Strategic Plan | Assignment 3

Page 1

STRATEGIC

3.
PLAN DATE: 10/25/22 CLASS: PLAN7007 – Plan Workshop, Climate Studio Project Group: Anna Mueller, Scarlet Andrzejczak, Lizzy Geraghty
VISION: CINCINNATI WILL STRENGTHEN ITS RESILIENCE TO CLIMATE CHANGE AND IN-MIGRATION THROUGH THE DESIGN AND IMPLEMENTATION OF AN INTEGRATED NETWORK OF GREEN INFRASTRUCTURE AND GREEN SPACE. LEFT OFF HERE... EVERY NEIGHBORHOOD SHOULD HAVE AT LEAST A 15% INCREASE OF GREEN INFRASTRUCTURE & 5% INCREASE IN GREEN SPACE VISION, OBJECTIVES, & BENEFITS MATRIX1
3 FIVE WHY’S OBJECTIVES MAINTAIN ADAPT BALANCE ATTRACT CONNECT Create comprehensive local environmental guidelines for developers Promote economic development by connecting existing businesses to green infrastructure Develop a connected network of green spaces (existing and proposed) Better prepare for natural disasters using green infrastructure Conserve land for green spaces and green infrastructure Maintain and support existing ecological corridors where possible
4 We
have created multiple flow charts to demonstrate how a user can select the strategies that best fit their project or needs.
Three Ways to Approach the Problem
5 BENEFITS MATRIX
6 BENEFITS MATRIX THESE GREEN SPACES ARE GROUPED BASED ON PRESERVING LAND FOR HUMAN INTERACTIONS AND NATURAL ECOSYSTEMS THESE STRATEGIES ARE GROUPED BASED ON LARGE SCALE NATURAL DISASTER MITIGATION THESE STRATEGIES ARE GROUPED BASED ON SMALL SCALE NATURAL DISASTER MANAGEMENT THESE ARE GROUPED BASED ON HOW CITY AUTHORITY CAN GUIDE DEVELOPERS THESE ARE GROUPED BASED ON HOW CITIES CAN GIVE TAX INCENTIVES FOR DEVELOPERS TO COMPLETE THESE PROJECTS THESE ARE GROUPED BASED ON CREATING A GREEN NETWORK THAT IS INTEGRATED INTO THE TRANSPORATION FABRIC TOP TAKEAWAYS
7 Regular Title GREEN SPACE GREEN INFRASTRUCTURE GREEN TACTICS/TOOLS STRATEGY TYPOLOGIES2 Bike Path Bioswale Flood Barriers Infiltration Basin Landslide Retaining Wall Living Walls Pedestrian Trails Rainwater Storing Pavement Renewable Energy Sources Silty/Sandy Soil Replacement with Berm and Vegetation Vegetative Retaining Walls Water Quality/ Management Green/Sustainable Development Green Roofs Impervious Pavement Land Aquisition Land Availability Assessment SWOT Assessment Tree Ordinances Urban Infill Community Gardens Courtyards Green Medians Green Streets Green Vacant Parcels Greenways Parks Plazas and Event Spaces Riverfront Utilization Wildlife Corridor

Regular

TYPOLOGIES

Community Garden - A semi-public land parcel gardened and harvested by a collective group of individuals united by their common geographic proximity

Courtyards - An unroofed area that is completely or mostly enclosed by the walls of a large building

Green Medians - The portion of the roadway separating opposing directions of the roadway, or local lanes from through travel lanes covered with native vegetation that provides ecological and environmental benefits, such as biodiversity support or cleaner air

Green Streets – A street with transit use that also incorporates environmental features like trees, rain gardens, infiltration planters, and permeable paving to capture, slow the course of runoff, and filter it naturally before it reaches major waterways and sensitive plant and animal life

Green Vacant Parcels - Pieces of land that do not contain buildings or structures and are intended to be developed for use of green infrastructure, biodiversity protection, or to support the environmental objectives of a community or local government

Greenway - A strip of undeveloped land near an urban area, set aside for recreational use or environmental protection.

