Res Gestae - May/June 2025

THE OFFICIAL AWARD-WINNING PUBLICATION OF THE LEE COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION

FAMILIES FIGHTING FOR JUSTICE

SPRING SYMPOSIUM:

Biohacking… Mind, Heart & Body

LEADING WITH

PURPOSE MEET YOUR EXECUTIVE BOARD

LEADERSHIP&LAW

MAY/JUNE 2025

EXPERIENCED SPECIALIST TO REFER PERSONAL INJURY CASES

Randall L. Spivey: Board Certified by The Florida Bar as a specialist in Civil Trial law (2001 – present) Rated AV Preeminent by Martindale Hubbell Selected to Florida Super Lawyers Client Distinction Award and Gold Client Champion by Martindale Hubbell

•

Maximum Referral Fees Paid

•

More than 28 years of experience with numerous jury trials throughout Florida

Serving ALL of Florida randall l. spivey

SpiveyLaw.com 239.337.7483 Main Office

randall l. spivey

13400 Parker Commons Blvd Fort Myers, FL 33912

United We Stand...

For the Accused

All Criminal Charges, Felonies and Misdemeanors, State & Federal

Aggressive Criminal Defense

Over 150 Years of Combined Experience

239.277.5297 MuscaLaw.com Attorney John Musca 21 Year Veteran Defense Attorney

2200 Martin Luther King Blvd.

Fort Myers, FL 33901

41

MAY/JUNE 2025

JUDICIAL SPOTLIGHT

The Hon. Trent Reichling

6

42

LETTER FROM PRESIDENT

INTERIOR FEATURE

Highlights For May & June John Miller, III, Esq.

8

Local Students Rock Mock Trial 2025 Maria Alaimo, Esq.

16

LETTER FROM EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR

Finding Our Moments Lauren Baugh

44 YLD

Growing With Guidance Gabriel Arbois, Esq.

46

ON THE COVER

10

HEALTH & WELLNESS SYMPOSIUM

SPECIAL EVENTS CALENDAR

48

12

COMMUNITY CONNECTION

ETHICALLY SPEAKING

Harry Chapin Food Bank

50

Court Affirms Court Orders Can Be Proof of Rule Violations Henry Lee Paul, Esq.

100 CLUB

51

MEMBER SPOTLIGHT

16

Rob Anderson

53

COVER FEATURE

FOUNDATION SPONSORS

Leading With Purpose Meet Your LCBA Executive Board

54

IN THE NEWS

25

WELCOME NEW MEMBERS

26

PRACTICE SECTION

Family Law in Motion: 2025 Updates, Events & CLEs Kayla Richmond, Esq.

28

INTERIOR FEATURE

A Foundation of Support for Lee County Ryan Downey

59

Pictured: LCBA members at Law in the Mall during Law Week 2025.

THANK YOU TO OUR SPONSORS

61

DONOR LISTING

30

37

Out of Many, One - The Tradition of Law Week 2025 Lauren Baugh

Looking Back at the Ladies in the Law T. Rankin Terry, Jr., JD, LLM

INTERIOR FEATURE

34

PRACTICE SECTION

Florida Criminal Law Changes Asma Anwar

TERRY'S TAKE ON THINGS

Mental Health & Wellness

62

SPONSOR SPOTLIGHT

Boy Agnew Pontavic Miller

63

SPONSOR SPOTLIGHT

38

LEGAL LENS

Shrimp Boil

Goldstein Buckley, Cechman, Rice, Purtz, Smith & Smith

AD DIRECTORY Aloia Roland Barbara M. Pizzolato Bill Burke Boy Agnew Potanovic Miller Brazzeal Mediation Business Observer Dal Lago Law

4 LEEBAR.ORG

22-23 60 60 9 9 60 51

DeMine Immigration Law Firm Donna (Tisch) Lugar Edison National Bank Henderson Franklin Law Offices of Dennis L. Webb Mark Loren Designs Mediate with Ody (Dickman Law Firm)

50 25 64 7 24 24 60

Musca Law Office, Inc. Priority Marketing Roetzel Senior Advocacy Group Spivey Law Firm Personal Injury Stockman Mediation The North Law Firm, P.A.

3 40 7 58 2 51 5

For over 30 years, we have been representing clients in Accident and Injury cases.

Attorney Joe North

Car & Truck Accidents Motorcycle Accidents Drunk Driving Accidents Serious Injury Cases Family Law Custody & Support Cases Hurricane Property Damage Claims Paralysis Cases Apartment Shootings Gun Violence Cases Courtroom Trials Workers Compensation Wrongful Death Cases Pedestrian Accidents Bicycle Accidents Dog Bite Cases Slip & Fall Accidents Negligent Security Cases Attorney Joseph North Settlements

(239) 337-1191

TheNorthLawFirm.com

& JUNE 2025 5 5220 Summerlin Commons Blvd., Suite 300 | Fort Myers, Florida MAY 33907

PRESIDENT'S LETTER

Highlights For May & June It has been another fantastic couple of months since the last issue, and I’m excited to share highlights from recent events and provide a glimpse of what’s ahead for our organization.

This year’s Bench Bar-B-Q and Shrimp Boil was a tremendous success, with a record-breaking turnout at our new venue, the IMAG History & Science Center. I want to thank Lauren Baugh, our Executive Director, for her exceptional planning, Jerry VonGruben and Judge Robert Branning for their delicious low-country boil, all of our amazing sponsors, and everyone who attended to help make the event so much fun. A special thank you goes to those who volunteered in the dunk tank to raise funds for the Lee County Bar Association Foundation, including (but not limited to) Fort Myers Mayor Kevin Anderson and Lee County Clerk of Courts and Comptroller Kevin Karnes. Shout out to the Law Firm of Scott T. Moorey for sponsoring the dunk tank and the unlimited balls! Your participation and generosity at, and to, events like these make a real difference.

Our Mock Trial Competition was another big highlight of the last two months. The county competition was a huge success, and all the schools that participated did a great job. I want to pass along a big congratulations to Fort Myers High School, the county and Circuit tournament winners, who represented us exceptionally well at the state level. A big kudos to our very own Ben O’Brien, who won the Best Attorney Award for the entire competition!

Looking forward, Law Week is just around the corner, and I encourage everyone to join us for all of the great activities that take place, including the blood drive and Law in the Mall.

I would love to see a great turnout for the Law Week Awards Luncheon on Friday, May 2, at the Riverside Community Center.

It’s a wonderful opportunity to celebrate the achievements of our peers and reflect on the work we do as a legal community.

LEE COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION ADMINISTRATION Executive Director Lauren Baugh

Administrative Assistant Mairelis Tamayo

EXECUTIVE COUNCIL President John Miller, III, Esq.

President Emeritus Hon. Kathy Smith

Vice President John Dommerich, Jr., Esq.

Secretary Kristianna Soto, Esq.

YLD President Kevin Huguelet, Esq.

Treasurer Dawn Maselli, Esq.

BOARD MEMBERS

JUDICIAL LIAISONS

COMMITTEE CHAIRS

LCBA Foundation Charity Golf Tournament Ryan Downey, Esq. Andrew Koehler, Esq.

Erin Casey, Esq. Jerry Olivo, Esq. Blake Rizzolo, Esq. Megan Strayhorn, Esq.

Bench-Bar Gala Diana “Dawn” Maselli, Esq. Health and Wellness Hon. Kimberly Davis Bocelli Ashley Kogan-Weed, Esq. John Miller, III, Esq. History Hon. Jenna Persons-Mulicka E. Bruce Strayhorn, Esq. Megan Strayhorn, Esq. Law-Related Education T. Rankin Terry, Jr., JD, LLM Law Week Hon. John Carlin

Hon. Robert Branning Hon. Devin George

Mock Trial Maria Alaimo, Esq. Shaina Zuppke, Esq. Paralegal TBA Pro Bono Andrew Banyai, Esq. Peter Dennis, Esq. Mental Health Initiative Committee Holly Cosby, Esq. Dawn Maselli, Esq.

PRACTICE SECTION CHAIRS Alternative Dispute Resolution Anne Dalton, Esq. Alexandra Kleinfeldt, Esq.

Immigration Law Nirupa Netram, Esq. Pablo Hurtado, Esq.

There are many other activities and events coming up that provide an excellent opportunity to get involved with the Lee County Bar Association. Please feel free to reach out to us if you have any questions about getting involved.

Criminal Law Asma Anwar, Esq.

Intellectual Property Law Mark Nieds, Esq.

Elder Law Lisa Gelman, Esq. Blake Hampton, Esq.

Land Use and Governmental Law Zachary Liebetreu, Esq.

Thank you for your continued support and engagement with the LCBA.

Family Law Kayla Richmond, Esq. Magistrate Christopher Whitney

John Miller, III, Esq., LCBA President JohnM@bapfirm.com | 239.208.6542 6 LEEBAR.ORG

General Civil and Business Litigation Joel Hyatt, Esq. Kara Jursinski Murphy, Esq.

Real Property, Probate and Trust Law Peter Knize, JD, LLM Solo & Small Firm Conor Foley, Esq. Tort Litigation Diana “Dawn” Maselli, Esq.

1

FAMILY DRAMA

t

r u

3

l

i

s t

i

g

a

t

i

o

ACROSS 3. Protective legal action 5. Process involving distribution of assets 6. A leading law firm DOWN 1. Property held for good of beneficiary 2. City in Lee County 4. City in Collier County

4

R

O

r t

m

p

r

o

b

a

E

T Z

E

L

l

6

s

f o

n a

5

2

t

y

e r s

KEY CONTACT: JAMIE SCHWINGHAMER | JSCHWINGHAMER@RALAW.COM | 239.213.3887

Roetzel & Andress, LPA offers solutions for your most puzzling trust and estate matters. As a leading law firm located in Naples and Fort Myers, our attorneys regularly represent beneficiaries, fiduciaries and corporations in all aspects of estate and trust administrations.

Then, if family drama ensues, Roetzel’s team of trust and estate litigators and appellate attorneys will be ready to protect your interests.

999 VANDERBILT BEACH ROAD SUITE 401 NAPLES, FL 34108

ralaw.com

Expand Your Firm’s Services and Your Clients’ Resources.

When your client’s needs fall outside your focus, Henderson Franklin is ready to assist. From business litigation to family law and estate planning, our team of almost 50 attorneys and multiple practice areas provides the additional services your clients may require. For over 100 years, we’ve been partnering with Lee County attorneys to deliver seamless legal support while preserving the relationships you’ve worked hard to build. Let us help you meet your clients’ needs effectively and professionally – just as we’ve done since 1924.

Recognized in 2025 by Best Law Firms©

henlaw.com • 239.344.1100 1715 Monroe Street Fort Myers, FL 33901

Where Tradition Meets the Future.®

BUSINESS & TAX • BUSINESS LITIGATION • CONSTRUCTION • DIVORCE, MARITAL & FAMILY • EMPLOYMENT • HEALTH CARE • LAND USE, ZONING & ENVIRONMENTAL • MERGERS & ACQUISITIONS • REAL ESTATE • TORT & INSURANCE • WILLS, TRUST & ESTATE PLANNING • WORKERS’ COMPENSATION ©2025 Henderson Franklin Starnes & Holt, P.A.

