8
The Mosaic San Jose Teen Urban Journalism Workshop
SUMMER 2020
Demise of SAT, ACT confuses college-bound students By Ariana Noble Mosaic staff writer COVID-19 has taken a big toll on students’ education and rites of passage, especially for high school students planning for college.The traditionally important SAT and ACT tests required for getting into college were cancelled in May, leaving students confused and worried about the changing application process. Around the United States, many colleges have decided to make these tests optional. They have also eliminated the SAT essay section for all future applications. “They partly made this decision because many students weren’t able to have access to taking these tests,” said Pam Miracle, an independent college admissions officer and affiliate consultant with Compass to College. She said this decision was made for many reasons. “We are navigating uncharted territory,” Miracle said. Schools, especially UCs, she explained, have been moving toward the decision to eliminate SATs and ACTs for years now in order to level the playing field for all students. Miracle said that instead of focusing on these tests, colleges will accept students based on their essays, extracurricular activities, and grade point averages. UC Santa Cruz Associate Vice Chancellor of Enrollment Management Michelle Whittingham said UC Santa Cruz has moved to test
optional for the next two years, and then it will move to test-blind, which means students may attach their scores to their applications but they will not be used to determine whether a student is accepted into the university. One question that many wonder about is: Will submitting an SAT/ACT score with an application increase your chance of getting accepted over someone who didn’t? No, it won’t, Whittingham said. A test score would be considered as “value-added information in the selection process.”
There are 13 other points colleges consider when accepting students under comprehensive review. They include grade point average, number of AP classes a student has passed, and special achievements such as awards or internships. In the meantime, University of California administrators are exploring creating a new test for incoming students that will reflect skills students should have mastered before attending a UC. The goal is to have this test ready by 2021 fall applications.
There are many different opinions and perspectives about the changing application requirements. Melissa Nelson, an upcoming senior at Lincoln High School, said she sees both pros and cons of flexible test scores. One pro, she said, is that students who have test anxiety and don’t perform well on tests will have the opportunity to shine through their essays and other requirements. One con is that students might feel added pressure to participate in extracurricular activities for their application, Nelson said. Kassidy Moreno, an upcoming senior at Archbishop Mitty High School, feels that a huge weight has been lifted off her shoulders now that her dream schools don’t require SAT scores. “I studied for months through a paid study class with some of my classmates and I didn’t learn anything.” Claire Kolling, a former high school teacher and SAT tutor, believes the tests give students a false sense of unworthiness. “SAT scores don’t define a student’s intelligence,” Kolling said. She said that she has seen students have panic attacks, crying episodes, and bouts of depression over studying for the SAT. The future of college acceptance standards is still very much up in the air, and it will probably take years to work it all out. “Education is a business, and sadly, it’s not changing anytime soon,” Kolling said. Ariana Noble is a rising senior at Lincoln High School in San Jose.
university admissions, public employment
Despite the support that ACA 5 is receiv-
mative action. “When you see Prop. 209, it makes you think that they take gender and race out of their consideration, which is a good thing,” said Mindy, who hopes to attend UC Santa Barbara. “However, you can also see the unintended (negative) effect. It allowed people of color and women to be met with more inequality” when some race- or gender-specific programs were eliminated by public organizations, she said. Amaris Albini, a Latina at Overfelt High School in San Jose, says that students of color often face additional hurdles beyond what affirmative action would help counter. “Prop. 209 employed color blindness that allowed people of color to fall through the cracks,” said Amaris, a rising junior who wants to attend UCLA. “It didn’t take into account that many people of color have had the cards stacked against them their entire lives.” Zahra Ali, a Pakistani American attending San Jose State University, said repealing Proposition 209 is just the beginning of what needs to be done to reach a level playing field. “I wish there was more reparations to communities that were disadvantaged,” said Ali, a sophomore who’s majoring in global studies.
quoted in a Chinese-language newspaper earlier this month as saying “many Hispanic and African ethnic groups are unable to compete or have the ability to continue their studies due to unresolved structural economic and educational problems.” In response, Silicon Valley civil rights activists called for Chu’s resignation. In a written statement, Chu denied making the comments and said the English translation provided by the San Jose-Silicon Valley NAACP was inaccurate. During the legislative debate on ACA 5, Assemblyman Evan Low of Campbell said that he had received thousands of calls from constituents and that only a fraction of them were in favor of the measure. Low said that many of those who were against it questioned his identity and said he was betraying the Asian community by voting for the measure. “I stand you with significant mixed emotion of sadness and of conflict. It does come with political peril, but I did not run for office for self-preservation,” Low said on a YouTube clip of his Assembly remarks.. He later voted in favor of ACA 5. Tara Nguyen is a rising junior at Silver Creek High School in San Jose.
