THE INdependent student newspaper at the university of cincinnati
Vol. CXXVIV Issue 26
wednesday , nov . 25, 2009 tnr gives thanks
city spotlight
The News Record staff shares what they’re thankful for this year. page 2
Northside: Cincinnati’s most eclectic neighborhood page 5
UC hosts Darwinian scholars
basketball Cats knock off Maryland, play for Maui title Wednesday. page 8
“[The cameras] provide a service beyond law enforcement.” —Capt. Russ Neville, CPD Information technology manager
Ashley Morgan the news record
The Darwin Sesquicentennial Celebration Committee hosted “The Vision and Legacy of Charles Darwin,” Monday, Nov. 23. The all-day event took place in Tangeman University Center’s Great Hall. Anthony Perzigian, UC senior vice president, funded the conference. The symposium had a two-part objective: to boost UC’s research reputation and celebrate Darwin’s “On the Origin of Species.” “[The book is] accessible, readable and easy to understand,” said Wendy Beckman, a Darwin committee member. The symposium included six speakers, a question and answer session, a book signing and a reception open to the public. Throughout the day, approximately 900 people attended to listen and observe. “We wanted everyone: UC students, faculty and members of the community,” Beckman said. “We wanted to try and catch everybody. We wanted doubters and skeptics, but overall we wanted people who were interested in science.” UC Board of Trustees chairman Buck Niehoff and Cincinnati Zoo and Botanical Garden employee Catherine “Cat Lady” Hilker were also in attendance. The event began at noon with UC President Gregory Williams welcoming the speakers and audience. “One of the greatest assets that sets UC apart from thousands of other colleges and universities is our immense capacity as a major research university,” Williams said. The keynote lecture, “Charles Darwin Against Himself: Caution versus Honesty in the Life of a Reluctant Revolutionary,” was presented by a Darwin-Wallace scholar and author David Quammen, who also graduated from St. Xavier High School. Quammen’s speech accumulated an audience of more than 700 people including 500 students and faculty from St. Xavier. People in the United States are not seeing facts because of their religious backgrounds and do not fully understand evolution, Beckman said. see darwin | page 6
brief garage flasher
The University of Cincinnati Police Division is warning students to watch out for suspicious persons in campus parking garages. In two incidents, there were reports of indecent exposure to people in Campus Green parking garage Thursday, Nov. 19, and Woodside Garage Friday, Nov. 20. “It’s not usually a crime we’re used to around here,” said Capt. Karen Patterson of UCPD. Although Patterson only saw one of the reports, there has not been a working description of the suspect or suspects in the case. weather forecast
james sprague the news record
sam greene | the news record
Cars pass through the intersection at Clifton and Ludlow avenues during morning rush hour, Tuesday, Nov. 24. The intersection is one of many where cameras are scheduled to be installed.
Cincinnati ups surveillance
City begins multimillion dollar camera installations
T
rusty pate the news record
he Cincinnati Police Department recently installed eight surveillance cameras around the city and plans to add around 60 more by the end of 2011, said Capt. Russ Neville, information technology manager of CPD. The price for each camera is $19,000, including the installation costs. “[The cameras] provide a service beyond law enforcement,” Neville said. They should be able to help other city services such as sanitation, traffic and fire, Neville said. The process of deciding which districts would get the cameras included a five-point plan, Neville said. “We did a statistical analysis on crimes and criminal conduct,” Neville said. “We discussed with district commanders and district personnel.” The presence of cameras might not guarantee safety, though. “Surveillance cameras, at this point, have become more of an illusion of safety rather than
any actual crime fighting tool,” said Gary Daniels, associate director of the Ohio American Civil Liberties Union. The University of Cincinnati also uses similar cameras, said Capt. Karen Patterson of the UC Police. “Just because you have cameras does not mean that you are stopping a crime from occurring,” Patterson said. Cameras are often used as a tool to help police investigate after a crime has occurred, Patterson said. Neville echoed her sentiment. “Right now it will be used reactively, not proactively,” Neville said. Daniels, however, says the cameras are a first step in a surveillance overhaul. “We’ve been arguing for years now that once you start allowing surveillance cameras at any given location, its not going to stop there,” Daniels said. Neville said the police department’s only concern is public space and insists no privacy rights will be violated. “These cameras are made for public view and public view alone,” Neville said. “Such
as, nothing outside of what any citizen would have the capability of seeing as they walk, drive or ride a bicycle up and down a street.” He also added there are protections in place should misuse occur. “If there is any inappropriate use of a system, we do have policies and procedures for accountability,” Neville said. Surveillance policies may be found under the Procedure Manuals on the CPD Web site. Daniels still worries about the trade off of a better prosecution tool for increased government access to surveillance. “There seems to be this idea that if the technology exists, that we should take advantage of it, simply because it exists – without asking the question of is this really effective,” Daniels said. The privacy concerns are unfounded, Neville said. “Its important people understand they are a city-wide, neighborhood public safety camera system,” Neville said. “It’s not a crime camera system.”
