NYU’s Daily Student Newspaper
WASHINGTON SQUARE NEWS Vol. 41, No. 105
TUESDAY, DECEMBER 10, 2013
nyunews.com
Students reimagine digital classroom
Kimmel to house commuters during finals By TONY CHAU
Registration for an on-campus overnight accommodation program for commuters during finals week opened online last night, Dec. 9. The program, which will take place Dec. 15 to 20, will provide a maximum of 30 cots per night to students in the Commuter Lounge at the Kimmel Center for University Life. Reservations, which can be arranged free of charge on a Student Resource Center webpage, will be made on a first-come, first-serve basis and can only be made for the night before a student’s exam. Commuters are able to register online until Dec. 13 at 10 a.m. Because there will not be an official verification of a student’s exam schedule at the time of registration, the reservations will be made on an honor system. In the past, commuters were able to stay on campus during
COMMUTERS cont’d on PG. 4
By PATRICK ANKER
HANNAH LUU/WSN
NYU professors create robotic jellyfish Two mathematics professors at the NYU Courant Institute worked together to build a motorized, robotic jellyfish, which differs from traditional robot models, with stable flying capabilities.
STORY ON PAGE 5
Next semester, an independent digital classroom interface founded by a group of NYU students will provide an alternative to the NYU Classes system. The program, dubbed Kipin Hall, was only open to 2,000 students and 17 professors this semester in a closed beta, but will be accessbile by the community this spring. The website will pull information from the Albert database to create student schedules. All students will be able to connect to Kipin Hall by using their NYU email addresses. “Kipin Hall is a platform where students can connect with students, with professors and with clubs,” Kipin Hall co-founder and CAS sophomore Abhinay Ashutosh said. The founders said the interface will be more user-friendly to use than the current system. When a student logs into the site, he is met with a wall of posts, similar to
KIPIN continued on PG. 3
Fall in love with ‘Her’ for cast, story, cinematography By BEN MARQUES
VIA WIKIPEDIA.ORG
To put it simply, “Her” is the best film of the year. Spike Jonze’s not-so-futuristic tale of the love between a lonely man and his computer’s operating system is one of the most genuine and authentic romances ever made. Joaquin Phoenix plays Theodore Twombly, a writer at a company specializing in composing poetic, hand-written notes for all occasions. His divorce weighs heavily on his heart, and he struggles to connect with others in a seemingly utopian society. Then
he meets an operating system named Samantha, voiced with impeccable sincerity by Scarlett Johansson, and proceeds to fall in love with her. Every development in the story hits the right note. Working from his first entirely original screenplay, Jonze breaks free of his past work as a conduit for Charlie Kaufman. Their collaborations on “Being John Malkovich” and “Adaptation” were wildly successful and noteworthy, but something always felt missing. With “Her,” a notion of cohesion and individual artistic expression signals the solidification of Jonze
as a titan in cinema, and not just in the realms of skate and music videos. After appearing in Paul Thomas Anderson’s “The Master” last year, Phoenix and Amy Adams again display unbelievable nuance and authenticity that is uncommon in science fiction. As Theodore’s friend from college, Adams plays a mutually respectful and understanding confidante for the fragile protagonist. Both display a versatility refreshing versatility, reminding audiences of their standing as two of the most valuable actors working today. The performances are out-
standing from beginning to end, regardless of screen time — Olivia Wilde shines as an eccentric date, Chris Pratt is grounded as the goofy boss and Rooney Mara is devastating as Theodore’s bitter ex-wife. And then, there is Johansson, who has a voice that is easy to love. She commands attention scene after scene with the nuanced inflections of her voice. Samantha Morton was originally cast as Samantha and was on set throughout production in an isolated sound booth as well as working with Phoe-
HER continued on PG. 7
INSIDE THIS ISSUE
Exhibit tracks fashion trends
World Cup predictions
FIT’s “Trend-ology” exhibit uncovers the sociopolitical roots of style.
Germany and Argentina will most likely meet for a rematch in Rio de Janeiro this year.
STORY on PG. 8 RACHEL LIQUINDOLI/WSN
STORY on PG. 9
‘Christmas Law’ singles out holidays Legislation in Texas is biased against other smaller religions. STORY on PG. 11
VIA WIKIPEDIA.ORG
FIND THE WASHINGTON SQUARE NEWS ONLINE: FACEBOOK.COM/NYUNEWS | TWITTER — @NYUNEWS | INSTAGRAM — NYUNEWS | YOUTUBE.COM/NYUNEWS
2
WASHINGTON SQUARE NEWS | TUESDAY, DECEMBER 10, 2013 | NYUNEWS.COM
ON THE SIDE WSN THANKS ITS READERS, CONTRIBUTORS AND STAFF FOR A FANTASTIC FALL SEMESTER
COMPILED BY THE
WSN STAFF
WASHINGTON SQUARE NEWS Editor-in-Chief JONATHON DORNBUSH Managing Editor
JORDAN MELENDREZ Web Managing Editor
HANQING CHEN Creative Director
LYANNE NATIVIDAD Blog Editor
AMY ZHANG Special Issues Director
KALEEL MUNROE
SENIOR STAFF
news EMILY BELL, NICOLE BROWN,
MICHAEL DOMANICO arts JEREMY GROSSMAN features JONATHAN KESHISHOGLOU sports FRANCISCO NAVAS multimedia JONATHAN TAN copy CASEY DALRYMPLE social media GENTRY BROWN senior editors VERONICA CARCHEDI, TONY CHAU, DAN HINTON, MICHELLE LIM, STEFAN MELNYK, SAM RULLO, WICY WANG david DAVID LIN
DEPUTY STAFF
news KEVIN BURNS, NEELA QADIR,
BILLY RICHLING books/theater DYLAN JARRETT film ALEX GREENBERGER entertainment ISABEL JONES music JAKE FOLSOM the highlighter blog VALERIE NELSON features MARINA ZHENG beauty & style ARIANA DIVALENTINO dining DANIEL YEOM sports CHRIS MARCOTRIGIANO multimedia RACHEL KAPLAN, JOON LEE video ALEX LINZMEIER copy THOMAS DEVLIN social media SYMONE WILLIAMS pet OMAR JOHNSON, SHADOW ZHANG
OPINION PAGE opinion editor
RAQUEL WOODRUFF deputy opinion editors
EDWARD RADZIVILOVSKIY, PETER KEFFER
ADVERTISING BUSINESS MANAGER
ELLEN MCQUEEN
CIRCULATION MANAGER
CHLOE COFFMAN SALES MANAGER
ALISON LIZZIO
PROMOTIONS MANAGER
KALEEL MUNROE UNIVERSITY AND ALUMNI COORDINATOR
CLAIRE MAHANY
SALES REPRESENTATIVES
ARIANA DIVALENTINO, ETHAN JACOBS
ADVISING DIRECTOR OF OPERATIONS
NANCI HEALY EDITORS-AT-LARGE
JAEWON KANG, DAVID LIN, AMANDA RANDONE, EMILY YANG
About WSN: Washington Square News (ISSN 15499389) is the student newspaper of New York University. WSN is published Monday through Thursday during NYU’s academic year, except for university holidays, vacations and exam periods. Corrections: WSN is committed to accurate reporting. When we make errors, we do our best to correct them as quickly as possible. If you believe we have erred, contact managing editor Jordan Melendrez at managing@nyunews.com or at 212.998.4302.