Pedestrian Trails - Walking paths that can be integrated into the larger transportation network for daily travel or connected to a park for recreation

Plaza and Event Space - A public square, marketplace, or similar open space in a built-up area used for recreation or community activities

Riverfront Utilization - The way in which land or property along a river is used to balance societal and ecological needs

Wildlife Corridors - A strip of natural habitat connecting populations of wildlife otherwise separated by cultivated land, roads, etc.

8
GREENTitleSPACE
Community Gardens Courtyards Green Medians Green Streets Green Vacant Parcels Greenways Parks Plazas and Event Spaces Riverfront Utilization Wildlife Corridor Conservation Corridor Planning, Northern Virginia Atlanta Beltline | Atlanta, Georgia
CASE STUDIES:

RegularGREENTitleINFRASTRUCTURE TYPOLOGIES

Infiltration Basin Landslide Retaining Wall Living Walls

Bike Paths - A distinct path or road for only bicycles that can be incorporated into the street network to function with automobiles as part of comprehensive transit system.

Bioswale - a long, channeled depression or trench that receives rainwater runoff (as from a parking lot) and has vegetation (such as grasses, flowering herbs, and shrubs) and organic matter (such as mulch) to slow water infiltration and filter out pollutants

Flood Barriers - Any manmade obstruction which serves to prevent, hinder, restrict, bar or alter the passage of flood waters through usual and normal conveyance channels, other than any structure specifically approved as part of a flood control project, which has more than a purely localized effect on conveyance

Infiltration Basin - Infiltration basins are vegetated depressions designed to store runoff on the surface and infiltrate it gradually into the ground. They are dry except in periods of heavy rainfall

Retaining Walls – Engineered structures that stabilize sensitive areas with high landslide susceptibility

Living Walls - Self-sufficient vertical gardens that are attached to the exterior or interior of a building

Rainwater Storing Pavement – Permeable pavement that absorbs rainwater and retains it to cool surfaces as well as to lower and manage the temperature of areas impacted by the urban heat island effect

Renewable Energy Sources - Energy derived from natural sources that are replenished at a higher rate than they are consumed

Silty & Sand Loam Soil Replacement with Berm and Vegetation - A berm is a flat strip of land, raised bank, or terrace used to keep land vulnerable to landslides in place. Silty and sandy loam soil and vegetation stabilize earth that is vulnerable to landslides

Vegetative Retaining Walls – Retaining walls with native plants used to stabilize land that is vulnerable to landslides

Water Quality/Management- monitoring and control of the quality of the water directly affected by a drainage activity, as well as the receiving waters of a drainage activity, to ensure that minimal degradation in surface or ground water quality occurs.

Green/Sustainable Development – A real estate concept that prioritizes fostering economic growth and the expansion of the built environment while ensuring that natural assets continue to provide the resources and environmental services that allow people to live

Pedestrian Trails

Rainwater Storing Pavement Renewable Energy Sources

Pedestrian Trails- Walking paths that can be integrated into the larger transportation network for daily travel or connected to a park for recreation

Green Roof - A layer of vegetation planted over a waterproofing system that is installed on top of a flat or slightly sloped roof.

Silty/Sandy Soil Replacement with Berm and Vegetation Vegetative Retaining Walls Water Quality/ Management

Green/Sustainable Development Green Roofs

9
Bike Path Bioswale Flood Barriers
GreenPlan Philadelphia Green Acres Goal Wanted: Green Acres | Natural Defense Resources Council CASE STUDIES:

Regular

Aquisition

Land Availability

Impervious Surface Pavement Requirements –Regulations placed on the percentage of land in a development that must be constructed with materials that that do not interfere with natural absorption of water into the Earth’s ground water system

Land Acquisition - Acquisition of private land by the government (local, state or federal) in fee simple (through purchase or donation) to protect sensitive areas

Land Availability Assessment - A Strategic Housing Land Availability Assessment (SHLAA) is a technical exercise to determine the quantity and suitability of land potentially available for housing development

SWOT Assessment – Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats assessment that helps

local governments and organizations plan for future climate migration and environmental situations

Tree Ordinances - Policies for how a community wants to maintain and protect its trees. They set standards for selection, planting, maintaining, and conserving community trees. Ordinances seek to establish a legal means of protecting the public interest. Provides environmental benefits such as lower pollution and temperatures

Urban Infill - The process of developing vacant or underutilized parcels within existing developed areas