MAY & JUNE 2025 7

EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR'S LETTER

Finding Our Moments What is the trick to slowing time down? This role makes time fly, and so does being a mother. Sometimes, time flies by so fast that I find I am not able to enjoy each moment.

I can't be the only one?

Which, I guess, is a good reminder that the LCBA offers six free therapy sessions for all attorneys in Lee County! This is only possible with the help of many amazing donors. See page 61 for a complete list of the individuals and businesses who recognize the value of prioritizing mental health.

Another positive when it comes to time? One way I combine my time between LCBA and my family is by bringing my daughter, Eden, to anything I can. While I did not have the chance to bring her to this year's Bench Bar-B-Q & Shrimp Boil, many of you brought your kiddos – and they had such a great time! The IMAG hosted our event this year, and we were grateful for such an incredible venue. As a friendly reminder, IMAG offers a really great summer camp!

Another LCBA event taught us many great ways to biohack the mind, body and heart: Our 2nd Annual FRC and LCBA Spring Symposium! Shout out to the leader of that amazing event, Kristianna Soto.

March and April brought some amazing events. May and June are also going to do the same!

For example, LCBA hosted our annual Law in the Mall Pro Bono Clinic at the North Fort Myers Library and that was a great success. Three cheers for Katherine Camadeco, my boss for that day. Another big thank you to all who volunteered your time to speak to those in the community that need to be heard!

But Law Week is not over yet! We have a few other Law Week events coming up, so be sure to sign up to attend.

Lastly, I want to plug the Florida Bar Voluntary Bar Leaders Conference. Each year, I have attended and met some amazing lawyers, vendors and Florida Bar BOGs and staff. Anyone looking to pursue a path of leadership in our Lee County Bar or The Florida Bar: Go to this event! It is being hosted right in our backyard at the Sunseeker Resort in Punta Gorda on July 11 and 12. It is sure to be a great time, whether you are there to attend and learn, or to sponsor and network! This conference brings about 200 attendees and is super fun – and educational, too!

Lauren Baugh, Executive Director LBaugh@LeeBar.org | 239.334.0047 Ext. 102 8 LEEBAR.ORG

The official award-winning publication of the Lee County Bar Association, which has served citizens and the legal community since 1949.

STAFF Publisher Teri Hansen, APR Associate Editor Jada Bigord Advertising Account Executive Ed Kitsos Editor Sarah Nadal Editors In Law Hon. Kathy Smith Lauren Baugh Creative/Art Director Christi Finger Graphic Designer Lynsey Gill Contributing Writers Asma Anwar, Esq. Gabriel Arbois, Esq. Maria Alaimo, Esq. Lauren Baugh Dave Breitenstein Ryan Downey, Esq. John Miller, III, Esq. Henry Lee Paul, Esq. T. Rankin Terry, Jr., JD, LLM Kayla Richmond, Esq. Contributing Photographers Jim Jett Photography J&K Soto Photography

Res Gestae is an award-winning magazine published monthly by Priority Marketing in partnership with the Lee County Bar Association. All editorial, advertising and photos may be submitted for consideration through email to rgeditor@prioritymarketing.com. To advertise, contact Ed Kitsos at (239) 267-2638 or rgsales@prioritymarketing.com. For billing inquiries, call (239) 334-0047.

We make every effort to ensure the accuracy of the information published, but we cannot be held responsible for any consequences arising from omissions or errors. Opinions expressed by writers and advertisers are not necessarily opinions shared by LCBA, Res Gestae or Priority Marketing.

Copyright©2025 Lee County Bar Association, Inc. All Rights Reserved. No portion of the publication may be reproduced in part or in whole without prior written permission from the Lee County Bar Association. To inquire about such permission, please contact Lee County Bar Association at info@leebar.org.

12140 Carissa Commerce Ct., Ste. 201 | Fort Myers, FL 33966 239.267.2638 | prioritymarketing.com | info@prioritymarketing.com

Your business is our business.

Employment ■ Business ■ Government We represent businesses in employment law matters – from hire to termination and everything in between. We provide legal counseling and training to help employers identify legal risks, and collaborate with them to create solutions that work for their workplaces, both private and public sector. While our goal is typically to help clients avoid claims and lawsuits, when litigation cannot be avoided, we are also experienced litigators prepared to defend our clients through trial and appeal.

bapfirm.com ■ 239.208.6500 4415 Metro Parkway, Suite 110 | Fort Myers, FL 33916

Mediation. Arbitration.

Virtual or In-Person.

Board Certified in Civil Trial Law by The Florida Bar Represented Plaintiffs and Defendants Former Plaintiff-side Personal Injury Attorney Former Medical Malpractice Defense Attorney Southwest Florida Resident Since 2005 Office in Collier County, Florida

(239) 821-0069

BrazzealMediation.com

Chad T. Brazzeal, Esquire

Chad@BrazzealMediation.com

Schedule Online MAY & JUNE 2025 9

SAVE THE DATE FOR 2025 As you plan ahead for the remainder of the year, here are special LCBA events to note for your calendar. All dates are subject to change, and any updates will be posted on LeeBar.org.

MAY 2025 1 L CAWL Judicial Appreciation Reception

Time: 5:30 p.m. to 7:30 p.m.

Location: The Capital Gallery at Sidney & Berne Davis Art Center Tickets: $25 for LCAWL Members and $30 for NON LCAWL Members See flyer on page 36 for full details!

2 L aw Week Awards Luncheon & Ceremony

Time: 11:30 a.m. to 1 p.m.

Location: Riverside Community Center Tickets: LCBA Members: $25 NON LCBA Members: $35 and GOV Attorneys $20 See flyer on page 31 for full details!

9 R PPTL Virtual Brown Bag

12 C riminal Law Section CLE

Time: 12 p.m. to 1 p.m.

Location: Lee County Justice Center, CR2B Speakers: Judge Nicole Mirra, Judge Robert Branning, Judge Andrew Marcus, Judge Devin George and Judge Zachary Gill Moderated By: 12th Francine Donnorummo, Esq. Topic: Bench Banter: Lunch & Learn with the Judiciary Cost: FREE for all Members Sponsored By: Law Offices of Michael M. Raheb PA

13 R PPTL Virtual Brown Bag

Time: 12 p.m. to 1 p.m.

Location: Microsoft Teams Speaker: Bob Kirkland, Esq. Topic: TBA

Time: 12 p.m. to 1 p.m.

Location: Microsoft Teams Speaker: Scott Johns, Esq. Topic: Actually, Yes, How Your Client Invests Their Money IS Your Problem

19 A DR Virtual Lunch and Learn

Time: 12 p.m. to 1 p.m.

Location: Zoom Speaker: Hilda Cenecharles, Esq. and Jerri Sutton Topic: Current Events: Division Versus Unity

JULY 2025 4 I ndependence Day - LCBA and courts closed 11-12 V oluntary Bar Leaders Conference

Time: 8:30 a.m. Shotgun Start Location: The Club at Gateway 12091 Gateway Greens Drive Fort Myers, FL 33913 Cost: $175 per player See flyer on page 32-33 for full details!

AUGUST 2025 1 J unk Food with the Judges 7 B aseball with the Bar

15 A DR Virtual Lunch and Learn

23 F oundation Golf Tourney Sponsorships Available!

26 M emorial Day - LCBA and courts closed

JUNE 2025 6 YLD Burritos with the Bench

Time: 12 p.m. to 1 p.m.

Location: Lee County Justice Center, Courtroom 4A Cost: FREE for all Members See flyer on page 11 for full details!

10 LEEBAR.ORG

Time: 12 p.m. to 1 p.m.

Location: Zoom Speaker: Julia Corbin Topic: TBA

See flyer on page 20 for full details!

15 L CBA & Florida Bar State of the Bar Luncheon

SEPTEMBER 2025 1 L abor Day - LCBA and courts closed 23 R osh Hashanah - LCBA and courts closed

MAY & JUNE 2025 11

ETHICALLY SPEAKING

By Henry Lee Paul, Esq.

Court Affirms Court Orders Can Be Proof

of Rule Violations Judicial referral cases are now working their way through the disciplinary process and represent perhaps the most dramatic change in Florida’s lawyer regulation in recent history.

In The Florida Bar v. Farah, SC22-472, the Florida Supreme Court reversed a referee’s recommendation of not guilty in a disciplinary case. The Bar’s case was based on a sanction order entered by a District Court against Mr. Farah and his co-counsel. The District Court based its order on the report and recommendation of a special master appointed to investigate the conduct of the lawyers involved.

The investigation related to thousands of “Engle” tobacco cases, in which Mr. Farah and his co-counsel represented plaintiffs. The District Court found misconduct and imposed sanctions on Mr. Farah and his co-counsel, who were each ordered to pay a fine in excess of $2 million.

The Supreme Court reversed the referee’s recommendation of not guilty and stated it wrongly “found that The Bar improperly based its case on the special master’s report and investigatory materials and did not conduct its own investigation into Farah’s conduct.”

The Supreme Court then found, based on the special master's report, that Mr. Farah violated rules 4-1.3 (Diligence), 4-1.4(a) (Communication), Rule 4-1.16(a)(1) (Declining or Terminating Representation) and Rule 4-1.5(f)(2) (Contingent Fees).

Henry Lee Paul, Esq. is a former Bar Counsel who now represents lawyers in all matters before the Florida Bar and offers risk management services on all legal practice matters. He also represents applicants in all matters before The Florida Board of Bar Examiners.

12 LEEBAR.ORG

The Court’s approval of the Bar’s reliance on the judicial order in the disciplinary case is just one example of its growing deference to the judiciary in disciplinary proceedings. Rule 3-7.16 (Judicial Referral) was adopted in 2021.

Judicial referral cases are now working their way through the disciplinary process and represent perhaps the most dramatic change in Florida’s lawyer regulation in recent history. A judicial referral may provide for a dramatically altered disciplinary process, without the same longstanding due process protections traditionally afforded to respondents.

I advise clients who have received a judicial referral that The Florida Bar will likely treat their cases with an adverse presumption that

makes a recommendation of dismissal far more improbable. I restate my warnings to litigators to take extra care to avoid the possibility of judicial referral. I further suggest that the judiciary carefully consider the impact and potential unintended consequences of making a judicial referral.

The Farah case should also serve as a reminder to those who refer cases to other counsel. A referral of a contingent case requires signed fee agreements or written consent of all parties, including the referring lawyer. Mr. Farah was found to have violated Rule 4-1.5(f)(2) by not having signed contingent agreements as well as not obtaining the written consent of the clients for referral to another lawyer.

Mr. Farah was held jointly responsible for the misconduct of co-counsel in the prosecution of thousands of Engle cases. The Court noted that all lawyers that participate in a contingent fee case “assume joint legal responsibility to the client.”

The Court found that Rule 4-1.16 (Declining or Terminating Representation) was violated when Mr. Farah and co-counsel filed suit without conducting adequate investigation and filed numerous cases that clearly lacked merit. The Court concluded Mr. Farah took on far more cases than he could reasonably handle and that he should have known “he could not provide legal services to the thousands of Engle plaintiffs and still fully comply with his professional obligations.”

