LETTERS
SAUL & THE WITCH READER: I recently read some of your posts on Saul and the Radak's interpretation, and I have some questions: 1) The most obvious: why did the talmudic rabbis, who we rely on for all of our tradition, say nothing like this, that Saul only “imagined” he spoke with the dead Samuel? 2) Is there any scientific examples of this kind of delusion occurring in a person? And if there is was it an easy enough stage to reach, to justify these people being so heavily believed in and relied upon? RABBI: Radak was brilliant mind, no less than talmudic rabbis, maybe even greater. There are
FACT OR FICTION?
countless talmudic sections depicting metaphors such as this. But perhaps this story is so clearly impossible to be understood literally, and must be describing Saul’s psychological state, no talmudic commentary was necessary. Yes, there are cases of people believing they see and hear things, when nothing is present. Saul was not the first. With great desperation or psychological derangement, one can be fooled he senses what never occured. Saul believed his fantasy. This is why Torah depicts this story as if it were real...to stress the reality a desperate person ascribes to his desires. ■
WWW.MESORA.ORG AUG. 6, 2021
|
17
