

2

V yp 2

(c )

V2 2

r

V yp 2

(d ) V 1

r2V yp

IES-18. Ans. (a) IES-19.

For the state of plane stress. Shown the maximum and minimum principal stresses are: (a) 60 MPa and 30 MPa (b) 50 MPa and 10 MPa (c) 40 MPa and 20 MPa (d) 70 MPa and 30 MPa [IES-1992]

IES-19. Ans. (d) V 1,2

Vx Vy 2

2

Â§Vx Vy Âˇ 2  Â¨ Â¸  W xy 2 ÂŠ Âš 2

V 1,2 V max

50  ( 10) Â§ 50  10 Âˇ 2  Â¨ Â¸  40 2 ÂŠ 2 Âš 70 and V min

30

IES-20.

Normal stresses of equal magnitude p, but of opposite signs, act at a point of a strained material in perpendicular direction. What is the magnitude of the resultant normal stress on a plane inclined at 45Â° to the applied stresses? [IES-2005] (a) 2 p (b) p/2 (c) p/4 (d) Zero Vx Vy Vx Vy IES-20. Ans. (d) V x  cos 2T 2 2 P P P P  cos 2 u 45 0 Vn 2 2 IES-21.

A plane stressed element is subjected to the state of stress given by

V x W xy 100 kgf/cm 2 and Ç&#x201D;y = 0. Maximum shear stress in the element is equal to

a 50

[IES-1997]

3 kgf/cm 2

b 100 kgf/cm 2 Page 92 of 429

c 50

5 kgf/cm2

d 150 kgf/cm 2

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

IES-21. Ans. (c)

Vx 0

V 1,2

2

Â§V 0Â· r Â¨ x  W xy2 Â¸ Â© 2 Â¹

Maximum shear stress =

IES-22.

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

2

V 1  V 2 2

50 # 50 5

50 5

Match List I with List II and select the correct answer, using the codes given below the lists: [IES-1995] List I(State of stress) List II(Kind of loading)

Codes: (a) (c) IES-22. Ans. (c)

A 1 2

B 2 4

C 3 3

D 4 1

A 2 3

(b) (d)

B 3 4

C 4 1

D 1 2

Mohr's circle IES-23.

Consider the Mohr's circle shown above: What is the state of stress represented by this circle? (a)V x V y z 0, W xy 0

(b)V x  V y (c)V x

0, W xy z 0

0, V y W xy z 0

(d)V x z 0, V y

W xy

0 [IES-2008]

IES-23. Ans. (b) It is a case of pure shear. Just put V 1 IES-24.

V 2

For a general two dimensional stress system, what are the coordinates of the centre of Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circle? (a)

Vx V y 2

,0

(b) 0,

Vx Vy 2

(c)

Vx Vy 2

,0

(d) 0,

Vx V y 2

IES-24. Ans. (c) IES-25.

In a Mohr's circle, the radius of the circle is taken as: 2

(a)

2 Â§ V x V y Â· Â¨ Â¸  W xy

(c)

2 Â§ V x V y Â· Â¨ Â¸  W xy

(b)

V

x

[IES-2006; GATE-1993]

V y

2

2

 W xy

2

2

Page 93 of 429

(d)

V

2

x

 V y  W xy

2

[IE

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Where, Ç&#x201D;x and Ç&#x201D;y are normal stresses along x and y directions respectively and Ç&#x2022;xy is the shear stress. IES-25. Ans. (a)

IES-26.

Maximum shear stress in a Mohr's Circle [IES- 2008] (a) Is equal to radius of Mohr's circle (b) Is greater than radius of Mohr's circle (c) Is less than radius of Mohr's circle (d) Could be any of the above IES-26. Ans. (a)

Â§ Â¨ Â§ Vx  Vy Â¨ Â¨Â¨ 2 Â¨ Â© Â© ? Radius of the Mohr Circle Vx  Vy Â§ Â¨Â¨ V xc  2 Â©

2

Â· 2 Â¸Â¸  Wxcyc Â¹

2 Â· Â· 2 Â¸ Â¸Â¸  W xy Â¸ Â¸ Â¹ Â¹

2

2

Â§ Vx  Vy Â· 2 Â¨Â¨ Â¸Â¸  W xy 2 Â© Â¹ Vx  Vy

? Vt

V2

2 Vx  Vy

Â&#x; Wmax

IES-27.

2

Â§ Vx  Vy  Â¨Â¨ 2 Â©

Â§ Vx  Vy  Â¨Â¨ 2 Â©

V1  V2 2

r

2

Â· 2 Â¸Â¸  W xy Â¹

2

Â· 2 Â¸Â¸  W xy Â¹ Â&#x; Wmax

Â§ Vx  Vy Â¨Â¨ 2 Â©

2

Â· 2 Â¸Â¸  W xy Â¹

At a point in two-dimensional stress system Ç&#x201D;x = 100 N/mm2, Ç&#x201D;y = Ç&#x2022;xy = 40 N/mm2. What is the radius of the Mohr circle for stress drawn with a scale of: 1 cm = 10 [IES-2005] N/mm2? Page 94 of 429 (a) 3 cm (b) 4 cm (c) 5 cm (d) 6 cm

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

IES-27. Ans. (c) Radius of the Mohr circle ÂŞ V V 2 Âş ÂŞ Â§ 100  40 Âˇ2 Âş y Âˇ 2 ÂŤ Â¨Â§ x ÂŤ Â¨ Âť / 10 40  W xy 2 Âť / 10  Â¸ Â¸ ÂŤ ÂŠ Âť 2 Âš 2 ÂŤ ÂŠ Âť Âš ÂŹ Âź ÂŹ Âź IES-28.

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

50 / 10

5 cm

Consider a two dimensional state of stress given for an element as shown in the diagram given below: [IES-2004]

What are the coordinates of the centre of Mohr's circle? (a) (0, 0) (b) (100, 200) (c) (200, 100) Â§ V x  V y Âˇ Â§ 200  100 Âˇ ,0 Â¸ Â¨ ,0 Â¸ 50,0

IES-28. Ans. (d) Centre of Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circle is Â¨ 2 Âš ÂŠ 2 Âš ÂŠ

(d) (50, 0)

IES-29.

Two-dimensional state of stress at a point in a plane stressed element is represented by a Mohr circle of zero radius. Then both principal stresses (a) Are equal to zero [IES-2003] (b) Are equal to zero and shear stress is also equal to zero (c) Are of equal magnitude but of opposite sign (d) Are of equal magnitude and of same sign IES-29. Ans. (d) IES-30.

Assertion (A): Mohr's circle of stress can be related to Mohr's circle of strain by some constant of proportionality. [IES-2002] Reason (R): The relationship is a function of yield stress of the material. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IES-30. Ans. (c) IES-31.

When two mutually perpendicular principal stresses are unequal but like, the maximum shear stress is represented by [IES-1994] (a) The diameter of the Mohr's circle (b) Half the diameter of the Mohr's circle (c) One-third the diameter of the Mohr's circle (d) One-fourth the diameter of the Mohr's circle IES-31. Ans. (b) IES-32.

State of stress in a plane element is shown in figure I. Which one of the following figures-II is the correct sketch of Mohr's circle of the state of stress? [IES-1993, 1996]

Figure-I

Page 95 of 429

Figure-II

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

IES-32. Ans. (c)

Strain IES-33.

A point in a two dimensional state of strain is subjected to pure shearing strain of magnitude J xy radians. Which one of the following is the maximum principal strain? (a) J xy

(b) J xy / 2

[IES-2008] (d) 2 J xy

(c) J xy /2

IES-33. Ans. (c) IES-34.

Assertion (A): A plane state of stress does not necessarily result into a plane state of strain as well. [IES-1996] Reason (R): Normal stresses acting along X and Y directions will also result into normal strain along the Z-direction. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IES-34. Ans. (a)

Principal strains Principal strains at a point are 100 u 106 and 200 u 106 . What is the maximum shear strain at the point? [IES-2006] â&#x20AC;&#x201C;6 â&#x20AC;&#x201C;6 â&#x20AC;&#x201C;6 (b) 200 Ă&#x2014; 10 (c) 150 Ă&#x2014; 10 (d) 100 Ă&#x2014; 10â&#x20AC;&#x201C;6 (a) 300 Ă&#x2014; 10 6 6 IES-35. Ans. (a) J max H 1  H 2 100  200 u 10 300 u 10 IES-35.

don' t confuse withMaximumShear stress W max

in strain

J xy

H1  H 2

2

2

and W max

V1  V 2 2

V1  V 2 2

that is the difference.

IES-36.

The principal strains at a point in a body, under biaxial state of stress, are 1000Ă&#x2014;10â&#x20AC;&#x201C;6 and â&#x20AC;&#x201C;600 Ă&#x2014; 10â&#x20AC;&#x201C;6. What is the maximum shear strain at that point? [IES-2009] (b) 800 Ă&#x2014; 10â&#x20AC;&#x201C;6 (c) 1000 Ă&#x2014; 10â&#x20AC;&#x201C;6 (d) 1600 Ă&#x2014; 10â&#x20AC;&#x201C;6 (a) 200 Ă&#x2014; 10â&#x20AC;&#x201C;6 IES-36. Ans. (d)

Â?x  Â?y

Ixy

2

2

Â&#x;

Ixy

Â?x  Â?y

1000 u 106  600 u 106

1600 u 106

IES-37.

The number of strain readings (using strain gauges) needed on a plane surface to determine the principal strains and their directions is: [IES-1994] (a) 1 (b) 2 (c) 3 (d) 4 IES-37. Ans. (c) Three strain gauges are needed on a plane surface to determine the principal strains and their directions.

Principal strain induced by principal stress IES-38.

The principal stresses at a point in two dimensional stress system are V 1 and V 2 and corresponding principal strains are H1 and H 2 . If E and Q denote Young's modulus and Poisson's ratio, respectively, then which one of the following is correct? [IES-2008] E (a) V 1 EH1 (b)V 1 >H1  QH 2 @ 1Q 2 E (c)V 1 (d)96Vof E >H 1  QH 2 @ >H1  QH 2 @ Page 1 429 1Q 2

Chapter-2 IES-38. Ans. (b) F1

T1 T N 2 E E

Principal Stress and Strain S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s T T and F2  2  N 1 From these two equation eliminate T2 . E E

IES-39.

Assertion (A): Mohr's construction is possible for stresses, strains and area moment of inertia. [IES-2009] Reason (R): Mohr's circle represents the transformation of second-order tensor. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A. (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A. (c) A is true but R is false. (d) A is false but R is true. IES-39. Ans. (a)

Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Stresses due to Pure Shear IAS-1.

On a plane, resultant stress is inclined at an angle of 45o to the plane. If the [IAS-2003] normal stress is 100 N /mm2, the shear stress on the plane is: (b) 100 N/mm2 (c) 86.6 N/mm2 (d) 120.8 N/mm2 (a) 71.5 N/mm2 IAS-1. Ans. (b) We know V n V cos2 T and W V sin T cos T

100 V cos2 45 or V

W IAS-2.

200

200 sin 45 cos 45 100

Biaxial stress system is correctly shown in

[IAS-1999]

IAS-2. Ans. (c)

IAS-3.

The complementary shear stresses of intensity W are induced at a point in the material, as shown in the figure. Which one of the following is the correct set of orientations of principal planes with respect to AB? (a) 30Â° and 120Â° (b) 45Â° and 135Â° (c) 60Â° and 150Â° (d) 75Â°Page and97165Â° of 429 [IAS-1998]

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondal’s

IAS-3. Ans. (b) It is a case of pure shear so principal planes will be along the diagonal. IAS-4.

A uniform bar lying in the x-direction is subjected to pure bending. Which one of the following tensors represents the strain variations when bending moment is about the z-axis (p, q and r constants)? [IAS-2001]

§ py 0 0 · ¨ ¸ (a) 0 qy 0 ¸ ¨ ¨ 0 0 ry ¸ © ¹ 0 · § py 0 ¨ ¸ (c) 0 py 0 ¸ ¨ ¨ 0 0 py ¸¹ ©

§ py 0 0 · ¨ ¸ (b) 0 qy 0 ¸ ¨ ¨ 0 0 0 ¸¹ © § py 0 0 · ¨ ¸ (d) 0 qy 0 ¨ ¸ ¨ 0 0 qy ¸ © ¹

IAS-4. Ans. (d) Stress in x direction = ǔx Therefore IAS-5.

Vx , E

Hx

Hy

P

Vx , E

Hz

P

Vx E

Assuming E = 160 GPa and G = 100 GPa for a material, a strain tensor is given as: [IAS-2001]

§ 0.002 0.004 0.006 · ¨ ¸ 0 ¸ ¨ 0.004 0.003 ¨ 0.006 0 0 ¸¹ © The shear stress,

W xy is:

(a) 400 MPa

(b) 500 MPa

(c) 800 MPa

(d) 1000 MPa

IAS-5. Ans. (c)

W xy

G J xy

ªH xx H xy H xz º J xy « » «H yx H yy H yz » and H xy 2 «H H H » ¬ zx zy zz ¼ 3 100 u 10 u 0.004 u 2 MPa 800MPa

Principal Stress and Principal Plane IAS-6.

A material element subjected to a plane state of stress such that the maximum shear stress is equal to the maximum tensile stress, would correspond to [IAS-1998]

IAS-6. Ans. (d) W max IAS-7.

V1  V 2

V 1  ( V 1 )

2

2

V1

A solid circular shaft is subjected to a maximum shearing stress of 140 MPs. The magnitude of the maximum normal stress developed in the shaft is: Page 98 of 429 [IAS-1995]

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain (a) 140 MPa

IAS-7. Ans. (a) W max IAS-8.

(b) 80 MPa

V1  V 2 2

Maximum normal stress will developed if V 1

IAS-8. Ans. (c)

W max

Â§V x V y Âˇ Â¨Â¨ Â¸Â¸  W xy 2 = 2 ÂŠ Âš

V 2

V

2

Â§  40  40 Âˇ 2 Â¨ Â¸  30 = 50 MPa 2 ÂŠ Âš

A horizontal beam under bending has a maximum bending stress of 100 MPa and a maximum shear stress of 20 MPa. What is the maximum principal stress in the beam? [IAS-2004]

(a) 20 IAS-9. Ans. (c) Ç&#x201D;b=100MPa Ç&#x201D;1,2=

(b) 50

(c) 50 +

2900

(d) 100

W =20 mPa 2

Vb

V 1,2 IAS-10.

(d) 60 MPa

The state of stress at a point in a loaded member is shown in the figure. The [IAS 1994] magnitude of maximum shear stress is [1MPa = 10 kg/cm2] (a) 10 MPa (b) 30 MPa (c) 50 MPa (d) 100MPa

2

IAS-9.

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

(c) 70 MPa

Â§V Âˇ  Â¨ b Â¸ W 2 2 ÂŠ 2 Âš 2

Vb

2

Â§V Âˇ  Â¨ b Â¸ W 2 2 ÂŠ 2 Âš

100 Â§ 100 Âˇ 2  Â¨ Â¸  20 2 ÂŠ 2 Âš

50 

2900 MPa

When the two principal stresses are equal and like: the resultant stress on any plane is: [IAS-2002] (a) Equal to the principal stress (b) Zero (c) One half the principal stress (d) One third of the principal stress

IAS-10. Ans. (a)

Vn

Vx V y 2



V x V y

[We may consider this as

2

W xy

cos 2T 0 ] Vx

V y V ( say )

IAS-11.

So

V n V for any plane

Assertion (A): When an isotropic, linearly elastic material is loaded biaxially, the directions of principal stressed are different from those of principal strains. [IAS-2001] Reason (R): For an isotropic, linearly elastic material the Hooke's law gives only two independent material properties. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-11. Ans. (d) They are same. Page 99 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

IAS-12.

Principal stress at a point in a stressed solid are 400 MPa and 300 MPa respectively. The normal stresses on planes inclined at 45Â° to the principal planes will be: [IAS-2000] (a) 200 MPa and 500 MPa (b) 350 MPa on both planes (c) 100MPaand6ooMPa (d) 150 MPa and 550 MPa IAS-12. Ans. (b)

Vn

Â§ Vx V y Â¨ ÂŠ 2

Âˇ Â§ V x V y Â¸Â¨ Âš ÂŠ 2

Âˇ Â¸ cos 2T Âš

400  300 400  300  cos 2 u 45o 2 2

350MPa

The principal stresses at a point in an elastic material are 60N/mm2 tensile, 20 N/mm2 tensile and 50 N/mm2 compressive. If the material properties are: Îź = 0.35 and E = 105 Nmm2, then the volumetric strain of the material is: [IAS-1997] (b) 3 Ă&#x2014; 10-4 (c) 10.5 Ă&#x2014; 10â&#x20AC;&#x201C;5 (d) 21 Ă&#x2014; 10â&#x20AC;&#x201C;5 (a) 9 Ă&#x2014; 10â&#x20AC;&#x201C;5 IAS-13. Ans. (a) Vy Vy Âˇ Â§Vy Vz Âˇ Â§V Vx V Âˇ Vz Â§V Â?x  PÂ¨   P Â¨ z  x Â¸ and Â?z  PÂ¨ x  Â¸ , Â?y Â¸ E EÂš E E Âš E E Âš ÂŠE ÂŠE ÂŠE

IAS-13.

Â?v Â?x  Â?y  Â?z

Vx  Vy  Vz E

Â§Vx  Vy  Vz Âˇ Â¸ E ÂŠ Âš

1  2P Â¨



2P V x  V y  V z

E

Â§ 60  20  50 Âˇ Â¨ Â¸ 1  2 u 0.35

105 ÂŠ Âš

9 u 10 5

Mohr's circle IAS-14.

Match List-I (Mohr's Circles of stress) with List-II (Types of Loading) and select the correct answer using the codes given below the lists: [IAS-2004] List-I List-II (Mohr's Circles of Stress) (Types of Loading)

Codes: (a) (c) IAS-14. Ans. (d)

A 5 4

B 4 3

C 3 2

D 2 5

1.

A shaft compressed all round by a hub

2.

Bending moment applied at the free end of a cantilever

3.

Shaft under torsion

4.

Thin cylinder under pressure

5.

Thin spherical shell under internal pressure

(b) (d)

Page 100 of 429

A 2 2

B 4 3

C 1 1

D 3 5

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

IAS-15.

The resultant stress on a certain plane makes an angle of 20Â° with the normal to the plane. On the plane perpendicular to the above plane, the resultant stress makes an angle of Ç&#x2030; with the normal. The value of Ç&#x2030; can be: [IAS-2001] (a) 0Â° or 20Â° (b) Any value other than 0Â° or 90Â° (c) Any value between 0Â° and 20Â° (d) 20Â° only IAS-15. Ans. (b) IAS-16.

The correct Mohr's stress-circle drawn for a point in a solid shaft compressed by a shrunk fit hub is as (O-Origin and C-Centre of circle; OA = Ç&#x201D;1 and OB = Ç&#x201D;2) [IAS-2001]

IAS-16. Ans. (d) IAS-17.

A Mohr's stress circle is drawn for a body subjected to tensile stress in two mutually perpendicular directions such that

f x > f y . Which one of the

following statements in this regard is NOT correct?

f x is equal to

(a) Normal stress on a plane at 45Â° to (b) Shear stress on a plane at 450 to

f x is equal to

(c) Maximum normal stress is equal to (d) Maximum shear stress is equal to IAS-17. Ans. (d) Maximum shear stress is

IAS-18.

fx  f y 2 fx  f y 2

fx . fx  f y 2

2

V x =2

N/mm2,

Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circle is:

V x =0

and W xy

0 , the correct [IAS-1999]

Â§Vx Vy Âˇ ,0 Â¸ IAS-18. Ans. (d) Centre Â¨ ÂŠ 2 Âš 2

IAS-19.

[IAS-2000]

fx  f y

For the given stress condition

f x and f y

Â§Vx Vy Âˇ 2 Â¨ Â¸ Wx 2 ÂŠ Âš

Â§20 Âˇ Â¨ 2 ,0 Â¸ ÂŠ Âš

1, 0

2

Â§20Âˇ Â¨ 2 Â¸ 0 ÂŠ Âš

1

For which one of the following two-dimensional states of stress will the Mohr's stress circle degenerate into a point? [IAS-1996]

Page 101 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

IAS-19. Ans. (c) Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circle will be a point. 2

Radius of the Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circle =

Â§Vx Vy Âˇ 2 Â¨ Â¸  W xy ÂŠ 2 Âš

? W xy

0 andV x

Vy

V

Principal strains IAS-20.

In an axi-symmetric plane strain problem, let u be the radial displacement at r. Then the strain components H r , HT , beT are given by [IAS-1995] (a)

Hr

(c)

Hr

u , HT r u , HT r

wu , b rT wr wu , b rT wr

w 2u wrwT

(b)

Hr

0

(d)

Hr

wu , HT wr wu , HT wr

u , b rT o r wu w 2u , b rT wT wrwT

IAS-20. Ans. (b) IAS-21.

Assertion (A): Uniaxial stress normally gives rise to triaxial strain. Reason (R): Magnitude of strains in the perpendicular directions of applied stress is smaller than that in the direction of applied stress. [IAS-2004] (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-21. Ans. (b) IAS-22.

Assertion (A): A plane state of stress will, in general, not result in a plane state of strain. [IAS-2002] Reason (R): A thin plane lamina stretched in its own plane will result in a state of plane strain. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-22. Ans. (c) R is false. Stress in one plane always induce a lateral strain with its orthogonal plane.

Page 102 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

What are principal in planes? The planes which pass through the point in such a manner that the resultant stress across them is totally a normal stress are known as principal planes. No shear stress exists at the principal planes.

Conventional Question IES-2009 Q.

The Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circle for a plane stress is a circle of radius R with its origin at + 2R on V axis. Sketch the Mohrâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s circle and determine V max , V min , V av , this situation.

Ans.

Here V max

V min

Wxy max for [2 Marks]

3R

R

3R  R 2R 2 V max  V min and W xy 2 V Vv

3R  R 2

R

R

R

(2R,0)

3R

Conventional Question IES-1999 Question:

Direct tensile stresses of 120 MPa and 70 MPa act on a body on mutually perpendicular planes. What is the magnitude of shearing stress that can be applied so that the major principal stress at the point does not exceed 135 MPa? Determine the value of minor principal stress and the maximum shear stress.

Let shearing stress is 'U ' MPa. The principal stresses are 2

Â?120  70 ÂŹÂ­ 120 70 2 o Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; Â­ U Â&#x17E;Â&#x; ÂŽÂ­ 2 2 Major principal stress is Äą1,2

120 70 Äą1

2

2

Â?120  70 ÂŹÂ­ 2 Â­Â­ U Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; Â&#x; ÂŽ 2

135(Given) or , U  31.2MPa. Page 103 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Minor principal stress is Äą2

W max

120  70  2 V1  V 2 2

2

Â§ 120  70 Âˇ 2 Â¨ Â¸  31.2 2 ÂŠ Âš 135  55 40 MPa 2

55 MPa

Conventional Question IES-2009 Q.

The state of stress at a point in a loaded machine member is given by the principle stresses. [ 2 Marks] V1 600 MPa, V 2 0 and V3 600 MPa . (i) (ii)

Ans.

What is the magnitude of the maximum shear stress? What is the inclination of the plane on which the maximum shear stress acts with respect to the plane on which the maximum principle stress V1 acts? (i) Maximum shear stress,

W

V1  V3 2

600  600

2 600 MPa

Ç&#x2030; = 45Âş max. shear stress occurs with Ç&#x201D;1 plane. Since Ç&#x201D;1 and Ç&#x201D;3 are principle stress does not contains shear stress. Hence max. shear stress is at 45Âş with principle (ii) At plane.

Conventional Question IES-2008 Question:

A prismatic bar in compression has a cross- sectional area A = 900 mm2 and carries an axial load P = 90 kN. What are the stresses acts on (i) A plane transverse to the loading axis; (ii) A plane at Č&#x2122; = 60o to the loading axis? (i) From figure it is clear A plane transverse to loading axis, Č&#x2122; =0o P 90000 N / mm 2 = Tn  cos2 Č&#x2122;= A 900  100 N / mm 2 P 90000 and U = Sin 2Č&#x2122;= q sinČ&#x2122;=0 2A 2Ă&#x2014;900 (iii)

A plane at 60o to loading axis, Č&#x2122; = 60Â°- 30Â° = 30Â° P 90000 Tn  cos2 Č&#x2122;= q cos2 30 A 900  75N / mm 2 P 90000 U sin2R  sin2 q 60o 2A 2 q 900  43.3N / mm 2

Conventional Question IES-2001 Question:

A tension member with a cross-sectional area of 30 mm2 resists a load of 80 kN, Calculate the normal and shear stresses on the plane of maximum shear stress.

Äąn

P cos2 Č&#x2122; A

U

P sin 2Č&#x2122; 2A

Page 104 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

For maximum shear stress sin2Č&#x2122; = 1, or, Č&#x2122; = 45o

Äą n

80 q103 P 80 q103 q cos2 45  1333MPa and Umax    1333MPa 30 2A 30 q 2

Conventional Question IES-2007 Question:

At a point in a loaded structure, a pure shear stress state U = o 400 MPa prevails on two given planes at right angles. (i) What would be the state of stress across the planes of an element taken at +45Â° to the given planes? (ii) What are the magnitudes of these stresses? (i) For pure shear

Äą x  Äą y ;

U max  oÄą x  o400MPa

(ii) Magnitude of these stresses

Äą n  U xy Sin 2Č&#x2122;  U xy Sin90o  U xy  400 MPa and U  (U xy cos 2Č&#x2122; )  0 Conventional Question IAS-1997 Question:

Draw Mohr's circle for a 2-dimensional stress field subjected to (a) Pure shear (b) Pure biaxial tension (c) Pure uniaxial tension and (d) Pure uniaxial compression Mohr's circles for 2-dimensional stress field subjected to pure shear, pure biaxial tension, pure uniaxial compression and pure uniaxial tension are shown in figure below:

Conventional Question IES-2003 Question:

A Solid phosphor bronze shaft Page60 105mm of 429in diameter is rotating at 800 rpm and transmitting power. It is subjected torsion only. An electrical resistance

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

strain gauge mounted on the surface of the shaft with its axis at 45Â° to the shaft axis, gives the strain reading as 3.98 Ă&#x2014; 10â&#x20AC;&#x201C;4. If the modulus of elasticity for bronze is 105 GN/m2 and Poisson's ratio is 0.3, find the power being transmitted by the shaft. Bending effect may be neglected. Answer:

Let us assume maximum shear stress on the cross-sectional plane MU is U . Then

1 4U 2 = -U (compressive) 2 1 Principal stress along, LU = 4U 2  U (tensile) 2 Thus magntude of the compressive strain along VM is Principal stress along, VM = -

U = (1 Îź)  3.98 q104 E 3.98 q104 q 105 q109

or U =  32.15 MPa 1 0.3

= Torque being transmitted (T) = U q  32.15 q106 q

Ę&#x152; qd 3 16

Ę&#x152; q 0.063 =1363.5 Nm 16

Â? 2Ę&#x152;N ÂŹÂ­ Â? 2Ę&#x152;Ă&#x2014;800 ÂŹÂ­ Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; = Power being transmitted, P =T.X =T.Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; =1363.5Ă&#x2014; Â­ Â­W  114.23 kW Â&#x;Â&#x17E; 60 ÂŽÂ­ Â&#x;Â&#x17E; 60 ÂŽÂ­

Conventional Question IES-2002 Question:

The magnitude of normal stress on two mutually perpendicular planes, at a point in an elastic body are 60 MPa (compressive) and 80 MPa (tensile) respectively. Find the magnitudes of shearing stresses on these planes if the magnitude of one of the principal stresses is 100 MPa (tensile). Find also the magnitude of the other principal stress at this point.

Page 106 of 429

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Above figure shows stress condition assuming shear stress is ' U xy'

80Mpa

Jxy

Principal stresses

Äą1,2

2

Â? Äą  Äą y ÂŹÂ­ Â­ U xy2 o Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; x Â&#x17E;Â&#x; 2 ÂŽÂ­Â­

Äąx Äą y 2

or , Äą1,2

60Mpa

60Mpa

Jxy

Jxy

2

Â? 60  80 ÂŹÂ­ 2 Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; Â­Â­ U xy Â&#x17E;Â&#x; ÂŽ 2

60 80 o 2

2

Jxy 80Mpa

Â? 60  80 ÂŹÂ­ 60 80 2 or , Äą1,2  o Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; Â­Â­ U xy Â&#x17E; Â&#x; ÂŽ 2 2 To make principal stress 100 MPa we have to consider '+' . = Äą1  100 MPa  10 702 U xy2 ; or, U xy  56.57 MPa Therefore other principal stress will be 60 80 Äą2   2

2

Â? 60  80 ÂŹÂ­ 2 Â­ (56.57) Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E;Â&#x;Â&#x17E; ÂŽÂ­ 2

i.e. 80 MPa(compressive) Conventional Question IES-2001 Question: A steel tube of inner diameter 100 mm and wall thickness 5 mm is subjected to a torsional moment of 1000 Nm. Calculate the principal stresses and orientations of the principal planes on the outer surface of the tube. Answer:

Polar moment of Inertia (J)=

Ę&#x152; Â 4 4 Â˘ 0.110  0.100 ÂŻÂ°Âą = 4.56 q106 m 4 ÂĄ 32

5mm

T .R 1000 q(0.055) T U Now  or J   J R J 4.56 q106  12.07MPa Now, tan 2Č&#x2122; p

2U xy

r,

Äąx  Äąy

0

gives Č&#x2122;p  45 or 135

50mm

0

= Äą1  U xy Sin 2Č&#x2122;  12.07 q sin 900  12.07 MPa and Äą 2  12.07 sin 2700  12.07MPa Conventional Question IES-2000 Question:

At a point in a two dimensional stress system the normal stresses on two mutually perpendicular planes are T x and T y and the shear stress is U xy. At what value of shear stress, one of the principal stresses will become zero?

Two principal stressdes are Äą1,2

Äąx Äą y 2

2

Â? Äą x - Äą y ÂŹÂ­ Â­ U xy2 o Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; Â&#x17E;Â&#x; 2 ÂŽÂ­Â­ Page 107 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Considering (-)ive sign it may be zero 2

2

Â? Äą x  Äą y ÂŹÂ­ Â? Äą Äą y ÂŹÂ­ Â­ U xy2 = Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; x Â­Â­  Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; Â&#x17E;Â&#x; 2 ÂŽÂ­Â­ Â&#x17E;Â&#x; 2 ÂŽÂ­ 2

2

Â? Äą Äą y ÂŹÂ­ Â? Äą x  Äą y ÂŹÂ­ Â­ Â&#x17E; Â­ U xy2 or, Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; x Â&#x17E;Â&#x; 2 ÂŽÂ­Â­ Â&#x;Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; 2 ÂŽÂ­Â­

2

Â? Äą Äą y ÂŹÂ­ Â? Äą x  Äą y ÂŹÂ­ or, U  Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; x Â­  Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; Â­ Â&#x;Â&#x17E; 2 ÂŽÂ­Â­ Â&#x;Â&#x17E; 2 ÂŽÂ­Â­ 2 xy

2 or, U xy  Äą xÄą y

or,U xy  o Äą x Äą y

Conventional Question IES-1996 Question:

A solid shaft of diameter 30 mm is fixed at one end. It is subject to a tensile force of 10 kN and a torque of 60 Nm. At a point on the surface of the shaft, determine the principle stresses and the maximum shear stress. Given: D = 30 mm = 0.03 m; P = 10 kN; T= 60 Nm

Pr incipal stresses V 1,V 2 and max imum shear stress W max : Tensile stress V t

10 u 103

Vx

S 4

u 0.032

T J TR J

As per torsion equation,

W

? Shear stress,

14.15 u 106 N / m2 or 14.15 MN / m2

W R 60 u 0.015

TR

S 32

D

S

4

32

u 0.03

4

11.32 u 106 N / m2

or 11.32 MN / m2 The principal stresses are calculated by u sin g the relations : Â§Vx  Vy Âˇ Â¸r 2 Âš ÂŠ

V 1,2 Â¨ Here

Vx

ÂŞÂ§ V x  V y Âˇ 2 Âş 2 ÂŤÂ¨ Â¸ Âť  W xy 2 Âš Âť ÂŤÂŹÂŠ Âź

14.15MN / m2 ,V y

0;W xy

W

11.32

MN / m2

2

?

V 1,2

14.15 2 Â§ 14.15 Âˇ r Â¨  11.32

Â¸ 2 ÂŠ 2 Âš 7.07 r 13.35

Hence,major principal stress, V 1 Minor principal stress, V 2 Maximum shear stress,W max

20.425 MN / m2 , 6.275MN / m2 . 20.425 MN / m2 tensile

6.275MN / m2 compressive

V1  V 2

24.425  6.275

2

2

13.35mm / m2

Conventional Question IES-2000 Two planes AB and BC which are at right angles are acted upon by tensile stress of 140 N/mm2 and a compressive stress of 70 N/mm2 respectively and also by stress 35 N/mm2. Determine the principal stresses and principal planes. Find also the maximum shear stress and planes on which they act. Sketch the Mohr circle and mark the relevant data.

Question:

Page 108 of 429

Principal Stress and Strain Given

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s 2

70N/mm

Äą x =140MPa(tensile)

B

C

Äą y = -70MPa(compressive)

35Nmm

U xy  35MPa

2 2

140N/mm

Principal stresses; Äą1, Äą2 ; A

We know that, Äą1,2

Äąx Äąy 2

2

Â? Äą x  Äą y ÂŹÂ­ 2 Â­ U xy o Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; Â&#x17E;Â&#x; 2 ÂŽÂ­Â­

140  70 o 2

2

Â?140 70 ÂŹÂ­ 2 Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; Â­Â­ 35  35 o 110.7 Â&#x17E;Â&#x; ÂŽ 2

Therefore Äą1 =145.7 MPa and Äą 2  75.7MPa

Position of Principal planes Č&#x2122;1, Č&#x2122; 2 tan 2Č&#x2122; p

2U xy Äąx  Äąy

2 q 35  0.3333 140 70

Maximum shear stress, Umax

Äą1 - Äą 2 145 75.7   110.7MPa 2 2 Y

Mohr cirle: OL=Äą x  140MPa

S

OM  Äą y  70MPa SM  LT  U xy  35MPa

U

2Rp =198.4

L M

O

Joining ST that cuts at 'N'

N

V

2R 

Äą = 140

T

SN=NT=radius of Mohr circle =110.7 MPa OV=Äą1  145.7MPa OV  Äą 2  75.7MPa

Conventional Question IES-2010 Q6.

The data obtained from a rectangular strain gauge rosette attached to a stressed

steel

member

0 Â?0 =  220 u 106 , Â?45 120 u 1006 ,

are

and

Â?90 =220 u 106 . Given that the value of E = 2 u 105 N / mm2 and Poissonâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Ratio P 0.3 , calculate the values of principal stresses acting at the point and Ans.

their directions. A rectangular strain gauge rosette strain

Â?0 220 u 106 E = 2 u 1011 N / m2

Â?

450

[10 Marks]

120 u 106 Â?90 220 u 106 poisson ratio P 0.3

Find out principal stress and their direction. Let ea Â?o ec Â?90 and eb Â?45 We know that principal strain are

ea  eb 2 2 ea  eb  eb  ec

2 220 u 106  120 u 106 1 Â&#x; r 220  120  106 2 2 1 354.40 u 106 Â&#x; 50 u 106 r 2 Page 109 of 429 Â?12

2

 120  220 10

6

2

Chapter-2 6

Â?12 Â&#x; 50 u 10

Principal Stress and Strain r 250.6 u 106

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Â?1 2.01 u 104

Â?2 3.01 u 104 Direction can be find out : -

2 u 120 u 106 220 u 106  220 u 106

2eb  ea  ec ec  ea

tan 2Ç&#x2030;pÂ?

240 0.55 440 2Ç&#x2030;pÂ? 28.81 Â&#x;

Ç&#x2030;pÂ?

14.450 clockwiseform principal strain t1

Principal stress:-

Ç&#x201D;1

E Â?1  Ç? Â?2

2 u 1011 2  0.3 3 u 104

2

2

1 Ç?

1  0.3

241.78 u 105 N / m 2 527.47 u 105 N / m 2 Conventional Question IES-1998 Question: Answer:

When using strain-gauge system for stress/force/displacement measurements how are in-built magnification and temperature compensation achieved? In-built magnification and temperature compensation are achieved by (a) Through use of adjacent arm balancing of Wheat-stone bridge. (b) By means of self temperature compensation by selected melt-gauge and dual element-gauge.

Conventional Question AMIE-1998 Question:

A cylinder (500 mm internal diameter and 20 mm wall thickness) with closed ends is subjected simultaneously to an internal pressure of 0-60 MPa, bending moment 64000 Nm and torque 16000 Nm. Determine the maximum tensile stress and shearing stress in the wall. Given: d = 500 mm = 0Âˇ5 m; t = 20 mm = 0Âˇ02 m; p = 0Âˇ60 MPa = 0.6 MN/m2; M = 64000 Nm = 0Âˇ064 MNm; T= 16000 Nm = 0Âˇ016 MNm. Maximum tensile stress: First let us determine the principle stresses V 1 and V 2 assuming this as a thin cylinder.

and

V2

pd 0.6 u 0.5 7.5MN / m2 2t 2 u 0.02 0.6 u 0.5 3.75MN / m2 4 u 0.02

V1

We know,

pd 4t

Next consider effect of combined bending moment and torque on the walls of the cylinder. Then the principal stresses V '1 and V '2 are given by

Page 110 of 429

Chapter-2

Principal Stress and Strain

V '1 and

V '2

?

V '1

and

V '2

16 Âª M  M2  T 2 Âº 3 Â¬ Â¼ Sd 16 Âª M  M2  T 2 Âº Â¼ S d3 Â¬ 16 Âª0.064  0.0642  0.0162 Âº 3 Â¬ Â¼ S u 0.5

16

S u 0.5

3

Âª0.064  0.0642  0.0162 Âº Â¬ Â¼

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

5.29MN / m2

0.08MN / m2

Maximum shearing stress,W max : We Know, W max

V II ?

W max

V I  V II 2

V 2  V '2

3.75  0.08

12.79  3.67 2

3.67MN / m2 tensile

4.56MN / m2

Page 111 of 429

3.

Moment of Inertia and Centroid

Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) 3.1 Centre of gravity The centre of gravity of a body defined as the point through which the whole weight of a body may be assumed to act.

3.2 Centroid or Centre of area The centroid or centre of area is defined as the point where the whole area of the figure is assumed to be concentrated.

3.3 Moment of Inertia (MOI) x

About any point the product of the force and the perpendicular distance between them is known as moment of a force or first moment of force.

x

This first moment is again multiplied by the perpendicular distance between them to obtain second moment of force.

x

In the same way if we consider the area of the figure it is called second moment of area or area moment of inertia and if we consider the mass of a body it is called second moment of mass or mass moment of Inertia.

x

Mass moment of inertia is the measure of resistance of the body to rotation and forms the basis of dynamics of rigid bodies.

x

Area moment of Inertia is the measure of resistance to bending and forms the basis of strength of materials.

3.4 Mass moment of Inertia (MOI)

I

¦m r

2 i i

i

x

Notice that the moment of inertia ‘I’ depends on the distribution of mass in the system.

x

The furthest the mass is from the rotation axis, the bigger the moment of inertia.

x

For a given object, the moment of inertia depends on where we choose the rotation axis.

x

In rotational dynamics, the moment of inertia ‘I’ appears in the same way that mass m does Page 112 of 429

in linear dynamics.

Chapter-3 x

Moment of Inertia and Centroid

Solid disc or cylinder of mass M and radius R, about perpendicular axis through its

1 MR2 2

centre, I

x

Solid sphere of mass M and radius R, about an axis through its centre, I = 2/5 M R2

x

Thin rod of mass M and length L, about a perpendicular axis through its centre.

I x

1 ML2 12

Thin rod of mass M and length L, about a perpendicular axis through its end.

I

1 ML2 3

3.5 Area Moment of Inertia (MOI) or Second moment of area x

To find the centroid of an area by the first moment of the area about an axis was determined ( 혵 x dA )

x

Integral of the second moment of area is called moment of inertia (혵 x2dA)

x

Consider the area ( A )

x

By definition, the moment of inertia of the differential area about the x and y axes are dIxx and dIyy

x

dIxx = y2dA

Ixx = 혵 y2 dA

x

dIyy = x2dA

Iyy = 혵 x2 dA

3.6 Parallel axis theorem for an area The rotational inertia about any axis is the sum of second moment of inertia about a parallel axis through the C.G and total area of the body times square of the distance between the axes.

INN = ICG + Ah2

Page 113 of 429

Chapter-3

Moment of Inertia and Centroid

3.7 Perpendicular axis theorem for an area If x, y & z are mutually perpendicular axes as shown, then I zz J

I xx  I yy

Z-axis is perpendicular to the plane of x â&#x20AC;&#x201C; y and vertical to this page as shown in figure.

x

To find the moment of inertia of the differential area about the pole (point of origin) or z-axis,

(r) is used. (r) is the perpendicular distance from the pole to dA for the entire area J = Â&#x153; r2 dA = Â&#x153; (x2 + y2 )dA = Ixx + Iyy (since r2 = x2 + y2 ) Where, J = polar moment of inertia

3.8 Moments of Inertia (area) of some common area (i) MOI of Rectangular area Moment of inertia about axis XX which passes through centroid. Take an element of width â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;dyâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; at a distance y from XX axis.

? Area of the element (dA) = b u dy. and Moment of Inertia of the element about XX axis dA u y 2

?Total

b.y 2 .dy

MOI about XX axis (Note it is area

moment of Inertia) h

I xx

2

Âł

h

h

2

by dy 2

2

2 Âł by 2 dy 0

bh3 12

3

bh 12

I xx Similarly, we may find, I yy

hb3 12

?Polar moment of inertia (J) = Ixx + Iyy =

bh3 hb3  12 12

Page 114 of 429

Chapter-3

Moment of Inertia and Centroid

If we want to know the MOI about an axis NN passing through the bottom edge or top edge. Axis XX and NN are parallel and at a distance h/2. Therefore INN = Ixx + Area

u (distance) 2

bh3 Â§hÂˇ  buhuÂ¨ Â¸ 12 ÂŠ2Âš

2

bh3 3

Case-I: Square area

I xx

a4 12

Case-II: Square area with diagonal as axis

a4 12

I xx

Case-III:

Rectangular area with a centrally

rectangular hole Moment of inertia of the area = moment of inertia of BIG rectangle â&#x20AC;&#x201C; moment of inertia of SMALL rectangle

I xx

BH 3 bh3  12 12

Page 115 of 429

Chapter-3 Moment of Inertia and Centroid (ii) MOI of a Circular area The moment of inertia about axis XX this passes through the centroid. It is very easy to find polar moment of inertia about point ‘O’. Take an element of width ‘dr’ at a distance ‘r’ from centre. Therefore, the moment of inertia of this element about polar axis

d(J) = d(Ixx + Iyy ) = area of ring u (radius)2 2S rdr u r 2

or d(J)

Integrating both side we get R

J

S R4

3

³ 2S r dr

S D4

2 32 0 Due to summetry I xx I yy Therefore, I xx

I xx

J 2

I yy

64

S D4

I yy

Case-I:

S D4

64

and J

Moment of inertia of a circular

area with a concentric hole. Moment of inertia of the area = moment of inertia of BIG circle – moment of inertia of SMALL circle.

Ixx = Iyy =

S D4 64

S 64

Case-II:

S d4 64

( D4  d4 )

S

and J

32

( D4  d4 )

Moment of inertia of a semi-

circular area. I NN

1 of the momemt of total circular lamina 2 1 § S D4 · S D4 u¨ ¸ 2 © 64 ¹ 128

We

know

4r 3S

2D 3S

that

distance

of

CG

from

base

is

h say

i.e. distance of parallel axis XX and NN is (h)

? According to parallel axis theory

Page 116 of 429

S D4 32

Chapter-3

Moment of Inertia and Centroid I G  Area Ã&#x2014; distance

I NN or or

S D4

1 Â§ S D2 Â· 2 I xx  Â¨ Â¸ u h

2Â© 4 Â¹ 1 Â§ S D 2 Â· Â§ 2D Â· I xx  u Â¨ Â¸u 2 Â© 4 Â¹ Â¨Â© 3S Â¸Â¹

128

S D4 128

0.11R 4

I xx

or

2

Case â&#x20AC;&#x201C; III: Quarter circle area IXX = one half of the moment of Inertia of the Semicircular area about XX.

1 u 0.11R4 2

I XX

I XX

0.055 R4

0.055 R 4

INN = one half of the moment of Inertia of the Semicircular area about NN.

? I NN

1 S D4 u 2 64

S D4 128

(iii) Moment of Inertia of a Triangular area (a) Moment of Inertia of a Triangular area of a axis XX parallel to base and passes through C.G.

I XX

bh3 36

(b) Moment of inertia of a triangle about an axis passes through base

I NN

bh3 12

Page 117 of 429

Chapter-3 Moment of Inertia and Centroid (iv) Moment of inertia of a thin circular ring: Polar moment of Inertia

J

R2 u area of whole ring R 2 u 2S Rt 2S R 3 t

I XX

IYY

J 2

S R 3t

(v) Moment of inertia of a elliptical area

I XX

S ab3 4

Let us take an example: An I-section beam of 100 mm wide, 150 mm depth flange and web of thickness 20 mm is used in a structure of length 5 m. Determine the Moment of Inertia (of area) of cross-section of the beam. Answer: Carefully observe the figure below. It has sections with symmetry about the neutral axis.

We may use standard value for a rectangle about an axis passes through centroid. i.e. I

bh3 . 12

The section can thus be divided into convenient rectangles for each of which the neutral axis passes I Beam

the centroid.

I Re c tan gle - I Shaded area ª 0.100 u 0.150 3 0.40 u 0.1303 º 4 « »m -2 u 12 12 «¬ »¼ 1.183 u 10-4 m4

3.9 Radius of gyration Consider area A with moment of inertia Ixx. Imagine that the area is concentrated in a thin strip parallel to Page 118 of 429

Chapter-3

Moment of Inertia and Centroid

the x axis with equivalent Ixx.

kxx

2 kxx A or

I xx

I xx A

kxx =radius of gyration with respect to the x axis.

Similarly

I yy

2 kyy A or

ko2 A or

J

ko2

I yy

kyy

ko

A

J A

2 2 kxx  kyy

Let us take an example: Find radius of gyration for a circular area of diameter â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; about central axis.

We know that, I xx

2 K xx A

Page 119 of 429

Chapter-3

Moment of Inertia and Centroid Sd

or K XX

I XX A

4

64 S d2 4

d 4

Page 120 of 429

Chapter-3

Moment of Inertia and Centroid

OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Moment of Inertia (Second moment of an area) GATE-1.

The second moment of a circular area about the diameter is given by (D is the diameter) (a)

[GATE-2003]

S D4

(b)

4

S D4 16

(c)

S D4 32

(d)

S D4 64

GATE-1. Ans. (d)

GATE-2.

The area moment of inertia of a square of size 1 unit about its diagonal is: [GATE-2001] (a)

1 3

GATE-2. Ans. (c) I xx

(b)

a4 12

1

1 4

(c)

1 12

(d)

1 6

4

12

Radius of Gyration Data for Q3–Q4 are given below. Solve the problems and choose correct answers. A reel of mass “m” and radius of gyration “k” is rolling down smoothly from rest with one end of the thread wound on it held in the ceiling as depicted in the figure. Consider the thickness of the thread and its mass negligible in comparison with the radius “r” of the hub and the reel mass “m”. Symbol “g” represents the acceleration due to gravity. [GATE-2003]

Page 121 of 429

Chapter-3

GATE-3.

Moment of Inertia and Centroid

The linear acceleration of the reel is: gr 2 gk2 (a) 2 (b) r  k2 r 2  k2

(c)

grk

r

2

 k2

(d)

mgr 2

r

2

 k2

GATE-3. Ans. (a) For downward linear motion mg â&#x20AC;&#x201C; T = mf, where f = linear tangential acceleration = rÇ&#x201A;, Ç&#x201A; = rotational acceleration. Considering rotational motion Tr I D . or, T = mk2 u

GATE-4.

f gr 2 therefore mg â&#x20AC;&#x201C; T = mf gives f = r2 r 2  k2

The tension in the thread is: mgrk mgr 2 (a) 2 (b) 2 2 r  k2 r k

GATE-4. Ans. (c) T

mk2 u

f r2

mk2 u

gr 2

(c)

2

2

mgk

r r k

2

r

2

mgk2

r

2

k

2

(d)

mg

r

2

 k2

2

 k2

Previous 20-Years IES Questions Centroid IES-1.

Assertion (A): Inertia force always acts through the centroid of the body and is directed opposite to the acceleration of the centroid. [IES-2001] Reason (R): It has always a tendency to retard the motion. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IES-1. Ans. (c) It has always a tendency to oppose the motion not retard. If we want to retard a motion then it will wand to accelerate.

Page 122 of 429

Chapter-3

Moment of Inertia and Centroid

Figure shows a rigid body of mass m having radius of gyration k about its centre of gravity. It is to be replaced by an equivalent dynamical system of two masses placed at A and B. The mass at A should be: a um bum (a) (b) a b a b m a m b (d) (c) u u 3 b 2 a [IES-2003]

IES-2. Ans. (b) IES-3. Force required to accelerate a cylindrical body which rolls without slipping on a horizontal plane (mass of cylindrical body is m, radius of the cylindrical surface in contact with plane is r, radius of gyration of body is k and acceleration of the body is a) is: [IES-2001] 2 2 2 2 2 2 (b) mk / r .a (c) mk .a (a) m k / r  1 .a (d) mk / r  1 .a

IES-3. Ans. (a) IES-4. A body of mass m and radius of gyration k is to be replaced by two masses m1 and m2 located at distances h1 and h2 from the CG of the original body. An equivalent dynamic system will result, if [IES-2001] (a) h1  h2

k

2

(b) h1

 h22

k2

(c) h1h2

k2

(d)

h1h2

k2

IES-4. Ans. (c)

Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Radius of Gyration IAS-1.

A wheel of centroidal radius of gyration 'k' is rolling on a horizontal surface with constant velocity. It comes across an obstruction of height 'h' Because of its rolling speed, it just overcomes the obstruction. To determine v, one should use the principle (s) of conservation of [IAS 1994] (a) Energy (b) Linear momentum (c) Energy and linear momentum (d) Energy and angular momentum IAS-1. Ans. (a)

Page 123 of 429

Chapter-3

Moment of Inertia and Centroid

When are I-sections preferred in engineering applications? Elaborate your answer. I-section has large section modulus. It will reduce the stresses induced in the material. Since I-section has the considerable area are far away from the natural so its section modulus increased.

Page 124 of 429

4.

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) 4.1 Shear Force and Bending Moment At first we try to understand what shear force is and what is bending moment? We will not introduce any other co-ordinate system. We use general co-ordinate axis as shown in the figure. This system will be followed in shear force and bending moment diagram and in deflection of beam. Here downward direction will be negative i.e. negative Y-axis. Therefore downward deflection of the

We use above Co-ordinate system

beam will be treated as negative.

Some books fix a co-ordinate axis as shown in the following figure. Here downward direction will be positive i.e. positive Y-axis. Therefore downward deflection of the beam will be treated as positive. As beam is generally deflected in downward directions and

this

co-ordinate

system

treats

downward

deflection is positive deflection. Consider a cantilever beam as shown subjected to external load ‘P’. If we imagine this beam to be cut by a section X-X, we see that the applied force tend to displace the left-hand portion of the beam relative to the right hand portion, which is fixed in the wall. This tendency is resisted by internal forces between the two parts of the beam. At the cut section a resistance shear force (Vx) and a bending moment (Mx) is induced. This resistance shear force and the bending moment at the cut section is shown in the left hand and right hand portion of the cut beam. Using the three equations of equilibrium

¦F

x

0 ,

¦F

y

We find that Vx

0 and

¦M

P and M x

i

0

P . x

In this chapter we want to show pictorially Page 125the of 429

Some books use above co-ordinate system

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondal’s

variation of shear force and bending moment in a beam as a function of ‘x' measured from one end of the beam.

Shear Force (V) ŋ equal in magnitude but opposite in direction to the algebraic sum (resultant) of the components in the direction perpendicular to the axis of the beam of all external loads and support reactions acting on either side of the section being considered. Bending Moment (M) equal in magnitude but opposite in direction to the algebraic sum of the moments about (the centroid of the cross section of the beam) the section of all external loads and support reactions acting on either side of the section being considered.

What are the benefits of drawing shear force and bending moment diagram? The benefits of drawing a variation of shear force and bending moment in a beam as a function of ‘x' measured from one end of the beam is that it becomes easier to determine the maximum absolute value of shear force and bending moment. The shear force and bending moment diagram gives a clear picture in our mind about the variation of SF and BM throughout the entire section of the beam. Further, the determination of value of bending moment as a function of ‘x' becomes very important so as to determine the value of deflection of beam subjected to a given loading where we will use the formula, EI

d 2y dx 2

Mx .

4.2 Notation and sign convention x Shear force (V) Positive Shear Force A shearing force having a downward direction to the right hand side of a section or upwards to the left hand of the section will be taken as ‘positive’. It is the usual sign conventions to be followed for the shear force. In some book followed totally opposite sign convention.

Page 126 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

downward

S K Mondal’s

The upward direction shearing

The

direction

force which is on the left hand

shearing force which is on the

of the section XX is positive

right hand of the section XX is

shear force.

positive shear force.

Negative Shear Force A shearing force having an upward direction to the right hand side of a section or downwards to the left hand of the section will be taken as ‘negative’.

The

x

downward

direction

The upward direction shearing

shearing force which is on the

force which is on the right

left hand of the section XX is

hand of the section XX is

negative shear force.

negative shear force.

Bending Moment (M) Positive Bending Moment A bending moment causing concavity upwards will be taken as ‘positive’ and called as sagging bending moment.

Page 127 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondal’s

Sagging If the bending moment of

If the bending moment of

A bending moment causing

the left hand of the section

the right hand of the

concavity upwards will be

XX is clockwise then it is a

section

positive bending moment.

clockwise then it is a

called as sagging bending

positive bending moment.

moment.

XX

is

anti-

taken

as

‘positive’

and

Negative Bending Moment

Hogging If the bending moment of

A bending moment causing

the

the right hand of the

convexity upwards will be

anti-

section XX is clockwise

taken as ‘negative’ and called

If the bending moment of the

left

section

hand XX

is

of

clockwise then it is a

then

positive bending moment.

bending moment.

it

is

a

positive

as hogging bending moment.

Way to remember sign convention

x

Remember in the Cantilever beam both Shear force and BM are negative (–ive).

4.3 Relation between S.F (Vx), B.M. (Mx) & Load (w) x

dVx = -w (load) The value of the distributed load at any point in the beam is dx equal to the slope of the shear force curve. (Note that the sign of this rule may change depending on the sign convention used for the external distributed load).

x

dM x = Vx The value of the shear force at any point in the beam is equal to the slope dx of the bending moment curve.

Page 128 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondal’s

4.4 Procedure for drawing shear force and bending moment diagram Construction of shear force diagram x

x

First determine the reactions.

x

Then the vertical components of forces and reactions are successively summed from the left end of the beam to preserve the mathematical sign conventions adopted. The shear at a section is simply equal to the sum of all the vertical forces to the left of the section.

x

The shear force curve is continuous unless there is a point force on the beam. The curve then “jumps” by the magnitude of the point force (+ for upward force).

x

When the successive summation process is used, the shear force diagram should end up with the previously calculated shear (reaction at right end of the beam). No shear force acts through the beam just beyond the last vertical force or reaction. If the shear force diagram closes in this fashion, then it gives an important check on mathematical calculations. i.e. The shear force will be zero at each end of the beam unless a point force is applied at the end.

Construction of bending moment diagram

x

The bending moment diagram is obtained by proceeding continuously along the length of beam from the left hand end and summing up the areas of shear force diagrams using proper sign convention.

x

The process of obtaining the moment diagram from the shear force diagram by summation is exactly the same as that for drawing shear force diagram from load diagram.

x

The bending moment curve is continuous unless there is a point moment on the beam. The curve then “jumps” by the magnitude of the point moment (+ for CW moment).

x

We know that a constant shear force produces a uniform change in the bending moment, resulting in straight line in the moment diagram. If no shear force exists along a certain portion of a beam, then it indicates that there is no change in moment takes place. We also know that dM/dx= Vx therefore, from the fundamental theorem of calculus the maximum or minimum moment occurs where the shear is zero.

x

The bending moment will be zero at each free or pinned end of the beam. If the end is built in, the moment computed by the summation must be equal to the one calculated initially for the reaction.

4.5 Different types of Loading and their S.F & B.M Diagram (i) A Cantilever beam with a concentrated load ‘P’ at its free end.

Page 129 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Shear force: At a section a distance x from free end consider the forces to the left, then (Vx) = - P (for all values of x) negative in sign i.e. the shear force to the left of the x-section are in downward direction and therefore negative.

Bending Moment: Taking moments about the section gives (obviously to the left of the section)

Mx = -P.x (negative sign means that the

S.F and B.M diagram

moment on the left hand side of the portion is in the anticlockwise direction and is therefore taken as negative according to the sign convention) so that the maximum bending moment occurs at the fixed end i.e. Mmax = - PL (at x = L)

(ii) A Cantilever beam with uniformly distributed load over the whole length When a cantilever beam is subjected to a uniformly distributed load whose intensity is given w /unit length.

Shear force: Consider any cross-section XX which is at a distance of x from the free end. If we just take the resultant of all the forces on the left of the X-section, then

Vx = -w.x

for all values of â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;x'.

At x = 0, Vx = 0 At x = L, Vx = -wL (i.e. Maximum at fixed end) Plotting the equation Vx = -w.x, we get a straight line because it is a equation of a straight line y (Vx) = m(- w) .x

Bending Moment: Bending Moment at XX is obtained by treating the load to the left of XX as a concentrated load of the same value (w.x)

S.F and B.M diagram

acting through the centre of gravity at x/2. Therefore, the bending moment at any cross-section XX is

Mx

w .x .

x 2



w .x 2 2

Therefore the variation of bending moment is according to parabolic law. The extreme values of B.M would be at x = 0,

Mx = 0

and x = L, Mx = 

wL2 2

Page 130 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

Maximum bending moment,

Mmax

wL2 2

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

at fixed end

Another way to describe a cantilever beam with uniformly distributed load (UDL) over itâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s whole length.

(iii) A Cantilever beam loaded as shown below draw its S.F and B.M diagram

In the region 0 < x < a Following the same rule as followed previously, we get

Vx =- P; and Mx = - P.x In the region a < x < L

Vx =- P +P=0; and Mx = - P.x +P x  a P.a

S.F and B.M diagram

(iv) Let us take an example: Consider a cantilever bean of 5 m length. It carries a uniformly distributed load 3 KN/m and a concentrated load of 7 kN at the free end and 10 kN at 3 meters from the fixed end.

Draw SF and BM diagram.

Page 131 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

Answer: In the region 0 < x < 2 m Consider any cross section XX at a distance x from free end. Shear force (Vx) = -7- 3x So, the variation of shear force is linear. at x = 0,

Vx = -7 kN

at x = 2 m , Vx = -7 - 3 u 2 = -13 kN at point Z

Vx = -7 -3 u 2-10 = -23 kN

Bending moment (Mx) = -7x - (3x).

x 2



3x 2  7x 2

So, the variation of bending force is parabolic. at x = 0,

Mx = 0

at x = 2 m,

Mx = -7 u 2 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (3 u 2) u

2 = - 20 kNm 2

In the region 2 m < x < 5 m Consider any cross section YY at a distance x from free end Shear force (Vx) = -7 - 3x â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 10 = -17- 3x So, the variation of shear force is linear. at x = 2 m, Vx = - 23 kN at x = 5 m, Vx = - 32 kN

Â§xÂˇ Â¸ - 10 (x - 2) ÂŠ2Âš

Bending moment (Mx) = - 7x â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (3x) u Â¨

3  x 2  17 x  20 2 So, the variation of bending force is parabolic. at x = 2 m, Mx

3  u 22  17 u 2  20 = - 20 kNm 2

at x = 5 m, Mx = - 102.5 kNm

Page 132 of 429

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Chapter-4

(v)

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondal’s

A Cantilever beam carrying uniformly varying load from zero at free end and w/unit length at the fixed end

Consider any cross-section XX which is at a distance of x from the free end. At this point load (wx) =

w .x L L

L

³ w x dx

³ L .xdx =

0

Shear force Vx

w

0

wL 2

1 §w · wx 2  . ¨ x ¸ .x  2 ©L ¹ 2L ? The shear force variation is parabolic. at x = 0, Vx 0 at x = L, Vx



WL i.e. Maximum Shear force (Vmax ) 2

Page 133 of 429

 WL at fixed end 2

Chapter-4 Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram Bending moment Mx load u distance from centroid of triangle ABC

S K Mondal’s

wx 2 § 2x · wx 3 .¨ ¸  2L © 3 ¹ 6L ? The bending moment variation is cubic. at x= 0, Mx 0 

at x = L,

Mx

wL2 i.e. Maximum Bending moment (Mmax ) 6



Integration method

d Vx

Alternative way : We know that

dx

L

or d(Vx )



w .x .dx L

Integrating both side Vx

x

³ d Vx

0

or Vx



³ 0

w . x .dx L

w x2 . L 2

Again we know that d Mx

Vx

dx or

d Mx

-

-

wx 2 2L

wx 2 dx 2L

Page 134 of 429

wL2 at fixed end. 6

Chapter-4 Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram Integrating both side we get at x=0,Mx =0

Mx

Âł

x

d(Mx )

0

or Mx

Âł 0

-

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

wx 2 .dx 2L

w x3 Ă&#x2014; 2L 3

-

wx 3 6L

(vi) A Cantilever beam carrying gradually varying load from zero at fixed end and w/unit length at the free end

Considering equilibrium we get, MA

wL2 and Reaction R A

3

wL 2

Considering any cross-section XX which is at a distance of x from the fixed end. At this point load (Wx )

Shear force Vx

W .x L

RA  area of triangle ANM

wL 1 Â§ w Âˇ wL wx 2 - . Â¨ .x Â¸ .x = + 2 2 ÂŠL Âš 2 2L ? The shear force variation is parabolic. wL at x 0, Vx  i.e. Maximum shear force, Vmax 2 at x L, Vx 0 Bending moment Mx =R A .x -



wL 2

wx 2 2x . - MA 2L 3

wL wx 3 wL2 .x 2 6L 3 ? The bending moment variation is cubic =

at x = 0, Mx



at x

0

L, Mx

wL2 i.e.Maximum B.M. Mmax

3

Page 135 of 429



wL2 . 3

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondal’s

(vii) A Cantilever beam carrying a moment M at free end

Consider any cross-section XX which is at a distance of x from the free end.