MAY & JUNE 2025 13

14 LEEBAR.ORG

MAY & JUNE 2025 15

LEADING WITH

PURPOSE Meet Your LCBA Executive Board

The Lee County Bar Association plays a vital role in supporting legal professionals across our community. From continuing legal education and mentorship to networking opportunities, member services and public outreach, the LCBA is a resource and a connector — helping attorneys practice more effectively and engage more meaningfully with their peers and the public.

Behind these efforts is a dedicated group of leaders: the LCBA Executive Board. Each year, this board is elected by the membership and sworn in at the January luncheon to serve as the governing body of the association. Board members provide oversight, shape programming and help guide the initiatives that bring value to the LCBA’s diverse membership — including CLE resources, community service projects, lawyer referral services and professional development events.

This year’s executive board represents a cross-section of our legal community, united by a shared commitment to strengthening the practice of law and building strong relationships that support it.

John Miller, III, Esq. President John Miller, III, Esq. serves as president of the Lee County Bar Association. He is also a partner at Boy Agnew Potanovic Miller, PLLC, where he focuses exclusively on civil litigation, representing businesses, government entities, individuals and insurance carriers at the trial and appellate levels, as well as in arbitration proceedings.

He has represented clients successfully in numerous jury trials at both the state and federal level, regularly defends municipal and government clients at the trial and appellate levels, and handles matters of substance ranging from 16 LEEBAR.ORG

business and employment disputes to personal injury. John also has a growing OSHA practice, where he represents employers facing OSHA inspections or investigations, and defends employers who have been cited by OSHA. To further his knowledge in this growing practice, John earned the OSHA 10-Hour card in construction safety and health.

He holds an AV Preeminent rating from Martindale-Hubbell and has been named a Florida Super Lawyers® Rising Star seven times. John was also recognized with the James A. Dixon Young Lawyer of the Year Award from the Florida Defense Lawyers Association.

He has served as a governor of The Florida Bar Young Lawyers Division and as director on the Florida Defense Lawyers Association Board. Locally, John serves on the boards of the Fort Myers YMCA and the Foundation for Lee County Public Schools. A Pine Island native, he lives in North Fort Myers with his wife, Kayla, and their three children. In his spare time, John enjoys camping, running and participating in triathlons.

John Dommerich, Jr., Esq.

Kevin Huguelet, Esq.

Vice President

YLD President

John Dommerich, Jr., serves as deputy chief assistant state attorney at the Office of the State Attorney for the 20th Judicial Circuit Court.

According to State Attorney Amira Fox, this recent promotion places him in charge of the Collier County office’s day-to-day operations.

Kevin Huguelet, Esq. is president of the Lee County Bar Association Young Lawyers Division and an assistant U.S. attorney in the Civil Division for the Middle District of Florida. Based in Fort Myers, he represents the United States, its agencies and employees in a wide range of civil litigation matters.

He previously served as the circuit-wide chief of special prosecutions, responsible for reviewing all officer-involved shootings, in-custody deaths and investigations in which law enforcement officers are accused of committing a crime.

He also reviewed all internal affairs investigations that have sustained findings regarding an officer’s truthfulness in a criminal case. He supervised the circuit-wide public records division and score sheet unit and reviews all Sunshine Law complaints and violations.

Before being promoted to chief of special prosecutions, John served as the assistant circuit court chief in Lee County, supervising a large division of prosecutors, investigators and clerical assistants. Prior to that, he worked in Hendry and Glades counties, where he supervised the State Attorney’s Offices.

John handles a docket of cases involving first-degree murder, second-degree murder, attempted murder of a law enforcement officer, drug trafficking, firearm offenses, sex offenses committed against children, and child abuse. He also represents the State Attorney’s Office in coordination with the U.S. Attorney’s Office on federal and state prosecutions of violent crimes. He is a member of the State Attorney’s Office Narcotics Enforcement Task Force (NETFORCE).

He is an active member of the Rotary Club of Fort Myers and co-chair of the YMCA of Fort Myers Community Board. John previously served as co-chair of the 20th Judicial Circuit Bar Grievance Committee A, former vice president of the Hendry-Glades Bar Association, and member of the Calusa Inns of Court.

John has been married to his wife, Devin, since 2013.

They have a 5-year-old son, Jack, and a 3-year-old daughter, Ellery.

Originally from Chicago’s South Side, Kevin earned a bachelor’s degree from Creighton University and graduated magna cum laude from the University of Miami School of Law. While in law school, he served as an editor on the law review, received several academic and writing awards, and was inducted into the Order of the Coif.

He began his legal career as a law clerk to Justice R. Fred Lewis of the Florida Supreme Court and the Hon. Judge Sheri Polster Chappell of the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida. Kevin is the immediate past president of the Southwest Florida Federal Court Bar Association and a former member of the Calusa Inn of Court.

Kevin lives in Fort Myers with his wife and two daughters.

He brings a passion for public service and mentorship to his role leading the Young Lawyers Division.

EXECUTIVE COUNCIL President

John Miller, III, Esq.

Vice President

John Dommerich, Jr., Esq.

YLD President

Kevin Huguelet, Esq.

President Emeritus

Hon. Kathy Smith

Secretary

Kristianna Soto, Esq.

Treasurer

Dawn Maselli, Esq.

MARCH & APRIL 2025 17

Hon. Kathleen Smith

Kristianna Soto, Esq.

President Emeritus

Secretary

The Hon. Kathleen “Kathy” Smith serves as immediate past president of the Lee County Bar Association. In 2008, she was elected public defender for the 20th Judicial Circuit Court, serving the citizens of Lee, Collier, Charlotte, Hendry and Glades counties. Kathy is a “Double Gator,” having obtained both her bachelor’s degree and juris doctor from the University of Florida. She went on to earn her master’s degree in public administration from Florida Gulf Coast University.

She began her legal career as an assistant public defender in 1990, ultimately specializing in the representation of clients living with mental illness and substance use. She is a past recipient of Advocate of the Year, awarded by Lee Mental Health Inc., and was also honored with a Florida senator’s proclamation for her advocacy on behalf of mentally ill clients.

Kathy’s passion for 360-degree wraparound client care resulted in an appointment on behalf of the Florida Public Defender Association to serve on the Florida Supreme Court’s Substance Abuse and Mental Health Task Force.

Kathy is a dedicated community leader in addition to her elected position of public defender. She is a sitting board member for the Justice Administrative Commission and an adjunct professor at Florida Gulf Coast University, teaching constitutional criminal procedure. She has served on the board of directors for the PACE Center for Girls in Lee County, Southwest Florida Addiction Services, Lee Mental Health Inc. and the Institute for Youth and Justice Studies through Florida Gulf Coast University.

18 LEEBAR.ORG

Kristianna Soto is the secretary of the Lee County Bar Association and a managing attorney at The Law Office of Kristianna Soto, P.A. in Fort Myers. Her practice focuses on family law, juvenile matters and criminal defense, where she is known for a client-centered and compassionate approach.

Kristianna earned her Juris Doctor from the University of Florida in 2009 after completing dual majors in international affairs and Spanish, with a minor in criminology, at Florida State University. She began her legal career as an assistant public defender in the 20th Judicial Circuit, where she served for more than 11 years, including in supervisory and legal training roles.

She is active in the local legal and nonprofit communities, serving on the board of the Family Resource Center of Southwest Florida and volunteering through various outreach initiatives. Fluent in Spanish, Soto provides bilingual representation and remains committed to improving access to legal services in underserved areas.

Dawn Maselli, Esq. Treasurer Diana Dawn Maselli is treasurer of the Lee County Bar Association and an attorney with Associates and Bruce L. Scheiner, based in Fort Myers. She joined the firm while attending FGCU in 2007 and continued working there through law school.

In addition to participating in trial advocacy programs during law school, Dawn prepared for and attended multiple trials under the supervision of Bruce and Preston Scheiner. In 2012, she graduated from Ave Maria School of Law in Naples, Florida. She was an active member of the Ave Maria Women’s Law Association from 2009 to 2012 and held an officer position within the organization from 2011 to 2012.

Dawn has been admitted to practice in Florida since 2012 and in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida since 2016. She was selected as a Top 40 Under 40 Civil Plaintiff attorney by The National Trial Lawyers in 2019, as well as a 2019–20 fellow of The Florida Bar’s Leadership Academy. She served on both the 20th Judicial Circuit Court Grievance Committee C and the Statewide Advertising and Solicitation Grievance Committee from 2019 to 2022.

She currently serves on the boards of the Southwest Florida Federal Court Bar Association, Southwest Florida Trial Lawyers Association and the Lee County Bar Association’s Young Lawyers Division. Dawn is also co-chair of the LCBA Tort Litigation Section and an active member of #KindLee, the American Association for Justice, the Florida Justice Association, the Lee County Association for Women Lawyers, the Lee County Injury Prevention Coalition and the Calusa Inn of Court.

A Sarasota native, Dawn lives in Fort Myers and enjoys spending time with family and friends outside of work.

Thank You

FOR YOUR SERVICE TO LCBA! MAY & JUNE 2025 19

20 LEEBAR.ORG

Highlighting

FAMILIES FIGHTING FOR JUSTICE This special advertising section showcases local firms’ generations of leadership in Lee County. Join us in celebrating these families and their impacts on our community!

MAY & JUNE 2025 21

Frank Aloia & a Frank Aloia & a Legacy of Legal Excellence Legacy of Legal Excellence The name Aloia is synonymous with dedication, integrity, and service in the Fort Myers community.

Fordedication, decades, Frank Aloia’s has The name Aloialegal is synonymous with integrity, andfamily service in played a pivotal role in shaping the region’s legal landscape, leaving the Fort Myers legal community. For decades, Frank Aloia’s family has an indelible markrole on both the profession and the people they serve. played a pivotal in shaping the region’s legal landscape, leaving an indelible mark on both the profession and the people they serve.

Frank Aloia’s journey in law is more than a personal accomplishment— Frank Aloia’s in law family is moretradition. than a personal accomplishment— it is part of ajourney deep-rooted His father, Frank Aloia Sr., a it is part of Fort a deep-rooted father, attorney, Frank Aloia a respected Myers Real family Estatetradition. / Estate His Planning setSr.,the respected Myers Realinstilling Estate /inEstate Planning set and the foundation Fort for this legacy, him the values attorney, of hard work foundation for this legacy, in him the values of hard workwhen and justice. Perhaps one of theinstilling most meaningful milestones came justice.

Perhaps one of the most meaningful milestones when Frank’s father was honored as a 50-year member of thecame Florida Bar. Frank’s father symbolized was honored asonly a 50-year member of the Florida Bar. That moment not the longevity of his career but also That momentand symbolized not Aloia only family the longevity of his career but also the influence respect the has garnered over the years. the influence and respect the Aloia family has garnered over the years.

One of the most defining moments of Frank’s career was the day he One of the in most of Frank’s career the day he was sworn as adefining membermoments of the Florida Bar and as anwas Assistant State was sworn in as a member of the Florida Bar and as an Assistant State Attorney. Among those present was his distant cousin, Joseph Attorney.

