VALLEY'S 8.20.20 4C

Page 1

News Observer The Valley’s

Volume 35 Number 40

Serving the San Fernando Valley for Over 35 Years

Observer Group Newspapers of Southern California

Regulating Police Brutality Manny Otiko California Black Media Last week, the California Supreme Court ruled that Los Angeles County had to pay $8 million to the family of Darren Burley, an unarmed Black man who died under circumstances similar to George Floyd. In 2012, Deputy David Aviles placed his knee on Burley’s neck and back while restraining him. Aviles weighs 200lbs. Burley died 10 days later in the hospital. The violent murder of George Floyd in Minneapolis at the hands of police has inflamed the country and sparked protests in California and around the nation and the world. But the disproportionate use of excessive police force against Black men, too often ending up fatally, is not new to California. “From Rodney King in 1991 to Stephon Clark in 2018, California has a bad history with excessive use of force by police officers,” said Assemblymember Chris Holden (D- Pasadena) in a news release. In response to this, the California Legislative Black Caucus (CLBC) has authored a series of bills to reign in police violence. Those bills include: • AB 1196, which would ban the use of the chokehold. It passed in the State Assembly and is now under review in the Senate Appropriations Committee. • AB 1506. This would require police shootings to be investigated by a division of the Department of Justice. The State Assembly passed the legislation. It is currently under review in the Senate Appropriations Commit-

tee. • AB 2342. This would allow parolees to reduce their terms by attending college or volunteering. It passed in the Assembly and is now under review in the Senate Appropriations Committee. • AB 1022. This bill would require officers to report incidents of excessive force. The bill passed in the Assembly and the Senate Public Safety Committee. It is under review in the Senate Appropriations Committee. • AB 1185. This would require an oversight board for sheriff’s departments. It passed in the Assembly and is now under review in the Senate Public Safety Committee. California Attorney General Xavier Becerra praised Holden’s AB 1022, which is also called “the George Floyd” law. “Americans across the nation demand more accountability in our criminal justice system,” said Becerra. “It’s going to take sustained, thoughtful reform like Assembly Bill 1022 to help answer the call. At the California Department of Justice, we’re committed to partnering with our legislators and stakeholders across the state to help get the job done.” Becerra said he commends Holden and the bill’s other legislative supporters for getting it through the Senate Public Safety Committee. It’s time for important policies like a peace officer’s duty to intervene to be more than just recommendations. We’re ready for them to be the law of the land.”

Holden said Americans were shocked that officers didn’t intervene when they saw Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin choking the life out of Floyd. Instead, they formed a protective cordon around him and held off the crowd. “We were outraged when we watched the killing of George Floyd by a Minneapolis police officer from a knee to the neck,” said Holden. “Equally disturbing, was the lack of intervention from the police officers who witnessed a clear use of excessive force.”

Members of Congress Demand Answers About California

DMV $50M Personal Data Sale

Rocklin, CA / USA - March 25 2019: A California DMV sign in front of the Department of Motor Vehicles building in Rocklin. (Courtesy Photo)

By Manny Otiko California Black Media When news broke about Facebook collaborating with data mining companies during the runup to the 2016 presidential election, it may have broken the damn. Now almost four years later, more citizens are raising concerns about their data and who’s sharing it. Several members of California’s delegation to the United States Congress, including Rep. Barbara Lee (DCA-13), who is a member of the Congressional Black Caucus, are demanding information from the California Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV). They say the DMV has been selling California drivers’ personal data. According to Motherboard, a tech publication that’s part of the Vice network, the DMV generates about $50 million a year from selling drivers’ data. 

“We’re troubled by press reports about the California DMV’s disclosure of vast quantities of data which could enable invasive biometric policing and be a symptom of a deeper privacy malady. The California DMV receives more than $50 million annually from selling the personal information of Californians, according to press reports. The individuals whose data are being sold are reportedly not informed of this practice or given the opportunity to opt-out. What information is being sold, to whom it is sold, and what guardrails are associated with the sale remain unclear,” said the letter addressed to Steve Gordon, Director, California Department of Motor Vehicles. Eleven U.S.