and contracting. Students are watching close- ing from some people of color, there are some Affirmative action: ly to see how it could affect them. mixed reactions among Asian Americans. Students see their future Mindy Tuong, a Vietnamese American ris- Assemblyman Kansen Chu — who reping junior at San Jose’s Silver Creek High resents portions of North San Jose, Milpitas, hanging on fall vote School, supports a repeal of the ban on affir- Santa Clara, Fremont and Newark — was By Tara Nguyen Mosaic staff writer Hugo Marquez, a 2020 graduate of James Lick High School, is heading to college with big aspirations, hoping to become mayor of San Jose one day. As he looks forward to starting at UC Davis this fall, he’s keeping an eye on a possible state constitutional amendment on affirmative action that he believes could open doors for people of color. “I’m excited to some extent, because there needs to be a greater representation of people of color because, disproportionately, Latinos and African American people have been underrepresented,” Marquez said. In November, California voters will be asked whether to repeal Proposition 209, which banned affirmative action in California more than two decades ago. Assembly Constitutional Amendment 5, known as ACA 5, was approved by the state Legislature in June. Now voters will decide if race, sex, color, ethnicity or national origin may be considered in
SUMMER 2020
Coming out to their parents is fraught with danger for LGBTQ+ teens By Cassandra Rosales Mosaic staff writer Maria, 15, of San Jose is having a hard time coming out to her parents. It is a scary feeling, and she is not sure if she is ready to do it yet. Maria, who is a lesbian, has been out to her friends since the sixth grade. Now, she is waiting for the right time — if there is one — to tell her parents. Maria says that her parents are homophobic. She fears that if she told them, they would reject her or kick her out. For LGBTQ+ teens, coming out to their parents is fraught with danger. If they hear their parents make unpleasant remarks on the LGBTQ+ community, they struggle with the fear of being abandoned by their own families. Even if their parents have said that they are tolerant, it confuses some teens who have also picked up conflicting signals from them. “Teens who are coming out may fear that their loved ones will not embrace their identity or understand who they are,” said Rebecca Reed, a therapist at The LGBTQ+ Youth Space in San Jose. Because it can be scary coming out to someone whose views you don’t know, LGBTQ+ teens confide most in other LGBTQ+ teens. Nationally, around 93% of them are out to their LGBTQ+ friends, while only 68% are
Excerpts from stories written by students in the 2020 Mosaic high school journalism program. For the complete stories and more articles, visit www.mosaicjournalism.org.
CASSANDRA ROSALES - STAFF PHOTOGRAPHER
LGBTQ teens often hide their identity from their parents for fear of rejection.
out to their parents, according to The Trevor Project’s 2019 National Survey on LGBTQ+ Mental Health. Teens who are not out to their parents often aren’t able to talk to them about the problems they face. Only 31% of these teens say there is an adult in their family they can talk to when they’re sad, versus 63% of teens who are out to their families, according to the Human Rights Campaign’s 2012 National Coming Out Day Report. Maria’s parents make harsh comments on the LGBTQ+ community. “They say rude comments like ‘oh gross’ or ‘they’re not supposed to dress like that,’” Maria said. Maria worries that if she comes out, her parents will not love her anymore. To protect their privacy, Mosaic is not using the real names of any of the teenagers interviewed for this story. Like Maria, Rubi, a 15-year-old pansexual from San Jose, is not out to her parents, who are Roman Catholic. Her mom has told her she would not support any of her children if they were LGBTQ+ because it goes against her religion. Rubi fears that if she is open about her sexuality, her parents will try to convert her. Some parents may bluntly show that they are homophobic, while others give mixed signals or none at all. Kai, a 15-year-old transgender boy from San Jose, came out to his family three weeks ago. They were talking about quarantine, friendships, and what ifs. When he started asking what if questions about changing his body and name, his parents caught on to what he was trying to say. His parents said they were supportive of him, but they also gave mixed signals. Kai’s
mom said that she would not pay for his transition. This hurt Kai. He was a sobbing mess by this point. His family comforted him. “My dad hugged me and my brother and mom told me it was OK and to just breathe. They made it easier, because I felt like I was drowning in my own fear of rejection,” Kai said. Still, Kai said he wasn’t sure how his mom or dad felt. He said his dad didn’t look at Kai. His mom had unreadable facial expressions. “Often, parents have to go through their own grieving process due to losing who they expected their child to be,” Reed said. Flor, a 15-year-old bisexual from San Jose, is not out to her parents because she does not know where they stand. They push gender norms on her, but they don’t insist on them. Flor’s mom tells her to wear dresses because she is a girl, but doesn’t order her. “My parents are weird. It’s like they care but they also don’t care, which makes it harder for me to come out,” Flor said. She is out to her older sister. Her sister had assured her in the past that whether she liked guys or girls, she would be supportive. It was still scary to come out to her. “I was nervous, that was for sure. I felt like my face was scrunching up, but I don’t really remember. I was fiddling with my earbuds out of the nerves,” Flor said. It was a relief to Flor that her sister was genuinely happy for her. In the end, that’s what all LGBTQ+ teens want, Reed said. “All people want to be accepted and loved for exactly who they are.” Cassandra Rosales is a rising sophomore at Cristo Rey San José Jesuit High School.