Magdalene Laundries - The True Story

2024.1 Edition

Displays above 9 inch

Magdalene Laundries Liberate Grace Reveals the Dark Side of Ireland The True Story of the Scandals and Abuses of the Irish Governments perpetrated against the Young Women of the Magdalene Laundries and the Mother and Baby Homes from 1765 to 2024.

www.liberategrace.com

12/13/23

Liberate Grace Reveals the Dark Side of Ireland The True Story of the Scandals and Abuses of the Irish Governments perpetrated against the Young Women of the Magdalene Laundries and the Mother and Baby Homes from 1765 to 2024.

Exterior of the “Magdalene Laundries” (Casa Magdalena) in Dublin closed at the end of 1996 (Photo credits: www.liberategrace.com)

The Magdalene Laundries, a dark chapter in the history of Ireland, represent a shadow that extends for over two centuries. Often, the information published about them is incomplete or contradictory, or it lacks reliable sources, which provides the reader with a distorted view of what really happened.

In fact, in Ireland until the end of 1996, girls or young women who were sexually abused could be incarcerated for life in the Magdalene Laundries by the Irish authorities [1].

These institutions were founded as charitable works by members of the Irish nobility and subsequently came under the aegis of the Irish government, which delegated their daily operations to third-party associations.

© Liberate Grace 2024

Page 1 of 13 License Terms BY-NC-ND

Liberate Grace Reveals the Dark Side of Ireland The True Story of the Scandals and Abuses of the Irish Governments perpetrated against the Young Women of the Magdalene Laundries and the Mother and Baby Homes from 1765 to 2024.

The first Magdalene House was founded in Dublin in 1765 by Lady Arabella Denny [2], an Anglican philanthropist and daughter of Count Thomas FitzMaurice, who in turn was the nephew of Baron William FitzMaurice [3].

The conditions inside these laundries were of unimaginable cruelty. It is not possible to quantify the exact number of girls and young women confined in these structures. From the available archives, it appears that at least several tens of thousands of them were arrested under Irish law and then transferred by the authorities to the Magdalene Laundries, where they were subjected to forced silence, incessant surveillance, and emotional and physical abuses of unheard-of severity. Very often these women were guilty only of having been raped, of being unmarried mothers, or of being prostitutes. Sometimes they were women convicted of minor crimes, such as petty theft, and only rarely also for serious crimes such as infanticide [4].

Young girls in a “Magdalene Laundries” in Ireland at the beginning of the twentieth century (Photo credits: Public Domain)

In 2013, an investigation led by Irish Senator Martin McAleese, officially known as the “Report of the Interdepartmental Committee to Establish the Facts of the State’s Involvement with the Magdalene Laundries”, revealed that the Irish government and the state police force, “Garda”, bore significant responsibility for sending women to the Magdalene Laundries and failing to protect their © Liberate Grace 2024

Page 2 of 13 License Terms BY-NC-ND

Liberate Grace Reveals the Dark Side of Ireland The True Story of the Scandals and Abuses of the Irish Governments perpetrated against the Young Women of the Magdalene Laundries and the Mother and Baby Homes from 1765 to 2024. rights as workers. From this investigation, it appears that the laundries were not private structures (this means that they were public by law, therefore owned by the Irish State, Ed.), and the vast majority of girls and young women were sent there against their will [5].

In 1921 the “Bethany House for Mother and Child” was founded, also known more simply as Bethany House. This house, subject to inspections by the Ministry for Housing, Local Authorities and Heritage, was known to the Irish judicial system as a place of detention for Protestant women [6][7]. In the 1950s, Bethany House facilitated the adoption of children by Protestant families in the United States, and others were transferred to England; some of the latter were subsequently sent to Australia [8].

The facility was closed between 1971 and 1972. In 2011, the surviving residents requested to be included in the investigation led by Senator Martin McAleese on the State’s involvement in the case of the Magdalene Laundries, as similarities were highlighted between the two institutions and the needs of the survivors. In June 2011, the then Irish Minister of Education, Ruairi Quinn, announced the Irish government’s refusal to include Bethany House in the McAleese investigation. The then Deputy Minister, at the Ministry of Health, Kathleen Lynch was expelled from the Irish Parliament while trying to raise the issue of the survivors of Bethany House with the then minister of the centerright party Fianna Fáil [9].