GOT AN EVENT? EMAIL US AT AGENDA@NYUNEWS.COM OR TWEET US @NYUNEWS. GOT SOMETHING TO SHARE? EMAIL US AT TIPS@NYUNEWS.COM.
NYUNEWS.COM
NYUNEWS.COM | TUESDAY, DECEMBER 10, 2013 | WASHINGTON SQUARE NEWS
KIPIN continued from PG. 1
NYU students to launch alternative to NYU Classes online system in spring semester
JUSTIN LANIER/WSN
CAS sophomore Abhinay Ashutosh co-founded Kipin Hall with several other students. Facebook. Students can post questions for their professors or classmates to answer. The student postings can be sorted using hashtags. “This is a quick way for the professor to answer questions to students in a very public way,” Ashutosh said. “The advantage for professors is that they can answer a question just once, forever. If someone next year asks the same question, [the professor] doesn’t need to keep answering that question. They can just refer to the original.” The students can also choose to post questions anonymously. “It’s [hard] for the quiet kids to stand up and ask a
question they think is stupid,” Ashutosh said. Similar to NYU Classes, the page retains a navigation bar that lists the student’s classes and group pages. The page also includes a full roster, assignments and calendar of events. While the NYU Information Technology Services welcomed the Kipin Hall interface, the university has no immediate plans to intergrate the system with NYU Classes. “The group determined, with concurring input from the Student Technology and Research Committee of the Student Senators Council, that it is not presently a priority for ITS to integrate Kipin Hall into
NYU Classes,” said Marilyn McMillan, ITS Chief Information Technology Officer. Tech@NYU president and Stern senior Emanuel Hahn is familiar with the site and said he looks forward to the launch of Kipin Hall. “NYU Classes is very inefficient and does a poor job of meeting students’ needs,” Hahn said. “Kipin Hall can improve that tremendously because they are not bogged down by bureaucracy, but instead can adapt rapidly to what students want [or] need.” Patrick Anker is a staff writer. Email him at news@nyunews.com.
Langone vice president joins de Blasio staff By MICHAEL DOMANICO
Anthony Shorris, NYU Langone Medical Center’s chief of staff, senior vice president and vice dean, was selected to be New York City Mayorelect Bill de Blasio’s deputy mayor. “I am profoundly excited about the chance to support this mayor,” Shorris said when the announcement was made on Dec. 4. As deputy mayor, de Blasio said, Shorris will be charged with the day-to-day operations of the city. “This will be the person who will have my imprimatur to help make sure that our agenda is implemented each and every day in the government,” de Blasio said at the public announcement. Shorris’ resume includes working as the executive director of the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, the director of NYU’s Rudin Center for Transportation Policy and Management and a professor at the Wagner Graduate School of Public Service. Even though Shorris is leaving three positions at Langone, there has been no update on who will succeed him in these positions. Several of his colleagues wished him well on his new role in city government. “Tony is a great colleague, mentor and friend. He will be sorely missed,” Langone CFO Michael Burke said. “Our loss is the city’s gain.” Richard Donoghue, Langone’s senior vice president for strategy, planning and business development, said he worked closely with Shorris as a member of the executive leadership. “[Shorris] has a long history of
leadership roles in New York City government, which were beneficial in his role at NYU Langone,” Donoghue said. “His time at NYU Langone will have provided him with new experiences that will make him very effective as a deputy mayor.” Shorris, who has known de Blasio for 20 years, said he trusted de Blasio’s left-of-center politics and was optimistic about his plans. “I do think there are people who worried about it because they don’t know Bill as well as I did or have as much exposure to him over those years,” Shorris said at the event. “I think once they understand that our agenda is about a better, fairer, stronger city, they’ll be signing on with this mayor as they have with mayors past.” Michael Domanico is a news editor. Email him at mdomanico@nyunews.com.
VIA WIKIPEDIA.ORG
Anthony Shorris was selected to be Bill de Blasio’s deputy mayor.
Hackathon yields creative, user-friendly apps
By WARD PETTIBONE
The Kimmel Center Market Place was taken over by hackers for 24 hours beginning on Dec. 6. The Student Senators Council hosted the first Create a Better NYU Hackathon, a daylong event to encourage students, faculty and alumni to create apps, websites and data visualizations from public datasets to improve student life. “It’s a collaborative competition,” said Griffin Dooling, Stern senior and chair of the SSC’s Student Technology and Research Committee. “We’ve got a very passionate group of students.” Around 4 p.m., participants were allowed to access datasets from NYU dining, athletics, safety and others. Mike Jaoudi, a CAS junior computer science major, worked on a template app called NYU Clubs, which would provide club officers with a simpler way to create their own club apps. “Most club presidents don’t really code,” Jaoudi said. “So I’ll make it very easy, very simple to customize it and make it your own.” Although the rules of the hackathon allowed participants to work remotely, about 15 stu-
dents spent the night at Kimmel Center for University Life to keep working. Hackers were provided with dinner, a midnight snack and cots. The teams continued to work until the 3 p.m. submission deadline on Dec. 7. Juan Felipe Beltran, a senior visiting from NYU Abu Dhabi who spearheaded the hackathon, announced the winners. “What I keep forgetting is that a very small number of programmers can have such a humongous impact,” Beltran said. “The data is out there, the programmers want to do it. We just [needed] to bridge that gap.” CAS seniors Benjamin Xie, Chris Williams and Daniel
3
Padawer, won first place for BobStreet, an app that helps locate books in Bobst Library based on their call number. Padawer said they hope to continue working on the app in the future. Williams said the process of finding a book in Bobst was difficult, requiring multiple steps and the use of a physical map to determine where the book was supposed to be. “What we decided to do was to do that once and for all, for all of you, so you guys never ever have to do that again,” Williams said. Wayne Jones, an NYU-Poly alumnus, received second place for NYU Safe Walk, a map showing crimes that have occurred along a given route between
DANIEL COLE/WSN
Students take over Kimmel for the Create a Better NYU Hackathon.
places at and near NYU. Jaoudi’s NYU Clubs app won third place. Nick Jensen, an NYU alumnus who helped run the hackathon and who now works at Hashtag NYU, said he was amazed by the projects created at the event.
“This has been such an inspiring night and day, and morning,” Jensen said. Ward Pettibone is a contributing writer. Email him at news@nyunews.com.
4
WASHINGTON SQUARE NEWS | TUESDAY, DECEMBER 10, 2013 | NYUNEWS.COM
Students, university respond to Mandela’s death By NICOLE BROWN
The death of former South African president Nelson Mandela on Dec. 5 sparked a global discussion from TV network segments and newspapers to personal reactions on social media. Members of the NYU community mourned the leader’s death as well. NYU President John Sexton sent an email to the NYU community and attached his letter of condolence to current South African president Jacob Zuma. “His courageous struggle to bring rights, democracy, and human dignity to his fellow black South Africans made him one of the titans of our times,” Sexton wrote in the email. “He belonged to the world, to the people of Africa, and, as a recipient of NYU’s Presidential Medal in 2002, to the NYU community, too.” The Center for Multicultural Education and Programs also sent an email to students the following day, mourning the loss of Mandela. Steinhardt freshman Caitlin Venter, who is from South Africa, said she was pleased to see people around the world recogniz-
VIA FACEBOOK.COM
Nelson Mandela is known as a South African leader. ing him, the challenges he faced and his achievements. “A few nights ago I saw the Empire State Building lit up with the colours of the South African flag in remembrance,” Venter said. “That was amazing.” Marcella Runell Hall, a faculty affiliate of CMEP, visited the prison cell at Robben Island, South Africa where Mandela spent 27 years. “Few things in my life were as inspiring and eyeopening for me as going to Robben Island,” Hall said. “I can only hope to honor Mandela’s legacy in some small way by working in the realm of social justice and multi-faith leadership.”