Shear force: Vx = 0 at any point. Bending moment (Mx) = -M at any point, i.e. Bending moment is constant throughout the length.

(viii) A Simply supported beam with a concentrated load ‘P’ at its mid span.

Considering equilibrium we get, R A = RB =

P 2

Now consider any cross-section XX which is at a distance of x from left end A and section YY at a distance from left end A, as shown in figure below.

Page 136 of 429

Shear force: In the region 0 < x < L/2

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondal’s

Vx = RA = + P/2 (it is constant)

In the region L/2 < x < L Vx = RA – P =

P - P = - P/2 2

(it is constant)

Bending moment: In the region 0 < x < L/2 Mx =

P .x 2

(its variation is linear)

at x = 0, Mx = 0

and at x = L/2 Mx =

Maximum bending moment,

PL i.e. maximum 4

PL 4

Mmax

at x = L/2 (at mid-point)

In the region L/2 < x < L Mx =

PL P P  .x (its variation is linear) .x – P(x - L/2) = 2 2 2

at x = L/2 , Mx =

PL 4

and at x = L,

Mx = 0

(ix) A Simply supported beam with a concentrated load ‘P’ is not at its mid span.

Considering equilibrium we get, RA =

Pb Pa and RB = L L

Now consider any cross-section XX which is at a distance x from left end A and another section YY at a distance x from end A as shownPage in figure below. 137 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondal’s

Shear force: In the range 0 < x < a Vx = RA = +

Pb L

(it is constant)

In the range a < x < L Vx = RA - P = -

Pa L

(it is constant)

Bending moment: In the range 0 < x < a Mx = +RA.x =

Pb .x L

at x = 0, Mx = 0

(it is variation is linear)

and at x = a, Mx =

Pab L

(i.e. maximum)

In the range a < x < L Mx = RA.x – P(x- a) =

Pb .x – P.x + Pa (Put b = L - a) L

= Pa (1 - Pa ¨ 1  at x = a, Mx =

x· ) L ¸¹

Pab L

and at x = L, Mx = 0

(x) A Simply supported beam with two concentrated load ‘P’ from a distance ‘a’ both end. The loading is shown below diagram

Page 138 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Take a section at a distance x from the left support. This section is applicable for any value of x just to the left of the applied force P. The shear, remains constant and is +P. The bending moment varies linearly from the support, reaching a maximum of +Pa. A section applicable anywhere between the two applied forces. Shear force is not necessary to maintain equilibrium of a segment in this part of the beam. Only a constant bending moment of +Pa must be resisted by the beam in this zone. Such a state of bending or flexure is called pure bending. Shear and bending-moment diagrams for this loading condition are shown below.

(xi) A Simply supported beam with a uniformly distributed load (UDL) through out its length

We will solve this problem by following two alternative ways.

(a) By Method of Section Considering equilibrium we get RA = RB =

wL 2

Now Consider any cross-section XX which is at a distance x from left end A.

Page 139 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

Then the section view

Shear force: Vx =

wL  wx 2

(i.e. S.F. variation is linear) Vx =

at x = 0,

wL 2

at x = L/2, Vx = 0 Vx = -

at x = L,

wL 2

wL wx 2 .x  2 2

Bending moment: M x

(i.e. B.M. variation is parabolic) at x = 0, Mx = 0 at x = L, Mx = 0 Now we have to determine maximum bending moment and its position.

For maximum B.M:

d Mx

dx or

0 i .e. Vx

wL  wx 2

0 or

Therefore, maximum bending moment,

0

x

ª d M x

« dx ¬

L 2

Mmax

wL2 8

(a) By Method of Integration Shear force: We know that,

or

d Vx

dx

d Vx

w

wdx

Integrating both side we get (at x =0, Vx =

º Vx » ¼

wL ) 2

Page 140 of 429

at x = L/2

S K Mondal’s

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

Vx

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

x

Â³ d V

 Â³ wdx

x

wL  2

or Vx  or Vx

0

wL wx 2 wL  wx 2

Bending moment: We know that,

d Mx

dx

Vx

d M x Vx dx

or

Â§ wL Â· Â¨ 2  wx Â¸ dx Â© Â¹

Integrating both side we get (at x =0, Vx =0) Mx

Â³

x

d Mx

o

or M x

Â§ wL Â·  wx Â¸ dx 2 Â¹ 0

wL wx 2 .x  2 2

Let us take an example: A loaded beam as shown below. Draw its S.F and B.M diagram.

Considering equilibrium we get

Â¦M

A

0 gives

- 200 u 4 u 2  3000 u 4  RB u 8 or

RB

1700N

And R A  RB or

RA

0

200 u 4  3000

2100N

Now consider any cross-section XX which is at a distance 'x' from left end A and as shown in figure

Page 141 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

In the region 0 < x < 4m Shear force (Vx) = RA – 200x = 2100 – 200 x

§x· 2 ¸ = 2100 x -100 x ©2¹

Bending moment (Mx) = RA .x – 200 x . ¨ at x = 0, at x = 4m,

Vx = 2100 N, Vx = 1300 N,

Mx = 0 Mx = 6800 N.m

In the region 4 m < x < 8 m Shear force (Vx) = RA - 200 u 4 – 3000 = -1700 Bending moment (Mx) = RA. x - 200 u 4 (x-2) – 3000 (x- 4) = 2100 x – 800 x + 1600 – 3000x +12000 = 13600 -1700 x at x = 4 m,

Vx = -1700 N,

at x = 8 m,

Vx = -1700 N,

Mx = 6800 Nm Mx = 0

Page 142 of 429

S K Mondal’s

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondal’s

(xii) A Simply supported beam with a gradually varying load (GVL) zero at one end and w/unit length at other span.

Consider equilibrium of the beam =

¦M

B

R A .L or R A

1 wL acting at a point C at a distance 2L/3 to the left end A. 2

0 gives wL L . 2 3 wL 6

Similarly

0

¦M

A

0 gives RB

wL 3

The free body diagram of section A - XX as shown below, Load at section XX, (wx) =

Page 143 of 429

w x L

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

The resulted of that part of the distributed load which acts on this free body is applied at a point Z, distance x/3 from XX section.

Shear force (Vx) = R A -

wx 2 2L

wL wx 2 6 2L

Therefore the variation of shear force is parabolic

wL 6

at x = 0,

Vx =

at x = L,

Vx = -

wL 3 wL wx 2 x .x  . 6 2L 3

and Bending Moment (Mx )

wL wx 3 .x  6 6L

The variation of BM is cubic at x = 0, Mx = 0 at x = L, Mx = 0 For maximum BM;

or

wL wx 2 6 2L

and Mmax

i.e.

d Mx

0

dx

0 or x

i.e. Vx

L 3

wL § L · w § L · u¨ u¨ ¸ ¸ 6 © 3 ¹ 6L © 3 ¹

Mmax

ª d Mx

« dx ¬

0

3

wL2 9 3

wL2 at x

9 3 Page 144 of 429

L 3

º Vx » ¼

S K Mondal’s

1 w x . x 2 L

wx 2 2L

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondal’s

(xiii) A Simply supported beam with a gradually varying load (GVL) zero at each end and w/unit length at mid span.

Consider equilibrium of the beam AB total load on the beam

Therefore R A

RB

§1 L · 2u¨ u u w¸ ©2 2 ¹

wL 4

The free body diagram of section A –XX as shown below, load at section XX (wx)

The resultant of that part of the distributed load which acts on this free body is applied at a point, distance x/3 from section XX.

Shear force (Vx):

wL 2

Page 145 of 429

2w .x L

1 2w .x. .x 2 L

wx 2 L

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

In the region 0 < x < L/2

Vx

RA 

wx 2 L

wL wx 2  4 L

Therefore the variation of shear force is parabolic.

wL 4

at x = 0,

Vx =

at x = L/4,

Vx = 0

In the region of L/2 < x < L The Diagram will be Mirror image of AC.

Bending moment (Mx): In the region 0 < x < L/2

wL § 1 2wx · .x  ¨ .x. . x / 3

Mx

wL wx 3 4 3L

The variation of BM is cubic at x = 0,

Mx = 0

at x = L/2, Mx =

wL2 12

In the region L/2 < x < L BM diagram will be mirror image of AC.

For maximum bending moment

d Mx

dx

or

0

wL wx 2 4 L

and Mmax

i.e.

i.e. Vx

ª d Mx

« dx ¬

0

0 or x

º Vx » ¼

L 2

wL2 12

Mmax

wL2 12

at x

Page 146 of 429

L 2

S K Mondal’s

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

(xiv) A Simply supported beam with a gradually varying load (GVL) zero at mid span and w/unit length at each end.

We now superimpose two beams as (1) Simply supported beam with a UDL through at its length

Vx 1 Mx 1

wL  wx 2 wL wx 2 .x  2 2

And (2) a simply supported beam with a gradually varying load (GVL) zero at each end and w/unit length at mind span. In the range 0 < x < L/2

Vx 2 Mx 2

wL wx 2  4 L wL wx 3 .x  4 3L

Now superimposing we get

Shear force (Vx): In the region of 0< x < L/2 Page 147 of 429

Chapter-4

Vx

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram Â§ wL wx 2 Â· wL Vx 1  Vx 2 Â§Â¨ -wx Â·Â¸  Â¨ Â¸ L Â¹ Â© 2 Â¹ Â© 4

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

w 2 x - L/2

L Therefore the variation of shear force is parabolic at x = 0,

Vx = +

at x = L/2,

Vx = 0

wL 4

In the region L/2 < x < L The diagram will be mirror image of AC

Bending moment (Mx) = Mx 1 - Mx 2 =

Â§ wL wx 2 Â· Â§ wL wx 3 Â· .x .x    Â¨ Â¸ Â¨ Â¸ 2 Â¹ Â© 4 3L Â¹ Â© 2

wx 3 wx 2 wL .x   3L 2 4

The variation of BM is cubic

at x

0, Mx

0

at x

L / 2, Mx

wx 2 24

(xv) A simply supported beam with a gradually varying load (GVL) w1/unit length at one end and w2/unit length at other end.

Page 148 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

At first we will treat this problem by considering a UDL of identifying (w1)/unit length over the whole length and a varying load of zero at one end to (w2- w1)/unit length at the other end. Then superimpose the two loadings.

Consider a section XX at a distance x from left end A (i) Simply supported beam with UDL (w1) over whole length

Vx 1 Mx 1

w1L  w1x 2 w1L 1 .x  w1x 2 2 2

And (ii) simply supported beam with (GVL) zero at one end (w2- w1) at other end gives

Vx 2

w 2  w1  w 2  w1 x 2 6

M x 2 w 2  w 1 .

L .x  6

2L w 2  w1 x 3 6L

Now superimposing we get

Shear force Vx

Vx 1 + Vx 2

w1L w 2L x2 +  w 1x  w 2  w1

3 6 2L

? The SF variation is parabolic at x

0, Vx

at x L,

Vx

Bending moment Mx

w1L w 2L L  2w1  w 2

3 6 6 L  w1  2w 2

6

Mx 1  Mx 2

w1L wL 1 Â§ w -w Âˇ .x  1 .x  w1x 2  Â¨ 2 1 Â¸ .x 3 3 6 2 ÂŠ 6L Âš

?The BM variation is cubic.

at x

0,

Mx

0

at x

L,

Mx

0

Page 149 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

(xvi) A Simply supported beam carrying a continuously distributed load. The intensity of the load at any point is, w x

Â§Sx Â· w sin Â¨ Â¸ . Where â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;xâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; is the distance from each end of Â© L Â¹

the beam.

We will use Integration method as it is easier in this case. We know that

Therefore

d Vx

dx

d Vx

dx d Vx

and

d Mx

dx

Vx

Â§Sx Â· w sin Â¨ Â¸ Â© L Â¹ Â§Sx Â· w sin Â¨ Â¸ dx Â© L Â¹

Integrating both side we get

Â³ d V

x

Â§Sx Â·  w Â³ sin Â¨ Â¸ dx Â© L Â¹

or

Vx

Â§SxÂ· w cos Â¨ Â¸ Â© L Â¹ A 

S

L

> where, A

constant of Integration@

Page 150 of 429



Â§SxÂ· cos Â¨ Â¸A S Â© L Â¹

wL

Chapter-4 Again we know that d Mx

dx

Vx

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

or

d Mx

Vx dx

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Â­ wL Â½ Â§Sx Â· cos Â¨  A Â¾ dx Â® Â¸ Â© L Â¹ Â¯S Â¿

Integrating both side we get

Â§Sx Â· sin Â¨ Â¸ S Â© L Â¹  Ax + B

wL Mx

wL2

S

S2

Â§Sx Â· sin Â¨ Â¸  Ax + B Â© L Â¹

L [Where B = constant of Integration] Now apply boundary conditions At x = 0,

Mx = 0

and

at x = L,

Mx = 0

This gives A = 0 and B = 0

Â§Sx Â· cos Â¨ Â¸ S Â© L Â¹ wL2 Â§Sx Â· sin Â¨ Â¸ 2 S Â© L Â¹

? Shear force Vx

And Mx

?

Mmax

wL2

S2

wL

and

Vmax

wL

S

at x

0

at x = L/2

(xvii) A Simply supported beam with a couple or moment at a distance â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;aâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; from left end.

Considering equilibrium we get Page 151 of 429

Chapter-4

¦M

A

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram 0 gives

RB ×L +M 0 or RB and

¦M

B



S K Mondal’s

M L

0 gives M L

 R A ×L +M 0 or R A

Now consider any cross-section XX which is at a distance ‘x’ from left end A and another section YY at a distance ‘x’ from left end A as shown in figure.

In the region 0 < x < a Shear force (Vx) = RA =

M L

Bending moment (Mx) = RA.x =

M .x L

In the region a< x < L Shear force (Vx) = RA =

M L

Bending moment (Mx) = RA.x – M =

M .x - M L

Page 152 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

(xviii) A Simply supported beam with an eccentric load

When the beam is subjected to an eccentric load, the eccentric load is to be changed into a couple = Force u (distance travel by force) = P.a (in this case) and a force = P Therefore equivalent load diagram will be

Considering equilibrium

ÂŚM

A

0 gives

-P.(L/2) + P.a + RB u L = 0 or RB =

P P.a  2 L

and RA + RB = P gives RA =

P P.a  2 L

Now consider any cross-section XX which is at a distance â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;xâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; from left end A and another section YY at a distance â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;xâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; from left end A as shown in figure.

Page 153 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

In the region 0 < x < L/2 Shear force (Vx) =

P P.a  2 L Â§ P Pa Âˇ  Â¸.x ÂŠ2 L Âš

Bending moment (Mx) = RA . x = Â¨

In the region L/2 < x < L Shear force (Vx) =

P Pa  P 2 L

=-

P Pa  2 L

Bending moment (Vx) = RA . x â&#x20AC;&#x201C; P.( x - L/2 ) â&#x20AC;&#x201C; M =

PL Â§ P Pa Âˇ .x - Pa   2 Â¨ÂŠ 2 L Â¸Âš

4.6 Bending Moment diagram of Statically Indeterminate beam Beams for which reaction forces and internal forces cannot be found out from static equilibrium equations alone are called statically indeterminate beam. This type of beam requires deformation equation in addition to static equilibrium equations to solve for unknown forces.

Statically determinate - Equilibrium conditions sufficient to compute reactions. Statically indeterminate - Deflections (Compatibility conditions) along with equilibrium equations should be used to find out reactions. Page 154 of 429

Chapter-4 Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Type of Loading & B.M Diagram Reaction Bending Moment

R A= R B =

RA = RB =

P 2

wL 2

wL2 M =M = 12 A

B

RA

Pab 2 L2

RB

Pa 2 (3b  a) L3

MB = - 

Pa 2b L2

3wL 16

5wL 8

RB

+ -

B

MA = - 

Rc =

-

A

Pb 2 (3a  b) L3

R A= R B =

RA

PL M =M = 8

Page 155 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

4.7 Load and Bending Moment diagram from Shear Force diagram OR Load and Shear Force diagram from Bending Moment diagram If S.F. Diagram for a beam is given, then (i)

If S.F. diagram consists of rectangle then the load will be point load

(ii)

If S.F diagram consists of inclined line then the load will be UDL on that portion

(iii)

If S.F diagram consists of parabolic curve then the load will be GVL

(iv)

If S.F diagram consists of cubic curve then the load distribute is parabolic. After finding load diagram we can draw B.M diagram easily.

If B.M Diagram for a beam is given, then (i)

If B.M diagram consists of inclined line then the load will be free point load

(ii)

If B.M diagram consists of parabolic curve then the load will be U.D.L.

(iii)

If B.M diagram consists of cubic curve then the load will be G.V.L.

(iv)

If B.M diagram consists of fourth degree polynomial then the load distribution is parabolic.

Let us take an example: Following is the S.F diagram of a beam is given. Find its loading diagram.

Answer: From A-E inclined straight line so load will be UDL and in AB = 2 m length load = 6 kN if UDL is w N/m then w.x = 6 or w u 2 = 6 or w = 3 kN/m after that S.F is constant so no force is there. At last a 6 kN for vertical force complete the diagram then the load diagram will be

As there is no support at left end it must be a cantilever beam. Page 156 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondal’s

4.8 Point of Contraflexure In a beam if the bending moment changes sign at a point, the point itself having zero bending moment, the beam changes curvature at this point of zero bending moment and this point is called the point of contra flexure. Consider a loaded beam as shown below along with the B.M diagrams and deflection diagram.

In this diagram we noticed that for the beam loaded as in this case, the bending moment diagram is partly positive and partly negative. In the deflected shape of the beam just below the bending moment diagram shows that left hand side of the beam is ‘sagging' while the right hand side of the beam is ‘hogging’. The point C on the beam where the curvature changes from sagging to hogging is a point of contraflexure.

x

There can be more than one point of contraflexure in a beam.

4.9 General expression x

d4y EI dx 2

Z

x

EI

d3y dx3

Vx

x

d2y EI 2 dx

Mx Page 157 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram x

dy = Č&#x2122; = slope dx

x

y= G = Deflection

x

Flexural rigidity = EI

Page 158 of 429

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondal’s

OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Shear Force (S.F.) and Bending Moment (B.M.) GATE-1.

A concentrated force, F is applied (perpendicular to the plane of the figure) on the tip of the bent bar shown in Figure. The equivalent load at a section close to the fixed end is: (a) Force F (b) Force F and bending moment FL (c) Force F and twisting moment FL (d) Force F bending moment F L, and twisting moment FL [GATE-1999]

GATE-1. Ans. (c) GATE-2.

The shear force in a beam subjected to pure positive bending is…… (positive/zero/negative) [GATE-1995] GATE-2. Ans. Zero

Cantilever GATE-3.

Two identical cantilever beams are supported as shown, with their free ends in contact through a rigid roller. After the load P is applied, the free ends will have [GATE-2005]

(a) (b) (c) (d)

Equal deflections but not equal slopes Equal slopes but not equal deflections Equal slopes as well as equal deflections Neither equal slopes nor equal deflections

GATE-3. Ans. (a) As it is rigid roller, deflection must be same, because after deflection they also will be in contact. But slope unequal. GATE-4.

A beam is made up of two identical bars AB and BC, by hinging them together at B. The end A is built-in (cantilevered) and the end C is simplysupported. With the load P acting as shown, the bending moment at A is: [GATE-2005] Page 159 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram (a) Zero

(b)

PL 2

(c)

3PL 2

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s (d) Indeterminate

GATE-4. Ans. (b)

Cantilever with Uniformly Distributed Load GATE-5.

The shapes of the bending moment diagram for a uniform cantilever beam carrying a uniformly distributed load over its length is: [GATE-2001] (a) A straight line (b) A hyperbola (c) An ellipse (d) A parabola GATE-5. Ans. (d)

Cantilever Carrying load Whose Intensity varies GATE-6.

A cantilever beam carries the antisymmetric load shown, where Ç&#x161;o is the peak intensity of the distributed load. Qualitatively, the correct bending moment diagram for this beam is:

[GATE-2005]

GATE-6. Ans. (d)

Page 160 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

Mx

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

wx 2 wx 3  2 6L

Simply Supported Beam Carrying Concentrated Load GATE-7.

A concentrated load of P acts on a simply supported beam of span L at a distance

L from the left support. The bending moment at the point of 3

application of the load is given by

PL (a) 3

2 PL (b) 3

[GATE-2003]

PL (c ) 9

2 PL (d ) 9

GATE-7. Ans. (d) Mc

GATE-8.

Pab l

Â§ L Âˇ Â§ 2L Âˇ PuÂ¨ Â¸uÂ¨ Â¸ ÂŠ3Âš ÂŠ 3 Âš L

2PL 9

A simply supported beam carries a load 'P' through a bracket, as shown in Figure. The maximum bending moment in the beam is (a) PI/2 (b) PI/2 + aP/2 (c) PI/2 + aP (d) PI/2 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; aP [GATE-2000]

GATE-8. Ans. (c) Taking moment about Ra P u l  Pa  Rbl 0 2 P a P a or Rb P ?Ra P 2 l 2 l Maximum bending moment will be at centre â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Câ&#x20AC;&#x2122; l l Pl ?Mc Ra u  P u a  Rb u  Pa or Mmax 2 2 2

Beam

Carrying

a

Uniformly

Statement for Linked Answer and Questions Q9-Q10: A mass less beam has a loading pattern as shown in the figure. The beam is of rectangular Page 161 of 429 cross-section with a width of 30 mm and height of 100 mm. [GATE-2010]

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

The maximum bending moment occurs at (a) Location B (c) 2500 mm to the right of A GATE-9. Ans. (C)

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

GATE-9.

(b) 2675 mm to the right of A (d) 3225 mm to the right of A

3000 N/m

R1 R1  R 2

R2 3000 u 2

R1 u 4  3000 u 2 u 1 R1

6000N 0

1500,

S.F. eqn . at any section x from end A. R1  3000 u x  2

x

^for

0

x ! 2m}

2.5 m.

GATE-10. The maximum magnitude of bending stress (in MPa) is given by (a) 60.0 (b) 67.5 (c) 200.0 (d) 225.0 GATE-10. Ans. (b) Binding stress will be maximum at the outer surface So taking 9 = 50 mm

ld 3 12

m u 50 3 ld 12 x2 m x 1.5 u 103 [2000  x]  2 6 ? m2500 3.375 u10 N  mm and I

?V

& V

3.375 u 106 u 50 u 12 30 u 1003

67.5 MPa

Data for Q11-Q12 are given below. Solve the problems and choose correct answers A steel beam of breadth 120 mm and height 750 mm is loaded as shown in the figure. Assume Esteel= 200 GPa.

[GATE-2004] GATE-11. The beam is subjected to a maximum bending moment of (a) 3375 kNm (b) 4750 kNm (c) 6750 kNm Page 162 of 429

(d) 8750 kNm

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram 2

GATE-11. Ans. (a) Mmax

wl 8

120 u 15 kNm 8

3375kNm

GATE-12. The value of maximum deflection of the beam is: (a) 93.75 mm (b) 83.75 mm (c) 73.75 mm 3

5 wl4 384 EI

0.12 u 0.75

(d) 63.75 mm

3

bh 4.22 u 103 m4 12 12 5 120 u 103 u 154 u m 93.75mm 384 200 u 109 u 4.22 u 103

GATE-12. Ans. (a) Moment of inertia (I) =

G max

S K Mondal’s

2

Statement for Linked Answer and Questions Q13-Q14: A simply supported beam of span length 6m and 75mm diameter carries a uniformly distributed load of 1.5 kN/m [GATE-2006] GATE-13. What is the maximum value of bending moment? (a) 9 kNm (b) 13.5 kNm (c) 81 kNm (d) 125 kNm 2 2 wl 1.5 u 6 6.75kNm But not in choice. Nearest choice (a) GATE-13. Ans. (a) Mmax 8 8 GATE-14. What is the maximum value of bending stress? (a) 162.98 MPa (b) 325.95 MPa (c) 625.95 Mpa 3 32M 32 u 6.75 u 10 GATE-14. Ans. (a) V Pa 162.98MPa 2 S d3 S u 0.075

(d) 651.90 Mpa

Simply Supported Beam Carrying a Load whose Intensity varies Uniformly from Zero at each End to w per Unit Run at the MiD Span GATE-15. A simply supported beam is subjected to a distributed loading as shown in the diagram given below: What is the maximum shear force in the beam? (a) WL/3 (b) WL/2 (c) WL/3 (d) WL/6 [IES-2004] 1 WL uL u W Total load 2 2 § · ¸ WL Wx 2 WL 1 ¨ W  x. ¨ u X ¸  Sx 4 2 ¨ L 4 L ¸ ¨ ¸ © 2 ¹ WL Smax at x 0 4

GATE-15. Ans. (d)

GATE-16. A simply supported beam of length 'l' is subjected to a symmetrical uniformly varying load with zero intensity at the ends and intensity w (load per unit length) at the mid span. What is the maximum bending moment? [IAS-2004] Page 163 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram (a)

3wl 8

2

2

(b)

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

2

wl 12

(c)

wl 24

(d)

5wl 2 12

GATE-16. Ans. (b)

Previous 20-Years IES Questions Shear Force (S.F.) and Bending Moment (B.M.) IES-1.

A lever is supported on two hinges at A and C. It carries a force of 3 kN as shown in the above figure. The bending moment at B will be (a) 3 kN-m (b) 2 kN-m (c) 1 kN-m (d) Zero

[IES-1998] IES-1. Ans. (a) IES-2.

A beam subjected to a load P is shown in the given figure. The bending moment at the support AA of the beam will be (a) PL (b) PL/2 (c) 2PL (d) zero

[IES-1997] IES-2. Ans. (b) Load P at end produces moment

PL in 2

anticlockwise direction. Load P at end produces moment of PL in clockwise direction. Net moment at AA is PL/2.

IES-3.

The bending moment (M) is constant over a length segment (I) of a beam. The shearing force will also be constant over this length and is given by [IES-1996] (a) M/l (b) M/2l (c) M/4l (d) None of the above IES-3. Ans. (d) Dimensional analysis gives choice (d) IES-4.

A rectangular section beam subjected to a bending moment M varying along its length is required to develop same maximum bending stress at any crosssection. If the depth of the section is constant, then its width will vary as [IES-1995] (a) M

IES-4. Ans. (a) IES-5.

M I

(b)

M

(c) M2

(d) 1/M

3

const.

and

I

bh 12

Consider the following statements: [IES-1995] If at a section distant from one of the ends of the beam, M represents the bending moment. V the shear force and w the intensity of loading, then 1. dM/dx = V 2. dV/dx = w 3. dw/dx = y (the deflection of the beam at the section) Select the correct answer using the codes given below: (a) 1 and 3 (b) 1 and 2 (c) 2 and 3 (d) 1, 2 and 3 Page 164 of 429 IES-5. Ans. (b)

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondal’s

Cantilever IES-6.

The given figure shows a beam BC simply supported at C and hinged at B (free end) of a cantilever AB. The beam and the cantilever carry forces of

100 kg and 200 kg respectively. The bending moment at B is: [IES-1995] (a) Zero (b) 100 kg-m (c) 150 kg-m (d) 200 kg-m IES-6. Ans. (a) IES-7.

Match List-I with List-II and select the correct answer using the codes given below the lists: [IES-1993] List-I List-II (Condition of beam) (Bending moment diagram) A. Subjected to bending moment at the 1. Triangle end of a cantilever B. Cantilever carrying uniformly distributed 2. Cubic parabola load over the whole length C. Cantilever carrying linearly varying load 3. Parabola from zero at the fixed end to maximum at the support D. A beam having load at the centre and 4. Rectangle supported at the ends Codes: A B C D A B C D (a) 4 1 2 3 (b) 4 3 2 1 (c) 3 4 2 1 (d) 3 4 1 2 IES-7. Ans. (b) IES-8.

If the shear force acting at every section of a beam is of the same magnitude and of the same direction then it represents a [IES-1996] (a) Simply supported beam with a concentrated load at the centre. (b) Overhung beam having equal overhang at both supports and carrying equal concentrated loads acting in the same direction at the free ends. (c) Cantilever subjected to concentrated load at the free end. (d) Simply supported beam having concentrated loads of equal magnitude and in the same direction acting at equal distances from the supports. IES-8. Ans. (c)

Cantilever with Uniformly Distributed Load A uniformly distributed load Z (in kN/m) is acting over the entire length of a 3 m long cantilever beam. If the shear force at the midpoint of cantilever is 6 kN, what is the value of Z ? [IES-2009] (a) 2 (b) 3 (c) 4 (d) 5 IES-9. Ans. (c) IES-9.

Shear force at mid point of cantilever

Zl 2 

Zu 3 2



Z

6

6 6u2 3

4 kN / m Page 165 of 429

Chapter-4 IES-10.

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

Code: (a) (c) IES-10. Ans. (b) IES-11.

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Match List-I with List-II and select the correct answer using the code given below the Lists: [IES-2009]

A 1 1

B 5 3

C 2 4

D 4 5

(b) (d)

A 4 4

B 5 2

C 2 5

D 3 3

The shearing force diagram for a beam is shown in the above figure. The bending moment diagram is represented by which one of the following?

[IES-2008]

IES-11. Ans. (b) Uniformly distributed load on cantilever beam.

Page 166 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

IES-12.

A cantilever beam having 5 m length is so loaded that it develops a shearing force of 20T and a bending moment of 20 T-m at a section 2m from the free end. Maximum shearing force and maximum bending moment developed in the beam under this load are respectively 50 T and 125 T-m. The load on the beam [IES-1995] is: (a) 25 T concentrated load at free end (b) 20T concentrated load at free end (c) 5T concentrated load at free end and 2 T/m load over entire length (d) 10 T/m udl over entire length IES-12. Ans. (d)

Cantilever Carrying Uniformly Distributed Load for a Part of its Length IES-13.

A vertical hanging bar of length L and weighing w N/ unit length carries a load W at the bottom. The tensile force in the bar at a distance Y from the support will be given by [IES-1992]

a W  wL

b W  w( L  y )

c W  w y / L

d W 

W (L  y) w

IES-13. Ans. (b)

Cantilever Carrying load Whose Intensity varies IES-14.

A cantilever beam of 2m length supports a triangularly distributed load over its entire length, the maximum of which is at the free end. The total load is 37.5 kN.What is the bending moment at the fixed end? [IES 2007] (a) 50 u 106 N mm (b) 12.5 u 106 N mm (c) 100 u 106 N mm (d) 25 u 106 N mm IES-14. Ans. (a)

Page 167 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

M = 37.5 u

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

4 KNm = 50 u 106 Nmm 3

Simply Supported Beam Carrying Concentrated Load IES-15.

Assertion (A): If the bending moment along the length of a beam is constant, then the beam cross section will not experience any shear stress. [IES-1998] Reason (R): The shear force acting on the beam will be zero everywhere along the length. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IES-15. Ans. (a) IES-16. Assertion (A): If the bending moment diagram is a rectangle, it indicates that the beam is loaded by a uniformly distributed moment all along the length. Reason (R): The BMD is a representation of internal forces in the beam and not the moment applied on the beam. [IES-2002] (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IES-16. Ans. (d) IES-17.

The maximum bending moment in a simply supported beam of length L loaded by a concentrated load W at the midpoint is given by [IES-1996] (a) WL

(b)

WL 2

(c)

WL 4

(d)

WL 8

IES-17. Ans. (c) IES-18.

A simply supported beam is loaded as shown in the above figure. The maximum shear force in the beam will be (a) Zero (b) W (c) 2W (d) 4W [IES-1998]

IES-18. Ans. (c) IES-19.

If a beam is subjected to a constant bending moment along its length, then the shear force will [IES-1997] (a) Also have a constant value everywhere along its length (b) Be zero at all sections along the beam (c) Be maximum at the centre and zero at the ends (d) zero at the centre and maximum at the ends IES-19. Ans. (b) Page 168 of 429

Chapter-4 IES-20.

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

A loaded beam is shown in the figure. The bending moment diagram of the beam is best represented as:

[IES-2000]

IES-20. Ans. (a) IES-21.

A simply supported beam has equal over-hanging lengths and carries equal concentrated loads P at ends. Bending moment over the length between the supports [IES-2003] (a) Is zero (b) Is a non-zero constant (c) Varies uniformly from one support to the other (d) Is maximum at mid-span IES-21. Ans. (b)

IES-22.

The bending moment diagram for the case shown below will be q as shown in

(a)

(b)

(c)

(d)

[IES-1992] IES-22. Ans. (a)

Page 169 of 429

Chapter-4 IES-23.

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Which one of the following portions of the loaded beam shown in the given figure is subjected to pure bending? (a) AB (b)DE (c) AE (d) BD [IES-1999]

IES-23. Ans. (d) Pure bending takes place in the section between two weights W IES-24.

Constant bending moment over span "l" will occur in

[IES-1995]

IES-24. Ans. (d) IES-25. For the beam shown in the above figure, the elastic curve between the supports B and C will be: (a) Circular (b) Parabolic (c) Elliptic (d) A straight line

[IES-1998] IES-25. Ans. (b) IES-26.

A beam is simply supported at its ends and is loaded by a couple at its mid-span as shown in figure A. Shear force diagram for the beam is given by the figure. [IES-1994]

(a) B IES-26. Ans. (d)

IES-27.

(b) C

(c) D

(d) E

A beam AB is hinged-supported at its ends and is loaded by couple P.c. as shown in the given figure. The magnitude or shearing force at a section x of the [IES-1993] beam is:

(a) 0

(b) P

(c) P/2L

Page 170 of 429

(d) P.c./2L

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondal’s

IES-27. Ans. (d) If F be the shearing force at section x (at point A), then taking moments about B, F x 2L = Pc

or F

Pc 2L

Thus shearing force in zone x

Beam

Pc 2L

Carrying

a

Uniformly

A freely supported beam at its ends carries a central concentrated load, and maximum bending moment is M. If the same load be uniformly distributed over the beam length, [IES-2009] then what is the maximum bending moment? (a) M

(b)

M 2

(c)

IES-28. Ans. (b)

B.MMax

WL 4

M

Where the Load is U.D.L. Maximum Bending Moment 2 § W ·§ L · ¨ ¨ L ¸ 8¸ © ¹© ¹ WL 1 § WL · 8 2 ¨© 4 ¸¹

M 2

Page 171 of 429

M 3

(d) 2M

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondal’s

Simply Supported Beam Carrying a Load whose Intensity varies Uniformly from Zero at each End to w per Unit Run at the MiD Span IES-29.

A simply supported beam is subjected to a distributed loading as shown in the diagram given below: What is the maximum shear force in the beam? (a) WL/3 (b) WL/2 (c) WL/3 (d) WL/6 [IES-2004] 1 WL uL u W Total load 2 2 § · ¸ WL Wx 2 WL 1 ¨ W  x. ¨ u X ¸  Sx 4 2 ¨ L 4 L ¸¸ ¨ © 2 ¹ WL Smax at x 0 4

IES-29. Ans. (d)

Simply Supported Beam carrying a Load whose Intensity varies IES-30.

A beam having uniform cross-section carries a uniformly distributed load of intensity q per unit length over its entire span, and its mid-span deflection is ǅ.

The value of mid-span deflection of the same beam when the same load is distributed with intensity varying from 2q unit length at one end to zero at the other end is: [IES-1995] (a) 1/3 ǅ (b) 1/2 ǅ (c) 2/3 ǅ (d) ǅ IES-30. Ans. (d)

Simply Supported Beam with Equal Overhangs and carrying a Uniformly Distributed Load IES-31.

A beam, built-in at both ends, carries a uniformly distributed load over its entire span as shown in figure-I. Which one of the diagrams given below, represents bending moment distribution along the length of the beam? [IES-1996]

Page 172 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

IES-31. Ans. (d)

The Points of Contraflexure IES-32.

The pointÂˇ of contraflexure is a point where: [IES-2005] (a) Shear force changes sign (b) Bending moment changes sign (c) Shear force is maximum (d) Bending moment is maximum IES-32. Ans. (b) IES-33.

Match List I with List II and select the correct answer using the codes given below the Lists: [IES-2000] List-I List-II A. Bending moment is constant 1. Point of contraflexure B. Bending moment is maximum or minimum 2. Shear force changes sign C. Bending moment is zero 3. Slope of shear force diagram is zero over the portion of the beam D. Loading is constant 4. Shear force is zero over the portion of the beam Code: A B C D A B C D (a) 4 1 2 3 (b) 3 2 1 4 (c) 4 2 1 3 (d) 3 1 2 4 IES-33. Ans. (b)

The bending moment diagram shown in Fig. I correspond to the shear force diagram in [IES-1999]

IES-34. Ans. (b) If shear force is zero, B.M. will also be zero. If shear force varies linearly with length, B.M. diagram will be curved line. IES-35.

Bending moment distribution in a built be am is shown in the given Page 173 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

The shear force distribution in the beam is represented by

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

[IES-2001]

IES-35. Ans. (a) IES-36.

The given figure shows the shear force diagram for the beam ABCD. Bending moment in the portion BC of the beam [IES-1996] (b) Is zero (d) Varies parabolically from B to C

(a) Is a non-zero constant (c) Varies linearly from B to C IES-36. Ans. (a)

IES-37.

Figure shown above represents the BM diagram for a simply supported beam. The beam is subjected to which one of the following? (a) A concentrated load at its midlength (b) A uniformly distributed load over its length (c) A couple at its mid-length (d) Couple at 1/4 of the span from each end [IES-2006]

IES-37. Ans. (c) IES-38.

If the bending moment diagram for a simply supported beam is of the form given below. Then the load acting on the beam is: (a) A concentrated force at C (b) A uniformly distributed load over the whole length of the beam (c) Equal and opposite moments applied at A and B (d) A moment applied at C [IES-1994] IES-38. Ans. (d) A vertical line in centre of B.M. diagram is possible when a moment is applied there. IES-39.

The figure given below shows a bending moment diagram for the beam CABD: Page 174 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

Load diagram for the above beam will be:

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

[IES-1993]

IES-39. Ans. (a) Load diagram at (a) is correct because B.M. diagram between A and B is parabola which is possible with uniformly distributed load in this region. IES-40.

The shear force diagram shown in the following figure is that of a [IES-1994] (a) Freely supported beam with symmetrical point load about mid-span. (b) Freely supported beam with symmetrical uniformly distributed load about midspan (c) Simply supported beam with positive and negative point loads symmetrical about the mid-span (d) Simply supported beam with symmetrical varying load about mid-span

IES-40. Ans. (b) The shear force diagram is possible on simply supported beam with symmetrical varying load about mid span.

Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Shear Force (S.F.) and Bending Moment (B.M.) IAS-1.

Assertion (A): A beam subjected only to end moments will be free from shearing force. [IAS-2004] Reason (R): The bending moment variation along the beam length is zero. Page 175 of 429 (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

(b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-1. Ans. (a) IAS-2. Assertion (A): The change in bending moment between two cross-sections of a beam is equal to the area of the shearing force diagram between the two sections. [IAS-1998] Reason (R): The change in the shearing force between two cross-sections of beam due to distributed loading is equal to the area of the load intensity diagram between the two sections. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-2. Ans. (b)

IAS-3.

The ratio of the area under the bending moment diagram to the flexural rigidity between any two points along a beam gives the change in [IAS-1998] (a) Deflection (b) Slope (c) Shear force (d) Bending moment IAS-3. Ans. (b)

Cantilever IAS-4.

A beam AB of length 2 L having a concentrated load P at its mid-span is hinge supported at its two ends A and B on two identical cantilevers as shown in the given figure. The correct value of bending moment at A is (a) Zero (b) PLl2 [IAS-1995] (c) PL (d) 2 PL IAS-4. Ans. (a) Because of hinge support between beam AB and cantilevers, the bending moment can't be transmitted to cantilever. Thus bending moment at points A and B is zero. IAS-5.

A load perpendicular to the plane of the handle is applied at the free end as shown in the given figure. The values of Shear Forces (S.F.), Bending Moment (B.M.) and torque at the fixed end of the handle have been determined respectively as 400 N, 340 Nm and 100 by a student. Among these values, those of [IAS-1999] (a) S.F., B.M. and torque are correct (b) S.F. and B.M. are correct (c) B.M. and torque are correct (d) S.F. and torque are correct

IAS-5. Ans. (d) S.F 400N and BM

Torque

400 u 0.25

400 u 0.4  0.2

240Nm

100Nm

Cantilever with Uniformly Distributed Load IAS-6.

If the SF diagram for a beam is a triangle with length of the beam as its base, the beam is: [IAS-2007] (a) A cantilever with a concentrated load at its free end (b) A cantilever with udl over its whole span (c) Simply supported with a concentrated load Page 176 of 429 at its mid-point (d) Simply supported with a udl over its whole span

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

IAS-6. Ans. (b)

IAS-7.

A cantilever carrying a uniformly distributed load is shown in Fig. I. Select the correct R.M. diagram of the cantilever. [IAS-1999]

IAS-7. Ans. (c) Mx

IAS-8.

 wx u

x 2



wx 2 2

A structural member ABCD is loaded as shown in the given figure. The shearing force at any section on the length BC of the member is: (a) Zero (b) P (c) Pa/k (d) Pk/a [IAS-1996]

IAS-8. Ans. (a)

Cantilever Carrying load Whose Intensity varies IAS-9.

The beam is loaded as shown in Fig. I. Select the correct B.M. diagram [IAS-1999]

Page 177 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

IAS-9. Ans. (d)

Simply Supported Beam Carrying Concentrated Load IAS-10.

Assertion (A): In a simply supported beam carrying a concentrated load at midspan, both the shear force and bending moment diagrams are triangular in nature without any change in sign. [IAS-1999] Reason (R): When the shear force at any section of a beam is either zero or changes sign, the bending moment at that section is maximum. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-10. Ans. (d) A is false.

IAS-11.

For the shear force to be uniform throughout the span of a simply supported beam, it should carry which one of the following loadings? [IAS-2007] (a) A concentrated load at mid-span (b) Udl over the entire span (c) A couple anywhere within its span (d) Two concentrated loads equal in magnitude and placed at equal distance from each support

Page 178 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

IAS-11. Ans. (d) It is a case of pure bending.

IAS-12.

Which one of the following figures represents the correct shear force diagram for the loaded beam shown in the given figure I? [IAS-1998; IAS-1995]

IAS-12. Ans. (a)

Beam

Carrying

a

Uniformly

For a simply supported beam of length fl' subjected to downward load of uniform intensity w, match List-I with List-II and select the correct answer using the codes given below the Lists: [IAS-1997] List-I List-II A.

Slope of shear force diagram

5wL 4 1. 384 E I

B.

Maximum shear force

2. w

C.

Maximum deflection

3.

D.

Magnitude of maximum bending moment

4.

Codes: (a) (c)

A 1 3

B 2 2

C 3 1

D 4 (b) Page 429 4 179 of (d)

A 3 2

wL 4 8 wL 2 B 1 4

C 2 1

D 4 3

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

IAS-13. Ans. (d)

Simply Supported Beam Carrying a Load whose Intensity varies Uniformly from Zero at each End to w per Unit Run at the MiD Span IAS-14.

A simply supported beam of length 'l' is subjected to a symmetrical uniformly varying load with zero intensity at the ends and intensity w (load per unit length) at the mid span. What is the maximum bending moment? [IAS-2004]

3wl 2 (a) 8

wl 2 (b) 12

wl 2 (c) 24

5wl 2 (d) 12

IAS-14. Ans. (b)

Simply Supported Beam carrying a Load whose Intensity varies IAS-15.

A simply supported beam of span l is subjected to a uniformly varying load having zero intensity at the left support and w N/m at the right support. The reaction at the right support is: [IAS-2003] (a)

wl 2

(b)

wl 5

(c)

wl 4

(d)

wl 3

IAS-15. Ans. (d)

Simply Supported Beam with Equal Overhangs and carrying a Uniformly Distributed Load IAS-16.

Consider the following statements for a simply supported beam subjected to a couple at its mid-span: [IAS-2004] 1. Bending moment is zero at the ends and maximum at the centre 2. Bending moment is constant over the entire length of the beam 3. Shear force is constant over the entire length of the beam 4. Shear force is zero over the entire length of the beam Which of the statements given above are correct? (a) 1, 3 and 4 (b) 2, 3 and 4 (c) 1 and 3 (d) 2 and 4 IAS-16. Ans. (c)

Page 180 of 429

Chapter-4

IAS-17.

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Match List-I (Beams) with List-II (Shear force diagrams) and select the correct answer using the codes given below the Lists: [IAS-2001]

Codes: (a) (c) IAS-17. Ans. (d)

A 4 1

B 2 4

C 5 3

D 3 5

(b) (d)

A 1 4

B 4 2

C 5 3

D 3 5

The Points of Contraflexure IAS-18.

A point, along the length of a beam subjected to loads, where bending moment changes its sign, is known as the point of [IAS-1996] (a) Inflexion (b) Maximum stress (c) Zero shear force (d) Contra flexure IAS-18. Ans. (d) IAS-19.

Assertion (A): In a loaded beam, if the shear force diagram is a straight line parallel to the beam axis, then the bending moment is a straight line inclined to the beam axis. [IAS 1994] Reason (R): When shear force at any section of a beam is zero or changes sign, the bending moment at that section is maximum. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A Page 181 of 429 (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

(c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-19. Ans. (b)

The shear force diagram of a loaded beam is shown in the following figure: The maximum Bending Moment of the beam is: (a) 16 kN-m (b) 11 kN-m (c) 28 kN-m

(d) 8 kN-m

[IAS-1997] IAS-20. Ans. (a)

IAS-21.

The bending moment for a loaded beam is shown below:

[IAS-2003]

The loading on the beam is represented by which one of the followings diagrams? (b) (a)

(c)

(d)

IAS-21. Ans. (d) Page 182 of 429

Chapter-4 IAS-22.

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Which one of the given bending moment diagrams correctly represents that of the loaded beam shown in figure? [IAS-1997]

IAS-22. Ans. (c) Bending moment does not depends on moment of inertia. The shear force diagram is shown

IAS-23.

above

for

a

corresponding

beam.

bending

The

moment

diagram is represented by

[IAS-2003]

IAS-23. Ans. (a) IAS-24.

The bending moment diagram for a simply supported beam is a rectangle over a larger portion of the span except near the supports. What type of load does the beam carry? [IAS-2007] (a) A uniformly distributed symmetrical load over a larger portion of the span except near the supports (b) A concentrated load at mid-span (c) Two identical concentrated loads equidistant from the supports and close to midpoint of the beam Page 183 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram (d)

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Two identical concentrated loads equidistant from the mid-span and close to supports

IAS-24. Ans. (d)

Page 184 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question IES-2005 Question:

A simply supported beam of length 10 m carries a uniformly varying load whose intensity varies from a maximum value of 5 kN/m at both ends to zero at the centre of the beam. It is desired to replace the beam with another simply supported beam which will be subjected to the same maximum 'bending momentâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; and â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;shear force' as in the case of the previous one. Determine the length and rate of loading for the second beam if it is subjected to a uniformly distributed load over its whole length. Draw the variation of 'SF' and 'BM' in both the cases.

X

5KN/m

5KN/m

B X

10m

RA

RB

10  25 kN 2

25  12.5 kN 2 Take a section X-X from B at a distance x. For 0 b x b 5 m we get rate of loading = RA  RB

X  a bx [as lineary varying] at x=0, X =5 kN / m and at x = 5, X  0 These two bounday condition gives a = 5 and b = -1 = X  5 x

We know that shear force(V),

dV  X dx

or V =Â¨ Xdx =  Â¨ (5  x )dx  5 x

at x = 0, F =12.5 kN (RB ) so c1  12.5 x2

12.5 2 It is clear that maximum S.F = 12.5 kN = V = -5x +

Page 185 of 429

x2

c1 2

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

For a beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

dM V dx

x2 5x 2 x 3

12.5)dx =

12.5 x C2 2 2 6 at x = 0, M = 0 gives C2  0 or , M =Â¨ Vdx  Â¨ (5 x

M = 12.5x - 2.5x 2 x 3 / 6

for Maximum bending moment at

dM 0 dx

x2

12.5  0 2 or , x 2  10 x 25  0 or-5x+

or , x  5 means at centre. So, Mmax  12.5 q 2.5  2.5 q 52 53 / 6  20.83 kNm X

A

XKNm B

L

RA

RB X

Now we consider a simply supported beam carrying uniform distributed load over whole length (X KN/m). Here R A  RB

WL 2

S.F .at section X-X WA  Xx 2  12.5 kN

Vx

Vmax

B.M at section X-X WA Wx 2 x 2 2 2 2 dM x WL X Â?Â&#x17E; L ÂŹÂ­ WL   qÂ&#x17E; Â­Â­   20.83 (ii ) dx 2 2 Â&#x17E;Â&#x; 2 ÂŽ 8 Solving (i ) & (ii ) we get L=6.666m and X =3.75kN/m

Mx

Page 186 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram X

5KN/m

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

5KN/m

3.75kN/m

B -12.5KN/m

12.5KN/m

X

10m

RA

RB

12.5kN

6.666m

12.5kN

S.F.D

S.F.D 20.83KNm

Cubic parabola

B.M.D

Parabola

20.83kNm

Conventional Question IES-1996 Question:

A Uniform beam of length L is carrying a uniformly distributed load w per unit length and is simply supported at its ends. What would be the maximum bending moment and where does it occur? By symmetry each support reaction is equal i.e. RA=RB=

WA 2

B.M at the section x-x is Mx=+

WA Wx 2 x 2 2

For the B.M to be maximum we have to

dM x  0 that gives. dx

WA Xx  0 + 2 or x= A i.e. at mid point. 2

Bending Moment Diagram

2

XA A X Â AÂŻ wA 2 And Mmax= q  qÂĄ Â°

2 2 ÂĄÂ˘ 2 Â°Âą 2 8 Conventional Question AMIE-1996 Question:

Calculate the reactions at A and D for the beam shown in figure. Draw the bending moment and shear force diagrams showing all important values.

Page 187 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Equivalent figure below shows an overhanging beam ABCDF supported by a roller support at A and a hinged support at D. In the figure, a load of 4 kN is applied through a bracket 0.5 m away from the point C. Now apply equal and opposite load of 4 kN at C. This will be equivalent to a anticlockwise couple of the value of (4 x 0.5) = 2 kNm acting at C together with a vertical downward load of 4 kN at C. Show U.D.L. (1 kN/m) over the port AB, a point load of 2 kN vertically downward at F, and a horizontal load of 2 3 kN as shown.

For reaction and A and D. Let ue assume RA= reaction at roller A. RDV vertically component of the reaction at the hinged support D, and Page 188 of 429

RDH horizontal component of the reaction at the hinged support D.

Chapter-4 Obviously

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram RDH= 2 3 kN ( o )

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

In order to determine RA, takings moments about D, we get

Â§2 Â· R A u 6  2 u 1 1u 2 u Â¨  2  2 Â¸  2  4 u 2 Â©2 Â¹ or R A 3kN Also R A  RDV

1u 2  4  2

or

5kN vetrically upward

RDV

8

R  R

2

? Re action at D, RD

DV

Inclination with horizontal T

2

DH

tan1

52  2 3

5 2 3

2

6.08kN

55.30

S.F.Calculation : VF

2kN

VD

2  5

3kN

VC

34

1kN

VB

1kN

VA

1  1u 2

3kN

B.M.Calculation : MF

0

MD

2 u 1 2kNm

MC

ÂªÂ¬ 2 1  2  5 u 2ÂºÂ¼  2

6kNm

The bending moment increases from 4kNm in i,e., 2 1  2  5 u 2

to 6kNm as shown MB MP

MA

2 1  2  2  5 2  4 u 2  2

4kNm

2Â· 1 Â§ 2 Â¨ 1  2  2  Â¸  5 2  2  1  4 2  1  2  1u 1u 2Â¹ 2 Â© 2.5kNm 0

Conventional Question GATE-1997 Question:

Construct the bending moment and shearing force diagrams for the beam shown in the figure.

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Calculation: First find out reaction at B and E. Taking moments, about B, we get

RE u 4.5  20 u 0.5 u or

RE

RB  RE RB

50 u 3  40 u 5

55kN

Also, or

0.5  100 2

20 u 0.5  50  40

> RE

45kN

S.F. Calculation :

B.M.Calculation :

55kN@

VF

40kN

VE

40  55 15kN

VD

15  50

35kN

VB 35  45 10kN MG 0 MF

0

ME

40 u 0.5

MD

40 u 2  55 u 1.5

20kNm

2.5kNm

MC 40 u 4  55 u 3.5  50 u 2 67.5kNm The bending moment increases from  62.5kNm to 100. 0.5 MB 20 u 0.5 u 2.5kNm 2 Conventional Question GATE-1996 Question:

Two bars AB and BC are connected by a frictionless hinge at B. The assembly is supported and loaded as shown in figure below. Draw the shear force and bending moment diagrams for the combined beam AC. clearly labelling the Page 190 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

important values. Also indicate your sign convention.

There shall be a vertical reaction at hinge B and we can split the problem in two parts. Then the FBD of each part is shown below

Calculation: Referring the FBD, we get,

Fy

0, and R1  R2

200kN

From

ÂŚM

or

R2

?

R1

500 125kN 4 200  125 75kN

Again, R3

R1

75kN

and

B

0,100 u 2  100 u 3 R2 u 4

M 75 u 1.5 112.5kNm.

Conventional Question IES-1998

Page 191 of 429

0

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Question:

A tube 40 mm outside diameter; 5 mm thick and 1.5 m long simply supported at 125 mm from each end carries a concentrated load of 1 kN at each extreme end. (i) Neglecting the weight of the tube, sketch the shearing force and bending moment diagrams; (ii) Calculate the radius of curvature and deflection at mid-span. Take the modulus of elasticity of the material as 208 GN/m2

(i) Given, d0

W

1kN; E

40 mm 0.04 m; di

208GN / m

2

d0  2t 2

40  2 u 5

30 mm

2

208 u 10 N / m ; l 1.5; a 125mm

Calculation: (ii) Radius of coordinate R As per bending equation:

M I

V

E y R EI or R    i

M Here,M W u a 1u 103 u 0.125 125Nm I

S

d 64

4 0

 d14

S ÂŞ 4 4 0.04  0.03 Âş 8.59 u 108 m4

Âź 64 ÂŹ Substituting the values in equation i , we get 208 u 108 u 8.59 u 108 125 Deflection at mid  span : R

EI

d2 y dx 2

Mx

142.9 m

 Wx  W x Page  Wx  Wx  Wa a 192 of 429

 Wa

0.03 m;

0.125 m

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram Integrating, we get EI

dy dx

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

 Wax  C1

1 dy , 0 2 dx 1 Wal 0  Wa  C1 or C1 ? 2 2 dy Wal EI ?  Wax  dx 2 Integrating again, we get When,

x

When

x 2 Wal x  C2  2 2 a, y 0

 Wa

EIy x

Wa3 Wa2l   C2 2 2 Wa3 Wa2l C2  2 2 2 Wax Walx Âª Wa3 Wa2l Âº EIy   Â«  Â» 2 2 2 Â¼ Â¬ 2

?

0

or

? or

y

At mid  span,i,e., x y



Wa Âª x 2 lx a2 al Âº    Â» Â« EI Â¬ 2 2 2 2 Â¼ l/2 2 l u l / 2 a2 al Âº Wa Âª l / 2

Â«    Â» EI Â« 2 2 2 2Â» Â¬ Â¼ 2 2 Wa Âª l a al Âº  Â» Â«  EI Â¬ 8 2 2 Â¼ Âª 1.52 0.1252 0.125 u 1.5 Âº 1u 1000 u 0.125   Â« Â» 208 u 109 u 8.59 u 10 8 Â¬ 8 2 2 Â¼

0.001366m 1.366mm It will be in upward direction

Conventional Question IES-2001 Question:

What is meant by point of contraflexure or point of inflexion in a beam? Show the same for the beam given below:

17.5kN/m A

20kN C

B 4M

D 2m

In a beam if the bending moment changes sign at a point, the point itself having zero bending moment, the beam changes curvature at this point of zero bending moment and this point is called the point of contra flexure.

Page 193 of 429

Chapter-4

Bending Moment and Shear Force Diagram

17.5kN/m A

20kN C

4M

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

B 4M

D 2M

BMD From the bending moment diagram we have seen that it is between A & C. [If marks are more we should calculate exact point.]

Page 194 of 429

5.

Deflection of Beam

Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) 5.1 Introduction

x

We know that the axis of a beam deflects from its initial position under action of applied forces.

x

In this chapter we will learn how to determine the elastic deflections of a beam.

Selection of co-ordinate axes We will not introduce any other co-ordinate system. We use general co-ordinate axis as shown in the figure. This system will be followed in deflection of beam and in shear force and bending moment diagram. Here downward direction will be negative i.e. negative Y-axis. Therefore downward deflection of the beam will be treated as negative.

We use above Co-ordinate system

To determine the value of deflection of beam subjected to a given loading where we will use the formula, EI

d 2y dx 2

Mx .

Some books fix a co-ordinate axis as shown in the following figure. Here downward direction will be positive i.e. positive Y-axis. Therefore downward deflection of the beam will be treated as positive. As beam is generally deflected in downward directions and

this

co-ordinate

system

treats

downward

deflection is positive deflection.

Some books use above co-ordinate system

To determine the value of deflection of beam subjected to a given loading where we will use the formula, EI

d 2y dx 2

M x .

Why to calculate the deflections?

x

To prevent cracking of attached brittle materials

x

To make sure the structure not deflect severely and to â&#x20AC;&#x153;appearâ&#x20AC;? safe for its occupants

x

To help analyzing statically indeterminate structures Page 195 of 429

Chapter-5

x

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondal’s

Information on deformation characteristics of members is essential in the study of vibrations of machines

Several methods to compute deflections in beam x

Double integration method (without the use of singularity functions)

x

Macaulay’s Method (with the use of singularity functions)

x

Moment area method

x

Method of superposition

x

Conjugate beam method

x

Castigliano’s theorem

x

Work/Energy methods

Methods to find deflection

Double integration

Geometrical

Moment area method

Energy Method

Conjugate beam method

Castiglian’s theorem

Virtual Work

Assumptions in Simple Bending Theory x

Beams are initially straight

x

The material is homogenous and isotropic i.e. it has a uniform composition and its mechanical properties are the same in all directions

x

The stress-strain relationship is linear and elastic

x

Young’s Modulus is the same in tension as in compression

x

Sections are symmetrical about the plane of bending

x

Sections which are plane before bending remain plane after bending

Non-Uniform Bending x

In the case of non-uniform bending of a beam, where bending moment varies from section to section, there will be shear force at each cross section which will induce shearing stresses

x

Also these shearing stresses cause warping (or out-of plane distortion) of the cross section so that plane cross sections do not remain plane even after bending Page 196 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

5.2 Elastic line or Elastic curve We have to remember that the differential equation of the elastic line is

2

d y EI 2 =M x dx Proof: Consider the following simply supported beam with UDL over its length.

