Empire Clean Cities Fall 2013 Newsletter Stakeholder Spotlight Luke Tonachel Senior Vehicles Analyst, NRDC
Empire Green Fleets Increase Vehicle Efficiency, Reduce Fuel Consumption, & Save Money
Empire Green Fleet Supporters Support a green fleet today!
*Funding Opportunities $19 Million available through the New York Truck Voucher Incentive Program (NYT-VIP)
Upcoming ECC Events 2-day Odyssey Event • Mini-conference : October 9th, NYU Poly • Vehicle Showcase October 10th, Union Square
Industry Events • • •
2013 Green Fleet Conference Expo Natural Gas Technology Forum NGV Bridge Market Development Infrastructure Summit
Table of Contents
Welcome from Executive Director…………………………………………….. p. 3 Empire Green Fleet Program ……………………………………………………. p. 4 Empire Green Fleet Supporter Program…………………………………….. p. 8 Stakeholder Spotlight: Luke Tonachel………………………………………… p. 9 Platinum Members Highlight……………………………………………………… p. 11-13 Event Highlights …………………………………………………………………………. p. 14-15 Funding Opportunities……………………………………………………………….. p. 16 Upcoming Events……………………………………………………………………….. p. 17-18
ECC Fall 2013
Welcome Featuring engaging articles, information on industry trends, and events, Empire Clean Citiesâ€™ (ECC) Newsletter is an indispensable guide for our members, stakeholders, and partners committed to reducing greenhouse gas emissions and petroleum consumption. Published twice a year, the ECC Newsletter reaches 900+ people and keeps you up to date on industry trends. We would like to thank you for your continued commitment towards supporting Empire Clean Cities (ECC) mission to ensure clean air for future generations. We are committed to providing citizens and stakeholdersâ€™ access to reliable information about alternative fuels and advanced technologies through helping fleets receive funding through programs such as the $19 million New York Truck Voucher Incentive Program (NYT-VIP), and cutting edge programs such as, Empire Green Fleets. ECC will continue to strive to be a great forum for bringing people together to improve our regions air quality and inform citizens of the benefits of implementing policies and practices that reduce petroleum in on-road transportation through educational events such as National Plug In Day, Odyssey Day , and the CNG Case Study hosted by Phoenix Beverage. With the support of our stakeholders and citizens throughout the New York Metropolitan region we strongly believe we will achieve our goals. I encourage you to join our mission and become part of the solution.
Empire Clean Cities Executive Director, Christina Ficicchia
Executive Director, Christina Ficicchia & Board President Steven Levy at NYC Parks 5th Annual Fleet Demo Show
ECC Fall 2013
Empire Green Fleets
This June, Empire Clean Cities (ECC) announced the certification of its inaugural class of the Empire Green Fleets (EGF). ECC certified the public sector fleet of New York City Parks & Recreation as well as the City of White Plains and the corporate fleet of Down East Seafood. As part of the Empire Green Fleets program, ECC partners with fleet managers to track vehicle emissions and develop strategies to improve fleet efficiency, reduce fuel costs, and decrease a fleet’s environmental impact. ECC does this by collecting fleet vehicle information and measuring vehicle emissions compared to the average emissions of similar class vehicles. Fleets whose overall vehicle emissions are lower than expected are awarded points and can earn certification as an Empire Green Fleet. “Empire Green Fleets is an initiative we’ve been working on since 2012, gathering data from fleet managers to evaluate their emissions in GHG and criteria pollutants,” says Christina Ficicchia, Executive Director of ECC, “we are proud to certify our inaugural class who have reduced their emissions and increased their fleet efficiency by displacing a combined 100,000 gallons of petroleum this year.”