Tisch sophomore Bill Chen, who lived in South Africa his whole life, said while it is good that people have reacted internationally to Mandela’s death, truly understanding his influence is unique to the people in South Africa. “I wouldn’t have been able to go to school there or live there [without Mandela],” Chen said. “I definitely would not be here if not for Nelson Mandela.”
A team at NYU’s College of Dentistry has developed a procedure that decreases the amount of time required to wear braces. The process is called micro-osteoperforation, which involves poking small holes into the patient’s gums using a special plastic drill called a Propel. The controlled injury allows porous bone tissue to form, and as a result, braces can move the teeth faster. “It is based on biology of bone,” said Cristina Teixeira, the department chair of orthodontics at the dentistry school. “It shows that minor injuries to the bone can facilitate bone turnover and can facilitate swift movement.” Teixeira led the team of 10 that developed the procedure, along with Mani Alikhani, director of the Consortium for Translational Orthodontic Research, a center for orthodontic scientists and clinicians. According to an article the team published in 2010 in the Journal of Dental Research titled “Cytokine Expression and Accelerated Tooth Movement,” the test study was first
conducted on 48 rats. The team’s research confirmed the process, which causes inflammation of gums, increases the rate of tooth movement. “This research started as an animal study two years ago,” Teixeira said. “So it’s actually very different from a lot of things that are happening in the clinic. We first did the animal study and then we start doing it in the clinic, and now we completed the clinical trial.” The article also addressed the possible side effects of the procedure. While microosteoperforation can accelerate bone remodeling and tooth movement, it can damage tooth and gum structure if not carefully performed. “It is important to mention that inflammation is a twosided sword,” the article said. But Teixeira said the procedure has worked successfully on several patients, which the team showed in “Effect of micro-osteoperforations on the rate of tooth movement,” an article published in the American Journal of Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics in November of this year. “We finally published the
Greenwich Hotel offers no vacancies for commuters, seek shelter in Kimmel finals week by booking a room in Greenwich Hotel residence hall. However, as vacancies in residence halls became scarce, that offer became unavailable starting in the fall 2012 semester, prompting the Commuter Student Council to seek an alternative. “When the facility continued to be unavailable, I wanted to do something about it,” said Nischala Meni, the vice president of advocacy of the Commuter Student Council who spearheaded the initiative. “Several commuter students who were aware of this facility also voiced their concerns, which only supported my decision.” LS freshman Kendi Tang said he appreciated CSC’s and university’s effort to provide an alternative. “I think it’s good that they’re even attempting to try to make up for it because they can see that it’s a struggle for commuters to be around, try to study and do well on their finals without having to worrying about commuting,” Tang said. Kimmel, which usually closes at 11 p.m. Monday through Wednesday and
1 a.m. on weekends, will stay open 24 hours for the overnight guests. Kimmel director Jonathan Ross said NYU Public Safety will staff the front desk with a security officer overnight, with a patrol officer making regular tours of the building. Associate director of the Student Resource Center Paulina Abaunza said two Commuter Assistants will be present in the Commuter Lounge each night to ensure cots are put away in the morning and students remain on the second floor throughout the night. CAS freshman Abdii Kassa, who commutes two-hour round-trip from Secaucus, N.J., said the program would ease the strain of commuting. “This is a good initiative to help commuters get on even footing with people who dorm,” Kassa said. “This [Commuter Lounge] is our home anyways, more than Greenwich Hotel. I feel we’re more at ease here.” Tony Chau is a senior editor. Email him at tchau@nyunews.com.
Additional reporting by Klein Aleardi, Kavish Harjai and Ann Schmidt. Nicole Brown is a news editor. Email them at news@nyunews.com.
College of Dentistry speeds up teeth movement, braces process By AFEEFA TARIQ
COMMUTERS continued from PG. 1
results of the clinical trial,” Teixeira said. “It was a controlled clinical trial [in which] we showed the accelerated movement. We’ve been doing this in the clinic for almost two years in our patients.” Orthodontics professor Rebecca Poling said she believes patients will respond well to this procedure. “One of the main concerns of patients is how long orthodontic treatment will take,” Poling said. “So doing accelerated treatment can reduce this treatment time by about half, which is significant. I think patients will want to have it done.” Stern freshman Joyce Wang, who currently uses Invisalign teeth aligners instead of traditional braces, said she sees the benefit of teeth being fixed faster. “If it is proven to be safe and healthy for the gums with no other risks, I think it is always good to have more products for consumers to choose from,” Wang said. Additional reporting by Klein Aleardi. Afeefa Tariq is a staff writer. Email her at news@nyunews.com.
FILE PHOTO BY RACHEL KAPLAN/WSN
The Commuter Lounge will host students overnight during finals week.
BLOGS
THE HIGHLIGHTER // UNDER THE ARCH // VIOLET VISION
FIND THEM AT NYUNEWS.COM
NYUNEWS.COM | TUESDAY, DECEMBER 10, 2013 | WASHINGTON SQUARE NEWS
5
FEATURES
EDITED BY JONATHAN KESHISHOGLOU FEATURES@NYUNEWS.COM
Student Internet Alliance fosters activism for freedom By BAILEY EVANS
With so many news headlines revolving around how much privacy the Internet offers users, some students are preparing to defend online privacy. Steinhardt and NYU-Poly senior Alec Foster has created an organization called the Student Internet Alliance, which seeks to advance the digital rights of students. “There are many ways in which Internet policy directly affects students,” Foster said. “Internet policy has been in the news in the past year more than ever before. It has dire needs for reform.” The Net Alliance, whose board of directors currently includes Foster, Steinhardt senior Eli Kurland and Gallatin sophomore John Curran, received a Google Grant on Oct. 11 to help finance the organization. Foster applied for the #freeandopen micro-grant, which was a competition among Google student ambassadors to
submit proposals for a project that shows why a free and open Internet matters to students. At NYU, the Net Alliance seeks to address some of issues students feel the Internet faces today as well as to create a template for other schools as they address student Internet concerns. “There are very few instances where you could identify the problems a demographic faces better than that demographic could identify it themselves,” Kurland said. “To give the demographic the resources to identify and articulate and actually solve their own problems is a main component of what [the Net Alliance] does.” Foster, who is also a member of the Student Senators’ Council Research and Development Committee, helped co-found the 24-Hour Hackathon held on Dec. 6. The Hackathon was a contest among NYU student developers to create an app that would benefit the university community. The Net Alliance is currently
FILE PHOTO BY DAVID LIN/WSN
Senior Alex Foster founded the Student Internet Alliance. creating an activist dashboard to facilitate some of the alliance’s larger goals by building a platform for activists to create campaigns for specific causes. “All of the issues that we’ll prioritize for the year will be chosen by students,” Foster said. “Through our activist
dashboard platform, students will be able to vote on what issues matter to them most in their community.” Although the Net Alliance has developed quickly, its goal is to create an enduring organization. “We’re hoping to create an organization and a movement
Courant professors create flying robot By NICOLE DEL MAURO
Most flying robot models currently base their design on insect-like wing motions, like those of bees, hummingbirds and moths. Instead of flapping up and down, insects sweep their wings forward, flip them over and bring them back the other way. Leif Ristroph, assistant professor of Mathematics at NYU’s Courant Institute, has designed and created a jellyfish-like robot with flying capabilities, along with Steve Childress, retired NYU Professor Emeritus of Mathematics, and the assistance of other professors in the Department of Mathematics. The robot, which Ristroph began building after receiving a postdoctoral fellowship from the National Science Foundation, consists of four Mylar plastic wings and is framed by carbon fiber rods. A tiny direct current electric motor spins a crankshaft around, pulls the wings in and out to make the robot fly. A part of the motor is the gearbox, which slows down power to flap wings 20 times per second, a frequency suitable for flight. Ristroph started the project about two years ago in the Courant Institute’s Applied Mathematics lab. He and Childress iterated many varying ideas and tested them in a trial and error process. Jun Zhang, professor of physics and math, and Mike Shelley, professor of math and neuroscience, contributed their ideas to assist the process. Zhang and Shelley are co-directors of the lab and Childress is a co-founder. Ristroph’s flying robot is the first to differ from insect-like models, instead using a closing and opening motion to move itself. Flight stability is a main advantage of the jellyfish design. From studying
their product, Ristroph discovered if their model is knocked over while in flight, perhaps from a gust of wind, it tends to come back upright. “[Our model] is a much simpler way to fly, where keeping upright is automatically taken care of by the aerodynamics and doesn’t need any sensors or any neural circuits or anything like that,” Ristroph said. Zhang explained how the robot’s method of flying differs from current flight technology. “Swimming and flying is a natural phenomenon, and we always find them fascinating. But real-world fliers like an airplane or a ship that involve a steady state approach, they don’t have many moving parts,” Zhang said. “[The model] is important in sense because we better understand nature.”