Representatives from California signed the letter. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA-12) and Hon. David S. Kim, Secretary, California State Transportation Agency. 

The letter also addressed concerns about data possibly being shared with federal agencies such as Immigrations and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and the FBI. Since California allows undocumented immigrants to gain driver’s licenses, their personal data may be used by ICE to track and deport people in the country illegally. 

“What types of organizations has the DMV disclosed drivers’ data to in the past three years? In particular, has the DMV sold or otherwise disclosed data to debt collection agencies, private investigators, data brokers, or law enforcement agencies?” the letter inquired. 

According to a statement responding to the letter, the DMV says the money generated from the data sale helps offset some of the agency’s operating costs. 

The practice is not only confined to California. Both Virginia and Wisconsin DMVs also sell driver personal data. The practice is sanctioned under the Driver’s Privacy Protection Act (DPPA), which was passed in the 1990s. 

“In this day and age, unfortunately, government entities don’t resist the lure of selling Americans’ personal information for private exploitation. This problem will only get worse as cities, trying to be ‘smart,’ collect more information about what we do and where we go,” said Lee Tien, senior staff attorney at the Electronic Frontier Foundation, in an e-mail to Motherboard.

Shirley Weber’s CSU Ethnic Studies Bill is Now State Law

Assemblymember Shirley Weber, center, receives applause from fellow lawmakers during a floor session on June 10, 2020. Weber’s bill, AB 1460, was signed into law yesterday making ethnic studies courses a requirement at CSU. (Photo by Rich Pedroncelli, AP Photo)

Joe W. Bowers Jr. California Black Media Gov. Newsom signed AB 1460 into law on Monday, Aug. 17. The new state law requires California State University (CSU), the nation’s largest four-year public university system, to provide courses in Ethnic studies at each of its 23 campuses beginning with the 2021–22 academic year and requires CSU students to take a 3-credit course in Ethnic studies in order to graduate beginning in the 2024-

2025 academic year. The bill was introduced last year by Assemblymember Shirley Weber (D-San Diego), professor emeritus of Africana studies at San Diego State, on behalf of the California Faculty Association (CFA) and with support from the legislative ethnic caucuses (Black, Latino, and Asian Pacific Islander). It passed on Aug. 3 after legislators engaged in personal and passionate debates during committee hearings and on the floor of the Assembly and Senate as each expressed their perspectives on the pressing

need for our society to deal with its history of racial inequities.  Ethnic studies is an interdisciplinary study of race and ethnicity that gained acceptance nationally in universities following the 1960’s Black student uprisings. Research shows that students of color and white students benefit academically and socially from taking Ethnic studies courses. These courses can play an important role in building an inclusive multicultural democracy. According to Charles Toombs, CFA president and a professor of Africana Studies at San Diego State, Ethnic studies differs from other disciplines. It is crucial in its own right. Because of that, AB1460 specifies that CSU students take a course in one of the four historically defined racialized core groups: African American studies, Latino studies, Native American studies or Asian American studies. The bill states, “It is the intent of the Legislature that students of the California State University acquire the knowledge and skills that will help them comprehend the diversity and social justice history of the United States and of the society in which they live to enable them to contribute to that society as responsible and constructive citizens.” AB1460 passed despite opposition from CSU Chancellor Timothy White, the Academic Senate of the California State University, and the leadership at all 23 CSU campuses. Chancellor White asked the Executive Senate Committee at each CSU campus to write a letter of opposition when the bill was introduced. Allison Wren from CSU Academic Affairs Division presented CSU’s three main objections to AB 1460 at an Assembly Higher Education Committee Hearing. “First, we believe the legislature should not impose curriculum,” Wren said. “A legislative mandate, such as this will set the dangerous precedent of allowing the government to determine curriculum. And this does in fact threaten the academic freedom of our campuses.” “Second, the proposed bill is not necessary,” she continued. “We already have cultural diversity requirements on all 23 campuses. Many of these requirements are met by existing courses in Ethnic studies or courses and other departments such as anthropology, history, gender Women’s Studies, among many others.” “Finally, such a requirement could adversely impact our associate degrees for transfers programs. The bill could Continued on page A2

Free!