In 2021, Dr Michael Jackson and John McDowell, the Anglican Archbishops of Dublin and Armagh respectively, officially apologized on behalf of the Anglican Church of Ireland for the role it played in shaping the society that led to austere institutions like the Magdalene Laundries and the Mother and Baby Homes.

The Archbishops recalled that the Mother and Baby Homes housed young women and girls who became pregnant out of wedlock until a few decades ago, and although operating under the “Protestant Ethos”, their management had no connection with the Anglican Church of Ireland. Finally, they added: “We must all be ashamed of the climate that has driven so many women and children towards these facilities” [10].

© Liberate Grace 2024

Page 3 of 13 License Terms BY-NC-ND

Liberate Grace Reveals the Dark Side of Ireland The True Story of the Scandals and Abuses of the Irish Governments perpetrated against the Young Women of the Magdalene Laundries and the Mother and Baby Homes from 1765 to 2024.

“Bethany Mother and Baby Home” in Dublin, Ireland, European Union (Photo credits: Public Domain)

The words of the Catholic Archbishop, Mons. Eamon Martin, in 2021 were much stronger. The Archbishop, after expressing his regret and asking forgiveness from the survivors of the Mother and Baby Homes and the Magdalene Laundries, recalled that the terrifying events that occurred in these structures must push Ireland to undertake “the journey towards healing and repair”, adding that “No mother or child today should feel unwelcome, unwanted or unloved. No father today should shirk his responsibilities. No priest, bishop, nun or lay member of the Church today should deny the mercy and forgiveness of Jesus. No family today should avoid their own child to protect a misguided notion of ‘respectability’ in the parish community. We still have much to learn and much work to do”. Mons. Eamon Martin concludes by saying that the investigation still leaves “room for further investigations” and encourages all the heads of the Churches and the Irish State to “extend their full cooperation”, so that “those who have been most affected can be helped to find hope and peace for the future” [11].

© Liberate Grace 2024

Page 4 of 13 License Terms BY-NC-ND

Liberate Grace Reveals the Dark Side of Ireland The True Story of the Scandals and Abuses of the Irish Governments perpetrated against the Young Women of the Magdalene Laundries and the Mother and Baby Homes from 1765 to 2024.

“Bessborough Mother and Baby Home”, Ireland, European Union (Photo credits: Public Domain)

The Mother and Baby Homes and the Magdalene Laundries served as a source for adoptions. In fact, human trafficking by the Irish government to facilitate adoptions does not seem to have been an isolated case. Between 1940 and 1970, the trafficking of minors involved at least 2,000 children who were torn from the arms of their mothers to be trafficked mainly to the United States of America. According to a recent report corroborated by strong evidence, arbitrary detention, forced labour, coercive and illegal adoption, and inhuman and degrading treatment occurred systematically throughout the network of institutions and government agencies that were supposed to take care of unmarried families. The co-director of the report, Claire McGettrick, stated that the documents held by the Irish State are still secret and therefore inaccessible [12].

These abuses continued unabated from the establishment of the “Free State of Ireland” in 1922 until the end of the 20th century, with the approval of all subsequent Irish governments. It is paradoxical to talk about the “Free State of Ireland” when tens of thousands of girls and young women lived in a real state of slavery. The girls and young women were imprisoned and were forced to © Liberate Grace 2024

Page 5 of 13 License Terms BY-NC-ND

Liberate Grace Reveals the Dark Side of Ireland The True Story of the Scandals and Abuses of the Irish Governments perpetrated against the Young Women of the Magdalene Laundries and the Mother and Baby Homes from 1765 to 2024. work for free mainly in the laundries, as these institutions had to be selfsufficient by generating profits; probably also for those who had personal interests in the existence of these structures.

St Mary’s Domestic Training Centre, Stanhope Street in Dublin, Ireland, European Union (Photo credits: Public Domain)

The conditions inside these “laundries” were in all respects comparable to those of prisons, and confinement often involved various coercive measures.