From elementary calculus we know that curvature of a line (at point Q in figure)

1 R

d2 y dx 2

3/2

Â­Â° Â§ dy Âˇ2 Â˝Â° ÂŽ1  Â¨ Â¸ Âž ÂŻÂ° ÂŠ dx Âš ÂżÂ°

For small deflection, or

dy |0 dx

1 d2 y | R dx 2

Page 197 of 429

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Chapter-5 Deflection of Beam Bending stress of the beam (at point Q)

S K Mondal’s

 Mx .y

Vx

EI From strain relation we get

H 1  x and H x R y 1 Mx ? R EI d2 y Mx Therefore dx 2 EI d2 y or EI Mx dx 2

Vx E

5.3 General expression From the equation EI

d2y dx 2

M x we may easily find out the following relations.

x

EI

d4y dx 4

x

EI

d3y dx3

Vx

x

EI

d2y dx 2

M x Bending moment

x

dy = ș = slope dx

x x

y = G = Deflection, Displacement Flexural rigidity = EI

Shear force

5.4 Double integration method (without the use of singularity functions)

³

Z dx

x

Vx =

x

Mx = Vx dx

x

EI

d2y dx 2

x

T

Slope

x

G

Deflection

³

Mx

1 M x dx EI ³

³ T dx

4-step procedure to solve deflection of beam problems by double integration method Page 198 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Step 1: Write down boundary conditions (Slope boundary conditions and displacement boundary conditions), analyze the problem to be solved

Step 2: Write governing equations for, EI

d2y dx 2

Mx

Step 3: Solve governing equations by integration, results in expression with unknown integration constants

Step 4: Apply boundary conditions (determine integration constants)

Following table gives boundary conditions for different types of support.

Types of support and Boundary Conditions Clamped or Built in support or Fixed end : ( Point A)

Deflection, y 0 Slope, T 0 Moment , M z 0

i.e.A finite value

Free end: (Point B)

Deflection, y z 0

i.e.A finite value

Slope, T z 0 i.e.A finite value Moment , M

0

Roller (Point B) or Pinned Support (Point A) or Hinged or Simply supported.

Deflection, y 0 Slope, T z 0 i.e.A finite value Moment , M

0

End restrained against rotation but free to deflection

Deflection, y z 0 i.e.A finite value Slope, T

0

Shear force, V

0

Flexible support

Deflection, y z 0 i.e.A finite value Slope, T z 0 i .e. A finite value

Page 199 of 429

Figure

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

Moment , M kr Shear force, V

S K Mondal’s

dy dx k. y

Using double integration method we will find the deflection and slope of the following loaded beams one by one. (i)

A Cantilever beam with point load at the free end.

(ii)

A Cantilever beam with UDL (uniformly distributed load)

(iii)

A Cantilever beam with an applied moment at free end.

(iv)

A simply supported beam with a point load at its midpoint.

(v)

A simply supported beam with a point load NOT at its midpoint.

(vi)

A simply supported beam with UDL (Uniformly distributed load)

(vii) A simply supported beam with triangular distributed load (GVL) gradually varied load. (viii) A simply supported beam with a moment at mid span. (ix)

A simply supported beam with a continuously distributed load the intensity of which at any point ‘x’ along the beam is

wx

§Sx · w sin ¨ ¸ © L ¹

(i) A Cantilever beam with point load at the free end. We will solve this problem by double integration method. For that at first we have to calculate (Mx). Consider any section XX at a distance ‘x’ from free end which is left end as shown in figure.

? Mx = - P.x We know that differential equation of elastic line

EI

d2 y dx 2

Mx

P.x

Integrating both side we get

Page 200 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

2

dy  P Â³ x dx dx 2 dy x2 or EI  P.  A dx 2

Â³ EI

.............(i)

Again integrating both side we get Â§ x2 Â· Â³ Â¨Â© P 2  A Â¸Â¹ dx Px 3 or EIy = ..............(ii)  Ax +B 6 Where A and B is integration constants.

EIÂ³ dy =

Now apply boundary condition at fixed end which is at a distance x = L from free end and we also know that at fixed end at x = L,

y=0

at x = L,

dy dx

0

from equation (ii) EIL = -

PL3 + AL +B 6

from equation (i) EI.(0) = -

PL2 +A 2

Solving (iii) & (iv) we get A =

Therefore,

y=-

..........(iii) â&#x20AC;¦..(iv)

PL2 PL3 and B = 2 3

Px 3 PL2 x PL3   6EI 2EI 3EI

The slope as well as the deflection would be maximum at free end hence putting x = 0 we get ymax = -

(Slope)max = T

max

=

PL2 2EI

Remember for a cantilever beam with a point load at free end.

3

Downward deflection at free end,

And slope at free end,

T

G

PL 3EI

PL2 2EI Page 201 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

(ii) A Cantilever beam with UDL (uniformly distributed load)

We will now solve this problem by double integration method, for that at first we have to calculate (Mx). Consider any section XX at a distance â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;xâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; from free end which is left end as shown in figure.

? Mx

 w.x .

x 2



wx 2 2

We know that differential equation of elastic line

EI

d2 y dx 2



wx 2 2

Integrating both sides we get

d2 y wx 2  dx dx 2 Âł 2 dy wx 3   A ......(i) or EI dx 6

Âł EI

Again integrating both side we get Â§ wx 3 Âˇ Âł Â¨ÂŠ  6  A Â¸Âš dx wx 4 or EIy =  Ax  B.......(ii) 24 > where A and B are integration constants@ EIÂł dy

Now apply boundary condition at fixed end which is at a distance x = L from free end and we also know that at fixed end. at x = L,

y=0

at x = L,

dy =0 dx

from equation (i) we get

EI u (0) =

from equation (ii) we get

-wL3 +wL3 + A or A = 6 6

EI.y = -

or

B=-

wL4 + A.L + B 24

wL4 8

The slope as well as the deflection would be maximum at the free end hence putting x = 0, we get Page 202 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam 4



y max

wL 8EI

slope max

S K Mondal’s

wL3 6EI

Remember: For a cantilever beam with UDL over its whole length,

4

Maximum deflection at free end

Maximum slope,

T

wL 8EI

G

wL3 6EI

(iii) A Cantilever beam of length ‘L’ with an applied moment ‘M’ at free end.

Consider a section XX at a distance ‘x’ from free end, the bending moment at section XX is (Mx) = -M We know that differential equation of elastic line

or EI

d2 y dx 2

M

Integrating both side we get d2 y  ³ M dx dx 2 dy or EI Mx + A ...(i) dx or EI³

Page 203 of 429

Chapter-5 Deflection of Beam Again integrating both side we get EIÂł dy =

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Âł M x +A dx

Mx 2  Ax + B ...(ii) 2 Where A and B are integration constants.

or EI y 

applying boundary conditions in equation (i) &(ii) at x = L,

dy dx

0 gives A = ML

ML2 2 2 Mx MLx ML2 Therefore deflection equation is y =   2EI EI 2EI Which is the equation of elastic curve.

at x = L, y = 0 gives B =

ML2  ML2 2



2

ML G = 2EI ML T

EI

? Maximum deflection at free end

? Maximum slope at free end

(It is downward)

Let us take a funny example: A cantilever beam AB of length â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; and uniform flexural rigidity EI has a bracket BA (attached to its free end. A vertical downward force P is applied to free end C of the bracket. Find the ratio a/L required in order that the deflection of point A is zero.

[ISRO â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2008]

We may consider this force â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Pâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; and a moment (P.a) act on free end A of the cantilever beam.

Page 204 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s 3

Due to point load â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Pâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; at free end â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Aâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; downward deflection G

Due to moment M = P.a at free end â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Aâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; upward deflection G

PL 3EI ML2 2EI

(P.a)L2 2EI

For zero deflection of free end A

PL3 (P.a)L2 = 3EI 2EI a 2 or L 3

(iv) A simply supported beam with a point load P at its midpoint. A simply supported beam AB carries a concentrated load P at its midpoint as shown in the figure.

We want to locate the point of maximum deflection on the elastic curve and find its value.

In the region 0 < x < L/2 Bending moment at any point x (According to the shown co-ordinate system)

Â§PÂˇ Â¸ .x ÂŠ2Âš

Mx = Â¨

and In the region L/2 < x < L Mx =

P x  L / 2

2

We know that differential equation of elastic line

EI

d2 y dx 2

P .x 2

In the region 0 < x < L/2

Integrating both side we get d2 y

or EI

Âł dx

or EI

dy dx

2

P

Âł 2 x dx P x2 .  A (i) 2 2

Again integrating both side we get

Page 205 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Â§P Âˇ EI Âł dy = Âł Â¨ x 2  A Â¸ dx ÂŠ4 Âš 3 Px or EI y =  Ax + B (ii) 12 > Where A and B are integrating constants@ Now applying boundary conditions to equation (i) and (ii) we get

at x = 0, at x = L/2, A=-

y=0 dy dx

0

PL2 and B = 0 16

? Equation of elastic line, y =

Px 3 PL12 x 12 16

3

Maximum deflection at mid span (x = L/2)

and maximum slope at each end

PL G = 48EI

T

PL2 16EI

(v) A simply supported beam with a point load â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Pâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; NOT at its midpoint. A simply supported beam AB carries a concentrated load P as shown in the figure.

We have to locate the point of maximum deflection on the elastic curve and find the value of this deflection. Taking co-ordinate axes x and y as shown below

Page 206 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

For the bending moment we have In the region 0 d x d a,

Mx

And, In the region a d x d L,

Mx

Â§ P.a Âˇ Â¨ L Â¸ .x ÂŠ Âš



P.a L - x

L

So we obtain two differential equation for the elastic curve. d2 y P.a .x L dx 2 d2 y P.a and EI 2  . L - x

dx L

for 0 d x d a

EI

for a d x d L

Successive integration of these equations gives

dy P.a x 2 . + A1 ......(i) dx L 2 dy P.a 2 EI P.a x x  A2 ......(ii) dx L P.a x 3 EI y . +A1x+B1 ......(iii) L 6 x 2 P.a x 3 EI y P.a .  A 2 x + B2 .....(iv)  2 L 6

for o d x d a

EI

for a d x d L for 0 d x d a for a d x d L

Where A1, A2, B1, B2 are constants of Integration. Now we have to use Boundary conditions for finding constants: BCS

(a) at x = 0, y = 0 (b) at x = L, y = 0

Â§ dy Âˇ Â¸ = Same for equation (i) & (ii) ÂŠ dx Âš

(c) at x = a, Â¨

(d) at x = a, y = same from equation (iii) & (iv) We get

A1 and B1

Pb 2 L  b2 ; 6L

A2

P.a 2L2  a2 6L

0;

B2

Pa3 / 6EI

Page 207 of 429

Therefore we get two equations of elastic curve

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

Pbx 2 L  b2  x 2 ..... (v) 6L Âş Pb ÂŞÂ§ L Âˇ 3 EI y = x - a  L2  b2 x - x3 Âť . ...(vi) Â¨ Â¸ ÂŤ 6L ÂŹÂŠ b Âš Âź EI y = -

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

for 0 d x d a

for a d x d L

For a > b, the maximum deflection will occur in the left portion of the span, to which equation (v) applies. Setting the derivative of this expression equal to zero gives

x=

a(a+2b) 3

L2  b2 3

(L-b)(L+b) 3

at that point a horizontal tangent and hence the point of maximum deflection substituting this value of x into equation (v), we find,

y max

P.b(L2  b2 )3/2 9 3. EIL

Case â&#x20AC;&#x201C;I: if a = b = L/2 then Maximum deflection will be at x =

L2  L/2

3

2

L/2

i.e. at mid point

and y max

G

^

P. L/2 u L2  L/2

2

3/2

`

9 3 EIL

PL3 48EI

(vi) A simply supported beam with UDL (Uniformly distributed load) A simply supported beam AB carries a uniformly distributed load (UDL) of intensity w/unit length over its whole span L as shown in figure. We want to develop the equation of the elastic curve and find the maximum deflection G at the middle of the span.

Taking co-ordinate axes x and y as shown, we have for the bending moment at any point x

Mx

wL x2 .x - w. 2 2

Then the differential equation of deflection becomes

EI

d2 y dx 2

Mx

wL x2 .x - w. 2 2

Integrating both sides we get

EI

dy dx

wL x 2 w x 3 .  . A 2 2 2 3

Page 208 of 429 .....(i)

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Again Integrating both side we get

EI y

wL x 3 w x 4 .  .  Ax + B 2 6 2 12

.....(ii)

Where A and B are integration constants. To evaluate these constants we have to use boundary conditions. at x = 0, y = 0 at x = L/2,

dy dx

gives

0

gives

B=0

A



wL3 24

Therefore the equation of the elastic curve

y

wL 3 w wL3 wx ÂŞL3  2L.x 2  x 3 ÂşÂź .x  .x 4  .x = 12EI 24EI 12EI 24EI ÂŹ

The maximum deflection at the mid-span, we have to put x = L/2 in the equation and obtain

4

Maximum deflection at mid-span,

And Maximum slope T A

G

5wL 384EI

(It is downward)

TB at the left end A and at the right end b is same putting x = 0 or x = L

Therefore we get Maximum slope

T

wL3 24EI

(vii) A simply supported beam with triangular distributed load (GVL) gradually varied load. A simply supported beam carries a triangular distributed load (GVL) as shown in figure below. We have to find equation of elastic curve and find maximum deflection G .

In this (GVL) condition, we get

Page 209 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam 4

EI

dy dx 4



w .x L

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

.....(i)

Separating variables and integrating we get

EI

d3 y dx 3

Vx



wx 2 +A 2L

.....(ii)

Again integrating thrice we get

EI

d2 y dx 2

Mx

EI

dy dx



EI y



wx 3 + Ax +B 6L

.....(iii)

wx 4 Ax 2 + +Bx + C 24L 2

.....(iv)



wx 5 Ax 3 Bx 2 + + + Cx +D 120L 6 2

.....(v)

Where A, B, C and D are integration constant. Boundary conditions

A=

at x = 0,

Mx = 0,

at x = L,

Mx = 0, y = 0 gives

y=0

wL 7wL3 , B = 0, C = , D=0 360 6

Therefore y = -

wx 7L4  10L2 x 2  3x 4 360EIL

^

To find maximum deflection G , we have

`

dy =0 dx

And it gives x = 0.519 L and maximum deflection G = 0.00652

wL4 EI

(viii) A simply supported beam with a moment at mid-span A simply supported beam AB is acted upon by a couple M applied at an intermediate point distance â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;aâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; from the equation of elastic curve and deflection at point where the moment acted.

Considering equilibrium we get R A

M and RB L



M L

Taking co-ordinate axes x and y as shown, we have for bending moment In the region 0 d x d a,

Mx

M .x L

In the region a d x d L,

Mx

M x-M L Page 210 of 429

So we obtain the difference equation for the elastic curve

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam 2

dy dx 2 d2 y and EI 2 dx EI

M .x L M .x  M L

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

for 0 d x d a for a d x d L

Successive integration of these equation gives

M x2 .  A1 L 2 M x2 - Mx+ A 2 L 2 M x3  A1x + B1 and EI y = . L V M x 3 Mx 2   A 2 x + B2 EI y = L V 2 dy dx dy EI dx EI

....(i)

for 0 d x d a

.....(ii)

for a d x d L

......(iii)

for 0 d x d a

......(iv)

for a d x d L

Where A1, A2, B1 and B2 are integration constants. To finding these constants boundary conditions (a) at x = 0, y = 0 (b) at x = L, y = 0

Â§ dy Âˇ Â¸ = same form equation (i) & (ii) ÂŠ dx Âš

(c) at x = a, Â¨

(d) at x = a, y = same form equation (iii) & (iv)

ML Ma2 + , A2 3 2L Ma2 B2 2

A1

M.a +

B1

0,

ML Ma2  3 2L

With this value we get the equation of elastic curve

Mx 6aL - 3a2  x 2  2L2 6L ? deflection of x = a, Ma y= 3aL - 2a2  L2 3EIL y=-

^

^

`

for 0 d x d a

`

(ix) A simply supported beam with a continuously distributed load the Â§SxÂˇ intensity of which at any point â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;xâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; along the beam is wx w sin Â¨ Â¸ ÂŠ L Âš

At first we have to find out the bending moment at any point â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;xâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; according to the shown co-ordinate system. We know that

Page 211 of 429

Chapter-5 d Vx

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Â§Sx Â·  w sin Â¨ Â¸ Â© L Â¹

dx

Integrating both sides we get

Â³ d V

x

or Vx

Â§Sx Â·  Â³ w sin Â¨ Â¸ dx +A Â© L Â¹ wL Â§Sx Â·  .cos Â¨ Â¸A S Â© L Â¹

and we also know that

d Mx

Â§Sx Â· cos Â¨ Â¸A Â© L Â¹

wL

Vx

dx

S

Again integrating both sides we get

Â­ wL Â½ Â§Sx Â·  A Â¾ dx cos Â¨ Â® Â¸ Â© L Â¹ Â¯S Â¿

Â³ d M Â³ x

wL2

or Mx

S

Â§Sx Â· sin Â¨ Â¸  Ax +B Â© L Â¹

2

Where A and B are integration constants, to find out the values of A and B. We have to use boundary conditions

and

at x = 0,

Mx = 0

at x = L,

Mx = 0

From these we get A = B = 0. Therefore Mx

wL2

S

2

Â§Sx Â· sin Â¨ Â¸ Â© L Â¹

So the differential equation of elastic curve

EI

d2 y dx 2

wL2

Mx

S

2

Â§SxÂ· sin Â¨ Â¸ Â© L Â¹

Successive integration gives

EI

dy dx

EI y

wL3

Â§Sx Â· cos Â¨ Â¸C S Â© L Â¹ wL4 Â§Sx Â·  4 sin Â¨ Â¸  Cx  D S Â© L Â¹ 

3

.......(i) .....(ii)

Where C and D are integration constants, to find out C and D we have to use boundary conditions at x = 0,

y=0

at x = L,

y=0

and that give C = D = 0 Therefore slope equation

dy wL3 Â§Sx Â·  3 cos Â¨ Â¸ dx S Â© L Â¹ wL4 Â§Sx Â·  4 sin Â¨ S EI Â© L Â¸Â¹

EI

and Equation of elastic curve y

Â§Sx Â· Â¸ is maximum Â© L Â¹ Page 212 of 429

Deflection will be maximum if sin Â¨

Chapter-5 §Sx · sin ¨ ¸=1 © L ¹

Deflection of Beam or

S K Mondal’s

x = L/2

and Maximum downward deflection G =

WL4 (downward). S 4EI

5.5 Macaulay's Method (Use of singularity function)

x

When the beam is subjected to point loads (but several loads) this is very convenient method for determining the deflection of the beam.

x

In this method we will write single moment equation in such a way that it becomes continuous for entire length of the beam in spite of the discontinuity of loading.

x

After integrating this equation we will find the integration constants which are valid for entire length of the beam. This method is known as method of singularity constant.

Procedure to solve the problem by Macaulay’s method Step – I: Calculate all reactions and moments Step – II: Write down the moment equation which is valid for all values of x. This must contain brackets.

Step – III: Integrate the moment equation by a typical manner. Integration of (x-a) will be

x-a

2

2

3

§ x2 · x-a so on. not ¨  ax ¸ and integration of (x-a)2 will be 3 © 2 ¹

Step – IV: After first integration write the first integration constant (A) after first terms and after second time integration write the second integration constant (B) after A.x . Constant A and B are valid for all values of x.

Step – V: Using Boundary condition find A and B at a point x = p if any term in Macaulay’s method, (x-a) is negative (-ive) the term will be neglected.

(i) Let us take an example: A simply supported beam AB length 6m with a point load of 30 kN is applied at a distance 4m from left end A. Determine the equations of the elastic curve between each change of load point and the maximum deflection of the beam.

Answer: We solve this problem using Macaulay’s method, for that first writes the general momentum equation for the last portion of beam BC of the loaded beam.

EI

d2 y dx 2

Mx

10x -30 x - 4 N.m

....(i) Page 213 of 429

By successive integration of this equation (using Macaulay’s integration rule

Chapter-5 e.g

Deflection of Beam

x  a

Âł x  a dx

2

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

2

)

We get

EI

dy dx

5x 2  A -15 x-4

and EI y =

2

N.m2

5 3 x  Ax + B - 5 (x - 4)3 N.m3 3

..... ii

..... iii

Where A and B are two integration constants. To evaluate its value we have to use following boundary conditions. at x = 0, and

y=0

at x = 6m, y = 0

Note: When we put x = 0, x - 4 is negativre (â&#x20AC;&#x201C;ive) and this term will not be considered for x = 0 , so our equation will be EI y =

5 3 x  Ax +B, and at x = 0 , y = 0 gives B = 0 3

But when we put x = 6, x-4 is positive (+ive) and this term will be considered for x = 6, y = 0 so our equation will be EI y =

5 3 x + Ax + 0 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 5 (x â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 4)3 3

This gives

5 3 .6  A.6  0  5(6  4)3 3 or A = - 53 EI .(0) =

So our slope and deflection equation will be

EI

dy dx

5x 2 - 53 - 15 x - 4

2

5 3 3 x - 53x + 0 - 5 x - 4

3

and EI y

Now we have two equations for entire section of the beam and we have to understand how we use these equations. Here if x < 4 then x â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 4 is negative so this term will be deleted. That so why in the region o d x d 4m we will neglect (x â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 4) term and our slope and deflection equation will be

EI

dy dx

5x 2 -53

5 3 x - 53x 3 But in the region 4m  x d 6m , (x â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 4) is positive so we include this term and our slope and and

EI y

deflection equation will be

EI

dy dx

EI y

5x 2 - 53 - 15 x - 4

2

5 3 3 x - 53x - 5 x - 4

3

Now we have to find out maximum deflection, but we donâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t know at what value of â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;xâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; it will be maximum. For this assuming the value of â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;xâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; will be in the region 0 d x d 4m .

Page 214 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s dy Deflection (y) will be maximum for that = 0 or 5x 2 - 53 = 0 or x = 3.25 m as our calculated x is dx in the region 0 d x d 4m ; at x = 3.25 m deflection will be maximum or

EI ymax =

or

ymax = -

5 u 3.253 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 53 u 3.25 3 115 EI

But if you have any doubt that Maximum deflection may be in the range of 4  x d 6m , use EIy = 5x2 â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 53x â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 5 (x â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 4)3 and find out x. The value of x will be absurd that indicates the maximum deflection will not occur in the region 4  x d 6m . Deflection (y) will be maximum for that

dy =0 dx

2

or

5x 2 - 53 - 15 x - 4 = 0

or

10x2 -120x + 293 = 0

or

x = 3.41 m or 8.6 m

Both the value fall outside the region 4  x d 6m and in this region 4  x d 6m and in this region maximum deflection will not occur.

(ii)

Now take an example where Point load, UDL and Moment applied simultaneously in a beam:

Let us consider a simply supported beam AB (see Figure) of length 3m is subjected to a point load 10 kN, UDL = 5 kN/m and a bending moment M = 25 kNm. Find the deflection of the beam at point D if flexural rigidity (EI) = 50 KNm2.

ÂŚM

A

0 gives

-10 u 1 - 25 - 5 u 1 u 1  1  1/ 2  RB u 3 or RB

0

15.83kN

R A  RB

10  5 u 1 gives R A

0.83 kN

We solve this problem using Macaulayâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s method, for that first writing the general momentum equation for the last portion of beam, DB of the loaded beam.

d2 y EI dx 2

Mx

0.83x

0

-10 x-1 25 x-2 

5 x-2

Page 215 of 429 2

2

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

By successive integration of this equation (using Macaulayâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s integration rule e.g

Âł x  a dx

x  a

2

2

)

We get

EI

dy dx



and EIy = 

0.83 2 5 2 3 .x  A -5 x  1 25 x  2  x  2

2 6

0.83 3 5 25 5 3 2 4 x  Ax +B - x  1  x  2  x  2

6 3 2 24

Where A and B are integration constant we have to use following boundary conditions to find out A & B. at x = 0,

y=0

at x = 3m, y = 0 Therefore B = 0

0.83 5 5 u 33  A u 3 + 0 - u 23 12.5 u 12  u 14 6 3 24 or A = 1.93 and 0 = -

EIy = - 0.138x3  1.93x -1.67 x  1

3

2

12.5 x  2  0.21 x  2

4

Deflextion at point D at x = 2m EIyD

0.138 u 23  1.93 u 2  1.67 u 13 

or yD

8.85 EI

8.85

50 u 103 0.177mm downward . 

(iii) A simply supported beam with a couple M at a distance â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;aâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; from left end If a couple acts we have to take the distance in the bracket and this should be raised to the power zero. i.e. M(x â&#x20AC;&#x201C; a)0. Power is zero because (x â&#x20AC;&#x201C; a)0 = 1 and unit of M(x â&#x20AC;&#x201C; a)0 = M but we introduced the distance which is needed for Macaulayâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s method.

EI

d2 y dx 2

M R A. x  M x-a

0

Successive integration gives EI

dy dx

EI y

M x2 1 .  A - M x-a

L 2 M x-a

M 3 x  Ax + B 6L 2

2

Where A and B are integration constants, we have to use boundary conditions to find out A & B. at x = 0, y = 0 gives B = 0 at x = L, y = 0 gives A =

M L-a

2L

2



ML 6

Page 216 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondal’s

8. Moment area method x

This method is used generally to obtain displacement and rotation at a single point on a beam.

x

The moment area method is convenient in case of beams acted upon with point loads in which case bending moment area consist of triangle and rectangles. A

B

C

L Mn

Mc

B.M.diag

MB

θ

X

Deflection

θ2

OA

A

ymax

C

θ AB

x

tBA

A

Angle between the tangents drawn at 2 points A&B on the elastic line, ș AB

ș AB =

1 u Area of the bending moment diagram between A&B EI i.e. slope

x

B

D

T AB

A B.M. EI

Deflection of B related to 'A' yBA = Moment of

M diagram between B&A taking about B (or w.r.t. B) EI i.e. deflection yBA

A B.M u x EI

Important Note If

A1 = Area of shear force (SF) diagram

A2 = Area of bending moment (BM) diagram, Then, Change of slope over any portion of the loaded beam =

Page 217 of 429

A1 u A2 EI

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Some typical bending moment diagram and their area (A) and distance of C.G from one edge

x is shown in the following table. [Note the distance

will be different from other end] Shape

BM Diagram

Area

Distance from C.G

1. Rectangle

A

bh

x

b 2

x

b 3

x

b 4

2. Triangle

3. Parabola

4. Parabola 5.Cubic Parabola 6. y = k xn 7. Sine curve

Determination of Maximum slope and deflection by Moment Area- Method (i) A Cantilever beam with a point load at free end

Page 218 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

Area of BM (Bending moment diagram)

1 u L u PL 2 Therefore

A

PL2 2

Maximum slope T

A EI

Maximum deflection G

§ PL2 · § 2 · ¨ ¸ u ¨ L¸ © 2 ¹ ©3 ¹ EI

PL2 2EI Ax EI

PL3 3EI

(at free end)

(at free end)

(ii) A cantilever beam with a point load not at free end Area of BM diagram A

1 u a u Pa 2

Pa2 2

Therefore

Maximum slope T

A EI

Maximum deflection G

§ Pa2 · § a · ¨ ¸ u ¨ L- ¸ © 2 ¹ © 3¹ EI

Pa2 2EI Ax EI

( at free end)

Pa2 § a · . L(at free end) 2EI ¨© 3 ¸¹

(iii) A cantilever beam with UDL over its whole length Area of BM diagram A

§ wL2 · 1 uL u ¨ ¸ 3 © 2 ¹

wL3 6

Therefore

Maximum slope T

A EI

Maximum deflection G

§ wL3 · § 3 · ¨ ¸u ¨ L¸ © 6 ¹ ©4 ¹ EI

wL3 6EI Ax EI

(at free end)

wL4 (at free end) 8EI

(iv) A simply supported beam with point load at mid-spam

Page 219 of 429

S K Mondal’s

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondal’s

A

1 L PL u u 2 2 4

PL2 16

Therefore

A EI

Maximum slope T

Maximum deflection G

§ PL2 L · u ¸ ¨ © 16 3 ¹ EI

PL2 (at each ends) 16EI Ax EI

PL3 48EI

(at mid point)

(v) A simply supported beam with UDL over its whole length Area of BM diagram (shaded)

A

2 § L · § wL2 · u u¨ ¸ 3 ¨© 2 ¸¹ © 8 ¹

wL3 24

Therefore

Maximum slope T

A EI

Maximum deflection G

§ wL3 · § 5 L · ¨ ¸u¨ u ¸ © 24 ¹ © 8 2 ¹ EI

wL3 24EI Ax EI

5 wL4 384 EI

(at each ends)

(at mid point)

9. Method of superposition Assumptions: x

Structure should be linear

x

Slope of elastic line should be very small.

x

The deflection of the beam should be small such that the effect due to the shaft or rotation of the line of action of the load is neglected.

Principle of Superposition: •

Procedure is facilitated by tables of solutions for common types of loadings and supports.

Example:

For the beam and loading shown, determine the slope and deflection at point B. Page 220 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

10. Conjugate beam method In the conjugate beam method, the length of the conjugate beam is the same as the length of the actual beam, the loading diagram (showing the loads acting) on the conjugate beam is simply the bending-moment diagram of the actual beam divided by the flexural rigidity EI of the actual beam, and the corresponding support condition for the conjugate beam is given by the rules as shown below.

Corresponding support condition for the conjugate beam Page 221 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Conjugates of Common Types of Real Beams Conjugate beams for statically determinate

Conjugate

beams

real beams

indeterminate real beams

for

Statically

By the conjugate beam method, the slope and deflection of the actual beam can be found by using the following two rules: x

The slope of the actual beam at any cross section is equal to the shearing force at the corresponding cross section of the conjugate beam.

x

The deflection of the actual beam at any point is equal to the bending moment of the conjugate beam at the corresponding point.

Procedure for Analysis x

Construct the M / EI diagram for the given (real) beam subjected to the specified (real) loading. If a combination of loading exists, you may use M-diagram by parts

x

Determine the conjugate beam corresponding to the given real beam

x

Apply the M / EI diagram as the load on the conjugate beam as per sign convention

x

Calculate the reactions at the supports of the conjugate beam by applying equations of equilibrium and conditions

x

Determine the shears in the conjugate beam at locations where slopes is desired in the

real beam, Vconj = Ç&#x2030;real x

Determine the bending moments in the conjugate beam at locations where deflections is desired in the real beam, Mconj = yreal

Page 222 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

The method of double integration, method of superposition, moment-area theorems, and Castiglianoâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s theorem are all well established methods for finding deflections of beams, but they require that the boundary conditions of the beams be known or specified. If not, all of them become helpless. However, the conjugate beam method is able to proceed and yield a solution for the possible deflections of the beam based on the support conditions, rather than the boundary conditions, of the beams.

(i) A Cantilever beam with a point load â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Pâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; at its free end. For Real Beam: At a section a distance â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;xâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; from free end consider the forces to the left. Taking moments about the section gives (obviously to the left of the section) Mx = -P.x (negative sign means that the moment on the left hand side of the portion is in the anticlockwise direction and is therefore taken as negative according to the sign convention) so that the maximum bending moment occurs at the fixed end i.e. Mmax = - PL ( at x = L)

Considering equilibrium we get, MA

wL2 and Reaction R A

3

wL 2

Considering any cross-section XX which is at a distance of x from the fixed end. At this point load (Wx )

Shear force Vx

W .x L

R A  area of triangle ANM

wL 1 Â§ w Âˇ wL wx 2 - . Â¨ .x Â¸ .x = + 2 2 ÂŠL Âš 2 2L ? The shear force variation is parabolic. wL at x 0, Vx  i.e. Maximum shear force, Vmax 2 at x L, Vx 0 Bending moment Mx = R A .x -

wx 2 2x . - MA 2L 3

Page 223 of 429



wL 2

Chapter-5 Deflection of Beam 3 2 wL wx wL = .x 2 6L 3 ? The bending moment variation is cubic

at x = 0, Mx



at x

0

L, Mx

wL2 i.e.Maximum B.M. Mmax

3



wL2 . 3

Page 224 of 429

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondal’s

OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Beam Deflection GATE-1. A lean elastic beam of given flexural rigidity, EI, is loaded by a single force F as shown in figure. How many boundary conditions are necessary to determine the deflected centre line of the beam? (a) 5

(b) 4

(c) 3

(d) 2

[GATE-1999] 2

GATE-1. Ans. (d) EI

dy dx 2

M . Since it is second order differential equation so we need two boundary

conditions to solve it.

Double Integration Method GATE-2.

A simply supported beam carrying a concentrated load W at mid-span deflects by ǅ1 under the load. If the same beam carries the load W such that it is distributed uniformly over entire length and undergoes a deflection ǅ2 at the mid span. The ratio ǅ1: ǅ2 is: (a) 2: 1

GATE-2. Ans. (d) G1

GATE-3.

(b)

Wl3 48EI

and G 2

[IES-1995; GATE-1994]

2:1 §W· 5 ¨ ¸ l4 © l ¹ 384EI

(c) 1: 1

(d) 1: 2

5Wl3 Therefore ǅ1: ǅ2 = 5: 8 384EI

A simply supported laterally loaded beam was found to deflect more than a specified value.

[GATE-2003]

Which of the following measures will reduce the deflection? (a)

Increase the area moment of inertia

(b)

Increase the span of the beam

(c)

Select a different material having lesser modulus of elasticity

(d)

Magnitude of the load to be increased

GATE-3. Ans. (a) Maximum deflection (ǅ) =

Wl3 48EI

To reduce, ǅ, increase the area moment of Inertia.

Page 225 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Previous 20-Years IES Questions Double Integration Method IES-1.

Consider the following statements: [IES-2003] In a cantilever subjected to a concentrated load at the free end 1. The bending stress is maximum at the free end 2. The maximum shear stress is constant along the length of the beam 3. The slope of the elastic curve is zero at the fixed end Which of these statements are correct? (a) 1, 2 and 3 (b) 2 and 3 (c) 1 and 3 (d) 1 and 2 IES-1. Ans. (b) IES-2.

A cantilever of length L, moment of inertia I. Young's modulus E carries a concentrated load W at the middle of its length. The slope of cantilever at the free end is: [IES-2001] (a)

WL2 2 EI

(b)

WL2 4 EI

(c)

WL2 8 EI

(d)

WL2 16 EI

2

Â?LÂŹ W Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; Â­Â­Â­ Â&#x17E;Â&#x; 2 ÂŽ WL2 IES-2. Ans. (c) R   2EI 8EI IES-3.

The two cantilevers A and B shown in the figure have the same uniform cross-section and the same material. Free end deflection of cantilever 'A' is Ç&#x2026;. The value of mid- span deflection of the cantilever â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Bâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; is:

1 a G 2

IES-3. Ans. (c) G

y mid

IES-4.

2 b G 3

c G

WL3 Â§ WL2 Âˇ 5WL3 Â¨ Â¸L 3EI ÂŠ 2EI Âš 6EI W Â§ 2Lx 2 x 3 Âˇ 5WL3  Â¨ Â¸ EI ÂŠ 2 6 Âšat x L 6EI

d 2G

G

A cantilever beam of rectangular cross-section is subjected to a load W at its free end. If the depth of the beam is doubled and the load is halved, the deflection of the free end as compared to original deflection will be: [IES-1999] (a) Half (b) One-eighth (c) One-sixteenth (d) Double

IES-4. Ans. (c) Deflectionin cantilever

Wl 3 3EI

Wl 3 u12 3Eah3

If h is doubled, and W is halved, New deflection IES-5.

[IES-2000]

4Wl 3 Eah3 4Wl 3 2 Ea 2h

3

=

1 4Wl 3 u 16 Eah3

A simply supported beam of constant flexural rigidity and length 2L carries a concentrated load 'P' at its mid-span and the deflection under the load is G . If a cantilever beam of the same flexural rigidity and length 'L' is subjected to load 'P' at its free end, then the deflection at the free end will be: [IES-1998]

1 a G 2

b G

c 2G

Page 226 of 429

d 4G

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

IES-5. Ans. (c)

W 2L

G for simply supported beam

48 EI

3

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

WL3 6 EI

3

and deflection for Cantilever IES-6.

WL 3EI

Two identical cantilevers are loaded as shown in the respective figures. If slope at the free end of the cantilever in figure E is Ç&#x2030;, the slope at free and of the cantilever in figure F will be:

2G

Figure E

Figure F [IES-1997]

(a)

1 T 3

(b)

1 T 2

(c)

2 T 3

IES-6. Ans. (d) When a B. M is applied at the free end of cantilever,

T

(d)

ML EI

PL / 2 L EI

When a cantilever is subjected to a single concentrated load at free end, then

IES-7.

PL2 2 EI PL2 2 EI

A cantilever beam carries a load W uniformly distributed over its entire length. If the same load is placed at the free end of the same cantilever, then the ratio of maximum deflection in the first case to that in the second case will be: [IES-1996] (a) 3/8 (b) 8/3 (c) 5/8 (d) 8/5

IES-7. Ans. (a) IES-8.

T

T

Wl 3 Wl 3 y 8 EI 3EI

3 8

The given figure shows a cantilever of span 'L' subjected to a concentrated load 'P' and a moment 'M' at the free end. Deflection at the free end is given by [IES-1996]

PL2 ML2 (a)  2 EI 3EI

ML2 PL3 (b)  2 EI 3EI

ML2 PL3 (c)  3EI 2 EI

ML2 PL3 (d)  2 EI 48 EI

IES-8. Ans. (b) IES-9.

For a cantilever beam of length 'L', flexural rigidity EI and loaded at its free end by a concentrated load W, match List I with List II and select the correct answer. [IES-1996] List I List II A. Maximum bending moment 1. Wl B. Strain energy 2. Wl2/2EI C. Maximum slope 3. Wl3/3EI D. Maximum deflection 4. W2l2/6EI Codes: A B C D A B C D (a) 1 4 3 2 (b) 1 4 2 3 (c) 4 2 1 3 (d) 4 3 1 2

IES-9. Ans. (b) IES-10.

Maximum deflection of a cantilever beam of length â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; carrying uniformly Page 227 of 429 distributed load w per unit length will be: [IES- 2008]

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam (a) wl4/ (EI)

(b) w l4/ (4 EI)

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

(c) w l4/ (8 EI)

(d) w l4/ (384 EI)

[Where E = modulus of elasticity of beam material and I = moment of inertia of beam cross-section] IES-10. Ans. (c)

IES-11.

A cantilever beam of length â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;lâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; is subjected to a concentrated load P at a distance of l/3 from the free end. What is the deflection of the free end of the beam? (EI is the flexural rigidity) [IES-2004]

2 Pl 3 (a) 81EI

3Pl 3 (b) 81EI

14 Pl 3 (c) 81EI

15 Pl 3 (d) 81EI

Moment Area method gives us

IES-11. Ans. (d)

GA

Area x EI

1 Â§ 2Pl Âˇ Â§ 2l Âˇ Â§ l 4 Âˇ u u u  l 2 Â¨ÂŠ 3 Â¸Âš Â¨ÂŠ 3 Â¸Âš Â¨ÂŠ 3 9 Â¸Âš EI Pl3 2 7 14 Pl3 u u EI 9 9 81 EI 2

Alternatively Ymax

IES-12.

Â§ 2l Âˇ WÂ¨ Â¸ Wa2 Â­ l a Â˝ ÂŠ 3 Âš Â­ l  2l / 3 Â˝ ÂŽ  Âž ÂŽ Âž EI ÂŻ 2 6 Âż EI ÂŻ 2 6 Âż Wl3 4 9  2

u u EI 9 18 14 Wl3 81 EI

A 2 m long beam BC carries a single concentrated load at its mid-span and is simply supported at its ends by two cantilevers AB = 1 m long and CD = 2 m long as shown in the figure. The shear force at end A of the cantilever AB will be (a) Zero (b) 40 kg (c) 50 kg (d) 60 kg

[IES-1997]

IES-12. Ans. (c) Reaction force on B and C is same 100/2 = 50 kg. And we know that shear force is same throughout its length and equal to load at free end. IES-13. Assertion (A): In a simply supported beam subjected to a concentrated load P at mid-span, the elastic curve slope becomes zero under the load. [IES-2003] Reason (R): The deflection of the beam is maximum at mid-span. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IES-13. Ans. (a) IES-14.

At a certain section at a distance 'x' from one of the supports of a simply supported beam, the intensity of loading, bending moment and shear force arc Wx, Mx and Vx respectively. If the intensity of loading is varying continuously along the length of the beam, then the invalid relation is: [IES-2000]

a Slope Qx

Mx Vx

b Vx

dM x dx

c Wx

IES-14. Ans. (a) Page 228 of 429

d 2M x dx 2

d Wx

dVx dx

Chapter-5 IES-15.

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondal’s

The bending moment equation, as a function of distance x measured from the left end, for a simply supported beam of span L m carrying a uniformly distributed load of intensity w N/m will be given by [IES-1999]

wL w 3 L-x - L-x Nm 2 2 wL 2 w 3 c M= L-x - L-x Nm 2 2

wL w 2 x - x Nm 2 2 wL 2 wLx Nm d M= x 2 2

a M=

b M=

IES-15. Ans. (b) IES-16.

A simply supported beam with width 'b' and depth ’d’ carries a central load W and undergoes deflection ǅ at the centre. If the width and depth are interchanged, the deflection at the centre of the beam would attain the value [IES-1997]

d a G b

2

3

d b §¨ ·¸ G ©b¹

IES-16. Ans. (b) Deflection at center G

d c §¨ ·¸ G ©b¹ Wl3 48EI

In second case, deflection G c

3/2

G

Wl3 § bd3 · 48E ¨ ¸ © 12 ¹

Wl 3 48EI c

Wl 3 § db3 · 48 E ¨ ¸ © 12 ¹

Wl 3 d2 § bd 3 · b 2 48 E ¨ ¸ © 12 ¹

d2 G b2

IES-17.

A simply supported beam of rectangular section 4 cm by 6 cm carries a midspan concentrated load such that the 6 cm side lies parallel to line of action of loading; deflection under the load is ǅ. If the beam is now supported with the 4 cm side parallel to line of action of loading, the deflection under the load will be: [IES-1993] (a) 0.44 ǅ (b) 0.67 ǅ (c) 1.5 ǅ (d) 2.25 ǅ IES-17. Ans. (d) Use above explanation IES-18.

A simply supported beam carrying a concentrated load W at mid-span deflects by ǅ1 under the load. If the same beam carries the load W such that it is distributed uniformly over entire length and undergoes a deflection ǅ2 at the [IES-1995; GATE-1994] mid span. The ratio ǅ1: ǅ2 is: (a) 2: 1

IES-18. Ans. (d) G1

(b)

Wl3 48EI

2:1

and G 2

(c) 1: 1

§W· 5 ¨ ¸ l4 © l ¹ 384EI

(d) 1: 2

5Wl3 Therefore ǅ1: ǅ2 = 5: 8 384EI

Moment Area Method IES-19.

Match List-I with List-II and select the correct answer using the codes given below the Lists: [IES-1997] List-I List-II 1. Moment area method A. Toughness B. Endurance strength 2. Hardness C. Resistance to abrasion 3. Energy absorbed before fracture in a tension test D. Deflection in a beam 4. Fatigue loading Code: A B C D A B C D (a) 4 3 1 2 (b) 4 3 2 1 (c) 3 4 2 1 (d) 3 4 1 2 IES-19. Ans. (c) Page 229 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondal’s

Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Slope and Deflection at a Section IAS-1.

Which one of the following is represented by the area of the S.F diagram from one end upto a given location on the beam? [IAS-2004] (a) B.M. at the location (b) Load at the location (c) Slope at the location (d) Deflection at the location IAS-1. Ans. (a)

Double Integration Method IAS-2.

Which one of the following is the correct statement? If for a beam

dM dx

[IAS-2007]

0 for its whole length, the beam is a cantilever:

(a) Free from any load (b) Subjected to a concentrated load at its free end (c) Subjected to an end moment (d) Subjected to a udl over its whole span IAS-2. Ans. (c) udl or point load both vary with x. But if we apply Bending Moment (M) = const. and

dM dx

0

IAS-3.

In a cantilever beam, if the length is doubled while keeping the cross-section and the concentrated load acting at the free end the same, the deflection at the free end will increase by [IAS-1996] (a) 2.66 times (b) 3 times (c) 6 times (d) 8 times IAS-3. Ans. (d)

G

PL3 3EI

3

? G fL

G ? 2 G1

§ L2 · ¨ ¸ © L1 ¹

3

8

Conjugate Beam Method IAS-4.

By conjugate beam method, the slope at any section of an actual beam is equal to: [IAS-2002] (a) EI times the S.F. of the conjugate beam (b) EI times the B.M. of the conjugate beam (c) S.F. of conjugate beam (d) B.M. of the conjugate beam IAS-4. Ans. (c) IAS-5.

I = 375 × 10-6 m4; l = 0.5 m E = 200 GPa Determine the stiffness of the beam shown in the above figure (a) 12 × 1010 N/m (b) 10 × 1010 N/m (c) 4 × 1010 N/m (d) 8 × 1010 N/m

[IES-2002] IAS-5. Ans. (c) Stiffness means required load for unit deformation. BMD of the given beam Page 230 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

The deflection at the free end of the actual beam = BM of the at fixed point of conjugate beam 3 Â?1 ÂŹÂ­ Â? ÂŹ Â? ÂŹ Â? ÂŹ ML ÂŹÂ­ 2L Â?Â&#x17E; WL Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E;L L Â­Â­ Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; 1 q L q WL Â­Â­q Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E;L 2L Â­Â­  3WL y  Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E; q L q q

q L q Â­ Â­ Â&#x17E; Â&#x17E;Â&#x; 2 ÂŽÂ­ Â&#x;Â&#x17E; 2 ÂŽÂ­ Â&#x;Â&#x17E; 2 2EI ÂŽÂ­ Â&#x;Â&#x17E; 3 ÂŽÂ­ 2EI EI ÂŽÂ­ 3 Â&#x;Â&#x17E; 2EI 9 6 W 2EI 2 q 200 q10 q 375 q10

Or stiffness =  3   4 q1010 N / m 3 y 3L 3 q 0.5

Page 231 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question GATE-1999 Question:

Consider the signboard mounting shown in figure below. The wind load acting perpendicular to the plane of the figure is F = 100 N. We wish to limit the deflection, due to bending, at point A of the hollow cylindrical pole of outer diameter 150 mm to 5 mm. Find the wall thickness for the pole. [Assume E = 2.0 X 1011 N/m2]

Given: F = 100 N; d0 = 150 mm, 0.15 my = 5 mm; E = 2.0 X 1O11 N/m2 Thickness of pole, t The system of signboard mounting can be considered as a cantilever loaded at A i.e. W = 100 N and also having anticlockwise moment of M = 100 x 1 = 100 Nm at the free end. Deflection of cantilever having concentrated load at the free end,

WL3 ML2  3EI 2EI 100 u 53 100 u 53 5 u 10 3  3 u 2.0 u 1011 u I 2 u 2.0 u 1011 u I ÂŞ 100 u 53 1 100 u 53 Âş  I ÂŤ Âť 5 u 10 3 ÂŹ 3 u 2.0 u 1011 2 u 2.0 u 1011 Âź y

or

But ?

5.417 u 10 6 m4

S 4 d0  di4

64 S 5.417 u 106 0.15 4  di4

64 I

or

di

0.141m or 141 mm

?

t

d0  di 2

150  141 2

4.5 mm

Conventional Question IES-2003 Question:

Find the slope and deflection at the free end of a cantilever beam of length 6m as loaded shown in figure below, using method of superposition. Evaluate their numerical value using E = 200 GPa, I = 1Ă&#x2014;10-4 m4 and W = 1 kN.

Page 232 of 429

Deflection of Beam We have to theory. 1st consider

use

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

superposition

PL3 (3W ) q 23 8W   3EI 3EI EI 2 2 PL (3W ).2 6W   È&#x2122;c  2EI 2EI EI Ä¯c

Deflection at A due to this load(Ä¯1 ) = Ä¯ c Rc .(6  2) =

8W 6W 32W

q4  EI EI EI

2nd consider:

2W q 43

128W 3EI 3EI 2 (2W ) q 4 16W RB   EI 2EI Deflection at A due to this load(Ä¯ 2 ) Ä¯B

=Ä¯B RB q (6  4)=

224W 3EI

.

3rd consider : W q 63 72W  3EI EI W q 62 18W RA   2EI EI

(Ä¯3 )  Ä¯ A

Apply superpositioning form ula È&#x2122;=È&#x2122; A È&#x2122; B È&#x2122; c

40 q 10 3

6W 16W 18W 40W

EI EI EI EI 200 q 10 9 q 10  4

32W 224W 72W 40W 563Ã&#x2014;W =

EI EI EI 3 EI 3EI 563Ã&#x2014;(10 3 ) =  8.93 m m 3 q (200 q 10 9 ) q 10  4

Ä¯  Ä¯1 Ä¯ 2 Ä¯ 3

Conventional Question IES-2002 Question:

If two cantilever beams of identical dimensions but made of mild steel and grey cast iron are subjected to same point load at the free end, within elastic limit, which one will deflect more and why?

Grey cost iron will deflect more.

We know that a cantilever beam of length 'L' end load 'P' will deflect at free end (E ) =

PL3 3EI Page 233 of 429

Chapter-5

Deflection of Beam

S K Mondal’s

1 E ECast Iron  125 GPa and EMild steel  200 GPa =E r

Conventional Question IES-1997 Question:

A uniform cantilever beam (EI = constant) of length L is carrying a concentrated load P at its free end. What would be its slope at the (i) Free end and (ii) Built in end P PL2 (i) Free end, ș = (ii) Built-in end,

2EI ș0

L

Page 234 of 429

6.

Bending Stress in Beam

Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) 6.1 Euler Bernoulliâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Equation or (Bending stress formula) or Bending Equation

V y Where

M I

E R

V = Bending Stress M = Bending Moment I

= Moment of Inertia

E = Modulus of elasticity R = Radius of curvature y = Distance of the fibre from NA (Neutral axis)

6.2 Assumptions in Simple Bending Theory All of the foregoing theory has been developed for the case of pure bending i.e. constant B.M along the length of the beam. In such case

x

The shear force at each c/s is zero.

x

Normal stress due to bending is only produced.

x

Beams are initially straight

x

The material is homogenous and isotropic i.e. it has a uniform composition and its mechanical properties are the same in all directions

x

The stress-strain relationship is linear and elastic

x

Youngâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Modulus is the same in tension as in compression

x

Sections are symmetrical about the plane of bending

x

Sections which are plane before bending remain plane after bending

6.3

Page 235 of 429

Chapter-6

Bending Stress in Beam

V max V t

Mc1 I

V min V c

Mc2 I

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

(Minimum in sense of sign)

6.4 Section Modulus (Z)

I Z= y x

Z is a function of beam c/s only

x

Z is other name of the strength of the beam

x

The strength of the beam sections depends mainly on the section modulus

V

M Z

x

The flexural formula may be written as,

x

Rectangular c/s of width is "b" & depth "h" with sides horizontal, Z =

x

Square beam with sides horizontal, Z =

x

Square c/s with diagonal horizontal, Z =

x

Circular c/s of diameter "d", Z =

a3 6 a3 6 2

Sd3 32

Page 236 of 429

bh 2 6

Chapter-6

Bending Stress in Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

A log diameter "d" is available. It is proposed to cut out a strongest beam from it. Then Z=

b( d 2  b 2 ) 6

Therefore, Zmax =

bd 3 d for b = 9 3

6.5 Flexural Rigidity (EI) Reflects both

x

Stiffness of the material (measured by E)

x

Proportions of the c/s area (measured by I )

6.6 Axial Rigidity = EA 6.7 Beam of uniform strength It is one is which the maximum bending stress is same in every section along the longitudinal axis.

M D bh 2

For it

Where b = Width of beam h = Height of beam To make Beam of uniform strength the section of the beam may be varied by

x

Keeping the width constant throughout the length and varying the depth, (Most widely used)

x

Keeping the depth constant throughout the length and varying the width

x

By varying both width and depth suitably.

6.8 Bending stress due to additional Axial thrust (P). A shaft may be subjected to a combined bending and axial thrust. This type of situation arises in various machine elements. If P = Axial thrust

Then direct stress ( V d ) = P / A (stress due to axial thrust) This direct stress ( V d ) may be tensile or compressive depending upon the load P is tensile or compressive. Page 237 of 429

Chapter-6

Bending Stress in Beam

And the bending stress ( V b ) =

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

My is varying linearly from zero at centre and extremum (minimum I

or maximum) at top and bottom fibres.

If P is compressive then

P My  A I

V

x

At top fibre

x

At mid fibre

x

At bottom fibre

(compressive)

P A

V V

(compressive)

P My â&#x20AC;&#x201C; (compressive) A I

6.9 Load acting eccentrically to one axis x

V max

P P u e y  A I

x

V min

P P u e y  A I

where â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;eâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; is the eccentricity at which â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Pâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; is act.

Condition for No tension in any section x

For no tension in any section, the eccentricity must not exceed

2k 2 d

[Where d = depth of the section; k = radius of gyration of c/s]

h 6

x

For rectangular section (b x h) , e d

x

For circular section of diameter â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; , e d

For hollow circular section of diameter â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;dâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; , e d

d 8

h of the middle section. 3

i.e. diameter of the kernel, 2e

D2  d 2 8D

d 4

i.e. diameter of the kernel, 2e d

Page 238 of 429

D2  d 2 . 4D

Chapter-6

Bending Stress in Beam

S K Mondal’s

OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Bending equation GATE-1.

A cantilever beam has the square cross section 10mm × 10 mm. It carries a transverse load of 10 N. Considering only the bottom fibres of the beam, the correct representation of the longitudinal variation of the bending stress is:

GATE-1. Ans. (a) Mx

P.x

M I

V y

or V

[GATE-2005]

My I

10 u x u 0.005

0.01

4

60.(x) MPa

12 At x 0; V 0 At x 1m; V 60MPa And it is linear as V f x GATE-2.

Two beams, one having square cross section and another circular cross-section, are subjected to the same amount of bending moment. If the cross sectional area as well as the material of both the beams are the same then [GATE-2003] (a) Maximum bending stress developed in both the beams is the same (b) The circular beam experiences more bending stress than the square one (c) The square beam experiences more bending stress than the circular one (d) As the material is same both the beams will experience same deformation M E V My ; or V ; GATE-2. Ans. (b) I U y I

V sq ? V sq

§a· M¨ ¸ ©2¹ 1 a.a3 12  V cir

6M ; a3

V cir

§d· M¨ ¸ ©2¹ S d4 64

32M S d3

4S S M 22.27M a3 a3

ª S d2 « ¬ 4

º a2 » ¼

Section Modulus GATE-3.

Match the items in Columns I and II. Column-I Column-II 1. Cam P. Addendum Page 239 of 429 2. Beam Q. Instantaneous centre of velocity

[GATE-2006]

Chapter-6

Bending Stress in Beam

R. Section modulus S. Prime circle (a) P â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 4, Q â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2, R â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 3, S â&#x20AC;&#x201C; l (c) P â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 3, Q â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2, R â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1, S â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 4 GATE-3. Ans. (b)

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

3. Linkage 4. Gear (b) P â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 4, Q â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 3, R â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2, S â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1 (d) P â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 3, Q â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 4, R â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 1, S â&#x20AC;&#x201C; 2

Combined direct and bending stress GATE-4.

For the component loaded with a force F as shown in the figure, the axial stress at the corner point P is: [GATE-2008]

(a)

F (3L  b) 4b3

(b)

F (3L  b) 4b3

(c)

F (3L  4b) 4b3

(d)

F (3L  2b) 4b3

GATE-4. Ans. (d) Total Stress = Direct stress + Stress due to Moment =

P My F F (L  b ) q b

2

A I 4b 2b q ( b )3 12

Previous 20-Years IES Questions Bending equation IES-1.

Beam A is simply supported at its ends and carries udl of intensity w over its entire length. It is made of steel having Young's modulus E. Beam B is cantilever and carries a udl of intensity w/4 over its entire length. It is made of brass having Young's modulus E/2. The two beams are of same length and have same cross-sectional area. If Ç&#x201D;A and Ç&#x201D;B denote the maximum bending stresses developed in beams A and B, respectively, then which one of the following is correct? [IES-2005] (a) Ç&#x201D;A/Ç&#x201D;B (b) Ç&#x201D;A/Ç&#x201D;B < 1.0 (d) Ç&#x201D;A/Ç&#x201D;B depends on the shape of cross-section (c) Ç&#x201D;A/Ç&#x201D;B > 1.0 My , y and I both depends on the IES-1. Ans. (d) Bending stress V

I Shape of cross  sec tion so

IES-2.

VA depends on the shape of cross  sec tion VB

If the area of cross-section of a circular section beam is made four times, keeping the loads, length, support conditions and material of the beam unchanged, then the qualities (List-I) will change through different factors (List-II). Match the List-I with the List-II and select the correct answer using the code given below the Lists: [IES-2005] List-I List-II Page 240 of 429 A. Maximum BM 1. 8

Chapter-6

Bending Stress in Beam

S K Mondal’s

B. Deflection 2. 1 C. Bending Stress 3. 1/8 D. Section Modulus 4. 1/16 Codes: A B C D A (a) 3 1 2 4 (b) 2 (c) 3 4 2 1 (d) 2 IES-2. Ans. (b) Diameter will be double, D = 2d. A. Maximum BM will be unaffected B. deflection ratio C. Bending stress

EI1 EI2

V

4

B 4 1

C 3 3

D 1 4

1 16 M d / 2

My I

or Bending stress ratio

S d4

V2 V1

3

1 8

64

D. Selection Modulus ratio

Z2 Z1

I2 y1 u y1 I1

3

8

IES-3.

Consider the following statements in case of beams: [IES-2002] 1. Rate of change of shear force is equal to the rate of loading at a particular section 2. Rate of change of bending moment is equal to the shear force at a particular suction. 3. Maximum shear force in a beam occurs at a point where bending moment is either zero or bending moment changes sign Which of the above statements are correct? (a) 1 alone (b) 2 alone (c) 1 and 2 (d) 1, 2 and 3 IES-3. Ans. (c) IES-4.

Match List-I with List-II and select the correct answer using the code given below the Lists: [IES-2006] List-I (State of Stress) List-II (Kind of Loading)

Codes: (a) (c) IES-4. Ans. (c)

A 2 2

B 1 4

C 3 3

D 4 1

1.

Combined bending and torsion of circular shaft

2.

Torsion of circular shaft

3.

Thin cylinder pressure

4.

Tie bar subjected to tensile force

(b) (d)

Page 241 of 429

A 3 3

B 4 1

subjected

C 2 2

to

D 1 4

internal

Chapter-6

Bending Stress in Beam

S K Mondal’s

Section Modulus IES-5.

Two beams of equal cross-sectional area are subjected to equal bending moment. If one beam has square cross-section and the other has circular section, then [IES-1999] (a) Both beams will be equally strong (b) Circular section beam will be stronger (c) Square section beam will be stronger (d) The strength of the beam will depend on the nature of loading

IES-5. Ans. (b) If D is diameter of circle and 'a' the side of square section, Z for circular section =

IES-6.

Sd2 32

a3 ; 4 S

4

d2

4

a 2 or d

and Z for square section =

S

a

a3 6

A beam cross-section is used in two different orientations as shown in the given figure: Bending moments applied to the beam in both cases are same. The maximum bending stresses induced in cases (A) and (B) are related as: (a) V A 4V B (b) V A 2V B (c)

VB

VA

2

(d)

VA

VB [IES-1997]

4 2

M

Z A .V A

Z B .V B

bd , ZA 6 b3 b3 or V A VB, 24 12

IES-6. Ans. (b) Z for rectangular section is

IES-7.

S

2 3

b , 24 or V A

ZB

b 2 ub 2 6

b3 12

2V B

A horizontal beam with square cross-section is simply supported with sides of the square horizontal and vertical and carries a distributed loading that produces maximum bending stress a in the beam. When the beam is placed with one of the diagonals horizontal the maximum bending stress will be: [IES-1993]

(a)

1 V 2

IES-7. Ans. (c) Bending stress =

(b) V

(c)

2V

(d) 2V

M Z

a3 For rectangular beam with sides horizontal and vertical, Z = 6 3 a For same section with diagonal horizontal, Z = 6 2

? Ratio of two stresses = 2 IES-8.

Which one of the following combinations of angles will carry the maximum load as a column? [IES-1994]

Page 242 of 429

Chapter-6

Bending Stress in Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

IES-8. Ans. (a) IES-9.

Assertion (A): For structures steel I-beams preferred to other shapes. [IES-1992] Reason (R): In I-beams a large portion of their cross-section is located far from the neutral axis. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IES-9. Ans. (a)

Combined direct and bending stress IES-10.

Assertion (A): A column subjected to eccentric load will have its stress at centroid independent of the eccentricity. [IES-1994] Reason (R): Eccentric loads in columns produce torsion. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IES-10. Ans. (c) A is true and R is false. IES-11. For the configuration of loading shown in the given figure, the stress in fibre AB is given by: [IES-1995] (a) P/A (tensile)

(c)

(b)

Â§ P P.e.5 Âˇ Â¨  Â¸ (Compressive) ÂŠ A I xx Âš

IES-11. Ans. (b)

Vd

P (compressive), V x A

Â§ P P.e.5 Âˇ Â¨  Â¸ (Compressive) ÂŠ A I xx Âš

(d) P/A (Compressive)

My Ix

Pky (tensile) Ix

Page 243 of 429

Chapter-6 IES-12.