ECC Fall 2013
Down East Seafood
Down East Seafood: Down East Seafood is a NYC based seafood distribution company located in the Hunts Point neighborhood of the Bronx, NY. Down East was the first small business in the city to operate an all-electric delivery truck and delivers to all five boroughs, Westchester, Southern Connecticut, Long Island, and Northern New Jersey, they do this using their fleet of efficient vehicles including 2 Smith allelectric trucks. Down East received a three green apple certification in the Empire Green Fleet program, the highest certification possible, accumulating 191 total points. They achieved petroleum reductions of 21% and greenhouse gas emissions reductions of 17%. EGF measures five pollutants from all vehicles. Down East Seafood saw -25% reduction in Carbon Monoxide (CO), -36% reduction in Oxides of Nitrogen (NOx), 81% in Particulate Matter 2.5 (PM 2.5), and 54% in Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC).
Down East Seafood Emissions Reductions Pollutants CO (lb) NOx (lb) PM2.5 (lb) VOC (lb) Average
Percentage Reductions -25% -36% -81% -54% -49%
Check out http://nyc.missionelectric.org/ Mission Electric empowers you to pave the way for electric vehicles, and for a future of clean and efficient transportation in our cities.
â€œDown East appreciates the partnership we enjoy with the State of New York, the City of New York, and especially the Bronx for supporting us to get greener and receiving our green apples from Empire Clean Cities Empire Green Fleets program,â€? said Ed Taylor, CEO, Down East Seafood. ECC Fall 2013
NYC Parks: The NYC Parks & Recreation Department is the steward of approximately 29,000 acres of land which is about 14 percent of New York City. They operate over 5,000 individual properties; more than 800 athletic fields, nearly 1,000 playgrounds, and care for 1,200 monuments, 23 historic house museums, look after 650,000 street trees, and two million more in parks. The Parks Department has three guiding principles that they keep in mind: increased greening, improved access to recreational, and fitness opportunities, and using parks as a vehicle for community and economic development.
“Parks is a national role model in fleet sustainability and well deserving of this recognition” says New York City Chief Fleet Officer Keith Kerman, “Biodiesel, natural gas, hybrids, plug ins, right-sizing, fuel tracking. If you name the sustainable approach, you’ll find Parks leading the way.”
NYC Parks Emissions Reductions Pollutants CO (lb) NOx (lb) PM2.5 (lb) VOC (lb) Average
Percentage Reductions 3.22% -0.84% 3.49% -1.55% 1.08%
NYC Parks has made a commitment to operate a sustainable fleet that runs on alternative fuels. NYC Parks has a total fleet of 2,115 vehicles and was awarded 76 points out of a possible 200 to receive a two green apple certification in the Empire Green Fleet Program. NYC Parks managed reductions in their petroleum usage with an overall reduction of 54.83% and considerable reductions in their greenhouse gas emissions totals with a reduction percentage of -33.51%. NYC Parks achieved reductions of 3.22% in Carbon Monoxide (CO), -0.84% reduction in Oxides of Nitrogen (NOx), -3.49% in Particulate Matter 2.5 (PM 2.5), and -1.55% in Volatile Organic Compounds (VOC).
ECC Fall 2013
City of White Plains
The City of White Plains: White Plains, situated just 25 miles north of Manhattan, has impressive credentials as one of the top suburban office and retail centers in the nation. White Plains is the Westchester County Seat and the center for corporate, retail, and Federal, State, and County courts and offices. It offers a comprehensive, efficient, multi-modal public transportation system and their Mayor Thomas Roach has made a commitment to make White Plains a â€œGreenâ€? city. The City of White Plains acquired a total of 40 points to receive a certification of one green apple in the Empire Green Fleets program. The City of White Plains has taking responsibility to implement a greener fleet for their community, which has resulted in petroleum reductions of 23% and greenhouse gas emissions reductions of 12%. The City of White Plains achieved reductions of -2.7% in Carbon Monoxide (lb) (CO), -3.1% reduction in Oxides of Nitrogen (lb) (NOx), -1.7% in Particulate Matter 2.5 (lb) (PM 2.5), and -1.1% in Volatile Organic Compounds (lb) (VOC).