Tax Incentives - a government measure that is intended to encourage individuals and businesses to spend money or to save money by reducing the amount of tax that they must pay

10
Title
Impervious Pavement
Land
Assessment
SWOT Assessment Tree Ordinances Urban Infill New York City Green Infrastructure Plan | NYC Environmental Protection TREE CITY USA Arbor Day Foundation Wildlife movements in the face of climate change | The Nature Conservancy
CASE STUDIES: GREEN TACTIC & TOOL TYPOLOGIES
BUSINESSES DISTRICT AT INTERSECTION OF GLENWAY AVENUE AND WARSAW AVENUE KROGER SETON HIGH SCHOOL SAINT LAWRENCE CHURCH & SCHOOL GLENWAY WOODS NATURE PRESERVE UNUSED SPORTS FIELD COMMERCIAL RETAIL DISTRICT WARSAW AVENUE GLENWAY AVENUE Bike Paths Improved Bike Network Commercial Corridor Opportunity Space School/ Institution Service Green Space Improved Street Network LEGEND Benefits of Implementing Typologies: • Increase biodiversity with connection of green street network and proposed wildlife corridor • Increase traffic calming along bike network • Decrease stormwater runoff with greened streets Green Streets Wildlife Corridor Green Median Land Availability Assessment 11 Regular Title3 PRICE HILL
Regular Title4 DOWNTOWN GREYHOUND BUS STATION & SURFACE PARKING LOTS ON E COURT STREET & EDDLESTON AVENUE GREYHOUND BUS STATION HAMILTON COUNTY JUVENILE COURT CASINO AND PARKING GARAGE HARD ROCK CASINO SURFACE PARKING E CENTRALPARKWAY E COURT STREET GILBERTAVENUE EGGLESTONAVENUE SURFACE PARKING CINCINNATI FIRE DEPARTMENT STATION 3 REEDY STREET I-471 I-71 I-71 Green Roof Impervious Pavement Rainwater Storing Pavement Bike Path Vegetative Retaining Wall Green/ Sustainable Development Improved Bike Network Commercial Corridor Opportunity Space School/ Institution Service Green Space Improved Street Network LEGEND Benefits of Implementing Typologies: • Reduce Urban Island Effect with rainwater storing pavement • Enhance air quality with green roof and green • Increase walkability and connection to Eden Park with bike path
Regular Title5 EAST END COLUMBIA TUSCULUM HISTORIC DISTRICT AND RIVERFRONT RIVERSIDE EAST ACADEMY COMMERCIAL RETAIL DISTRICT RIVERSIDEDRIVE COLUMBIAPARKWAY COLUMBIAPARKWAY KELLOG AVENUE DELTAAVENUE STANLEYAVENUE RAKESTRAW MEMORIAL FIELD OHIORIVER COMMUNITY GARDEN MT CARMEL BAPTIST CHURCH CARNEGIE CENTER KINDER MORGAN QUEEN CITY TERMINAL ST. STEPHENS CHURCH TURKEY RIDGE PARK OHIO RIVER LAUNCH CLUB Landslide Retaining Wall Community Gardens Land Availability Assessment Green Vacant Parcels Courtyards Green Streets Water Quality/ Management Riverfront Utilization Flood Barriers Renewable Energy Sources Improved Bike Network Commercial Corridor Opportunity Space School/ Institution Service Green Space Improved Street Network LEGEND Benefits of Implementing Typologies: • Decrease flood susceptability with flood barrier for Riverside East Academy • Decrease landslide susceptability with landslide retaining wall • Renewable energy terminal can take pressure off typical energy grid 13
EXISTING GREEN NETWORK MAP
PROPOSED GREEN NETWORK MAP

Regular

1. Bike Paths - A distinct path or road for only bicycles that can be incorporated into the street network to function with automobiles as part of comprehensive transit system.

2. Bioswale - a long, channeled depression or trench that receives rainwater runoff (as from a parking lot) and has vegetation (such as grasses, flowering herbs, and shrubs) and organic matter (such as mulch) to slow water infiltration and filter out pollutants

3. Community Garden - A semi-public land parcel gardened and harvested by a collective group of individuals united by their common geographic proximity

4. Courtyards - An unroofed area that is completely or mostly enclosed by the walls of a large building

5. Flood Barriers - Any manmade obstruction which serves to prevent, hinder, restrict, bar or alter the passage of flood waters through usual and normal conveyance channels, other than any structure specifically approved as part of a flood control project, which has more than a purely localized effect on conveyance.