The robot’s flight was filmed using two high-speed cameras to capture all of its wing motions The team can reconstruct the robot’s 3-D flight path based on the two camera views of its flight. In the future, miniature fliers could be used for search and rescue, air quality monitoring or surveillance. Ristroph and Childress continue to analyze the experiment even though they built a functioning flying model. “Where we’d like to go next is actually understanding how it works. We don’t really understand the aerodynamics of it,” Ristroph said. “We got it to work, we don’t really know why in terms of the physics, so we’re still after that.” Nicole Del Mauro is a staff writer. Email her at features@nyunews.com.
HANNAH LUU/WSN
Leif Ristroph’s robot looks like a jellyfish, but it has wings and can fly.
that lasts much longer than our time here because these issues will keep coming up,” Curran said. “We’re hoping to create an organization that will continue to fight for the digital rights of students, so they can continue to maximize their potential for education.” Foster and the rest of the group do not just seek to aid students in the United States, but they also aim to address censorship issues students in foreign countries face when using the Internet. “When we had the idea for this organization, it was because it could adapt to the issues that have the most traction at any university or in any country,” Foster said. “Internet policy issues that affect us [in the United States] are different than those that affect students in Syria … We want to use the Internet to save it.” Bailey Evans is a staff writer. Email her at features@nyunews.com.
* *
* * * * * find us online
NYUNEWS.COM
**
6
WASHINGTON SQUARE NEWS | TUESDAY, DECEMBER 10, 2013 | NYUNEWS.COM
EDITED BY JEREMY GROSSMAN ARTS@NYUNEWS.COM
Musician JD Samson discusses career, creation of MEN By MALINA GULINO
JD Samson is considered an icon among feminists and in the queer community, but she has mixed feelings about the esteem she receives. “I was in the right place at the right time,” she said of her involvement with feminist electroclash band Le Tigre, which achieved considerable success before deciding to take an extended break in 2006. “I was this genderqueer performer and artist that kind of helped push along a new … revolution in identity,” Samson said. In an interview with WSN, Samson discussed her current project, the band MEN, which is performing in Brooklyn on Saturday, Dec. 14. Since forming in 2007, the band has addressed issues like trans representation, feminism and the arrest of Pussy Riot. “We think it’s so awesome that people can define themselves as whatever they want,” Sam-
son said about the band’s name. “And anyone can be a man if they want to be, and anyone can be anything … that’s really what MEN speaks to.” Samson calls herself a gender outlaw, someone whose gender expression or identity doesn’t fit with the traditional concepts of feminine or masculine. “Since I was a kid, I was kind of … outside the regular gender binary,” she recounted. “[My gender expression] was something that in the past I had to explain a lot to the press and just in my everyday life.” With the rise of Le Tigre, Samson became a hero to many people grappling with their gender identities. But in MEN’s second album, “Labor,” Samson attempted to focus on a different side of herself. “Part of the process in writing this last record was definitely about trying to think of myself more as a person and less as an object in this political moment,” she said.
“Labor,” a catchy, upbeat record Samson described as “juxtaposing dance music with intellectual lyrics,” proved a more personal album than MEN’s debut album, “Talk About Body.” The feminist activism present in all of Samson’s work is still there. But its approach is more grounded in Samson’s own self-identity. “I wrote a song about Caster Semenya,” Samson said referring to the South African Olympic runner who was subjected to gender testing. “But I wrote it in first person. It was interesting to force myself to write from the first person, even though I was writing about other people or other political ideas.” For Samson, who has spent much of her career with an activist identity, separating that persona from her artistic identity proved tough. “It was difficult for me, to find myself through writing because I was so used to writing for a community,” she said.
The figure on the album cover for “Labor” is a depiction of Samson. But in representing herself, Samson still wanted to retain a part of her identity as privately hers. “It’s hard to figure out how
to write a record that speaks to yourself but doesn’t give too much away,” she said. Malina Gulino is a contributing writer. Email her at music@nyunews.com.
VIA MENMAKEMUSIC.COM
JD Samson’s MEN released their album “Labor” earlier this fall.
Christmas album comes with Grande promise By ERICA GONZALES
INFORMING YOU FIRST @nyunews Washington Square News
@nyunews
NYUNEWS.COM
‘Tis the season for Christmas albums. Kelly Clarkson, Mary J. Blige and Jewel are just a few to release their spins on seasonal songs this year, but, unexpectedly, 20-year-old Ariana Grande seems to be receiving the most hype for her EP, “Christmas Kisses,” scheduled for release on Dec. 24. What is it that makes Grande’s EP such an anticipated hit? 1. She keeps listeners engaged with weekly singles. The bright-eyed songstress released the first track, “Last Christmas,” on Nov. 19, and has debuted a new song every Tuesday since — a la Justin Bieber’s “Music Mondays.” Grande has also debuted “Love is Everything” and “Snow in California,” both original songs. The fourth and final track, “Santa Baby,” is a duet with former “Victorious” co-star Elizabeth Gillies. 2. She translated an 80’s classic into a hip-hop number. Many a young artist has covered Wham!’s “Last Christmas” but none have done it quite like Grande. Her formula — add a soulfully melodic intro, write original verses and collaborate with “Victorious” co-star Leon Thomas III, who is credited as part of his producer group “The Ras-
cals.” Thomas gives the ‘80s hit a contemporary hip-hop vibe, with bouncy beats and background shouts of “hey” included. The result? One of the catchiest “Last Christmas” covers to date. 3. She keeps things warm and fuzzy.