Bending Stress in Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

A column of square section 40 mm Ă&#x2014; 40 mm, fixed to the ground carries an eccentric load P of 1600 N as shown in the figure. If the stress developed along the edge CD is â&#x20AC;&#x201C;1.2 N/mm2, the stress along the edge AB will be: (a) (b) (c) (d)

â&#x20AC;&#x201C;1.2 N/mm2 +1 N/mm2 +0.8 N/mm2 â&#x20AC;&#x201C;0.8 N/mm2

[IES-1999] IES-12. Ans. (d) Compressive stress at CD = 1.2 N/mm2 =

or

IES-13.

6e 20

0.2. Sostress at AB 

P Â§ 6e Âˇ 1600 Â§ 6e Âˇ Â¨1  Â¸ Â¨1  Â¸ AÂŠ b Âš 1600 ÂŠ 20 Âš

1600 1  0.2 0.8 N/mm2 (com) 1600

A short column of symmetric crosssection made of a brittle material is subjected to an eccentric vertical load P at an eccentricity e. To avoid tensile stress in the short column, the eccentricity e should be less than or equal to: (a) h/12 (b) h/6 (c) h/3 (d) h/2

[IES-2001] IES-13. Ans. (b) IES-14.

A short column of external diameter D and internal diameter d carries an eccentric load W. Toe greatest eccentricity which the load can have without producing tension on the cross-section of the column would be: [IES-1999]

Dd (a) 8

D2  d 2 (b) 8d

D2  d 2 (c) 8D

IES-14. Ans. (c) Page 244 of 429

(d)

D2  d 2 8

Chapter-6

Bending Stress in Beam

S K Mondal’s

Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Bending equation IAS-1.

Consider the cantilever loaded as shown below:

[IAS-2004]

What is the ratio of the maximum compressive to the maximum tensile stress? (a) 1.0 (b) 2.0 (c) 2.5 (d) 3.0 IAS-1. Ans. (b) ǔ=

My I

V compressive, Max

ǔ tensile, max =

IAS-2.

M § 2h · u ¨ ¸ at lower end of A. I © 3 ¹

M §h· u ¨ ¸ at upper end of B I ©3¹

A 0.2 mm thick tape goes over a frictionless pulley of 25 mm diameter. If E of the material is 100 GPa, then the maximum stress induced in the tape is: [IAS 1994] (a) 100 MPa (b) 200 MPa (c) 400 MPa (d) 800 MPa

IAS-2. Ans. (d)

V y or V

0.2 E Here y = 2 R

0.1 mm = 0.1 x 10-3 m, R =

25 mm = 12.5 x 10-3 m 2

100 u 103 u 0.1 u 10 3 MPa = 800MPa 12.5 u 10 3

Section Modulus IAS-3.

A pipe of external diameter 3 cm and internal diameter 2 cm and of length 4 m is supported at its ends. It carries a point load of 65 N at its centre. The sectional modulus of the pipe Page will245 be:of 429 [IAS-2002]

Chapter-6

Bending Stress in Beam (a)

65S cm3 64

IAS-3. Ans. (c) Section modulus (z)

IAS-4.

(d)

65S cm3 128

A Cantilever beam of rectangular cross-section is 1m deep and 0.6 m thick. If the beam were to be 0.6 m deep and 1m thick, then the beam would. [IAS-1999] (a) Be weakened 0.5 times (b) Be weakened 0.6 times (c) Be strengthened 0.6 times (d) Have the same strength as the original beam because the cross-sectional area remains the same

IAS-4. Ans. (b)

z1

I y

and z2 ?

IAS-5.

65S 65S cm3 cm3 (c) 32 96 S 4 4 3 2

65S I 64 cm3 cm3 3 y 96 2

(b)

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

z2 z1

0.6 u 13 0.5 I y 0.72 1.2

1.2m3

1u 0.63 0.3

0.72m3

0.6 times

A T-beam shown in the given figure is subjected to a bending moment such that plastic hinge forms. The distance of the neutral axis from D is (all dimensions are in mm) (a) Zero (b) 109 mm (c) 125 mm (d) 170 mm

[IAS-2001] IAS-5. Ans. (b)

IAS-6.

Assertion (A): I, T and channel sections are preferred for beams. [IAS-2000] Reason(R): A beam cross-section should be such that the greatest possible amount of area is as far away from the neutral axis as possible. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true Page 246 429 IAS-6. Ans. (a) Because it will increase area moment ofofinertia, i.e. strength of the beam.

Chapter-6 IAS-7.

Bending Stress in Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

If the T-beam cross-section shown in the given figure has bending stress of 30 MPa in the top fiber, then the stress in the bottom fiber would be (G is centroid) (a) Zero (b) 30 MPa (c) â&#x20AC;&#x201C;80 MPa (d) 50 Mpa

[IAS-2000] IAS-7. Ans. (c)

M I

V1

V2

y1

y2

or V 2

y2 u

V1 y1

30 110  30 u 30

80 MPa

As top fibre in tension so bottom fibre will be in compression. Assertion (A): A square section is more economical in bending than the circular section of same area of cross-section. [IAS-1999] Reason (R): The modulus of the square section is less than of circular section of same area of cross-section. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-8. ans. (c)

IAS-8.

Bimetallic Strip IAS-9.

A straight bimetallic strip of copper and steel is heated. It is free at ends. The strip, will: [IAS-2002] (a) Expand and remain straight (b) Will not expand but will bend (c) Will expand and bend also (d) Twist only IAS-9. Ans. (c) As expansion of copper will be more than steel.

Combined direct and bending stress IAS-10.

A short vertical column having a square cross-section is subjected to an axial compressive force, centre of pressure of which passes through point R as shown in the above figure. Maximum compressive stress occurs at point (a) S (b) Q (c) R (d) P [IAS-2002]

IAS-10. Ans. (a) As direct and bending both the stress is compressive here. IAS-11.

A strut's cross-sectional area A is subjected to load P a point S (h, k) as shown in the given figure. The stress at the point Q (x, y) is: [IAS-2000]

Page 247 of 429

Chapter-6

Bending Stress in Beam

P Phy Pkx   A Ix Iy P Phx Pky  (b)   A Iy Ix P Phy Pkx   (c) A Iy Ix P Phx Pky   (d) A Iy Ix (a)

IAS-11. Ans. (b) All stress are compressive, direct stress,

P My Pky (compressive), V x (compressive) A Ix Ix Mx Phx and V y (compressive) Iy Iy

Vd

Page 248 of 429

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Chapter-6

Bending Stress in Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question IES-2008 Question:

A Simply supported beam AB of span length 4 m supports a uniformly distributed load of intensity q = 4 kN/m spread over the entire span and a concentrated load P = 2 kN placed at a distance of 1.5 m from left end A. The beam is constructed of a rectangular cross-section with width b = 10 cm and depth d = 20 cm. Determine the maximum tensile and compressive stresses developed in the beam to bending.

X

2KN

4kN/M

A

B 1.5 4m

NA

RA

RB B=10cm

X

C/s

R A + RB = 2 + 4Ă&#x2014;4.........(i) -R A Ă&#x2014;4 + 2Ă&#x2014;(4-1.5) + (4Ă&#x2014;4)Ă&#x2014;2=0.......(ii) or R A = 9.25 kN, RB =18-R A = 8.75 kN if 0 b x b 2.5 m

2 -2(x-2.5)

Mx =RB Ă&#x2014;x - 4x. x

=8.75x - 2x 2 - 2x + 5 = 6.75x - 2x 2 + 5

...(ii)

From (i) & (ii) we find out that bending movment at x = 2.1875 m in(i) gives maximum bending movement

dM for both the casses] dx  8.25 q 2.1875  2 q18752  9.57K 7kNm

[Just find Mmax

bh3 0.1q 0.23   6.6667 q105 m 4 12 12 Maximum distance from NA is y = 10 cm = 0.1m

Area movement of Inertia (I) =

Tmax

My (9.57 q103 )q 0.1 N   14.355MPa m2 I 6.6667 q105

Therefore maximum tensile stress in the lowest point in the beam is 14.355 MPa and maximum compressive stress in the topmost fiber of the beam is -14.355 MPa.

Conventional Question IES-2007 Question:

A simply supported beam made of rolled steel joist (I-section: 450mm Ă&#x2014; 200mm) has a span of 5 m and it carriers a central concentrated load W. The flanges are strengthened by two 300mm Ă&#x2014; 20mm plates, one riveted to each flange over the entire length of the flanges. The second moment of area of the Page 249 of 429 joist about the principal bending axis is 35060 cm4. Calculate

Chapter-6

Bending Stress in Beam (i) (ii)

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

The greatest central load the beam will carry if the bending stress in the 300mm/20mm plates is not to exceed 125 MPa. The minimum length of the 300 mm plates required to restrict the maximum bending stress is the flanges of the joist to 125 MPa.

Moment of Inertia of the total section about X-X (I) = moment of inertia of I â&#x20AC;&#x201C;section + moment of inertia of the plates about X-X axis. 2 Â 30 q 23 Â? 45 2 ÂŹÂ­ ÂŻÂ° ÂĄ Â&#x17E;  35060 2 ÂĄ

30 q 2 qÂ&#x17E; Â­Â­ Â°  101370 cm 4 Â&#x17E;Â&#x; 2 12 2 ÂŽ Â°Âą ÂĄÂ˘

(i) Greatest central point load(W): For a simply supported beam a concentrated load at centre. WL W q 5   1.25W M= 4 4 6 8 Äą.I 125 q10 q 101370 q10

517194Nm M y 0.245 = 1.25W = 517194 or W = 413.76 kN (ii) Suppose the cover plates are absent for a distance of x-meters from each support. Then at these points the bending moment must not exceed moment of resistance of â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;Iâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; section alone i.e

35060 q108

Äą.I 6  125 q10 q  178878Nm y 0.245 = Bending moment at x metres from each support

Page 250 of 429

Chapter-6

Bending Stress in Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

W q x  178878 2 41760 q x  178878 or , 2 or x  0.86464 m Hence leaving 0.86464 m from each support, for the

=

middle 5 - 2Ă&#x2014;0.86464 = 3.27 m the cover plate should be provided. Conventional Question IES-2002 Question:

Calculate:

A beam of rectangular cross-section 50 mm wide and 100 mm deep is simply supported over a span of 1500 mm. It carries a concentrated load of 50 kN, 500 mm from the left support. (i) The maximum tensile stress in the beam and indicate where it occurs: (ii) The vertical deflection of the beam at a point 500 mm from the right support. E for the material of the beam = 2 Ă&#x2014; 105 MPa.

RR q1500  50 q 500 or , RR  16.667 kN or , RL RR  50 = RL  50  16.667=33.333 kN Take a section from right R, x-x at a distance x.

Bending moment (Mx )  RR .x

Therefore maximum bending moment will occur at 'c' Mmax=16.667Ă&#x2014;1 KNm (i) Moment of Inertia of beam cross-section

(I )

bh3 0.050q (0.100)3 4 m = 4.1667Ă&#x2014;106 m 4  12 12

Applying bending equation M Äą E   I y S

or, Äą max

My  I

Â? 0.001ÂŹÂ­ Â­ 2 ÂŽÂ­ N / m 2  200MPa 4.1667 q106

16.67q103 qÂ&#x17E;Â&#x17E;Â&#x17E;Â&#x;

It will occure where M is maximum at point 'C' (ii) Macaulay's method for determing the deflection of the beam will be convenient as there is point load. M x  EI

d2y  33.333q x  50q ( x  0.5) dx 2

Page 251 of 429

Chapter-6

Bending Stress in Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Integrate both side we get d2 y x 2 50  33.333 q  ( x  0.5)2 c1 x c2 2 dx 2 2 at x=0, y=0 gives c2  0 EI

at x=1.5, y=0 gives 0=5.556Ă&#x2014;(1.5)3  8.333q13 c1 q1.5 or , c1  6.945 = EIy  5.556q x 3 8.333( x  0.5)3  6.945q1  2.43 or , y

2.43 m = -2.9167 mm[downward so -ive] (2Ă&#x2014;10 q10 )q (4.1667q106 ) 5

6

Conventional Question AMIE-1997 Question:

If the beam cross-section is rectangular having a width of 75 mm, determine the required depth such that maximum bending stress induced in the beam does not exceed 40 MN/m2 Given: b =75 mm =0Âˇ075 m, V max =40 MN/m2 Depth of the beam, d: Figure below shows a rectangular section of width b = 0Âˇ075 m and depth d metres. The bending is considered to take place about the horizontal neutral axis N.A. shown in the figure. The maximum bending stress occurs at the outer

d above or below the neutral axis. Any 2 My , where I fibre at a distance y from N.A. is subjected to a bending stress, V I bd3 denotes the second moment of area of the rectangular section about the N.A. i.e. . 12 d , the maximum bending stress there becomes At the outer fibres, y = 2 fibres of the rectangular section at a distance

or

Â§dÂˇ Mu Â¨ Â¸ ÂŠ2Âš V max bd3 12 bd2 M V max . 6

M bd2 6

    i

   (ii)

For the condition of maximum strength i.e. maximum moment M, the product bd2 must be a maximum, since V max is constant for a given material. To maximize the quantity bd2 we realise that it must be expressed in terms of one independent variable, say, b, and we may do this from the right angle triangle relationship. Page 252 of 429

Chapter-6

Bending Stress in Beam 2

2

b d

D

2

or

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

2

D2  b 2

d

Multiplying both sides by b, we get bd2 bD2  b3 To maximize bd2 we take the first derivative of expression with respect to b and set it equal to zero, as follows:

d bd2 db

d bD2  b3 db

D2  3b2

b2  d2  3b2

d2  2b2

0

...(iii) Solving, we have, depth d 2 b This is the desired radio in order that the beam will carry a maximum moment M. It is to be noted that the expression appearing in the denominator of the right side of eqn. (i) i. e.

bd2 is the section modulus (Z) of a rectangular bar. Thus, it follows; the 6

section modulus is actually the quantity to be maximized for greatest strength of the beam. Using the relation (iii), we have d=

2 x 0Âˇ075 = 0Âˇ0106 m

Now, M = V max x Z = V max x

bd2 6

Substituting the values, we get M = 40 Ă&#x2014;

V max

M Z

0.075 u 0.106

2

= 0.005618 MNm

6 0.005618 0.075 u 0.106 2 / 6

40MN / m2

Hence, the required depth d = 0Âˇ106 m = 106 mm

Page 253 of 429

7.

Shear Stress in Beam

Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) 1. Shear stress in bending ( W ) W =

vQ Ib

Where, V = Shear force =

dM dx c1

Q = Statical moment =

³ ydA y1

I = Moment of inertia b = Width of beam c/s.

2. Statical Moment (Q) c1

Q=

³ ydA = Shaded Area × distance of the centroid of the shaded area from the neutral axis of y1

the c/s.

3. Variation of shear stress Section

Diagram

Position

of

W max

W max Rectangular

N.A

W max =

3V 2A

W max 1.5W mean W NA Circular

N.A

W max

Page 254 of 429

4 W mean 3

Chapter-7

Shear Stress in Beam

Triangular

W max 1.5W mean

h from N.A 6

Trapezoidal

Section

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

W NA

= 1.33 W mean

h1 2

V Âª 2 h12 Âº h Â¼ 8I Â¬

h from N.A 6

W max

Diagram

Uni form

In Flange,

I-Section

( W max ) W max y

1

W max y

1

h

o 2

In Web

W max y

1

W m im y

1

o

h1 2

v Âªb(h12 h12 )  th12 Âº Â¼ 8It Â¬ vb 2 Âª h  h12 Âº Â¼ 8 It Â¬

4. Variation of shear stress for some more section [Asked in different examinations] Non uniform I-Section

Diagonally placed square section

L-section

Hollow circle

T-section

Cross

Page 255 of 429

Chapter-7

Shear Stress in Beam

S K Mondal’s

5. Rectangular section W max =

x

Maximum shear stress for rectangular beam:

x

For this, A is the area of the entire cross section

x

Maximum shear occurs at the neutral axis

x

Shear is zero at the top and bottom of beam

3V 2A

6. Shear stress in beams of thin walled profile section. x

Shear stress at any point in the wall distance "s" from the free edge

A Shearing occurs here

O

B

Vx

W where Vx

Vx It

s

³ ydA o

Shear force

W = Thickness of the section I = Moment of inrertia about NA x

Shear Flow (q) s

q =

x

Wt

Vx ydA I NA ³o

Shear Force (F)

Page 256 of 429

Chapter-7

Shear Stress in Beam

F= x

³

qds

Shear Centre (e) Point of application of shear stress resultant

Page 257 of 429

S K Mondal’s

Chapter-7

Shear Stress in Beam

S K Mondal’s

OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Shear Stress Variation GATE-1.

The transverse shear stress acting in a beam of rectangular crosssection, subjected to a transverse shear load, is: (a) Variable with maximum at the bottom of the beam (b) Variable with maximum at the top of the beam (c) Uniform (d) Variable with maximum on the neutral axis [IES-1995, GATE-2008]

GATE-1. Ans (d) GATE-2.

W max

3 W mean 2

The ratio of average shear stress to the maximum shear stress in a beam with a square cross-section is: [GATE-1994, 1998]

(a) 1

(b)

2 3

(c)

3 2

(d) 2

GATE-2. Ans. (b)

W max

3 W mean 2

Previous 20-Years IES Questions Shear Stress Variation IES-1.

At a section of a beam, shear force is F with zero BM. The cross-section is square with side a. Point A lies on neutral axis and point B is mid way between neutral axis and top edge, i.e. at distance a/4 above the neutral axis. If U A and U B denote shear stresses at points A and B, then what is the value of U A / U B? [IES-2005] (a) 0 (b) ¾ (c) 4/3 (d) None of above · a § a2 3 V 2 V u ¨  y2 ¸ .a 2© 4 WA VAy 3 V 2 4 ¹ 2 2 a3 a 4y or  IES-1. Ans. (c) W 2 W B 3 V ­°§ 2 Ib 2 a3 3 a4 ½ § a · ·° ua . 3 . ®¨ a  4 ¨ ¸ ¸ ¾ 12 ¨ 2 a °¯© © 4 ¹ ¸¹ °¿ Page 258 of 429

Chapter-7 IES-2.

Shear Stress in Beam

S K Mondal’s

A wooden beam of rectangular cross-section 10 cm deep by 5 cm wide carries maximum shear force of 2000 kg. Shear stress at neutral axis of the beam section is: [IES-1997] 2 2 (a) Zero (b) 40 kgf/cm (c) 60 kgf/cm (d) 80 kgf/cm2

IES-2. Ans. (c) Shear stress at neutral axis =

3 F u 2 bd

3 2000 u 2 10 u 5

60 kg/cm 2

IES-3.

In case of a beam of circular cross-section subjected to transverse loading, the maximum shear stress developed in the beam is greater than the average shear stress by: [IES-2006; 2008] (a) 50% (b) 33% (c) 25% (d) 10% IES-3. Ans. (b) In the case of beams with circular cross-section, the ratio of the maximum shear stress to average shear stress 4:3

IES-4. What is the nature of distribution of shear stress in a rectangular beam? [IES-1993, 2004; 2008] (a) Linear (b) Parabolic (c) Hyperbolic (d) Elliptic IES-4. Ans. (b)

W

V § h2 2· ¨  y1 ¸ indicating a parabolic distribution of shear stress across the cross4I © 4 ¹

section.

IES-5.

Which one of the following statements is correct? [IES 2007] When a rectangular section beam is loaded transversely along the length, shear stress develops on (a) Top fibre of rectangular beam (b) Middle fibre of rectangular beam (c) Bottom fibre of rectangular beam (d) Every horizontal plane IES-5. Ans. (b)

IES-6.

A beam having rectangular cross-section is subjected to an external loading. Page 259 due of 429to the external loading at a particular The average shear stress developed

Chapter-7

Shear Stress in Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

cross-section is t avg . What is the maximum shear stress developed at the same cross-section due to the same loading?

1 (a) tavg 2

[IES-2009]

3 (c) tavg 2

(b) tavg

(d) 2 tavg

IES-6. Ans. (c)

Shear stress in a rectangular beam, maximum shear stress,

Wmax

IES-7.

3F 2b. h

Shear stress in a circular maximum shear stress,

Wmax

1.5 W(average)

4F S 3 u d2 4

beam,

the

4 W(average) 3

The transverse shear stress acting in a beam of rectangular cross-section, subjected to a transverse shear load, is: (a) Variable with maximum at the bottom of the beam (b) Variable with maximum at the top of the beam (c) Uniform (d) Variable with maximum on the neutral axis [IES-1995, GATE-2008]

IES-7. Ans (d)

W max

3 W mean 2

IES-8.

A cantilever is loaded by a concentrated load P at the free end as shown. The shear stress in the element LMNOPQRS is under consideration. Which of the following figures represents the shear stress directions in the cantilever? [IES-2002] Page 260 of 429

Chapter-7

Shear Stress in Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

IES-8. Ans. (d) IES-9.

In I-Section of a beam subjected to transverse shear force, the maximum shear stress is developed. [IES- 2008] (a) At the centre of the web (b) At the top edge of the top flange (c) At the bottom edge of the top flange (d) None of the above IES-9. Ans. (a) IES-10.

The given figure (all dimensions are in mm) shows an I-Section of the beam. The shear stress at point P (very close to the bottom of the flange) is 12 MPa. The stress at point Q in the web (very close to the flange) is: (a) Indeterminable due to incomplete data (b) 60MPa (c) 18 MPa (d) 12 MPa [IES-2001]

IES-10. Ans. (b) IES-11. Assertion (A): In an I-Section beam subjected to concentrated loads, the shearing force at any section of the beam is resisted mainly by the web portion. Reason (R): Average value of the shearing stress in the web is equal to the value of shearing stress in the flange. [IES-1995] (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IES-11. Ans. (c)

Shear stress distribution for different section IES-12.

The shear stress distribution over a beam crosssection is shown in the figure above. The beam is of (a) Equal flange I-Section (b) Unequal flange I-Section (c) Circular cross-section (d) T-section

IES-12. Ans. (b)

Page 261 of 429

[IES-2003]

Chapter-7

Shear Stress in Beam

S K Mondal’s

Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Shear Stress Variation IAS-1.

Consider the following statements: [IAS-2007] Two beams of identical cross-section but of different materials carry same bending moment at a particular section, then 1. The maximum bending stress at that section in the two beams will be same. 2. The maximum shearing stress at that section in the two beams will be same. 3. Maximum bending stress at that section will depend upon the elastic modulus of the beam material. 4. Curvature of the beam having greater value of E will be larger. Which of the statements given above are correct? (a) 1 and 2 only (b) 1, 3 and 4 (c) 1, 2 and 3 (d) 2, 3 and 4

IAS-1. Ans. (a) Bending stress G =

VAy My and shear stress ( W ) = both of them does not depends Ib I

on material of beam.

IAS-2. In a loaded beam under bending [IAS-2003] (a) Both the maximum normal and the maximum shear stresses occur at the skin fibres (b) Both the maximum normal and the maximum shear stresses occur the neutral axis (c) The maximum normal stress occurs at the skin fibres while the maximum shear stress occurs at the neutral axis (d) The maximum normal stress occurs at the neutral axis while the maximum shear stress occurs at the skin fibres IAS-2. Ans. (c)

W

V § h2 2· ¨  y1 ¸ indicating a parabolic distribution of shear stress across the cross4I © 4 ¹

section.

Shear stress distribution for different section IAS-3.

Select the correct shear stress distribution Page 262 of 429 diagram for a square beam with a diagonal in a vertical position: [IAS-2002]

Chapter-7

Shear Stress in Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

IAS-3. Ans. (d) IAS-4.

The distribution of shear stress of a beam is shown in the given figure. The cross-section of the beam is: [IAS-2000]

IAS-4. Ans. (b) IAS-5. A channel-section of the beam shown in the given figure carries a uniformly distributed load. [IAS-2000]

Assertion (A): The line of action of the load passes through the centroid of the cross-section. The beam twists besides bending. Reason (R): Twisting occurs since the line of action of the load does not pass through the web of the beam. (a) Both A and R are individually true Page 263 and of 429R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A

Chapter-7

Shear Stress in Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

(c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-5. Ans. (c) Twisting occurs since the line of action of the load does not pass through the shear.

Page 264 of 429

Chapter-7

Shear Stress in Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question IES-2009 Q.

(i)A cantilever of circular solid cross-section is fixed at one end and carries a concentrated load P at the free end. The diameter at the free end is 200 mm and increases uniformly to 400 mm at the fixed end over a length of 2 m. At what distance from the free end will the bending stresses in the cantilever be maximum? Also calculate the value of the maximum bending stress if the concentrated load P = 30 kN [15-Marks]

Ans.

We have

V y

M I

.... (i)

Taking distance x from the free end we have

M = 30x kN.m = 30x Ă&#x2014; 103 N.m x 200  100

2 100  50x mm

y = 100 +

Sd4 64

and I =

Let d be the diameter at x from free end.

ÂŞ 400  200 x Âş S ÂŤ200  Âť 2 ÂŹ Âź 64 S 200  100x

4

4

64

mm 4

From equation (i), we have

V

100  50x u 103 30x u 103 S 200  100x 4 u 1012 64 960x ? V 200  100x 3 u 1012 S 960x 200  100x 3 u 1012 S dV For max V, 0 dx ?

...... (ii)

1012 u 960 S

ÂŞ x 3 100 200  100x 4  1. 200  100x 3 Âş ÂŹÂŤ ÂźÂť Â&#x; - 300x + 200 + 100x = 0 Â&#x; x = 1m

Page 265 of 429

0

Chapter-7

Shear Stress in Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

30kN

200 400

2000mm (2m) Hence maximum bending stress occurs at the midway and from equation (ii), maximum bending stress

V

960 1 200  100 3 u 1012 S 960 u 1012 S u 300

3

11.32 MPa

Conventional Question IES-2006 Question:

A timber beam 15 cm wide and 20 cm deep carries uniformly distributed load over a span of 4 m and is simply supported. If the permissible stresses are 30 N/mm2 longitudinally and 3 N/mm2 transverse shear, calculate the maximum load which can be carried by the timber beam. Ď&#x2030;N m

N/A

Moment of inertia (I)

bh3 12

20cm

3

0.15 u 0.20

12

104 m4

Distance of neutral axis from the top surface y

20 2

10 cm

0.1 m

M V My or V I y I Where maximum bending moment due to uniformly We know that

distributed load in simply supported beam ( M ) Considering longitudinal stress 2Z u 0.1 30 u 106 10 4 or, Z 15 kN/mÂŹ

Page 266 of 429

Z" 2

Z u 42

8

8

2Z

Chapter-7

Shear Stress in Beam

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Now consideng Shear Maximum shear force

Z.L

Z.4

2

2

2Z

Therefore average shear stress (W mean )

2Z 0.15 u 0.2

66.67 Z

For rectangular cross-section 3 u 66.67Z 100 Z 2 Z 30 kN/m Now 3 u 106 100Z ; So maximum load carring capacity of the beam = 15 kN/m (without fail). Maximum shear stress(W max )

3 .W 2

Page 267 of 429

8.

Fixed and Continuous Beam

Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) What is a beam? A (usually) horizontal structural member that is subjected to a load that tends to bend it.

Types of Beams

Simply supported beam

Cantilever beam

Simply Supported Beams

Cantilever Beam

Single Overhang Beam

Continuous Beam

Double Overhang Beam

Single Overhang Beam with internal hinge

Fixed Beam

Continuous beam

Continuous beams Beams placed on more than 2 supports are called continuous beams. Continuous beams are used when the span of the beam is very large, deflection under each rigid support will be equal zero.

Analysis of Continuous Beams (Using 3-moment equation)

Stability of structure If the equilibrium and geometry of structure is maintained under the action of forces than the structure is said to be stable.

Page 268 of 429

Chapter-8

Fixed and Continuous Beam

Page-267

External stability of the structure is provided by the reaction at the supports. Internal stability is provided by proper design and geometry of the member of the structure.

Statically determinate and indeterminate structures Beams for which reaction forces and internal forces can be found out from static equilibrium equations alone are called statically determinate beam.

Example: P

RB

RA

X

i

0,  Yi  0 and

M  0 i

is sufficient to calculate R A & RB .

Beams for which reaction forces and internal forces cannot be found out from static equilibrium equations alone are called statically indeterminate beam. This type of beam requires deformation equation in addition to static equilibrium equations to solve for unknown forces.

Example:

P

RA

RB

P

Rc

RD

Page 269 of 429

Chapter-8

Fixed and Continuous Beam

Page-268

Advantages of fixed ends or fixed supports x

Slope at the ends is zero.

x

Fixed beams are stiffer, stronger and more stable than SSB.

x

In case of fixed beams, fixed end moments will reduce the BM in each section.

x

The maximum deflection is reduced.

Bending moment diagram for fixed beam Example:

BMD for Continuous beams BMD for continuous beams can be obtained by superimposing the fixed end moments diagram over the free bending moment diagram.

Page 270 of 429

Chapter-8

Fixed and Continuous Beam

Three - moment Equation for continuous beams OR Clapeyronâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s Three Moment Equation

Page 271 of 429

Page-269

Chapter-8

Fixed and Continuous Beam

Page-270

OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years IES Questions Overhanging Beam IES-1.

An overhanging beam ABC is supported at points A and B, as shown in the above figure. Find the maximum bending moment and the point where it occurs. [IES-2009] (a) (b) (c) (d)

6 kN-m at the right support 6 kN-m at the left support 4.5 kN-m at the right support 4.5 kN-m at the midpoint between the supports

IES-1. Ans. (a) Taking moment about A

VB u 2 = 2 u 1  6 u 3

Â&#x;

2VB

2  18

Â&#x;

VB

10 kN

VA  VB ?

VA

26 8  10

8kN  2 kN

? Maximum Bending Moment = 6 kN-m at the right support

IES-2.

A beam of length 4 L is simply supported on two supports with equal overhangs of L on either sides and carries three equal loads, one each at free ends and the third at the mid-span. Which one of the following diagrams represents correct distribution of shearing force on the beam? [IES-2004]

IES-2. Ans. (d)

Page 272 of 429

Chapter-8

Fixed and Continuous Beam

Page-271

They use opposite sign conversions but for correct sign remember S.F & B.M of cantilever is (-) ive.

IES-3.

A horizontal beam carrying uniformly distributed load is supported with equal overhangs as shown in the given figure The resultant bending moment at the mid-span shall be zero if a/b is: [IES-2001] (a) 3/4 (b) 2/3 (c) 1/2 (d) 1/3 IES-3. Ans. (c)

Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Overhanging Beam IAS-1.

If the beam shown in the given figure is to have zero bending moment at its middle point, the overhang x should be: [IAS-2000] (a)

wl 2 / 4 P

IAS-1. Ans. (c)

Rc

RD

(b)

P

wl 2 / 6 P

wl 2 / 8P

(d)

wl 2 /12 P

wl 2

Bending moment at mid point (M) =

IAS-2.

(c)



wl l l lÂˇ Â§ u  RD u  P Â¨ x  Â¸ 0 gives x 2 4 2 2Âš ÂŠ

wl 2 8P

A beam carrying a uniformly distributed load rests on two supports 'b' apart with equal overhangs 'a' at each end. The ratio b/a for zero bending moment at mid-span is: [IAS-1997] (a)

1 2

(b) 1

Page 273 of 429

(c)

3 2

(d) 2

Chapter-8

Fixed and Continuous Beam

Page-272

IAS-2. Ans. (d)

IAS-3.

(i)

By similarity in the B.M diagram a must be b/2

(ii)

By formula M

Z ª b2

2º « a » 2¬4 ¼

0 gives a = b/2

A beam carries a uniformly distributed load and is supported with two equal overhangs as shown in figure 'A'. Which one of the following correctly shows the bending moment diagram of the beam? [IAS 1994]

IAS-3. Ans. (a)

Page 274 of 429

Chapter-8

Fixed and Continuous Beam

Page-273

What are statically determinate and in determinate beams? Illustrate each case through examples. Beams for which reaction forces and internal forces can be found out from static equilibrium equations alone are called statically determinate beam.

Example:

P

RB

RA

X

i

0, Yi  0 and

M  0 i

is sufficient

to calculate R A & RB. Beams for which reaction forces and internal forces cannot be found out from static equilibrium equations alone are called statically indeterminate beam. This type of beam requires deformation equation in addition to static equilibrium equations to solve for unknown forces.

Example:

P

RA

RB

P

Rc

Page 275 of 429

RD

9.

Torsion

Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) •

In machinery, the general term “shaft” refers to a member, usually of circular crosssection, which supports gears, sprockets, wheels, rotors, etc., and which is subjected to torsion and to transverse or axial loads acting singly or in combination.

An “axle” is a rotating/non-rotating member that supports wheels, pulleys,… and carries no torque.

A “spindle” is a short shaft. Terms such as lineshaft, headshaft, stub shaft, transmission shaft, countershaft, and flexible shaft are names associated with special usage.

Torsion of circular shafts 1. Equation for shafts subjected to torsion "T" τ R

=

T Gθ = J L

Torsion Equation

Where J = Polar moment of inertia

τ = Shear stress induced due to torsion T. G = Modulus of rigidity

θ = Angular deflection of shaft R, L = Shaft radius & length respectively

Assumptions •

The bar is acted upon by a pure torque.

The section under consideration is remote from the point of application of the load and from a change in diameter.

Adjacent cross sections originally plane and parallel remain plane and parallel after twisting, and any radial line remains straight.

The material obeys Hooke’s law

Cross-sections rotate as if rigid, i.e. every diameter rotates through the same angle

Page 276 of 429

Chapter-9

Torsion

S K Mondal’s

2. Polar moment of inertia As stated above, the polar second moment of area, J is defined as

J

=

z

R

0

2π r 3 dr

J = 2π

For a solid shaft

LM r OP N4Q

R

4

= 0

2 π R 4 π D4 = 4 32

(6)

For a hollow shaft of internal radius r: J =

z

R

0

2π r dr = 3

Lr O 2π M P N4Q 4

R

= r

π 2

( R4 − r 4 ) =

π 32

cD

4

−d4

h

(7)

Where D is the external and d is the internal diameter.

π d4

Solid shaft “J” =

Hollow shaft, "J” =

32

π 32

(do 4 − di 4 )

3. The polar section modulus Zp= J / c, where c = r = D/2 •

For a solid circular cross-section, Zp = π D3 / 16

For a hollow circular cross-section, Zp = π (Do4 - Di4 ) / (16Do)

Then, τ max = T / Zp

If design shears stress, τ d is known, required polar section modulus can be calculated from: Zp = T / τ d

4. Power Transmission (P) •

P (in Watt ) =

2π NT 60

Page 277 of 429

Chapter-9 •

Torsion

2π NT = 4500

P (in hp)

S K Mondal’s

(1 hp = 75 Kgm/sec). [Where N = rpm; T = Torque in N-m.]

5. Safe diameter of Shaft (d) •

Stiffness consideration

T Gθ = J L •

Shear Stress consideration

T τ = J R We take higher value of diameter of both cases above for overall safety if other parameters are given.

6. In twisting τ max

16T π d3

Solid shaft,

Hollow shaft,

Diameter of a shaft to have a maximum deflection " α "

=

τ max

16Td o π (d o 4 − di 4 )

=

d = 4.9 ×

4

TL Gα

[Where T in N-mm, L in mm, G in N/mm2]

7. Comparison of solid and hollow shaft •

A Hollow shaft will transmit a greater torque than a solid shaft of the same weight & same material because the average shear stress in the hollow shaft is smaller than the average shear stress in the solid shaft

(τ max )holloow shaft 16 • = (τ max ) solid shaft 15 •

Strength comparison (same weight, material, length and τ max )

Th n2 + 1 = Ts n n 2 − 1 •

Where, n=

External diameter of hollow shaft Internal diameter of hollow shaft

[ONGC-2005]

Weight comparison (same Torque, material, length and τ max )

(

)

n 2 − 1 n 2/3 Wh = 2/3 Ws n4 − 1 •

⎡ If solid shaft dia = D ⎤ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ Hollow shaft, d o = D, di = D ⎥ 2⎦ ⎣

(

)

Where, n=

External diameter of hollow shaft Internal diameter of hollow shaft

Strain energy comparison (same weight, material, length and τ max )

Uh n 2 + 1 1 = 1+ 2 = 2 Us n n

Page 278 of 429

[WBPSC-2003]

Chapter-9

Torsion

S K Mondal’s

8. Shaft in series θ = θ1 + θ 2 Torque (T) is same in all section Electrical analogy gives torque(T) = Current (I)

9. Shaft in parallel θ1 = θ 2

and T = T1 + T2

Electrical analogy gives torque(T) = Current (I)

10. Combined Bending and Torsion •

In most practical transmission situations shafts which carry torque are also subjected to bending, if only by virtue of the self-weight of the gears they carry. Many other practical applications occur where bending and torsion arise simultaneously so that this type of loading represents one of the major sources of complex stress situations.

In the case of shafts, bending gives rise to tensile stress on one surface and compressive stress on the opposite surface while torsion gives rise to pure shear throughout the shaft.

For shafts subjected to the simultaneous application of a bending moment M and torque T the principal stresses set up in the shaft can be shown to be equal to those produced by an equivalent bending moment, of a certain value Me acting alone.

Figure

Maximum direct stress ( σ x ) & Shear stress ( (τ xy ) in element A

32 M P + πd3 A 16T τ xy = 3 πd

σx =

Principal normal stresses ( σ 1,2 ) & Maximum stress ( τ max ) Page 279shearing of 429

Chapter-9

Torsion

σ 1,2

τ max = •

τ max

⎛σ ⎞ ± ⎜ x ⎟ + τ xy2 2 ⎝ 2 ⎠

σ1 − σ 2 2

2

⎛σ ⎞ = ± ⎜ x ⎟ + (τ xy ) 2 ⎝ 2 ⎠

=

=

16 ⎡ M + M 2 +T2 ⎤ ⎦ πd3 ⎣

16 M 2 +T2 3 πd

Location of Principal plane ( θ )

θ = •

σx

Maximum Principal Stress ( σ max ) & Maximum shear stress ( τ max )

σ max

=

S K Mondal’s

2

1 ⎛T ⎞ tan −1 ⎜ ⎟ 2 ⎝M ⎠

Equivalent bending moment (Me) & Equivalent torsion (Te).

⎡M + M 2 +T2 Me = ⎢ 2 ⎢⎣

⎤ ⎥ ⎥⎦

Te = M 2 + T 2 •

Important Note o

Uses of the formulas are limited to cases in which both M & T are known. Under any other condition Mohr’s circle is used.

Safe diameter of shaft (d) on the basis of an allowable working stress. o

σw

in tension , d =

o

τw

in shear , d=

3

3

32M e

πσ w

16Te

πτ w

11. Shaft subjected to twisting moment only •

Figure

Page 280 of 429

Chapter-9 •

Torsion

S K Mondal’s

Normal force ( Fn ) & Tangential for ( Ft ) on inclined plane AB

Fn = −τ × [ BC sin θ + AC cosθ ] Ft = τ × [ BC cosθ - AC sinθ ] •

Normal stress ( σ n ) & Tangential stress (shear stress) ( σ t ) on inclined plane AB.

σn

=

−τ sin 2θ

σt

=

τ cos 2θ

Maximum normal & shear stress on AB

θ

( σ n )max

0

0

45°

–τ

0

90

0

–τ

135

0

τ

max

• Important Note

• Principal stresses at a point on the surface of the shaft = + τ , - τ , 0 i.e

σ 1,2 = ± τ sin2θ

• Principal strains

∈1 =

τ E

(1 + μ ); ∈2 = −

τ E

(1 + μ ); ∈3 = 0

• Volumetric strain,

∈v =∈1 + ∈2 + ∈3 = 0 • No change in volume for a shaft subjected to pure torque.

12. Torsional Stresses in Non-Circular Cross-section Members •

There are some applications in machinery for non-circular cross-section members and shafts where a regular polygonal cross-section is useful in transmitting torque to a gear or pulley that can have an axial change in position. Because no key or keyway is needed, the possibility of a lost key is avoided.

Saint Venant (1855) showed that τ max in a rectangular b × c section bar occurs in the middle of the longest side b and is of magnitude formula

τ max =

T T ⎛ 1.8 ⎞ = 3+ 2 2 ⎜ b / c ⎟⎠ α bc bc ⎝

Where b is the longer side and α factor that is function of the ratio b/c. The angle of twist is given by

Page 281 of 429

Chapter-9

Torsion

θ =

S K Mondal’s

Tl β bc3G

Where β is a function of the ratio b/c Shear stress distribution in different cross-section

Rectangular c/s

Elliptical c/s

Triangular c/s

13. Torsion of thin walled tube •

For a thin walled tube Shear stress, τ =

Angle of twist,

T 2 A0t

φ=

τ sL 2 AO G

[Where S = length of mean centre line, AO = Area enclosed by mean centre line] •

Special Cases o

For circular c/s

J = 2π r 3t ;

Ao = π r 2 ;

S = 2π r

[r = radius of mean Centre line and t = wall thickness]

∴ τ=

ϕ= o

T T .r T = = 2 2π r t 2 Aot J

TL τL TL = = GJ Ao JG 2π r 3tG

For square c/s of length of each side ‘b’ and thickness ‘t’

A0 = b 2 S =4b o

For elliptical c/s ‘a’ and ‘b’ are the half axis lengths.

A0 = π ab ⎡3 ⎤ S ≈ π ⎢ (a + b) − ab ⎥ ⎣2 ⎦

Page 282 of 429

Chapter-9

Torsion

S K Mondal’s

OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Torsion Equation GATE-1.

A solid circular shaft of 60 mm diameter transmits a torque of 1600 N.m. The value of maximum shear stress developed is: [GATE-2004] (a) 37.72 MPa (b) 47.72 MPa (c) 57.72 MPa (d) 67.72 MPa 16T GATE-1. Ans. (a) τ = π d3 GATE-2.

Maximum shear stress developed on the surface of a solid circular shaft under pure torsion is 240 MPa. If the shaft diameter is doubled then the maximum shear stress developed corresponding to the same torque will be: [GATE-2003] (a) 120 MPa (b) 60 MPa (c) 30 MPa (d) 15 MPa 16T 16T 16T 240 GATE-2. Ans. (c) τ = , 240 = if diameter doubled d′ = 2d, then τ ′ = = = 30MPa 3 8 π d3 π d3 π ( 2d ) GATE-3.

A steel shaft 'A' of diameter 'd' and length 'l' is subjected to a torque ‘T’ Another shaft 'B' made of aluminium of the same diameter 'd' and length 0.5l is also subjected to the same torque 'T'. The shear modulus of steel is 2.5 times the shear modulus of aluminium. The shear stress in the steel shaft is 100 MPa. The shear stress in the aluminium shaft, in MPa, is: [GATE-2000] (a) 40 (b) 50 (c) 100 (d) 250 16T as T & d both are same τ is same GATE-3. Ans. (c) τ = π d3 GATE-4.

For a circular shaft of diameter d subjected to torque T, the maximum value of the shear stress is: [GATE-2006]

(a)

64T πd3

(b)

32T πd3

(c)

16T πd3

(d)

8T πd3

GATE-4. Ans. (c)

Power Transmitted by Shaft GATE-5.

The diameter of shaft A is twice the diameter or shaft B and both are made of the same material. Assuming both the shafts to rotate at the same speed, the maximum power transmitted by B is: [IES-2001; GATE-1994] th (a) The same as that of A (b) Half of A (c) 1/8 of A (d) 1/4th of A

GATE-5. Ans. (c) Power, P = T ×

or P =

τπ d3 16

×

2π N 60

and τ =

16T τπ d3 = or T 16 π d3

2π N or P α d3 60

Combined Bending and Torsion GATE-6.

A solid shaft can resist a bending moment of 3.0 kNm and a twisting moment of 4.0 kNm together, then the maximum torque that can be applied is: [GATE-1996] (a) 7.0 kNm (b) 3.5 kNm (c)4.5 kNm (d) 5.0 kNm Page 283 of 429

GATE-6. Ans. (d) Equivalent torque ( Te ) = M2 + T 2 = 32 + 42 = 5kNm

Chapter-9

Torsion

S K Mondal’s

Comparison of Solid and Hollow Shafts GATE-7.

The outside diameter of a hollow shaft is twice its inside diameter. The ratio of its torque carrying capacity to that of a solid shaft of the same material and the same outside diameter is: [GATE-1993; IES-2001] (a)

15 16

GATE-7. Ans. (a)

(b) T Gθ τ = = J L R

or T =

τJ R

3 4

(c)

1 2

(d)

1 16

if τ is const. T α J

π ⎡

4 ⎛D⎞ ⎤ 4 − D ⎢ ⎜2⎟ ⎥ 32 ⎣⎢ ⎝ ⎠ ⎥⎦ 15 Th J = h = = π 4 T J 16 D 32

Shafts in Series GATE-8.

A torque of 10 Nm is transmitted through a stepped shaft as shown in figure. The torsional stiffness of individual sections of lengths MN, NO and OP are 20 Nm/rad, 30 Nm/rad and 60 Nm/rad respectively. The angular deflection between the ends M and P of the shaft is: [GATE-2004]

(b) 1.0 rad (c) 5.0 rad (d) 10.0 rad TL GATE-8. Ans. (b) We know that θ = or T = k.θ [let k = tortional stiffness] GJ T T T 10 10 10 ∴θ = θMN + θNO + θ OP = MN + NO + OP = + + = 1.0 rad k MN k NO k OP 20 30 60

Shafts in Parallel GATE-9.

The two shafts AB and BC, of equal length and diameters d and 2d, are made of the same material. They are joined at B through a shaft coupling, while the ends A and C are built-in (cantilevered). A twisting moment T is applied to the coupling. If TA and TC represent the twisting moments at the ends A and C, respectively, then (b) TC =8 TA (c) TC =16 TA (a) TC = TA TL TC T TL T GATE-9. Ans. (c) θ AB = θBC or A A = C C or A4 = or TA = C 4 GA JA GC JC 16 πd π ( 2d) 32 32

[GATE-2005] (d) TA=16 TC

Previous 20-Years IES Questions Torsion Equation IES-1.

Consider the following statements: Maximum shear stress induced in Page a power transmitting shaft is: 284 of 429 1. Directly proportional to torque being transmitted. 2. Inversely proportional to the cube of its diameter.

[IES- 2008]

Chapter-9

Torsion

S K Mondal’s

3. Directly proportional to its polar moment of inertia. Which of the statements given above are correct? (a) 1, 2 and 3 (b) 1 and 3 only (c) 2 and 3 only (d) 1 and 2 only T × r 16T IES-1. Ans. (d) τ = = J π d3 IES-2.

A solid shaft transmits a torque T. The allowable shearing stress is τ . What is the diameter of the shaft? [IES-2008] 16T 32T 16T T (a) 3 (b) 3 (c) 3 (d) 3

πτ

πτ

τ

τ

IES-2. Ans. (a) IES-3.

Maximum shear stress developed on the surface of a solid circular shaft under pure torsion is 240 MPa. If the shaft diameter is doubled, then what is the maximum shear stress developed corresponding to the same torque? [IES-2009] (a) 120 MPa (b) 60 MPa (c) 30 MPa (d) 15 MPa

IES-3. Ans. (c) Maximum shear stress =

16T = 240 MPa = τ πd3

Maximum shear stress developed when diameter is doubled

=

16τ π ( 2d)

3

=

1 ⎛ 16T ⎞ τ 240 = = = 30MPa 8 ⎜⎝ πd3 ⎟⎠ 8 8

IES-4.

The diameter of a shaft is increased from 30 mm to 60 mm, all other conditions remaining unchanged. How many times is its torque carrying capacity increased? [IES-1995; 2004] (a) 2 times (b) 4 times (c) 8 times (d) 16 times 3 16T τπ d or T = for same material τ = const. IES-4. Ans. (c) τ = 16 π d3 3

∴ T α d3

or

3

T2 ⎛ d2 ⎞ ⎛ 60 ⎞ =⎜ ⎟ =⎜ ⎟ =8 T1 ⎝ d1 ⎠ ⎝ 30 ⎠

IES-5.

A circular shaft subjected to twisting moment results in maximum shear stress of 60 MPa. Then the maximum compressive stress in the material is: [IES-2003] (a) 30 MPa (b) 60 MPa (c) 90 MPa (d) 120 MPa IES-5. Ans. (b) IES-6.

Angle of twist of a shaft of diameter ‘d’ is inversely proportional to (c) d3 (d) d4 (a) d (b) d2 IES-6. Ans. (d)

[IES-2000]

IES-7.

A solid circular shaft is subjected to pure torsion. The ratio of maximum shear to maximum normal stress at any point would be: [IES-1999] (a) 1 : 1 (b) 1: 2 (c) 2: 1 (d) 2: 3

IES-7. Ans. (a) Shear stress =

16T 32T and normal stress = 3 πd πd3

∴ Ratio of shear stress and normal stress = 1: 2

IES-8.

Assertion (A): In a composite shaft having two concentric shafts of different materials, the torque shared by each shaft is directly proportional to its polar moment of inertia. [IES-1999] Reason (R): In a composite shaft having concentric shafts of different materials, the angle of twist for each shaft depends upon its polar moment of inertia. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A Page 285 of 429 (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true

Chapter-9

Torsion

S K Mondal’s

IES-8. Ans. (c) IES-9.

A shaft is subjected to torsion as shown.

[IES-2002]

Which of the following figures represents the shear stress on the element LMNOPQRS ?

IES-9. Ans. (d) IES-10. A round shaft of diameter 'd' and length 'l' fixed at both ends 'A' and 'B' is subjected to a twisting moment 'T’ at 'C', at a distance of 1/4 from A (see figure). The torsional stresses in the parts AC and CB will be: (a) Equal (b) In the ratio 1:3 (c) In the ratio 3 :1 (d) Indeterminate

[IES-1997]

T τ Gθ GRθ 1 or τ = = = ∴τ ∞ IES-10. Ans. (c) J R L L L

Hollow Circular Shafts IES-11.

One-half length of 50 mm diameter steel rod is solid while the remaining half is hollow having a bore of 25 mm. The rod is subjected to equal and opposite torque at its ends. If the maximum shear stress in solid portion is τ or, the maximum shear stress in the hollow portion is: [IES-2003]

15 (b) τ τ 16 τJ T τ IES-11. Ans. (d) = or T = J r r τJ τ J D⎤ ⎡ or s = h h ; ⎢ rs = rh = ⎥ rs rh 2⎦ ⎣ (a)

(c)

Page 286 of 429

4 τ 3

(d)

16 τ 15

Chapter-9

Torsion

π

S K Mondal’s

D4 Js 1 1 ⎛ 16 ⎞ 32 or τ h = τ × =τ × =τ × =τ × =τ ⎜ ⎟ 4 4 π Jh ⎡ ⎛d⎞ ⎤ ⎡ ⎛ 25 ⎞ ⎤ ⎝ 15 ⎠ D4 − d 4 1 1 − − ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ 32 ⎣⎢ ⎝ D ⎠ ⎦⎥ ⎣⎢ ⎝ 50 ⎠ ⎦⎥

(

)

Power Transmitted by Shaft IES-12.

In power transmission shafts, if the polar moment of inertia of a shaft is doubled, then what is the torque required to produce the same angle of twist? [IES-2006] (a) 1/4 of the original value (b) 1/2 of the original value (c) Same as the original value (d) Double the original value IES-12. Ans. (d) T Gθ τ T.L or Q = if θ is const. T α J if J is doubled then T is also doubled. = = J L R G.J

IES-13.

While transmitting the same power by a shaft, if its speed is doubled, what should be its new diameter if the maximum shear stress induced in the shaft remains same? [IES-2006]

1 of the original diameter 2

(a)

(b)

2 of the original diameter

(c)

(d)

1 of the original diameter 2 1

( 2)

1

of the original diameter

3

IES-13. Ans. (d) Power (P) = torque ( T ) × angular speed (ω ) T′ ω 1 = = or T ′ = ( T / 2 ) T ω′ 2 16T 16 ( T / 2 ) 1 ⎛ d′ ⎞ or ⎜ ⎟ = 3 σ = 3 = 3 πd 2 ⎝d⎠ π ( d′ )

if P is const.Tα

IES-14.

1

ω

if

For a power transmission shaft transmitting power P at N rpm, its diameter is proportional to: [IES-2005] 1/3

1/ 2

⎛P⎞ ⎟ ⎝N⎠

⎛P⎞ ⎟ ⎝N⎠

(a) ⎜

IES-14. Ans. (a) Power, P = T × or P =

⎛P⎞ ⎟ ⎝N⎠

(b) ⎜

τπ d3 16

2π N 60

and τ =

(c) ⎜

2/3

⎛P⎞ ⎟ ⎝N⎠

(d) ⎜

16T τπ d3 or T = 3 16 πd 1/3

×

2π N 480 P ⎛P⎞ or d3 = 2 or d α ⎜ ⎟ 60 π JN ⎝N⎠

IES-15.

A shaft can safely transmit 90 kW while rotating at a given speed. If this shaft is replaced by a shaft of diameter double of the previous one and rotated at half the speed of the previous, the power that can be transmitted by the new shaft is: [IES-2002] (a) 90 kW (b) 180 kW (c) 360 kW (d) 720 kW IES-15. Ans. (c) IES-16.

The diameter of shaft A is twice the diameter or shaft B and both are made of the same material. Assuming both the shafts to rotate at the same speed, the maximum power transmitted by B is: [IES-2001; GATE-1994] (d) 1/4th of A (a) The same as that of A (b) Half of A (c) 1/8th of A 3 2π N 16T τπ d and τ = or T = IES-16. Ans. (c) Power, P = T × 3 60 16 πd Page 287 of 429 3 τπ d 2π N × or P = or P α d3 16 60

Chapter-9

Torsion

S K Mondal’s

IES-17.

When a shaft transmits power through gears, the shaft experiences (a) Torsional stresses alone (b) Bending stresses alone (c) Constant bending and varying torsional stresses (d) Varying bending and constant torsional stresses IES-17. Ans. (d)

[IES-1997]

Combined Bending and Torsion IES-18.

The equivalent bending moment under combined action of bending moment M and torque T is: [IES-1996; 2008; IAS-1996] (a)

M2+T2

(c)

1 [M + T ] 2

1⎡ M + M 2 +T2 ⎤ ⎣ ⎦ 2 1 2 2 (d) ⎡ M + T ⎤ ⎦ 4⎣ (b)

IES-18. Ans. (b) IES-19.

A solid circular shaft is subjected to a bending moment M and twisting moment T. What is the equivalent twisting moment Te which will produce the same maximum shear stress as the above combination? [IES-1992; 2007] (a) M2 + T2

IES-19. Ans. (c) Te = IES-20.

M2

(c)

M2 +T2

(d) M – T

+ T2

A shaft is subjected to fluctuating loads for which the normal torque (T) and bending moment (M) are 1000 N-m and 500 N-m respectively. If the combined shock and fatigue factor for bending is 1.5 and combined shock and fatigue factor for torsion is 2, then the equivalent twisting moment for the shaft is: [IES-1994] (a) 2000N-m (b) 2050N-m (c) 2100N-m (d) 2136 N-m

IES-20. Ans. (d) IES-21.

(b) M + T

Teq =

(1.5 × 500 ) + ( 2 ×1000 ) 2

2

= 2136 Nm

A member is subjected to the combined action of bending moment 400 Nm and torque 300 Nm. What respectively are the equivalent bending moment and equivalent torque? [IES-1994; 2004] (a) 450 Nm and 500 Nm (b) 900 Nm and 350 Nm (c) 900 Nm and 500 Nm (d) 400 Nm and 500 Nm

IES-21. Ans. (a) Equivalent Bending Moment (Me ) =

M + M2 + T 2 400 + 4002 + 3002 = = 450N.m 2 2

Equivalent torque ( Te ) = M2 + T 2 = 4002 + 3002 = 500N.m IES-22.

A shaft was initially subjected to bending moment and then was subjected to torsion. If the magnitude of bending moment is found to be the same as that of the torque, then the ratio of maximum bending stress to shear stress would be: [IES-1993] (a) 0.25 (b) 0.50 (c) 2.0 (d) 4.0 IES-22. Ans. (c) Use equivalent bending moment formula, 1st case: Equivalent bending moment (Me) = M

0 + 02 + T 2 T = 2 2

(Me)288 = of 429 2nd case: Equivalent bending momentPage

Chapter-9

Torsion

S K Mondal’s

IES-23.

A shaft is subjected to simultaneous action of a torque T, bending moment M and an axial thrust F. Which one of the following statements is correct for this situation? [IES-2004] (a) One extreme end of the vertical diametral fibre is subjected to maximum compressive stress only (b) The opposite extreme end of the vertical diametral fibre is subjected to tensile/compressive stress only (c) Every point on the surface of the shaft is subjected to maximum shear stress only (d) Axial longitudinal fibre of the shaft is subjected to compressive stress only IES-23. Ans. (a) IES-24. For obtaining the maximum shear stress induced in the shaft shown in the given figure, the torque should be equal to

(b) Wl + T

(a) T

1

2 2 ⎡ 2 ⎛ wL ⎞ ⎤ (c) ⎢(Wl ) + ⎜ ⎟ ⎥ ⎝ 2 ⎠ ⎦⎥ ⎣⎢ 1

2 ⎡⎧ ⎤2 wL2 ⎫ 2 ⎥ + (d) ⎢ ⎨Wl + T ⎬ 2 ⎭ ⎢⎣ ⎩ ⎥⎦

[IES-1999]

IES-24. Ans. (d) Bending Moment, M = Wl + IES-25.

wL 2

Bending moment M and torque is applied on a solid circular shaft. If the maximum bending stress equals to maximum shear stress developed, them M is equal to: [IES-1992]

(a)

T 2

IES-25. Ans. (a) σ = IES-26.

2

(b) T

(c) 2T

(d) 4T

32 × M 16T and τ = π d3 π d3

A circular shaft is subjected to the combined action of bending, twisting and direct axial loading. The maximum bending stress σ, maximum shearing force

3σ and a uniform axial stress σ(compressive) are produced. The maximum compressive normal stress produced in the shaft will be: (a) 3 σ (b) 2 σ (c) σ IES-26. Ans. (a) Maximum normal stress = bending stress σ + axial stress (σ) = 2 σ We have to take maximum bending stress σ is (compressive)

σb

[IES-1998] (d) Zero

2

⎛σ ⎞ The maximum compressive normal stress = − ⎜ b ⎟ + τ xy2 2 ⎝ 2 ⎠ 2

−2σ ⎛ −2σ ⎞ = − ⎜ ⎟ + 2 ⎝ 2 ⎠ IES-27.

(

)

2

= −3σ

Which one of the following statements is correct? Shafts used in heavy duty speed reducers are generally subjected [IES-2004] Page 289 ofto: 429 (a) Bending stress only

Chapter-9

Torsion

S K Mondal’s

(b) Shearing stress only (c) Combined bending and shearing stresses (d) Bending, shearing and axial thrust simultaneously IES-27. Ans. (c)

Comparison of Solid and Hollow Shafts IES-28.

The ratio of torque carrying capacity of a solid shaft to that of a hollow shaft is given by: [IES-2008]

(

(a) 1 − K 4

)

(

(b) 1 − K 4

)

−1

(c)K 4

(d)1/ K 4

Di ; Di = Inside diameter of hollow shaft and Do = Outside diameter of hollow Do shaft. Shaft material is the same. IES-28. Ans. (b) τ should be same for both hollow and solid shaft

Where K =

Ts Th = π 4 π D D4 − Di4 32 o 32 o −1 Ts 1− k4 ∴ Th

(

(

Ts D4 = 4 o 4 Th Do − Di

)

4 Ts ⎛ ⎛ Di ⎞ ⎞ = ⎜1 − ⎜ ⎟ ⎟ Th ⎜ ⎝ Do ⎠ ⎟ ⎝ ⎠

−1

)

IES-29.

A hollow shaft of outer dia 40 mm and inner dia of 20 mm is to be replaced by a solid shaft to transmit the same torque at the same maximum stress. What should be the diameter of the solid shaft? [IES 2007] (d) 10 × (20)1/3 mm (a) 30 mm (b) 35 mm (c) 10 × (60)1/3 mm IES-29. Ans. (c) Section modules will be same

π (404 − 204 ) Js JH π d4 64 = or = × 40 Rs RH 64 d 2 2 or, d3 = (10)3 × 60 or d = 10 3 60 mm

IES-30.

The diameter of a solid shaft is D. The inside and outside diameters of a hollow shaft of same material and length are

2D D and respectively. What is the 3 3

ratio of the weight of the hollow shaft to that of the solid shaft? (a) 1:1

(b) 1:

IES-31.

