The Trussville Tribune
Page 16
Apr. 17 - 23, 2019
Politics
Bill would stop seizure of assets without criminal conviction; law enforcement opposed By MARY SELL, Alabama Daily News
Legislation pending in the Alabama Senate would prohibit law enforcement agencies from seizing the assets of people who haven’t been convicted of a crime. “I think that’s how the public assumes it works — before the government takes people’s stuff, there has to be a conviction or a plea,” said Sen. Arthur Orr, R-Decatur. But that’s not always the case under Alabama’s civil asset forfeiture law. Currently, police can seize property if they have reason to believe it was criminally gained. Even if there’s no conviction, law enforcement can keep the property with a civil court order. The property owner must prove his or her property wasn’t part of a crime — at his or her own expense. “The law was originally established to go after the ill-gotten gains of drug kingpins and those who were profiting from their criminal activities,” Orr said. “But it’s being used for low-level crimes for defendants who can’t afford a lawyer on the civil side (to get their property returned).” Orr’s Senate Bill 191 would require a conviction in order for seized property to be kept by law
enforcement and makes the seizure part of the criminal proceedings, not a separate civil action. The property could also be forfeited in a plea agreement. The Alabama District Attorneys Association is opposed to the bill. “We believe the bill is flawed in many ways, including constitutionally,” association executive director Barry Matson said last week. He argues criminal proceedings should remain separate from civil asset seizure. Matson said DAs didn’t see SB191 until the day it was filed earlier this month. It cleared the Senate Judiciary Committee on a 12-0 vote the following day and was on the Senate floor for a vote the next. Matson said law enforcement asked that the vote be delayed. “The sheriffs, the chiefs, no one has been contacted about (the bill),” Matson said. Calls to the Alabama Sheriff’s Association and the Alabama Association of Chiefs of Police were not returned. Law enforcement has opposed previous civil asset forfeiture reforms in the State House, arguing it is an essential crime-fighting tool. “I’m trying to correct the narrative that police are terrible,” Matson
said. Last year, the Alabama Appleseed Center for Law and Justice and the Southern Poverty Law Center examined 1,110 civil asset forfeiture cases in 14 counties from 2015. In 827 cases, a total of $2.2 million was awarded for law enforcement. One-fourth of the cases were against people never charged with a crime, according to Appleseed. They forfeited $670,000. Eighteen percent of cases where charges were filed involved simple possession of marijuana or paraphernalia. Not exactly kingpin-level drug activities, advocates for change say. “We found that in half of the cases examined, the amount of cash involved was $1,372 or less,” said Carla Crowder, executive director of Appleseed. “The government has clearly extended the use of civil forfeiture beyond the original intent.” Many cannot afford the attorney who could help them get it back, and attorneys’ fees would most likely stack up beyond $1,372, Crowder said. “We have the government allowing government agencies to directly profit, to the detriment of individual property owners,” said Shay Farley, policy counsel for
Southern Poverty Law Center. Farley said law enforcement agencies are underfunded. “But the answer is not to take property from individuals without proving criminal behavior,” she said. “No one should profit from crime or alleged criminal behavior, including those responsible for enforcing the law. That’s what this is, it’s called ‘policing for profit.’” Matson disputes the report and said some of the cases cited involved defendants who police “flipped” to go after larger criminals. “If they do that, we don’t charge him, but we don’t give him his money back because it’s drug money,” Matson said. He also said he’s studied the real-life examples cited by advocates as people who have lost their belongings without convictions. He questions their innocence and said the seizures were justified. Orr’s bill also requires the Alabama Attorney General to create a searchable public database that includes: The name of an agency that seized property; the type of property seized, alleged criminal offense, the outcome of the defendant’s criminal case and where the seized property or money is distributed. The attorney general’s office
Congressman Palmer reintroduces Retirement Freedom Act From The Trussville Tribune staff reports
WASHINGTON — Congressman Gary Palmer (RAL) recently reintroduced the Retirement Freedom Act (H.R. 2108), which would allow senior citizens to opt out of Medicare without losing their Social Security benefits. Companion legislation was introduced by Senators Ted Cruz (R-TX) and Mike Lee (R-UT). “This bill would empower seniors by giving them more
control over their healthcare decisions,” said Palmer. “Peo-
ple should not be forced to give up their private insurance because their Social Security is being held hostage,” Palmer. “Our Retirement Freedom Act gives seniors the ability to act in their own best interest without bureaucrats threatening to take away their Social Security.” Said Cruz. If passed, H.R. 2108 would decouple Social Security and Medicare, allowing seniors to keep their private insurance without losing Social Securi-
ty benefits. Currently, seniors must forfeit Social Security if they do not enroll in Medicare Part A. This link between the two programs acts as a mechanism to force Medicare enrollment, which is an overreach by the Social Security Administration and a serious restriction on seniors’ freedom of choice in their healthcare, according to Palmer’s statement. H.R. 2108 seeks to give that freedom back and to be one step towards fixing the entitlement system.