If a woman managed to escape from one of these institutions, she was sought, captured, and re-incarcerated in the Magdalene Laundries by the Irish police “Garda” [13].

In 2013, despite ongoing pressure from public opinion, Enda Kenny, the “Taoiseach” and head of the Irish government at the time, did not present a complete formal apology. Instead, he merely expressed a timid “regret” for the stigma associated with the girls and young women who were incarcerated in the Magdalene Laundries [14].

Subsequently, a compensation program for surviving victims was established.

In 2020, however, the Irish press reports that only a minority of victims have received the due compensation, albeit very modest. The recent average © Liberate Grace 2024

Page 6 of 13 License Terms BY-NC-ND

Liberate Grace Reveals the Dark Side of Ireland The True Story of the Scandals and Abuses of the Irish Governments perpetrated against the Young Women of the Magdalene Laundries and the Mother and Baby Homes from 1765 to 2024. compensation theoretically recognized by the Irish government would amount to about 36 thousand euros for each surviving victim [15][16].

The actions of the Irish government demonstrate that the life of a human being, particularly a girl or young woman, is valued at only a few thousand euros and does not warrant any further rights or protection. Conversely, in the “Free State of Ireland” the private profit of multinationals receives due protection. For example, the Irish government allows Apple to pay only 0.005% of taxes [17], fifty euros for every million in turnover [18], or guarantees The Coca-Cola Company to pay only 1.4% (one point four percent) of taxes [19][20].

This tax haven approach is applied to sales made throughout the European Union market. Therefore, Irish politicians not only subtract resources from their fellow citizens but cause serious harm to all Member States of the European Union and their citizens and/or residents. Ireland: a true paradise for profit but a real hell for the female gender.

To date, the cabinet of the “Emerald Isle” has not yet fully recognized its responsibilities in these abuses perpetrated against tens of thousands of women. In fact, the Irish government has never compensated all the surviving victims of the Magdalene Laundries and the Mother and Baby Homes.

Public opinion has long erroneously attributed the responsibility for these horrors solely to the management of these structures by religious orders. No religious order was in charge of managing the Magdalene Laundries for 158 years, from 1765 to 1922. Only after 1922 did the Irish government manage the operations of the Magdalene Laundries in collaboration with four religious orders [21]: 1. The Sisters of Mercy, order founded by the Irish Catherine Elizabeth McAuley [22] 2. Soeurs de la Charité de Notre Dame d'Evron, order founded by the French Perrine Brunet [23] 3. Sisters of Charity, order founded by the Irish Mary Aikenhead [24] 4. Sisters of the Good Shepherd, order founded by the French Mary Euphrasia Pelletier [25]

© Liberate Grace 2024

Page 7 of 13 License Terms BY-NC-ND

Liberate Grace Reveals the Dark Side of Ireland The True Story of the Scandals and Abuses of the Irish Governments perpetrated against the Young Women of the Magdalene Laundries and the Mother and Baby Homes from 1765 to 2024.

In 2017, the United Nations criticized the Irish government for not implementing the recommendations communicated to it and related to investigations into allegations of mistreatment and abuse suffered by women incarcerated in the Magdalene Laundries. The United Nations Committee against Torture strongly criticizes the government for not having prosecuted those responsible and for not having ensured that the victims had an effective right to compensation [26].

It is difficult to think that an institution as well-known as the Magdalene Laundries could operate on the territory of the Republic of Ireland without any control by the government authorities: it is not credible.

The Irish governments have always declined any responsibility regarding the Magdalene Laundries, claiming that these structures were privately managed by the nuns, the only ones responsible for the events inside the structures, and that the government had no involvement. What emerged not only exposes the Irish government, but could have permanently tarnished its reputation and authority in the eyes of the international community [27].

In fact, the claims of the Irish governments were refuted by the investigation of Senator McAleese. The report that emerged, in addition to revealing a significant and continuous involvement of the Irish State, concludes that there were no physical or sexual abuses committed by the nuns, and no evidence emerged relating to the other charges attributed to them [28].

The recent law passed by parliament in 2020, which many consider shameful and harmful, further corroborates the hypothesis that the Irish government still has much, perhaps too much, to hide. This law, which many consider shameful and harmful, seals for a further 30 years the records relating to the abuses committed by Irish institutions on the girls and young women incarcerated in the Magdalene Laundries [29].