WH = WS

(c) 1:2

(d) 1:3

π ⎛ 4D D ⎞ ⎜ ⎟× L× ρ × g − 4 ⎜⎝ 3 3 ⎟⎠ =1 π 2 D × L× ρ × g 4 2

IES-30. Ans. (a)

3

[IES 2007]

2

What is the maximum torque transmitted by a hollow shaft of external radius R and internal radius r? [IES-2006] (a)

π 16

(R

3

−r

3

)f

s

(b)

π 2R

(R

4

−r

4

)f

s

(c)

π 8R

(R

4

−r

4

)f

s

(d)

π ⎛ R4 − r 4 ⎞

⎜ 32 ⎝

R

⎟ fs ⎠

( f s = maximum shear stress in the shaft material)

π

(

)

R4 − r 4 π T fs J 2 IES-31. Ans. (b) = or T = × fs = × fs = R 4 − r 4 .fs . J R R R 2R

IES-32.

(

)

Page 290 of 429 A hollow shaft of the same cross-sectional area and material as that of a solid shaft transmits: [IES-2005]

Chapter-9

Torsion

(a) Same torque (c) More torque T n2 + 1 IES-32. Ans. (c) H = , TS n n2 − 1 IES-33.

S K Mondal’s

(b) Lesser torque (d) Cannot be predicted without more data Where n =

DH dH

The outside diameter of a hollow shaft is twice its inside diameter. The ratio of its torque carrying capacity to that of a solid shaft of the same material and the same outside diameter is: [GATE-1993; IES-2001] (a)

15 16

IES-33. Ans. (a)

3 4

(b) T Gθ τ = = J L R

or T =

τJ R

(c)

1 2

(d)

1 16

if τ is const. T α J

π ⎡

4 ⎛D⎞ ⎤ 4 ⎢D − ⎜ ⎟ ⎥ 32 ⎣⎢ ⎝ 2 ⎠ ⎥⎦ 15 Th J = h = = π 4 T J 16 D 32

IES-34.

Two hollow shafts of the same material have the same length and outside diameter. Shaft 1 has internal diameter equal to one-third of the outer diameter and shaft 2 has internal diameter equal to half of the outer diameter. If both the shafts are subjected to the same torque, the ratio of their twists

θ1 / θ 2

will be equal to:

(a) 16/81

[IES-1998]

(b) 8/27

(c) 19/27

d d14 − ⎛⎜ 1 Q 1 ⎝ 2 ∴ 1 = IES-34. Ans. (d) Q ∞ J Q2 d d14 − ⎛⎜ 1 ⎝ 3 IES-35.

(d) 243/256

4

⎞ ⎟ ⎠ = 243 4 256 ⎞ ⎟ ⎠

Maximum shear stress in a solid shaft of diameter D and length L twisted through an angle θ is τ. A hollow shaft of same material and length having outside and inside diameters of D and D/2 respectively is also twisted through the same angle of twist θ. The value of maximum shear stress in the hollow shaft will be: [IES-1994; 1997]

(a )

16 τ 15

( b)

8 τ 7

4 (c) τ 3

( d )τ

T Gθ τ G.R.θ = = or τ = if θ is const. τ α R and outer diameter is same in both J L R L the cases. Note: Required torque will be different.

IES-35. Ans. (d)

IES-36.

A solid shaft of diameter 'D' carries a twisting moment that develops maximum shear stress τ. If the shaft is replaced by a hollow one of outside diameter 'D' and inside diameter D/2, then the maximum shear stress will be: [IES-1994] (a) 1.067 τ (b) 1.143 τ (c) 1.333 τ (d) 2 τ T Gθ τ TR 1 IES-36. Ans. (a) = = or τ = if T is const. τ α J L R J J τh J D4 16 = = = = 1.06666 4 τ Jh 15 ⎛D⎞ 4 D −⎜ ⎟ ⎝2⎠

IES-37.

A solid shaft of diameter 100 mm, length Page 291 of 429 1000 mm is subjected to a twisting moment 'T’ The maximum shear stress developed in the shaft is 60 N/mm2. A hole of 50 mm diameter is now drilled throughout the length of the shaft. To

Chapter-9

Torsion

S K Mondal’s

develop a maximum shear stress of 60 N/mm2 in the hollow shaft, the torque 'T’ must be reduced by: [IES-1998] (a) T/4 (b) T/8 (c) T/12 (d)T/16

Tr 16T T ′32(d / 2) = = 4 4 3 J πd d − ( d / 2) 1 ∴ Reduction = 16

IES-37. Ans. (d)

τs =

or

T ′ 15 = T 16

IES-38.

Assertion (A): A hollow shaft will transmit a greater torque than a solid shaft of the same weight and same material. [IES-1994] Reason (R): The average shear stress in the hollow shaft is smaller than the average shear stress in the solid shaft. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IES-38. Ans. (a) IES-39.

A hollow shaft is subjected to torsion. The shear stress variation in the shaft along the radius is given by: [IES-1996]

IES-39. Ans. (c)

Shafts in Series IES-40.

What is the total angle of twist of the stepped shaft subject to torque T shown in figure given above?

16Tl π Gd 4 64Tl (c) π Gd 4

(a)

38Tl π Gd 4 66Tl (d) π Gd 4 (b)

[IES-2005]

T × 2l T×l Tl 66Tl + = 64 + 2] = IES-40. Ans. (d) θ = θ1 + θ 2 = 4 4 [ 4 π πd Gd Gd4 × ( 2d) G× G. 32 32

Shafts in Parallel IES-41.

For the two shafts connected in parallel, find which statement is true? (a)

Torque in each shaft is the same

(b)

Shear stress in each shaft is the same

(c)

Angle of twist of each shaft is the same

(d)

Torsional stiffness of each shaft is the same

IES-41. Ans. (c)

[IES-1992]

Page 292 of 429

Chapter-9 IES-42.

Torsion

S K Mondal’s

A circular section rod ABC is fixed at ends A and C. It is subjected to torque T at B. AB = BC = L and the polar moment of inertia of portions AB and BC are 2 J and J respectively. If G is the modulus of rigidity, what is the angle of twist at point B? (a)

TL 3GJ

[IES-2005] (b)

TL 2GJ

(c)

TL GJ

(d)

θ AB = θBC

IES-42. Ans. (a)

or TAB

TABL TBC.L = or TAB = 2TBC G.2J G.J + TBC = T or TBC = T / 3

or QB = Q AB =

IES-43.

2TL GJ

T L TL . = 3 GJ 3GJ

A solid circular rod AB of diameter D and length L is fixed at both ends. A torque T is applied at a section X such that AX = L/4 and BX = 3L/4. What is the maximum shear stress developed in the rod? (a)

16T π D3

(b)

IES-43. Ans. (b)

12T π D3

[IES-2004] (c)

8T π D3

(d)

4T π D3

θ AX = θ XB & TA + TB = T 3L TA.L / 4 TB × 4 or = GJ GJ or TA = 3TB or TA =

τ max

16TA = = π D3

3T , 4

3 ×T 12T 4 = 4 π D3 π D3

16 ×

IES-44.

Two shafts are shown in the above figure. These two shafts will be torsionally equivalent to each other if their (a) Polar moment of inertias are the same (b) Total angle of twists are the same (c) Lengths are the same (d) Strain energies are the same IES-44. Ans. (b)

[IES-1998]

Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Torsion Equation IAS-1.

Assertion (A): In theory of torsion, shearing strains increase radically away from the longitudinal axis of the bar. [IAS-2001] Page 293 of 429 Reason (R): Plane transverse sections before loading remain plane after the torque is applied.

Chapter-9

Torsion

(a) (b) (c) (d) IAS-1. Ans. (b) IAS-2.

The shear stress at a point in a shaft subjected to a torque is: [IAS-1995] (a) Directly proportional to the polar moment of inertia and to the distance of the point form the axis (b) Directly proportional to the applied torque and inversely proportional to the polar moment of inertia. (c) Directly proportional to the applied torque and polar moment of inertia (d) inversely proportional to the applied torque and the polar moment of inertia

IAS-2. Ans. (b) IAS-3.

S K Mondal’s

Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A A is true but R is false A is false but R is true

T τ = J R

If two shafts of the same length, one of which is hollow, transmit equal torque and have equal maximum stress, then they should have equal. [IAS-1994] (a) Polar moment of inertia (b) Polar modulus of section (c) Polar moment of inertia (d) Angle of twist

IAS-3. Ans. (b)

T τ J Here T & τ are same, so should be same i.e. polar modulus of section will = R J R

be same.

Hollow Circular Shafts IAS-4.

A hollow circular shaft having outside diameter 'D' and inside diameter ’d’ subjected to a constant twisting moment 'T' along its length. If the maximum shear stress produced in the shaft is σs then the twisting moment 'T' is given by:

[IAS-1999]

π D −d (a) σ s 8 D4 4

4

π D −d (b) σs 16 D4 4

T Gθ τ τJ IAS-4. Ans. (b) = = gives T = = J L R R

σs ×

4

(c)

π 32

π D −d σs 32 D4 4

(D D 2

4

− d4

)

=

π 16

σs

(D

4

π D −d4 (d) σs 64 D4

4

− d4

4

)

D

Torsional Rigidity IAS-5.

Match List-I with List-II and select the correct answer using the codes given below the lists: [IAS-1996] List-I (Mechanical Properties) List-II ( Characteristics) A. Torsional rigidity 1. Product of young's modulus and second moment of area about the plane of bending B. Modulus of resilience 2. Strain energy per unit volume C. Bauschinger effect 3. Torque unit angle of twist D. Flexural rigidity 4. Loss of mechanical energy due to local yielding Codes: A B C D A B C D (a) 1 3 4 2 (b) 3 2 4 1 (c) 2 4 1 3 (d) 3 1 4 2 IAS-5. Ans. (b) IAS-6.

Assertion (A): Angle of twist per unit length of a uniform diameter shaft depends upon its torsional rigidity. [IAS-2004] Reason (R): The shafts are subjected to torque only. Page 294 of 429 (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A

Chapter-9

Torsion

S K Mondal’s

(c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-6. Ans. (c)

Combined Bending and Torsion IAS-7.

A shaft is subjected to a bending moment M = 400 N.m alld torque T = 300 N.m The equivalent bending moment is: [IAS-2002] (a) 900 N.m (b) 700 N.m (c) 500 N.m (d) 450 N.m

IAS-7. Ans. (d)

Me =

M + M 2 + T 2 400 + 4002 + 3002 = = 450 Nm 2 2

Comparison of Solid and Hollow Shafts IAS-8.

A hollow shaft of length L is fixed at its both ends. It is subjected to torque T at a distance of the shaft?

L from one end. What is the reaction torque at the other end of 3

2T (a) 3

[IAS-2007]

T (b) 2

T (c) 3

T (d) 4

IAS-8. Ans. (c)

IAS-9.

A solid shaft of diameter d is replaced by a hollow shaft of the same material and length. The outside diameter of hollow shaft is

2d while the inside diameter 3

d . What is the ratio of the torsional stiffness of the hollow shaft to that of 3

the solid shaft? (a)

2 3

[IAS-2007] (b)

3 5

(c)

5 3

(d) 2

4 4 π ⎧⎪⎛ 2d ⎞ ⎛ d ⎞ ⎫⎪

⎛T IAS-9. Ans. (c) Torsional stiffness = ⎜ ⎝θ IAS-10.

⎨⎜ ⎟ −⎜ ⎟ ⎬ K H 32 ⎪⎩⎝ 3 ⎠ ⎝ 3 ⎠ ⎭⎪ 5 ⎞ GJ = = or ⎟= π 4 3 KS ⎠ L .d 32

Two steel shafts, one solid of diameter D and the other hollow of outside diameter D and inside diameter D/2, are twisted to the same angle of twist per unit length. The ratio of maximum shear stress in solid shaft to that in the hollow shaft is: [IAS-1998] (a)

4 τ 9

(b)

8 τ 7

(c)

16 τ 15

(d)

τ

T τ Gθ Gθ R as outside diameter of both the shaft is D so τ is or τ = = = J R L L same for both the cases.

IAS-10. Ans. (d)

Page 295 of 429

Chapter-9

Torsion

S K Mondal’s

Shafts in Series IAS-11.

Two shafts having the same length and material are joined in series. If the ratio of the diameter of the first shaft to that of the second shaft is 2, then the ratio of the angle of twist of the first shaft to that of the second shaft is: [IAS-1995; 2003] (a) 16 (b) 8 (c) 4 (d) 2

1 1 ∞ J d4

IAS-11. Ans. (a) Angle of twist is proportional to IAS-12.

A circular shaft fixed at A has diameter D for half of its length and diameter D/2 over the other half. What is the rotation of C relative of B if the rotation of B relative to A is 0.1 radian? [IAS-1994] (a) 0.4 radian (b) 0.8 radian (c) 1.6 radian (d) 3.2 radian

(T, L and C remaining same in both cases)

πd 4 T Gθ 1 1 or θ∞ or θ∞ 4 ∵ J = = 32 J L J d 4 θ d Here or θ = 1.6 radian. = 0.1 (d / 2)4

IAS-12. Ans. (c)

Shafts in Parallel IAS-13.

A stepped solid circular shaft shown in the given figure is built-in at its ends and is subjected to a torque To at the shoulder section. The ratio of reactive torque T1 and T2 at the ends is (J1 and J2 are polar moments of inertia):

J 2 × l2 J1 × l1 J ×l (c) 1 2 J 2 × l1

J 2 × l1 J 1 × l2 J ×l (d) 1 1 J 2 × l2

(b)

(a)

[IAS-2001] IAS-13. Ans. (c)

θ1 = θ 2

or

T1l1 T2l2 = GJ1 GJ 2

or

T1 ⎛ J1 l2 ⎞ =⎜ × ⎟ T2 ⎝ J 2 l1 ⎠

IAS-14.

Steel shaft and brass shaft of same length and diameter are connected by a flange coupling. The assembly is rigidity held at its ends and is twisted by a torque through the coupling. Modulus of rigidity of steel is twice that of brass. If torque of the steel shaft is 500 Nm, then the value of the torque in brass shaft will be: [IAS-2001] (a) 250 Nm (b) 354 Nm (c) 500 Nm (d) 708 Nm IAS-14. Ans. (a)

θ1 = θ 2 or IAS-15.

Ts ls Tl = bb Gs J s Gb J b

or

Ts Tb = Gs Gb

or

Tb Gb 1 = = Ts Gs 2

or Tb =

Ts = 250 Nm 2

A steel shaft with bult-in ends is subjected to the action of a torque Mt applied at an intermediate cross-section 'mn' as shown in the given figure. [IAS-1997] Page 296 of 429

Chapter-9

Torsion

S K Mondal’s

Assertion (A): The magnitude of the twisting moment to which the portion BC is subjected is

M ta a+b

Reason(R): For geometric compatibility, angle of twist at 'mn' is the same for the portions AB and BC. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-15. Ans. (a) IAS-16.

A steel shaft of outside diameter 100 mm is solid over one half of its length and hollow over the other half. Inside diameter of hollow portion is 50 mm. The shaft if held rigidly at two ends and a pulley is mounted at its midsection i.e., at the junction of solid and hollow portions. The shaft is twisted by applying torque on the pulley. If the torque carried by the solid portion of the shaft is 16000kg-m, then the torque carried by the hollow portion of the shaft will be: [IAS-1997] (a) 16000 kg-m (b) 15000 kg-m (c) 14000 kg-m (d) 12000 kg-m

π

IAS-16. Ans.(b) θ s = θH

(

)

100 4 − 50 4 TsL THL JH 32 or = or TH = TS × = 16000 × = 15000kgm π GJs GJH Js 4 100 32

(

Page 297 of 429

)

Chapter-9

Torsion

S K Mondal’s

Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question IES 2010 Q.

A hollow steel rod 200 mm long is to be used as torsional spring. The ratio of inside to outside diameter is 1 : 2. The required stiffness of this spring is 100 N.m /degree. Determine the outside diameter of the rod. Value of G is

Ans.

8 × 104 N/mm2 .

[10 Marks]

Length of a hollow steel rod = 200mm Ratio of inside to outside diameter = 1 : 2 Stiffness of torsional spring = 100 Nm /degree. = 5729.578 N m/rad 4

Rigidity of modulus (G) = 8 × 10 N / mm Find outside diameter of rod : We know that

T G.θ = J L

2

Where T = Torque

T ⎛N− M⎞ = Stiffness ⎜ ⎟ θ ⎝ rad ⎠ J = polar moment Stiffness =

T G.J = θ L

θ = twist angle in rad L = length of rod.

d2 = 2d1

π × d 42 - d14 32 π J= × 16d14 - d14 32

J=

( (

J=

)

)

d1 1 = d2 2

π × d14 × 15 32

8 × 104 × 106 N / m2 π × × d14 × 15 0.2 32

5729.578 × .2 × 32 = d14 10 8 × 10 × π × 15 d1 = 9.93 × 10−3 m. d1 = 9.93mm. d 2 = 2 × 9.93 = 19.86 mm

Ans.

Conventional Question GATE - 1998 Question:

A component used in the Mars pathfinder can be idealized as a circular bar clamped at its ends. The bar should withstand a torque of 1000 Nm. The component is assembled on earth when the temperature is 30°C. Temperature on Mars at the site of landing is -70°C. The material of the bar has an allowable shear stress of 300 MPa and its young's modulus is 200 GPa. Design the diameter of the bar taking a factor of safety of 1.5 and assuming a coefficient of thermal expansion for the material of the bar as 12 × 10–6/°C. Given: Page 298 of 429

Chapter-9

Torsion tE = 30 C; tm = −700 C;

Tmax = 1000Nm;

0

S K Mondal’s

τ allowable = 300MPa

E = 200GPa; F.O.S. = 1.5; α = 12 × 10 / C −6

0

Diameter of the bar,D : Change in length,δ L = L ∝ Δt,where L = original length,m. Change in lengthat Mars = L × 12 × 10 −6 × ⎣⎡30 − ( −70 )⎦⎤ = 12 × 10 −4 L meters Change in length 12 × 10 −4 L = = 12 × 10 −4 original length L

Linear strain =

σ a = axial stress = E × linear strain = 200 × 109 × 12 × 10 −4 = 2.4 × 108 N / m

2

From max imum shear stress equation,we have

τ max

⎡⎛ 16T ⎞ 2 ⎛ σ a ⎞ 2 ⎤ = ⎢⎜ +⎜ ⎟ ⎥ 3 ⎟ ⎣⎢⎝ π D ⎠ ⎝ 2 ⎠ ⎦⎥

τ allowable

300 = 200MPa F.O.S 1.5 Substituting the values, we get where, τ max =

=

2

⎛ 16 × 1000 ⎞ 8 4 × 1016 = ⎜ ⎟ + 1.2 × 10 3 D π ⎝ ⎠ 16 × 1000 or = 1.6 × 108 π D3

(

)

2

1/3

⎛ 16 × 1000 ⎞ or D = ⎜ 8 ⎟ ⎝ π × 1.6 × 10 ⎠

= 0.03169 m = 31.69 mm

Conventional Question IES-2009 Q.

Ans.

In a torsion test, the specimen is a hollow shaft with 50 mm external and 30 mm internal diameter. An applied torque of 1.6 kN-m is found to produce an angular twist of 0.4º measured on a length of 0.2 m of the shaft. The Young’s modulus of elasticity obtained from a tensile test has been found to be 200 GPa. Find the values of (i) Modulus of rigidity. (ii) Poisson’s ratio. [10-Marks] We have

T τ Gθ = = J r L

......... (i)

Where J = polar moment of inertia

J= =

(

π D4 − d4 32

(

)

)

π 504 − 304 × 10−12 32

= 5.338 × 10−7 T = 1.6 kN − m = 1.6 × 103 N-m θ = 0.4º l = 0.2 m E = 200 × 109 N/m 2 From equation (i)

T Gθ = J L Page 299 of 429

Chapter-9

Torsion 1.6 × 103 5.338 × 10 − 7 ⇒ G=

S K Mondal’s

π ⎤ ⎡ G × ⎢ 0.4 × 180 ⎥⎦ ⎣ = 0.2

1.6 × 0.2 × 103 × 180

0.4 × π × 5.338 × 10 − 7 = 85.92 GPa We also have

E = 2 G (1 + v)

∴ 200 = 2 × 85.92 (1 + v ) ⇒ 1 + v = 1.164 ⇒ v = 0.164 Conventional Question IAS - 1996 Question:

A solid circular uniformly tapered shaft of length I, with a small angle of taper is subjected to a torque T. The diameter at the two ends of the shaft are D and 1.2 D. Determine the error introduced of its angular twist for a given length is determined on the uniform mean diameter of the shaft. For shaft of tapering's section, we have

2TL ⎡ R12 + R1R 2 + R 22 ⎤ 32TL ⎡ D12 + D1D2 + D22 ⎤ ⎢ ⎥= ⎢ ⎥ 3Gπ ⎣ R13R32 D13D32 ⎦ 3Gπ ⎣ ⎦ 2 2 32TL ⎡ (1.2 ) + 1.2 × 1 + (1) ⎤ = ⎢ ⎥ [∵ D1 = D and D2 = 1.2D] 3 3 3Gπ D4 ⎢ × 1.2 1 ⎥ ( ) ( ) ⎣ ⎦ 32TL = × 2.1065 3Gπ D4 1.2D + D Now, Davg = = 1.1D 2

θ=

2 32TL ⎡ 3 (1.1D ) ⎤ 32TL 3 32TL ×⎢ × = × 2.049 θ'= ⎥= 6 4 4 3Gπ ⎢ (1.1D ) ⎥ 3Gπ (1.2 ) .D 3Gπ D4 ⎣ ⎦

Error =

θ − θ ' 2.1065 − 2.049 = = 0.0273 or 2.73% 2.1065 θ

Conventional Question ESE-2008 Question:

Solution:

A hollow shaft and a solid shaft construction of the same material have the same length and the same outside radius. The inside radius of the hollow shaft is 0.6 times of the outside radius. Both the shafts are subjected to the same torque. (i) What is the ratio of maximum shear stress in the hollow shaft to that of solid shaft? (ii) What is the ratio of angle of twist in the hollow shaft to that of solid shaft?

T τ Gθ = = J R L Inside radius (r) Given, = 0.6 and Th = Ts = T Out side (R) Using

(i) τ =

T .R T .R gives ; For hollow shaft (τh ) = π 4 J R −r 4) ( 2 Page 300 of 429

Chapter-9

Torsion

S K Mondal’s

T .R and for solid shaft ( τ s)= π 4 .R 2 Therefore

(ii) θ =

τn R4 = 4 = τs R −r 4

1 1 = = 1.15 4 1− 0.64 ⎛ r ⎞⎟ 1− ⎜⎜ ⎟⎟ ⎜⎝ R ⎠

TL T .L T .L gives θh = and θs = ⎛ ⎞ π π GJ G. (R 4 − r 4 ) G.⎜⎜ .R 4 ⎟⎟⎟ ⎜⎝ 2 2 ⎠

Therefore

θh R4 = 4 = θs R − r 4

1 1 = = 1.15 4 1− 0.64 ⎛ r ⎞⎟ 1− ⎜⎜ ⎟⎟ ⎜⎝ R ⎠

Conventional Question ESE-2006: Question:

Two hollow shafts of same diameter are used to transmit same power. One shaft is rotating at 1000 rpm while the other at 1200 rpm. What will be the nature and magnitude of the stress on the surfaces of these shafts? Will it be the same in two cases of different? Justify your answer. We know power transmitted (P) = Torque (T) ×rotation speed ( ω )

And shear stress ( τ ) =

Therefore τ α

P. D T .R PR 2 = = ⎛ ⎞ N 2 π π J ωJ ⎜ ⎟⎟ ( D 4 − d 4 ) ⎜⎜⎝ ⎠ 60 ⎟ 32

1 as P, D and d are constant. N

So the shaft rotating at 1000 rpm will experience greater stress then 1200 rpm shaft.

Conventional Question ESE-2002 Question:

A 5 cm diameter solid shaft is welded to a flat plate by 1 cm filled weld. What will be the maximum torque that the welded joint can sustain if the permissible shear stress in the weld material is not to exceed 8 kN/cm2? Deduce the expression for the shear stress at the throat from the basic theory. Consider a circular shaft connected to a plate by means of a fillet joint as shown in figure. If the shaft is subjected to a torque, shear stress develops in the weld. Assuming that the weld thickness is very small compared to the diameter of the shaft, the maximum shear stress occurs in the throat area. Thus, for a given torque the maximum shear stress in the weld is

τmax

⎛d ⎞ T ⎜⎜ + t ⎟⎟⎟ ⎜⎝ 2 ⎠ = J

Where T = Torque applied. d = outer diameter of the shaft t = throat thickness J = polar moment of area of the throat section =

π ⎡ π 4 (d + 2t ) − d 4 ⎤⎥⎦ = d 3 × t ⎢ ⎣ 32 4

Page 301 of 429

Chapter-9

Torsion [As t <<d] then τmax

S K Mondal’s

d 2 = 2T = π 3 πtd 2 d t 4 T

Given τmax

d = 5 cm = 0.05 m & t = 1cm = 0.1 m 8000N = 8 kN / cm 2 = = 80MPa = 80 ×106 N / m 2 2 −4 (10 ) m

∴T =

πd 2t τmax π × 0.052 × 0.01× 80 ×106 = = 3.142 kNm 2 2

Conventional Question ESE-2000 Question:

The ratio of inside to outside diameter of a hollow shaft is 0.6. If there is a solid shaft with same torsional strength, what is the ratio of the outside diameter of hollow shaft to the diameter of the equivalent solid shaft. Let D = external diameter of hollow shaft So d = 0.6D internal diameter of hollow shaft And Ds=diameter of solid shaft From torsion equation T τ = J R π {D 4 − ( 0 .6 D )4 } τJ 3 2 = τ × o r ,T = f o r h o llo w s h a f t R (D / 2 ) π D s4 τJ = J × 32 f o r s o lid s h a f t Ds R 2 π D 3s {1 − ( 0 . 6 ) 4 } = τ 16

and T=

τ

πD 3 16

or,

D = Ds

3

1 = 1 .0 7 2 1 − ( 0 .6 )4

Conventional Question ESE-2001 Question:

A cantilever tube of length 120 mm is subjected to an axial tension P = 9.0 kN, A torsional moment T = 72.0 Nm and a pending Load F = 1.75 kN at the free end. The material is aluminum alloy with an yield strength 276 MPa. Find the thickness of the tube limiting the outside diameter to 50 mm so as to ensure a factor of safety of 4.

Polar moment of inertia (J) =2πR 3t =

πD 3 t 4

Page 302 of 429

Chapter-9

Torsion S K Mondal’s τ T TD T.R TD 2T 2 × 72 18335 = = = = = = or, τ = J R J t 2J πD 3 t πD 2t π × (0.050)2 × t 2× 4 P 9000 9000 57296 = = Direct stress (σ1 ) = = A t πdt π(0.050)t d My M 2 Md = = Maximum bending stress (σ 2 ) = [J = 2I ] I I J 1750 × 0.120 × 0.050 × 4 106952 = = π × (0.050)3 t t 164248 ∴ Total longitudinal stress (σb ) = σ1 + σ 2 = t Maximum principal stress 2

⎛σ ⎞ σ 164248 + (σ1) = b + ⎜⎜⎜ b ⎟⎟⎟ + τ 2 = ⎝2⎠ 2 2t

2 2 ⎛ 276 ×106 ⎟⎞ ⎛164248 ⎞⎟ ⎛18335 ⎞⎟ ⎜ ⎜⎜ ⎜ + = ⎟ ⎟ ⎜ ⎜ ⎟⎟⎟ ⎜⎝ ⎜⎝ 2t ⎟⎠ ⎜⎝ t ⎠⎟ 4 ⎠

or , t = 2.4 ×10−3 m = 2.4 mm Conventional Question ESE-2000 & ESE 2001 Question:

A hollow shaft of diameter ratio 3/8 required to transmit 600 kW at 110 rpm, the maximum torque being 20% greater than the mean. The shear stress is not to exceed 63 MPa and the twist in a length of 3 m not to exceed 1.4 degrees. Determine the diameter of the shaft. Assume modulus of rigidity for the shaft material as 84 GN/m2. Let d = internal diameter of the hollow shaft And D = external diameter of the hollow shaft (given) d = 3/8 D = 0.375D Power (P)= 600 kW, speed (N) =110 rpm, Shear stress( τ )= 63 MPa. Angle of twist ( θ )=1.4°, Length ( ) =3m , modulus of rigidity (G) = 84GPa

2πN 60 3 60× P 60× (600×10 ) or T= = = 52087Nm 2× π ×110 2πN ∴ Tmax = 1.2×T = 1.2×52087 =62504 Nm We know that, (P) = T.

ω = T.

[T is average torque]

First we consider that shear stress is not to exceed 63 MPa From torsion equation

or J =

T τ = J R

T .R T .D = 2τ τ

π ⎡ 4 62504× D 4⎤ D − (0.375 D ) = ⎢ ⎥ ⎦ 2× (63×106 ) 32 ⎣ or D = 0.1727 m = 172.7 mm −−−−(i ) or

Second we consider angle of twist is not exceed 1.40 =

Page 303 of 429

Chapter-9

Torsion

S K Mondal’s

T Gθ = J

From torsion equation

T Gθ = J π or ⎡⎣⎢ D 4 − (0.375 D) 4 ⎤⎦⎥ = 32

or

62504×3 ⎛ π ×1.5 ⎞⎟ (84×109 ) ⎜⎜ ⎜⎝ 180 ⎠⎟⎟

or D = 0.1755m = 175.5mm −−−−(ii ) So both the condition will satisfy if greater of the two value is adopted

so D=175.5 mm Conventional Question ESE-1997 Question: Answer:

Determine the torsional stiffness of a hollow shaft of length L and having outside diameter equal to 1.5 times inside diameter d. The shear modulus of the material is G. Outside diameter (D) =1.5 d Polar modulus of the shaft (J) =

π π D 4 − d 4 ) = d 4 (1.54 −1) ( 32 32

T τ Gθ = = L J R π 4 G.θ d (1.54 − 1) GθJ 0.4Gθd 4 32 or T = = = L L L We know that

Conventional Question AMIE-1996 Question:

The maximum normal stress and the maximum shear stress analysed for a shaft of 150 mm diameter under combined bending and torsion, were found to be 120 MN/m2 and 80 MN/m2 respectively. Find the bending moment and torque to which the shaft is subjected. If the maximum shear stress be limited to 100 MN/m2, find by how much the torque can be increased if the bending moment is kept constant.

Given: σ max = 120MN / m2 ;τ max = 80MN / m2 ;d = 150mm = 0.15m

Part − 1:

M; T

We know that for combined bending and torsion, we have the following expressions:

16 ⎡ − − − (i) M + M2 + T 2 ⎤ ⎦ π d3 ⎣ 16 τ max = 3 ⎡ M2 + T 2 ⎤ and − − − − ( ii ) ⎦ πd ⎣ Substituting the given values in the above equations, we have 16 ⎡M + M2 + T 2 ⎤ − − − − − − ( iii ) 120 = 3 ⎣ ⎦ π × ( 0.15 )

σ max =

80 = or

16

π × ( 0.15 )

M +T = 2

2

3

⎡ M2 + T 2 ⎤ − − − − − − − − − ( iv ) ⎣ ⎦

80 × π × ( 0.15 ) 16

3

= 0.053 − − − − − − ( v )

Page 304 of 429

Chapter-9

Torsion Substituting this values in equation ( iii ) , we get

16

120 = ∴

π × ( 0.1503 )

S K Mondal’s

[M + 0.053]

M = 0.0265MNm

Substituting for M in equation ( v ) , we have

( 0.0265 )

2

+ T 2 = 0.053 T = 0.0459MNm

or

[∵τ max = 100MN / m2 ]

Part II : Increase in torque :

Bending moment (M) to be kept cons tan t = 0.0265MNm 2

( 0.0265 )

or

2

⎡100 × π × ( 0.15 )3 ⎤ ⎥ = 0.004391 +T =⎢ 16 ⎢⎣ ⎥⎦ 2

T = 0.0607 MNm ∴The increased torque = 0.0607 − 0.0459 = 0.0148MNm Conventional Question ESE-1996

Question: A solid shaft is to transmit 300 kW at 120 rpm. If the shear stress is not to exceed 100 MPa, Find the diameter of the shaft, What percent saving in weight would be obtained if this shaft were replaced by a hollow one whose internal diameter equals 0.6 of the external diameter, the length, material and maximum allowable shear stress being the same? Answer: Given P= 300 kW, N = 120 rpm, τ =100 MPa, d H = 0.6 DH Diameter of solid shaft, Ds:

2πNT 60×1000 T τ We know that = J R We know that P =

or, T=

τ .J R

or 300 =

2π ×120×T or T=23873 Nm 60×1000

100×106 × or, 23873 =

π 4 Ds 32

Ds 2

or, Ds= 0.1067 m =106.7mm

Percentage saving in weight:

TH = Ts

Page 305 of 429

Chapter-9

Torsion ⎛τ × J ⎜⎜ ⎝⎜ R or ,

⎞⎟ ⎟ ⎠⎟

4 H

⎛τ × J = ⎜⎜ ⎝⎜ R

H

⎞⎟ ⎟ ⎠⎟

s

4 H

{D − d } = D s3 DH

or ,DH = A g a in

Ds 3

4

(1 − 0 .6 )

S K Mondal’s

or , =

D H4 − (0 .6 D H ) 4 = D s3 DH

1 0 6 .7 3

1 − 0 .6 4

= 1 1 1 .8 m m

A L ρ g A WH = H H H = H As Ls ρ s g As WS

π (D H2 − d H2 ) D H2 (1 − 0 .6 2 ) ⎛ 1 1 1 .8 ⎞ 2 AH 4 ⎟ 1 − 0 .6 )2 = 0 .7 0 2 = = = ⎜⎜ 2 ⎜⎝ 1 0 6 .7 ⎠⎟⎟ ( π 2 As D s D 4 s ⎛ W ⎞ ∴ P e rc e n ta g e s a v in g s in w e ig h t = ⎜⎜⎜1 - H ⎟⎟⎟ × 1 0 0 ⎜⎝ W ⎠⎟ s

= (1 -0 .7 0 2 )× 1 0 0 = 2 9 .8 %

Page 306 of 429

Page 307 of 429

10. Thin Cylinder Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) 1. Thin Rings Uniformly distributed loading (radial) may be due to either •

Internal pressure or external pressure

Centrifugal force as in the case of a rotating ring

Case-I: Internal pressure or external pressure

s = qr

σ=

s qr = A A

Unit stress,

Circumferential strain, ∈c =

Diametral strain, ( ∈d ) = Circumferential strain, ( ∈c )

σ E

=

qr AE

Case-II: Centrifugal force

wω 2 r 2 Hoop's Tension, s = g

Where w = wt. per unit length of circumferential element

ω •

Hoop's stress,

σ=

= Angular velocity

s w 2 2 = .ω r A Ag

2. Thin Walled Pressure Vessels For thin cylinders whose thickness may be considered small compared to their diameter.

Inner dia of the cylinder (d i ) > 15 or 20 wall thickness (t)

Page 308 of 429

Chapter-10

Thin Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

3. General Formula σ1 r1 Where

+

σ2 r2

=

p t

σ 1 =Meridional stress at A σ 2 =Circumferential / Hoop's stress P = Intensity of internal gas pressure/ fluid pressure t = Thickness of pressure vessel.

4. Some cases: •

Cylindrical vessel

σ1 =

pr pD = 2t 4t

τ max = •

σ1 − σ 2 2

σ2 = =

⎡⎣ r1 → ∞, r2 = r ⎤⎦

pr pD = 4t 8t

Spherical vessel

pr pD = 2t 4t

σ1 = σ 2 = •

pr pD = t 2t

[r1 = r2 = r]

Conical vessel

σ1 =

py tan α [ r1 → ∞ ] 2t cos α

py tan α t cos α

σ2 =

and

α

Volume

'V'

of

the

spherical

shell,

V=

π 6

α

Di3

1/3

⎛ 6V ⎞ ⇒ Di = ⎜ ⎟ ⎝ π ⎠ •

σ2

σ2

Notes:

σ1

α

Design of thin cylindrical shells is based on hoop's stress

5. Volumetric Strain (Dilation) ΔV =∈x + ∈y + ∈z V0

Rectangular block,

Cylindrical pressure vessel

∈ 1=Longitudinal strain =

σ1 E

−μ

σ2

σ2 E

=

σ1

pr [1 − 2μ ] 2 Et

pr [1 − 2μ ] E E 2 Et ΔV pr pD Volumetric Strain, [5 − 4μ] = [5 − 4μ] =∈1 +2 ∈2 = Vo 2 Et 4 Et

∈2 =Circumferential strain =

−μ

=

i.e. Volumetric strain, (∈v ) = longitudinal strain (∈1 ) + 2 × circumferential strain (∈2 )

Spherical vessels

∈=∈1 =∈2 =

pr [1 − μ ] 2 Et

Page 309 of 429

α

Chapter-10

ΔV 3 pr [1 − μ ] = 3 ∈= V0 2 Et

Thin Cylinder

6. Thin cylindrical shell with hemispherical end Condition for no distortion at the junction of cylindrical and hemispherical portion

t2 1 − μ = t1 2 − μ

Where, t1= wall thickness of cylindrical portion t2 = wall thickness of hemispherical portion

7. Alternative method Consider the equilibrium of forces in the z-direction acting on the part cylinder shown in figure. Force due to internal pressure p acting on area π D2/4 = p. π D2/4 Force due to longitudinal stress sL acting on area π Dt = σ 1 π Dt

Equating: or

p. π D2/4 = σ 1 π Dt

σ1 =

pd pr = 4t 2t

Now consider the equilibrium of forces in the x-direction acting on the sectioned cylinder shown in figure. It is assumed that the circumferential stress σ 2 is constant through the thickness of the cylinder. Force due to internal pressure p acting on area Dz = pDz Force due to circumferential stress σ 2 acting on area 2tz = σ 2 2tz

Equating: pDz = σ 2 2tz or σ 2 =

pD pr = 2t t

Page 310 of 429

S K Mondal’s

Chapter-10

Thin Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Longitudinal stress GATE-1.

The maximum principal strain in a thin cylindrical tank, having a radius of 25 cm and wall thickness of 5 mm when subjected to an internal pressure of 1MPa, is (taking Young's modulus as 200 GPa and Poisson's ratio as 0.2) [GATE-1998] (a) 2.25 × 10–4 (b) 2.25 (c) 2.25 × 10–6 (d) 22.5 pr 1× 250 GATE-1. Ans. (a) Circumferential or Hoop stress (σ c ) = = = 50MPa t 5 pr Longitudinal stress (σ l ) = = 25MPa 2t

ec =

σc E

−μ

σl E

=

50 × 106 25 × 106 − 0.2 × = 2.25 × 10−4 200 × 109 200 × 109

Maximum shear stress GATE-2.

A thin walled cylindrical vessel of well thickness, t and diameter d is fitted with gas to a gauge pressure of p. The maximum shear stress on the vessel wall will then be: [GATE-1999]

(a)

pd t

(b)

GATE-2. Ans. (d) σ c =

pd , 2t

σl =

pd , 4t

pd 2t

(c)

Maximum shear stress =

pd 4t

(d)

σc − σl 2

=

pd 8t

pd 8t

Change in dimensions of a thin cylindrical shell due to an internal pressure Statement for Linked Answers and Questions 3 and 4 A cylindrical container of radius R = 1 m, wall thickness 1 mm is filled with water up to a depth of 2 m and suspended along its upper rim. The density of water is 1000 kg/m3 and acceleration due to gravity is 10 m/s2. The self-weight of the cylinder is negligible. The formula for hoop stress in a thin-walled cylinder can be used at all points along the height of the cylindrical container. [GATE-2008] GATE-3.

The axial and circumferential stress ( σ a , σ c ) experienced by the cylinder wall

at mid-depth (1 m as shown) are (a) (10,10) MPa (b) (5,10) MPa (c) (10,5) MPa GATE-3. Ans. (a) Pressure (P) = h ρ g = 1 × 1000 × 10 = 10 kPa Axial Stress ( σ a ) ⇒ σ a × 2πRt = ρg × πR L 2

ρ gRL

1000 × 10 × 1 × 1 = 10 MPa 1 × 10 −3 PR Page 10 ×311 1 of 429 Circumferential Stress( σ c )= = = 10 MPa t 1 × 10 −3

or σ a =

t

=

(d) (5,5)MPa

Chapter-10 GATE-4.

Thin Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

If the Young's modulus and Poisson's ratio of the container material are 100 GPa and 0.3, respectively, the axial strain in the cylinder wall at mid-depth is: (a) 2 × 10–5 (b) 6 × 10–5 (c) 7 × 10–5 (d) 1.2 × 10–5

GATE-4. Ans. (c)

εa =

σa E

−μ

σc E

=

10 10 − 0 .3 × = 7 × 10 −5 −3 −3 100 × 10 100 × 10

Previous 20-Years IES Questions Circumferential or hoop stress IES-1. Match List-I with List-II and select the correct answer: [IES-2002] List-I List-II (2-D Stress system loading) (Ratio of principal stresses) A. Thin cylinder under internal pressure 1. 3.0 B. Thin sphere under internal pressure 2. 1.0 C. Shaft subjected to torsion 3. –1.0 4. 2.0 Codes: A B C A B C (a) 4 2 3 (b) 1 3 2 (c) 4 3 2 (d) 1 2 3 IES-1. Ans. (a) IES-2.

A thin cylinder of radius r and thickness t when subjected to an internal hydrostatic pressure P causes a radial displacement u, then the tangential strain caused is: [IES-2002] (a)

du dr

(b)

1 du . r dr

(c)

u r

(d)

2u r

IES-2. Ans. (c) IES-3.

A thin cylindrical shell is subjected to internal pressure p. The Poisson's ratio of the material of the shell is 0.3. Due to internal pressure, the shell is subjected to circumferential strain and axial strain. The ratio of circumferential strain to axial strain is: [IES-2001] (a) 0.425 (b) 2.25 (c) 0.225 (d) 4.25

IES-3. Ans. (d) Circumferential strain, ec = Longitudinal strain, el =

IES-4.

σl E

−μ

σc E

σc E

−μ

=

σl E

=

pr (2 − μ ) 2Et

pr (1 − 2μ ) 2Et

A thin cylindrical shell of diameter d, length ‘l’ and thickness t is subjected to an internal pressure p. What is the ratio of longitudinal strain to hoop strain in terms of Poisson's ratio (1/m)? [IES-2004] (a)

m−2 2m + 1

(b)

IES-4. Ans. (b) longitudinal stress (σ l ) =

m−2 2m − 1

(c)

Pr 2t

Page 312 of 429

2m − 1 m−2

(d)

2m + 2 m −1

Chapter-10

Thin Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

Pr hoop stress (σ c ) = t σl 1 σc 1 1 − − ∈l m−2 ∴ = E m E = 2 m = 1 2m − 1 ∈c σ c 1 σ l 1− − 2m E mE

IES-5.

When a thin cylinder of diameter 'd' and thickness 't' is pressurized with an internal pressure of 'p', (1/m = μ is the Poisson's ratio and E is the modulus of elasticity), then

[IES-1998]

pd ⎛ 1 1 ⎞ ⎜ − ⎟ 2tE ⎝ 2 m ⎠

(a)

The circumferential strain will be equal to

(b)

The longitudinal strain will be equal to

pd ⎛ 1 ⎞ ⎜1 − ⎟ 2tE ⎝ 2m ⎠

(c)

The longitudinal stress will be equal to

pd 2t

(d)

The ratio of the longitudinal strain to circumferential strain will be equal to

m−2 2m − 1 IES-5. Ans. (d) Ratio of longitudinal strain to circumferential strain

⎛1⎞ ⎛1⎞ ⎟ σ c σ l − ⎜ ⎟ {2σ l } m − 2 ⎝m⎠ = ⎝m⎠ = = 2m − 1 ⎛1⎞ ⎛1⎞ σ c − ⎜ ⎟ σ l {2σ l } − ⎜ ⎟ σ l ⎝m⎠ ⎝m⎠ σ σ pr Circumferential strain, ec = c − μ l = (2 − μ )

σl − ⎜

E

Longitudinal strain, el =

IES-6.

σl E

−μ

E

σc E

=

2Et

pr (1 − 2μ ) 2Et

A thin cylinder contains fluid at a pressure of 500 N/m2, the internal diameter of the shell is 0.6 m and the tensile stress in the material is to be limited to 9000 [IES-2000] N/m2. The shell must have a minimum wall thickness of nearly (a) 9 mm (b) 11 mm (c) 17 mm (d) 21 mm

IES-6. Ans. (c) IES-7. A thin cylinder with closed lids is subjected to internal pressure and supported at the ends as shown in figure. The state of stress at point X is as represented in [IES-1999]

Page 313 of 429

Chapter-10

Thin Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

IES-7. Ans. (a) Point 'X' is subjected to circumferential and longitudinal stress, i.e. tension on all faces, but there is no shear stress because vessel is supported freely outside. IES-8.

A thin cylinder with both ends closed is subjected to internal pressure p. The longitudinal stress at the surface has been calculated as σo. Maximum shear stress at the surface will be equal to: [IES-1999]

( a ) 2σ o

( b ) 1.5σ o

(c) σ o

(d)

0.5σ o

IES-8. Ans. (d)

Longitudinal stress = σ o and hoop stress = 2σ o Max. shear stress = IES-9.

A metal pipe of 1m diameter contains a fluid having a pressure of 10 kgf/cm2. lf the permissible tensile stress in the metal is 200 kgf/cm2, then the thickness of the metal required for making the pipe would be: [IES-1993] (a) 5 mm (b) 10 mm (c) 20 mm (d) 25 mm

pd 10 × 100 1000 or 200 = or t = = 2.5 cm 2t 2×t 400

IES-9. Ans. (d) Hoop stress = IES-10.

2σ o − σ o σ o = 2 2

Circumferential stress in a cylindrical steel boiler shell under internal pressure is 80 MPa. Young's modulus of elasticity and Poisson's ratio are respectively 2 × 105 MPa and 0.28. The magnitude of circumferential strain in the boiler shell will be: [IES-1999] (a) 3.44 × 10–4 (b) 3.84 × 10–4 (c) 4 × 10–4 (d) 4.56 ×10 –4

1 (σ 1 − μσ 2 ) E Since circumferential stress σ 1 = 80 MPa and longitudinal stress σ 2 = 40 MPa

IES-10. Ans. (a) Circumferential strain =

1 80 − 0.28 × 40 ] ×106 = 3.44 x10−4 5 6 [ 2 ×10 ×10

∴Circumferential strain = IES-11.

A penstock pipe of 10m diameter carries water under a pressure head of 100 m. If the wall thickness is 9 mm, what is the tensile stress in the pipe wall in MPa? [IES-2009] (a) 2725 (b) 545·0 (c) 272·5 (d) 1090

IES-11. Ans. (b) Tensile stress in the pipe wall = Circumferential stress in pipe wall =

Pd 2t

P = ρgH = 980000N / m2 980000 × 10 ∴ Tensile stress = = 544.44 × 106 N / m2 = 544.44MN / m2 = 544.44MPa 2 × 9 × 10−3 Where,

IES-12.

A water main of 1 m diameter contains water at a pressure head of 100 metres. The permissible tensile stress in the material of the water main is 25 MPa. 2 What is the minimum thickness of the water main? (Take g = 10 m/ s ). [IES-2009] (a) 10 mm (b) 20mm (c) 50 mm (d) 60 mm 6 2 IES-12. Ans. (b) Pressure in the main = ρgh = 1000 × 10 × 1000 = 10 N / mm = 1000 KPa

Hoop stress = σc = ∴

t=

Pd 2t

(

)

106 (1) Pd 1 m = 20 mm = = 6 2σc 2 × 25 × 10 50 Page 314 of 429

Chapter-10

Thin Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

Longitudinal stress IES-13.

Hoop stress and longitudinal stress in a boiler shell under internal pressure are 100 MN/m2 and 50 MN/m2 respectively. Young's modulus of elasticity and Poisson's ratio of the shell material are 200 GN/m2 and 0.3 respectively. The hoop strain in boiler shell is: [IES-1995] −3 −3 −3 −3 (a) 0.425 × 10 (b) 0.5 × 10 (c) 0.585 × 10 (d) 0.75 × 10

IES-13. Ans. (a) Hoop strain =

1 1 (σ h − μσ l ) = [100 − 0.3 × 50] = 0.425 × 10−3 200 × 1000 E

IES-14.

In strain gauge dynamometers, the use of how many active gauge makes the dynamometer more effective? [IES 2007] (a) Four (b) Three (c) Two (d) One IES-14. Ans. (b)

Volumetric strain IES-15.

Circumferential and longitudinal strains in a cylindrical boiler under internal steam pressure are ε1 and ε 2 respectively. Change in volume of the boiler cylinder per unit volume will be:

(a) ε1 + 2ε 2

[IES-1993; IAS 2003]

(b) ε ε

(c) 2ε 1 + ε 2

2 1 2

(d) ε 12ε 2

IES-15. Ans. (c) Volumetric stream = 2 × circumferential strain + longitudinal strain IES-16.

The volumetric strain in case of a thin cylindrical shell of diameter d, thickness t, subjected to internal pressure p is: [IES-2003; IAS 1997] (a)

pd pd . ( 3 − 2 μ ) (b) . ( 4 − 3μ ) 2tE 3tE

(c)

pd . ( 5 − 4μ ) 4tE

(d)

pd . ( 4 − 5μ ) 4tE

(Where E = Modulus of elasticity, μ = Poisson's ratio for the shell material) IES-16. Ans. (c) Remember it.

Spherical Vessel IES-17.

For the same internal diameter, wall thickness, material and internal pressure, the ratio of maximum stress, induced in a thin cylindrical and in a thin spherical pressure vessel will be: [IES-2001] (a) 2 (b) 1/2 (c) 4 (d) 1/4 IES-17. Ans. (a) IES-18.

From design point of view, spherical pressure vessels are preferred over cylindrical pressure vessels because they [IES-1997] (a) Are cost effective in fabrication (b) Have uniform higher circumferential stress (c) Uniform lower circumferential stress (d) Have a larger volume for the same quantity of material used IES-18. Ans. (d)

Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Circumferential or hoop stress IAS-1.

The ratio of circumferential stress to longitudinal stress in a thin cylinder subjected to internal hydrostatic pressure is: [IAS 1994] Page 315 of 429 (a) 1/2 (b) 1 (c) 2 (d) 4 IAS-1. Ans. (c)

Chapter-10 IAS-2.

S K Mondal’s

A thin walled water pipe carries water under a pressure of 2 N/mm2 and discharges water into a tank. Diameter of the pipe is 25 mm and thickness is 2·5 mm. What is the longitudinal stress induced in the pipe? [IAS-2007] (a) 0 (b) 2 N/mm2 (c) 5 N/mm2 (d) 10 N/mm2

IAS-2. Ans. (c) IAS-3.

Thin Cylinder

σ=

Pr 2 × 12.5 = = 5 N/mm 2 2t 2 × 2.5

A thin cylindrical shell of mean diameter 750 mm and wall thickness 10 mm has its ends rigidly closed by flat steel plates. The shell is subjected to internal fluid pressure of 10 N/mm2 and an axial external pressure P1. If the longitudinal stress in the shell is to be zero, what should be the approximate value of P1? [IAS-2007] 2 2 2 (a) 8 N/mm (b) 9 N/mm (c) 10 N/mm (d) 12 N/mm2

⎛ π × 7502 ⎞ 10 × ⎜ ⎟ 4 ⎝ ⎠ IAS-3. Ans. (c) Tensile longitudinal stress due to internal fluid pressure ( δ 1) t = π × 750 ×10 tensile. Compressive longitudinal stress due to external pressure p1 (

δ

l)c =

⎛ π × 750 ⎞ P1 × ⎜ ⎟ 4 ⎝ ⎠ compressive. For zero longitudinal stress ( δ ) = ( δ ) . l t l c π × 750 × 10 2

IAS-4.

Assertion (A): A thin cylindrical shell is subjected to internal fluid pressure that induces a 2-D stress state in the material along the longitudinal and circumferential directions. [IAS-2000] Reason(R): The circumferential stress in the thin cylindrical shell is two times the magnitude of longitudinal stress. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true

IAS-4. Ans. (b) For thin cell

σc =

Pr t

σl =

Pr 2t

IAS-5.

Match List-I (Terms used in thin cylinder stress analysis) with List-II (Mathematical expressions) and select the correct answer using the codes given below the lists: [IAS-1998] List-I List-II A. Hoop stress 1. pd/4t B. Maximum shear stress 2. pd/2t C. Longitudinal stress 3. pd/2σ D. Cylinder thickness 4. pd/8t Codes: A B C D A B C D (a) 2 3 1 4 (b) 2 3 4 1 (c) 2 4 3 1 (d) 2 4 1 3 IAS-5. Ans. (d)

Longitudinal stress IAS-6.

Assertion (A): For a thin cylinder under internal pressure, At least three strain Page 316 of 429 gauges is needed to know the stress state completely at any point on the shell.

Chapter-10

Thin Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

Reason (R): If the principal stresses directions are not know, the minimum number of strain gauges needed is three in a biaxial field. [IAS-2001] (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-6. Ans. (d) For thin cylinder, variation of radial strain is zero. So only circumferential and longitudinal strain has to measurer so only two strain gauges are needed.

Maximum shear stress IAS-7.

The maximum shear stress is induced in a thin-walled cylindrical shell having an internal diameter 'D' and thickness’t’ when subject to an internal pressure 'p' is equal to: [IAS-1996] (a) pD/t (b) pD/2t (c) pD/4t (d) pD/8t σ − σ l PD PD PD IAS-7. Ans. (d) Hoop stress(σ c ) = ∴τ max = c = and Longitudinalstress(σ l ) = 2t 4t 2 8t

Volumetric strain IAS-8.

Circumferential and longitudinal strains in a cylindrical boiler under internal steam pressure are

ε1

and

ε2

respectively. Change in volume of the boiler

cylinder per unit volume will be:

(a) ε1 + 2ε 2

[IES-1993; IAS 2003]

(b) ε1ε 22

(c) 2ε 1 + ε 2

(d) ε 12ε 2

IAS-8. Ans. (c) Volumetric stream = 2 x circumferential strain + longitudinal strain. IAS-9.

The volumetric strain in case of a thin cylindrical shell of diameter d, thickness t, subjected to internal pressure p is: (a)

pd pd . ( 3 − 2 μ ) (b) . ( 4 − 3μ ) 2tE 3tE

[IES-2003; IAS 1997] (c)

pd . ( 5 − 4μ ) 4tE

(d)

pd . ( 4 − 5μ ) 4tE

(Where E = Modulus of elasticity, μ = Poisson's ratio for the shell material)

IAS-9. Ans. (c) Remember it. IAS-10.

A thin cylinder of diameter ‘d’ and thickness 't' is subjected to an internal pressure 'p' the change in diameter is (where E is the modulus of elasticity and μ is the Poisson's ratio) 2

(a)

pd (2 − μ ) 4tE

[IAS-1998]

2

(b)

pd (1 + μ ) 2tE

2

(c)

pd (2 + μ ) tE

2

(d)

pd (2 + μ ) 4tE

IAS-10. Ans. (a) IAS-11.

The percentage change in volume of a thin cylinder under internal pressure having hoop stress = 200 MPa, E = 200 GPa and Poisson's ratio = 0·25 is: [IAS-2002] (a) 0.40

IAS-11. Ans. (d) Hoop stress (σ t ) =

(b) 0·30

Pr = 200 × 106 Pa t Page 317 of 429

(c) 0·25

(d) 0·20

Chapter-10

Thin Cylinder

σ Pr ( 5 − 4μ ) = t ( 5 − 4μ ) 2 Et 2E 6 200 ×10 2 5 − 4 × 0.25 ) = = 9 ( 2 × 200 × 10 1000

S K Mondal’s

Volumetric strain (ev ) =

IAS-12.

A round bar of length l, elastic modulus E and Poisson's ratio μ is subjected to an axial pull 'P'. What would be the change in volume of the bar? (a)

Pl (1 − 2μ ) E

(b)

Pl (1 − 2 μ ) E

(c)

Pl μ E

[IAS-2007] (d)

Pl μE

IAS-12. Ans. (b)

σx =

P , A

or ε x =

σx E

σ y = 0 and σ z = 0 , ε y = −μ

and ε z = − μ

σx E

σx E

or ε v = ε x + ε y + ε z =

σx

(1 − 2μ ) =

E Pl δ V = ε v × V = ε v . Al = (1 − 2μ ) E IAS-13.

P (1 − 2μ ) AE

If a block of material of length 25 cm. breadth 10 cm and height 5 cm undergoes a volumetric strain of 1/5000, then change in volume will be: (b) 0.25 cm3

(a) 0.50 cm3

(c) 0.20 cm3

IAS-13. Ans. (b)

Volumetricstrain(ε v ) = or (δ V ) = ε v × V =

Volume change(δV) Initial volume(V)

1 × 25 × 10 × 5 = 0.25cm3 5000

Page 318 of 429

[IAS-2000] (d) 0.75 cm3

Chapter-10

Thin Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question GATE-1996 Question:

A thin cylinder of 100 mm internal diameter and 5 mm thickness is subjected to an internal pressure of 10 MPa and a torque of 2000 Nm. Calculate the

magnitudes of the principal stresses. Given: d = 100 mm = 0.1 m; t = 5 mm = 0.005 m; D = d + 2t = 0.1 + 2 x 0.005 = 0.11 m p = 10 MPa, 10 x 106N/m2; T= 2000 Nm. Longitudinal stress, σ l = σ x =

pd 10 × 106 × 0.1 = = 50 × 106 N / m2 = 50MN / m2 4t 4 × 0.005

Circumferential stress, σ c = σ y =

pd 10 × 106 × 0.1 = = 100MN / m2 2 × 0.005 2t

To find the shear stress, using Torsional equation,

T τ = , we have J R 2000 × ( 0.05 + 0.005 ) TR T ×R τ = τ xy = = = = 24.14MN / m2 π π J D4 − d4 0.114 − 0.14 32 32

(

)

(

)

Principal stresses are:

σ 1,2 =

σx + σy 2

2

2 ⎛σx −σy ⎞ ± ⎜ ⎟ + (τ xy ) 2 ⎠ ⎝ 2

50 + 100 2 ⎛ 50 − 100 ⎞ = ± ⎜ + ( 24.14 ) ⎟ 2 2 ⎝ ⎠ = 75 ± 34.75 = 109.75 and 40.25MN / m2

σ 1 (Major principal stress ) = 109.75MN / m2 ; σ 2 ( min or principal stress ) = 40.25MN / m2 ; Conventional Question IES-2008 Question:

A thin cylindrical pressure vessel of inside radius ‘r’ and thickness of metal ‘t’ is subject to an internal fluid pressure p. What are the values of (i) Maximum normal stress? (ii) Maximum shear stress?

Circumferential (Hoop) stress (σc ) = Longitudinal stress (σ

)==

p.r t

p.r 2t

Therefore (ii) Maximum shear stress, ( τ max) =

σc − σ p.r = 2 4t

Conventional Question IES-1996 Question:

A thin cylindrical vessel of internal diameter d and thickness t is closed at both ends is subjected to an internal pressure P. How much would be the hoop and longitudinal stress in the material? Page 319 of 429 For thin cylinder we know that

Chapter-10

Thin Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

Pd Hoop or circumferential stress (σ c ) = 2t Pd And longitudinal stress (σ ) = 4t Therefore σ c = 2σ Conventional Question IES-2009 Q.

A cylindrical shell has the following dimensions: Length = 3 m Inside diameter = 1 m Thickness of metal = 10 mm Internal pressure = 1.5 MPa Calculate the change in dimensions of the shell and the maximum intensity of [15-Marks] shear stress induced. Take E = 200 GPa and Poisson’s ratio ν = 0.3

Ans.

We can consider this as a thin cylinder. Hoop stresses, σ1 =

pd 2t

Longitudinal stresses, σ2 =

σ1 − σ 2 2 pd = 8t

pd 4t

Shear stress =

Hence from the given data

σ1 =

σ2 =

1.5 × 106 × 1 −3

= 0.75 × 108

2 × 10 × 10 = 75 MPa

1.5 × 106 × 1 4 × 10 × 10

−3

= 37.5 × 106 = 37.5 MPa

ε1 Hoop strain 1 ( σ − vσ2 ) E 1 Pd = (2 − v ) 4tE

ε1 =

= =

1.5 × 106 × 1 4 × 10 × 10−3 × 200 × 109 37.5 × 106 200 × 109

( 2 − 0.3 )

( 2 − 0.3 )

= 0.31875 × 10−3 Δd = 0.3187 × 10−3 d ∴ change in diameter, Δd = 1 × 0.31875 × 10−3 m = 0.31875 mm Page 320 of 429

Chapter-10 Logitudinal strain, ε2

∈2 = =

Thin Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

pd (1 − 2v ) 4tE

37.5 × 106 200 × 109

(1 − 2 × 0.3)

= 7.5 × 10−5 Δl = 7.5 × 10−5 l or Δl = 7.5 × 10−5 × 3 = 2.25 × 10−4 m = 0.225mm ⇒ Change in length = 0.225 mm and maximum shear stress,

σ=

pd 1.5 × 106 × 1 = 8t 8 × 10 × 10−3 = 18.75 MPa

Conventional Question IES-1998 Question:

A thin cylinder with closed ends has an internal diameter of 50 mm and a wall thickness of 2.5 mm. It is subjected to an axial pull of 10 kN and a torque of 500 Nm while under an internal pressure of 6 MN/m2 (i) Determine the principal stresses in the tube and the maximum shear stress.