“Love is Everything” is Grande’s call to action to give love on Christmas. “It’s time for us to all give something,” she begins over jingle bells and marching percussion, and is soon echoed line-per-line by a choir of children. By the bridge, she shows off her signature high notes and is later joined — after an emphatic key-change, of course — by a full, rich choir.
the two singers’ nearly identical range — whistle tones and all — they’ve also released Christmas albums, both consisting of original and traditional songs, at similar points in their careers. If Grande’s similarities to the “All I Want for Christmas Is You” singer stay true, perhaps one of the singles from “Christmas Kisses” will someday become a holiday classic. Erica Gonzales is a staff writer. Email her at music@nyunews.com.
4. She knows how to slow it down (and kills it). Grande’s “Snow in California” is a heartfelt R&B serenade to Santa, a plea to let it snow in California so her love, who is only staying for the holidays, can stay a little longer. This sweet, riff-laden ballad is sung over steady snapping beats — think of her American Music Award performance of “Tattooed Heart” — and bluesy harmonies. 5. She channels her inner Mariah. Comparisons to Mariah Carey may be reinforced with this Christmas album. Besides
VIA WIKIPEDIA.ORG
Ariana Grande will release a Christmas album on Dec. 24.
NYUNEWS.COM | TUESDAY, DECEMBER 10, 2013 | WASHINGTON SQUARE NEWS
7
ARTS Spend winter break binge-watching on classic TV By ISABEL JONES
Winter break is only a few stressful days away, and so too is the freedom to binge on Netflix. Depending on moods and interests, Netflix Instant’s offerings can please even the most discerning of customers. For a soapy departure from reality, check in with campy fan-favorite “Scandal.” Both the series’ plot and its burgeoning star, Kerry Washington, are responsible for carrying a massive and loyal audience. The show’s fans, selfproclaimed “Gladiators,” dominate the Twittersphere, live-tweeting every twist and turn. In the show’s short run it has inspired catchphrases, garnered an impressively increasing viewership and attached Washington’s face to the cover of every major magazine in the country. With the first two seasons available on Netflix, newcomers can easily see what all the hubbub is about. And if a passion for creator Shonda Rhimes comes as a result, there’s always nine seasons of “Grey’s Anatomy” to stream, too. A darker and much shorter binge-watch, the critically acclaimed miniseries “Top of the Lake” may be an unexpected favorite. In this New Zealand-set Sundance Original, “Mad Men’s” Elisabeth Moss stars as steadfast detective Robin Griffin. The performance has earned Moss countless accolades, including an Emmy nomination. “Lake” has also received recognition for its impressive supporting cast, which
includes Peter Mullan and Holly Hunter. On a lighter note, Netflix also carries many of TV’s best comedies. The service now carries every episode of “30 Rock.” For a good post-finals laugh, Tina Fey and Alec Baldwin deliver in spades. The Liz Lemon train may have departed last May, but the entirety of “30 Rock” is still worth watching, and with all seven seasons only a click away, who doesn’t “want to go to there?” Cult series “Chuck” is also available in its entirety. While it lasted for an impressive five seasons on NBC, “Chuck” never garnered a massive audience. But with plenty of charm thanks to a likable cast, pop culture references galore and an engaging central romance, this spy comedy with plenty of heart is well worth checking out. Of course, Netflix Original series are also a requisite watch. Audiences and critics alike have been sent into a frenzy by the unique and commercial-free shows. “House of Cards” and “Orange is the New Black” were released in February and July, respectively, but this hasn’t impacted their current popularity. With the many great series Netflix offers, a snowed-in Saturday shouldn’t be too harrowing. The break provides ample time to unwind and catch up, so bust out your prison slang or best suit and prepare to binge-watch. Isabel Jones is entertainment editor. Email her at entertainment@nyunews.com.
VIA FACEBOOK.COM
Tina Fey’s “30 Rock” is one of many great shows to watch on Netflix.
Documentary examines effects of nuclear impact By J.R. HAMMERER
The Atomic Age was launched into existence with the twin strikes at Hiroshima and Nagasaki, which makes it ironic because today Japan is one of the leading users of nuclear power. The tiny island has the third largest number of reactors in the world. Despite the trauma nuclear weapons wrought upon the nation, the last 40 years led to a frenzy of nuclear plant construction, bolstered by federal subsidies handed to tiny villages. The 2011 Japanese tsunami caused a meltdown at the Fukushima plant, resulting in a nuclear accident that reached the top level of the International Nuclear Event Scale. The meltdown leaft panic and mass evacuations in its wake. The only other accident to reach this level of international attention was Chernobyl. “Nuclear Nation,” a documentary by Atsushi Funahashi, focuses on the refugees forced to flee their homes in the town of Futaba following the 2011 meltdown. Abandoned by the Japanese government and torn up from the roots they planted, they were confined within the walls of an abandoned high school — most have been unable to return to their homes. The refugees recreated the town within the walls of the building, living on packaged sushi, and sleeping in sleeping bags on the floor. By the time the audience meets them, they’ve set up a hospital, welfare center and even a mayor’s office at the school.
VIA WIDEHOUSE.ORG
A cleanup crew observes the aftermath of a metldown. Months have passed since the meltdown, but they are living in a stasis. Public officials visit the refugees and military marching bands perform, but nowhere is there a sense that help is arriving. Even if they receive permits to go home, there’s nothing there. The tsunami leveled the town before the nuclear disaster, and rescuers could not search for missing family members before the evacuation was enforced. and the film shows this slow destruction of livelihoods. For instance, one local dairy farmer has the unenviable position of being forced to care for cows that will die of radiation instead of simply euthanizing them. The town soon rallies into a force to fight against nuclear power but, during the mobilization, they forget how they previously needed the plant to survive. One of Funahashi’s gently expressed ironies is that Futaba needed the
government subsidies from building more reactors to avoid bankruptcy. “Nation” sometimes diverges from this focus to examine the political factors swirling around nuclear power in Japan. Funahashi doesn’t editorialize, gloomy music notwithstanding. He just turns on his camera and records the strange tone of his environment, with cows roaming the roads and families living in school cafeterias. The wake of catastrophe is full of wreckage and the temporary forging of new lives. But with the wide presence of nuclear plants in Japan, it’s not unlikely such a disaster will happen again — potentially on a worse scale. As a warning, “Nuclear Nation” is unusually contemplative and asks the audience what happens after you’ve been uprooted once already? J.R. Hammerer is a staff writer. Email him at film@nyunews.com.
HER continued from PG. 1
Spike Jonze astounds audiences with visual, aural masterpiece ‘Her’ nix throughout the shoot. While editing, Jonze decided the performance was not what he had envisioned and decided Johansson would be better suited to the role. Morton still receives credit as a producer, but Jonze certainly made the right decision to switch actresses. In certain respects, “Her” is also one of the scariest films ever
made. Sitting in a theater and watching this film is a marvel, and it feels as though everyone is trying to laugh off the notion something like this could happen to him or herself. “Her” feels all too familiar, which is both terrifying and heartbreaking. The entire film is a technical and visual marvel. The subtlety and detail behind the production de-
sign, art direction and costuming is delightful, and Hoyte van Hoytema’s cinematography is crisp and funky. With humor and heart at every turn, it is safe to say nothing more satisfying than “Her” has been released this year. Ben Marques is a contributing writer. Email him at film@nyunews.com.
VIA FACEBOOK.COM
Joaquin Phoenix gives a stunning performance as the lead character Theodore Twombly.