Among those friend present was his and distant cousin, Joseph D’Alessandro—a longtime of his father the State Attorney at D’Alessandro—a longtime friend of his father and the State Attorney at the time. Their connection underscored the strong familial ties that the connection underscored thein strong familial ties That that havetime. longTheir influenced the legal profession Southwest Florida. have long influenced the legal profession in Southwest Florida. That day was capped with a celebratory lunch at The Veranda, where day was capped with a celebratory lunch at The Veranda, where family and colleagues gathered to recognize the continuation of a family and colleagues gathered to recognize the continuation of a proud legal tradition. proud legal tradition.

The family’s impact extends even further. Frank’s great-uncle, Frank The family’s impact extends even further. Frank’s great-uncle, Frank Pavese, Sr., was the founder of The Pavese Law Firm, a cornerstone of Pavese, Sr., was the founder of The Pavese Law Firm, a cornerstone of the Fort Myers legal community. His grandmother, Pavese’s older sister, the Fort Myers legal community. His grandmother, Pavese’s older sister, was present on the day he was sworn into the Bar—another testament was present on the day he was sworn into the Bar—another testament to the generational legacy of law and justice in the Aloia family. to the generational legacy of law and justice in the Aloia family.

Through decades decades of of legal legal service, service, their their legacy legacy continues continues to to shape shape the the Through future of Fort Myers’ legal community, inspiring generations to come. future of Fort Myers’ legal community, inspiring generations to come.

(239) 376-1661 LawDefined.com 22 LEEBAR.ORG

From Courtroom to Bench:

The Dommerich Family’s Lasting Impact

From the courtroom to private practice, Stephen Dommerich and his family are building a lasting legacy in the legal community, carrying forward a tradition of excellence that started decades ago.

It all began with John Dommerich Sr., who started his legal career as a prosecutor at the State Attorney’s Office. His passion for the law and dedication to fairness led to his appointment to the Lee County Bench in 1989. Nearly two decades later, in 2008, he ascended to the Circuit Court Bench, solidifying his legacy as a respected jurist.

Following in their father’s footsteps, both John Dommerich Jr. and Stephen Dommerich began their legal careers as prosecutors in the State Attorney’s Office. John Jr. has remained in public service, recently earning the esteemed position of Deputy Chief Assistant State Attorney for Collier County. His steadfast commitment to upholding justice has made him a cornerstone of the office.

Stephen, while starting his career in prosecution, later pursued private practice in 2017. His expertise and dedication led him to join Aloia Roland in 2021, where he quickly distinguished himself. In December 2023, his hard work was recognized when he was named a partner at the firm.

The Dommerich family's enduring contributions to the legal community highlight a shared passion for justice and service. Their collective impact continues to shape the legal landscape of Southwest Florida, ensuring a legacy that will be felt for generations to come.

(239) 376-1661 LawDefined.com MAY & JUNE 2025 23

The EVIDENCE is STUNNING Mark Loren Designs is known for beautiful custom pieces, stunning jewelry transformations and superior craftsmanship, engraving and repairs. Our jewelers are also a trusted source to restore or consign fine heirlooms.

Contact us for legal appraisals for estate, divorce and mediation.

Designer l Jeweler l Goldsmith | 239.482.4664 | MarkLorenDesigns.com

24 LEEBAR.ORG

WELCOME NEW MEMBERS

WELCOME, NEW MEMBERS

Please join the Lee County Bar Association in welcoming these newest additions to our membership rolls.

RICHARD ANNUNZIATA, ESQ. Annunziata Resolution

JONATHAN OLSON, ESQ. Musca Law

BROOKE BIRKEY Level Up Law Firm Coaching

ROBERT SIDDALL, ESQ. Law Firm of Scott T. Moorey

ROBERT KENNEDY, ESQ. Kennedy Law, PA.

DANIEL WELYTOK, ESQ. Von Briesen & Roper, S.C.

DOMINIK MEZZOLINE, ESQ. Pope, Mazzara & Menendez, PLLC.

MAY & JUNE 2025 25

PRACTICE SECTION

By Kayla Richmond, Esq.

FAMILY LAW IN MOTION 2 02 5 UP DATES , EV EN T S & CLES The Family Law Section has hit the ground running in 2025. This year, the section hosted its first event in collaboration with Everwell Financial, where we delved into important tax updates and explored the implications of potential changes to tax laws that are set to sunset in 2025. Danielle Lucht, our guest speaker, provided valuable insights on how tax policies impact family law cases. One of the key takeaways was the distinction between marginal tax rates and effective tax rates, crucial knowledge to better inform clients on their available income and ability to make sound decisions in their family law matters.

A Florida Bar-Board Certified expert in divorce, marital and family law, Kayla Richmond, Esq., is admitted to practice in all Florida state courts and the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida. Before joining Henderson, Franklin, Starnes & Holt, P.A., the Fort Myers native served as a law clerk for the Honorable David A. Demers in Florida’s 6th Judicial Circuit Court. She earned her law degree and master's in business administration at Stetson University.

26 LEEBAR.ORG

Looking ahead, we are excited to continue our educational efforts. On April 4, we participated in the 20th Judicial Circuit Court Pro Bono Family Law Seminar. And, on April 11, we joined forces with the Family Resources Center for their second annual Health and Wellness Symposium: Biohacking… Mind, Heart & Body!

These events are just a part of our ongoing commitment to support and empower both legal professionals and the broader community.

The Family Law section is also gearing up for additional Continuing Legal Education (CLE) opportunities in the summer and fall. One highlight will be a co-hosted CLE with the

Real Property, Probate, and Trust Law (RPPTL) section, focusing on crossover issues between trust and estate and family law. Additionally, we are collaborating with the Association of Family Law Professionals to host a Soberlink CLE, further expanding our reach and strengthening our connections within the family law community.

Through these collaborations, we have been continuously improving engagement and providing our members with relevant, timely information to enhance their daily practice, at the local level.

Statewide family law practitioners recently attended the Board Certification Family Law Review Course, held annually each January.

A more niche conference is also hosted by the American Academy of Matrimonial Lawyers the end of April, really getting in the weeds of complicated family law issues. If you were at either conference, please let us know if you would like to share on conference topics, locally!

Whether around the statewide or locally, we hope to see you at the next couple of events!

For more details on upcoming events, or if you have questions, please feel free to reach out to the family law section co-chairs.

FAMILY & FINANCE

TAK I NG A C LOS ER LO OK AT TAXES Everwell Financial owner and financial advisor, Danielle Lucht, RICP, CDFA, welcomed LCBA members to Henderson, Franklin, Starnes & Holt, P.A. for an informative Family Law Section lunch and learn about the changing landscape of federal taxes and used tax planning strategies. The free presentation reviewed possible changes, should the Tax Cut & Jobs Act sunset on January 1, 2025, examining marginal vs. effective tax rates and discussing unused planning strategies to minimize federal income taxes – now and in the future.

MAY & JUNE 2025 27

INTERIOR FEATURE

By Ryan Downey, President of the Lee County Bar Association Foundation

A FOUNDATION OF SUPPORT FOR LEE COUNTY Missing a little philanthropy in your life? Giving back to your community is closer than you think!

Now in its tenth year of existence, the Lee County Bar Association Foundation (LCBAF) serves as the charitable arm of the LCBA, providing our local lawyers with a vehicle for giving back to our neighbors in need. As a 501(c)(3) organization, the Foundation is able to provide 100% of proceeds straight to groups that are in need and match its mission.

Ryan Downey is currently serving his second term as the Lee County Bar Association Foundation President. He is the Circuit Court Chief at the Office of the Public Defender for the 20th Judicial Circuit, where he’s served the indigent community for nearly 20 years. A Fort Myers native, Ryan received his bachelor's degree from the University of Notre Dame before graduating from the University of Florida’s Levin College of Law.

28 LEEBAR.ORG

The Foundation focuses on four key tenets that guide their work: (1) promoting provision of legal aid to the indigent, (2) supporting and participating in charitable endeavors that benefit our youth and the underprivileged population, (3) encouraging and promoting education and community awareness of the law, and (4) providing for the establishment of scholarships.

With that framework in mind, and thanks to your generosity in designation of LCBA dues, attendance at Foundation events, and sponsorship thereof, over the past two years the LCBAF proudly awarded over $100,000 to more than

40 local, deserving entities. Each October, after the two-month grant application period closes, the Foundation’s Board of Directors, along with volunteers from the LCBA, convene to review and discuss all requests and allocate the available funds.

While what has been awarded is a substantial amount, the demand exceeds the Foundation’s current capabilities by at least 400% and, each year, the difficult decision to not fund many organizations must be made. That is why your support is more important than ever in 2025!

A wide array of projects are being sponsored

by Foundation funding in Lee County in line with their mission. Among them are the Sally J. Pimentel Deaf & Hard of Hearing Center’s hands-on training with local law enforcement.

With their unique perspective, they’ve made a breakthrough in how deaf individuals are served and interacted with in potentially high-pressure situations.

Another example is Junior Achievement of SWFL, who used this year’s grant to host Law Days

in conjunction with local high schools. Here, students gain exposure to the justice system and legal profession, and interest in careers in the field is sparked. From local food banks to organizations that empower and support children and young women, to community legal aid services, the LCBAF is able to cast a wide net, all in the name of our generous Lee County Bar Association.

As a result of the overwhelming support, the Foundation has also been able to extend the reach of its mission outside of the traditional grant cycle. In the fall of 2024, the greater Tampa Bay area was severely impacted by Hurricane Helene and other storms that devastated the region. Something we unfortunately know all too well is that attorneys and their support staff are not immune from the wrath of Mother Nature. In response, the Lee County Bar Association Foundation made donations to the Clearwater and St. Petersburg Bar Associations to assist in their recovery efforts, specifically designated for our sister legal communities. Not long before, in the wake of Hurricane Ian, the LCBAF took the lead in accepting donations from other Bar Associations across the state, reviewing need-based applications from the affected in Lee County and dispersing funds to our friends in peril.

Aside from hurricane relief, the Foundation also sponsors the Lee County High School Mock Trial competition’s Best Closing Argument Award (in honor of Miguel C. Fernandez), specifically to support our attorneys of tomorrow and their interest in the legal system. Read more about this annual academic competition on page 42.

Finally, Foundation events provide an excellent opportunity to advertise and promote your firm or business. Their annual signature events, such as the golf tournament in May and wine tasting in the fall, always include multiple levels of available sponsorship and have historically been great ways to get employees and associates involved in the local legal community. If interested, please reach out to LCBAF President Ryan Downey at ryand@pd20.org, or contact any Foundation Board Member.

Whether it’s your time, talent or treasure, through the Lee County Bar Association Foundation, there is always a way to open your heart and serve our community. There is no such thing as too little or too late when it comes to giving. We’re proud to be surrounded by such compassionate, benevolent people.

The LCBAF continues to thank you for your contributions and looks forward to seeing you soon!

MAY & JUNE 2025 29

INTERIOR FEATURE

By Lauren Baugh

OUT OF MANY, ONE THE TRADITION OF LAW WEEK 2025 Each year, we get the privilege of hosting a variety of events surrounding Law Day. This year, we are continuing that tradition.

With the help from our 2025 Law Week Chair, the Hon. Judge John Carlin, and his judicial assistant, Beth Nichols, we are all set to make this year the best yet!

The annual theme is set nationwide by the American Bar Association (ABA) and observed by our local Bar Association.