(ii) Represent the stress configuration on a square element taken in the load direction with direction and magnitude indicated; (schematic). Given: d = 50 mm = 0.05 m D = d + 2t = 50 + 2 x 2.5 = 55 mm = 0.055 m; Axial pull, P = 10 kN; T= 500 Nm; p = 6MN/m2 (i) Principal stresses ( σ 1,2 ) in the tube and the maximum shear stress ( t max ):

pd P 6 × 106 × 0.05 10 × 103 + = + −3 4t π dt 4 × 2.5 × 10 π × 0.05 × 2.5 × 10−3 = 30 × 106 + 25.5 × 106 = 55.5 × 106 N / m2

σx =

σy =

pd 6 × 106 × 0.05 = = 60 × 106 2t 2 × 2.5 × 10−3

Principal stresses are:

⎛σx + σy ⎞ ⎛σx −σy ⎞ 2 ⎟± ⎜ ⎟ + τ xy 2 ⎠ ⎝ ⎝ 2 ⎠ T τ Us e Torsional equation, = J R

σ 1,2 = ⎜

where J =

π

(D 32

4

)

− d4 =

− − − (1) − − − (i)

π ⎡ 4 4 ( 0.055 ) − ( 0.05 ) ⎤ = 2.848 × 10−7 m4

32 ⎣

( J = polar moment of in ertia )

Substituting the values in ( i ) , we get

Page 321 of 429

Chapter-10

Thin Cylinder 500 τ = 2.848 × 10−7 ( 0.055 / 2 )

τ=

or

500 × ( 0.055 / 2 ) 2.848 × 10−7

S K Mondal’s

= 48.28 × 106 N / m2

Now, substituting the various values in eqn. (i), we have

⎛ 55.5 × 106 + 60 × 106 ⎞ ⎛ 55.5 × 106 − 60 × 106 ± ⎟ ⎜ 2 2 ⎝ ⎠ ⎝

σ 1,2 = ⎜

⎞ 6 ⎟ + 48.28 × 10 ⎠

(

(55.5 + 60) × 106 ± 4.84 × 1012 + 2330.96 × 1012 2 = 57.75 × 106 ± 48.33 × 106 = 106.08MN / m2 ,9.42MN / m2 =

Principal stresses are : σ 1 = 106.08MN / m2 ; σ 2 = 9.42MN / m2 Maximum shear stress,τ max =

σ1 − σ 2 2

=

106.08 − 9.42 = 48.33MN / m2 2

(ii) Stress configuration on a square element :

Page 322 of 429

)

2

11. Thick Cylinder Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) 1. Thick cylinder Inner dia of the cylinder (d i ) < 15 or 20 wall thickness (t)

2. General Expression

3. Difference between the analysis of stresses in thin & thick cylinders •

In thin cylinders, it is assumed that the tangential stress

σ t is uniformly distributed over

the cylinder wall thickness. In thick cylinder, the tangential stress

σ t has the highest magnitude at the inner surface of

the cylinder & gradually decreases towards the outer surface.

σr

is neglected in thin cylinders while it is of significant magnitude in case

of thick cylinders.

4. Strain du . dr

Circumferential /Tangential strain ∈t =

Axial strain,

∈z =

⎛σ σ ⎞ −μ⎜ r + t ⎟ E ⎝ E E ⎠

u r

σz

Page 323 of 429

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

5. Stress •

pi ri 2 Axial stress, σ z = 2 r0 − ri 2

Circumferential /Tangential stress,

σr = A−

B r2

σt = A +

B r2

[Note: Radial stress always compressive so its magnitude always –ive. But in some books they assume that compressive radial stress is positive and they use,

σr =

6. Boundary Conditions

p r2 − p r2 7. A = i i 2 2o o ro − ri

and

At

r = ri ,

At

r = ro

σ r = − pi σ r = − po

ri 2 ro2 B = ( pi − po ) 2 2 (ro − ri )

8. Cylinders with internal pressure (pi) •

pi ri 2 σz = 2 2 r0 − ri

σr = −

pi ri 2 ⎡ r02 ⎤ ⎢ − 1⎥ r02 − ri 2 ⎣ r 2 ⎦

σt = +

pi ri 2 r02 − ri 2

i.e. po = 0

[ -ive means compressive stress]

⎡ r02 ⎤ ⎢ 2 + 1⎥ ⎣r ⎦

(a) At the inner surface of the cylinder

(i ) r = ri (ii ) σ r = − pi pi (ro2 + ri 2 ) (iii ) σ t = + ro2 − ri 2 (iv) τ max =

ro2 . pi ro2 − ri 2

(b) At the outer surface of the cylinder Page 324 of 429

B − A] r2

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

(i ) r = ro (ii ) σ r = 0 2pi ri2 (iii ) σ t = 2 2 ro − ri (c) Radial and circumferential stress distribution within the cylinder wall when only internal pressure acts.

9. Cylinders with External Pressure (po) i.e. pi = 0 po ro2 ro2 − ri 2

⎡ ri 2 ⎤ ⎢i − 2 ⎥ ⎣ r ⎦

σr = −

po ro2 ⎡ ri 2 ⎤ σ t = − 2 2 ⎢i + 2 ⎥ ro − ri ⎣ r ⎦

(a) At the inner surface of the cylinder (i)

r = ri

(ii)

σr = o

(iii)

σt = −

2 po ro2 ro2 − ri 2

(b) At the outer surface of the cylinder (i)

r = ro

(ii)

σ r = − po

(iii)

po (ro2 + ri 2 ) σt = − 2 2 ro − ri

(c) Distribution of radial and circumferential stresses within the cylinder wall when only external pressure acts

Page 325 of 429

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

10. Lame's Equation [for Brittle Material, open or closed end] There is a no of equations for the design of thick cylinders. The choice of equation depends upon two parameters.

Cylinder Material (Whether brittle or ductile)

Condition of Cylinder ends (open or closed)

When the material of the cylinder is brittle, such as cast iron or cast steel, Lame's Equation is used to determine the wall thickness. Condition of cylinder ends may open or closed. It is based on maximum principal stress theory of failure. There principal stresses at the inner surface of the cylinder are as follows: (i) (ii) & (iii)

(i ) σ r = − pi (ii ) σ t = +

pi (r02 + ri 2 ) r02 − ri 2

pi ri 2 (iii ) σ z = + 2 2 ro − ri •

σt >σz >σr

σ t is the criterion of design

For ro = ri + t

ro σ t + pi = ri σ t − pi

⎡ σ +p ⎤ i − 1⎥ ( Lame ' s Equation) t = ri × ⎢ t ⎥⎦ ⎣⎢ σ t − pi

σt =

σ ult fos

11. Clavarino's Equation [for cylinders with closed end & made of ductile material] When the material of a cylinder is ductile, such as mild steel or alloy steel, maximum strain theory of failure is used (St. Venant's theory) is used. Three principal stresses at the inner surface of the cylinder are as follows (i) (ii) & (iii) Page 326 of 429

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

(i ) σ r = − pi (ii )σ t = +

pi (ro2 + ri 2 ) (ro2 − ri 2 )

(iii )σ z = +

pi ri 2 (ro2 − ri 2 )

1 ⎡σ t − (σ r + σ z ) ⎤ ⎦ E⎣

∈t =

∈t =

Or

σ = σ t − μ (σ r + σ z ). Where σ =

σ

is the criterion of design

σ E

=

σ yld / fos E

σ yld fos

ro σ + (1 − 2μ ) pi = σ − (1 + μ ) pi ri •

For ro = ri + t

⎡ σ + (1 − 2 μ ) pi ⎤ t = ri ⎢ − 1⎥ ⎣ σ − (1 + μ ) pi ⎦

( Clavarion's Equation )

12. Birne's Equation [for cylinders with open end & made of ductile material] When the material of a cylinder is ductile, such as mild steel or alloy steel, maximum strain theory of failure is used (St. Venant's theory) is used. Three principal stresses at the inner surface of the cylinder are as follows (i) (ii) & (iii)

(i ) σ r = − pi pi (ro2 + ri 2 ) (ii )σ t = + (ro2 − ri 2 ) (iii )σ z = 0 •

σ = σ t − μσ r

σ

where σ =

σ yld fos

is the criterion of design

ro σ + (1 − μ ) pi = σ − (1 + μ ) pi ri •

For ro = ri + t

⎡ σ + (1 − μ ) pi ⎤ t = ri × ⎢ − 1⎥ ⎣ σ − (1 + μ ) pi ⎦

(Birnie's Equation)

Page 327 of 429

13. Barlow’s equation: [for high pressure gas pipe brittle or ductile material]

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder

t = ro Where σ t =

=

σy fos

σ ult fos

pi

S K Mondal’s [GAIL exam 2004]

σt

for ductile material

for brittle material

14. Compound Cylinder (A cylinder & A Jacket) •

When two cylindrical parts are assembled by shrinking or press-fitting, a contact pressure is created between the two parts. If the radii of the inner cylinder are a and c and that of the outer cylinder are (c- δ ) and b, δ being the radial interference the contact pressure is given by: 2 2 2 ⎤ ⎡ 2 Eδ ⎢ (b − c ) (c − a ) ⎥ P= ⎢ ⎥ Where E is the Young's modulus of the material c ⎢ 2c 2 (b 2 − a 2 ) ⎥ ⎣ ⎦

The inner diameter of the jacket is slightly smaller than the outer diameter of cylinder

When the jacket is heated, it expands sufficiently to move over the cylinder

As the jacket cools, it tends to contract onto the inner cylinder, which induces residual compressive stress.

There is a shrinkage pressure 'P' between the cylinder and the jacket.

The pressure 'P' tends to contract the cylinder and expand the jacket

The shrinkage pressure 'P' can be evaluated from the above equation for a given amount of interference

δ

The resultant stresses in a compound cylinder are found by supervision losing the 2- stresses 

stresses due to shrink fit



stresses due to internal pressure

Derivation:

Due to interference let us assume δ j = increase in inner diameter of jacket and δc = decrease in outer diameter of cylinder. so δ= δ j + δc i.e. without sign. Page 328 of 429

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder

⎡ ⎤ ⎣⎢∈ j = tangential strain⎥⎦

Now δ j =∈ j c =

S K Mondal’s

1 [ σt − µσr ] c E

=

⎤ cP ⎡⎢ b 2 + c 2 + µ⎥ − − − ( i ) 2 2 ⎥ E ⎢⎣ b − c ⎦

And in similar way δc =∈c c =

=-

⎡ ⎤ ⎢σ t =circumferential stress⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ p(b2 +c 2 ) ⎢ + ⎥ 2 2 ⎢ ⎥ b -c ( ) ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢⎣σ r =-p (radial stress) ⎥⎦ 2 2 ⎤ ⎡ ⎢ σ t = − p(c + a ) ⎥ ⎢ (c 2 − a2 ) ⎥⎥ ⎢ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢⎣ σ r = −p ⎥⎦

1 [ σt − µσ r ]c E

cP ⎡⎢ c 2 + a 2 ⎤⎥ - µ − − − (ii ) E ⎢⎣ c 2 − a 2 ⎥⎦

Here -ive signrepresents contraction

Adding ( i ) & ( ii ) ∴ δ = δ j + δc =

Pc E

⎡ 2c 2 ( b 2 − a 2 ) ⎤ ⎢ 2 ⎥ ⎢ (b − c 2 )(c 2 − a 2 ) ⎥ ⎣ ⎦

or P =

E δ ⎡⎢ (b 2 − c 2 )(c 2 − a 2 ) ⎤⎥ c ⎢⎣ 2c 2 (b 2 − a 2 ) ⎥⎦

15. Autofrettage Autofrettage is a process of pre-stressing the cylinder before using it in operation. We know that when the cylinder is subjected to internal pressure, the circumferential stress at the inner surface limits the pressure carrying capacity of the cylinder. In autofrettage pre-stressing develops a residual compressive stresses at the inner surface. When the cylinder is actually loaded in operation, the residual compressive stresses at the inner surface begin to decrease, become zero and finally become tensile as the pressure is gradually increased. Thus autofrettage increases the pressure carrying capacity of the cylinder.

16. Rotating Disc The radial & circumferential (tangential) stresses in a rotating disc of uniform thickness are given by

⎛ 2 ⎞ R02 Ri2 2 σr = ( 3 + μ ) ⎜ R0 + Ri − 2 − r 2 ⎟ 8 r ⎝ ⎠

ρω 2

σt =

ρω 2 8

( 3 + μ ) ⎜ R02 + Ri2 + ⎝

R02 Ri2 1 + 3μ 2 ⎞ .r ⎟ − r2 3+ μ ⎠

ρ = Density of the disc material

ω = Angular speed μ = Poisson's ratio.

Page 329 of 429

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder

Or, Hoop’s stress,

⎛ 1− μ ⎞ 2 ⎤ ⎛ 3+ μ ⎞ 2 ⎡ 2 σt = ⎜ ⎟ Ri ⎥ ⎟ .ρω . ⎢ R0 + ⎜ 3 μ + ⎝ 4 ⎠ ⎝ ⎠ ⎦ ⎣

⎛ 3+ μ ⎞ 2 2 2 σr = ⎜ ⎟ .ρω ⎡⎣ R0 − Ri ⎤⎦ ⎝ 8 ⎠

Page 330 of 429

S K Mondal’s

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Lame's theory GATE-1.

A thick cylinder is subjected to an internal pressure of 60 MPa. If the hoop stress on the outer surface is 150 MPa, then the hoop stress on the internal surface is: [GATE-1996; IES-2001] (a) 105 MPa (b) 180 MPa (c) 210 MPa (d) 135 MPa GATE-1. Ans. (c) If internal pressure = pi; External pressure = zero ⎤ p r2 ⎡r2 Circumferential or hoop stress (σc) = 2 i i 2 ⎢ o2 + 1⎥ ro − ri ⎣ r ⎦ At pi = 60MPa, σ c = 150MPa and r = ro r2 ∴ 150 = 60 2 i 2 ro − ri

⎡ ro2 ⎤ ri2 ⎢ 2 + 1⎥ = 120 2 2 ro − ri ⎣ ro ⎦

r2 150 5 or 2 i 2 = = 120 4 ro − ri

2

⎛r ⎞ 9 or ⎜ o ⎟ = 5 ⎝ ri ⎠

∴ at r = ri

σ c = 60

ri2 ro2 − ri2

⎡ ro2 ⎤ 5 ⎛9 ⎞ ⎢ 2 + 1⎥ = 60 × × ⎜ + 1⎟ = 210 MPa 4 ⎝5 ⎠ ⎣ ri ⎦

Previous 20-Years IES Questions Thick cylinder IES-1.

If a thick cylindrical shell is subjected to internal pressure, then hoop stress, radial stress and longitudinal stress at a point in the thickness will be: (a) Tensile, compressive and compressive respectively [IES-1999] (b) All compressive (c) All tensile (d) Tensile, compressive and tensile respectively IES-1. Ans. (d) Hoop stress – tensile, radial stress – compressive and longitudinal stress – tensile.

IES-2.

Radial and circumferential stress distribution within the cylinder wall when only internal pressure acts. Where does the maximum hoop pressure occur? (a) At the outer surface (c) At the mid-thickness

Distribution of radial and circumferential stresses within the cylinder wall when only external pressure acts.

stress in a thick cylinder under external [IES-2008] (b) At the inner surface (d) At the 2/3rd outer radius

Page 331 of 429

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

IES-2. Ans. (b) Circumferential or hoop stress = σ t

IES-3.

In a thick cylinder pressurized from inside, the hoop stress is maximum at (a) The centre of the wall thickness (b) The outer radius [IES-1998] (c) The inner radius (d) Both the inner and the outer radii IES-3. Ans. (c) IES-4.

Where does the maximum hoop stress in a thick cylinder under external pressure occur? [IES-2008] (a) At the outer surface (b) At the inner surface (c) At the mid-thickness (d) At the 2/3rd outer radius IES-4. Ans. (a) Maximum hoop stress in thick cylinder under external pressure occur at the outer surface.

IES-5.

A thick-walled hollow cylinder having outside and inside radii of 90 mm and 40 mm respectively is subjected to an external pressure of 800 MN/m2. The maximum circumferential stress in the cylinder will occur at a radius of [IES-1998] (a) 40 mm (b) 60 mm (c) 65 mm (d) 90 mm IES-5. Ans. (a) IES-6.

In a thick cylinder, subjected to internal and external pressures, let r1 and r2 be the internal and external radii respectively. Let u be the radial displacement of a material element at radius r, r2 ≥ r ≥ r1 . Identifying the cylinder axis as z axis,

ε rr is: u /θ

[IES-1996]

(a) u/r (b) IES-6. Ans. (c) The strains εr and εθ may be given by

(c) du/dr

Page 332 of 429

(d) du/dθ

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

∂ur 1 since σ z = 0 = ⎡σ r − vσ θ ⎤⎦ ∂r E ⎣ ( r + ur ) Δθ − rΔθ = ur = 1 σ − vσ εθ = ⎡ θ r⎤ ⎦ r Δθ r E ⎣

εr =

Representation of circumferential strain.

and

Lame's theory IES-7.

A thick cylinder is subjected to an internal pressure of 60 MPa. If the hoop stress on the outer surface is 150 MPa, then the hoop stress on the internal surface is: [GATE-1996; IES-2001] (a) 105 MPa (b) 180 MPa (c) 210 MPa (d) 135 MPa

IES-7. Ans. (c) If internal pressure = pi; External pressure = zero ⎤ p r2 ⎡r2 Circumferential or hoop stress (σc) = 2 i i 2 ⎢ o2 + 1⎥ ro − ri ⎣ r ⎦ At pi = 60MPa, σ c = 150MPa and r = ro

∴ 150 = 60

ri2 ro2 − ri2

⎡ ro2 ⎤ ri2 1 120 + = ⎢ 2 ⎥ ro2 − ri2 ⎣ ro ⎦

or

ri2 150 5 = = ro2 − ri2 120 4

2

⎛r ⎞ 9 or ⎜ o ⎟ = r 5 ⎝ i ⎠

∴ at r = ri

σ c = 60

ri2 r − ri2 2 o

⎡ ro2 ⎤ 5 ⎛9 ⎞ ⎢ 2 + 1⎥ = 60 × × ⎜ + 1⎟ = 210 MPa 4 ⎝5 ⎠ r ⎣i ⎦

IES-8.

A hollow pressure vessel is subject to internal pressure. [IES-2005] Consider the following statements: 1. Radial stress at inner radius is always zero. 2. Radial stress at outer radius is always zero. 3. The tangential stress is always higher than other stresses. 4. The tangential stress is always lower than other stresses. Which of the statements given above are correct? (a) 1 and 3 (b) 1 and 4 (c) 2 and 3 (d) 2 and 4 IES-8. Ans. (c) IES-9.

A thick open ended cylinder as shown in the figure is made of a material with permissible normal and shear stresses 200 MPa and 100 MPa respectively. The ratio of permissible pressure based on the normal and shear stress is: [di = 10 cm; do = 20 cm] (a) 9/5 (b) 8/5 (c) 7/5 (d) 4/5

[IES-2002]

IES-9. Ans. (b)

Longitudinal and shear stress IES-10.

A thick cylinder of internal radius and external radius a and b is subjected to internal pressure p as well as external pressure p. Which one of the following Page 333 of 429 statements is correct? [IES-2004] The magnitude of circumferential stress developed is: (a) Maximum at radius r = a (b) Maximum at radius r = b

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

(d) Constant (c) Maximum at radius r = ab IES-10. Ans. (d) Pr 2 − P r 2 Pa2 − Pb2 B σc = A + 2 A = i i 2 2o o = = −P r ro − ri b2 − a2 ∴σc = −P

B=

(Pi − Po ) ro2ri2 ro2 − ri2

=o

IES-11.

Consider the following statements: [IES-2007] In a thick walled cylindrical pressure vessel subjected to internal pressure, the Tangential and radial stresses are: 1. Minimum at outer side 2. Minimum at inner side 3. Maximum at inner side and both reduce to zero at outer wall 4. Maximum at inner wall but the radial stress reduces to zero at outer wall Which of the statements given above is/are correct? (a) 1 and 2 (b) 1 and 3 (c) 1 and 4 (d) 4 only IES-11. Ans. (c) IES-12.

Consider the following statements at given point in the case of thick cylinder subjected to fluid pressure: [IES-2006] 1. Radial stress is compressive 2. Hoop stress is tensile 3. Hoop stress is compressive 4. Longitudinal stress is tensile and it varies along the length 5. Longitudinal stress is tensile and remains constant along the length of the cylinder Which of the statements given above are correct? (a) Only 1, 2 and 4 (b) Only 3 and 4 (c) Only 1,2 and 5 (d) Only 1,3 and 5 IES-12. Ans. (c) 3. For internal fluid pressure Hoop or circumferential stress is tensile. 4. Longitudinal stress is tensile and remains constant along the length of the cylinder. IES-13.

A thick cylinder with internal diameter d and outside diameter 2d is subjected to internal pressure p. Then the maximum hoop stress developed in the cylinder is: [IES-2003] (a) p

(b)

2 p 3

(c)

IES-13. Ans. (c) In thick cylinder, maximum hoop stress

5 p 3

(d) 2p

2

⎛d ⎞ d +⎜ ⎟ 2 2 r +r ⎝2⎠ =5 p = p × 22 12 = p × 2 3 r2 − r1 ⎛d⎞ d2 −⎜ ⎟ ⎝2⎠ 2

σ hoop

Compound or shrunk cylinder IES-14.

Autofrettage is a method of: (a) Joining thick cylinders (c) Pre-stressing thick cylinders IES-14. Ans. (c)

[IES-1996; 2005; 2006] (b) Relieving stresses from thick cylinders (d) Increasing the life of thick cylinders

IES-15.

Match List-I with List-II and select the correct answer using the codes given below the Lists: [IES-2004] List-I List-II 1. Hydrostatic stress A. Wire winding B. Lame's theory 2. Strengthening of thin cylindrical shell C. Solid sphere subjected to uniform Page 3343.of 429 Strengthening of thick cylindrical shell pressure on the surface D. Autofrettage 4. Thick cylinders

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder

Coeds: (a) (c) IES-15. Ans. (d) IES-16.

A 4 2

B 2 4

C 1 3

D 3 1

S K Mondal’s A 4 2

(b) (d)

B 2 4

C 3 1

D 1 3

If the total radial interference between two cylinders forming a compound cylinder is δ and Young's modulus of the materials of the cylinders is E, then the interface pressure developed at the interface between two cylinders of the same material and same length is: [IES-2005] (a) Directly proportional of E x δ (b) Inversely proportional of E/ δ (c) Directly proportional of E/ δ (d) Inversely proportional of E / δ

IES-16. Ans. (a)

(

)

⎡ ⎤ 2D22 D32 − D12 PD2 ⎢ ⎥ δ = E ⎢ ⎡ D32 − D22 D22 − D12 ⎤ ⎥ ⎦⎦ ⎣⎣ ∴ P α E.δ

(

)(

)

Alternatively : if E ↑ then P ↑ and if δ ↑ then P ↑ so P α Eδ

IES-17.

A compound cylinder with inner radius 5 cm and outer radius 7 cm is made by shrinking one cylinder on to the other cylinder. The junction radius is 6 cm and the junction pressure is 11 kgf/cm2. The maximum hoop stress developed in the inner cylinder is: [IES-1994] (b) 36 kgf/cm2 tension (a) 36 kgf/cm2 compression (d) 72 kgf/cm2 tension. (c) 72 kgf/cm2 compression IES-17. Ans. (c)

Thick Spherical Shell IES-18.

The hemispherical end of a pressure vessel is fastened to the cylindrical portion of the pressure vessel with the help of gasket, bolts and lock nuts. The bolts are subjected to: [IES-2003] (a) Tensile stress (b) Compressive stress (c) Shear stress (d) Bearing stress IES-18. Ans. (a)

Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Longitudinal and shear stress IAS-1.

A solid thick cylinder is subjected to an external hydrostatic pressure p. The state of stress in the material of the cylinder is represented as: [IAS-1995]

Page 335 of 429

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

IAS-1. Ans. (c)

Distribution of radial and circumferential stresses within the cylinder wall when only external pressure acts.

Page 336 of 429

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

The pressure within the cylinder of a hydraulic press is 9 MPa. The inside diameter of the cylinder is 25 mm. Determine the thickness of the cylinder wall, if the permissible tensile stress is 18 N/mm2 Given: P = 9 MPa = 9 N/mm2, Inside radius, r1 = 12.5 mm; σ t = 18 N/mm2 Thickness of the cylinder:

⎡r2 + r2 ⎤ Usin g the equation;σ t = p ⎢ 22 12 ⎥ , we have ⎣ r2 − r1 ⎦ ⎡ r 2 + 12.52 ⎤ 18 = 9 ⎢ 22 2 ⎥ ⎣ r2 − 12.5 ⎦ r2 = 21.65mm

or

∴ Thickness of the cylinder = r2 − r1 = 21.65 − 12.5 = 9.15 mm Conventional Question IES-2010 Q.

A spherical shell of 150 mm internal diameter has to withstand an internal pressure of 30 MN/m2. Calculate the thickness of the shell if the allowable stress is 80 MN/m2. Assume the stress distribution in the shell to follow the law

σr = a − Ans.

2b b σ = + and a . 0 r3 r3

[10 Marks]

A spherical shell of 150 mm internal diameter internal pressure = 30 MPa. Allowable stress = 80 MN/m2

2b r3 b Circumference stress = σθ = a + 3 r Assume radial stress =

σr = a −

At internal diameter (r)

Page 337 of 429

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder

σr

S K Mondal’s

= −30N / mm2

σθ =

80N / mm2

2b (75)3 b 80 = a + (75)3 −30 = a −

..............(i) .................(ii)

Soluing eq n (i)&(ii) 110 × 753 130 b= a= 3 3 At outer Radius (R) radial stress should be zero 2b R3 2b 2 × 110 × 753 R3 = = = 713942.3077 130 a 3× 3 R = 89.376mm There fore thickness of cylinder = (R − r) o=a−

= 89.376 − 75 = 14.376mm Conventional Question IES-1993 Question:

A thick spherical vessel of inner 'radius 150 mm is subjected to an internal pressure of 80 MPa. Calculate its wall thickness based upon the (i) Maximum principal stress theory, and (ii) Total strain energy theory. Poisson's ratio = 0.30, yield strength = 300 MPa Given:

r1 = 150mm; p (σ r ) = 80MPa = 80 × 106 N / m2 ; μ =

1 = 0.30; m

σ = 300MPa = 300 × 106 N / m2 Wall thickness t : (i) Maximum principal stress theory :

⎛ r2 ⎞ ⎜ Where K = ⎟ r1 ⎠ ⎝

⎛ K 2 + 1⎞ We know that,σ r ⎜ 2 ⎟ ≤σ ⎝ K − 1⎠ or or or i.e.

⎛ K 2 + 1⎞ 6 80 × 106 ⎜ 2 ⎟ ≤ 300 × 10 ⎝ K − 1⎠ K ≥ 1.314 K = 1.314 r2 = 1.314 or r2 = r1 × 1.314 = 150 × 1.314 = 197.1mm r1

∴ Metal thickness, t = r2 − r1 = 197.1 − 150 = 47.1 mm (ii)

Total strain energy theory: 2 2 1 2 1 2

Use σ + σ − μσ σ ≤ σ y2 Page 338 of 429

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder

σ2 ≥

2σ r2 ⎡⎣K 4 (1 + μ ) + (1 − μ ) ⎤⎦

( 300 × 10 )

or

3002 K 2 − 1 = 2 × 802 1.3K 4

(K

2

)

−1

6 2

(

)

S K Mondal’s

2

(

2 × 80 × 106

2

(

)

2

⎡⎣K 4 (1 + 03 ) + (1 − 0.3 ) ⎤⎦

(K

) + 0.7 ) 2

−1

2

gives K = 1.86 or 0.59 It is clear that K > 1 ∴ K = 1.364 or

r2 = 1.364 or r2 = 150 × 1.364 = 204.6 mm r1

t = r2 − r1 = 204.6 − 150 = 54.6 mm

What is the difference in the analysis of think tubes compared to that for thin tubes? State the basic equations describing stress distribution in a thick tube. The difference in the analysis of stresses in thin and thick cylinder: (i) In thin cylinder, it is assumed that the tangential stress is uniformly distributed over the cylinder wall thickness. In thick cylinder, the tangential stress has highest magnitude at the inner surface of the cylinder and gradually decreases towards the outer surface. (ii) The radial stress is neglected in thin cylinders, while it is of significant magnitude in case of thick cylinders. Basic equation for describing stress distribution in thick tube is Lame's equation.

σr =

B B − A and σt = 2 + A 2 r r

What is auto frettage? How does it help in increasing the pressure carrying capacity of a thick cylinder? Autofrettage is a process of pre-stressing the cylinder before using it in operation. We know that when the cylinder is subjected to internal pressure, the circumferential stress at the inner surface limits the pressure carrying capacity of the cylinder. In autofrettage pre-stressing develops a residual compressive stresses at the inner surface. When the cylinder is actually loaded in operation, the residual compressive stresses at the inner surface begin to decrease, become zero and finally become tensile as the pressure is gradually increased. Thus autofrettage increases the pressure carrying capacity of the cylinder.

Conventional Question ESE-2001 Question:

When two cylindrical parts are assembled by shrinking or press-fitting, a contact pressure is created between the two parts. If the radii of the inner cylinder are a and c and that of the outer cylinder are (c- δ ) and b, δ being the radial interference the contact pressure is given by: 2 2 2 ⎤ ⎡ 2 Eδ ⎢ (b − c ) (c − a ) ⎥ P= c ⎢⎢ 2c 2 (b 2 − a 2 ) ⎥⎥ ⎣ ⎦

Page 339 429 material, Can you outline the steps Where E is the Young's modulus of ofthe involved in developing this important design equation?

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

Due to interference let us assume δ j = increase in inner diameter of jacket and δc = decrease in outer diameter of cylinder. so δ= δ j + δc i.e. without sign. ⎡ ⎤ ⎣⎢∈ j = tangential strain⎥⎦

Now δ j =∈ j c =

1 [ σt − µσr ] c E

=

⎤ cP ⎡⎢ b 2 + c 2 ⎥ − − − (i ) + µ ⎥ E ⎢⎣ b 2 − c 2 ⎦

⎡ ⎤ ⎢σ t =circumferential stress⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ p(b2 +c 2 ) ⎢ + ⎥ 2 2 ⎢ ⎥ b -c ( ) ⎢ ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢⎣σ r =-p (radial stress) ⎥⎦

And in similar way δc =∈c c =

1 [ σt − µσ r ] c E

2 2 ⎤ ⎡ ⎢σ t = − p(c + a ) ⎥ ⎢ (c 2 − a2 ) ⎥⎥ ⎢ ⎢ ⎥ ⎢⎣σ r = −p ⎥⎦

cP ⎡⎢ c 2 + a 2 ⎤⎥ - µ − − − (ii ) Here -ive signrepresents contraction E ⎢⎣ c 2 − a 2 ⎥⎦ Adding (i ) & (ii ) Pc ⎡⎢ 2c 2 (b 2 − a 2 ) ⎤⎥ ∴ δ = δ j + δc = E ⎢⎣ (b 2 − c 2 )(c 2 − a 2 ) ⎥⎦ E δ ⎡⎢ (b 2 − c 2 )(c 2 − a 2 ) ⎤⎥ or P = Proved. Page 340 of 429 c ⎢⎣ 2c 2 (b 2 − a 2 ) ⎥⎦ =-

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

Conventional Question ESE-2003 Question:

A steel rod of diameter 50 mm is forced into a bronze casing of outside diameter 90 mm, producing a tensile hoop stress of 30 MPa at the outside diameter of the casing. Find (i) The radial pressure between the rod and the casing (ii) The shrinkage allowance and (iii) The rise in temperature which would just eliminate the force fit. Assume the following material properties: −5 o Es = 2×105 MPa, μS = 0.25 , αs = 1.2×10 / C −5

Eb = 1×105 MPa , μb = 0.3, μb = 1.9×10

/o C

There is a shrinkage pressure P between the steel rod and the bronze casing. The pressure P tends to contract the steel rod and expand the bronze casing. (i) Consider Bronze casing, According to Lames theory

σt =

B +A r2

Where A =

Piri 2 − P0 r02 r02 − ri 2

(Pi − P0 )r02 ri 2 and B = r02 − ri 2 Pi = P, P0 = 0 and A=

Pr02 ri 2 Pri2 2Pri2 , B= = r02 − ri 2 r02 − ri 2 r02 − ri 2

∴ 30 =

Pr 2 Pr 2 2Pr 2 B +A= 2 i 2 + 2 i 2 = 2 i 2 2 ro r0 − ri r0 − ri r0 − ri

⎡⎛ 90 ⎞2 ⎤ ⎡r 2 ⎤ 30(r02 − ri 2 ) 0 ⎢⎜ ⎟⎟ − 1⎥ MPa=33.6MPa ⎢ ⎥ 15 1 15 or , P= = − = ⎜ ⎢⎜⎝ 50 ⎠⎟ ⎥ ⎢r 2 ⎥ 2ri 2 ⎣ i ⎦ ⎣⎢ ⎦⎥ Therefore the radial pressure between the rod and the casing is P= 33.6 MPa. (ii) The shrinkage allowance: Let δ j = increase in inert diameter of bronze casing δ C= decrease in outer diameter of steel rod 1st consider bronze casing:

Tangential stress at the inner surface(σ t ) j =

B +A ri 2

⎡ ⎛ 90 ⎞2 ⎤ ⎢ ⎜ ⎟⎟ + 1⎥ ⎢ ⎜⎜ ⎟ ⎥ Pr 2 P (r02 + r12 ) Pr 2 ⎢ ⎝ 50 ⎠ ⎥ = 63.6MPa = × = 2 0 2+ 2 i 2= 33.6 2 ⎢ ⎥ r0 − ri r0 − ri (r02 − ri 2 ) ⎢ ⎜⎛ 90 ⎞⎟ − 1⎥ ⎢ ⎜⎝⎜ ⎠⎟⎟ ⎥ Page 341 of 429 ⎣⎢ 50 ⎦⎥

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder

S K Mondal’s

and radial stress(σr ) j = −P = −33.6MPa longitudial stress(σ ) j = 0

Therefore tangential strain (εt ) j =

1⎡ (σt ) j − µ(σr ) j ⎤⎥⎦ E ⎢⎣

1 [63.6 + 0.3 × 33.6] =7.368×10 -4 5 1×10 ∴ δ j = (εt ) j × d i = 7.368 ×10−4 × 0.050 = 0.03684 mm =

2nd Consider steel rod:

Circumferential stress (σ t )s = −P and radial stress (σr )s = −P ∴ δc = (∈t )s × d i = =−

1 ⎡ (σt )S − µ(σr )s ⎤⎦⎥ × d i Es ⎣⎢

Pd i 33.6 × 0.050 (1− µ) = − [1− 0.3 ] = −0.00588mm [reduction] Es 2 ×105

Total shrinkage = δ j + δc =0.04272mm[it is diametral] = 0.02136 mm [radial] (iii) Let us temperature rise is ( Δt ) As

αb > αs due to same temperature rise steel not will expand less than bronze

casing. When their difference of expansion will be equal to the shrinkage then force fit will eliminate.

d i × αb ×Δt − d i × αs ×Δt = 0.04272 or t =

0.04272 0.04272 = = 122o C −5 −5 ⎤ ⎡ ⎤ ⎡ d i ⎢⎣αb − αs ⎥⎦ 50 × ⎢⎣1.9 ×10 − 1.2 ×10 ⎥⎦

Conventional Question AMIE-1998 Question:

A thick walled closed-end cylinder is made of an AI-alloy (E = 72 GPa,

1 = 0.33), has inside diameter of 200 mm and outside diameter of 800 mm. m The cylinder is subjected to internal fluid pressure of 150 MPa. Determine the principal stresses and maximum shear stress at a point on the inside surface of the cylinder. Also determine the increase in inside diameter due to fluid pressure. Answer:

200 800 = 100mm = 0.1m;r2 = = 400mm = 0.4;p = 150MPa = 150MN / m2 ; 2 2 1 E = 72GPa = 72 × 109 N / m2 ; = 0.33 = μ m

Given: r1 =

Principal stress and maximum shear stress: Using the condition in Lame’s equation:

b −a r2 At r = 0.1m, σ 2 = +p = 150MN / m2

σr =

r = 0.4m, σ 2 = 0 Substituting the values in the above equation we have

Page 342 of 429

Chapter-11

Thick Cylinder 150 = 0=

b

( 0.1) b

2

−a

−a

S K Mondal’s

− − − − (i) − − − − ( ii )

( 0.4 ) From ( i ) and ( ii ) , we get 2

a = 10 and b = 1.6

The circumferential ( or hoop ) stress by Lame ' s equation,is given by

σc =

b +a r2

1.6 + 10 = 170MN / m2 ( tensile ) , and 0.12 1.6 (σ c )min ,at r ( = r2 ) = 0.4m = 2 + 10 = 20MN / m2 ( tensile ) . 0.4 ∴ Pr incipal stresses are 170 MN / m2 and 20MN / m2 ∴ (σ c )max ,at r ( = r1 ) = 0.1m =

Maximum shear stress, τ max =

(σ c )max − (σ c )min 2

=

170 − 20 = 75MN / m2 2

Increase in inside diameter,δ d1 : 150 × ( 0.1) pr 2 We know,longitudinal ( or axial ) stress, σ l = 2 1 2 = = 10MN / m2 r2 − r1 ( 0.4 )2 − ( 0.1)2 2

Circumferential ( or hoop ) strain at the inner radius,is given by : 1 1 ⎡170 × 106 + 0.33 (150 − 10 ) × 106 ⎤⎦ = 0.003 ⎡σ c + μ (σ r − σ l ) ⎤⎦ = 9 ⎣ E⎣ 72 × 10 δ d1 Also, ∈1 = d1 δd or 0.003 = 1 0.1 Page 343 of 429 δ d1 = 0.003 × 0.1 = 0.003 m or 0.3 mm

∈1 =

12. Spring Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) 1. A spring is a mechanical device which is used for the efficient storage and release of energy. 2. Helical spring – stress equation Let us a close-coiled helical spring has coil diameter D, wire diameter d and number of turn n. The spring material has a shearing modulus G. The spring index, C =

D . If a force ‘P’ is exerted in both d

ends as shown. The work done by the axial force 'P' is converted into strain energy and stored in the spring.

U=(average torque) ×(angular displacement) T = ×θ 2 From the figure we get, θ = Torque (T)=

TL GJ

PD 2

length of wire (L)=πDn Polar m om ent of Inertia(J)= Therefore U=

πd 4 32

4P 2D 3 n Gd 4

According to Castigliano's theorem, the displacement corresponding to force P is obtained by partially differentiating strain energy with respect to that force.

Therefore δ =

∂ ⎢⎡ 4 p 2 D3n ⎥⎤ 8PD3n ∂U = = Gd 4 ∂P ∂P ⎢⎣ Gd 4 ⎥⎦

Axial deflection δ =

8 PD 3 n Gd 4

Spring stiffness or spring constant

(k ) =

P Gd 4 = D 3 n344 of 429 δ 8Page

Chapter-12

Spring 16T 16 ( PD / 2 ) 8PD The torsional shear stress in the bar, τ 1 = = = πd3 πd3 πd3 The direct shear stress in the bar, τ 2 =

P

⎛ πd ⎞ ⎜ ⎟ ⎝ 4 ⎠

Therefore the total shear stress, τ = τ 1 + τ 2 =

τ = Ks Where K s = 1 +

=

2

4P

πd2

=

S K Mondal’s

8PD ⎛ 0.5d ⎞ π d 3 ⎜⎝ D ⎟⎠

8PD ⎛ 0.5d ⎞ 8PD 1+ = Ks ⎟ 3 ⎜ D ⎠ πd ⎝ πd3

8PD πd3

0.5d is correction factor for direct shear stress. D

3. Wahl’s stress correction factor τ =K

8PD πd3

⎛ 4C − 1 0.615 ⎞ + is known as Wahl’s stress correction factor C ⎟⎠ ⎝ 4C − 4

Where K = ⎜

Here K = KsKc; Where K s is correction factor for direct shear stress and Kc is correction factor for stress concentration due to curvature.

Note: When the spring is subjected to a static force, the effect of stress concentration is neglected due to localized yielding. So we will use, τ = K s

8PD πd3

4. Equivalent stiffness (keq) Spring in series (δ e = δ1 + δ 2 )

1 1 1 = + K eq K1 K 2

or K eq =

K1 K 2 K1 + K 2

Shaft in series ( θ = θ1 + θ 2 )

Spring in Parallel (δ e = δ1 = δ 2 )

K eq = K1 + K 2

Shaft in Parallel ( θ eq = θ1 = θ 2 )

Page 345 of 429

Chapter-12

1 1 1 = + K eq K1 K 2

Spring

or K eq =

S K Mondal’s

K eq = K1 + K 2

K1 K 2 K1 + K 2

5. Important note • •

If a spring is cut into ‘n’ equal lengths then spring constant of each new spring = nk When a closed coiled spring is subjected to an axial couple M then the rotation,

φ=

64 MDnc Ed 4

6. Laminated Leaf or Carriage Springs •

3PL3 Central deflection, δ = 8Enbt 3

Maximum bending stress, σ max =

3PL 2nbt 2

Where P = load on spring b = width of each plate n = no of plates L= total length between 2 points t =thickness of one plate.

7. Belleville Springs Load, P =

4 Eδ (1 − μ 2 ) k f D02

⎡ δ⎞ ⎛ 3⎤ ⎢ (h − δ) ⎜ h − 2 ⎟ t + t ⎥ ⎝ ⎠ ⎣ ⎦ Do

Where, E = Modulus of elasticity

δ = Linear deflection μ =Poisson’s Ratio kf =factor for Belleville spring Do = outside diamerer h = Deflection required to flatten Belleville spring t = thickness

P t

Note: • • • •

Total stiffness of the springs kror = stiffness per spring × No of springs In a leaf spring ratio of stress between full length and graduated leaves = 1.5 Conical spring- For application requiring variable stiffness Belleville Springs -For application requiring high capacity springs into small space

Page 346 of 429

ho

Chapter-12

Spring

S K Mondal’s

OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Helical spring GATE-1.

If the wire diameter of a closed coil helical spring subjected to compressive load is increased from 1 cm to 2 cm, other parameters remaining same, then deflection will decrease by a factor of: [GATE-2002] (a) 16 (b) 8 (c) 4 (d) 2

GATE-1. Ans. (a) δ = GATE-2.

8PD3N G.d4

A compression spring is made of music wire of 2 mm diameter having a shear strength and shear modulus of 800 MPa and 80 GPa respectively. The mean coil diameter is 20 mm, free length is 40 mm and the number of active coils is 10. If the mean coil diameter is reduced to 10 mm, the stiffness of the spring is approximately [GATE-2008] (a) Decreased by 8 times (b) Decreased by 2 times (c) Increased by 2 times (d) Increased by 8 times

GATE-2. Ans. (d) Spring constant (K) = 3

P

δ

=

G.d 4 8D 3 N

or K ∝

1 D3

3

K 2 ⎛ D1 ⎞ ⎛ 20 ⎞ ⎟ =⎜ ⎟ =8 =⎜ K1 ⎜⎝ D2 ⎟⎠ ⎝ 10 ⎠ GATE-3.

Two helical tensile springs of the same material and also having identical mean coil diameter and weight, have wire diameters d and d/2. The ratio of their stiffness is: [GATE-2001] (a) 1 (b) 4 (c) 64 (d) 128

G.d 4 d4 GATE-3. Ans. (c) Spring constant (K) = = Therefore k ∞ n δ 8D 3 N P

GATE-4.

A uniform stiff rod of length 300 mm and having a weight of 300 N is pivoted at one end and connected to a spring at the other end. For keeping the rod vertical in a stable position the minimum value of spring constant K needed is: (a) 300 N/m (b) 400N/m (c) 500N/m (d) 1000 N/m

GATE-4. Ans. (c) Inclined it to a very low angle, dθ For equilibrium taking moment about ‘hinge’ W 300 ⎛l ⎞ = = 500N / m W × ⎜ dθ ⎟ − k ( ldθ ) × l = 0 or k = × 0.3 2 2l 2 ⎝ ⎠ GATE-5.

[GATE-2004]

A weighing machine consists of a 2 kg pan resting on spring. In this condition, with the pan resting on the spring, the length of the spring is 200 mm. When a mass of 20 kg is placed on the pan, the length of the spring becomes 100 mm. Page 347 of 429 For the spring, the un-deformed length lo and the spring constant k (stiffness) are: [GATE-2005]

Chapter-12

Spring

S K Mondal’s

(b) lo = 210 mm, k = 1960 N/m (a) lo = 220 mm, k = 1862 N/m (d) lo = 200 mm, k = 2156 N/m (c) lo = 200 mm, k = 1960 N/m GATE-5. Ans. (b) Initial length = lo m and stiffness = k N/m

2 × g = k ( lo − 0.2 )

2 × g + 20 × g = k ( lo − 0.1) Just solve the above equations.

Springs in Series GATE-6.

The deflection of a spring with 20 active turns under a load of 1000 N is 10 mm. The spring is made into two pieces each of 10 active coils and placed in parallel under the same load. The deflection of this system is: [GATE-1995] (a) 20 mm (b) 10 mm (c) 5 mm (d) 2.5 mm GATE-6. Ans. (d) When a spring is cut into two, no. of coils gets halved. ∴ Stiffness of each half gets doubled. When these are connected in parallel, stiffness = 2k + 2k = 4k Therefore deflection will be ¼ times. = 2.5 mm

Previous 20-Years IES Questions Helical spring IES-1.

A helical coil spring with wire diameter ’d’ and coil diameter 'D' is subjected to external load. A constant ratio of d and D has to be maintained, such that the extension of spring is independent of d and D. What is this ratio? [IES-2008] 4/3 4/3 D d (a)D3 / d4 (b)d3 / D4 (c) 3 (d) 3 d D

IES-1. Ans. (a) δ =

8PD3N Gd4

D ; 2 FD Τ= ; 2 L = π DN

1 Tθ 2 TL θ= GJ

T = F×

U=

2

U=

1 ⎛ FD ⎞ ⎛ L ⎞ 4F2D3N = 2 ⎜⎝ 2 ⎟⎠ ⎜⎝ GJ ⎟⎠ Gd4

δ=

∂U 8FD3N = ∂F Gd4

IES-2.

Assertion (A): Concentric cylindrical helical springs are used to have greater spring force in a limited space. [IES-2006] Reason (R): Concentric helical springs are wound in opposite directions to prevent locking of coils under heavy dynamic loading. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IES-2. Ans. (b) IES-3.

Assertion (A): Two concentric helical springs used to provide greater spring force are wound in opposite directions. [IES-1995; IAS-2004] Reason (R): The winding in opposite directions in the case of helical springs prevents buckling. Page 348R of is 429 (a) Both A and R are individually true and the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A

Chapter-12

Spring

S K Mondal’s

(c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IES-3. Ans. (c) It is for preventing locking not for buckling.

IES-4.

Which one of the following statements is correct? [IES-1996; 2007; IAS-1997] If a helical spring is halved in length, its spring stiffness (a) Remains same (b) Halves (c) Doubles (d) Triples 4 Gd 1 so k ∞ andn wiil behalf IES-4. Ans. (c) Stiffness of sprin ( k ) = n 8D3n IES-5.

A body having weight of 1000 N is dropped from a height of 10 cm over a closecoiled helical spring of stiffness 200 N/cm. The resulting deflection of spring is nearly [IES-2001] (a) 5 cm (b) 16 cm (c) 35 cm (d) 100 cm

IES-5. Ans. (b) mg(h + x) = IES-6.

A close-coiled helical spring is made of 5 mm diameter wire coiled to 50 mm mean diameter. Maximum shear stress in the spring under the action of an axial force is 20 N/mm2. The maximum shear stress in a spring made of 3 mm diameter wire coiled to 30 mm mean diameter, under the action of the same force will be nearly [IES-2001] (b) 33.3 N/mm2 (c) 55.6 N/mm2 (d) 92.6 N/mm2 (a) 20 N/mm2

IES-6. Ans. (c) Use τ = k s IES-7.

8PD π d3

A closely-coiled helical spring is acted upon by an axial force. The maximum shear stress developed in the spring is τ . Half of the length of the spring is cut off and the remaining spring is acted upon by the same axial force. The maximum shear stress in the spring the new condition will be: [IES-1995] (a) ½ τ (b) τ (c) 2 τ (d) 4 τ

IES-7. Ans. (b) Use τ = k s IES-8.

1 2 kx 2

8PD it is independent of number of turn π d3

The maximum shear stress occurs on the outermost fibers of a circular shaft under torsion. In a close coiled helical spring, the maximum shear stress occurs on the [IES-1999] (a) Outermost fibres (b) Fibres at mean diameter (c) Innermost fibres (d) End coils IES-8. Ans. (c) IES-9.

A helical spring has N turns of coil of diameter D, and a second spring, made of same wire diameter and of same material, has N/2 turns of coil of diameter 2D. If the stiffness of the first spring is k, then the stiffness of the second spring will be: [IES-1999] (a) k/4 (b) k/2 (c) 2k (d) 4k

IES-9. Ans. (a) Stiffness (k) =

Gd 4 Gd 4 k ; S econd spring,stiffness (k ) = = 2 3 N 4 3 64 R N 64 ( 2 R ) × 2

IES-10.

A closed-coil helical spring is subjected to a torque about its axis. The spring wire would experience a [IES-1996; 1998] (a) Bending stress (b) Direct tensile stress of uniform intensity at its cross-section (c) Direct shear stress (d) Torsional shearing stress IES-10. Ans. (a) IES-11.

Given that: [IES-1996] d = diameter of spring, R = mean radius of coils, n = number of coils and G = modulus of rigidity, the stiffness of the close-coiled helical spring subject to an Page 349 of 429 axial load W is equal to

Chapter-12

Spring 4

(a)

S K Mondal’s

3

Gd 64 R 3 n

(b)

IES-11. Ans. (a)

Gd 64 R 3 n

4

(c)

Gd 32 R 3 n

(d)

Gd 4 64 R 2 n

IES-12.

A closely coiled helical spring of 20 cm mean diameter is having 25 coils of 2 cm diameter rod. The modulus of rigidity of the material if 107 N/cm2. What is the stiffness for the spring in N/cm? [IES-2004] (a) 50 (b) 100 (c) 250 (d) 500 7 2 4 4 Gd4 10 (N / cm ) × 2 ( cm ) IES-12. Ans. (b) Stiffness of sprin ( k ) = = = 100N / cm 8D3n 8 × 203 ( cm3 ) × 25 IES-13.

Which one of the following expresses the stress factor K used for design of closed coiled helical spring? [IES-2008] 4C − 4 4C − 1 0.615 4C − 4 0.615 4C − 1 (a) (b) + (c) + (d) 4C − 1 4C − 4 C 4C − 1 C 4C − 4 Where C = spring index IES-13. Ans. (b) IES-14.

In the calculation of induced shear stress in helical springs, the Wahl's correction factor is used to take care of [IES-1995; 1997] (a) Combined effect of transverse shear stress and bending stresses in the wire. (b) Combined effect of bending stress and curvature of the wire. (c) Combined effect of transverse shear stress and curvature of the wire. (d) Combined effect of torsional shear stress and transverse shear stress in the wire. IES-14. Ans. (c) IES-15.

While calculating the stress induced in a closed coil helical spring, Wahl's factor must be considered to account for [IES-2002] (a) The curvature and stress concentration effect (b) Shock loading (c) Poor service conditions (d) Fatigue loading IES-15. Ans. (a) IES-16. Cracks in helical springs used in Railway carriages usually start on the inner side of the coil because of the fact that [IES-1994] (a) It is subjected to the higher stress than the outer side. (b) It is subjected to a higher cyclic loading than the outer side. (c) It is more stretched than the outer side during the manufacturing process. (d) It has a lower curvature than the outer side. IES-16. Ans. (a) IES-17.

Two helical springs of the same material and of equal circular cross-section and length and number of turns, but having radii 20 mm and 40 mm, kept concentrically (smaller radius spring within the larger radius spring), are compressed between two parallel planes with a load P. The inner spring will carry a load equal to [IES-1994] (a) P/2 (b) 2P/3 (c) P/9 (d) 8P/9 3

Wo Ri3 ⎛ 20 ⎞ 1 W W 8 = 3 = ⎜ ⎟ = ; Wo = i So Wi + i = P or Wi = P IES-17. Ans. (d) Wi Ro ⎝ 40 ⎠ 8 8 8 9 IES-18.

A length of 10 mm diameter steel wire is coiled to a close coiled helical spring having 8 coils of 75 mm mean diameter, and the spring has a stiffness K. If the same length of wire is coiled to 10 coils of 60 mm mean diameter, then the spring stiffness will be: [IES-1993] (a) K (b) 1.25 K (c) 1.56 K (d) 1.95 K

Gd 4 IES-18. Ans. (c) Stiffness of spring (k) = Where G and d is same 64 R 3 n Page 350 of 429

Chapter-12

Therefore

Spring

S K Mondal’s

k 1 1 1 = = = 3 3 k2 ⎛ R ⎞ ⎛ n ⎞ ⎛ 75 ⎞ ⎛ 8 ⎞ 1.56 ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ ⎟ ⎜ 60 ⎟ ⎜ 10 ⎟ ⎝ R2 ⎠ ⎝ n2 ⎠ ⎝ ⎠ ⎝ ⎠

IES-19.

A spring with 25 active coils cannot be accommodated within a given space. Hence 5 coils of the spring are cut. What is the stiffness of the new spring? (a) Same as the original spring (b) 1.25 times the original spring [IES-2004] (c) 0.8 times the original spring (d) 0.5 times the original spring 4 k n Gd 1 25 or 2 = 1 = IES-19. Ans. (b) Stiffness of spring ( k ) = ∴ kα = 1.25 n k1 n2 20 8D3n IES-20.

Wire diameter, mean coil diameter and number of turns of a closely-coiled steel spring are d, D and N respectively and stiffness of the spring is K. A second spring is made of same steel but with wire diameter, mean coil diameter and number of turns 2d, 2D and 2N respectively. The stiffness of the new spring is: [IES-1998; 2001] (a) K (b) 2K (c) 4K (d) 8K Gd4 IES-20. Ans. (a) Stiffness of spring ( k ) = 8D3n IES-21.

When two springs of equal lengths are arranged to form cluster springs which of the following statements are the: [IES-1992] 1. Angle of twist in both the springs will be equal 2. Deflection of both the springs will be equal 3. Load taken by each spring will be half the total load 4. Shear stress in each spring will be equal (a) 1 and 2 only (b) 2 and 3 only (c) 3 and 4 only (d) 1, 2 and 4 only IES-21. Ans. (a) IES-22. Consider the following statements: [IES-2009] When two springs of equal lengths are arranged to form a cluster spring 1. Angle of twist in both the springs will be equal 2. Deflection of both the springs will be equal 3. Load taken by each spring will be half the total load 4. Shear stress in each spring will be equal Which of the above statements is/are correct? (a) 1 and 2 (b) 3 and 4 (c)2 only (d) 4 only IES-22. Ans. (a) Same as [IES-1992]

Page 351 of 429

Chapter-12

Spring

S K Mondal’s

Close-coiled helical spring with axial load IES-23.

Under axial load, each section of a close-coiled helical spring is subjected to (a) Tensile stress and shear stress due to load [IES-2003] (b) Compressive stress and shear stress due to torque (c) Tensile stress and shear stress due to torque (d) Torsional and direct shear stresses IES-23. Ans. (d) IES-24.

When a weight of 100 N falls on a spring of stiffness 1 kN/m from a height of 2 m, the deflection caused in the first fall is: [IES-2000] (a) Equal to 0.1 m (b) Between 0.1 and 0.2 m (c) Equal to 0.2 m (d) More than 0.2 m

IES-24. Ans. (d) use mg (h + x ) =

1 2 kx 2

Subjected to 'Axial twist' IES-25.

A closed coil helical spring of mean coil diameter 'D' and made from a wire of diameter 'd' is subjected to a torque 'T' about the axis of the spring. What is the maximum stress developed in the spring wire? [IES-2008] 8T 16T 32T 64T (a) 3 (b) 3 (c) 3 (d) 3 πd πd πd πd IES-25. Ans. (b)

Springs in Series IES-26.

When a helical compression spring is cut into two equal halves, the stiffness of each of the result in springs will be: [IES-2002; IAS-2002] (a) Unaltered (b) Double (c) One-half (d) One-fourth IES-26. Ans. (b) IES-27.

Page 352 of 429

If a compression coil spring is cut into two equal parts and the parts are then used in parallel, the ratio of the spring rate to its initial value will be: [IES-1999]

Chapter-12

Spring

S K Mondal’s

(a) 1 (b) 2 (c) 4 (d) Indeterminable for want of sufficient data IES-27. Ans. (c) When a spring is cut into two, no. of coils gets halved. ∴ Stiffness of each half gets doubled. When these are connected in parallel, stiffness = 2k + 2k = 4k

Springs in Parallel IES-28.

The equivalent spring stiffness for the system shown in the given figure (S is the spring stiffness of each of the three springs) is: (a) S/2 (b) S/3 (c) 2S/3 (d) S

[IES-1997; IAS-2001] IES-28. Ans. (c)

IES-29.

1 1 1 2 = + or Se = S Se 2 S S 3

Two coiled springs, each having stiffness K, are placed in parallel. The stiffness of the combination will be: [IES-2000]

( a ) 4K

( b ) 2K

(c)

IES-29. Ans. (b) W = kδ = k1δ + k 2δ

IES-30.

K 2

(d)

K 4

A mass is suspended at the bottom of two springs in series having stiffness 10 N/mm and 5 N/mm. The equivalent spring stiffness of the two springs is nearly [IES-2000] (a) 0.3 N/mm (b) 3.3 N/mm (c) 5 N/mm (d) 15 N/mm

IES-30. Ans. (b)

1 1 1 10 = + or Se = Se 10 5 3

Page 353 of 429

Chapter-12 IES-31.

Spring

S K Mondal’s

Figure given above shows a springmass system where the mass m is fixed in between two springs of stiffness S1 and S2. What is the equivalent spring stiffness? (a) S1- S2 (b) S1+ S2 (c) (S1+ S2)/ S1 S2 S1 S2

(d) (S1- S2)/

[IES-2005] IES-31. Ans. (b) IES-32.

Two identical springs labelled as 1 and 2 are arranged in series and subjected to force F as shown in the given figure. Assume that each spring constant is K. The strain energy stored in spring 1 is: [IES-2001] (a)

F2 2K

(b)

F2 4K

(c)

F2 8K

(d)

⎛ F 1 2 1 IES-32. Ans. (c) The strain energy stored per spring = k .x / 2 = × keq × ⎜ ⎜k 2 2 ⎝ eq

F2 16 K 2

⎞ ⎟⎟ / 2 and here total ⎠

force ‘F’ is supported by both the spring 1 and 2 therefore keq = k + k =2k

IES-33.

What is the equivalent stiffness (i.e. spring constant) of the system shown in the given figure? (a) 24 N/mm (b) 16 N/mm (c) 4 N/mm (d) 5.3 N/mm

[IES-1997] IES-33. Ans. (a) Stiffness K1 of 10 coils spring = 8 N/mm ∴ Stiffness K2 of 5 coils spring = 16 N/mm Though it looks like in series but they are in parallel combination. They are not subjected to same force. Equivalent stiffness (k) = k1 + k2 = 24 N/mm

Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Helical spring IAS-1.

Assertion (A): Concentric cylindrical helical springs which are used to have Page 354 of 429 greater spring force in a limited space is wound in opposite directions.

Chapter-12

Spring

S K Mondal’s

Reason (R): Winding in opposite directions prevents locking of the two coils in case of misalignment or buckling. [IAS-1996] (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-1. Ans. (a) IAS-2.

An open-coiled helical spring of mean diameter D, number of coils N and wire diameter d is subjected to an axial force' P. The wire of the spring is subject to: [IAS-1995] (a) direct shear only (b) combined shear and bending only (c) combined shear, bending and twisting (d) combined shear and twisting only IAS-2. Ans. (d) IAS-3.

Assertion (A): Two concentric helical springs used to provide greater spring force are wound in opposite directions. [IES-1995; IAS-2004] Reason (R): The winding in opposite directions in the case of helical springs prevents buckling. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-3. Ans. (c) It is for preventing locking not for buckling. IAS-4. Which one of the following statements is correct? [IES-1996; 2007; IAS-1997] If a helical spring is halved in length, its spring stiffness (a) Remains same (b) Halves (c) Doubles (d) Triples Gd4 1 so k ∞ andn wiil behalf IAS-4. Ans. (c) Stiffness of sprin ( k ) = n 8D3n IAS-5.