It’s worth noting that this law, passed by the Irish parliament, is in full violation of not only international law and human rights, but also European law and regulations, such as the General Regulation on Data Protection (GDPR) [30], which the Irish government is obliged to obey. It should also be remembered that the European Commission or the other Member States can bring the Irish government before the Court of Justice of the European Union for not having applied European Union law [31]. It may not be long before we see the Irish © Liberate Grace 2024

Page 8 of 13 License Terms BY-NC-ND

Liberate Grace Reveals the Dark Side of Ireland The True Story of the Scandals and Abuses of the Irish Governments perpetrated against the Young Women of the Magdalene Laundries and the Mother and Baby Homes from 1765 to 2024. government condemned once again for violation of human and fundamental rights of the European Union.

In 2021, Dr. Maeve O’Rourke, from the Irish Center for Human Rights, requested access to the archives of the Magdalena House located in the town of Donnybrook in Dublin. This legitimate request for access to the archives made by Dr O’Rourke, although it is provided for by FOI-FOIA and GDPR regulations [32][33], was refused on the basis of a mere easily surmountable pretext [34].

As if that were not enough, in 2022, the Irish government continued to surprise many with its behavior, which is considered recidivist in terms of human rights violations. According to the site “NOYB - European Center for Digital Rights” with a last-minute amendment to the law “Courts and Civil Law (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2022”, the Irish government added a provision that would allow the Irish Commissioner for Data Protection to declare almost all of his procedures “confidential”. In fact, the “Section 26A” of the Irish law would make most of the reports, by European citizens, on procedures or decisions of the Irish Commissioner for Data Protection a crime. So simply talking about unfair procedures that often affect millions of people would become a crime, even when the Irish Commissioner for Data Protection, the government or multinationals based in Ireland, which process the data of European citizens, adopt extreme positions or act illegally [35].

The “Section 26A” of the law could be used by the Irish Commissioner for Data Protection to prohibit the sharing of documents with other whistleblowers, other regulators or even European authorities such as the European Committee for Data Protection (EDPB).

Should the surviving women of the Magdalene Laundries remain dissatisfied with the complaint procedure following a refusal of access to their data, they could face criminal sanctions if they expressed public criticism. The mere threat of a criminal sanction will undoubtedly silence most people who will thus be deprived of the fundamental rights guaranteed by the European Union [36].

We must never forget the horrors that the young women and their children experienced in the Magdalene Laundries and the Mother and Baby Homes.

The perpetrators can only be forgiven by the victims of those atrocities. But © Liberate Grace 2024

Page 9 of 13 License Terms BY-NC-ND

Liberate Grace Reveals the Dark Side of Ireland The True Story of the Scandals and Abuses of the Irish Governments perpetrated against the Young Women of the Magdalene Laundries and the Mother and Baby Homes from 1765 to 2024. who, we must ask, were the perpetrators of these abuses? Were they the families who deprived their mothers, sisters, and daughters of love and disowned them? Were they perhaps the governments that made laws to incriminate and exploit them? Were they instead the Irish police forces that incarcerated them and abused them with force and violated their dignity as human beings? Or was it the Archbishop of Dublin who forgot to honour the Word of God every day according to his Pastoral principles?

Although the only responsible party with the authority to determine the fate of the women incarcerated in the Magdalene Laundries remains the Irish government, the concurrence of guilt involves all the actors listed above. The violence and contempt to which these women were subjected was the failure of human society as a whole, unfortunately still permeated by pride and sloth.

It is difficult to understand why in almost three centuries the conduct of the Irish government has always been disrespectful of the dignity of these women and their children.

Children awaiting adoption sent to the Nidgee orphanage in Australia in 1928 (Photo credits: Public Domain)

© Liberate Grace 2024

Page 10 of 13 License Terms BY-NC-ND

Liberate Grace Reveals the Dark Side of Ireland The True Story of the Scandals and Abuses of the Irish Governments perpetrated against the Young Women of the Magdalene Laundries and the Mother and Baby Homes from 1765 to 2024.