In 2025, the Law Week theme is “The Constitution's Promise: Out of Many, One.” According to the ABA, “The Constitution enshrines our collective responsibility to one another, and this 2025 Law Day theme urges us to take pride in a constitution that bridges our differences to bring us together as a united nation. Our civic lives tie us together as one 'We,' whether through legislative efforts that serve the common good, through military service, or by working together, every day, to fulfill the promise of E pluribus unum, or, 'Out of many, one.'”

Each Bar Association and Voluntary Bar Association celebrates this day and the surrounding week uniquely. At the Lee County Bar Association, we like to celebrate all week!

Law Week starts off with the LCBA’s annual pro bono clinic, which we call “Law in the Mall.” This was held at the North Fort Myers Library, an area where we have not yet been able to do outreach. So, we were excited that we can help those in North Fort Myers, Cape Coral and the surrounding areas, which otherwise may not have easy access to justice.

Should you wish to volunteer for the pro bono clinic on April 26 from 10 a.m. to 12 p.m., we want to hear from you! Please reach

out to LBaugh@leebar.org, or contact LCBA’s Law in the Mall Chair Katherine Camadeco.

We want to shout out to all of our volunteer attorneys who came out on this Saturday morning to meet and greet all of our attendees! Should you wish to be involved next year with this great and enriching event, please reach out to LBaugh@leebar.org, or contact LCBA’s Law in the Mall Chair Katherine Camadeco.

LCBA's second event of Law Week was our Annual Blood Drive, which was held on April 30 from 8 a.m. to 12 p.m.

We encouraged our legal community to come out and support this effort by donating a pint or two of blood and they answered the call. It is not glamorous but it is very much needed in our area. This will help supply Lee County’s ever-growing need for blood donations.

Lastly, LCBA will host our Annual Law Week Awards Luncheon on May 2 from 11:30 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. This my favorite event of the series, because it offers the Bar Association the honor and opportunity to present four Law Enforcement Officer of the Year Awards. There’s also the School District of Lee County Teacher of the Year for Law-Related Education Award, which rewards a local hardworking teacher.

Then, of course, there's our coveted Liberty Bell Award.

The Liberty Bell Award is presented to a stellar member of our community that has gone above and beyond to promote our Constitution and the Bill of Rights. This individual also encourages a greater respect for law and the courts, and fosters a better understanding of the rule of law. It’s our honor to reward someone who truly makes freedom ring.

We hope you join us next year for the meaningful events surrounding Law Week!

30 LEEBAR.ORG

MAY & JUNE 2025 31

32 LEEBAR.ORG

MAY & JUNE 2025 33

PRACTICE SECTION

By Asma Anwar

Florida Criminal Law Changes: ERLINGER, IMMIGRATION AND SPEEDY TRIAL The new year has brought significant developments and challenges to Florida criminal law, particularly in sentencing, immigration and speedy trial.

ERLINGER’S EFFECTS ON FLORIDA CRIMINAL SENTENCING

Asma Anwar currently serves as misdemeanor chief of the 20th Circuit Public Defender’s Office, LCBA Criminal Section chair and vice president of the Lee County Bar Foundation. She has extensive trial experience, which Anwar applies in her current position as she develops and trains the next generation of trial attorneys.

34 LEEBAR.ORG

Among these changes, the recent U.S. Supreme Court decision in Erlinger v. United States, 602 U.S. 821 (2024), has introduced a shift in sentencing procedures that directly affects Florida’s criminal courts. In Erlinger, the Supreme Court held that any fact that increases a defendant’s sentence, such as recidivist enhancements under habitual offender statutes, must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt to a jury. This decision departs from prior practice, where judges determined sentence-enhancing factors, unless those factors constituted elements of the underlying offense.

Prosecutors and defense attorneys alike must now consider how Erlinger impacts charging documents, trial strategy and plea negotiations.

The application of Erlinger begins at the charging stage. Sentence-enhancing factors now arguably function as additional elements of the offense and may need to be explicitly charged in the information. Presently, prosecutors typically notice of its intent to seek an enhanced sentence—such as designations under the Prison Releasee Reoffender (PRR) or Habitual Felony Offender (HFO) statutes. However, debate remains as to whether such notice is constitutionally sufficient.

Moreover, discovery related to any facts the prosecution intends to use in support of sentence enhancement must be disclosed.

This includes witness testimony, documentary

evidence, and any other materials relevant to the alleged recidivist status.

If a defendant opts for a negotiated plea rather than trial, plea colloquies must be adjusted to address the rights the defendant is waiving under Erlinger, including the right to have a jury determine sentence-enhancing factors.

When considering a trial, a bifurcation of proceedings would be ideal, to mitigate undue prejudice against a defendant.

Under this approach, the jury would first determine guilt on the underlying offense before being presented with evidence related to the enhancement. Severance may also be an option, whereby one jury determines guilt, and a separate jury considers the enhancement factors. The Florida Bar’s proposed jury instructions currently only contemplate bifurcated trials for enhancements. Attorneys and the Court should also ensure that verdict forms for sentence enhancements are drafted with specificity to ensure compliance with the new constitutional requirements.

The appellate landscape surrounding this issue is still evolving, making it essential for practitioners to proactively litigate these issues and protect their clients’ Sixth Amendment rights. Preserving Erlinger based objections at every stage of litigation of a case is crucial to safeguarding a defendant’s constitutional rights and ensuring a strong record for appeal.

CRIMINAL LAW RELATED IMMIGRATION CHANGES Practitioners are also navigating changes in immigration laws that directly impact many defendants. On February 13, SB4-C was signed into law and became effective immediately. The new laws raise supremacy clause issues under the assertion immigration is under the jurisdiction of the federal government in addition to other constitutional challenges.

BRIEF HIGHLIGHTS OF CHANGES INCLUDE: 1. U nauthorized alien status may now be considered when contemplating bonds. If it can be shown the person has gained illegal reentry and returned to the US after being ordered to stay out or removed, there is no bond (F.S 811.103).

2. Illegal entry by adult unauthorized aliens into the State knowingly, after entering the US without inspection or examination by immigration, is now a first-degree misdemeanor with a minimum mandatory 9-month jail sentence. If it is the second offense, the mandatory jail time increases to a year and one day as the minimum mandatory sentence.

For the third or more offenses of illegal entry, it’s a two-year minimum mandatory sentence. There are exceptions, such as if the unauthorized alien should encounter police because of witnessing or reporting a crime, among others. Diversion programs are not available to these individuals (F.S 811.102).

3. A noncitizen participating in voting is now a third-degree felony.

4. Unauthorized aliens also face charge enhancements.

5. A n unauthorized alien convicted of a capital offense now must receive a mandatory death sentence (F.S 921.1426).

Generally, individuals serve their incarceration sentence before they are released to Federal immigration authorities.

SPEEDY TRIAL CHANGES Florida Rules of Criminal Procedure 3.191 (Speedy Trial) and 3.134 (Time for Filing Formal Charges) will have amendments implemented July 1, 2025. The changes effectively make the use of speedy trial as a tool less effective. The clock will begin upon the filing of charges, as opposed to arrest. The recapture period is mandatory and is now increased from 10 days to 30 days. Charges dismissed under speedy will be done so without prejudice, so they can simply be refiled, unless “the defendant’s constitutional right to speedy has been violated.”

Of course, these are all significant changes that will become clearer over time. However, by the end of the year, the courts will likely offer valuable guidance.

Author’s Note: This article was written in March 2025.

MAY & JUNE 2025 35

36 LEEBAR.ORG

TERRY'S TAKE ON THINGS

By T. Rankin Terry, Jr., JD, LLM

Looking bac k at th e

La d i es i n t he law Women lawyers were, and are, the trailblazers and leaders in our Southwest Florida legal community!

When I arrived back here in the fall of 1971, things were still a bit macho. A judge or two would fall into speech patterns such as, “Honey, you may approach the bench.”

My historical sources are poor; thus, I won’t discuss named individuals. I would leave someone out. The fact is that it took courage for a woman to practice law in the early ’70s.

Firms were reluctant to hire women for, among other things, fear of clients’ reaction. E.g., would a woman be “tough enough?” Today, we might call it sexism, but realistically, it was “the way things were.” Not right, but the way things were. Strangely, I don’t recall a woman lawyer’s competency as a lawyer ever being questioned.

My experience was, and memory is, that being “tough enough” was never an actual problem.

The spectrum of male lawyers’ complaints went from “not tough enough” over to “too pushy!”

The men complaining usually had just lost or been outmaneuvered by a woman lawyer just being a lawyer.

Post-Vietnam, overall law school enrollments went up, women’s law school enrollment went up, and more women were admitted to The Bar. I don’t have the numbers at hand, but I believe

that initially, in our area, more women lawyers were hired as prosecutors and public defenders than by firms. Firms and individual lawyers eventually came around, but probably not as fast as they should have. The “Honey you may …” judges came around.

The milestone was women taking the bench.

Not only was it a statement that women could competently do the work of being a lawyer, but also that they could “run the legal system.”

For the last several years, the profession has been troubled by a lack of professionalism in some quarters. I suggest that the admission of women to the bar and bench has driven down the level of unprofessionalism from where it otherwise would be.

It’s just anecdotal, but I think that lawyers that are unprofessional, are mostly men. And, if in court, more before men than women judges.

Some may disagree.

I could spend a thousand words on this article, but both men and woman lawyers should be able to spend more time with their families, especially raising kids. Some will say that women lawyers taking or being granted time with their families is somehow preferential.

I say no, that is life.

To the boys I say, try it!

T. Rankin Terry, Jr. is a longtime Southwest Florida practitioner.

He was board certified in civil trial for 35 years and has been a certified mediator for 29 years.

His undergraduate degree in mechanical engineering is from the University of Kentucky, his juris doctor is from Washington University in St. Louis, and his LLM in tax is from the University of Florida.

MAY & JUNE 2025 37

LEGAL LENS

Shrimp Boil

Reel Engagement

at the Bench Bar-B-Q & Shrimp Boil The LCBA hosted its annual Bench Bar-B-Q & Shrimp Boil on Saturday, March 29 in a brand-new venue: The IMAG History and Science Center in Fort Myers. This extraordinary, family-friendly destination in Southwest Florida features aquariums and animal exhibits, interactive displays, innovative programs and much more – all to inspire the imagination. It made for a delightful experience for LCBA members and their family members! Kids also enjoyed the bounce house, local DJ, facepainting, sweet treats and more.

Meanwhile, LCBA members enjoyed casual networking and making new connections over a plate of mouthwatering surf and turf, prepared by the Hon. Robert Branning and Jerry VonGruben. The duo served up a boatload of delicious barbecue and simmering seafood to the more than 100 attendees who took the bait and swam over to the IMAG for the 2025 LCBA Bench Bar-B-Q & Shrimp Boil.