6. Green Medians - The portion of the roadway separating opposing directions of the roadway, or local lanes from through travel lanes covered with native vegetation that provides ecological and environmental benefits, such as biodiversity support or cleaner air

7. Green Streets – A street with transit use that also incorporates environmental features like trees, rain gardens, infiltration planters, and permeable paving to capture, slow the course of runoff, and filter it naturally before it reaches major waterways and sensitive plant and animal life.

8. Green Vacant Parcels - Pieces of land that do not contain buildings or structures and are intended to be developed for use of green infrastructure, biodiversity protection, or to support the environmental objectives of a community or local government

9. Green/Sustainable Development – A real estate concept that prioritizes fostering economic growth and the expansion of the built environment while ensuring that natural assets

continue to provide the resources and environmental services that allow people to live

10. Greenroof - A layer of vegetation planted over a waterproofing system that is installed on top of a flat or slightly–sloped roof.

11. Greenway - A strip of undeveloped land near an urban area, set aside for recreational use or environmental protection.

12. Impervious Surface Pavement Requirements – Regulations placed on the percentage of land in a development that must be constructed with materials that that do not interfere with natural absorption of water into the Earth’s ground water system

13. Infiltration Basin - Infiltration basins are vegetated depressions designed to store runoff on the surface and infiltrate it gradually into the ground. They are dry except in periods of heavy rainfall.

14. Land Acquisition - Acquisition of private land by the government (local, state or federal) in fee simple (through purchase or donation) to protect sensitive areas

15. Land Availability Assessment - A Strategic Housing Land Availability Assessment (SHLAA) is a technical exercise to determine the quantity and suitability of land potentially available for housing development

16. Living Walls - Self-sufficient vertical gardens that are attached to the exterior or interior of a building.

17. Parks - Large public green areas in a place that are used for recreation or to protect wildlife and natural habitats

18. Pedestrian Trails- Walking paths that can be integrated into the larger transportation network for daily travel or connected to a park for recreation

19. Plaza and Event Space – A public square, marketplace, or similar open space in a built-up area used for recreation or community activities

20.Rainwater Storing Pavement – Permeable pavement that absorbs rainwater and retains it to cool surfaces as well as to lower and manage the temperature of areas impacted by the urban heat island effect

21. Renewable Energy Sources - Energy derived from natural sources that are replenished at a higher rate than they are consumed

22. Riverfront - The land or property along a river

23. Silty & Sand Loam Soil Replacement with Berm and Vegetation - A berm is a flat strip of land, raised bank, or terrace used to keep land vulnerable to landslides in place. Silty and sandy loam soil and vegetation stabilize earth that is vulnerable to landslides

24. SWOT Assessment – Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats assessment that helps local governments and organizations plan for future climate migration and environmental situations

25. Tax Incentives - a government measure that is intended to encourage individuals and businesses to spend money or to save money by reducing the amount of tax that they must pay

26. Tree Ordinances - Policies for how a community wants to maintain and protect its trees. They set standards for selection, planting, maintaining, and conserving community trees. Ordinances seek to establish a legal means of protecting the public interest. Provides environmental benefits such as lower pollution and temperatures

27. Urban Infill - The process of developing vacant or underutilized parcels within existing developed areas

28. Vegetative Retaining Walls – Retaining walls with native plants used to stabilize land that is vulnerable to landslides

29. Water Quality/Management- monitoring and control of the quality of the water directly affected by a drainage activity, as well as the receiving waters of a drainage activity, to ensure that minimal degradation in surface or ground water quality occurs.

30.Wildlife Corridors - A strip of natural habitat connecting populations of wildlife otherwise separated by cultivated land, roads, etc.