ECC Fall 2013
The City of White Plains Emissions Reductions Pollutants CO (lb) NOx (lb) PM2.5 (lb) VOC (lb) Average
Percentage Reductions 2.7% -3.1% -1.7% -1.1% 1.08%
CNG Rearloader, City of White Plaines
Mayor Tom Roach, "I am pleased to accept this award on behalf of the City of White Plains, which has a long history of seeking out and utilizing energy and fuel efficient vehicles. This award recognizes the City's efforts in this area."
Empire Green Fleet Supporter
In conjunction with our Empire Green Fleets (EGF) program this fall Empire Clean Cities will be launching another program called Empire Green Fleets Supporters. The Empire Green Fleets Supporter program was established to allow restaurants, retailers, and individuals the opportunity to demonstrate investment and support for a sustainable regional economy. Becoming a Green Fleets Supporter allows your business and certified Empire Green Fleets to earn recognition for the sustainable initiatives they’ve taken to clean our region’s air by supporting fleets operating on alternative fuels. There are three levels of Supporters
. Ambassador Level - The Ambassador Level is for businesses looking to gain recognition in the green economy and support the EGF fleets. A donation of $1,000 comes with the EGF Supporter decal, EGF Supporter tote bag, company logo displayed on the Empire Green Fleet website & homepage banner, your company logo displayed on all EGF promotional material, recognition at an Empire Clean Cities event, and an introduction at Empire Green Fleet events. Sustaining Level – The Sustaining Level is an opportunity for businesses to gain recognition. A donation of $350 provides the Sustaining level supporter with the EGF Supporter Decal, EGF Supporter tote bag, and company logo on the Empire Green Fleet website and homepage banner. Individuals – Any individual that is interested in supporting the program. To become an individual supporter a donation of $50 is required . Individuals will receive an EGF Supporter decal and tote bag.
ECC Fall 2013
Stakeholder Spotlight, Luke Tonachel
Luke Tonachel is NRDC's senior vehicles analyst in New York City and recently joined the Empire Clean Cities (ECC) Board of Directors. Since joining NRDC in 2004, Luke’s focus has been on reducing the environmental impacts of the world's transportation demands by adopting policies that develop and commercialize cleaner, more efficient vehicles, and non-petroleum fuels. Luke holds a bachelor’s degree in mechanical engineering from the University of Rochester and received his Masters in Public Policy from University of California, Berkeley in 2004. What interests you about becoming a member of the Empire Clean Cities Board of Directors? Empire Clean Cities is in a great position to help spur the broad adoption of clean energy, particularly in transportation. The health of New York’s citizens and the competitiveness of local businesses depend on moving to sustainable energy sources like efficiency and clean alternative fuels. Empire Clean Cities has connections with key industry stakeholders and early adopters that can show clean energy is a win-win, saving money for businesses while promoting a clean environment. I’m interested in helping Empire Clean Cities build on its past success and broaden its programs that spur clean energy deployment. What is NRDC working on in regards to alternative fuels and reducing the environmental impacts of the world’s transportation demands? For over thirty years, NRDC has been advocating for federal, state, and local policies that advance clean energy in transportation including mass transit, livable community development, vehicle efficiency and clean fuels. During the last few years, I have been focused on advancing strong fuel efficiency standards for cars and medium- and heavy-duty trucks. I am pleased with the progress now that new cars must reach the equivalent of 54.5 mpg by 2025 and the first-ever efficiency and carbon pollution standards for trucks has been adopted through 2018. Work on the next round of heavy-duty truck efficiency standards is starting up. In the Northeast, NRDC has also worked to advance a clean fuels standard that would reduce the carbon makeup of the transportation fuel pool over time. The performance-based standard would provide a strong market incentive (in the form of carbon reduction credits) to deploy clean alternative fuels. A similar program is already working in California. One alternative fuel that shows tremendous promise for displacing petroleum and cutting pollution is grid-supplied electricity. NRDC has been working with the New York Public Service Commission to ensure that electric vehicle owners get access to low-cost electricity by charging during off-peak periods, which is good for the grid and good for the environment.