Job Type: Full time Contact: HRQuestions@fcmpartners.com
Alabama bill would allow concealed carry without permit From The Trussville Tribune staff reports
MONTGOMERY — State Sen. Gerald Allen of Tuscaloosa has proposed a bill that would allow citizens to carry a concealed handgun in public without having to get a permit. The Senate Judiciary Committee will host a public hearing on the bill next week, according to The Tuscaloosa News. The Senate Judiciary Committee originally planned to host
the hearing on Wednesday. However, the committee adjourned before the hearing could take place due to time constraints. The Tuscaloosa News said that several state sheriffs and representatives from Moms Demand Action were on hand for the hearing. Allen has proposed this bill for several years. According to The Tuscaloosa News, he believes it is an issue of people being able to bear arms without a fee.
36 Years Serving Clay, Trussville & Surrounding Communities
The First Community Mortgage office is in a prime location in Trussville, downtown at 194 Main Street next to Brik Realty.
First Community Mortgage is an Equal Housing Lender, NMLS ID 629700
ruled that law enforcement violated the constitutional prohibition on excessive fines when they seized a Land Rover from an Indiana man who pleaded guilty to selling $225 worth of heroin to undercover officers. Besides Alabama Appleseed and the Southern Poverty Law Center, Alabama’s chapter of the National Federation of Independent Business (NFIB) is advocating for it. NFIB state director Rosemary Elebash said civil asset forfeiture reform is a priority issue for the organization this year and lawmakers were sent a letter saying so. “Our members were surprised that assets could be seized without a conviction, sometimes even without an indictment,” Elebash said. The bill has seven co-sponsors, including Sens. Rodger Smitherman and Linda Coleman-Madison, both Birmingham Democrats, Sen. Cam Ward, R-Alabaster, Sen. Tom Butler, R-Huntsville, and Sen. Jim McClendon, R-Springville. “Everyone supports law enforcement, but the current day practice has exceeded the contemplated boundaries when the law was passed years ago to allow civil asset forfeiture,” Orr said.
Keith Landscape Co. & Nursery Sales
Loan Originator position with base salary and great benefits!
If you want to become part of not only a great sales team but a company with full time support to enhance your success, please send your resume detailing your talents as soon as possible. We look forward to hearing from you!!
did not return a request for comment. Earlier this year, the Alabama District Attorneys Association and others announced the creation of a voluntary database where law enforcement can give details on property seizures. The database is not public, but a report will be released at the end of the year. “Let’s see where the problem is, if there’s a problem,” Matson said. “If there is, we’ll be in the front row trying to fix it.” ‘Everyone supports law enforcement’ Eleven states—California, Connecticut, Iowa, Minnesota, Missouri, Montana, Nevada, New Hampshire, Ohio, Oregon and Vermont—require a criminal conviction to engage in some or all forfeiture proceedings, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures. California, Iowa and Ohio exclude property valued under a certain amount from the criminal conviction requirement. North Carolina, New Mexico and Nebraska have abolished civil forfeiture entirely. The Arkansas Legislature voted last month to end the practice. Civil asset seizures gained renewed interest this year when in February the U.S. Supreme Court
OUR NURSERY OFFERS ALL TYPES OF
MULCH – GRAVEL – STONE – PEA GRAVEL SAND – PINE STRAW (ROLLS OR BALES) We provide professional advice on anything landscape!
§ § § § § § § § § §
Plants/Shrubs Trees Bedding plants Fertilizers Herbicides Screened topsoil Blended garden soil Fill dirt Chert Red rock
We deliver or load on your truck! WE SELL SOD BY THE PIECE OR BY THE PALLET! Our sod is green during growing season, not left on pallets.
Monday - Friday 8am-5pm Saturday 8am-2pm
www.KeithLandscaping.com
6750 Trussville-Clay Rd. - Trussville, AL (205) 681.8787