Thursday, August 20, 2020

VA Senator Charged with ‘Injury’ to Confederate Monument

PORTSMOUTH, Va. (AP) – A Virginia state senator has been charged with two felonies for her alleged involvement in the damaging of a large Confederate monument during protests in the city of Portsmouth, authorities said Monday. WAVY-TV reports Democratic state Sen. Louis Lucas faces charges of of conspiracy to commit a felony and injury to a monument in excess of $1,000. The monument stands on a site where slaves were once punished. It consists of a large obelisk and statues of four Confederate military personnel. During protests in June, heads were ripped off some of the statues while one was pulled down, critically injuring a demonstrator. Portsmouth Police Chief Angela Greene said during a Monday afternoon news conference that several people have warrants out against them. Besides Sen. Lucas, they include a local school board member as well as members of the NAACP and the public defender’s office. The chief also said that her department is asking for help in identifying several others and has released images to the public. WAVY was unable to reach Sen. Lucas for comment Monday, but the lawmaker has said previously that she did nothing wrong. Her attorney Don Scott told the station that he was just hearing about the charges. Confederate monuments around the country have fallen in recent years amid contentious debate over whether they are proud monuments to Southern heritage or hated symbols of racism and past slavery. The debate has escalated anew in the nationwide protests over police misconduct and racism after the death of George Floyd in Minneapolis.

Handcuffed Man Dies During Arrest by Deputies in CA GUERNEVILLE, Calif. (AP) – A man died after being shocked with a stun gun during his arrest by deputies who were responding to a domestic dispute in California, authorities said. The name of the man who died Saturday in the confrontation with Sonoma County deputies has not been released. As part of protocol for an officer-involved death, the Santa Rosa Police Department is investigating the incident while the Marin County coroner’s office is conducting the autopsy, the Press Democrat reported. Deputies were dispatched to the Hacienda Bridge area of Guerneville after a caller said two people were possibly in a fight inside a moving truck. A deputy went to a home after a nearby resident told him he heard a woman scream “somebody help me’’ from inside the house, the sheriff’s office said. A couple came out of the home with the woman asking for help while the suspect held on to her. When the deputy tried to separate the man from the woman, a fight began, authorities said. Another deputy saw the altercation and used his Taser to subdue the suspect, who continued resisting the deputies, the sheriff’s office said. After being placed in handcuffs, the man suffered a medical emergency, police said. The deputies began lifesaving measures and called for paramedics, who arrived and pronounced the man dead outside the home, the office said. Santa Rosa police Lt. Dan Marincik said his department will interview both deputies as well as review video footage from their body cameras as part of the investigation. He added that there were other witnesses. He said the man and woman knew each other, but he did not know the status of their relationship. The sheriff’s office said it will be doing its own administrative review to determine if the deputies followed its policies during the arrest.

Picture Perfect? Woman Receives ID with Photo of Empty Chair CENTERVILLE, Tenn. (AP) – Driver’s license photos aren’t always the best, but when a Tennessee woman received her new ID the picture was perfect _ for a furniture store. Jade Dodd renewed her license online and received it last week, but to her surprise, the photo wasn’t a picture of her. It only showed an empty chair. “The lady at the DMV did not really believe me when I was like `hey, I need my license fixed,’’’ Dodd said. “Then, she looked it up in the system and goes, `oh, I need my manager for this.’’’ The chair ended up being the focal point of the license because it was the last photo taken and saved to Dodd’s file, the Tennessee Department of Safety and Homeland Security told WKRN-TV. The photo was taken accidentally, the department said. Dodd said she wasn’t upset by the mistake. Instead, she said it lightened the mood amidst the coronavirus pandemic and provided her and her coworkers with a few laughs. “My boss thinks it’s funnier than anyone,” Dodd added. “I was at work Friday and he pointed to a chair outside of his office door and was like, `I thought this was you, I waved at it this morning.’” She posted the photo to Facebook on Aug. 6 and as of Wednesday, it had been shared more than 19,000 times and turned into several memes. Dodd received her new license Monday _ without the chair.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.