Here be rarities Unique books on campus
WEDNESDAY
69 51° 39 57°
THURSDAY
55 /36 FRIDAY
45 /27 SATURDAY
52 /34 SUNDAY
photos by coulter loeb | the news record
An original illuminated manuscript (above) from the early second millennium. The manuscripts were hand illustrated and scribed by monks. “Poems by Phillis Wheatley” (inlay), in the UC Archives and Rare Books, has its spine and corner bindings made of human skin. The lighter binding is sheep’s leather.
54 /40 index
1 News 2 Thanks 3 Opinion 5 College Living 7 Classifieds 8 Sports
AAUP works to protect free speech Recent federal court decisions ruling that faculty at public colleges are not protected by the First Amendment has drawn attention from the American Association of University Professors – a national faculty union that includes a University of Cincinnati chapter. The AAUP began a campaign to protect academic freedom at public universities, claiming the court decisions will erode faculty members’ speech rights. It is based on a particular Supreme Court ruling in the case of Garcetti v. Ceballos, which held that a government agency could restrict comments their employees made in connection to its official duties. A report issued by the AAUP Nov. 10 titled “Speak Up, Speak Out: Protect the Faculty Voice on Campus,” calls for faculty to not depend on courts for protection and to work with their respective schools in regards to policy protecting their speech. The report also suggested the University of Minnesota as a model example for an academic freedom policy, which was adopted by their Board of Regents this past June. However, for UC faculty, a free-speech policy has already been in place. Since 1974, the collective-bargaining agreement with the administration grants them protection. “We have a strong contract between the AAUP and UC that protects academic freedom and the faculty’s share in governance of the university,” said John McNay, an associate professor of history at UC’s Raymond Walters College, and a member of the AAUP executive council and chair of the organizing committee. Part of the agreement states “the right of academic freedom shall be the right of every faculty member. The university shall continue to be pledged to recognize and protect full freedom of inquiry, teaching and research in all aspects of University life.” UC faculty is noticing the issue in recent months. “Because we’ve had this contract and its protections of academic freedom since 1974, the UC chapter is really at the forefront of these issues,” he said. Howard Tolley, a UC political science professor, praises the administration in its approach to academic freedom and said the current agreement is working. “The administration, in my view, has done well in respecting free speech and encouraging those who take offense to compete in the free marketplace of ideas rather than to promote censorship,” Tolley said. Greg Hand, university spokesperson, agrees. “The faculty and the university both strongly believe in principle about academic freedom,” Hand said. Hand could not recall any major disputes over academic freedom or First Amendment protection in the 35 years the agreement has been in place. McNay seconds Hand. “We’ve not had a disagreement with the university in my time here specifically about academic freedom and this may stem from the strong language in the contract defending this issue,” said McNay, who has been at UC since 2000. Faculty might also consider recent national problems with university free speech, despite academic freedom being in the agreement with the university, said Daniel Langmeyer, a professor of psychology and vice president of the UC AAUP chapter. “Our contract does incorporate language about academic freedom as a right of the faculty,” Langmeyer said. “But perhaps [faculty members] will need to incorporate the recent threats and take a look at other universities’ policies.” The current agreement between the UC faculty and administration expires June 2010. Hand, however, expects negotiations regarding a new agreement to begin sometime in February 2010.
online @ www.newsrecord.org UC archives and rare books
TNR all the time
Check out photo editor Coulter Loeb’s photo slideshow of Blegen Library’s collection of unique works.
Now flip through the full issue online. Subscribe to The News Record Web site and RSS. If that’s not enough, follow us on Twitter @NewsRecord_UC.
newsrecordnews@gmail.com | 513.556.5908