16
Title6 APPENDIX/GLOSSARY
COLUMBIA TUSCULUM HISTORIC DISTRICT AND RIVERFRONT GREYHOUND BUS STATION & SURFACE PARKING LOTS ON E COURT STREET & EDDLESTON BUSINESSES DISTRICT AT INTERSECTION OF GLENWAY AVENUE AND WARSAW STRENGTHS • Strong community pride/feel • Historic area with old housing stock • Close to lots of housing developments and not too far from other business district on Delta Avenue • Highway proximity • Community garden can indicate motivated residents OPPORTUNITIES • Green renewable energy terminal along the river • Connect to river recreation opportunities • Improve walkability and sidewalks • Education on water managment • Traffic calming near highway WEAKNESSES • Vacant parcels • Hilly topography, would require foundation checks and resurfacing plots • Lack of connectivity through main streets THREATS • Systemic flooding and landslide issues • Historic area vulnerable to environmental disasters STRENGTHS • Highway access • Right now mostly surface lots so there is room to work with • Hard Rock Casino • Greyhound Station • Lots of people go here for the casino, bus station, or to park • High visability OPPORTUNITIES • Lots of workers at peak hours, what can make their walking experience enjoyable? • Make the Greyhound bus station more pleasant • Tax incentives to make land more attractive and available for public use WEAKNESSES • Has a very grey feel, not a pleasant walk • Right near the casino has inherent stigma, and noise at all hours THREATS • High land cost • Urban Heat Island • Potential to remain transit dominant and heavily polluting which could undermine green infrastructure improvements • Stormwater runoff STRENGTHS • Near a grocery store and other businesses • Dense housing • Within a 25-minute drive of downtown OPPORTUNITIES • Green streets • Better sidewalks • Connect the lower income residential area (north of Glenway) better to schools and the business district • Roads connect also across city to downtown • Vacant parcels WEAKNESSES • Traffic flow during rush hour and school end/ beginning of day • Building stock may not be in the best condition • Lacks walkability • Promotes driving due to location and not so much walking THREATS • Stormwater runoff • Landslides • Developers coming in and changing community character • Lots of community stakeholders 17 Regular Title APPENDIX/GLOSSARY PRICE HILL DOWNTOWN EAST END SWOT ANALYSIS

Regular

ECONOMIC

How economic factors like growth, inflation and interest rates are affecting your decisions

• Will be a costly investment

• Benefits may not be apparent at first or may go unnoticed due to stable conditions

• Potential friction over best utilization of land parcels (direct money makers for the city and private sector versus indirect benefits for the public

• Greater connection of trails for pedestrians and bikes will stimulate future economic prosperity. May not seem cost effective given waiting period to evaluate full economic benefit

• Public-private buy in and partnership

• May not be perceived as a priority to the mayor with other immediate needs, such as homelessness

• Certain aspects may not be completed with changes in government officials

• Policies may be viewed as controversial to private sector

POLITICAL

How government policy and legislation is impacting your decisions.

SOCIAL

How trends and lifestyle changes might impact your decisions

• Better connectivity to amenities through trails and green spaces which are important to mental health and overall wellbeing

• Quality of life and health enhancement through environmental benefits such as better air quality, lower temperatures, and fewer homes and lives lost to landslides and floods

• Social connections through public gathering spaces such as green spaces are likely to reduce isolation of vulnerable populations such as the elderly and children, which can improve opportunities and increase life expectancy

• Potential for less crime due to more people out using the green network

• Competing research for increasingly advanced technologies

• High funding needs to create and implement technology

• Potential for high maintenance costs

• Need for continuous research to maintain equilibrium as population growth and new climate threats emerge

TECHNOLOGY

How new technologies, automation and the pace of technological change are impacting your decisons.

18
Title APPENDIX/GLOSSARY
PEST EVALUATION
19 Regular Title APPENDIX/GLOSSARY GREEN UMBRELLA TRAIL NETWORK

Regular Title

CITATIONS

• Northern Virginia Regional Commission. (2012). Conservation Corridor Planning. https:// www.novaregion.org/1102/Conservation-Corridors-Project

• PLAN NYC, & New York City Environmental Protection. (2010). NYC Green Infrastructure Plan: A Sustainable Strategy for Clean Waterways. https://www1.nyc.gov/site/dep/wa ter/green-infrastructure.page

• WRT Planning, & Stuart Weitzman School of Design University of Pennsylvania. (2011). Planning + Design: Greenplan Philadelphia. WRT. https://www.wrtdesign.com/work/ greenplan-philadelphia.