The girls and young girls of the past and the only survivors of today, now elderly, have been denied any recognition, not only material but also moral.

European politicians and the vast majority of European public opinion believe that the horror of the Magdalene Laundries and the lack of compensation, as established by the High Court, by the Irish government towards these violated women, deserves to be brought to trial before the Court of Justice of the European Union in order to reach a definitive resolution that can give them a bit of peace and serenity. They deserve the peace and serenity that society has denied them for so long.

In 2024, after over 250 years of abuses, European civil society has the moral right, as well as the duty, to remedy this failure of the Irish governments. It is essential that an immediate repair, both moral and economic, is forcefully demanded, without further procrastination. We conclude by remembering that the Magdalene Laundries were institutions sponsored by the Irish State where women were incarcerated and forced to work without being paid. Their crimes?

Some had been sexually abused, others had been raped, others still were locked up because they had a reputation considered immoral by the State and society of the time [37]. As the famous Italian journalist Antonio Lubrano used to say: “The question arises spontaneously” who really committed the crimes?

The Irish governments have repeatedly demonstrated their desire to obtain all possible benefits from the European Union while disregarding its rules and the fundamental rights of citizens. But the “Free State of Ireland” can never be either free or a State until it respects the women who have contributed, with their sacrifice, to its birth.

Sources [1]https://www.family-tree.co.uk/news/last-magdalene-asylum-closes-on-this-day-in-history/ [2]https://www.britannica.com/topic/Magdalene-laundry [3]https://landedestates.ie/family/1887 [4]https://www.indymedia.ie/attachments/jun2011/bethany_home_and_state_nm_for_min_24may11.pdf [5]https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/feb/05/magdalene-laundries-ireland-state-guilt [6]https://web.archive.org/web/20190313060058/http://www.magdalenelaundries.com/press/JFM%20PR%2024-06-11.pdf [7]https://www.historyireland.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Bethany_HI_expanded__plus_mag_ver_Sep-Oct2010_.pdf [8]https://www.historyireland.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Bethany_HI_expanded__plus_mag_ver_Sep-Oct2010_.pdf [9]https://www.rte.ie/news/2011/0622/302705-bethany/ [10]https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-northern-ireland-55675544

© Liberate Grace 2024

Page 11 of 13 License Terms BY-NC-ND

Liberate Grace Reveals the Dark Side of Ireland The True Story of the Scandals and Abuses of the Irish Governments perpetrated against the Young Women of the Magdalene Laundries and the Mother and Baby Homes from 1765 to 2024.

[11]https://www.agensir.it/quotidiano/2021/1/27/irlanda-del-nord-rapporto-su-mother-and-baby-homes-and-magdalene-laundries-monsmartin-vescovi-irlandesi-chiedo-perdono-ai-sopravvissuti/ [12]https://www.irishpost.com/news/heartbreaking-report-reveals-2000-irish-children-sold-us-adoption-mother-baby-homes-160891 [13]https://aran.library.nuigalway.ie/bitstream/handle/10379/15636/O_Rourke_M_and_Smith_J_M_Ireland_s_Magda.pdf [14]https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/feb/05/ireland-magdalene-laundry-system-apology [15]https://www.independent.ie/news/36000-euro-for-magdalene-survivors/30430343.html [16]https://www.irishtimes.com/news/social-affairs/religion-and-beliefs/magdalene-survivors-insist-state-not-fulfilling-terms-ofcompensation-scheme-1.4288657 [17]https://www.cnbc.com/2016/08/30/how-apples-irish-subsidiaries-paid-a-0005-percent-tax-rate-in-2014.html [18]https://www.irishmirror.ie/news/irish-news/apple-paid-just-50-tax-8733883 [19]https://www.irishtimes.com/business/economy/how-did-coca-cola-pay-a-tax-rate-of-just-1-4-in-ireland-1.4432940 [20]https://www.irishtimes.com/business/manufacturing/coca-cola-paid-tax-on-1-4-on-irish-profits-of-up-to-2-5bn-us-court-1.4414091 [21]https://www.britannica.com/topic/Magdalene-laundry [22]https://sistersofmercy.ie/catherine-mcauley/ [23]https://www.soeurs-charite-evron.com/histoire.php [24]https://rsccaritas.com/who-we-are/mary-aikenhead/ [25]https://rgs.gssweb.org/ [26]https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/un-criticises-government-for-not-investigating-magdalene-laundries/36022766.html [27]https://www.rte.ie/culture/2021/1108/1256715-review-ireland-the-magdalene-laundries-a-campaign-for-justice/ [28]https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/feb/05/ireland-magdalene-laundry-system-apology [29]https://ohrh.law.ox.ac.uk/sealing-the-records-of-irish-institutional-abuse/ [30]https://ohrh.law.ox.ac.uk/sealing-the-records-of-irish-institutional-abuse/ [31]https://eur-lex.europa.eu/EN/legal-content/summary/infringement-of-eu-law.html [32]http://www.foia.gov.it/ [33]https://europa.eu/youreurope/business/dealing-with-customers/data-protection/data-protection-gdpr/index_it.htm [34]https://www.irishtimes.com/ireland/2023/03/04/state-accused-of-stonewalling-and-hiding-evidence-over-magdalene-laundries/ [35]https://noyb.eu/en/irish-gov-makes-critizising-big-tech-and-irish-dpc-crime [36]https://noyb.eu/en/ireland-corrupt-gdpr-procedures-now-confidential [37] https://www.bigissue.com/culture/tv/the-woman-in-the-wall-what-is-the-true-story-of-irelands-magdalene-laundries/

