Prisons Analysis

Page 1

CHAPTER 3: PRECEDENTS ANALYSIS

HALDEN PRISON

General information:

Location: Halden, Norway

Status: operational

Security class: Maximum

Capacity: 248-252

Population: 251(as of 2015)

Opened: April 8, 2010

‘Although often criticized for being especially liberal in its approach to crime and punishment, Norway focuses intensely on ensuring that” doing time” is done in a dignified way, and inmates’ sentence should be a dress rehearsal for living a life without crime once they have completed their sentence. The Halden Prison in Halden, Norway is considered to be the world’s most humane prison.’

Layout

Halden prison is designed in campus layout, Facilities are split between separate buildings, with a surrounding perimeter wall. So, inmates have to start their day with commute – mimicking life in the outside world, providing easy access to outdoor physical activityandgivesinmatesarichviewoftheirsurroundingenvironment (unlike the other layouts) ; This access to nature also gives inmates

35

track the passage of the time

what happen inside the walls?

Halden design affect the way correctional officers and inmates interact Housing to broken up into small communities with a shared kitchen and communal space. Correctional officers can easily monitor inmates through regular face-to-face contact, instead of observing large groups of people from a distance. And the guards’ rooms are intentionally designed too small, to incentivize them to move out into the inmates’ common area. In other prisons, interiors are made from hard materials, which block light, visually unappealing, and constantly reflect noise. But in Halden interiors are made from glass to let in natural light, cork, and wood to muffle the noise

36
FIGURE 23 : DAYROOM IN HALDEN PRISON

The grounds of humane prisons are usually landscaped carefully. At Halden tall birch and pine trees dwarf the buildings and obscure the perimeter wall.

Lending what designers call an “anti-authoritarian” feel to the campus:

inmates are never made to feel intimidated by architecture itself

37
Site

Recommendations

 Campus Design advantages -Humane prison are often laid out in a campus design-:

. normalize inmate daily routine mimicking life in the outside world

. gives inmates a rich view of their surrounding environment (unlike the other layouts)

. providing easy access to outdoor physical activity

 The grounds of humane prisons are usually landscaped carefully

 Design affect the way correctional officers and inmates interact

 Using materials let in natural light and muffle noise

 Lending what designers call an “anti-authoritarian” feel to the campus : inmates are never made to feel intimidated by architecture itself

38

STORSTRØM PRISON

General information:

Location: Falster, Denmark

Architect: C.F. Møller

Area: 35,000 m²

Year: 2017

‘to create the world’s most humane high-security prison, which contributes to the inmates’ social rehabilitation through architecture that supports the inmates’ mental and physical well-being and also ensures a secure and pleasant workplace for the prison staff’

Layout

Storstrøm Prison made up of ten buildings in total cover an overall floor space of approximately 35,000 m²

39
FIGURE 24 : STORSTROM BUILDINGS SHOT

The overall architectural approach is to create a building on the same scale and with the same structure as, including streets and squares. This will ensure a familiar and varied experience of the prison environment and keep the prison’s institutional atmosphere to a minimum.

Function analysis

Accommodation

40
F IGURE 25 : STORSTRØM PRISON , FUNCTIONAL ANALYSIS DIAGRAM , ACCOMMODATION

Prison facilities

41
FIGURE 26 : : STORSTRØM PRISON , FUNCTIONAL ANALYSIS DIAGRAM , PRISONERS FACILITIES FIGURE 27 : FIGURE 26 : : STORSTRØM PRISON , FUNCTIONAL ANALYSIS DIAGRAM , PRISONERS FACILITIES

Security analysis

Security through architecture

The architecture provides vantage points for prison staff, from which they can oversee a complete floor of a cell department, with a wide field of vision in several directions from central guardroom spaces. These spaces are also an obvious meeting place for inmates and staff. To safeguard staff safety, there are secure rooms and escape routes in the individual departments, so that staff can quickly assemble here and maintain the upper hand in the event of unrest among the inmates.

A prison within the prison

The secure wing is used for negatively dominant and restricted status inmates. This unit is surrounded by a wall, and inmates and prison staff are physically separated. In other units, the staff man has an open desk.

Flexible prison

The architectural design has been used to create a flexible prison that can adapt to different categories of inmates and specific emergencies. This is achieved by making it possible to divide individual departments into larger and smaller sections. This helps to

42
FIGURE 28 : SECURITY ANALYSIS DIAGRAM FIGURE 29 : ILLUSTRATION OF PRISON WITHIN PRISON

enhance security and provide good conditions for the social rehabilitation of prisoners in a secure environment.

Elevations

To create further variation, facades and roof ridges are angular in different ways and the facade materials alternate between light-coloured bricks and a combination of concrete and galvanised steel – all durable materials which weather beautifully and do not need much maintenance.

Conclusion

 prison main components

- accommodation

- prisoner facilities

- prison support

 Prison that Uses Architecture to Promote Prisoners’ Social Rehabilitation

 Storstrøm Prison humane high-security prison

 contributes to the inmates’ social rehabilitation through architecture that supports the inmates’ mental and physical well-being and also ensures a secure and pleasant workplace for the prison staff.

 prison architecture promote all of human needs from physiological to self actualization

43
FIGURE 30 : FIGURE 26 : : STORSTRØM PRISON , ELEVATIONS

 cell design :

- day light

- views out

- safety furniture

- high security achieved

 achieve a good inmates - guards relationship by providing social spaces for both

 The overall architectural approach is to create a building on the same scale and with the same structure as, including streets and squares.

 This will ensure a familiar and varied experience of the prison environment and keep the prison’s institutional atmosphere to a minimum.

 The townlike structure also resembles the surrounding villages, and is thus a natural element of the landscape

44

EXIT THROUGH THE PRISON student project

This prison was designed with Haarlem’s model as an alternative correctional program. this proposed model aims that the users of the prison must see themselves and be seen in roles other than that of prisoners.

This project proposes a pilot program aiming at the rehabilitation and reintroduction of the convicted population to society, preventing habitual offending (recidivism) and healing rather than harming the target group especially people with low-level education, low income, minorities, etc. this disadvantaged group is the most vulnerable group to recidivism, part of the traditionally social outcasts. A continuous curriculum of activities

45
FIGURE 31 : HARLEM'S MODEL ILLUSTRARTION

is used in this prison to provide inmates the opportunity to develop themselves socially, culturally, and professionally before their release. Since individuals react differently to the same rehabilitating methods, a more personalized program is necessary. The services of this prison are divided into 4 phases which correspond to the 4 different levels of the building. A large number of activities, vocational education, labor, will help each inmate in acquiring a new image for himself and a new position in his community. Encouragement of individual success through a progressively positive environment: quality and comfort increase evokes an awareness of possible improvement.

Goals are set by the “user: in accordance with the program’s demand. Thus the conditions of sentence and time or release are partly chosen by him. The importance of choice is crucialoppositetothedanger ofinstitutionalization.Eachpersonisvolunteeringinvolved in the offered programs which gives him the possibility of decreasing his sentence. The latter can only be applied and function if it has an end. As time passes and the “user” of the prison goes from one phase to the other the effects of the sentence are moderated. At the end of each phase, an exam decides if he can go on or not.

“Our 21st panopticon prison stretches from the reality tv and the internet age to publicsurveillanceby CCTVandintegrated systems for emotional staterecognition. As m. Foucault explains. The same strategies of power and knowledge operate both in a prison and in a city . The mechanismsof discipline , the methods of observation and evaluation that control the delinquent also control the citizen . This project accepts that this prison could not escape from being a part of our societies extended carceral network”

46

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.