• Green Umbrella. (2021). Cincinnati connects is now Crown. Green Umbrella - Cincin nati Connects. Retrieved September 15, 2022, from https://greenumbrella.org/TriSta teTrails-CincinnatiConnects

• Stevenage Borough Council. (2021). Green space strategy. Green Space Strate gy. Retrieved October 25, 2022, from https://www.stevenage.gov.uk/environment/ green-spaces/green-space-strategy

• Mass Audubon. (2022). Land conservation strategy. Mass Audubon. Retrieved October 25, 2022, from https://www.massaudubon.org/our-conservation-work/land-conserva tion/strategy

• Denchak, M. (2022, July 25). Green Infrastructure: How to manage water in a sus tainable way. NRDC. Retrieved October 25, 2022, from https://www.nrdc.org/stories/ green-infrastructure-how-manage-water-sustainable-way

• Patva, J. (2020, June 3). Types of retaining walls. Civil Wale. Retrieved October 25, 2022, from https://civilwale.com/types-of-retaining-walls/#Crib_Retaining_Wall

• Law Insider. (2020). Strategy Definitions. Law Insider. Retrieved October 25, 2022, from https://www.lawinsider.com/dictionary/flood-barrier

• Law Insider. (2020). Strategy Definitions. Law Insider. Retrieved October 25, 2022, from https://www.lawinsider.com/dictionary/green-streets

• OECD. (2015). Green growth and sustainable development, what is green growth and how can it help deliver sustainable development? OECD. Retrieved October 25, 2022, from https://www.oecd.org/greengrowth/whatisgreengrowthandhowcanithelpdeliver sustainabledevelopment.htm

• Susdrain. (2020). Infiltration Basin. Susdrain. Retrieved October 25, 2022, from https:// www.susdrain.org/delivering-suds/using-suds/suds-components/infiltration/infiltra tion-basin.html

• Planning for Hazards. (2022). Land acquisition. Land Acquisition | Planning For Hazards. Retrieved October 25, 2022, from https://planningforhazards.com/land-acquisition

• London Government. (2020, March 4). Strategic Housing Land Availability Assessment. London City Hall. Retrieved October 25, 2022, from https://www.london.gov.uk/whatwe-do/planning/london-plan/new-london-plan/strategic-housing-land-availabili ty-assessment

• Green Over Grey. (2020). What are living walls. What are Living Walls? Definition of Green Wall and Vertical Garden. Retrieved October 25, 2022, from http://www.gree novergrey.com/living-walls/what-are-living-walls.php

• United Nations. (2017). What is renewable energy? United Nations. Retrieved October 25, 2022, from https://www.un.org/en/climatechange/what-is-renewable-energy

• Collins English Dictionary. (2022). Tax incentive definition and meaning. Tax incentive definition and meaning | Collins English Dictionary. Retrieved October 25, 2022, from https://www.collinsdictionary.com/us/dictionary/english/tax-incentive

• Law Insider. (2020). Water Quality Management. Law Insider. Retrieved October 25, 2022, from https://www.lawinsider.com/dictionary/water-quality-management

• Atlanta Beltline. (2022). Home. Atlanta Beltline. Retrieved October 25, 2022, from https://beltline.org/

• Valderrama, A. (2016, December 15). Wanted: Green acres: How Philadelphia’s Greened Acre Retrofit program is catalyzing low-cost green infrastructure retrofits on private property. NRDC. Retrieved October 25, 2022, from https://www.nrdc.org/resources/ wanted-green-acres-how-philadelphias-greened-acre-retrofit-program-catalyz ing-low-cost

• Arbor Day Foundation. (2022). Tree City USA. Tree City USA at arborday.org. Retrieved October 25, 2022, from https://www.arborday.org/programs/treeCityUSA/index.cfm

• Hausheer, J. E., Miller, M. L., Keffer, K., & Byington, C. C. (2018, October 8). Migration in motion: Visualizing Species Movements due to climate change. Cool Green Science. Retrieved October 25, 2022, from https://blog.nature.org/science/2016/08/19/migra tion-in-motion-visualizing-species-movements-due-to-climate-change/

• ArcGIS Online

• Cadmapper Software

• CAGIS Data

20
APPENDIX/GLOSSARY

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
Strategic Plan | Assignment 3 by Lizzy Geraghty - Issuu