1

2

3

4

38 LEEBAR.ORG

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

1. Judge Kyle Cohen and his family 2. Lance Dunford, Scott Moorey, Jill Prenger and Robert Siddall 3. John Miller, Olive Miller and Kayla Richmond 4. Mykisha Atisele and her family 5. Judge Robert Branning and Jerry Von Gruben 6. Kelly Tackett and Ben Barlett 7. Suzanne Boy, John Agnew and John Miller 8. Lance Dunford and his family, Kristianna Soto and Casey Gartland 9. Krista Anderson, Mayor Kevin Anderson and Lauren Baugh 10. Letspeak Inc! 11. Kristianna Soto and daughter 12. Robert Bowen, Mike and Jodi Greenhoe, Phil Collins and wife, and Ryan Pomponio

MAY & JUNE 2025 39

When it comes to

Marketing, We set the Bar. Since 1992, Priority Marketing has grown to become Southwest Florida’s largest marketing agency offering the most comprehensive and award-winning marketing, advertising and public relations services.

Today, our team of 65 savvy creatives and mastermind strategists take great pride in delivering the full scope of marketing solutions to propel businesses and organizations to reach new heights.

Are you ready to raise the bar for your brand?

Contact Us! PriorityMarketing.com

40 LEEBAR.ORG

JUDICIAL SPOTLIGHT

Ready for referrals?

THINGS YOU DON'T KNOW ABOUT ME

u The Hon. Trent Reichling

Advertise in res gestae.

-WINNING IAL AWARD LEE THE OFFIC ON OF THE ION PUBLICATI OCIAT BAR ASS COUN TY

ng Advo catior All f e Justic Smith

1. I have rooted for the Florida State Seminoles since birth. My grandfather and parents went to FSU, and I was indoctrinated at birth. No one cried more over wide rights and lefts in the 90s than me! I am also a big Miami Heat fan.

Kathy The Hon. 2024 Vision r Shares He

Th e IEN CE EA KIN G SC GR OU ND BR Y LIV ING of HE ALTH

DA TE !

SA VE TH E Special Events Upcoming

THE OFFICIAL AWARD- WINNING PUBLICATION OF THE LEE COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION

JANUA

2. My greatest professional or academic accomplishment thus far is being appointed as a circuit court judge in the 20th Judicial Circuit Court by Gov. Ron DeSantis. Second to that, it would be representing the United States as an assistant United States attorney.

4

LEADING THE NEX T GENERATION OF LAW YER S Meet the

COURT ING Success AT MOCK TRIAL

High Schoolers Prep for Circuit Competition

2024 YLD Board

BREAK ING NEWS:

IMMIGRATION LAW UPDAT

RY 202

E

FEBRUARY 2024

Contact Ed Kitsos 239.267.2638 or RGSales@PriorityMarketing.com

3. I once sat outside at a restaurant in Sonoma County, California for lunch, looked to my left and there was David Beckham, Posh Spice and Gordon Ramsey sitting an arm’s length away. David and I exchanged a look of mutual respect for each other's hair, and Gordon Ramsey was the nicest guy ever.

4. Cooking is my favorite hobby. It's an escape for me.

Although, with a toddler running around the house, I have to approach the creation of each meal like I am in the Chopped kitchen. That is, time is of the essence!

5. Advice to my younger self? Always be yourself, be patient with your career, don't be afraid to challenge yourself and find great mentors – the more the merrier.

MAY & JUNE 2025 41

INTERIOR FEATURE

By Maria Alaimo, Esq.

THE JURY IS IN

COUNTY COMPETITION FINAL RESULTS

LOCAL STUDENTS ROCK MOCK TRIAL 2025

February 6-7, 2025

Best Attorney (Prosecution) Azriela Contreras Sponsored by The Law Offices of Kristianna Soto, P.A. Best Attorney (Defense) Natasha Agarwal Sponsored by Titan Law Best Witness (Prosecution) Remy Foos Sponsored by Poblet Legal, PLLC. Best Witness (Defense) Brigitte Maillakakis Sponsored by Titan Law Best Opening Benjamin O’Brien Sponsored by Law Office of Marcy L. Shaw Best Closing Jaya Parsa Sponsored by Lee County Bar Association Foundation, in honor of Miguel C. Fernandez, III

1

Team Professionalism Cypress Lake High School Sponsored by The Law Office of Karla Campos-Andersen

2 In early February, high school students from across Lee County gathered at the courthouse in downtown Fort Myers for the annual Mock Trial County and Circuit Competitions, hosted by the Lee County Bar Association (LCBA) in partnership with the School District of Lee County.

BLACK’S LAW DICTIONARY U.S. CONSTITUTION THE POWER OF WORDS

42 LEEBAR.ORG

Started in 1991, this time-honored tradition provides a way for students to investigate a potential career as an attorney by getting hands-on in the courtroom and putting their legal knowledge into action. This year, students tackled a criminal case involving a second-degree murder, using details and rules prepared by the Justice Teaching Center at Florida Southern College.

3 Six teams participated in this year’s event.

Following the county competition, Fort Myers High School emerged victorious and advanced to the circuit competition, which was hosted in Lee County this year. At the circuit level, which included teams from Charlotte, Collier and Lee counties, a team from Charlotte County proceeded to the State Mock Trial Championship.

Congratulations to each student who participated.

You brought your best to the 2025 Mock Trial Competition, and LCBA can’t wait to see where you go from here!

4

5

6 1-2. Mock Trial Teams awaiting verdicts 3. Brigitte Maillakakis 4. Fort Myers High School 5. Natasha Agarwal 6. Azriela Contreras 7. Benjamin O'Brien with Parents Christy and Aaron O'Brien 8. Remy Foos and Award Sponsor, Minerva Poblet

7

78 MAY & JUNE 2025 43

YOUNG LAWYERS DIVISION

By Gabriel Arbois, Esq.

GROWING with GUIDANCE Finding and Building Meaningful Mentorship Opportunities

As an associate at Hahn Loeser in complex commercial litigation, Gabriel Arbois is involved in cases through all stages, including legal research and drafting pleadings, motions and discovery. Gabriel graduated cum laude from Florida International University College of Law. Prior to joining Hahn Loeser, he worked for one of Florida’s largest civil defense firms and clerked for the Honorable Judge Migna Sanchez-Llorens in the 11th Judicial Circuit Court of Florida.

44 LEEBAR.ORG

For young lawyers, mentorship can be one of the most valuable tools for personal and professional development. A mentor can offer more than just advice—they can help you find your footing, guide you through difficult decisions, introduce you to professional networks, help you avoid common pitfalls and offer perspective that only comes with experience. But while mentorship is important, it doesn’t always fall in your lap, so you may need to be intentional in seeking it out.

request simple and clear. A brief email or in-person conversation expressing your curiosity and requesting a short meeting – coffee or lunch – is often the most effective approach.

If the person agrees to meet, show up prepared.

Have a few thoughtful questions ready and be mindful of their time. If the conversation goes well, follow up with a thank you note and stay in touch.

Consistent, respectful communication helps build the relationship over time.

The first step in seeking mentorship is to reflect on what kind of guidance you need. Are you looking for courtroom knowledge, help building a practice, or insight into work-life balance?

That said, not all mentorships will be formal or long term. Some of the most helpful advice can come from brief, organic conversations. For instance, the LCBA’s Young Lawyers Division hosts events like “Burritos with the Bench,” which offers a relaxed environment for legal professionals to engage with judges outside the formal courtroom setting.

Different mentors bring different strengths, and understanding what you’re looking for will help you identify the right people to approach. Once you’ve clarified your goals, begin paying attention to the lawyers and judges you admire. Whether it’s a colleague who handles themselves well under pressure or a judge whose courtroom demeanor you respect, the legal community offers countless opportunities to observe and learn.

Attend local bar events, CLEs, and community programs. These are not only great for learning, but also for naturally meeting potential mentors.

Once you identify someone you’d like to learn from and it comes time to reach out, keep your

Finally, remember that mentorship is a two-way street. As you gain experience, look for ways to mentor others. By helping the next generation of attorneys, you strengthen not only your own practice but the entire legal community. In a place as collegial and tight knit as Lee County, these connections matter. A strong mentorship can last an hour, a season or a lifetime – but either way, it begins with a single, respectful ask.

MAY & JUNE 2025 45

LEGAL LENS

Health & Wellness Symposium

H&W Symposium

On April 11, the Lee County Bar Association (LCBA) and the Family Resource Center of Southwest Florida (FRC) hosted their second annual Spring Symposium, titled "Biohacking... Mind, Heart & Body," at The Collaboratory in downtown Fort Myers.

This five-hour event brought together local professionals and community members to explore practical approaches to enhancing health and well-being. The symposium featured expert-led sessions on stress management, nutrition, gut health, detoxification, regenerative farming, and more! We had people of all walks of life and in the medical and health fields provide up-to-date crunchy health tips as well as answer a variety of questions. The event also offered powerful testimonials, networking opportunities, and physical exercise, including yoga and an Ultimate Breath Experience.

Held at The Collaboratory, a hub for community innovation, the symposium underscored the importance of holistic health practices in fostering a resilient and thriving community. We can only be our best in the community when we are well.

24 46 LEEBAR.ORG

1

3

4

5

6 1. Jordan Gatlin 2. Symposium Breath Experience 3. Symposium Yoga Workshop 4. Symposium Breath Experience Attendees 5. Chris Oikos 6. Dr. Teresa Spano 7. Dr. Tammy Bergum 8. Dr. John Edwards

7

78 MAY & JUNE 2025 47

COMMUNITY CONNECTION

By Dave Breitenstein

Feeding Southwest Florida, today and into the future.

Opulence is everywhere in Southwest Florida... beachfront mansions on Sanibel Island, posh high-rises along the Naples coastline and luxury car dealerships up and down U.S. 41.

Travel guides, real estate flyers and entertainment publications don't tell the full story, though.

Across our region, one in eight people – including one in six children and one in 12 seniors – is food insecure. This means they don’t have regular access to healthy, nutritious food and don’t always know where their next meal is coming from.

“Many Southwest Floridians, including those who have lived here for decades, cannot fathom that some of our neighbors are experiencing hunger,” said Richard LeBer, president and CEO of Harry Chapin Food Bank. “It’s not just people who are jobless or homeless that are food insecure. They are our neighbors – families, children, seniors and veterans.”

Since the pandemic, another group has emerged – working professionals.

“These individuals represent the ‘new hungry,’” said Kayla Richmond Miller, a board member for Harry Chapin Food Bank and attorney for Henderson, Franklin, Starnes & Holt, P.A. “They are employed full-time as educators, health care professionals, public service workers and others. They have never asked for help, but after facing the pandemic, multiple hurricanes, inflation and soaring rent, they simply don’t have enough money once bills are paid to go grocery shopping.”

“We must come together,” LeBer added. “When we support each other and take collective action, our community wins.”

Since 1983, Harry Chapin Food Bank has led the region’s hunger-relief efforts. About one-fourth of the nonprofit’s revenue derives from government sources; the remainder comes from generous individuals, businesses and foundations. Grocery stores, food distributors and local farms also do their part, providing in-kind support. Through a Feeding Network of 175 agency partners, Harry Chapin Food Bank serves 250,000 neighbors monthly at food banks, mobile pantries and distribution sites across Charlotte, Collier, Glades, Hendry and Lee counties.

HarryChapinFoodBank.org | 239-334-7007 48 LEEBAR.ORG

As the region’s population grows, so does hunger.