A closed coil helical spring has 15 coils. If five coils of this spring are removed by cutting, the stiffness of the modified spring will: [IAS-2004] (a) Increase to 2.5 times (b) Increase to 1.5 times (c) Reduce to 0.66 times (d) Remain unaffected

IAS-5. Ans. (b) K= IAS-6.

Gd 4 8D3 N

or K α

K N 15 1 or 2 = 1 = = 1.5 N K1 N 2 10

A close-coiled helical spring has wire diameter 10 mm and spring index 5. If the spring contains 10 turns, then the length of the spring wire would be: [IAS-2000] (a) 100 mm (b) 157 mm (c) 500 mm (d) 1570 mm

IAS-6. Ans. (d)

l = π Dn = π ( cd ) n = π × ( 5 ×10 ) ×10 = 1570 mm

IAS-7.

Consider the following types of stresses: [IAS-1996] 1. torsional shear 2. Transverse direct shear 3. Bending stress The stresses, that are produced in the wire of a close-coiled helical spring subjected to an axial load, would include (a) 1 and 3 (b) 1 and 2 (c) 2 and 3 (d) 1, 2 and 3 IAS-7. Ans. (b) IAS-8.

Two close-coiled springs are subjected to the same axial force. If the second spring has four times the coil diameter, double the wire diameter and double the number of coils of the first spring, then the ratio of deflection of the second spring to that of the first will be: [IAS-1998] 1 (a) 8 (b) 2 (c) (d) 1/16 2

Page 355 of 429

Chapter-12

Spring

S K Mondal’s

⎛ D2 ⎞⎛ N2 ⎞ ⎜ ⎟⎜ ⎟ δ 2 ⎝ D1 ⎠⎝ N1 ⎠ 43 × 2 8PD N or = = =8 IAS-8. Ans. (a) δ = 4 δ1 Gd4 24 ⎛ d2 ⎞ ⎜ ⎟ ⎝ d1 ⎠ 3

IAS-9.

A block of weight 2 N falls from a height of 1m on the top of a spring· If the spring gets compressed by 0.1 m to bring the weight momentarily to rest, then the spring constant would be: [IAS-2000] (a) 50 N/m (b) 100 N/m (c) 200N/m (d) 400N/m IAS-9. Ans. (d) Kinetic energy of block = potential energy of spring or W × h =

1 2 2Wh 2 × 2 × 1 k .x or k = 2 = N / m = 400 N / m 2 0.12 x

IAS-10.

The springs of a chest expander are 60 cm long when unstretched. Their stiffness is 10 N/mm. The work done in stretching them to 100 cm is: [IAS-1996] (a) 600 Nm (b) 800 Nm (c) 1000 Nm (d) 1600 Nm ⎧ ⎫ 1 2 1 ⎪⎪ 10N ⎪⎪ 2 2 IAS-10. Ans. (b) E = kx = × ⎨ ⎬ × {1 − 0.6} m = 800Nm 2 2 ⎪⎛ 1 ⎞ ⎪ m ⎪⎩ ⎜⎝ 1000 ⎟⎠ ⎪⎭ IAS-11.

A spring of stiffness 'k' is extended from a displacement x1 to a displacement x2 the work done by the spring is: [IAS-1999] (a)

1 2 1 2 1 k x1 − k x2 (b) k ( x1 − x2 ) 2 2 2 2

IAS-11. Ans. (a) Work done by the spring is =

(c)

1 k ( x1 + x2 ) 2 2

⎛ x1 + x2 ⎞ ⎟ ⎝ 2 ⎠

2

(d) k ⎜

1 2 1 2 k x1 − k x 2 2 2

IAS-12.

A spring of stiffness 1000 N/m is stretched initially by 10 cm from the undeformed position. The work required to stretch it by another 10 cm is: [IAS-1995] (a) 5 Nm (b) 7 Nm (c) 10 Nm (d) 15 Nm. 1 1 IAS-12. Ans. (d) E = k x 22 − x12 = × 1000 × 0.202 − 0.102 = 15Nm 2 2

(

)

{

}

Springs in Series IAS-13.

When a helical compression spring is cut into two equal halves, the stiffness of each of the result in springs will be: [IES-2002; IAS-2002] (a) Unaltered (b) Double (c) One-half (d) One-fourth IAS-13. Ans. (b) IAS-14.

The length of the chest-expander spring when it is un-stretched, is 0.6 m and its stiffness is 10 N/mm. The work done in stretching it to 1m will be: [IAS-2001] (a) 800 J (b) 1600 J (c) 3200 J (d) 6400 J IAS-14. Ans. (a) Work done =

1 1 ⎛ 10N ⎞ 1 10 N 2 2 k.x 2 = × ⎜ × 0.42 m 2 = 800 J ⎟ × (1 − 0.6 ) m = × 1 2 2 ⎝ 1mm ⎠ 2 ⎛ ⎞ ⎜ ⎟m ⎝ 1000 ⎠

Page 356 of 429

Chapter-12

Spring

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Springs in Parallel IAS-15.

The equivalent spring stiffness for the system shown in the given figure (S is the spring stiffness of each of the three springs) is: (a) S/2 (b) S/3 (c) 2S/3 (d) S

[IES-1997; IAS-2001] IAS-15. Ans. (c)

IAS-16.

1 1 1 2 = + or Se = S 3 Se 2 S S

Two identical springs, each of stiffness K, are assembled as shown in the given figure. The combined stiffness of the assembly is: (a) K2 (b) 2K (c) K (d) (1/2)K

[IAS-1998] IAS-16. Ans. (b) Effective stiffness = 2K. Due to applied force one spring will be under tension and another one under compression so total resistance force will double.

Flat spiral Spring IAS-17.

Mach List-I (Type of spring) with List-II (Application) and select the correct answer: [IAS-2000] List-I List-II A. Leaf/Helical springs 1. Automobiles/Railways coachers B. Spiral springs 2. Shearing machines C. Belleville springs 3. Watches Codes: A B C A B C (a) 1 2 3 (b) 1 3 2 (c) 3 1 2 (d) 2 3 1 IAS-17. Ans. (b) Page 357 of 429

Chapter-12

Spring

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Semi-elliptical spring IAS-18.

The ends of the leaves of a semi-elliptical leaf spring are made triangular in plain in order to: [IAS 1994] (a) Obtain variable I in each leaf (b) Permit each leaf to act as a overhanging beam (c) Have variable bending moment in each leaf (d) Make Mil constant throughout the length of the leaf. IAS-18. Ans. (d) The ends of the leaves of a semi-elliptical leaf spring are made rectangular in plan in order to make M/I constant throughout the length of the leaf.

Page 358 of 429

Chapter-12

Spring

S K Mondal’s

Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question ESE-2008 Question:

A close-coiled helical spring has coil diameter D, wire diameter d and number of turn n. The spring material has a shearing modulus G. Derive an expression for the stiffness k of the spring. The work done by the axial force 'P' is converted into strain energy and stored in the spring.

U=(average torque) ×(angular displacement) T = ×θ 2 From the figure we get, θ = Torque (T)=

TL GJ

PD 2

length of wire (L)=πDn Polar m om ent of Inertia(J)= Therefore U=

πd 4 32

4P 2D 3 n Gd 4

According to Castigliano's theorem, the displacement corresponding to force P is obtained by partially differentiating strain energy with respect to that force.

Therefore δ =

∂ ⎡⎢ 4 p 2 D 3n ⎤⎥ 8PD 3n ∂U = = ∂P ∂P ⎢⎣ Gd 4 ⎥⎦ Gd 4

P Gd 4 So Spring stiffness, (k ) = = δ 8D3n Conventional Question ESE-2010 Q.

A stiff bar of negligible weight transfers a load P to a combination of three helical springs arranged in parallel as shown in the above figure. The springs are made up of the same material and out of rods of equal diameters. They are of same free length before loading. The number of coils in those three springs are 10, 12 and 15 respectively, while the mean coil diameters are in ratio of 1 : 1.2 : 1.4 respectively. Find the distance ‘x’ as shown in figure, such that the stiff bar remains horizontal after the application of load P. [10 Marks]

P

x

Ans.

l

l

Page 359 of 429

Chapter-12

Spring

S K Mondal’s

The number of coils in the spring 1,2 and 3 is 10, 12 and 15 mean diameter of spring 1,2 and 3 in the ratio of 1 : 1.2 : 1.4 Find out distance x so that rod remains horizontal after loading. Since the rod is rigid and remains horizontal after the load p is applied therefore the deflection of each spring will be same

δ1 = δ2 = δ3 = δ

(say)

Spring are made of same material and out of the rods of equal diameter

G1 = G2 = G3 = G and d1 = d 2 = d3 = d

P1 =

Gd 4 δ Gd 4 δ Gd 4 δ = = 64R13n1 64R13 × 10 640R13

.....(1)

P2 =

Gd 4 δ Gd 4 δ Gd 4 δ = = 64 × R32n2 64 × (1.2)3 × 12R13 1327.10R13

.....(2)

P3 =

Gd 4 δ Gd4 δ Gd 4 δ = = 64R33n3 64 × (1.4)3 × 15R13 2634.2R13

.....(3)

From eqn (1) & (2)

640 P1 1327.1 P2 = 0.482 P1 P2 =

from eq n (1) & (3) 640 P3 = P1 = 0.2430 P1 2634.2 Taking moment about the line of action P1 P2 × L + P3 × 2L = P.x 0.4823 P1L + 0.2430 P1 × 2L = P.x. x=

( 0.4823 + 0.486 ) P1L

P total load in the rod is P=P1 +P2 +P3

........(4)

P = P1 + .4823P1 + 0.2430P1 P = 1.725 P1

......(5)

Equation (4) & (5) x=

0.9683L 0.9683L = = 0.5613L 1.725 P1 / P1 1.725 x = 0.5613 L

Conventional Question ESE-2008 Question:

A close-coiled helical spring has coil diameter to wire diameter ratio of 6. The spring deflects 3 cm under an axial load of 500N and the maximum shear stress is not to exceed 300 MPa. Find the diameter and the length of the spring wire required. Shearing modulus of wire material = 80 GPa.

Gd 4 P Stiffness, K = = δ 8D 3 n

Page 360 of 429

Chapter-12

Spring

500 (80 ×10 )× d = 0.03 8 × 63 × n 9

or ,

[given c=

S K Mondal’s

D = 6] d

or , d = 3.6 ×10−4 n −−− (i ) For static loading correcting factor(k) ⎛ 0.5 ⎞⎟ ⎛ ⎞ ⎜⎜1+ 0.5 ⎟⎟ = 1.0833 = k=⎜⎜1+ ⎟ ⎜⎝ c ⎠⎟ ⎝⎜ 6 ⎠⎟ 8PD We know that (τ ) =k πd3

⎡ ⎤ D ⎢ ∵ C = = 6⎥ ⎢⎣ ⎥⎦ d 1.0833 × 8 × 500 × 6 d= = 5.252×10−3 m = 5.252 mm 6 π × 300 ×10 So D=cd=6×5.252mm=31.513mm From, equation (i) n=14.59 15 Now length of spring wire(L) =πDn =π× 31.513×15 mm =1.485 m d2 =

8kPC πτ

A coil spring of stiffness 'k' is cut to two halves and these two springs are assembled in parallel to support a heavy machine. What is the combined stiffness provided by these two springs in the modified arrangement? When it cut to two halves stiffness of each half will be 2k. Springs in parallel. Total load will be shared so Total load = W+W

or δ.K eq = δ.(2k ) + δ.(2k ) or K eq = 4k.

Conventional Question ESE-2001 Question:

A helical spring B is placed inside the coils of a second helical spring A , having the same number of coils and free axial length and of same material. The two springs are compressed by an axial load of 210 N which is shared between them. The mean coil diameters of A and B are 90 mm and 60 mm and the wire diameters are 12 mm and 7 mm respectively. Calculate the load shared by individual springs and the maximum stress in each spring.

Gd4 8D 3 N Here load shared the springs are arranged in parallel The stiffness of the spring (k) =

Equivalent stiffness(k e )=k A +k B K Hear A KB

4

⎛d ⎞ = ⎜⎜⎜ A ⎟⎟⎟ ⎝⎜ d ⎠⎟ B

3

4 3 ⎛ DB ⎞⎟ ⎜⎜ ⎟ [As N = N ] = ⎜⎛12 ⎞⎟⎟ ×⎛⎜ 60 ⎞⎟⎟ = 2.559 ⎜⎜ ⎟ ⎜⎜ ⎟ N A ⎟ ⎝ 7 ⎠ ⎝ 90 ⎠ ⎝⎜⎜ D ⎠⎟ A

Let total deflection is 'x' m

x=

Equivalet stiffness

=

210 N K A + KB

Chapter-12

Spring

S K Mondal’s

210 210 Load shared by spring 'A'(FA ) = K A × x = =151N = ⎛ k B ⎞⎟ ⎛ ⎞⎟ 1 ⎜⎜1 + ⎟ ⎜⎜1 + ⎟ ⎜⎝ k ⎠⎟⎟ ⎝⎜ 2.559 ⎠⎟ A Load shared by spring 'A'(FB ) = K B × x = ( 210 −151) = 59 N ⎛ 0.5 ⎞ 8PD For static load: τ = ⎜⎜1+ ⎟⎟⎟ 3 ⎜⎝ C ⎠ πd ⎧ ⎫ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ 8×151× 0.090 0.5 ⎪ = 21.362 MPa (τ A )max = ⎨1 + ⎛ ⎞⎪⎬ 3 ⎪ 90 ⎟⎪ π ×(0.012) ⎪ ⎪ ⎜ ⎪ ⎜⎜ ⎟⎟⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎝ 12 ⎠⎪ ⎪ ⎩ ⎭

(τ B )max

⎛ ⎞⎟ ⎜⎜ ⎟ ⎜⎜ 0.5 ⎟⎟⎟ 8×59× 0.060 = ⎜⎜1 + = 27.816 MPa ⎟ 3 ⎜⎜ ⎛⎜ 60 ⎞⎟⎟⎟⎟ π ×(0.007) ⎜⎝ ⎜⎜⎝ 7 ⎠⎟⎟⎠⎟⎟

Conventional Question AMIE-1997 Question:

A close-coiled spring has mean diameter of 75 mm and spring constant of 90 kN/m. It has 8 coils. What is the suitable diameter of the spring wire if maximum shear stress is not to exceed 250 MN/m2? Modulus of rigidity of the spring wire material is 80 GN/m2. What is the maximum axial load the spring can carry? Given D = 75mm; k = 80kN / m; n = 8

τ = 250MN / m2 ; G = 80GN / m2 = 80 × 109 N / m2 Diameter of the spring wire, d:

T =τ × We know,

π

16

( where T = P × R )

d3

(

)

P × 0.0375 = 250 × 106 × Also or

π 16

− − − (i)

d3

P = kδ − − − ( ii )

P = 80 × 103 × δ

Using the relation:

8PD3n 8P × ( 0.075 ) × 8 P δ = = = 33.75 × 10−14 × 4 4 9 4 Gd 80 × 10 × d d 3

Substituting for δ in equation(ii), we get P P = 80 × 103 × 33.75 × 10−14 × 4 or d = 0.0128m or 12.8mm d Maximum axial load the spring can carry P: From equation (i), we get

(

)

P × 0.0375 = 250 × 106 ×

π

16

× ( 0.0128 ) ; 3

Page 362 of 429

P = 2745.2N = 2.7452kN

Page 363 of 429

13. Theories of Column Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) 1. Introduction •

Strut: A member of structure which carries an axial compressive load.

Column: If the strut is vertical it is known as column.

A long, slender column becomes unstable when its axial compressive load reaches a value called the critical buckling load.

If a beam element is under a compressive load and its length is an order of magnitude larger than either of its other dimensions such a beam is called a columns.

Due to its size its axial displacement is going to be very small compared to its lateral deflection called buckling.

Buckling does not vary linearly with load it occurs suddenly and is therefore dangerous

Slenderness Ratio: The ratio between the length and least radius of gyration.

Elastic Buckling: Buckling with no permanent deformation.

Euler buckling is only valid for long, slender objects in the elastic region.

For short columns, a different set of equations must be used.

2. Which is the critical load? •

At this value the structure is in equilibrium regardless of the magnitude of the angle (provided it stays small)

Critical load is the only load for which the structure will be in equilibrium in the disturbed position

At this value, restoring effect of the moment in the spring matches the buckling effect of the axial load represents the boundary between the stable and unstable conditions.

If the axial load is less than Pcr the effect of the moment in the spring dominates and the structure returns to the vertical position after a small disturbance – stable condition.

If the axial load is larger than Pcr the effect of the axial force predominates and the structure buckles – unstable condition.

Because of the large deflection caused by buckling, the least moment of inertia I can be expressed as, I = Ak2

Where: A is the cross sectional area and r is the radius of gyration of the cross sectional area, i.e. kmin =

Imin A Page 364 of 429

Chapter-13 •

Theories of Column

S K Mondal’s

Note that the smallest radius of gyration of the column, i.e. the least moment of inertia I should be taken in order to find the critical stress. l/ k is called the slenderness ratio, it is a measure of the column's flexibility.

3. Euler’s Critical Load for Long Column Assumptions: (i) The column is perfectly straight and of uniform cross-section (ii) The material is homogenous and isotropic (iii) The material behaves elastically (iv) The load is perfectly axial and passes through the centroid of the column section. (v) The weight of the column is neglected.

π 2 EI Pcr = 2 le

e=Equivalent

length of column (1st mode of bending)

4. Remember the following table Case

Diagram

Pcr

Equivalent length(le)

Both ends hinged/pinned

π 2 EI 2

Both ends fixed

4π 2 EI 2

One end fixed & other end free

π 2 EI 4 2

Page 365 of 429

2

2

C Chapter-13

Theorie es of Colum mn

S K Mo ondal’s

O end fixed & other en One nd pinned /h hinged

2

5 Slenderrness Rattio of Collumn 5. Pcr = =

π 2 EI wheere I=A k 2minn 2 Le π 2 EA ⎛ e ⎞ ⎜ ⎟ ⎝ kmin ⎠

k min = leasst radius of gyration

2

∴ Sleenderness Ratio R =

e

kmin

6 Rankine 6. e’s Cripp pling Load d R Rankine theoory is applieed to both •

Shortt strut /column (valid up pto SR-40)

Long g Column (Valid upto SR R 120)

Slend derness ratioo e

k • •

=

π2 E σe

(σ e = critiical stress)= =

Pcr A

P=

σc A

⎛ ⎞ 1+ K '⎜ e ⎟ ⎝k ⎠

2

wherre k' = Rankkine constannt =

σc Page 366 deepends on of material m429 & end conditioons 2 π E

Chapter-13

Theories of Column

S K Mondal’s

σ c = crushing stress •

For steel columns

1 for both ends fixed 25000

K’ =

1 for one end fixed & other hinged 12500

=

20 ≤

e

k

≤ 100

7. Other formulas for crippling load (P) •

Gordon’s formula,

P=

Aσ c

⎛ ⎞ 1+ b⎜ e ⎟ ⎝d ⎠

b = a constant, d = least diameter or breadth of bar

2

Johnson Straight line formula,

⎡ ⎛ ⎞⎤ P = σ c A ⎢1 − c ⎜ e ⎟ ⎥ ⎝ k ⎠⎦ ⎣ •

c = a constant depending on material.

Johnson parabolic formulae :

where the value of index ‘b' depends on the end conditions.

Fiddler’s formula,

P=

A⎡ ( σc + σe ) − C ⎢⎣

where, σ e =

(

σc + σe

)

2

⎤ − 2cσ c σ e ⎥ ⎦

π2 E ⎛ ⎜ ⎝

e

⎞ k ⎟⎠

2

Secant formula

σ m ax = Where

P A

⎡ ey c ⎛ e ⎞ ⎢1 + 2 sec ⎜ ⎟ k ⎝ 2k ⎠ ⎣

P ⎤ ⎥ EA ⎦

σ max =maximum compressive stress

P

P

u P

P

M

Page 367 of 429

M

Chapter-13

Theories of Column

A = Area of c/s y c = Distance of the outermost fiber in compression from the NA e = Eccentricity of the load

le = Equivalent length I A E = Modulus of elasticity of the material

k = Radius of gyration =

⎛ P ⎞ M = P.e.Sec ⎜⎜ e ⎟⎟ ⎝ 2k EA ⎠ Where M = Moment introduced. •

Prof. Perry’s Formula

⎛ σ max ⎞⎛ σ d − 1⎟⎜1 − ⎜ ⎝ σd ⎠⎝ σ e

⎞ e1 yc ⎟= 2 ⎠ k

Where σ max = maximum compressive stress P Load = A c/s area P Euler's load σe = e = A c / s area π 2 EI pe = Euler ' s load = 2

σd =

e

e ' = Versine at mid-length of column due to initial curvature e = Eccentricity of the load e1 = e '+ 1.2e yc = distance of outer most fiber in compression form the NA k = Radius of gyration If

σ max is allowed to go up to σ f (permssible stress)

Then,

σd = •

η=

e1 yc k2

σ f + σ e (1 + η ) 2

2

⎧ σ f + σ e (1 + η ) ⎫ − ⎨ ⎬ − σeσf 2 ⎩ ⎭

Perry-Robertson Formula

⎛ e⎞ ⎟ ⎝k ⎠

η = 0.003 ⎜

⎛ ⎞ σ f + σ e ⎜1 + 0.003 e ⎟ k ⎠ ⎝ − σd = 2

⎧ e ⎫ ⎪ σ f + σ e (1 + 0.003 k ⎪ ⎨ ⎬ − σeσ f ⎪ Page 368 of2429 ⎪ ⎩ ⎭

S K Mondal’s

Chapter-13

Theories of Column

9. ISI’s Formula for Columns and Struts •

For

e

k

=0 to 160

σy Pc =

fos ⎛ 1 + 0.2sec ⎜ e ⎝k

fos × pc ' ⎞ ⎟ 4E ⎠

Where, Pc = Permissible axial compressive stress Pc’ = A value obtained from above Secant formula

σ y = Guaranteed minimum yield stress = 2600 kg/cm2 for mild steel fos = factor of safety = 1.68

le = Slenderness ratio k 6 2 E = Modulus of elasticity = 2.045 × 10 kg / cm for mild steel

For

le > 160 k

Page 369 of 429

S K Mondal’s

Chapter-13

Theories of Column

S K Mondal’s

OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Strength of Column GATE-1.

The rod PQ of length L and with flexural rigidity EI is hinged at both ends. For what minimum force F is it expected to buckle? (a) (c)

π 2 EI L2 π 2 EI 2L2

(b) (b)

2π 2EI L2

π 2 EI 2L2

[GATE-2008]

GATE-1. Ans. (b) Axial component of the force FPQ = F Sin 450

π 2 EI

We know for both end fixed column buckling load (P) = and Fsin450 = P or

F=

L2

2π 2EI L2

Equivalent Length GATE-2.

The ratio of Euler's buckling loads of columns with the same parameters having (i) both ends fixed, and (ii) both ends hinged is: [GATE-1998; 2002; IES-2001] (a) 2 (b) 4 (c) 6 (d) 8 GATE-2. Ans. (b) Euler’s buckling loads of columns 4π 2EI (1) both ends fixed = 2 l π 2EI ( 2 ) both ends hinged = 2 l

Euler's Theory (For long column) GATE-3.

A pin-ended column of length L, modulus of elasticity E and second moment of the cross-sectional area I is loaded centrically by a compressive load P. The [GATE-2006] critical buckling load (Pcr) is given by:

EI π 2 L2 π 2 EI Pcr = 2 L

(a) Pcr =

(b)

Pcr =

π 2 EI

(c) Pcr =

2

3L

π EI

(d)

L2

GATE-3. Ans. (d) GATE-4.

What is the expression for the crippling load for a column of length ‘l’ with one end fixed and other end free? [IES-2006; GATE-1994]

2π 2 EI (a) P = l2

(b)

P=

π 2 EI 4l 2

Page 370 of 4294π

(c)

P=

2

EI

l2

(d)

P=

π 2 EI l2

Chapter-13

Theories of Column

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

GATE-4. Ans. (b)

21. The piston rod of diameter 20 mm and length 700 mm in a hydraulic cylinder is subjected to a compressive force of 10 KN due to the internal pressure. The end conditions for the rod may be assumed as guided at the piston end and hinged at the other end. The Youngâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s modulus is 200 GPa. The factor of safety for the piston rod is (a) 0.68 (b) 2.75 (c) 5.62 (d) 11.0 [GATE-2007] 21. Ans. (c)

Previous 20-Years IES Questions Classification of Column IES-1.

A structural member subjected to an axial compressive force is called [IES-2008] (a) Beam (b) Column (c) Frame (d) Strut IES-1. Ans. (d) A machine part subjected to an axial compressive force is called a strut. A strut may be horizontal, inclined or even vertical. But a vertical strut is known as a column, pillar or stanchion. The term column is applied to all such members except those in which failure would be by simple or pure compression. Columns can be categorized then as: 1. Long column with central loading 2. Intermediate-length columns with central loading 3. Columns with eccentric loading 4. Struts or short columns with eccentric loading IES-2.

Which one of the following loadings is considered for design of axles? (a) Bending moment only [IES-1995] (b) Twisting moment only (c) Combined bending moment and torsion (d) Combined action of bending moment, twisting moment and axial thrust. IES-2. Ans. (a) Axle is a non-rotating member used for supporting rotating wheels etc. and do not transmit any torque. Axle must resist forces applied laterally or transversely to their axes. Such members are called beams.

Page 371 of 429

Chapter-13 IES-3.

Theories of Column

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

The curve ABC is the Euler's curve for stability of column. The horizontal line DEF is the strength limit. With reference to this figure Match List-I with ListII and select the correct answer using the codes given below the lists: List-I List-II (Regions) (Column specification) A. R1 1. Long, stable B. R2 2. Short C. R3 3. Medium D. R4 4. Long, unstable

Codes: (a) (c) IES-3. Ans. (b)

A 2 1

B 4 2

C 3 4

D 1 3

(b) (d)

A 2 2

B 3 1

C 1 3

D 4 4

[IES-1997]

IES-4.

Mach List-I with List-II and select the correct answer using the codes given below the lists: [IAS-1999] List-I List-II 1. Thin cylindrical shell A. Polar moment of inertia of section B. Buckling 2. Torsion of shafts C. Neutral axis 3. Columns D. Hoop stress 4. Bending of beams Codes: A B C D A B C D (a) 3 2 1 4 (b) 2 3 4 1 (c) 3 2 4 1 (d) 2 3 1 4 IES-4. Ans. (b)

Strength of Column IES-5.

Slenderness ratio of a column is defined as the ratio of its length to its (a) Least radius of gyration (b) Least lateral dimension [IES-2003] (c) Maximum lateral dimension (d) Maximum radius of gyration IES-5. Ans. (a) IES-6.

Assertion (A): A long column of square cross section has greater buckling stability than a similar column of circular cross-section of same length, same material and same area of cross-section with same end conditions. Reason (R): A circular cross-section has a smaller second moment of area than a square cross-section of same area. [IES-1999; IES-1996] (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IES-6. Ans. (a)

Equivalent Length IES-7.

Four columns of same material and same length are of rectangular crosssection of same breadth b. The depth of the cross-section and the end conditions are, however different are given as follows: [IES-2004] Column Depth End conditions 1 0.6 b Fixed-Fixed 2 0.8 b Fixed-hinged 3 1.0 b Hinged-Hinged 4 2.6 b Fixed-Free Which of the above columns Euler buckling load maximum? (a) Column 1 (b) ColumnPage 2 372 of 429(c) Column 3 (d) Column 4 IES-7. Ans. (b)

Chapter-13 IES-8.

Theories of Column

S K Mondal’s

Match List-I (End conditions of columns) with List-II (Equivalent length in terms of length of hinged-hinged column) and select the correct answer using the codes given below the Lists: [IES-2000] List-I List-II A. Both ends hinged 1. L

B. One end fixed and other end free 2. L/ 2 C. One end fixed and the other pin-pointed 3. 2L D. Both ends fixed 4. L/2 Code: A B C D A B C D (a) 1 3 4 2 (b) 1 3 2 4 (c) 3 1 2 4 (d) 3 1 4 2 IES-8. Ans. (b) IES-9. The ratio of Euler's buckling loads of columns with the same parameters having (i) both ends fixed, and (ii) both ends hinged is: [GATE-1998; 2002; IES-2001] (a) 2 (b) 4 (c) 6 (d) 8 IES-9. Ans. (b) Euler’s buckling loads of columns 4π 2EI (1) both ends fixed = 2 l π 2EI ( 2 ) both ends hinged = 2 l

Euler's Theory (For long column) IES-10.

What is the expression for the crippling load for a column of length ‘l’ with one end fixed and other end free? [IES-2006; GATE-1994] (a)

P=

IES-10. Ans. (b)

2π 2 EI l2

(b)

P=

π 2 EI 4l 2

(c)

P=

4π 2 EI l2

(d)

P=

π 2 EI l2

IES-11.

Euler's formula gives 5 to 10% error in crippling load as compared to experimental results in practice because: [IES-1998] (a) Effect of direct stress is neglected (b) Pin joints are not free from friction (c) The assumptions made in using the formula are not met in practice (d) The material does not behave in an ideal elastic way in tension and compression IES-11. Ans. (c) IES-12.

Euler's formula can be used for obtaining crippling load for a M.S. column with hinged ends. Which one of the following conditions for the slenderness ratio satisfied? (a) 5 <

IES-12. Ans. (d)

l <8 k

l is to be k [IES-2000]

(b) 9 <

l < 18 k

(c) 19 <

l < 40 k

(d)

l ≥ 80 k

IES-13.

If one end of a hinged column is made fixed and the other free, how much is the critical load compared to the original value? [IES-2008] (a) ¼ (b) ½ (c) Twice (d) Four times IES-13. Ans. (a) Critical Load for both ends hinged = π 2EI/ l 2 And Critical Load for one end fixed, and other end free = π 2EI/4l2 IES-14.

If one end of a hinged column is made fixed and the other free, how much is the critical load compared to the original value? [IES-2008] (a) ¼ (b) ½ (c) Twice (d) Four times π 2EI Page 373 of 429 IES-14. Ans. (a) Original load = 2 I

Chapter-13

Theories of Column

S K Mondal’s

When one end of hinged column is fixed and other free. New Le = 2L π2EI π2EI 1 = = × Original value ∴ New load = 2 2 4 4L ( 2L )

IES-15.

Match List-I with List-II and select the correct answer using the code given below the Lists: [IES-1995; 2007; IAS-1997] List-I (Long Column) List-II (Critical Load) 1. π 2EI/4l2 A. Both ends hinged B. One end fixed, and other end free 2. 4 π 2EI/ l2 C. Both ends fixed 3. 2 π 2EI/ l2 D. One end fixed, and other end hinged 4. π 2EI/ l2 Code: A B C D A B C D (a) 2 1 4 3 (b) 4 1 2 3 (c) 2 3 4 1 (d) 4 3 2 1 IES-15. Ans. (b) IES-16.

The ratio of the compressive critical load for a long column fixed at both the ends and a column with one end fixed and the other end free is: [IES-1997] (a) 1 : 2 (b) 1: 4 (c) 1: 8 (d) 1: 16 IES-16. Ans. (d) Critical Load for one end fixed, and other end free is π 2EI/4l2 and both ends fixed is 4 π 2EI/ l 2 IES-17.

The buckling load will be maximum for a column, if (a) One end of the column is clamped and the other end is free (b) Both ends of the column are clamped (c) Both ends of the column are hinged (d) One end of the column is hinged and the other end is free IES-17. Ans. (b) Buckling load of a column will be maximum when both ends are fixed

[IES-1993]

IES-18.

If diameter of a long column is reduced by 20%, the percentage of reduction in Euler buckling load is: [IES-2001] (a) 4 (b) 36 (c) 49 (d) 59

IES-18. Ans. (d) IES-19.

2

L

4 4 ′ 4 p − p′ d − d ⎛ 0.8d ⎞ P ∞ I or P ∞ d or = = 1− ⎜ ⎟ = 0.59 p d4 ⎝ d ⎠

( )

4

A long slender bar having uniform rectangular cross-section 'B x H' is acted upon by an axial compressive force. The sides B and H are parallel to x- and yaxes respectively. The ends of the bar are fixed such that they behave as pinjointed when the bar buckles in a plane normal to x-axis, and they behave as built-in when the bar buckles in a plane normal to y-axis. If load capacity in either mode of buckling is same, then the value of H/B will be: [IES-2000] (a) 2 (b) 4 (c) 8 (d) 16

IES-19. Ans. (a) IES-20.

P=

π 2 EI

Pxx =

π 2 EI L2

4π 2 EI ′ BH3 HB3 H ′ and Pyy = as P = P then = = × I 4I or 4 or = 2 xx yy 2 12 12 B L

The Euler's crippling load for a 2m long slender steel rod of uniform crosssection hinged at both the ends is 1 kN. The Euler's crippling load for 1 m long steel rod of the same cross-section and hinged at both ends will be: [IES-1998] (a) 0.25 kN (b) 0.5 kN (c) 2 kN (d) 4 kN

IES-20. Ans. (d) For column with both ends hinged, P = IES-21.

π 2 EI l2

. If ‘l’ is halved, P will be 4 times.

If σc and E denote the crushing stress and Young's modulus for the material of a column, then the Euler formula can be applied for determination of cripping load of a column made of this material only, if its slenderness ratio is: (a) More than

π E / σc

Page 374 of 429

(b) Less than

π E / σc

[IES-2005]

Chapter-13

Theories of Column

(c) More than

⎛ E⎞ ⎟ ⎝ σc ⎠

π2⎜

S K Mondal’s

(d) Less than

⎛ E⎞ ⎟ ⎝ σc ⎠

π2⎜

IES-21. Ans. (a) For long column PEuler < Pcrushing or

π 2EI le

2

< σcA

or

π 2EAK 2 le

2

2

< σcA

π E ⎛ le ⎞ or ⎜ ⎟ > σc k ⎝ ⎠ 2

or

le > π E / σc k

IES-22.

Four vertical columns of same material, height and weight have the same end conditions. Which cross-section will carry the maximum load? [IES-2009] (a) Solid circular section (b) Thin hollow circular section (c) Solid square section (d) I-section IES-22. Ans. (b)

Rankine's Hypothesis for Struts/Columns IES-23. Rankine Gordon formula for buckling is valid for (a) Long column (b) Short column (c) Short and long column (d) Very long column IES-23. Ans. (c)

[IES-1994]

Prof. Perry's formula IES-24.

Match List-I with List-II and select the correct answer using the code given below the lists: [IES-2008] List-I (Formula/theorem/ method) List-II (Deals with topic) 1. Deflection of beam A. Clapeyron's theorem B. Maculay's method 2. Eccentrically loaded column C. Perry's formula 3. Riveted joints 4. Continuous beam Code: A B C A B C (a) 3 2 1 (b) 4 1 2 (c) 4 1 3 (d) 2 4 3 IES-24. Ans. (b)

Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Classification of Column IAS-1.

Mach List-I with List-II and select the correct answer using the codes given below the lists: [IAS-1999] List-I List-II 1. Thin cylindrical shell A. Polar moment of inertia of section B. Buckling 2. Torsion of shafts C. Neutral axis 3. Columns D. Hoop stress 4. Bending of beams Codes: A B C D A B C D (a) 3 2 1 4 (b) 2 3 4 1 (c) 3 2 4 1 (d) 2 3 1 4 IAS-1. Ans. (b)

Strength of Column IAS-2.

Assertion (A): A long column of square cross-section has greater buckling stability than that of a column of circular cross-section of same length, same material, same end conditions and same area of cross-section. [IAS-1998] Reason (R): The second moment of area of a column of circular cross-section is Page 375 of 429 smaller than that of a column of square cross section having the same area. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A

Chapter-13

Theories of Column

S K Mondal’s

(b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-2. Ans. (a)

IAS-3.

Which one of the following pairs is not correctly matched? [IAS-2003] (a) Slenderness ratio : The ratio of length of the column to the least radius of gyration (b) Buckling factor : The ratio of maximum load to the permissible axial load on the column (c) Short column : A column for which slenderness ratio < 32 (d) Strut : A member of a structure in any position and carrying an axial compressive load IAS-3. Ans. (b) Buckling factor: The ratio of equivalent length of the column to the least radius of gyration.

Equivalent Length IAS-4.

A column of length 'I' is fixed at its both ends. The equivalent length of the column is: [IAS-1995] (a) 2 l (b) 0.5 l (c) 2 l (d) l IAS-4. Ans. (b) IAS-5.

Which one of the following statements is correct? [IAS-2000] (a) Euler's formula holds good only for short columns (b) A short column is one which has the ratio of its length to least radius of gyration greater than 100 (c) A column with both ends fixed has minimum equivalent or effective length (d) The equivalent length of a column with one end fixed and other end hinged is half of its actual length IAS-5. Ans. (c) A column with both ends fixed has minimum equivalent effective length (l/2)

Euler's Theory (For long column) IAS-6.

4π 2 EI For which one of the following columns, Euler buckling load = ? l2

(a) Column with both hinged ends [IAS-1999; 2004] (b) Column with one end fixed and other end free (c) Column with both ends fixed (d) Column with one end fixed and other hinged IAS-6. Ans. (c) IAS-7. Assertion (A): Buckling of long columns causes plastic deformation. [IAS-2001] Reason (R): In a buckled column, the stresses do not exceed the yield stress. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IAS-7. Ans. (d) And Critical Load for one end fixed, and other end free = π 2EI/4l2

IAS-8.

Match List-I with List-II and select the correct answer using the code given below the Lists: [IES-1995; 2007; IAS-1997] List-I (Long Column) List-II (Critical Load) 2 2 A. Both ends hinged 1. Page 376 of 429 π EI/4l B. One end fixed, and other end free

2. 4

π 2EI/ l 2

Chapter-13

Theories of Column

C. Both ends fixed

3. 2

D. One end fixed, and other end hinged

4.

Code: (a) (c) IAS-8. Ans. (b)

A 2 2

B 1 3

C 4 4

D 3 1

A (b) 4 (d) 4

Page 377 of 429

S K Mondal’s

π 2EI/ l 2

π 2EI/ l 2 B 1 3

C 2 2

D 3 1

Chapter-13

Theories of Column

S K Mondal’s

Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question ESE-2001, ESE 2000 Question: Answer: Column:

Differentiate between strut and column. What is the general expression used for determining of their critical load? Strut: A member of structure which carries an axial compressive load. If the strut is vertical it is known as column. For strut failure due to compression or σc =

Compressive force Area

If σc > σ yc it fails. Euler's formula for column ( PC ) =

π 2 EI 2 e

Conventional Question ESE-2009 Q.

Two long columns are made of identical lengths ‘l’ and flexural rigidities ‘EI’. Column 1 is hinged at both ends whereas for column 2 one end is fixed and the other end is free. (i) Write the expression for Euler’s buckling load for column 1. (ii) What is the ratio of Euler’s buckling load of column 1 to that column 2? [ 2 Marks]

Ans.

(i)

π2EI

π2EI

( right ) L2 4L2 For column l, both end hinged l e = L

(ii)

P1 =

; P2 =

P1 =4 P2

Conventional Question ESE-2010 Q.

Ans.

The piston rod of diameter 20 mm and length 700 mm in a hydraulic cylinder is subjected to a compressive force of 10 kN due to internal pressure. The piston end of the rod is guided along the cylinder and the other end of the rod is hinged at the cross-head. The modulus of elasticity for piston rod material is 200 GPa. Estimate the factor of safety taken for the piston rod design. [2 Marks]

P

σ=

P PL ; δ= ; A AE

e

=

2

; Pe =

π2 EI 2 e

(considering one end of the column is fixed and

other end is hinged) Pe = Euler Crippling load Compressive load, Pc = σ c × Area = 10 kN Euler’s load, Pe =

P

20mm

(

) (

2π2 × 200 × 109 × π × 0.0204 / 64

2

(0.7)

F.S =

Page 378 of 429

)

= 63.278 kN

Chapter-13 Theories of Column Conventional Question ESE-1999 Question: Answer:

S K Mondal’s

State the limitation of Euler's formula for calculating critical load on columns Assumptions: (i) The column is perfectly straight and of uniform cross-section (ii) The material is homogenous and isotropic (iii) The material behaves elastically (iv) The load is perfectly axial and passes through the centroid of the column section. (v) The weight of the column is neglected.

Conventional Question ESE-2007 Question:

What is the value of Euler's buckling load for an axially loaded pin-ended (hinged at both ends) strut of length 'l' and flexural rigidity 'EI'? What would be order of Euler's buckling load carrying capacity of a similar strut but fixed at both ends in terms of the load carrying capacity of the earlier one? From Euler's buckling load formula,

π 2EI 2 e

Equivalent length ( e ) = for both end hinged = So for both end hinged (Pc )beh = and for both fixed (Pc )bef =

π 2EI

( 2)

2

2

for both end fixed.

π 2EI 2

=

4 π 2EI 2

Euler's critical load for a column with both ends hinged is found as 40 kN. What would be the change in the critical load if both ends are fixed? We know that Euler's critical laod, PEuler= e

π 2 EI 2 e

[Where E = modulus of elasticity, I = least moment of inertia

= equivalent length ]

For both end hinged ( e) = And For both end fixed ( e) =

/2

2

∴ (PEuler )b.e.h. =

π EI

and (PEuler )b.e.F . =

2

=40 kN(Given)

π 2EI π 2 EI = 4 × = 4 × 40 = 160 kN 2 ( / 2)2

Conventional Question ESE-1999 Question:

A hollow cast iron column of 300 mm external diameter and 220 mm internal diameter is used as a column 4 m long with both ends hinged. Determine the safe compressive load the column can carry without buckling using Euler's formula and Rankine's formula E = 0.7×105 N/mm2, FOS = 4, Rankine constant (a) = 1/1600 Crushing Stress ( σ c ) = 567 N/mm2

Given outer diameter of column (D) = 300 mm = 0.3 m. Inner diameter of the column (d) = 220 mm = 0.22 m. Length of the column ( ) = 4 m End conditions is both ends hinged. Therefore equivalent length (

e

)=

Yield crushing stress ( σ c ) = 567 MPa = 567×106 N/m2 Page of 429 5 N/mm2 = 70 x 109 N/m2 E379 = 0.7×10 Rankine constant (a) = 1/ 1600 and

= 4 m.

Chapter-13

Theories of Column S K Mondal’s π π ⎡0.3 4 − 0.224 ⎤ = 2.826 ×10−4 m 4 Moment of Inertia(I) = (D 4 − d 4 ) = ⎥⎦ 64 64 ⎢⎣

π (D 4 − d 4 ) D 2 + d 2 0.32 + 0.222 64 = = = 0.093m π 2 16 16 2 (D − d ) 4

I = Slenderness ratio(k)= A

π 2 π (D − d 2 ) = (0.32 − 0.222 ) = 0.03267 m 2 4 4 (i) Euler's buckling load, PEuler Area(A) =

PEuler =

π 2EI 2 e

π 2 × (70 ×109 ) × (2.826 ×10−4 ) = 12.2MN 42

=

PEuler 12.2 = = 3.05 MN fos 4 (ii)Rankine's buckling load, PRankine ∴ Safe load =

PRankine =

(567×10 )× 0.03267 6

σ c .A 2

⎛ ⎞ 1 + a.⎜⎜ e ⎟⎟ ⎜⎝ k ⎠⎟

=

2

⎛ 4 ⎞⎟ 1 ×⎜⎜ 1+ ⎟ 1600 ⎜⎝ 0.093 ⎠⎟

= 8.59 MN

PRankine 8.59 = = 2.148 MPa fos 4

Conventional Question ESE-2008 Question:

A both ends hinged cast iron hollow cylindrical column 3 m in length has a critical buckling load of P kN. When the column is fixed at both the ends, its critical buckling load raise by 300 kN more. If ratio of external diameter to internal diameter is 1.25 and E = 100 GPa determine the external diameter of column.

Pc =

π 2 EI I e2

For both end hinged column π 2EI −−− (i ) L2 For both end fixed column

P=

P+300=

π 2EI

(L 2)

2

=

4π 2EI −−− ( ii ) L2

Dividing (ii) by (i) we get P+300 = 4 or P=100kN P Moment of inertia of a hollow cylinder c/s is PL2 π D4 − d 4 ) = 2 ( 64 πE 3 2 64 (100 ×10 ) 3 4 4 = 1.8577 ×10−5 orD − d = 2 9 π π ×100 ×10

I=

Page 380 of 429

Chapter-13

Theories of Column

S K Mondal’s

D D = 1.25 or d = d 1.25-5 4 ⎡ ⎛ 1 ⎞ ⎤ ⎟ ⎥ = 1.8577 ×10−5 or D4 ⎢⎢1− ⎜⎜ ⎜⎝1.25 ⎟⎠⎟ ⎥ ⎢⎣ ⎥⎦ or D=0.0749 m = 74.9 mm given

Conventional Question AMIE-1996 Question:

A piston rod of steam engine 80 cm long in subjected to a maximum load of 60 kN. Determine the diameter of the rod using Rankine's formula with permissible compressive stress of 100 N/mm2. Take constant in Rankine's

1 for hinged ends. The rod may be assumed partially fixed 7500

with length coefficient of 0·6. Given: l = 80 cm = 800 mm ;P = 60kN = 60 × 103 N, σ c = 100N / mm2 ;

a=

1 for hinged ends; 7500

length coefficient = 0.6

To find diameter of the rod, d: Use Rankine’s formula

P=

σcA

2

⎛l ⎞ 1+ a ⎜ e ⎟ ⎝k⎠ Here le = 0.6l = 0.6 × 800 = 480 mm [∵length coefficient = 0.6]

π k=

I = A

64

π

4

d4

=

d2

d 4

⎛π ⎞ 100 × ⎜ d2 ⎟ ⎝4 ⎠ 60 × 103 = 2 1 ⎡ 480 ⎤ 1+ 7500 ⎢⎣ d / 4 ⎥⎦

Solving the above equation we get the value of ‘d’ Note: Unit of d comes out from the equation will be mm as we put the equivalent length in mm.

or

d = 33.23mm

Conventional Question ESE-2005 Question:

A hollow cylinder CI column, 3 m long its internal and external diameters as 80 mm and 100 mm respectively. Calculate the safe load using Rankine formula: if (i) Both ends are hinged and (ii) Both ends are fixed. 2 Take crushing strength of material as 600 N / mm , Rankine constant 1/1600 and factor of safety = 3.

Moment of Inertia (I)=

π (0.14 − 0.08 4 ) m 4 = 2.898 ×10−6 m 4 64

Page 381 of 429

C Chapter-13

Theorie es of Colum mn

Area( A) =

S K Mo ondal’s

π 0.12 − 0.082 ) = 2.8274 2 ×10 0−3 m 2 ( 4

I 2.898 ×10−6 Radius off gyration (k) = ( = = 0..032 m A 2.8274 ×10−3 σ c .A PRankine = uivalent len ngth] ; [ e = equ 2 ⎛ e ⎞⎟ 1+ a ⎜⎜ ⎟⎟ ⎜⎝ k ⎠

(600 ×10 )×(2.8274 ×10 ) −3

6

(i)

=

2

⎛ 1 ⎞⎟ ⎛ 3 ⎞⎟ ×⎜ 1+ ⎜⎜ ⎟ ⎜⎝1600 ⎟⎟⎠ ⎝⎜⎜ 0.0 032 ⎟⎠

; [

e

= l = 3 m for both h end hinged]

2.61026kN N =2 P 26126 Safe load d (P)= Rankine = = 87.09 kN FOS S 3 (ii) For bo oth end fixxed, e = = 1.5 m 2 (600 ×106 )×(2.8274 ×10−3 ) PRankinee = = 714.8 kN k 2 ⎛ 1.5 ⎟⎞ 1 ×⎜⎜ 1+ ⎟⎟ ⎠ 0 1600 ⎜⎝ 0.032 P 714.8 8 Safe load d (P)= Rankkine = = 238.27 7 kN S 3 FOS C Convention nal Questiion AMIE--1997 Q Question:

A slender column is built-in att one end and a an ecce entric load is applied at the nciples fin nd the exp pression fo or the free end. Working from the first prin m length off column su uch that th he deflectio on of the fr ree end do oes not maximum exceed th he eccentric city of load ding.

Above figu ure shows a slender colu umn of lengtth ‘I’. The coolumn is built in at one e end B and eccentric load P is applied at the t free end A. he deflection n at any secttion XX disttant x from the fixed en nd B. Let δ be the Let y be th deflection at a A. The bendin ng moment at a the section XX is give en by Page 382 of 429

Chapter-13

Theories of Column 2

dy = P (δ + e − y ) dx 2 d2 y EI 2 + Py = P (δ + e ) dx

S K Mondal’s

− − − − (i)

EI

d2 y P P + y = (δ + e ) 2 EI EI dx

or

The solution to the above differential equation is

⎡ P⎤ ⎡ P⎤ y = C1 cos ⎢ x ⎥ + C2 sin ⎢ x ⎥ + (δ + e ) ⎢⎣ EI ⎥⎦ ⎢⎣ EI ⎥⎦ Where C1 and C2 are the cons tan ts.

− − − ( ii )

At the end B, x = 0 and y = 0 ∴

0 = C1 cos 0 + C2 sin 0 + (δ + e )

or

C1 = − (δ + e )

Differentiating equation ( ii ) we get ⎡ P ⎤ ⎡ P ⎤ dy P P = −C1 sin ⎢ x cos ⎢ x ⎥ + C2 ⎥ dx EI EI ⎢⎣ EI ⎥⎦ ⎢⎣ EI ⎥⎦ Again,at the fixed end B, dy When x = 0, =0 dx P P cos 0 × 0 + C2 EI EI

0 = (δ + e )

or C2 = 0 At the free end A,x = ,y = δ

Substituting for x and y in equation (ii ) ,we have ⎡

δ = − (δ + e ) cos ⎢ ⎣

⎡ cos ⎢ ⎣

P EI

⎤ ⎥ = (δ + e ) ⎦

P ⎤ e ⎥= EI ⎦ δ + e

− − − (iii )

It is mentioned in the problem that the deflection of the free end does not exceed the eccentricity. It means that δ = e Substituting this value in equation (iii), we have

⎡ cos ⎢ ⎣ ∴ ∴

P⎤ e 1 = ⎥= EI ⎦ δ + e 2

P ⎛ 1⎞ π = cos −1 ⎜ ⎟ = EI ⎝ 2⎠ 3 =

π 3

EI P

Conventional Question ESE-2005 Question:

A long strut AB of length ' ' is of uniform section throughout. A thrust P is applied at the ends eccentrically on the same side of the centre line with eccentricity at the end B twice than that at the end A. Show that the maximum bending moment occurs at a distance x from the end A, Where, tan(kx)=

2 − cos k P and k= sin k EI Page 383 of 429

C Chapter-13 An nswer:

Theorie es of Colum mn

S K Mo ondal’s

Let at a distance 'x' from L m end A defllection of the b beam is y

d 2y = −P.y dx 2 d 2y P + o or y =0 2 EI E dx ∴ EI

o or

d 2y + k 2y = 0 2 dx

⎡ ⎤ ⎢∵ k = P giiven ⎥ ⎢ ⎥ EI ⎢⎣ ⎥⎦

C.F of this diifferential equation C y = A cos kx + B sin kx, Where W A & B constant. I is clear at x = 0, y = e It A at x = , y= 2e And

∴ e = A..................(i )

⎡ 2e − e cos k or B = ⎢ ⎢⎣ sin k ⎡ 2e − e cos k ⎤ ⎥ sin kx os kx + ⎢ ∴ y = e co ⎥⎦ ⎢⎣ s k sin Where be ending mom ment is maximum, dy the deflection will be maximum so s =0 dx ⎡ 2e − e coss k ⎤ dy ⎥ cos kx = 0 e sin kx + k . ⎢ ∴ = −ek ⎢⎣ ⎥⎦ sin k dx 2e = A cos s k + B sin k

or tan kx =

⎤ ⎥ ⎥⎦

2 − cos k sin k

C Convention nal Questiion ESE-1996 Q Question:

The link of o a mecha anism is su ubjected to axial com mpressive fo orce. It has s solid circular cross-sectio c on with dia ameter 9 mm m and len ngth 200 mm m. The two o ends 2 of the link k are hing ged. It is made m of stee el having yield y strength = 400 N/mm N and elastic moduluss = 200 kN N/mm2. Calc culate the critical lo oad that th he link y. Use John non's equatiion. can carry According to t Johnson'ss equation

⎡ σ y ⎛ ⎞⎟2 ⎤⎥ ⎢ ⎜⎜ ⎟ Pcr = σ y .A ⎢1− 4n π 2E ⎜⎝ k ⎟⎠ ⎥⎥⎦ ⎢⎣ πd2 = 63.62 2 mm 2 4 ⎛ πd 4 ⎞⎟ ⎜⎜ ⎟ ⎜⎝ 64 ⎠⎟⎟ d I least radiu us of gyratio on (k) = = = 2.55 mm = ⎛ πd 2 ⎞⎟ 4 A ⎜⎜ ⎟⎟ ⎜⎝ 4 ⎠⎟

Hear A=arrea of crosss section=

For both end e hinged n=1 2 ⎡ ⎛ 200 ⎞⎟ ⎤⎥ 400 ⎢ ⎜ ∴ Pcr = 400 × 63.62 ⎢1− ⎟ =15.262kN ⎜ 4 ×1× π 2 × (200 ×103 ) × ⎜⎝ 2.25 ⎠⎟ ⎥⎥⎦ ⎢⎣ C Convention nal Questiion GATE--1995 Q Question:

Find the shortest s length of a hinged h Page 384 stee el429 column having h a re ectangular crossof section 60 00 mm × 10 00 mm, for r which the e elastic Euler formu ula applies. Take

Theories of Column

S K Mondal’s

yield strength and modulus of elasticity value for steel as 250 MPa and 200 GPa respectively. Given: Cross-section, (= b x d) = 600 mm x 100 mm = 0.6 m x 0.1 m = 0.06 m2;

P = 250MPa = 250MN / m 2 ; E = 200 GPa = 200 ×1012 N / m 2 A Length of the column, L :

Yield strength =

bd 3 0.6 × 0.13 = = 5 ×10−5 m4 12 12 I 5 ×10−5 = 8.333 ×10−4 m 2 Also, k2 = = A 0.6 × 0.1 [ ∵ I = AK 2 ( where A = area of cross-section, k = radius of gyration)] From Euler's formula for column, we have Least area moment of Inertia, I =

Pcr =

π 2EI π 2EI = 2 L2e L

For both endhinged type of column, Le = L or or

π 2EAk 2 L2 ⎛ P ⎞ π 2EI Yield stress ⎜⎜ cr ⎟⎟⎟ = 2 ⎜⎝ A ⎠ L

or

Pcr =

L2 =

π 2Ek 2 (Pcr / A)

Substituting the value, we get

π 2 × 200 ×109 × 0.0008333 = 6.58 250 ×106 L = 2.565 m L2 =

Conventional Question GATE-1993 Question:

Determine the temperature rise necessary to induce buckling in a lm long circular rod of diameter 40 mm shown in the Figure below. Assume the rod to be pinned at its ends and the coefficient of thermal expansion as 20 ×10−6 / 0 C . Assume uniform heating of the bar.

Let us assume the buckling load be'P'.

Page 385 of 429

Chapter-13

Theories of Column δL = L. ∝ . t , Where t is the temperature rise.

or Also,

δL L. ∝ PL or δL = AE π 2EI Pcr = 2 Le

S K Mondal’s

t=

P=

δL.AE L

−− − ( where L e =equivalent length)

π 2EI δL.A.E = [QLe =L For both endhinged] L L2 π 2I δL = or LA δL π 2I π 2I t= = = 2 L. ∝ LA.L. ∝ L A. ∝ Substituting the values, we get 4 π π 2 × ×(0.040) 64 t= Temperature rise = 49.350 C 2 4 π −6 (1) × ×(0.040) × 20 ×10 4

or

So the rod will buckle when the temperature rises more than 49.35°C.

Page 386 of 429

14. Strain Energy Method Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) 1. Resilience (U) •

Resilience is an ability of a material to absorb energy when elastically deformed and to return it when unloaded.

The strain energy stored in a specimen when stained within the elastic limit is known as resilience.

U=

σ2 × V o lu m e 2E

or U =

∈2 E × V o lu m e 2

2. Proof Resilience •

Maximum strain energy stored at elastic limit. i.e. the strain energy stored in the body upto elastic limit.

This is the property of the material that enables it to resist shock and impact by storing energy. The measure of proof resilience is the strain energy absorbed per unit volume.

3. Modulus of Resilience (u) The proof resilience per unit volume is known as modulus of resilience. If

σ is the stress due to

σ2 u= 2E

∈2 E or u= 2

4. Application 3 L P2. P2 L P2 L 4 4 U= + = 2 π πd 2 AE 2 (2d ) 2 E E 2. 4 4

L/4

L

2d

P

Strain energy becomes smaller & smaller as the cross sectional area of bar is increased over more & more of its length i.e. A ↑ , U ↓

5. Toughness •

This is the property which enables a material to be twisted, bent or stretched under impact Page be 387 considered of 429 load or high stress before rupture. It may to be the ability of the material to

C Chapter-14

Strain En nergy Meth hod

S K Mo ondal’s

absorrb energy in i the plasttic zone. Th he measure e of toughneess is the amount of energy absorrbed after beeing stressed d upto the point p of fractture. •

Toug ghness is an ability to ab bsorb energy y in the plasstic range.

The ability a to witthstand occa asional stressses above th he yield streess without ffracture.

Toug ghness = streength + ducttility

The materials with w higherr modulus of toughne ess are useed to makee components and strucctures that will w be expossed to sudden and impacct loads.

M Modulus off Toughnes ss •

The ability of un nit volume of materiall to absorb energy y in the plasttic range.

The amount of work per unit u volumee that

the

material

can

withstand d

withoout failure.

The area a under the entire stress strain n diagrram is called d modulus off toughness,

UT = Хu Зf

which h is a meassure of energy that can n be absorbed a by y the unit volume off mateerial due to impact i loadiing before itt fractu ures.

6 Strain energy 6. e in shear an nd torsion n • Strain energy e per unit u volumee, (u s )

T

A

τ2 Gγ 2 us = or, u s = 2 2G •

Totall Strain Eneergy (U) for a Shaft in Torsion

1 U s = Tφ 2 O

1 GJφ 2 1 ⎛ T 2L ⎞ ∴U s = ⎜ or ⎟ 2 L 2 ⎝ GJ ⎠

or •

Us =

τ 2max 2π L 2 ρ dρ 2G r 2 ∫

Case es

•Sollid shaft , U s =

τ 2max ×π r2L 4G

4 4 2 2 τ 2max π ( D − d ) L τ 2max ( D + d ) • Hollow shaft , U s = × = × × Volume D2 D2 4G 4G

Page 388 of 429

B

φ

Chapter--14

Strain n Energy Method M

S K Mondal’s

2

τ × sLt 4G w where s = Leength of meean centre linne

•T Thin walledd tube , U s =

2

GJ ⎛ dφ ⎞ GJ ⎜ ⎟ dx = ∫ 2 ⎝ dx ⎠ 2

• Conical sppring , US =

2

=

P 2GJ

2π n

∫ 0

2

⎛ PR ⎞ R ) ⎜ ⎟ .R.dα ( R = Radius ⎝ GJ ⎠

2πn

∫ R dα 3

(R varries with ∝ )

0

3 ⎛ P2 L ⎞ • Cantilever beam b with load l 'p' at ennd, Us = ⎜ ⎟ 5 ⎝ bhG ⎠ • Helical sprring , U s =

πP 2 R 3 n GJ

(∵ L = 2π Rn )

7. Strain energy in bending. An ngle subtend ded by arc, θ =

Sttrain energy y stored in beam. L

Ub =

0

or U •

b

Mx

∫ EI .dxx

M x2 .d x 2E I L

EI = 2

∫ 0

2

⎛ d 2y ⎞ dx ⎜ 2 ⎟ ⎝ dx ⎠

⎛ d 2y M ⎞ ∵ = − ⎜ ⎟ 2 EI ⎠ dx ⎝

Cases

P 2 L3 6 EI

o

Cantilever beam with a end load l P , Ub =

o

Simplly supported d with a load d P at centre e, U b =

P 2 L3 96 EI E

mportant Note N Im o

o

For pu ure bending g •

M is consttant along th he length ‘L L’

θ=

ML EI

U=

EIθ 2 M 2L if curvature θ / L isknown if Misknow wn = 2L 2EI

b For noon-uniform bending •

Strain energy in shea ar is neglecte ed

Strain energy in bend ding is only considered.

8. Castiiglione’s theorem ∂U = δn ∂P Pn

Page 389 of 429

Chapter-14

Strain Energy Method

∂U 1 = ∂p EI •

⎛ ∂M x Mx ⎜ ⎝ ∂p

⎞ ⎟dx ⎠

Note: o

Strain energy, stored due to direct stress in 3 coordinates

U= o

1 ⎡ ∑ (σ x ) 2 − 2 μ ∑ σ x σ y ⎤⎦ 2E ⎣

If σ x = σ y = σ z ,in case of equal stress in 3 direction then U=

3σ 2 σ2 [1 − 2μ] = 2E 2k

(volume strain energy)

Page 390 of 429

S K Mondal’s

Chapter-14

Strain Energy Method

S K Mondal’s

OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Strain Energy or Resilience GATE-1.

