Michigan Chronicle 10/23/19 Edition

Page 1

Foznworth Bentley Gets REAL

with Chevorlet and NNPA’s DTU Journalism Fellows See City.Life.Style C1

Michigan Chronicle

Vol. 83 – No. 7 | October 23-29, 2019

Powered by Real Times Media | michiganchronicle.com

Former DPS students and "Literacy" lawsuit plaintiffs who say they did not receive an adequate education.

The Right to Read

Detroit Students Appeal Decision Denying Right of Access to Literacy and a Basic Education By Eli Day How many words are needed to express what you’ve experienced in Detroit’s public schools? Jamarria Hall, 19, talks about his own history with laser-beam precision. The crumbling system, he says, was “diminishing,” making him less than what he might have been in an environment that actually supported learning. Hall enrolled in a Florida community college after graduating from Osborne High School in 2017. When we speak, however, he returns to this feeling — that something precious was stolen from him and his classmates . “I know I’ve lost four years of education being at Osborne and being in the [Detroit public] school system,” he says. “I know that is not my fault.” Hall’s feeling of urgency is palpable and rightfully so. The “Right to Literacy” case that

WHAT’S INSIDE

brought his all too common journey to public attention a few years ago that was ultimately dismissed by a federal judge, is now going before an appeals court in Cincinnati this week Filed on behalf of Hall and a group of other DPS students, attorney Mark Rosenbaum makes a straightforward argument: under 11 plus years of management, the State of Michigan acted as a neglectful tyrant, seizing control of Detroit’s public schools while allowing both its physical and educational quality to decay. By doing so, the attorney argues, the state violated students' constitutional right to be able to learn to read. The idea is pretty simple: while the constitution doesn’t say so explicitly, the right to read is an obvious linchpin of every other constitutional right. Without it, it is practically impossible to fully participate in the democratic process.

Under the then-Republican administration of Rick Snyder, the state basically called this nonsense, arguing that, “There is no fundamental right to literacy.” Michigan’s constitution, they insisted, only requires that the Legislature provide “a system of free public schools,” leaving everything else “to the local school districts.” It’s important to be painfully clear here. This boils down to an argument that the state only has to provide the skeleton of a school system, regardless of whether that system is eating itself from the[GG1] inside out as a result of inadequate resources and funding. Demanding that the state intervene any further, they argued, would “destroy the American tradition of democratic control of schools.” And, when reviewing the legal briefs related to this case the the state of Michigan (legal representation under Bill Schutte),

in a incredible display of pure apathy, pointed to “parental involvement (or lack thereof)” and “intellectual[GG2] limitations” as possible explanations for why students fail to learn in buildings that have seen their best days behind them The system’s deterioration has been well-documented. From widespread maintenance issues that will soon eclipse $1 billion to correct to dramatic teacher shortages, generations of students have been forced to do their best under appalling conditions. In his 2018 decision, Judge Stephen J. Murphy III wrote that the alleged conditions were “devastating.” Yet he still dismissed the case on the grounds that “the Due Process Clause does not require a state to provide[GG3] access to minimally adequate education.” But outraged Detroiters still saw a narrow path to victory. This was the summer of 2018

Roots. B3

$1.00

“It's really sad...for her to take the ‘no’ position just like Rick Snyder,” Jamarria says.

See RIGHT

TO READ page A2

River Rouge Schools lawsuit alleges Mike Duggan conspired to block advertisement on DDOT buses By Branden Hunter

Autoworker Builds Business out of Necessity

and Gretchen Whitmer would soon clinch the Democratic Party nomination for governor. She had spoken forcefully about the trial while campaigning, arguing that "Despite what the federal court said, despite what Bill Schuette and Gov. Snyder say, I believe every child in this state has a constitutional right to literacy," Whitmer said. "I believe you have a birthright to a good education. And it includes having a great teacher in your classroom, having facilities that promote the kind of learning that today’s day and age requires. All of these are pieces of that[GG4] .Within a year, her administration would pivot , laying out a maze of an argument to that lead to the same conclusion as Snyder. The same conclusion she campaigned against.

The River Rouge School District and the City of Detroit have been battling over students for years. Now the two will battle it out in federal court over an alleged scheme that Detroit Mayor Mike Duggan ordered Detroit Department of Transportation (DDOT) buses to not use River Rouge school ads on its buses, impacting the district’s enrollment-boosting advertising campaign. In a federal lawsuit filed Tuesday in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan, River Rouge School District Superintendent Dr. Derrick Coleman and Board Trustee Deborah Harper accused Duggan, DDOT, and city-based advertising company Outfront Media, of preventing River Rouge’s advertisements from appearing on DDOT buses in violation of the district’s free speech rights. The River Rouge School District is seeking $5 million in damages for a breach of contract and a violation of First Amendment rights.

“For many years, the River Rouge Schools has been advertising on DDOT buses through contracts with Outfront Media (formerly CBS Outdoors). This has been a positive relationship for both DDOT and River Rouge Schools. DDOT has been paid for this advertising campaign and River Rouge Schools has benefited from the advertising by more

than doubling its student population during the time that it has undertaken this advertising campaign. This relationship has also benefitted school-age children in the City of Detroit as it has informed them and their families about the free quality educational options available to them. That relationship, however, has been ended because of an order by

Mayor Mike Duggan. River Rouge Schools believes this is part of a targeted attack by the Mayor against the School District,” the lawsuit reads. River Rouge said it has been advertising on DDOT buses since approximately 2012 and signed a deal June 13, 2019 with Outfront Media to run district advertisement posters on the back of DDOT buses from July 8 through September 1. The lawsuit states, on July 3, 2019, Outfront employee, Devin Holly, issued an email to Dr. Coleman indicating the contracts could not be performed as agreed and River Rouge’s advertisements would not be displayed on DDOT buses because, “The Mayor of Detroit has decided for DDOT to run only Detroit Public Schools advertising on the buses.” River Rouge said its enrollment has grown since 2012, when Dr. Coleman was hired, due to his implementation of promotional ads that have been featured on the side of DDOT buses.

See LAWSUIT page A2


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.