Riding Herd Saying things that need to be said. July 15, 2024 • www.aaalivestock.com
Volume 66 • No. 7
Here We Go Again LEE PITTS
D
espite writing a weekly syndicated column for 40 years and thousands of feature stories I am not a journalist. As I understand it, journalists are supposed to be unbiased and not have any agendas. That’s definitely not me! I don’t think I’ve ever given the impression that I was impartial or objective. For gosh sakes, I’ve never taken a journalism class in my life and I don’t even know how to type. It’s my wife, who must have paid more attention than I did in high school English class, who fixes all my mistakes and makes sure I follow all the rules of English. I consider myself more of a curious snoop than I do a journalist and the job gives me carte blanche to ask all sorts of personal questions. Anyone who has ever talked to me knows I ask more questions than I have a right to and I’m surprised I’ve gotten away with it for 50 years without getting punched in the nose or sued for everything I own. Having said all that, there have been two instances in my career where I accidentally came close to being a journalist. In both instances I clearly chose sides, something real journalists, I am told, never do. But if you
watch CNN or read the New York Times you know that’s a bunch of horse pucky. One of those fights I lost big time and one of them I won. If I was a baseball player I’d be batting 500. That’s good if you’re a ballplayer but terrible if you’re a brain surgeon or a team roper.
Choose Your Battles Wisely The battle I lost was the heist of the checkoff by the NCBA. And enough said about that.
at the time to unveil the damage beta agonists like Merck’s Zilmax® were doing to cattle and to the cattle business in general. When I wrote my first story about beta agonists I never dreamed that it would lead to my working with two of my cowboy heroes to get Merck® to withdraw their beta agonist from the market, which at the time was a 159 million dollar annual product for them. Beta agonists had been around since 2007 but it wasn’t until seven years later that the proverbial manure hit the fan. The only problem with the war we waged was we didn’t finish the job because after Merck pulled Zilmax®, cattle feeders merely switched to another lesser known beta agonist called ractopamine, which is produced by Elanco Animal Health, a division of Eli Lilly
Never give the Devil a ride — He will always want the reins. In the second battle I waged I had better luck. At the time I was the first and only writer in the livestock press to introduce ranchers to beta agonists and this paper was the only one
Supreme Court Strikes Down Chevron, Curtailing Power of Federal Agencies BY AMY HOWE
NEWSPAPER PRIORITY HANDLING
I
n a major ruling, the Supreme Court of the US (SCOTUS) cut back sharply on the power of federal agencies to interpret the laws they administer and ruled that courts should rely on their own interpretation of ambiguous laws in late June. The decision will likely have far-reaching effects across the country, from environmental regulation to healthcare costs. By a vote of 6-3, the justices overruled their landmark 1984 decision in Chevron v. Natural Resources Defense Council, which gave rise to the doctrine known as the Chevron doctrine. Under that doctrine, if Congress has not directly addressed the question at the center of a dispute, a court was required to uphold the agency’s interpretation of the statute as long as it was reasonable. But in a 35-page ruling by Chief Justice John Roberts, the justices rejected that doctrine, calling it “fundamentally misguided.” When the Supreme Court first issued its decision in the Chevron case more than 40 years ago, the decision was not necessarily regarded as a particularly consequential one. But in the years since then, it became one of the most important rulings on federal administrative law, cited by federal courts more continued on page 3
and Company. Their beta agonist is marketed in America as Paylean® for swine, Topmax® for turkeys and Optaflexx® for cattle. It is a feed additive that enables cattle to produce more lean meat with less fat. In one study carcass weight increased by more than 100 pounds compared to cattle not given Optaflexx®. Nearly all studies about ractopamine showed that growth performance declines as the duration of feeding is prolonged, but an improvement in muscular growth continues with the increasing duration of its use. Ractopamine is known to increase the rate of weight gain, improve feed efficiency, and increase carcass leanness in finishing swine. Its use in finishing swine yields about 6.6 lb. of additional lean pork per animal, and improves feed efficiency by 10 percent. That’s the good news about ractopamine. Now here’s the bad. According to the National Library of Medicine, “There is no evidence in the scientific community to prove that ractocontinued on page 2
“Ecocide” Legislation is Radical Environmentalism BY JACLYN DE CANDIO FOR PROTECT THE HARVEST
A
poorly kept secret is that environmental extremist groups and like-minded NGOs work diligently in America to undermine personal liberties and essential industries, including agriculture. Such has been the case for half a century or longer. As they routinely do, radical environmentalists recently added a new term to their misinformation/disinformation vocabulary: “Ecocide.” Sounds ominous. It’s a term being used to demonize activity that allegedly damages the environment based on how these groups define the so-called devastation. This war of words is another example of environmental extremist ideology focused on creating more and tougher restrictions for Americans, our society, and economy. This folly has serious consequences for the nation’s food-producing capabilities, food security, and food independence. According to the group Stop Ecocide International – which is a partner of the United Nations (UN) – this term is used to describe what is happening to our planet: the mass damage and destruction of the natural living world. It literally means ‘killing one’s home’ and was coined in the 1970s by an American bioethicist to describe the environmental damage caused by Agent Orange used during the war in Vietnam. continued on page 4
by LEE PITTS
BoobyTrapped
T
he feds came out with a list of rules that protect wolves but make living in the West like walking through a mine-field. The feds have now placed booby-traps everywhere in the West that are meant to trap people like you, so I’d watch my step if I were you. It’s become very dangerous to tread anywhere on the 46 percent of the eleven western-most contiguous states that is public land owned by the U.S. government. For example, a person may NOT kill a wolf in the act of killing livestock on public land. If you do, you’re facing serious prison time and legal bills up the wazoo. If you are one of those people who believe in the three S’s, as in shoot, shovel and shut up, be sure to bury the carcass on your neighbor’s property so he or she will be the one being someone’s girlfriend in prison. These new rules make it harder for urban dwellers too, not just ranchers. Suppose you live in a big city and take Fifi, your poodle, for its daily walk in a park that, unbeknownst to you, is public property. And suppose a wolf jumps out of the weeds and starts killing and eating your beloved poodle. And suppose you pick up a branch and start trying to beat said wolf so he’d stop munching on Fifi. Well, you’re going to be cell mates with the rancher because you can’t kill or injure a wolf in the act of injuring your pet. As if to rub it in, you cannot go home and get your gun and go back to shoot the wolf now feeding on Fifi’s carcass. I’d think twice if I were you because it’s now illegal to kill a wolf on public property feeding on the dead carcass of an animal it murdered. You’re just supposed to stand there and watch the wolf tear and rip the meat from a dog that you loved dearly. It is now illegal “to enter official enclosures or rendezvous sites where there is denning behavior.” Pardon me but I think you’d need a master’s degree in wildlife biology to be able to recognize “wolf rendezvous sites.” Are these rendezvous like mountain men and trappers traveled to 150 years ago or are they more like the rendezvous when a businessman
continued on page 4