8
WASHINGTON SQUARE NEWS | TUESDAY, DECEMBER 10, 2013 | NYUNEWS.COM
BEAUTY & STYLE
EDITED BY ARIANA DIVALENTINO BSTYLE@NYUNEWS.COM
Exhibit traces trend origins of past two centuries
By HANNAH TREASURE
From Rodarte’s clothing collaboration with Target to Maison Martin Margiela’s debut line for H&M, the phenomenon of what is trendy permeates stores and streets despite different socioeconomic standpoints. However, the visibility of trends is not just a modern concept — Fashion Institute of Technology’s new “Trendology” exhibit allows viewers to venture through over 250 years of trends, aiming to answer not only what is in style but, more importantly, why. The exhibit itself, curated by Emma McClendon and Ariele Elias, offers a visual experience like that of a runway — a long, narrow, dark hallway with the fashions illuminated on both sides. The displayed
clothing is arranged chronologically, beginning with the 1700s trend of incorporating the color yellow, sets an example for the globally minded motif of the exhibit. The exhibit explains how yellow was previously associated with heretics in Europe, but it became identified with the Emperor of China as trade expanded. By transforming the cultural meaning, wearers embodied this high-low adaptation — taking a specific high-class or designer trend and making it more accessible for the everyday consumer. The same frenzied expansion is explained throughout many of the exhibit’s examples, such as tartan print from King George IV’s visit to Scotland as well as 1920s embellishments and silk in Holly-
RACHEL LIQUINDOLI/WSN
Trend pieces were displayed in chronological order. wood dresses reflecting Art Deco in France. In addition to cultural collaboration, “Trendology” provides insight to the political undertones of certain fashions. The
1930s representation, a structured black suit, shows how clothing of the Great Depression aimed to provide working women with two uses for an outfit — professional enough
Warm winter looks suit every holiday party occasion By GIANNA COLLIER-PITTS
Before the year comes to a close, there is one thing left to be done — party. Whether with close family or dozens of friends, the party season has arrived in full force, and you’ll want to prepare for whatever the holiday calendar throws your way. The key features for any winter party look should be warmth and weather-resistance. Thankfully the trends this season will endure long nights out on the town or wherever you find yourself during the break. Fur and leather have remained integral staples of the Fall/Winter fashion season and can be implemented in more ways than simply donning a nice coat. Leather dresses and skirts have been featured in several collections including Saint Laurent and Alice + Olivia, and fur or faux-fur scarves are sure to add a cozy touch to a holiday outfit. Velvet and wool have also had a big presence this past season and can be made party-friendly by incorporating accessories that bring life to the signature fabrics. To complement the richness of velvet fabric, pair it with shimmery jewelry for a Hollywood glam look. With wool, add some glamour to its heat factor by spicing up a monochrome knit swing dress ($24.95, H&M) with berry-colored platforms and patterned tights. With regards to work- and school-related events, it’s im-
portant to maintain a level of professional conservativism in any ensemble, but keep it fun and youthful as well. Play around with lower hemline wool or leather pencil skirts of varying colors, which can be paired easily with a loosefitting blouse and metallic pumps to bring the holidays into a professional setting. For attending a more formal party, look for dresses that allow for movement and aren’t likely to weigh you down during the night’s events. Styles popular this season range from bright glitter and sequined frocks to sheer paneled A-line dresses, and almost nothing is off-limits in terms of cut and fit. A retail favorite for this holiday season is the slip dress, and the look can be amped up with a structured jacket and ankle booties with socks and sheer tights, or made casual via
layering with chunky knit sweaters. For those looking for a classic, seasonal party look, a black bodycon dress with sequins ($29.80, Forever 21) is the perfect mix of wintertime elegance and can be dressed up or down depending on the occasion. Keep in mind that following the trends is less important than dressing for your specific body type, so pick party looks that fit the season while also highlighting personal assets. Also, it is easy for holiday ensembles to take over their wearers, so remember to wear dresses and ensembles that showcase you as the statement and not just the clothes. After all, holiday fashion is about having fun, letting loose and transform your daily look into yuletide chic. Gianna Collier-Pitts is a staff writer. Email her at bstyle@nyunews.com.
VIA FOREVER21.COM
Fur items and shimmering dresses are perfect winter party attire.
for work but sleek enough for evening outings. In the representations for the late 1960s and early 1970s, as a backlash to capitalism and mass-produced industries, clothing began to incorporate tie-dye, folk art and hand-sewn patches — allowing even a counterculture to become trendy. “I think political connotations of clothing should be discussed more,” Gallatin freshman Felix Chan said after viewing this section of the exhibit. “There are such strong messages behind all of these fashions, even on streets today.” In the final section of the exhibit, picks from Rad Hourani’s 2013 collection, illustrated the current trend of unisex clothing. “I personally only wear men’s clothing, but I think
the meaning behind current, unisex apparel shows how we’re progressing,” said Justin Pituch, a Gallatin freshman who attended the exhibit. “If styles can intermix between sexes, maybe gendered roles in society can be interchangeable as well.” “Trend-ology” brings the real meaning behind our choice of cuts and colors of fabrics, proving the power behind trends. The exhibit shows how popularization of certain fashions brings to life a reflection of our society, a way to convey our messages without saying a word. The exhibit runs from Dec. 3 to April 30, and admission is free. Hannah Treasure is a staff writer. Email her at bstyle@nyunews.com.
NYUNEWS.COM
NYUNEWS.COM | TUESDAY, DECEMBER 10, 2013 | WASHINGTON SQUARE NEWS
9
SPORTS
EDITED BY FRANCISCO NAVAS SPORTS@NYUNEWS.COM
Predicting World Cup results: Who will come out on top? By FRANCISCO NAVAS
This draw for the World Cup is quite conservative by most standards, leaving the teams with the four best odds in the semifinals. Selecting two finalists is never easy. Odds put Brazil (4-1) and Argentina (5-2) in the finals in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil on July 13. I see Germany and Argentina instead, a rematch of multiple cups past. Brazil has the strongest back line of the four — Dani Alves, Thiago Silva, David Luiz, Marcelo. But the team as a whole is too young and inexperienced. Argentina has Lionel Messi and the rest of the world’s best forwards, but they suffer from a weak defense. Javier Mascherano cannot possibly carry that weight himself. The Argentines will have a relatively easy track until they meet Spain. But Spain is old, plain and simple. They insist on continuing their tiki-taka futbol, but Xavi Hernández, Andrés Iniesta and Xabi Alonso can no longer keep up. The team has the potential to play fast counterattack soccer with Jesús Navas and David Silva at the wings and Juan Mata and Santi Cazorla in the middle, but it seems like head coach Vicente del Bosque does not understand the need to alter the style of play. Of the four expected semifinalists, Germany boasts the best all-around
team. Graced with some of the best players from Bayern Munich and Borussia Dortmund, their counterattack, like a freight train, has torn through every defense they have faced. With speed and crisp passing, they will cruise straight to the final and possibly win the cup. Although ESPN’s Nate Silver projected Portugal and the United States to be within only one percentage point of a chance to book a place into the round of 16 (40 percent and 39 percent, respectively), this possibility relies on many unlikely variables. Logic puts Germany and Portugal through. Two other unpopular possibilities include Ecuador placing first in their group and Colombia eliminating Uruguay in the round of 16. Although Uruguay recently beat Colombia 2-0 in qualifying, Uruguay is inconsistent, and the match was closer than the score represented. With a whole six months to improve, Falcao and James Rodriguez’s chemistry will peak while Uruguay continues to age. As for Ecuador, speed kills. With Manchester United’s Antonio Valencia, their leading wing, they outrun most teams, and will outrun the lackluster defenders in Group E. Francisco Navas is sports editor. Email him at sports@nyunews.com.