Statistics provided by Harry Chapin Food Bank prove that point: 2024

2023

39.5

35.7

2022

34.9

million pounds of food distributed

million pounds of food distributed

million pounds of food distributed

(equivalent to 32.9 million meals)

(equivalent to 29 million meals)

(equivalent to 28.9 million meals)

“Those numbers represent a 13.2% increase in food distributed over two years,” LeBer notes. “That only tells half the story, though. The cost of everything we purchase – produce, meats, canned goods, cereal, pasta and more – has also increased by double digits, making it even more important to amplify our fundraising efforts.”

By 2030, the Food Bank expects to distribute more than 50 million pounds of food annually.

“Hunger has reached a crisis level in Southwest Florida,” LeBer said, “but if there is one thing I have learned since I moved here, it’s that our community always responds during our neighbors’ time in need.”

“There is power in numbers, and imagine if our entire legal community got behind hunger as our primary charitable cause,” Miller said. “Whether you’re donating resources or volunteering your time, our neighbors need us to step up and join Harry Chapin Food Bank’s fight to end hunger in Southwest Florida.”

Volunteer Opportunities • Food packing: Distribution centers in Fort Myers and Naples welcome groups of 10-20 individuals in shifts lasting three hours.

Volunteers can pack produce or canned and boxed foods into meal kits.

• Food distributions: Mobile food pantries are held nearly every day at locations across Southwest Florida. Volunteers can place items in neighbors’ bags or vehicles.

• Food collections: Employee or workplace food drive can include donations of breakfast bars, canned fish or chicken, dry or canned beans, canned vegetables, pasta, bottled pasta sauces, cooking oil, dry milk, jelly, rice and canned soups.

MAY & JUNE 2025 49

100 CLUB

IS YOUR FIRM PART OF THE 100 CLUB? Any firm with two or more attorneys and 100% membership in LCBA qualifies. If you feel your firm is eligible, email a listing of your attorneys to admin@leebar.org, and we will let you know.

Absolute Law, P.A.

GrayRobinson, P.A.

Patrone Bentley Law Group

All Injuries Law

Green, Schoenfeld & Kyle, LLP

Pavese Law Firm

Aloia, Roland, Lubell & Morgan, PLLC.

Hahn, Loeser & Parks, LLP

Pope Mazzara & Menendez PLLC

Arend & Sisk, P.A.

Holz Family Law

Robert Harris Law Firm

Associates & Bruce L. Scheiner, P.A.

Kagan Law Firm

Roetzel & Andress, L.P.A.

Bergermann Law Firm

Kemp & Mace, P.A.

Scarmozzino/King Trial Lawyers

Boy Agnew Potanovic Miller, PLLC.

Knott Ebelini Hart

Schmucker & Lavy Legal, PLLC

Boyle & Leonard & Anderson, P.A.

Law Offices of Dennis L. Webb, P.A.

Sheldon E. Finman, P.A.

Burandt, Adamski, Feichthaler & Sanchez, PLLC.

Law Offices of Michael M. Raheb, Criminal Lawyer

Sheppard Law Firm

Calvo & Calvo, Attorneys at Law

Law Offices of Scott T. Moorey

Simmons & Cook, PLLC

City of Fort Myers Attorney’s Office

Lee County Legal Aid Society, Inc.

Spivey Law Firm, Personal Injury Attorneys, P.A.

Freidin & Inglis, P.A.

Light Path Law, P.A.

Strayhorn, Persons-Mulicka & Fisher, P.L.

Garvin Injury Law

Linde Law Group

School District of Lee County

Goldberg, Noone, Abraham

Men’s Rights Law Firm

Viles & Beckman, LLC

Goldstein, Buckley, Cechman, Rice, Purtz, Smith & Smith

Office of the City Attorney (Cape Coral)

Wilbur Smith, LLC

Osterhout & McKinney, P.A.

Yeslow, Koeppel & Anderson

50 LEEBAR.ORG

MEMBER SPOTLIGHT

THINGS YOU DON'T KNOW ABOUT ME

u Rob Anderson

1. I was excited to come to Fort Myers primarily for the fishing opportunities, but it really has been the community and the people we’ve made connections with that have led my family to put down roots here. I can't think of a place that would be a better fit for my family.

2. Fishing has always been my favorite hobby, and it probably will be again in a few years, but today there’s nothing I’d rather do than watch my daughter in a dance competition or my son play baseball.

3. I take my son to a sports car race called the 24 Hours of Daytona every year. We haven't missed a race in seven years, and we do it bigger and better each year. We camp in the infield and usually have to contend with bad weather and any number of self-inflicted camping adversities, but that is part of what makes it fun.

4. I’m a Florida Gator, because I was raised a Gator – and I was lucky enough to go to law school there. I have a lot of memories from the Swamp growing up. Last year, I was able to take my father and my son to see the Gators in the College World Series. By the time you're reading this, the Gators will have won the NCAA Tournament.

5. I attended the 1996 Sugar Bowl and was able to see the Gators beat FSU 52-20 to earn their first national championship. It will never get better than that!

MAY & JUNE 2025 51

52 LEEBAR.ORG

Thank You

To Our 2025 Foundation Contributors!

Jane Abaravich, Esq. Benjamin Abdulnour, Esq. Sheba Abraham, Esq. John Agnew, Esq. Maria Alaimo, Esq. Albert Alguadich, Esq. Jeremiah Ambabo, Esq. Amanda Anderson, Esq. Robert Anderson, Esq. Gabriel Arbois, Esq. Ronald Arend, Esq. Scott Atwood, Esq. Alexis Barkis, Esq. Melissa Barris, Esq. Albert Batista, Esq. John Belcastro, Esq. Victor Bermudez, Esq. Madaline Bischel, Esq. Ljubica Bjazeric, Esq. Brooke Blackman, Esq. William Boltrek, Esq. Braxton Bowen, Esq. Suzanne Boy, Esq. Mark Boyle, Esq. Alexander Brockmeyer, Esq. Molly Brockmeyer, Esq. Benjamin Brown, Esq. Philip Burnett, Esq. Garey Butler, Esq. Katheryn Calvo, Esq. Jose Calvo, Esq. Katherine Camadeco, Esq. Karla Campos-Andersen Esq. Edward Canterbury, Esq. Gary Carmen, Esq. Joe Cerino, Esq. Michael Cheffer, Esq. Michael Chionopoulos, Esq. Michael Colombo, Esq. Kati Cook, Esq. Jay Cooper, Esq. Spencer Cordell, Esq. Michael Corso, Esq. Terry Cramer III, Esq. Taylor Curley, Esq. Dan Dalesandro, Esq. L. David Sims, Esq. Donald Day, Esq. Indera DeMine, Esq. Joan DeMichael Henry, Esq. Olimpia DePena, Esq. Ody Dickman, Esq. Stephen Dommerich, Esq. Hayley Donaldson, Esq. Jarred Duke, Esq. Lance Dunford, Esq. Mark Ebelini, Esq. Thomas Eckerty, Esq. Samantha Encalada, Esq. Jennifer Fairbanks, Esq. Charles Ferber, Esq. William Ferris, Esq. Julia Finman, Esq.

Shelly Finman, Esq. Jennifer Fisher, Esq. Eric Fluharty, Esq. Howard Freidin, Esq. Herbert Fried, Esq. Linda Fried, Esq. Wayne Frohlich, Esq. Casey Gartland, Esq. Leland Garvin, Esq. Daniel Garza, Esq. Steven Gendreau, Esq. George Gift, Esq. Paul Giordano, Esq. Malcam Godwin, Esq. Logan Goldberg, Esq. Scot Goldberg, Esq. Douglas Gould, Esq. Brian Greenberg, Esq. George Griffin, Esq. Jesse Gubernat, Esq. Thomas Gunderson, Esq. Samuel Hagan, Esq. Jennifer Hammond, Esq. Blake Hampton, Esq. Ginine Hanco, Esq. Daniel Hanuka, Esq. Thomas Hart, Esq. Stacey Haverfield, Esq. Michael Haymans, Esq. Craig Hersch, Esq. Scott Hertz, Esq. Michael Hill, Esq. Emily Hogentogeler, Esq. David Holley, Esq. James Holloway, Esq. Christina Holly, Esq. Rana Holz, Esq. Dominika Honisch, Esq. Michael Hornung, Esq. William Horowitz, Esq. Philip Howard, Esq. Jonathan Huffman, Esq. Pablo Hurtado, Esq. Frank Holley II, Esq. Joel Hyatt, Esq. Stephen Kagan, Esq. Jason King, Esq. George Mitar III, Esq. John Miller III, Esq. Jack Morgan III, Esq. Jerry Olivo III, Esq. J. Tom Smoot III, Esq. Richard Inglis, Esq. Ken Jones, Esq. Frank Aloia Jr, Esq. Ernest Hatch Jr, Esq. D. Hugh Kinsey Jr, Esq. Elizabeth Kagan, Esq. Christopher Kagan, Esq. Peter Kamm, Esq. Luke Kane, Esq. Colby Keefe, Esq. Anna Kegelmeyer, Esq.

Carlos Kelly, Esq. Kenny Kemp, Esq. James Kerr, Esq. Tim Kizzire, Esq. Asher Knipe, Esq. Peter Knize, Esq. George Knott, Esq. Steven Koeppel, Esq. Kevin Kyle, Esq. Mike Dal Lago, Esq. Michael Leonard, Esq. Vee Leonard, Esq. Steven Leskovich, Esq. Matthew Linde, Esq. Drew Lipscher, Esq. Courtney Lovejoy, Esq. Evan Lubell, Esq. Benjamin Lusk, Esq. T. Brandon Mace, Esq. Richard Mancini, Esq. Jonathan Martin, Esq. Dawn Maselli, Esq. Jason Maughan, Esq. Justin Mazzara, Esq. Stephen McCann, Esq. Matthew McConnell, Esq. Patrick McLain, Esq. Michael McQuagge, Esq. Lisa Mead, Esq. Anthony Melchiorre, Esq. Alexander Menendez, Esq. Jason Mikes, Esq. Mark Miller, Esq. Lori Moore, Esq. Scott Moorey, Esq. John Morgan, Esq. Jenna Persons-Mulicka, Esq. Timothy Murty, Esq. John Musca, Esq. R. Frank Myers, Esq. Terry Nelson, Esq. Michael Noone, Esq. Joseph North, Esq. Joseph North Jr, Esq. Aaron O’Brien, Esq. Christina O'Brien, Esq. Kenneth Oliver, Esq. Henry Lee Paul, Esq. Raymond Pelstring, Esq. Shelly Perry, Esq. Michael Anthony Pica, Esq. Rochelle Pitts, Esq. Barbara Pizzolato, Esq. Minerva Poblet, Esq. Genet Polly, Esq. Christopher Pope, Esq. John Potanovic, Esq. Beth Prather, Esq. Jill Prenger, Esq. Richard Pringle, Esq. Robert Pritt, Esq. Shannon Puopolo, Esq. Michael Raheb, Esq.