ECC Fall 2013
Where do you see the alternative fuel sector heading? Clean alternative fuels will continue to grow under technological advances and strong policies. Petroleum is the source of energy for over 95 percent of our mobility, which gives the oil industry a virtual monopoly on the transportation sector. Policies, like a state or regional clean fuels standard, help level the playing field for emerging alternative fuels while also boosting the stateâ€™s economy. Instead of spending money to import petroleum from other parts of the country or other nations, spending on locally-produced clean alternative fuels will keep our fuel dollars in the local economy. What are the biggest hurdles you see when it comes to adopting policies that develop and commercialize cleaner vehicles and non-petroleum fuels? Changing the status quo can be difficult. Even as dependence on the volatile world oil market can wreak havoc on business operations, a new way of thinking is may be needed to adopt new, cleaner technologies. While new vehicles that are more efficient or use a cheaper, cleaner fuel save on operational costs, their up-front costs may be higher than conventional systems that are well-known. Businesses and consumers need the tools to take a long view on the benefits of cleaner technologies to justify their investments. Policies can also help bring down up-front costs through R&D programs and performance standards (for efficiency and low-carbon fuels) that provide certainty to suppliers and encourage them to invest in bringing new technologies to scale. How did you get involved with alternative fuels and why? One of my first experiences with a non-conventional transportation fuel was as a naval officer; my ship was powered by two nuclear reactors. Not being dependent on oil brought specific operational advantages. In on-road vehicles, clean alternative fuels can also provide big advantages in terms of higher driver satisfaction, lower costs and less pollution. Since coming to NRDC, I have realized that cleaning up the transportation sector to meet health, climate and economic goals requires a multi-prong approach that includes more transportation choices that reduce the need to drive single-occupancy vehicles, more efficient vehicles and clean fuels. We need them all. Clean alternative fuels are one important part of the puzzle for a clean energy future in transportation. What role do you see Clean Cities playing in the greening of our regions vehicles and policies? Clean Cities is a great forum for bringing together peopleâ€”particularly in businessesâ€”that want to improve their bottom line and recognize that environmental sustainability is part of economic sustainability. Through Clean Cities, companies can share best practices and lessons learned. Clean Cities can also play a role in recognizing leaders in clean energy, which will serve as case studies for others to rely on and promote broader adoption of clean energy. New York City and the Empire State have historically been home to leaders in clean energy, and continued growth in clean energy use here can strengthen policies and practices that can be examples for other states and the federal government.
ECC Fall 2013
Platinum Member NYC Parks Empire Clean Cities would like to thank the NYC Parks Department for the continued support as an Platinum Member and their sustainable efforts to make our region cleaner. Parks Vehicles (2,682 in total) Biodiesel 939 Hybrid 376 Electric 204 Compressed Natural Gas (CNG) 91 Propane 6 Solar 4 Current Alternative Fuel Units 1,620 (60 percent of the Parks fleet) Biodiesel (20%) • 148 Ford Diesel Pick Ups designed to run on B20 • 49 Light Towers for use in emergencies • 51 Tree Trimmers, Log Loaders, and other forestry vehicles Hybrid electric • 206 hybrid sedans including 198 Toyota Prius and 8 Honda Civic Hybrids • 112 Hybrid Ford Escapes and 18 Hybrid Toyota Highlander utilities • 23 Chevrolet Volts • 15 Hybrid medium duty rack trucks and dump trucks
Compressed Natural Gas (CNG) • 80 CNG Honda sedans and 7 CNG cargo vans • 1 CNG Tram and 3 CNG street sweepers Diesel Emissions Technology • 153 vehicles equipped with diesel particulate filters (DPFs) • 152 vehicles with selective catalytic reduction (SCRs) • 617 total vehicles with diesel emissions reduction technologies
Awards • 2013 Green Fleet Certification from Empire Clean Cities • 2011 Eye on Biodiesel Award presented February, 2011 • 2010, 2011 Government Green Fleet Award from 100 Best Fleets • 2010, 2011 100 Best Fleets in North America • 2008 Fleet of the Year (Vocational) from Fleet Owner Magazine • 2008 Greenest Fleet Award from National Association of Fleet Administrators (NAFA) ECC Fall 2013 11
All Electric • 151 GEM carts and 31 other electric carts • 15 All-electric sedans, including 9 Nissan Leafs and 2 Ford Focus EVs • 6 electric forklifts • 1 electric bus shuttle and 1 Navistar E-star van • 3 Solar powered electric carts and 1 solar light tower • Expanding electric vehicle infrastructure with 29 J1772 Level 2 charging stations
Platinum Member NYCDOT
Thank you New York City Department of Transportation for your continued support of Empire Clean Cities.