The strain energy stored in the beam with flexural rigidity EI and loaded as shown in the figure is: [GATE-2008]

(a)

P 2L3 3EI 4L

GATE-1. Ans. (c)

∫ 0

L

= 2∫ 0

L

= 2∫ 0

GATE-2.

(b)

2P 2L3 3EI

(c) 3L

L

4P 2L3 3EI

(d)

8P 2L3 3EI

4L

M 2dx M 2dx M 2dx M 2dx =∫ +∫ +∫ EI EI EI EI L 0 3L L 4L 2 2 ⎡ ⎤ ⎢By symmetry M dx = M dx ⎥ ∫ EI ∫ EI ⎥⎥ ⎢ ⎢⎣ 0 3L ⎦

3L

M 2dx M 2dx +∫ EI EI L 3L

(Px )2 dx (PL )2 dx 4P 2L3 +∫ = EI EI 3EI L

PL3 is the deflection under the load P of a cantilever beam [length L, modulus 3EI

of elasticity, E, moment of inertia-I]. The strain energy due to bending is: [GATE-1993]

(a)

P 2 L3 3EI

(b)

P 2 L3 6 EI

(c )

GATE-2. Ans. (b) We may do it taking average

P 2 L3 4 EI

Strain energy = Average force x displacement =

(d )

P 2 L3 48 EI

3 P 2 L3 ⎛ P ⎞ PL × = ⎜ ⎟ 6 EI ⎝ 2 ⎠ 3EI

Alternative method: In a funny way you may use Castiglione’s theorem, δ =

∂U . Then ∂P

∂U PL3 PL3 ∂P Partially integrating with respect to P we get or U = ∫ ∂U = ∫ = ∂P 3EI 3EI P2L3 U= 6EI δ=

Page 391 of 429

C Chapter-14 G GATE-3.

Strain En nergy Meth hod

S K Mo ondal’s

The stresss-strain behaviour T b of a m material i is shown in figur re. Its 3, r resilience hness, in Nm/m N and tough a respectively are (a a) 28 × 104, 76 × 104 (b b) 28 × 104, 48 × 104 (cc) 14 × 104, 90 9 × 104 (d d) 76 × 104

[GATE E-2000] G GATE-3. An ns. (c) Resiliience = area under this curve c up to 0.004 strain n 1 = × 0.004 × 70 × 106 = 14 4 × 10 4 Nm/m m3 2 T Toughness = area under this curve up u to 0.012 strain s 1 = 14 × 10 4 + 70 7 × 106 × ( 0.0 012 − 0.004 ) + × ( 0.012 − 0.004 ) × (120 − 70 ) × 10 06 Nm/m3 2 = 90 × 104 Nm m/m3 G GATE-4.

A square ba ar of side 4 cm and le ength 100 cm m is subjec cted to an a axial load P. P The s same bar iss then used d as a cantiilever beam m and subje ected to alll end load P. P The r ratio of the e strain ene ergies, stor red in the bar in the second case to that stored in n the first case, is: E-1998] [GATE (a a) 16 (b) 400 (c) 1000 (d) 2500 2

G GATE-4.

⎛W⎞ ⎜ A ⎟ AL W 2L A Ans. (d) U1 = ⎝ ⎠ = 2AE 2E 2 3 2 3 W L W L 2W 2L3 U2 = = = 6EI Ea 4 ⎛ 1 ⎞ 6E ⎜ a4 ⎟ ⎝ 12 ⎠ 2

o or

U2 4L2 ⎛ 100 ⎞ = 2 = 4×⎜ ⎟ = 2500 U1 a ⎝ 4 ⎠

T Toughn ness G GATE-5.

The total ar T rea under the stress--strain curv ve of a milld steel spe ecimen testted up to failure under tensio on is a mea asure of [GATE E-2002] a) Ductility (b) Ultimate U streength (c) Stiffn ness (d) Tough hness (a G GATE-5. An ns. (d)

Prev vious 20-Ye 2 ars IE ES Que estion ns S Strain E Energy y or Re esilienc ce IES-1.

What is the W e strain en nergy store ed in a bod dy of volum me V with stress σ due d to g gradually a applied load d? [IES S-2006] (a a)

σE V

(b)

σ E2 V

(c)

σV 2 E

(d)

σ 2V 2E

W Where, E = Modulus M of elasticity e 1 σ2 IES-1. Ans. (d) Strain Energy = . ×V 2 E IES-2.

A bar havin ng length L and uniform cross s-section with w area A is subjec cted to b both tensile force P and torqu ue Page T. If is the she ear modulus and E is the 392Gof 429 Y Young's mo odulus, the internal sttrain energ gy stored in n the bar iss: [IES S-2003]

Chapter-14

Strain Energy Method 2

2

2

S K Mondal’s

2

2

T L P L T L P L + + (c) GJ 2 AE 2GJ 2 AE 1 1 1 PL 1 TL IES-2. Ans. (c) Internal strain energy = Pδ + T θ = P + T 2 2 2 AE 2 GJ (a)

T L P L + 2GJ AE

2

(b)

2

(d)

T L P2 L + GJ AE

IES-3.

Strain energy stored in a body of volume V subjected to uniform stress s is: [IES-2002] (c) sV2/E (d) s2V/2E (a) s E / V (b) sE2/ V IES-3. Ans. (d) IES-4.

A bar of length L and of uniform cross-sectional area A and second moment of area ‘I’ is subjected to a pull P. If Young's modulus of elasticity of the bar material is E, the expression for strain energy stored in the bar will be: [IES-1999]

PL2 P2L (d) AE AE 1 1 ⎛P⎞ ⎛P L⎞ PL2 IES-4. Ans. (a) Strain energy = x stress x strain x volume = × ⎜ ⎟ × ⎜ . ⎟ × ( AL ) = 2 2 ⎝ A⎠ ⎝ A E ⎠ 2 AE (a)

IES-5.

P2L 2AE

PL2 2EI

(b)

(c)

Which one of the following gives the correct expression for strain energy stored in a beam of length L and of uniform cross-section having moment of inertia ‘I’ and subjected to constant bending moment M? [IES-1997]

(a ) IES-5. Ans. (d)

ML EI

(b)

ML 2 EI

(c)

M 2L EI

M 2L 2 EI

(d)

2

IES-6.

A steel specimen 150 mm in cross-section stretches by 0·05 mm over a 50 mm gauge length under an axial load of 30 kN. What is the strain energy stored in the specimen? (Take E = 200 GPa) [IES-2009] (a) 0.75 N-m (b) 1.00 N-m (c) 1.50 N-m (d) 3.00 N-m IES-6. Ans. (a) Strain Energy stored in the specimen

30000 ) × 50 × 10 −3 ( 1 1 ⎛ PL ⎞ P2L = Pδ = P ⎜ = = = 0.75 N-m 2 2 ⎝ AE ⎟⎠ 2AE 2 × 150 × 10−6 × 200 × 109 2

IES-7.

What is the expression for the strain energy due to bending of a cantilever beam (length L. modulus of elasticity E and moment of inertia I)? [IES-2009] (a)

P 2 L3 3EI

(b)

P 2 L3 6 EI

(c)

P 2 L3 4 EI

(d)

P 2 L3 48EI

L

(Px)2 dx P2 ⎛ x 3 ⎞ P2L3 = IES-7. Ans. (b) Strain Energy Stored = ∫ ⎜ ⎟ = 2E 2EI ⎝ 3 ⎠ 0 6EI 0 L

IES-8.

The property by which an amount of energy is absorbed by a material without plastic deformation, is called: [IES-2000] (a) Toughness (b) Impact strength (c) Ductility (d) Resilience IES-8. Ans. (d) IES-9.

30 C 8 steel has its yield strength of 400 N/mm2 and modulus of elasticity of 2 × 105 MPa. Assuming the material to obey Hooke's law up to yielding, what is its proof resilience? [IES-2006] (b) 0.4 N/mm2 (c) 0·6 N/mm2 (d) 0·7 N/mm2 (a) 0·8 N/mm2

IES-9. Ans. (b) Proof resilience (Rp ) =

1 σ 2 1 ( 400 ) = × = 0.4N / mm2 . 2 E 2 2 × 105 2

Page 393 of 429

Chapter-14

Strain Energy Method

S K Mondal’s

Toughness IES-10.

Toughness for mild steel under uni-axial tensile loading is given by the shaded portion of the stress-strain diagram as shown in [IES-2003]

IES-10. Ans. (d) Toughness of material is the total area under stress-strain curve.

Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Strain Energy or Resilience IAS-1.

Total strain energy stored in a simply supported beam of span, 'L' and flexural rigidity 'EI 'subjected to a concentrated load 'W' at the centre is equal to: [IAS-1995] (a)

W 2 L3 40 EI

(b) L

IAS-1. Ans. (c) Strain energy =

W 2 L3 60 EI L/2

(c) L/2

M2 dx M2 dx 1 2 = × ∫0 2EI ∫0 2EI = EI × ∫0

W 2 L3 96 EI

(d)

W 2 L3 240 EI

2

W 2L3 ⎛ Wx ⎞ dx = ⎜ 2 ⎟ 96EI ⎝ ⎠

Alternative method: In a funny way you may use Castiglione’s theorem, δ =

∂U ∂U = ∂P ∂W

WL3 for simply supported beam in concentrated load at mid span. 48EI ∂U ∂U WL3 WL3 = ∂W partially integrating with Then δ = or U = ∫ ∂U = ∫ = ∂P ∂W 48EI 48EI W 2L3 respect to W we get U = 96EI

We know that δ =

IAS-2.

If the cross-section of a member is subjected to a uniform shear stress of intensity 'q' then the strain energy stored per unit volume is equal to (G = modulus of rigidity). [IAS-1994] (a) 2q2/G (b) 2G / q2 (c) q2 /2G (d) G/2 q2 IAS-2. Ans. (c) IAS-3.

The strain energy stored in the beam with flexural rigidity EI and loaded as shown in the figure is: [GATE-2008]

Page 394 of 429

Chapter-14

(a)

Strain Energy Method

P 2L3 3EI 4L

IAS-3. Ans. (c)

∫ 0

L

= 2∫ 0

L

= 2∫ 0

IAS-4.

(b) L

2P 2L3 3EI

3L

(c)

S K Mondal’s

4P 2L3 3EI

(d)

8P 2L3 3EI

4L

M 2dx M 2dx M 2dx M 2dx =∫ +∫ +∫ EI EI EI EI L 0 3L 3L

M 2dx M 2dx +∫ EI EI L

L 4L 2 2 ⎡ ⎤ ⎢By symmetry M dx = M dx ⎥ ∫ EI ∫ EI ⎥⎥ ⎢ 0 3L ⎣⎢ ⎦

3L

(Px )2 dx (PL )2 dx 4P 2L3 +∫ = EI EI 3EI L

Which one of the following statements is correct? [IAS-2004] The work done in stretching an elastic string varies (a) As the square of the extension (b) As the square root of the extension (c) Linearly with the extension (d) As the cube root of the extension

2⎤ ⎡ σ2 1 2 1 ⎢ (δl ) ⎥ = ∈ E = ⎢ 2 ⎥E IAS-4. Ans. (a) 2E 2 2⎢ L ⎥ ⎣ ⎦

Toughness IAS-5.

Match List-I with List-II and select the correct answer using the codes given below the lists: [IAS-1996] List-I (Mechanical properties) List-II (Meaning of properties) A. Ductility 1. Resistance to indentation B. Hardness 2. Ability to absorb energy during plastic C. Malleability deformation D. Toughness 3. Percentage of elongation 4. Ability to be rolled into flat product Codes: A B C D A B C D (a) 1 4 3 2 (b) 3 2 4 1 (c) 2 3 4 1 (d) 3 1 4 2 IAS-5. Ans. (d) IAS-6.

Match List-I (Material properties) with List-II (Technical definition/requirement) and select the correct answer using the codes below the lists: [IAS-1999] List-I List-II 1. Percentage of elongation A. Hardness B. Toughness 2. Resistance to indentation C. Malleability 3. Ability to absorb energy during plastic deformation D. Ductility 4. Ability to be rolled into plates Codes: A B C D A B C D (a) 3 2 1 4 (b) 2 3 4 1 (c) 2 4 3 1 (d) 1 3 4 2 IAS-6. Ans. (b) IAS-7.

A truck weighing 150 kN and travelling at 2m/sec impacts which a buffer spring which compresses 1.25cm per 10 kN. The maximum compression of the Page 395 of 429 spring is: [IAS-1995]

Chapter-14

Strain Energy Method

(a) 20.00 cm (b) 22.85 cm (c) 27.66 cm (d) 30.00 cm

IAS-7. Ans. (c) Kinetic energy of the truck = strain energy of the spring

⎛ 150 × 103 ⎞ 2 ⎜ ⎟×2 9.81 ⎠ 1 1 2 mv 2 ⎝ 2 = = 0.2766m = 27.66 cm mv = kx or x = 2 2 k ⎡ 10 × 1000 ⎤ ⎢ 0.0125 ⎥ ⎣ ⎦

Page 396 of 429

S K Mondal’s

Chapter-14

Strain Energy Method

S K Mondal’s

Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question IES 2009 Q.

Ans.

A close coiled helical spring made of wire diameter d has mean coil radius R, number of turns n and modulus of rigidity G. The spring is subjected to an axial compression W. (1) Write the expression for the stiffness of the spring. (2) What is the magnitude of the maximum shear stress induced in the spring wire neglecting the curvature effect? [2 Marks]

W Gd4 = X 8nD3 8WD (2) Maximum shear stress, τ = πd3 (1) Spring stiffness, K =

Conventional Question IES 2010 Q.

A semicircular steel ring of mean radius 300 mm is suspended vertically with the top end fixed as shown in the above figure and carries a vertical load of 200 N at the lowest point. Calculate the vertical deflection of the lower end if the ring is of rectangular cross- section 20 mm thick and 30 mm wide. 5

2

Value of Elastic modulus is 2 × 10 N/mm . Influence of circumferential and shearing forces may be neglected. [10 Marks]

Ans.

Load applied, F = 200 N Mean Radius, R = 300 mm 5

2

Elastic modules, E = 2 × 10 N/mm I = Inertia of moment of cross – section

I=

bd3 12

b = 20 mm

d = 30 mm

20 × ( 30 )

3

=

12

= 45,000 mm4

⇒ Influence of circumferential and shearing force are neglected strain energy at the section.

Page 397 of 429

Chapter-14

Strain Energy Method π

u=

S K Mondal’s

2

M Rd θ R for ≥ 10 2EI 4 0

M = F × R sin θ ∂M = R sinθ ∂F

π

∂u F R2 sin2 θ FR2 δ= =∫ dθ ⇒ ×π ∂F 0 EI 2EI π × 200 × ( 300 ) π FR2 δ= = 2EI 2 × 2 × 105 × 45000 2

δ = 3.14 × 10−3 mm.

Conventional Question GATE-1996 Question:

A simply supported beam is subjected to a single force P at a distance b from one of the supports. Obtain the expression for the deflection under the load using Castigliano's theorem. How do you calculate deflection at the mid-point of the beam? Let load P acts at a distance b from the support B, and L be the total length of the beam.

Re action at A, Re action at A,

Pb , and L Pa RB = L RA =

Strain energy stored by beam AB, U = Strain energy stored by AC (U AC) + strain energy stored by BC (U BC) a

2

2

b ⎛ Pa P 2b2 a 3 P 2b2 a 3 ⎛ Pb ⎞ dx ⎞ dx + = + x x . . ⎜ L ⎟ 2EI ∫0 ⎜ L ⎟ 2EI 6EIL2 6EIL2 ⎝ ⎠ ⎝ ⎠

=

=

2 2 P 2b2 a 2 P 2b2 a 2 P ( L − b ) b + = = a b ( ) 6EIL 6EIL 6EIL2

0

2

⎡⎣∵ ( a + b ) = L )⎤⎦

2 P ( L − b ) b2 ∂U 2P ( L − b ) b = = Deflection under the load P , δ = y = ∂P 6EIL 3EIL Deflection at the mid-span of the beam can be found by Macaulay's method. By Macaulay's method, deflection at any section is given by 2

Page 398 of 429

2

Chapter-14

Strain Energy Method P (x − a) Pbx Pb 2 L − b2 x − − 6L 6L 6 Where y is deflection at any distance x from the support. L At x = , i, e. at mid-span, 2 3 ⎛L ⎞ 3 P ⎜ − a⎟ Pb × ( L / 2 ) Pb 2 L 2 ⎠ EIy = L − b2 × − ⎝ − 6L 6L 2 6 3 2 2 2 Pb L b − P L 2 a − ( ) PbL or, EIy = − − 48 12 48 P ⎡ 2 3 y= bL − 4b L2 − b2 − ( L − 2a ) ⎤ ⎣ ⎦ 48EI EIy =

3

(

3

)

(

(

)

)

(

)

Page 399 of 429

S K Mondal’s

15. Theories of Failure Theory at a Glance (for IES, GATE, PSU) 1. Introduction •

Failure: Every material has certain strength, expressed in terms of stress or strain, beyond which it fractures or fails to carry the load.

Failure Criterion: A criterion used to hypothesize the failure.

Failure Theory: A Theory behind a failure criterion.

Why Need Failure Theories? •

To design structural components and calculate margin of safety.

To guide in materials development.

To determine weak and strong directions.

Failure Mode •

Yielding: a process of global permanent plastic deformation. Change in the geometry of the object.

Low stiffness: excessive elastic deflection.

Fracture: a process in which cracks grow to the extent that the component breaks apart.

Creep: a high-temperature effect. Load carrying capacity drops.

Failure Modes: Excessive elastic deformation 1. Stretch, twist, bending 2. Buckling 3. Vibration

or

Yielding

Fracture

• •

Plastic deformation at room temperature Creep at elevated temperatures Yield stress is the important design factor

• • •

2. Maximum Principal Stress Theory (W. Rankin’s Theory- 1850) – Brittle Material The maximum principal stress criterion: Page 400 of 429

Sudden fracture of brittle materials Fatigue (progressive fracture) Stress rupture at elevated temperatures Ultimate stress is the important design factor

Chapter--15 •

Theo ories of Fa ailure

S K Mondal’s

Ra ankin stated d max principal stress theory t as folllows- a matterial fails by y fracturing g when the la argest princiipal stress exceeds the ultimate u strrength σu in a simple tension test. That T is, at th he onset of frracture, |σ1| = σu OR |σ σ3| = σu

Crrack will sttart at the most highly y stressed point p in a brittle materrial when th he largest prrincipal streess at that pooint reachess σu

Crriterion hass good experrimental verrification, even though it assumess ultimate strength is sa ame in comp pression and d tension

Failu ure surface according g to maximu um princip pal stress th heory •

Th his theory of o yielding has h very pooor agreemen nt with experiment. How wever, the theory t has beeen used succcessfully forr brittle matterials.

Used to descrribe fracture of brittle materials m su uch as cast iron i

Liimitations o

Doesn n’t distinguissh between tension or co ompression

o

Doesn n’t depend on o orientatiion of princcipal planess so only ap pplicable to o isotropic materrials

Generalizatioon to 3-D stress case is easy: e

3. Maximum She ear Stress s or Stres ss differe ence theo ory (Guest’s or Tres sca’s Theory-1868)- Ductile e Material The Tressca Criterio on: •

Allso known as the Maxim mum Shear Stress S criterrion.

Yiielding will occur when the maximu um shear sttress reaches that which h caused yie elding in a simple tension n test. Page 401 of 429

C Chapter-15 •

Theorie es of Failure

S K Mo ondal’s

Recall that yield ding of a material m occu urred by slip ppage betweeen planes oriented at 45° to princcipal stressees. This shoould indicatee to you tha at yielding of a material depends on the maxiimum shear stress in the material rather r than the t maximu um normal stress. If σ 1 > σ 2 > σ 3 Then T σ1 − σ 3 = σ y

Failu ure by slip (yielding) ( occcurs when the t maximu um shearing g stress, τ max exceeds th he yield stress τ f as deterrmined in a uniaxial ten nsion test.

This theory givess satisfactory ry result for ductile ma aterial.

Failur re surface according a t maximu to um shear sttress theory y

4 Strain Energy 4. E Th heory (Ha aigh’s Theory) T The theory associated d with Haig gh T This theory is i based on the assump ption that sttrains are re ecoverable up u to the ela astic limit, and a the energy absorrbed by the material m at failure f up too this point is a single valued v function indepen ndent of th he stress system causin ng it. The strrain energy per unit vollume causin ng failure is equal to the e strain energy at thee elastic limiit in simple tension.

σ y2 1 2 2 2 ⎡ ⎤ U= σ 1 + σ 2 + σ 3 − 2μ (σ 1σ 2 + σ 2σ 3 + σ 3σ 1 ) ⎦ = 2E 2E ⎣ σ 12 + σ 22 + σ 32 − 2μ (σ 1σ 2 + σ 2σ 3 + σ 3σ 1 ) = σ y2

σ 12 + σ 22 − 2μσ μ 1σ 2 = σ y2

3 stress For 3D-

For 2D2 stress

5 Shear Strain 5. S En nergy The eory (Disttortion En nergy The eory or M Mises-Hen nky Theory y or Von-M Misses Theory)-Du uctile Ma aterial V Von-Mises C Criterion: •

Also known as th he Maximum m Energy of Distortion criterion c

Page ofncipal 429 Based on a more complex vieew of the rolle of the402 prin stresss differencess.

Chapter--15 •

Theo ories of Fa ailure

S K Mondal’s

In n simple term ms, the von Mises criterrion considerrs the diameeters of all tthree Mohr’ss circles as coontributing to t the characterization of o yield onse et in isotropiic materials.

W When the critterion is app plied, its rela ationship to the uniaxia al tensile yield strength is:

Foor a state off plane stress ( σ3 =0)

σ 12 − σ 1σ 2 + σ 22 = σ y2 •

It is often con nvenient to express e this as an equivalent stress, σ e: 1/2 1 ⎡ 2⎤ 2 2 ⎢⎣(σ1 − σ2 ) + (σ2 − σ3 ) + (σ3 − σ1 ) ⎥⎦ 2 1 ⎡ 2 2 2 2 2 2 ⎤ 1/2 or σe = 6 τ xy + τ yz + τ zx )⎥⎦ ⎢⎣(σ x − σ y ) + (σ y − σz ) + (σ x − σz ) + 6( 2

σe =

In n formulatin ng this failurre theory wee used generalized Hooke's law for an isotropicc material soo the theory y given is only appliccable to tho ose materials but it ca an be generalized to an nisotropic materials. m

Th he von Misees theory is a little lesss conservativ ve than the Tresca theoory but in most m cases th here is little difference in i their pred dictions of fa ailure. Mostt experimenttal results te end to fall on n or between n these two theories. t

It gives very good g result in i ductile material. m

6. Maximum Prin ncipal Strrain Theo ory (St. Ve enant The eory)

According g to this theeory, yieldin ng will occurr when the maximum principal sttrain just ex xceeds the strain at the tensile yield point in either sim mple tension n or compreession. If ε1 and ε2 are maximum and minim mum princip pal strains correspondin c ng to σ1 and σ2, in the lim miting case

Page 403 of 429

C Chapter-15

Theorie es of Failure

S K Mo ondal’s

7 Mohr’s theory- Brittle 7. B Ma aterial M Mohr’s Theo ory •

Mohrr’s theory iss used to prredict the fracture fr of a material having h diffeerent properrties in tensiion and comp pression. Crriterion mak kes use of Mo ohr’s circle

In Mohr’s circle, we note tha at τ depends on σ, or τ = f(σ). Note the t vertical line PC reprresents statees of stress on o planes with same σ but differing τ , which means m the weeakest plane e is the one with w maximu um τ , pointt P.

Pointts on the outer o circle are the weeakest planes. On thesse planes th he maximu um and minim mum princip pal stresses are sufficien nt to decide whether or not failure w will occur.

Expeeriments aree done on a given mateerial to dete ermine the states of strress that re esult in failurre. Each sta ate defines a Mohr’s ciircle. If the e data are obtained o froom simple tension, simple compression, and purre shear, the three resu ulting circless are adequa ate to constrruct an enve elope (AB & A’B’)

Mohrr’s envelope thus represents the locu us of all possible failuree states.

H Higher shearr stresses arre to the lefft of origin, since most brittle mateerials have higher stren ngth in compression

8 Comparison 8.

A comparison n among thee different failure f theorries can be made m by sup perposing th he yield surfa faces as shown in figu ure

Page 404 of 429

Chapter--15

Theo ories of Fa ailure

Page 405 of 429

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Chapter-15

Theories of Failure

S K Mondal’s

OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Maximum Shear stress or Stress Difference Theory GATE-1.

Match 4 correct pairs between list I and List II for the questions List-I List-II (a) Hooke's law 1. Planetary motion (b) St. Venant's law 2. Conservation Energy (c) Kepler's laws 3. Elasticity (d) Tresca's criterion 4. Plasticity (e) Coulomb's laws 5. Fracture (f) Griffith's law 6. Inertia GATE-1. Ans. (a) - 3, (c) -1, (d) -5, (e) -2 St. Venant's law: Maximum principal strain theory

[GATE-1994]

GATE-2.

Which theory of failure will you use for aluminium components under steady loading? [GATE-1999] (a) Principal stress theory (b) Principal strain theory (c) Strain energy theory (d) Maximum shear stress theory GATE-2. Ans. (d) Aluminium is a ductile material so use maximum shear stress theory

Shear Strain Energy Theory (Distortion energy theory) GATE-3.

According to Von-Mises' distortion energy theory, the distortion energy under three dimensional stress state is represented by [GATE-2006]

GATE-3. Ans. (c) Vs =

{

1 2 2 2 (σ 1 − σ 2 ) + (σ 2 − σ 3 ) + (σ 3 − σ 1 ) 12G

}

Where E = 2G(1 + μ ) simplify and get result.

GATE-4.

A small element at the critical section of a component is in a bi-axial state of stress with the two principal stresses being 360 MPa and 140 MPa. The maximum working stress according to Distortion Energy Theory is: [GATE-1997] (a) 220 MPa (b) 110 MPa (c) 314 MPa (d) 330 MPa GATE-4. Ans. (c) According to distortion energy theory if maximum stress (σt) then or σ t2 = σ 12 + σ 22 − σ 1σ 2 or σ t2 = 3602 + 1402 − 360 × 140 or σ t = 314 MPa Page 406 of 429

Chapter--15

Theo ories of Fa ailure

S K Mondal’s

Pre evious s 20-Y Years IES I Qu uestio ons Maxim mum Principa P al Stres ss The eory IES-1.

Match Liist-I (Theor ry of Failure) with Liist-II (Pred dicted Ratio o of Shear Stress to Direct Stress S at Yield Y Condition for Steel S Speciimen) and select the e correct answer using u the code given below b the Lists: L [IIES-2006] List-I List-II mum shear sttress theory y A. Maxim 1. 1·0 B. Maxim mum distortion energy th heory 2. 0·577 C. Maxim mum principa al stress theeory 3. 0·62 D. Maxim mum principa al strain theeory 4. 0·50 Codes: A B C D A C D B 4 3 (b b) 4 3 1 2 (a) 1 2 1 3 4 2 (d d) 4 2 1 3 (c) ns. (d) IES-1. An From a tension t tesst, the yield d strength of steel is found to be 200 N/mm m2. Using a factor of safety of 2 and app plying max ximum prin ncipal stresss theory of o failure, missible stress in the steel s shaft subjected to t torque w will be: [IIES-2000] the perm 2 (a) 50 N/m mm2 (b) 57.7 N/mm N (c) 86.6. N/mm2 (d) 100 N/mm2 ns. (d) For pure p shear τ = ±σ x IES-2. An IES-2.

IES-3.

A circular solid sh haft is sub bjected to a bending g moment of 400 kN Nm and a o 300 kNm m. On the basis of th he maximu um princip pal stress twisting moment of theory, the t direct stress is σ and acc cording to o the maximum shea ar stress theory, the t shear sttress is τ . The T ratio σ/ σ τ is: [IIES-2000]

(a )

1 5

ns. (c) σ = IES-3. An

(b)

(

3 9

16 M + M2 + T 2 π d3

Therefore

(c)

)

and τ =

16 π d3

(

9 5

M2 + T 2

(d)

)

11 6

σ M + M2 + T 2 4 + 42 + 32 9 = = = τ 5 M2 + T 2 42 + 32

A transm mission sha aft subjecte ed to bendiing loads must m be designed on the basis of [IIES-1996] mum normall stress theory (a) Maxim (b) Maxim mum shear stress s theory y (c) Maxim mum normal stress and maximum m sh hear stress theories t (d) Fatigu ue strength ns. (a) IES-4. An IES-4.

Design of o shafts ma ade of britttle materia als is based on [IIES-1993] (a) Guest''s theory (b b) Rankine’s theory (cc) St. Venantt's theory (d)) Von Mises theory ns. (b) Ran nkine's theorry or maxim mum princip ple stress th heory is mosst commonly y used for IES-5. An brittle ma aterials. IES-5.

Maxim mum Shear S s stress o Stress Diffference or e Theory IES-6.

Which on ne of the fo ollowing fig gures repre esents the maximum shear stress theory or Tresca a criterion n? [IIES-1999]

Page 407 of 429

Chapter-15

Theories of Failure

IES-6. Ans. (b) IES-7.

S K Mondal’s

According to the maximum shear stress theory of failure, permissible twisting moment in a circular shaft is 'T'. The permissible twisting moment will the same shaft as per the maximum principal stress theory of failure will be: [IES-1998: ISRO-2008] (a) T/2

(b) T

IES-7. Ans. (d) Given τ =

(c)

2T

(d) 2T

σ yt

16T principal stresses for only this shear stress are = 2 π d3

σ 1,2 = τ 2 = ±τ maximum principal stress theory of failure gives max[σ 1,σ 2 ] = σ yt = IES-8.

16 ( 2T )

π d3

Permissible bending moment in a circular shaft under pure bending is M according to maximum principal stress theory of failure. According to maximum shear stress theory of failure, the permissible bending moment in the same shaft is: [IES-1995] (a) 1/2 M

(

(b) M

16 M + M2 + T 2 IES-8. Ans. (b) σ = π d3

)

(c)

(

2M

(d) 2M

)

16 and τ = 3 M2 + T 2 put T = 0 πd ⎛ 32M ⎞ 32M 16M′ σ yt ⎜⎝ π d3 ⎟⎠ 16M or σ yt = and τ = ThereforeM′ = M = = = 2 2 π d3 π d3 π d3

IES-9.

A rod having cross-sectional area 100 x 10- 6 m2 is subjected to a tensile load. Based on the Tresca failure criterion, if the uniaxial yield stress of the material is 200 MPa, the failure load is: [IES-2001] (a) 10 kN (b) 20 kN (c) 100 kN (d) 200 kN IES-9. Ans. (b) Tresca failure criterion is maximum shear stress theory.

We know that,τ =

P sin 2θ P σ yt or P = σ yt × A or τ max = = A 2 2A 2

IES-10.

A cold roller steel shaft is designed on the basis of maximum shear stress theory. The principal stresses induced at its critical section are 60 MPa and - 60 MPa respectively. If the yield stress for the shaft material is 360 MPa, the factor of safety of the design is: [IES-2002] (a) 2 (b) 3 (c) 4 (d) 6 IES-10. Ans. (b) IES-11.

A shaft is subjected to a maximum bending stress of 80 N/mm2 and maximum shearing stress equal to 30 N/mm2 at a particular section. If the yield point in tension of the material is 280 N/mm2, and the maximum shear stress theory of failure is used, then the factor of safety obtained will be: [IES-1994] (a) 2.5 (b) 2.8 (c) 3.0 (d) 3.5 2

IES-11. Ans. (b) Maximum shear stress =

⎛ 80 − 0 ⎞ 2 2 ⎜ ⎟ + 30 = 50 N/mm 2 ⎝ ⎠

According to maximum shear stress theory, τ

IES-12.

For a two-dimensional state stress ( σ 1

=

σy 2

; ∴ F .S . =

280 = 2.8 2 × 50

> σ 2 , σ 1 > 0, σ 2 < 0 ) the designed values

are most conservative if which one of the following failure theories were used? [IES-1998] (a) Maximum principal strain theory (b) Maximum distortion energy theory (c) Maximum shear stress theory (d) Maximum principal stress theory Page 408 of 429 IES-12. Ans. (c)

Chapter-15

Theories of Failure

S K Mondal’s

Graphical comparison of different failure theories Above diagram shows that σ 1 > 0, σ 2 < 0 will occur at 4th quadrant and most conservative design will be maximum shear stress theory.

Shear Strain Energy Theory (Distortion energy theory) IES-13.

Who postulated the maximum distortion energy theory? (a) Tresca (b) Rankine (c) St. Venant IES-13. Ans. (d)

[IES-2008] (d) Mises-Henky

IES-14.

[IES-2008] (d) Mises-Henky

Who postulated the maximum distortion energy theory? (a) Tresca (b) Rankine (c) St. Venant IES-14. Ans. (d) Tresca Maximum shear stress theory → Rankine Maximum principal stress theory → St. Venant Maximum principal strain theory → Mises – Henky Maximum shear strain energy theory → IES-15.

The maximum distortion energy theory of failure is suitable to predict the failure of which one of the following types of materials? [IES-2004] (a) Brittle materials (b) Ductile materials (c) Plastics (d) Composite materials IES-15. Ans. (b) IES-16. If σy is the yield strength of a particular material, then the distortion energy theory is expressed as [IES-1994] (a) (b)

(σ 1 − σ 2 ) + ( σ 2 − σ 3 ) + (σ 3 − σ 1 ) 2

2 1

2

2

= 2σ y2

− σ 22 + σ 32 ) − 2 μ (σ 1σ 2 + σ 2σ 3 + σ 3σ 1 ) = σ y2

(σ 1 − σ 2 ) + (σ 2 − σ 3 ) + (σ 3 − σ 1 ) = 3σ y2 2 2 (d) (1 − 2 μ )(σ 1 + σ 2 + σ 3 ) = 2 (1 + μ ) σ y

(c)

2

2

2

IES-16. Ans. (a) IES-17.

If a shaft made from ductile material is subjected to combined bending and twisting moments, calculations based on which one of the following failure theories would give the most conservative value? [IES-1996] (a) Maximum principal stress theory (b) Maximum shear stress theory. (d Maximum strain energy theory (d) Maximum distortion energy theory. IES-17. Ans. (b)

Page 409 of 429

Chapter-15

Theories of Failure

S K Mondal’s

Maximum Principal Strain Theory IES-18.

Match List-I (Failure theories) with List-II (Figures representing boundaries of these theories) and select the correct answer using the codes given below the Lists: [IES-1997] List-I List-II A. Maximum principal stress theory

B. Maximum shear stress theory

C. Maximum octahedral stress theory

D. Maximum shear energy theory

Code: (a) (c) IES-18. Ans. (d)

A 2 4

B 1 2

strain

C 3 3

D 4 1

(b) (d)

A 2 2

B 4 4

C 3 1

D 1 3

Previous 20-Years IAS Questions Maximum Principal Stress Theory IAS-1.

For

σ1 ≠ σ 2

and σ3 = 0, what is the physical boundary for Rankine failure

theory? (a) A rectangle

(b) An ellipse

(c) A square

Page 410 of 429

[IAS-2004] (d) A parabola

Chapter-15

Theories of Failure

S K Mondal’s

IAS-1. Ans. (c) Rankine failure theory or Maximum principle stress theory.

Shear Strain Energy Theory (Distortion energy theory) IAS-2.

Consider the following statements: [IAS-2007] 1. Experiments have shown that the distortion-energy theory gives an accurate prediction about failure of a ductile component than any other theory of failure. 2. According to the distortion-energy theory, the yield strength in shear is less than the yield strength in tension. Which of the statements given above is/are correct? (a) 1 only (b) 2 only (c) Both 1 and 2 (d) Neither 1 nor 2

IAS-2. Ans. (c)

τy =

σy

3

= 0.577σ y

IAS-3.

Consider the following statements: [IAS-2003] 1. Distortion-energy theory is in better agreement for predicting the failure of ductile materials. 2. Maximum normal stress theory gives good prediction for the failure of brittle materials. 3. Module of elasticity in tension and compression are assumed to be different stress analysis of curved beams. Which of these statements is/are correct? (a) 1, 2 and 3 (b) 1 and 2 (c) 3 only (d) 1 and 3 IAS-3. Ans. (b) IAS-4.

Which one of the following graphs represents Mises yield criterion? 1996]

[IAS-

IAS-4. Ans. (d)

Maximum Principal Strain Theory IAS-5.

Given that the principal stresses

σ1 > σ 2 > σ 3

and σe is the elastic limit stress in

simple tension; which one of the following must be satisfied such that the elastic failure does not occur in accordance with the maximum principal strain theory? [IAS-2004] (a)

σe

σ ⎞ σ ⎛σ <⎜ 1 −μ 2 −μ 3 ⎟ E ⎝E E E⎠

(b)

σe

σ ⎞ σ ⎛σ >⎜ 1 −μ 2 −μ 3 ⎟ E ⎝E E E⎠

Page 411 of 429

Chapter-15 (c)

Theories of Failure

σe

σ ⎞ σ ⎛σ >⎜ 1 +μ 2 +μ 3 ⎟ E ⎝E E E⎠

(d)

σe

σ ⎞ σ ⎛σ <⎜ 1 +μ 2 −μ 3 ⎟ E ⎝E E E⎠

IAS-5. Ans. (b) Strain at yield point>principal strain

σe E

>

σ1 E

−μ

σ2 E

−μ

σ3 E

Page 412 of 429

S K Mondal’s

Chapter-15

Theories of Failure

S K Mondal’s

Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question ESE-2010 Q.

The stress state at a point in a body is plane with

σ 1 = 60N / mm 2 & σ 2 = −36 N / mm 2 If the allowable stress for the material in simple tension or compression is 100 N/mm2 calculate the value of factor of safety with each of the following criteria for failure (i) Max Stress Criteria (ii) Max Shear Stress Criteria (iii) Max strain criteria [10 Marks] (iv) Max Distortion energy criteria Ans.

The stress at a point in a body is plane

σ1 = 60 N / mm2 (i)

σ2 = −36 N / mm2

Allowable stress for the material in simple tension or compression is 100 N/mm2 Find out factor of safety for Maximum stress Criteria : - In this failure point occurs when max principal stress reaches the limiting strength of material. Therefore. Let F.S factor of safety

σ1 =

σ ( allowable ) F.S

F.S = (ii)

100 N / mm2 = 1.67 60 N / mm2

Ans.

Maximum Shear stress criteria : - According to this failure point occurs at a point in a member when maximum shear stress reaches to shear at yield point

γ max =

σyt 2 F.S

σyt = 100 N / mm2 γ max =

σ1 − σ2 2

=

60 + 36 96 = = 48 N / mm2 2 2

100 2 × F.S 100 100 F.S = = = 1.042 2 × 48 96 F.S = 1.042 Ans.

48 =

(iii)

Maximum Strain Criteria ! – In this failure point occurs at a point in a member when maximum strain in a bi – axial stress system reaches the limiting value of strain (i.e strain at yield point)

⎛σ ⎞ + − 2μσ 1σ 2 = ⎜ allowable ⎟ ⎝ FOS ⎠ FOS = 1.27

σ 12

2

σ 22

( μ = 0.3assume) (iv)

Maximum Distortion energy criteria ! – In this failure point occurs at a point in a member when distortion strain energy per unit volume in a bi – axial system reaches the limiting distortion strain energy at the of yield

Page 413 of 429

Chapter-15

Theories of Failure

⎛σ ⎞ σ12 + σ22 − σ1 × σ2 = ⎜ yt ⎟ ⎝ F.S ⎠

⎛ 100 ⎞ 60 + ( 36 ) − ×60 × −36 = ⎜ ⎟ ⎝ F.S ⎠ F.S = 1.19 2

2

S K Mondal’s

2

2

Conventional Question ESE-2006 Question:

A mild steel shaft of 50 mm diameter is subjected to a beading moment of 1.5 kNm and torque T. If the yield point of steel in tension is 210 MPa, find the maximum value of the torque without causing yielding of the shaft material according to (i) Maximum principal stress theory (ii) Maximum shear stress theory.

We know that, Maximum bending stress (σb ) = and Maximum shear stress (τ ) =

32M πd 3

16T πd 3

Principal stresses are given by: 2

σ1,2

⎛σ ⎞ σ 16 ⎡ 2 2⎤ = b ± ⎜⎜ b ⎟⎟⎟ + τ 2 = ⎢M ± M + T ⎥⎦ ⎜ ⎝2⎠ 2 πd 3 ⎣

(i ) According to Maximum principal stress theory Maximum principal stress=Maximum stress at elastic limit (σ y ) or

or

16 πd 3

⎡M + M 2 + T 2 ⎤ = 210 ×106 ⎢⎣ ⎥⎦

16 3

π (0.050)

⎡1500 + 15002 + T 2 ⎤ = 210 ×106 ⎢⎣ ⎥⎦

or T = 3332 Nm = 3.332 kNm (ii ) According to Maximum shear stress theory σ1 − σ 2 σ y = 2 2 or , σ1 − σ 2 = σ y τmax =

or , 2×

16 M 2 + T 2 = 210 ×106 3 πd

or , T = 2096 N m = 2.096 kNm Conventional Question ESE-2005 Question:

Illustrate the graphical comparison of following theories of failures for twodimensional stress system: (i)

Maximum normal stress theory

(ii)

Maximum shear stress theory

Page 414 of 429

Chapter--15

Theo ories of Fa ailure

S K Mondal’s

Conventtional Que estion ESE E-2004 Question n: Answer:

State th he Von- Miises's theor ry. Also giv ve the natur rally expre ession. Accordin ng to this theory t yielding would occur o when total distorrtion energy y absorbed per unitt volume du ue to applied d loads exce eeds the distortion enerrgy absorbed d per unit volume at the tensiile yield poin nt. The failu ure criterion is 2

2

2

(σ1 − σ 2 ) + (σ 2 − σ 3 ) + (σ 3 − σ1) = 2σ 2y [sym mbols has usual u meaning] Conventtional Que estion ESE E-2002 Question n:

Derive an expresssion for the distortiion energy y per unit volume fo or a body d σ 2 with the subjectted to a uniform u str ress state, given by the σ 1 and t third princip pal stress σ3 being ze ero.

Accordin ng to this theory t yielding would occur o when total distorrtion energy y absorbed per unitt volume du ue to applied d loads exce eeds the distortion enerrgy absorbed d per unit volume at the tensiile yield point. Total strrain energy ET and stra ain energy for f volume change EV can be giiven as

Substitu uting strains in terms of o stresses th he distortion n energy can n be given ass

At the tensile t yield point, σ1 = σy , σ2 = σ3 = 0 which gives

The faillure criterion n is thus obttained by eq quating Ed and Edy , whiich gives

In a 2-D D situation iff σ3 = 0, the criterion red duces to

Conventtional Que estion GAT TE-1996 Question n:

A cube of 5mm sid de is loaded as shown n in figure below. (i) Determine the t princip pal stresses s σ1 ,σ2 ,σ3 . (ii)

Will the cub W be yield if the yield strength s off the mater rial is 70 MPa? M Use Von-Mises th heory. Page 415 of 429 Yield sttrength of th he material σet = 70 MPa a = 70 MN/m m2 or 70 N/m mm2.

Chapter-15

Theories of Failure

S K Mondal’s

(i) Principal stress σ1, σ2 , σ3 : 2000 = 80 N/mm2 ; 5×5 500 σz = = 20 N/mm2 ; 5×5 σx =

σ=

σ x + σy 2

= 60 ±

1000 = 40 N/mm2 5×5 800 = = 32 N/mm2 5×5

σy = τ xy

⎛ σ x − σ y ⎞⎟ 80 + 40 2 ⎟ + τ xy ± ⎜⎜⎜ = ± ⎟ 2 ⎝⎜ 2 ⎠⎟ 2

2

⎛ 80 − 40 ⎞⎟ 2 ⎟⎟ + (32) ⎜⎜⎜ ⎝ 2 ⎠

2

(20) + (32) = 97.74, 22.26

σ1 = 97.74N/mm2 , or 97.74 MPa

and

σ2 = 22.96N/mm2 or 22.96 MPa σ3 = σz = 20N/mm2 or 22 MPa

(ii) Will the cube yieldor not? According to Von-Mises yield criteria, yielding will occur if 2

2

2

2

2

2

(σ1 − σ2 ) + (σ2 − σ3 ) + ( σ3 − σ1) ≥ 2σyt2 Now

(σ1 − σ2 ) + (σ2 − σ3 ) + ( σ3 − σ1) 2

2

2

= (97.74 − 22.96) + (22.96 − 20) + (20 − 97.74)

−− − (i )

= 11745.8 and,

2

2σyt2 = 2 ×(70) = 9800

−− − (ii )

Since 11745.8 > 9800 so yielding will occur.

Conventional Question GATE-1995 Question:

A thin-walled circular tube of wall thickness t and mean radius r is subjected to an axial load P and torque T in a combined tension-torsion experiment. (i) Determine the state of stress existing in the tube in terms of P and T. (ii) Using Von-Mises - Henky failure criteria show that failure takes place when

σ 2 + 3τ 2 = σ0 , where σ0 is the yield stress in uniaxial tension, σ and τ are respectively the axial and torsional stresses in the tube.

Mean radius of the tube = r, Wall thickness of the tube = t, Axial load = P, and Torque = T. (i) The state of stress in the tube:

Page 416 of 429

Chapter-15

Theories of Failure

S K Mondal’s

P Due to axial load, the axial stress in the tube σ x = 2πrt Due to torque, shear stress,

τ xy =

Tr Tr T = = 3 J 2πr t 2πr 3 t

π 4 (r + t ) − r 4 = 2πr 3t -neglecting t 2 higher power of t. 2 P T , σy = 0, τ xy = ∴ The state of stress in the tube is, σ x = 2πrt 2πr 3 t J=

{

}

(ii) Von Mises-Henky failure in tension for 2-dimensional stress is

σ02 = σ12 + σ22 − σ1σ2 σ1 = σ2 =

⎛ σ − σ y ⎞⎟2 2 ⎟ + τ xy + ⎜⎜⎜ x ⎜⎝ 2 ⎠⎟⎟

σx + σy 2 σ x + σy 2

In this case,

2

⎛ σ x − σ y ⎞⎟ 2 ⎟⎟ + τ xy − ⎜⎜⎜ ⎟ ⎜⎝ 2 ⎠ σ1 =

σx σ x2 2 + + τ xy , and 2 4

σ2 =

σx σ2 2 − x + τ xy 2 4

(∵ σy = 0)

2

2

2 2 2 ⎡σ ⎤ ⎡σ ⎤ ⎡ ⎤⎡ ⎤ σ x2 2 ⎥ ⎢ x − σx + τ 2 ⎥ − ⎢ σx + σx + τ 2 ⎥ ⎢ σx − σx + τ 2 ⎥ ∴ σ = ⎢⎢ x + + τ xy + xy ⎥ xy ⎥ ⎢ xy ⎥ ⎥ ⎢2 ⎢2 4 4 4 4 ⎢⎣ 2 ⎥⎦ ⎢⎣ ⎥⎦ ⎢⎣ ⎥⎦ ⎢⎣ 2 ⎥⎦ ⎡ σ2 σ2 ⎤ ⎡σ2 σ2 ⎤ 2 σ σ2 2 2 ⎥ ⎢ x + x + τ 2 + 2. σ x . σ x + τ 2 ⎥ = ⎢⎢ x + x + τ xy + 2. x . x + τ xy + xy xy ⎥ ⎥ ⎢4 4 2 4 4 2 4 ⎢⎣ 4 ⎥⎦ ⎢⎣ ⎥⎦ ⎡ σ2 σ2 ⎤ 2 ⎥ − ⎢ x − x − τ xy ⎢4 ⎥ 4 ⎣ ⎦

2

2 0

2 = σ x2 + 3τ xy 2 σ0 = σ x2 + 3τ xy

Conventional Question GATE-1994 Question:

Find the maximum principal stress developed in a cylindrical shaft. 8 cm in diameter and subjected to a bending moment of 2.5 kNm and a twisting moment of 4.2 kNm. If the yield stress of the shaft material is 300 MPa. Determine the factor of safety of the shaft according to the maximum shearing stress theory of failure. Given: d = 8 cm = 0.08 m; M = 2.5 kNm = 2500 Nm; T = 4.2 kNm = 4200 Nm

σyield (σyt ) = 300 MPa = 300 MN/m2

Equivalent torque, Te = M 2 + T 2 =

2

2

(2.5) + (4.2) = 4.888 kNm

Maximum shear stress developed in the shaft, τmax =

16T 16 × 4.888 ×103 = ×10−6 MN/m2 = 48.62MN/m2 3 3 πd π ×(0.08)

Permissible shear stress = ∴

Factor of safety =

300 = 150MN/m2 2

150 Page 417 of 429 = 3.085 48.62

Chapter-15

Theories of Failure

Page 418 of 429

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Page 419 of 429

16. Rive eted and Weld ded Joint J Th heory at a a Glance G e (for IES, I G GATE, PSU)

Page 420 of 429

Chapter--16

Riveted d and Welde ed Joint

Page 421 of 429

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Chapter-16

Riveted and Welded Joint

S K Mondal’s

OBJECTIVE QUESTIONS (GATE, IES, IAS) Previous 20-Years GATE Questions Failure of riveted joint GATE-1.

Bolts in the flanged end of pressure vessel are usually pre-tensioned Indicate which of the following statements is NOT TRUE? [GATE-1999] (a) Pre-tensioning helps to seal the pressure vessel (b) Pre-tensioning increases the fatigue life of the bolts (c) Pre-tensioning reduces the maximum tensile stress in the bolts (d) Pre-tensioning helps to reduce the effect of pressure pulsations in the pressure vessel GATE-1. Ans. (c)

Statement for Linked Answers and Questions Q2 and Q3 A steel bar of 10 × 50 mm is cantilevered with two M 12 bolts (P and Q) to support a static load of 4 kN as shown in the figure.

GATE-2.

The primary and secondary shear loads on bolt P, respectively, are: [GATE-2008] (A) 2 kN, 20 kN (B) 20 kN, 2kN (C) 20kN,0kN (D) 0kN, 20 kN

GATE-2. Ans. (a) Primary (Direct) Shear load =

4 kN = 2k N 2

GATE-3.

The resultant stress on bolt P is closest to (A) 132 MPa (B) 159 MPa GATE-3. Ans. (b) GATE-4.

(C) 178 MPa

[GATE-2008] (D) 195 MPa

A bolted joint is shown below. The maximum shear stress, in MPa, in the bolts at A and B, respectively are: [GATE-2007]

Page 422 of 429

Chapter--16

Riveted d and Welde ed Joint

(a) 242.6, 42.5 GATE-4. Ans. (a) GATE-5.

(b) 42 25.5, 242.6

(c) 42.5, 42.5

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

42.6, 242.6 (d) 24

A bracke et (shown in i figure) is i rigidly mounted m on n wall usin ng four rive ets. Each rivet is 6 mm in dia ameter and d has an efffective leng gth of 12 m mm. [GA ATE-2010]

Direct sh hear stress (in MPa) in the mostt heavily lo oaded rivet is: (a) 4.4 (b) 8.8 8 (c) 17.6 (d d) 35.2 GATE-5. Ans. (b)

F=

1000 = 250 N 4

and

z=

F 250 = = 8.8MPa A Ď&#x20AC; (6) 2 4

Efficiency of o a rive eted jo oint GATE-6.

If the ra atio of the diameter d o rivet holle to the piitch of rive of ets is 0.25, then the tearing efficiency e o the joint is: of [GA ATE-1996] (a) 0.50 (b) 0.7 75 (c) 0.2 25 (d) 0.8 87 GATE-6. Ans. (b)

Page 423 of 429

Chapter-16

Riveted and Welded Joint

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

GATE-7.

A manufacturer of rivets claims that the failure load in shear of his product is 500 Âą 25 N. This specification implies that [GATE-1992] (a) No rivet is weaker than 475 N and stronger than 525 N (b) The standard deviation of strength of random sample of rivets is 25 N (c) There is an equal probability of failure strength to be either 475 Nor 525 N (d) There is approximately two-to-one chance that the strength of a rivet lies between 475 N to 525 N GATE-7. Ans. (a)

Previous 20-Years IES Questions Failure of riveted joint IES-1.

An eccentrically loaded riveted joint is shown with 4 rivets at P, Q, R and S. Which of the rivets are the most loaded? (a) P and Q (b) Q and R (c) Rand S (d) Sand P

[IES-2002]

IES-1. Ans. (b) IES-2.

A riveted joint has been designed to support an eccentric load P. The load generates value of F1 equal to 4 kN and F2 equal to 3 kN. The cross-sectional area of each rivet is 500 mm2. Consider the following statements: 1. The stress in the rivet is 10 N / mm2 2. The value of eccentricity L is 100 mm 3. The value of load P is 6 kN 4. The resultant force in each rivet is 6 kN Which of these statements are correct? (a) 1 and 2 (b) 2 and 3 (c) 3 and 4 (d) 1 and 3 IES-2. Ans. (d)

Page 424 of 429

[IES-2003]

Chapter-16

Riveted and Welded Joint

S K Mondal’s

P = 2F2 = 2 x 3 = 6 kN and P.L = F1l + F1l = 2 F1l or 6 L = 2 × 4l = 8l L 8 = or l 6

Resultant force on rivet, R = F12 +F22 +2F1F2 cosθ =

( 4 ) + ( 3) 2

2

+ 2 × 4 × 3cos θ

= 5 kN

∴ Shear stress on rivet, τ= IES-3.

R 5×103 = =10 N/mm 2 Area 500

If permissible stress in plates of joint through a pin as shown in the given figure is 200 MPa, then the width w will be (a) 15 mm (b) 18 mm (c) 20 mm (d) 25 mm

[IES-1999] IES-3. Ans. (a) (w – 10) × 2 × 10-6 × 200 × 106 = 2000 N; or w = 15 mm. IES-4.

For the bracket bolted as shown in the figure, the bolts will develop (a) Primary tensile stresses and secondary shear stresses (b) Primary shear stresses and secondary shear stresses (c) Primary shear stresses and secondary tensile stresses (d) Primary tensile stresses and secondary compressive stresses

[IES-2000]

IES-4. Ans. (a) IES-5. Assertion (A): In pre-loaded bolted joints, there is a tendency for failure to occur in the gross plate section rather than through holes. [IES-2000] Reason (R): The effect of pre-loading is to create sufficient friction between the assembled parts so that no slippage occurs. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A Page 425 of 429 (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true

Chapter-16

Riveted and Welded Joint

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

IES-5. Ans. (a) IES-6.

Two rigid plates are clamped by means of bolt and nut with an initial force N. After tightening, a separating force P (P < N) is applied to the lower plate, which in turn acts on nut. The tension in the bolt after this is: [IES-1996] (a) (N + P) (b) (N â&#x20AC;&#x201C; P) (c) P (d) N IES-6. Ans. (a)

Efficiency of a riveted joint IES-7.

Which one of the following structural joints with 10 rivets and same size of plate and material will be the most efficient? [IES-1994]

IES-7. Ans. (b) IES-8.

The most efficient riveted joint possible is one which would be as strong in tension, shear and bearing as the original plates to be joined. But this can never be achieved because: [IES-1993] (a) Rivets cannot be made with the same material (b) Rivets are weak in compression (c) There should be at least one hole in the plate reducing its strength (d) Clearance is present between the plate and the rivet IES-8. Ans. (c) Riveted joint can't be as strong as original plates, because there should be at least one hole in the plate reducing its strength.

Assertion (A): In a boiler shell with riveted construction, the longitudinal scam is, jointed by butt joint. [IES-2001] Reason (R): A butt joint is stronger than a lap joint in a riveted construction. (a) Both A and R are individually true and R is the correct explanation of A (b) Both A and R are individually true but R is NOT the correct explanation of A (c) A is true but R is false (d) A is false but R is true IES-9. Ans. (c)

Page 426 of 429

Chapter-16

Riveted and Welded Joint

Previous 20-Years IAS Questions

S K Mondalâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s

Failure of riveted joint IAS-1.

Two identical planks of wood are connected by bolts at a pitch distance of 20 cm. The beam is subjected to a bending moment of 12 kNm, the shear force in the bolts will be: (a) Zero (b) 0.1 kN (c) 0.2 kN (d) 4 kN [IAS-2001]

IAS-1. Ans. (a) IAS-2.

Match List-I with List-II and below the Lists: List-I (Stress Induced) A. Membrane stress B. Torsional shear stress C. Double shear stress D. Maximum shear stress Code: A B C (a) 3 1 4 (c) 3 2 4 IAS-2. Ans. (c)

select the correct answer using the code given [IAS-2007] List-II (Situation/ Location) 1. Neutral axis of beam 2. Closed coil helical spring under axial load 3. Cylindrical shell subject to fluid pressure 4. Rivets of double strap butt joint D A B C D 2 (b) 4 2 3 1 1 (d) 4 1 3 2

Page 427 of 429

Chapter-16

Riveted and Welded Joint

S K Mondal’s

Previous Conventional Questions with Answers Conventional Question GATE-1994 Question:

The longitudinal joint of a thin cylindrical pressure vessel, 6 m internal diameter and 16 mm plate thickness, is double riveted lap point with no staggering between the rows. The rivets are of 20 mm nominal (diameter with a pitch of 72 mm. What is the efficiency of the joint and what would be the safe pressure inside the vessel? Allowable stresses for the plate and rivet materials are; 145 MN/m2 in shear and 230 MN/m2 in bearing. Take rivet hole diameter as 1.5 mm more than the rivet diameter. Given: Diameter of rivet = 20 mm Diameter of hole = 20 + 1.5 = 21.5 mm Diameter the pressure vessel, d = 6 m Thickness of the plate, t = 16 mm Type of the joint: Double riveted lap joint Allowable stresses: σ 1 = 145 MN / m2 ; τ = 120 MN / m2 ; σ c = 230 MN / m2 ⎡ 72 − ( 2 × 21.5 ) ⎤ 16 × 145 Strength of plate in tearing/pitch, Rt = ⎢ ⎥× 1000 ⎣⎢ ⎦⎥ 1000 = 0.06728 MN 2

π

⎛ 20 ⎞ ×⎜ × 120 4 ⎝ 1000 ⎟⎠ = 0.0754 MN 16 ⎞ ⎛ 20 × Strength of plate in crushing/pitch,Rs = 2 × ⎜ ⎟ × 230 ⎝ 1000 1000 ⎠ = 0.1472 MN

Strength of rivert in tearing/pitch,Rs = 2 ×

From the above three modes of failure it can be seen that the weakest element is the plate as it will have tear failure at 0.06728 MN/pitch load itself. Stresses acting on the plate for an inside pressure of pN/m2 is shown in figure. pd p×6 = = 187.5 p Hoop stress = 2t 2 × ( 0.016 ) Longitudinal stress =

pd p×6 = = 93.75 p 4t 4 × ( 0.016 )

Maximum principal stress acting on the plate = only ( i, e.187.5 p ) as there is no shear stress. or

or

pd 2t

0.06728 ≤ 145 ⎡ 72 − ( 2 × 21.5 ) ⎤ ( 0.016 ) × ⎢ 1000 ⎥ ⎣ ⎦ p ≤ 0.7733 MN / m2 or 0.7733 MPa Page 428 of 429 Rt 0.06728 η jo int = = = 0.4028 = 40.28% p.t.σ t ( 0.072 ) × ( 0.016 ) × 145

187.5 p ≤

Chapter-16

Riveted and Welded Joint

S K Mondal’s

Conventional Question GATE-1995 Question:

Determine the shaft diameter and bolt size for a marine flange-coupling transmitting 3.75 MW at 150 r.p.m. The allowable shear stress in the shaft and bolts may be taken as 50 MPa. The number of bolts may be taken as 10 and bolt pitch circle diameter as 1.6 times the shaft diameter. Given, P = 3.75MW; N = 150 r.p.m.; τ s = τ b = 50 MPa; n = 10, Db = 1.6 D Shaft diameter, D : 2π NT P= 60 2π × 150 × T E 3.78 × 106 = 60 3.75 × 106 × 60 or T = = 238732 Nm 2π × 150

π

Also,

T = τs ×

or

238732 = 50 × 106 ×

⎛ 238732 × 16 ⎞ D=⎜ ⎟ = 0.28 m or 290 mm 6 ⎝ 50 × 10 × π ⎠

16

× D3

π 16

D3

Bolt size,db : Bolt pitch circle diameter, Db = 1.6 D = 1.6 × 0.29 = 0.464 m Now, or or

T = n×

π 4

⎛D ⎞ db2 × τ b × ⎜ b ⎟ ⎝ 2 ⎠

π

⎛ 0.464 ⎞ db2 × 50 × 106 × ⎜ ⎟ 4 ⎝ 2 ⎠ db = 0.0512 m or 51.2 mm 238732 = 10 ×

Page 429 of 429