The Merionite June 5, 2012
Volume 83, Issue 9
The official student newspaper of Lower Merion High School since 1929
Lawsuit reaches Supreme Court Bulldog dedicated Carter Rauch
Class of 2013
Over the past few years, LM has been involved in more than its fair share of lawsuits. While the infamous webcam lawsuits garnered an international spotlight, it is Students Doe v Lower Merion School District that has the potential to make more of an impact on the school district. The case was filed in May 2009, in response to the school board’s controversial 2009 redistricting plan. That plan, according to the plaintiffs, illegally used race (in violation of the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment) as a factor in sending a large group of South Ardmore students to Harriton High School, despite their ability to walk to LM. Now, after two controversial decisions by federal district and appellate courts, the case has the potential to reach the U.S. Supreme Court. The case was first heard in the U.S. District Court in April 2010. The school district claimed that all redistricting decisions were made with respect to geography and other factors and that race was only considered to prevent isolation. This case was “novel,” because a neighborhood, rather than one or more particular individuals, was targeted, meaning that each high school student residing in South Ar-
dmore was sent to Harriton regardless of his or her race. Contradicting the precedent of Parents Involved in Community Schools v. Seattle School District No. 1, a Supreme Court case prohibiting the assignment of specific minority children to schools to encourage racial integration, District Court Judge Michael Baylson ruled that Lower Merion’s redistricting decision was, in fact, constitutional. Unsatisfied with the decision, the plaintiffs appealed to higher court. The Third Circuit Court of Appeals, the secondhighest level of federal court, heard the appeal. The NAACP (National Association for the Advancement of Colored People) filed an Amicus Curiae (“Friend of the Court”) brief in favor of the school district, supporting the goals of redistricting. The NAACP Legal Defense Fund claimed that the plaintiffs’ case would undermine the landmark Brown v. Board of Education decision by opposing the goal of racial integration. Supporters of the Students Doe plaintiffs argued that the NAACP ignored the fact that the redistricting plan assigned students to schools on the basis of race. Even if the district were encouraging diversity, the plaintiff claimed, the policy was discriminatory. Like the District Court, the Third Circuit ruled in favor of the district, in December of 2011, suggesting that the District “used pristine, non-discriminatory goals as
See COURT, page 2
General Becton visits LM
in courtyard
Galen McMullen
Class of 2014 With the semester closing and finals nearing, we are yet again surrounded by endings. This year, LM is also grateful to welcome new beginnings. Thanks to artist Leo Sewell, LM was granted a handmade sculpture, the newest addition to our school. Representing our spirited mascot, a bulldog statue now stands proudly in the courtyard, surrounded by windows for all to enjoy. Familiarized with Harriton’s similar apple sculpture, both ideas, an apple and a bulldog, were suggested and approved by the Lower Merion Harriton High School (LMHHS) Alumni Association. The two designs originated after long discussions within the Association, and later were brought to action once the alumnus selected the artist Leo Sewell. Growing up near a dump, Sewell was prone to playing with junk—in fact he’s been doing so for fifty years now. Using recognizable objects of metal, wood, and plastic, Sewell has developed his own assemblage technique. He tends to choose materials based on shape, texture, durability, and patina. Like our bulldog, his outdoor sculptures are constructed of found objects that are welded together. Size
Noah Blodget
‘Jr.’ after my name even though Dad died more Class of 2014 than 40 years ago.” His biggest focus however, It is not often that a retired three-star general w a s t h e i m p o r t a n c e o f e d u c a t i o n . H e s t a t e d , walks the halls of your school, and it is even “With a good education, you are able to unlock more unusual when that general calls your school t h e d o o r s t o y o u r g o a l . E d u c a t i o n s e r v e s a s his home. On the platform to M o n d a y, M a y your desires in 21, Lieutenant life.” EducaGeneral Julius tion has played Wesley Becton a major role in Jr. walked into Lt. Gen. BecLM, 68 years t o n ’s l i f e , a s after he graduhe graduated ated. During a from Prairie day filled with View A&M numerous fesU n i v e r s i t y, tivities, the where he later stoic 86 year served as presold spoke about ident, and has the foundasince earned tions set in his h i s m a s t e r ’s youth, the racdegree and an ism he faced in honorary Ph. Photo by Doug Cotler the military, and the im- D from MuhlenGeneral Becton (to left) visits the new bulldog portance of integrity and berg University. loyalty. In an interview He stressed the in the courtyard. conducted by English teacher, Dr. Debra Hobbs importance of truly applying yourself, as LM is and junior Josh Harper, Lt. Gen. Becton began one of the strongest programs nationwide. by discussing his early youth, growing up in As the interview progressed, the focus shifted an apartment in Bryn Mawr. He highlighted his m o r e t o w a r d s t h e g e n e r a l ’s v a l i a n t m i l i t a r y experience as a football player for LM as one of career and the challenges he faced, such as segthe most influential periods in his life. He also regated ranks and Vietnamese guerrilla warfare. discussed the importance of a strong family unit He commented often on the importance of integand good education. When asked about those rity. He stated, “Integrity is non-negotiable. A who served as his mentors, he responded, “I man is judged by his integrity.” In addition, he must always include my father, Julius W. Becton noted that loyalty is just as important. “Loyalty Sr. His influence is the reason I continue to use is a two way street. It should go up as well as
See GENERAL, page 2
Photo by Efi Narliotis/Staff
Sewell’s bulldog construction incorporates recognizable junkyard finds. isn’t the issue with Leo Sewell, whose pieces range from a life size housecat to a 40-foot installation. His work can be found throughout Philadelphia, including nearby facilities like the Please Touch Museum. Many responses regarding Sewell’s bestowal support the investment. Sophomore Arman Hassan believes the sculpture “adds a bit more character to the building, and tradition with the bulldog will evolve over the years to come.” Staff and students are not only excited by the statue’s appearance, but show enthusiasm regarding its significance to the school. Principal Sean Hughes reflects on LM’s new addition through recognition, “The LM/Harriton High School Alumni Association has been instrumental in celebrating not only our storied past but also our exciting future through a bevy of celebrations such
See BULLDOG, page 2