BRAZIL CHILE
COLOMBIA URUGUAY ECUADOR
BRAZIL
NIGERIA
GERMANY
GERMANY
ECUADOR
COLOMBIA
BRAZIL
RUSSIA
GERMANY
GERMANY
GERMANY ARGENTINA
SPAIN
ARGENTINA
ITALY
SPAIN
SPAIN
CROATIA
ITALY
ARGENTINA
JAPAN
ARGENTINA
FRANCE
BELGIUM
BELGIUM PORTUGAL
Wrestling tightens hold on New York City area By SEAN BILLINGS
Until recently a stigma against inner-city wrestling has plagued the sport. But organizations have been working to improve its public image. Where once a void existed in the youth sports department of the New York City area, organizations like Beat the Streets stepped up to the challenge of providing positive opportunities for kids from a young age through high school to become involved in a sport and compete at a high level. “For a long time you had coaches in the city who were just collecting paychecks, now there has been a shift and people are really pushing to emphasize city wrestling,” said Mike Torriero, a coach at Beat the Streets, an organization started to revive the wrestling culture in and around the New York City area. There has even been an increase in the coverage of wrestling in the city. The organization Gotham City Wrestling looks to be the authority on all things wrestling in the city, certainly a boost to the culture of wrestling in the city. The increased attention onwrestling in New York City has occurred on nearly all levels. The college programs in the area in-
cluding Columbia University, Hoftstra University, Hunter College and NYU have all gained prominence on the national level for their competitive programs. Most recently, the second annual Grapple at the Garden took place, a college dual meet event that hosted some of the top college programs in the country including Cornell University and Illinois University, who are each currently in the top 10 in the country. Events such as this bring the spotlight to New York City for wrestling, and officials of Madison Square Garden have gone as far to say they are looking to host the Division I NCAA Championships in the near future. And this past May, a huge international event was held at Grand Central Station, dubbed The Rumble on the Rails, where the United States squared off against two worthy opponents from Team Russia and Team Iran. With such high-profile events on all levels, and with organizations looking to support the sport, New York can expect to become a hub for big-time wrestling in the near future. Sean Billings is a contributing writer. Email him at sports@nyunews.com.
10
WASHINGTON SQUARE NEWS | TUESDAY, DECEMBER 10, 2013 | NYUNEWS.COM
The New York Times Syndication Sales Corporation 620 Eighth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10018 For Information Call: 1-800-972-3550 For Release Tuesday, December 10, 2013
THE NEW YORK TIMES CROSSWORD & DAILY SUDOKU Crossword ACROSS 1 Fed. procurement overseer 4 Boito’s “Mefistofele,” e.g. 9 “Delta of Venus” author Nin 14 Giver of a hoot 15 Remove, as a spill 16 Bendel of fashion 17 *Migratory flock 19 Couldn’t stand 20 Small French case 21 Appear 22 Plenteous 23 Cuckoo in the head 25 Dada pioneer 28 Heart 29 Greek letter traditionally associated with Earth Day 30 *Singer Amy with six Grammys 33 Drought ender 35 Group of papers
36 *Pegasus, notably 39 Asian capital that was from 2004-07 home of the world’s tallest building 41 ___ Minor 42 *“Regardless of the outcome …” 44 News items often written years in advance 49 Directional suffix 50 D.C. V.I.P. 51 Dim sum dish 52 Yale Whale players 54 Blarney Stone home 57 Stat for A-Rod 58 Take care of a fly? 60 Witticism … or, literally, a description of the answer to each of the four starred clues? 62 Año’s start
ANSWER TO PREVIOUS PUZZLE O B G Y N
A E I O U
L U M P
O S S A
K I N G A R T H U R
M S R P
A M E R
Z U L U
I N U S E M A D D E N
B R A M A X I W I L T D E S C E R H R A A N I R A N L O G I E S A N M O N G A O M G E E N T N E S
K A L K A N
N C A A
S C O F C O L L I N D E S E X N T S C A T R O N I T A C I S H I N C A D E A R I P D O N I T O I S S I
F I N E
S E T S
A R O O
Z E S T
M A N D M
E S T O P
63 Facing the pitcher 64 Who said “The revolution is not an apple that falls when it is ripe. You have to make it fall” 65 “Hollywood Nights” singer Bob 66 Bronx Bombers 67 Le Mans race unit: Abbr.
Edited by Will Shortz 1
2
3
14
5
9
10
11
12
13
47
48
16 19 22
24
25
29
30 33
26
27
31
28 32
34
35
37
38
40
41
42
43
49
58
8
21
23
52
7
18
20
39
6
15
17
36
DOWN 1 Head toward the setting sun 2 Trade, as places 3 Attraction 4 “Yipe!,” online 5 Wordsworth words 6 Sporting weapon 7 Artifice 8 Hypothetical primate 9 “Yes … that’s the spot … yes!” 10 Approaching 11 Like a “Better active today than radioactive tomorrow” sentiment 12 “You can’t make me!” 13 Not the main action 18 Course-altering plan? 24 Brothers of old Hollywood 26 Auto take-backs 27 Mummy, maybe 30 Golfer Michelle 31 River through Pakistan 32 Training acad. 34 Like a ballerina 36 Manitoba’s capital
4
No. 1105
44
50
45
46
51
53
54 59
55
56
60
57 61
62
63
64
65
66
67
PUZZLE BY PAULA GAMACHE
37 Big W.S.J. news 38 Charlemagne’s domain: Abbr. 39 Plucks, as brows 40 Fleet operator 43 Like a relationship with a narcissist 45 Historical subject for Gore Vidal
46 “It’s me again” 47 Chinese martial art 48 Onetime colleague of Ebert 51 “___ Previews” (onetime show of 48-Down) 53 Not doubting
55 Journalist Skeeter of the Harry Potter books 56 Amazon.com ID 59 ___ favor 61 Amt. to the right of a decimal point
For answers, call 1-900-285-5656, $1.49 a minute; or, with a credit card, 1-800-814-5554. Annual subscriptions are available for the best of Sunday crosswords from the last 50 years: 1-888-7-ACROSS. AT&T users: Text NYTX to 386 to download puzzles, or visit nytimes.com/mobilexword for more information. Online subscriptions: Today’s puzzle and more than 2,000 past puzzles, nytimes.com/crosswords ($39.95 a year). Share tips: nytimes.com/wordplay. Crosswords for young solvers: nytimes.com/learning/xwords.