To check out more of what NYCDOT is working on visit them at http://www.nyc.gov/html/dot/html/home/home.shtml
NYCDOT at National PlugIn Day 2012 Times Square
ECC Fall 2013
ECC Fall 2013
CNG Case Study/Phoenix Beverages
CNG Case Study Phoenix Beverages On Thursday, August 8th, Phoenix Beverages and Empire Clean Cities hosted a Compressed Natural Gas (CNG) Case Study at Phoenix Beveragesâ€™ Brooklyn facility. Noel Jimenez, Director of Fleet Maintenance, shared his insights and lessons learned in front of a packed audience. The case study focused on the history of the businessâ€™ fleet and the fleets impacts on the community and its employees prior to CNG, the process of receiving funding for CNG trucks, and the return on investment on their fleet of CNG trucks. Phoenix Beverages introduced 17 CNG vehicles into their fleet and have made a commitment to their employees, the community, and the environment by doing so. By using CNG for 15% of their fleet, Phoenix Beverages was able to save $9,088.03 a year as compared to using diesel. These cost savings will continue to dramatically increase as the percentage of CNG vehicles in their fleet increase. CNG vs Diesel Cost Comparison Costs & Savings CNG Diesel Difference (savings)
Monthly $1,812.31 $2,569.65 ($757.34)
ECC Fall 2013
Quarterly $5,436.94 $7,708.95 ($2,272.01)
Per Year $21,747.77 $30,835.80 ($9,088.03)
Event Highlights: EVSE Workshop Event The New York State Energy Research & Development Authority (NYSERDA) sponsored a series of workshops throughout New York State to help facilitate the deployment of electric vehicles and associated charging infrastructure. The EVSE Workshop, hosted by the New York Power Authority (NYPA), provided concepts, challenges, and solutions, and best practices for the implementation of electric vehicle programs. These workshops were geared toward local community planners, building code officials, electrical installers, and electrical inspectors who wished to learn about electric vehicles and their associated charging infrastructure to be prepared for widespread rollout of electric vehicles throughout New York. At the workshop, attendees learned about the current electric vehicle landscape in New York State and projects that will expand the use of electric vehicles. Attendees heard from Brian Roy from Energetics, Ron Troyer, Westchester County IAEI, and Adam Lubinsky, PhD, AICP Managing Principal at WXY Architects + Urban Design, about planning considerations for EVs. Speakers discussed how electric vehicle infrastructure can be planned and constructed in each area and what best practices can help improve the chances for success with future projects. Best practices for zoning ordinances included: • • • •
Define what types of EVSE are allowable and appropriate in each land use type Request developers install EVSE or wiring with new developments or significant renovations Establish design criteria for EVSE installations Provide density bonuses for EVSE installations
ECC Fall 2013
Funding Opportunities Please contact us for more information on partnering and applying for funding. Christina@empirecleancities.org (212) 839-7728 New York Truck - Voucher Incentive Program (NYT-VIP) $19 Million Available Governor Andrew M. Cuomo on Friday August 9th announced a $19 million New York Truck Voucher Incentive Program to encourage the purchase of battery-electric commercial trucks as well as other energy-efficient transportation, including hybrid and compressed natural gas trucks. Read the Governor's press release by clicking here. Highlights: $19M available for the New York Truck Voucher Incentive Program Visit the NYT-VIP Website at https://truck-vip.ny.gov to: Determine Program Eligibility Evaluate Funding Options Download Program Applications Learn How to Apply Need application support? Contact the Voucher Processing Center Questions. Call Toll Free: (855) MYNYT-VIP or (855) 696-9884 or email info@MYNYT-VIP.com