© Liberate Grace 2024

Page 12 of 13 License Terms BY-NC-ND

Liberate Grace Reveals the Dark Side of Ireland The True Story of the Scandals and Abuses of the Irish Governments perpetrated against the Young Women of the Magdalene Laundries and the Mother and Baby Homes from 1765 to 2024.

2024.1 Edition

License Agreement This work is licensed for use under the terms of the CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. To read the full license, visit the website: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/legalcode.en

1. Attribution - If you are reproducing this work, you must include with it the code or the wording below: Code for Website (HTML) <a href="https://www.liberategrace.com/"> Magdalene Laundries. Liberate Grace Reveals the Dark Side of Ireland © 2024 di Liberate Grace è concessa in licenza d’uso secondo i termini del contratto: Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International. Per leggere la licenza completa, visitare il sito web: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-ncnd/4.0/legalcode.it</a>

Wording for Printed Paper and other Media Magdalene Laundries. Liberate Grace Reveals the Dark Side of Ireland © 2024 di Liberate Grace è concessa in licenza d’uso secondo i termini del contratto: Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International. Per leggere la licenza completa, visitare il sito web: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/legalcode.it

2. NonCommercial - You may not use the material for commercial purposes, except for public domain photos.

3. NoDerivatives - You cannot transform, modify, adapt or alter in any way the work or the materials contained therein, except for public domain photos.

4. No additional restrictions - You may not apply legal terms or technological measures that legally restrict others from doing anything the license permits.

Limitation of Liability and Warranty Exclusion This publication is provided ‘as is’, without any warranty, either express or implied, including, but not limited to, warranties of merchantability, fitness for a particular purpose or non-infringement.

Despite the publication being produced with the utmost care possible, based on current knowledge and technologies, the information gathered from sources does not necessarily represent the author’s point of view or the owners of the website from which it was downloaded.

The author of this publication assumes no responsibility for any errors or omissions in the information provided, nor for the results obtained from their use. To the maximum extent permitted by law, the author will not be liable for any losses or damages of any kind resulting from the use of this publication, including, but not limited to, direct, indirect, incidental, punitive and consequential damages.

The author does not guarantee the accuracy, completeness or suitability of the information contained in this publication for any purpose. In the event that errors or inaccuracies are believed to exist, it is possible to exercise the ‘Right of Rectification’. The information contained in this publication can be modified or updated without notice.

This limitation of liability and the exclusion of warranty are governed by the laws of the European Union. Any dispute arising from the use of this publication will be subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of the courts of the European Union.

Right of Rectification It is possible to submit a rectification request to the following email address: editor@liberategrace.com

© Liberate Grace 2024

Page 13 of 13 License Terms BY-NC-ND