NYUNEWS.COM | TUESDAY, DECEMBER 10, 2013 | WASHINGTON SQUARE NEWS
11
OPINION
EDITED BY RAQUEL WOODRUFF OPINION@NYUNEWS.COM
UNIVERSITY
Old, tenured professors impair Core program By RAQUEL WOODRUFF
I still vividly remember my first day of classes at NYU four years ago. My first class was a physics lecture that fulfilled a science requirement. I sat down in a large raked lecture theater filled with hundreds of other students, curious to meet the professor who would be navigating the ominous course material for the next 15 weeks. I couldn’t believe what happened next. A professor shy of 90 years old descended down the aisle, managing six steps in six painful minutes. Over the course of my four years at NYU, I’ve encountered the same problem time and again with the Core Curriculum program — a professor who is too old, but tenured. While tenure provides benefits and stability to hard working educators, it also creates a costly and difficult hurdle for schools to remove underperforming teachers because of the lengthy legal process involved. It costs an average of $250,000 to fire a teacher in New York City. A study at Northwestern University found that non-tenure track faculty were more effective teachers than ten-
ured ones. This is not to say that all tenured professors are not great teachers. The problem is that tenured faculty are not required to retire because of their age. The median age of tenured faculty is approximately 55. And a Fidelity Investments survey found that “some 74 percent of professors aged 49 [to] 67 plan to delay retirement past age 65 or never retire at all.” When you put a professor well past 65 in front of a hundred students to instruct a course as broad and material-heavy as a Core Curriculum class, the results will likely not be overwhelmingly positive. The purpose of the Core is to provide a foundational, well-rounded academic experience to enrich and broaden a student’s overall intellectual outlook. Ideally, the Core offers a canon of essential skills to students’ personal and professional development. However, these merits cannot
be realized if teachers are unable to steer through a wide range of material with energy and clarity. The strongest parts of my education at NYU have been shaped by the courses with engaging professors — all of which fall within my field of study or my minor. In these areas, NYU has opened many intellectual and professional doors for me. On the other hand, the Core Curriculum program, exceptions notwithstanding, has largely been unprofitable in my experience. Many classes lack organization and structure, and they are led by professors who, while certainly intelligent and knowledgeable of the material, are too old to teach. I applaud the university for emphasizing a well-rounded education, but also ask that it reflects on the current state of professors in its Core Curriculum program. Keeping professors who are unable to educate detracts from a students’ academic discipline and is dishonest to NYU’s commitment to provide a balanced, quality education. Raquel Woodruff is opinion editor. Email her at rwoodruff@nyunews.com.
EDUCATION
Humanities should not be undervalued By CHRISTINA COLEBURN
An article published in the Dec. 2 edition of The International New York Times has rejuvenated discussions about the value of the humanities in the landscape of higher education. According to the piece, funding for humanities research in the United States has declined since 2009 and accounted for less than 0.5 percent of financing for science and engineering research developments in 2011. These austere statistics are not the only indicators of the perceived inconsequence of the humanities. Proposed political interference suggests some elected officials find such studies unimportant. Earlier in March, the senator from Oklahoma, Tom Coburn, submitted an amendment to the Continuing Appropriations Act of 2013 that forbade the National Science Foundation from funding political science research unless the project promoted economic or national security interests. Last year, a task force assembled by Florida Gov. Rick Scott said students majoring in the social sciences and humanities should pay higher tuition than those concentrating in the STEM — science, technology, engineering and
SUBMITTING TO
mathematics — fields. Although corporations, governmental entities and news media have lauded the STEM fields as the future of the U.S. economy, students can also stand to benefit from an education founded on the humanities. Subjects like literature, history and philosophy can teach cultural insight, social intelligence, ethical reasoning and historical clarity. These skills involve both analytical reasoning and critical thinking skills that, frankly, cannot be taught from STEM training alone. This is not to suggest extensive scientific or mathematical training is inherently detrimental. On the contrary, receiving an education with a STEM background can be both academically and economically worthwhile. Adopting this notion simply maintains that the humanities should be respected for their intrinsic qualities rather than be subjected to systematic devaluation. A governmental task force recom-
mending a comparative literature major should pay higher tuition fees than a chemistry major — for attendance at the same university — speaks to the one-dimensional, and often patronizing, shift the narrative about the humanities has taken. Rather than sustaining this tone of condescension, the dialogue should shift to one of respect. Despite innate differences, proponents of STEM could learn a great deal from the lessons offered by the humanities. By studying these allegedly soft subjects, STEM students could integrate insight about the human experience to complement their hard disciplines. While certain outlets have held that STEM fields are the future of the U.S. economy, they have failed to grasp a critical point. What America truly needs are talented, diligent and independent-thinking individuals who can find creative solutions in the 21st century. These students may originate from STEM fields, but others may easily be comparative literature majors. A humanities education has immense value in these respects, and it should be celebrated, not devalued. Christina Coleburn is a staff columnist. Email her at opinion@nyunews.com.
STAFF EDITORIAL
Texas law discriminates against religious minorities
Just in time for the holidays, Texas is reminding public schools and their teachers that wishing someone a “Merry Christmas” is protected under state law. The bill, also known as the “Merry Christmas law,” was signed by Gov. Rick Perry in June. The bill also safeguards “winter celebrations” from legal challenges, specifically naming Christmas and Hanukkah. Last summer, Perry stated “religious freedom does not mean freedom from religion” when explaining the motive of the legislation last summer. But he failed to recognize that religious freedom does not allow for the promotion of any certain religion. The law is often self-contradictory and highly vague, perhaps reflecting an intent to create a law that fits different interpretations. For instance, the law states that “school districts may educate students about the history of traditional winter celebrations,” yet it insists it “may not include a message that encourages adherence to a specific religious belief.” But, any historical account of traditional winter celebrations is necessarily steeped in religion. Worse still, the inclusion of specific religions in an educational context gives the beliefs credence and encourages adherence. In 1971, the Supreme Court of the United States introduced what is commonly referred to as the Lemon Test — a judicial tool detailing the requirements for legislation concerning religion. Within the test, the court held that “the government’s action must not have the primary effect of either advancing or inhibiting religion.” This requirement is clearly at odds with Texas legislation. In signaling a specific religious group as being in the possession of any right, lawmakers necessarily exclude members who are not part of that group. The bill allows school districts to display religious scenes such as “a menorah or ... nativity” as long as they do not “encourage adherence to a particular religious belief.” These scenes would have to represent either more than one religion or include one religion and at least one secular scene. Essentially, a school could have scenes and symbols from only one religion as long as they have the occasional snowman included. However, the bill explicitly protects Christmas and Hanukkah while ignoring other religious holidays. The Merry Christmas law, which at face value is meant to protect religious expression in schools, is inherently predicated on a bias against other religious groups. The bill awards special privileges to Judeo-Christian practices under vague and deceiving language like “winter celebrations,” extending preferential treatment to two specific religions in public schools and leaving other minority groups to identify their rights through the bill’s muddled logic. The selective endorsement of religious freedom is discriminatory and has no place inside the Texas public school system.
Email the WSN Editorial Board at editboard@nyunews.com. EDITORIAL BOARD: Raquel Woodruff (Chair), Edward Radzivilovskiy (Co-chair), Peter Keffer (Co-chair), Harry Brown, Marcelo Cicconet, Christina Coleburn, Omar Etman, Adam Fazlibegu, Nina Golshan, Nickhil Sethi
Send mail to: 838 Broadway, Fifth Floor New York, N.Y. 10003 or email: opinion@nyunews.com WSN welcomes letters to the editor, opinion pieces and articles relevant to the NYU community, or in response to articles. Letters should be less than 450 words. All submissions must be typed or emailed and must include the author’s name, address and phone number. Members of the NYU community must include a year and school or job title.
WSN does not print unsigned letters or editorials. WSN reserves the right to reject any submission and edit accepted submissions in any and all ways. With the exception of the staff editorial, opinions expressed on the editorial pages are not necessarily those of WSN, and our publication of opinions is not an endorsement of them.