3.3.17

Page 1

CRI ER

MUNSTER HIGH SCHOOL

vol. 51/issue 9/march. 3, 2017

upcoming

inside look Page 9: Dance team went to Nationals yesterday to compete this weekend Page 3: Students discuss gun laws in Indiana

8808 Columbia Ave

Sign up for AP testing by March 10 in Guidance

page 6-7 Meet this year’s Battle of the Bands performers

Orchestra hosts Five Guys fundraiser all day Sunday Tonight’s Boys Basketball student section theme is “rich out” at East Chicago Battle of the Bands tickets go on sale Monday during lunches for $5 per person

. Munster , IN 46321

A

hallmark of American society, the First Amendment is arguably the most quintessential of all things American.

Yet, these freedoms are limited in schools across the country. According to Mr. Morgan Nolan, Assistant Principal, it is necessary to limit student speech to maintain the sanctity of the school environment. “You have a student body that is required to be here for school, so you have this compulsory attendance process in Indiana and across the United States,” Mr. Nolan said. The Indiana House of Representatives has decided to expand the breadth of students’ First Amendment rights, starting with student press. This past December, legislators drew up House Bill 1130, which limits censorship on student media. The bill passed through the House 88-4, and will be heard in the Senate on March 15. Mr. Ed Clere, State Representative from New Albany and author of the bill, is hopeful that the bill will pass through the Senate, and he believes it is necessary to give student media more freedom. “(Free student press) is an essential part of civics education,” Rep. Clere said. “It can really enrich the school environment by providing valuable news and commentary in the school community, while also bringing about more accountability and engagement by students and other members of the school community. The press plays a critical and fundamental role in our civil society.” Others are more doubtful of the efficacy of the bill. “I don’t think the bill if it gets passed, will last very long because it opens up a Pandora’s box if you will, of issues. I think the system we have in place works pretty well,” Mr. Nolan said. “I think that if the Game against bill passes, there will be a situation where a Lake Central at student newspaper is 7 p.m. at East out of line, and it will Chicago tonight cause a big issue in the district.” It should be noted DRIVING IN Josh Davis, freshman, dribbles past the bill does not allow Gary West Side defendtotal press freedom. er, Jaiwon Carson, as “Even this bill does the Mustangs win 42-36. not give students 100

Shedding light on

student rights

students speak Survey reveals students’ views on First Amendment rights at MHS Do you think students should be given more freedoms in regards to speech?

77%

said yes

Do you feel your speech has been unfairly restricted at MHS?

43%

said yes

source: survey on Google forms of 504 responses from Feb. 27 to March 1 photo illustration by Danijela Kaurin

Mimi Brody Page Editor

Students’ First Amendment rights explained as House Bill 1130 passes through House

Basketball advances to semi-final of Sectionals

photo by Kess Vaitkus

percent freedom,” Mrs. Diana Hadley, Director of the Indiana High School Press Association, said. “They still can’t print anything that is unlawful, they can’t libel people or print anything that would cause a major disruption to the school day. There are still boundaries on what they can do. But if they have more freedom to cover more topics, they might actually make their lives better for their fellow students or make their school better.” With the current abundance of technology and social media, not only has speaking one’s mind become easier, but it is easier to be heard. This has presented a tough situation for schools, as it seems the line of what is considered protected speech is blurrier than ever. “We don’t have any specific policies about social media outside of school or off school grounds other than those related to substantial disruptions,” Mr. Nolan said. “It’s a very very fine line. In most cases we need to make an educated or gut judgement if speech that took place off school grounds was causing too much of a disruption. It doesn’t always have to be something where the student body feels that the speech off grounds is causing a commotion, it could misrepresent the school.” Vince Bravo, junior, was in his study hall class when a fight broke out between two students. Vince reached for his cell phone and recorded the event, eventually posting the video on Twitter where it got about 200 re-tweets. “I really wanted it to go viral,” Vince said. “My first aspiration wasn’t even to put it on Twitter, I just wanted to show my friends. Once I looked at the video and realized how funny it was, I just had to post it.” Upon hearing about the video, administration quickly reprimanded Vince as he broke a rule saying, “Filming or audio recording of staff members or students without explicit permission is subject to discipline.” “I see people recording videos on Snapchat every day,” Vince said. “They don’t get Saturday detentions. If the school gave Saturday detentions to everybody that recorded in school, there would be 40 kids in a Saturday detention room each week. If the school has an issue that needs to be fixed, and a student calls them out on it, the student shouldn’t be punished because of that,” Vince said. “It’s not a dictatorship here, students should be able to express their thoughts how they want as long as they say them with respect toward the school and staff, even if it is negativity towards the school.” Rep. Clere is hopeful that the effects of the bill will trickle down into giving students more freedoms in school. “I think this (the bill) will help create a more open atmosphere in schools which will lead to more openness over all, not just a more open student press. It will have all kinds of positive consequences. On some level, this is a great civics lesson in that the content student journalists produce is very much civics in action,” he said.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.