MEDChronicle www.medicalacademic.co.za
The doctor's newspaper
MAY 2022
The NHI is a process, not an event
The National Health Insurance (NHI) Bill was recently in the news again when the National Department of Health was called to respond to some of the criticisms raised by stakeholders at the parliamentary public hearings on the NHI Bill. By Nicky Belseck, medical journalist
P
RIOR TO THE Covid-19 pandemic, when it came to health in SA, there was no question that the NHI Bill was the main topic of discussion. While the Bill may not have made as many headlines over the last two years, the National Department of Health (NDoH) has still been working on implementing it as soon as possible. Following President Cyril Ramaphosa’s announcement that the National State of Disaster had been lifted as from 5 April 2022 and with everyone getting used to the new ‘normal’, deputy director-general of the NHI, Dr Nicholas Crisp, gave an update on the state of NHI during a webinar hosted by The Institute of Health Risk Managers (IHRM) last month.
WHY DOES SA NEED NHI? “Health is not a tradeable commodity, it is a public good,” said Dr Crisp, and went on to explain that public goods are common resources that need to be supported by collective investment. Public goods are supported by all and accessible to all. “The reason they are public goods, rather than individual commodities, is we have decided that they are so fundamental to our wellbeing that they should not be entirely the province of private investment or market forces. “With that as a point of departure, we recognise that SA is even more unequal than it was before, and it is now firmly and vastly more unequal than any other society in the world. We used to be competing with Brazil for this, but we are now firmly far ahead,” Dr Crisp said.
“We have an economy that does not equally benefit all citizens. In fact, 10% of the population owns more than 80% of the wealth. These inequities are shown in our income gap, our gender inequality, our healthcare, social classes, and a range of other places throughout our society. In healthcare, some individuals receive better and more professional care compared to others. The SA wealth gap has not only been unchanged but has deteriorated since apartheid. This is not something to be proud of,” he said. “Our healthcare reflects our inequitable society. As a nation we spend 8.4% of our GDP on our health system but our outcomes are comparable with some of our neighbours including Mozambique in some instances, which is one of the poorest nations in the
Objective risk assessments in PAH optimise treatment
world. So, we are doing extremely poorly in terms of health outcomes, and that’s of serious concern to us. Part of the reason for that is that roughly half of our spend is in the public sector on the majority of the population, the other half is spent in the private sector on a minority of the population. Two out of every three medical specialists work in the private sector. “We have created a dual health system that entrenches and exacerbates inequity and poor health services in both public and private sectors. And we’ve reached a point where both the public sector and the private sector are in trouble. The public sector because it’s underserviced, and the private sector because it’s overserviced, and both are very duplicative and wasteful. “Our health system is failing everyone. Many poor people are denied care continued on page 3
continued on page 2
C
I RD
AC
GE A P
A
26
MEDICAL CHRONICLE | May 2022