PON 2755 Electric Vehicle-Enabling Technology Demonstration Program PON 2755, which seeks proposals for projects that research and demonstrate innovative technologies, policies, and systems that can help make electric vehicles more economically viable, reduce their impacts on the electric grid, and/or improve their (already significant) environmental benefits. Two categories of projects will be considered for funding: Feasibility and Market Research Studies Integration and Demonstration of New Technologies
Proposals are due to NYSERDA on October 22 at 5 pm. Questions can be directed to Adam Ruder at firstname.lastname@example.org or 518-862-1090 x3411.
ECC Fall 2013
Upcoming ECC Events
1ST ANNUAL CONFERENCE October 9, 2013 co-hosted by NYU-Poly Wednesday October 9th, 2013
Register Here! http://www.empirecleancities.org/events/odyssey-day-2013/ The 1st Annual Conference, held as a mini-conference on October 9th, is co-hosted by NYU-Poly. Empire Clean Cities’ goal is to discuss emerging topics around sustainability, and answer questions like what is NYC doing to be innovative, and what can we learn from other cities and their innovative solutions. The focus of the conference is "Innovations and Infrastructure", where we will focus on: the Inside Look into Electrifying our Future & Transportation in the Urban Form Our current speakers for the conference: • Professor John Falcocchio - NYU-Poly • John Markowitz - New York Power Authority • Asaf Selinger – Project Manager, Electric Vehicles – Hertz • Nick Nigro – Senior Manager of Transportation Initiatives – Center for Climate and Energy Solutions • Jaycie Chitwood – Manager, Advanced Technologies Group – Toyota USA Make sure you register for the event! For ECC Members, NYU-Poly faculty & students, and the NYC-ACRE network, please contact Ted at Ted@EmpireCleanCities.Org for discount code. VEHICLE AND EQUIPMENT DISPLAY Thursday October 10th, 2013 10:00am - 2:00pm Union Square Held in Union Square this year, Odyssey Day is an outreach and education event dedicated to promoting cleaner choices in transportation. Our mission is to educate the public on public and private business leaders who are committed to greening their own local communities by spreading the word on alternative fuel vehicles and technologies .
Don’t forget to follow us on social media to Keep up on All Event Information! Facebook.com/empirecleancities
ECC Fall 2013
Upcoming Industry Events
Natural Gas Technology Forum October 22-23, 2013 Brookhaven National Laboratory in Long Island, New York The U.S. Department of Energy invites you to save the date for the 2013 Natural Gas Vehicle Technology Forum (NGVTF). The 2013 meeting will be held at Brookhaven National Laboratory in Long Island, New York, on October 22 and 23. NGVTF is free and open to stakeholders, so join the conversation about natural gas engines, vehicles, infrastructure, and codes and standards. For registration and more information about this event, please visit their website at https://www.ngvbridge.com/boston/ NGV Bridge Market Development & Infrastructure Summit October 29-30, 2013 Boston, Massachusetts https://www.ngvbridge.com/boston/ 2013 National Gas Vehicle Conference & Expo November 18-21, 2013 Atlanta, Georgia For more information, visit the conference website. 2014 World LNG Fuels Conference & Expo January 21-23, 2014 Houston, Texas For more information, check out http://www.worldlngfuels.com/
ECC Fall 2013