Michael Randolph, Esq. Leon Rendeiro, Esq. Gary Rhodes, Esq. Michael Rich, Esq. Kayla Richmond, Esq. Luis Rivera II, Esq. Adrian Roe, Esq. Matthew Roepstorff, Esq. Ty Roland, Esq. Derek Rooney, Esq. David Roos, Esq. Ben Russell, Esq. Cameron Sadighi, Esq. Chris Santospirito, Esq. James Scarmozzino, Esq. PJ Scheiner, Esq. Bruce Scheiner, Esq. Lowell Schoenfeld, Esq. Kristie Scott, Esq. Alessandro Secino, Esq. Danielle Seitz, Esq. Carol Sellers, Esq. Samuel Sendrow, Esq. Amanda Sharkey-Ross, Esq. Spencer Shaw, Esq. Brendan Shearman, Esq. Melissa Sherman, Esq. Robert Shearman, Esq. Thomas Shepard, Esq. Gus Simmons, Esq. Deans Sisk, Esq. Joeie Skelly, Esq. Ellen Smith, Esq. Sawyer Smith, Esq. John Spear, Esq. Vicki Sproat, Esq. Dan Stengle, Esq. Bruce Strayhorn, Esq. Megan Strayhorn, Esq. Janet Strickland, Esq. Carolann Swanson, Esq. Richard Swift, Esq. Doug Szabo, Esq. Madison Tanner, Esq. Michael Tew, Esq. Colten Thomas, Esq. Justin Thomas, Esq. Aisha Tirado, Esq. Matthew Toll, Esq. Greg Toomey, Esq. Michael Traficante, Esq. Kaylee Tuck, Esq. S. Thomas Ullman, Esq. Vincent Tolisano, Esq. Denise Molina-Vel, Esq. Michael Versnik, Esq. Robert White, Esq. Michael Whitt, Esq. Charles Whittington, Esq. Mark Yeslow, Esq.

MAY & JUNE 2025 53

IN THE NEWS 36 UNDER 36 AND COOKING Katherine “Kati” Cook was awarded the 2024-25 YLD 36 Under Thirty-Six Professionalism Award for her unwavering commitment to civility, integrity and service in the legal profession. A dedicated civil litigation and employment law attorney at Boy Agnew Potanovic Miller, PLLC, Kati exemplifies professionalism through her respectful advocacy, ethical practice and dedication to community service.

YLD WINS SMALL AFFILIATE OF THE YEAR AWARD The Lee County Bar Association Young Lawyers Division (LCBA YLD) was named the 2024-25 Small Affiliate of the Year in recognition of its professional development initiatives and creative programming. The LCBA YLD has demonstrated a commitment to young attorneys and the local community through events such as pro bono legal clinics, CLE programs, including a session on “AI and Ethics,” and fostered judicial engagement through events like Burritos with the Bench. The LCBA YLD continues to inspire camaraderie among young lawyers.

THE STATE OF THE DISTRICT On Wednesday, April 2, the SWFL Bar Association welcomed the general public for a State of the District presentation at The Veranda in downtown Fort Myers. Provided by the Honorable Chief Judge of the Middle District of Florida, Marcia Morales Howard, the free presentation included food, drinks and a half-hour of CLE credit for local attorneys.

54 LEEBAR.ORG

NEW TWENTIETH CIRCUIT JUDICIARY Judge William Dorman began working as an assistant state attorney in the 20th Judicial Circuit County in 2010.

In 2015, he became the only full-time assistant state attorney in Glades County, as well as the felony chief and assistant office head for Hendry/Glades County. He is a graduate of Auburn University and the Florida State University School of Law. He fills the judicial vacancy created by the retirement of Judge Jack Lundy.

Judge Tracey Redd has over 27 years of courtroom experience, and 23 of those years were served in the 20th Judicial Circuit Court. In 2002, she opened her private practice after serving as an assistant public defender for four years in Broward and Lee counties. Judge Redd earned her bachelor’s degree from Fairfield University and her juris doctor from the University of Miami School of Law.

Judge Sean Lux served as an assistant state attorney in the 20th Judicial Circuit Court from 2018 to 2021.

His experience includes serving as an associate attorney and partner through 2025. Judge Lux is a graduate of Ave Maria School of Law, as well as the University of Colorado and City University of Seattle. He fills the judicial vacancy created by the retirement of Judge Peter Bell.

Judge Michael Powell served as an assistant state attorney with the State Attorney’s Office in Punta Gorda for a decade. For more than 17 years, Judge Powell practiced criminal defense and family law in a private practice.

Judge Powell obtained his bachelor’s degree from the University of South Florida and his juris doctor from Mississippi College School of Law. He fills the judicial vacancy created by Judge Paul Alessandroni.

SCOUTS HONOR JUDGE GAGLIARDI The Hon. Josephine Gagliardi recently received the Southwest Florida Council of Boy Scouts of America Leadership Award, in recognition of her service as Council President. In her role as president of the local Scouting America chapter, Judge Gagliardi has guided young scouts, helping them grow through service, skill building and community involvement. It all started when she got involved through her son, who is an Eagle Scout. LCBA congrats you on this well-deserved honor!

CHAMBER LUNCH IS IN SESSION In February, the YLD put on its first-ever “Chambers Lunch” program. The Hon. Kyle Cohen hosted attendees for an informal roundtable lunch featuring Panera. Chambers Lunches are intended to connect the bench and bar outside the formalities of court or typical LCBA events. This program is designed to have limited attendance — allowing participants to get to know one another on a personal level over lunch.

With Judge Cohen as host, the YLD’s first Chambers Lunch was, unsurprisingly, a smashing success. Attendees clamored for a follow-up, so YLD intends to continue this program. We hope you join us for lunch next time!

MAY & JUNE 2025 55

IN THE NEWS CONGRATS, DEPUTY CHIEF! LCBA’s own Vice President, John Dommerich, Jr., Esq., has been promoted to the position of Deputy Chief Assistant State Attorney.

“Congratulations to John! He will be in charge of our Collier County office. In this role, John will be responsible for overseeing the day-to-day operations of our Collier County office,” said Amira Fox, State Attorney for the 20th Judicial Circuit Court of Florida, covering Charlotte, Collier, Glades, Hendry and Lee counties.

ATTORNEYS ON THE MOVE The law firm of Henderson, Franklin, Starnes & Holt, P.A. is pleased to announce that real estate attorney Colten Thomas has been appointed to the Board of Directors for the Uncommon Friends Foundation.

A third-generation Fort Myers native, Thomas is deeply committed to the responsible development and preservation of Southwest Florida’s rich history.

As an associate at Henderson Franklin, he counsels clients on land use matters, community association issues and real estate transactions.

Additionally, the firm is pleased to welcome Michael Green as a senior associate in its workers’ compensation department. With more than 15 years of experience in labor and employment law, he focuses his practice on defending employers, insurance carriers and self-insured entities against workers’ compensation claims throughout Florida.

56 LEEBAR.ORG

SHARE YOUR NEWS! If you have legal news to share, we want to hear from you!

Please send press releases to RGEditor@ PriorityMarketing.com.

SHOW AND TELL AT CYPRESS LAKE MIDDLE SCHOOL On March 14, a delegation of LCBA members visited Mr. Stansell and Mrs. Voyer’s civics classes at Cypress Lake Middle School.

Attorneys Asma Anwar, Ryan Downey, Michael Raheb, Lisa Heffington, Kristianna Soto and David Holton educated the bright young students about criminal law defense from a private and public defense perspective.

MAY & JUNE 2025 57

Estate Planning is all about preparing for an unknown future.

Our caring and experienced advocates are the supporting cast you’ve been looking for to complete your clients’ trusted advisor team.

FOUNDERS

There are no dress rehearsals for life’s uncertainties.

58 LEEBAR.ORG

Shelley R. PERRY, JD

Linda O.

FLORES, CDP

Professional Fiduciary and Lifecare Management Solutions

239.206.1203 | SeniorAGroup.com 2390 Tamiami Trail North, Suite 202 | Naples, FL 34103

THANK YOU TO OUR LCBA SPONSORS Want to see your firm or business on this list?

Contact Lauren Baugh at LBaugh@LeeBar.org or (239) 334-0047.

PLATINUM

GOLD GOLD

GOLD SILVER

GOLD

BRONZE

INGOLD KIND Jim Jett Photography MAY & JUNE 2025 59

LEGAL NOTICE ADVERTISING Meet your legal notice requirements with our broad coverage to publish in Lee, Collier, Charlotte, Sarasota, Manatee, Pinellas, Pasco, Hillsborough, Polk, Orange, Flagler and Volusia counties, or any combination of the 12.

The Business Observer offers: • Electronic invoicing and E-filing capabilities • Professional staff to quickly assist you • Low competitive flat rates • Qualified legal status • All print notices published by the Business Observer are automatically placed on BusinessObserverFL.com and FloridaPublicNotices.com at no additional cost To publish your legal notices, call Kristen:

941-906-9386, ext. 323

XNLV21572

Email: kboothroyd@BusinessObserverFL.com

BusinessObserverFL.com

Florida’s Leading Business Publication

FREE Consultations

Bill B. Berke Truck Accident Lawyer

We pay permissible referral and co-counsel fees. We look forward to co-counseling with you.

Lawyer for Life Barbara M. Pizzolato, Esq.  Over 30 years experience  Licensed to practice in New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, and Florida  Committed to establishing long-lasting relationships with her clients  Offers personalized, customized legal services that clients expect and deserve

(239) 225-7911

8660 College Parkway. Suite 400 Fort Myers, FL 33919

CALL 800.572.3735 truckwreckflorida.com

PIZZOLATOLAW.COM 60 LEEBAR.ORG

DONOR LISTING MENTAL HEALTH & WELLNESS MISSION Thank You, Mental Health and Wellness Mission Sponsors

DIAMOND SPONSOR - $10,000

SILVER SPONSORS GOLD - $2,000 Holly Cosby, Esq. | Honorable Kathy Smith

GOLD - $1,000 BRONZE SPONSORS

Robert Bowen, Esq. | Holly Cosby, Esq. | Joseph North, Esq.

GOLD

PEARL SPONSORS - $350 Honorable Kathy Smith | Karla Campos-Andersen, Esq. | Judge Joseph Foster

INDIVIDUAL MHWM CONTRIBUTORS GOLD Michael Corso, Esq. | T. Rankin Terry, Esq. | Steven Spence, Esq. Shelly Finman, Esq. | William Stockman, Esq. MAY & JUNE 2025 61

SPONSOR SPOTLIGHT

BOY AG N E W P OTAN OVIC M I LLE R EMPLOYMENT | BUSINESS | GOVERNMENT

YOUR BUSINESS IS OUR BUSINESS

Rethinking the traditional law firm model, Boy Agnew Potanovic Miller (BAPM) is a collaborative, service-oriented firm that aligns our firm’s interests with our clients’ interests on everything from fee structures to business goals.

BAPM is the only law firm in Southwest Florida with multiple attorneys who are board certified in labor and employment law by The Florida Bar. With that unique credential, our primary focus is naturally on the workplace, and we help employers with all the issues that arise between employers and their employees. We pride ourselves in being proactive in our counseling and our training, with the goal of helping clients avoid claims and lawsuits, but when the need arises, we are also experienced, talented litigators willing to fight for our clients.

In addition to our employment law practice, our attorneys represent several local government entities, acting as general counsel in their day-to-day operations, and we also handle a significant variety of litigation matters ranging from complex business litigation to insurance defense.

Training

Even great employers make mistakes. Complex and evolving employment laws create an environment ripe for mistakes with costly consequences. Our training sessions give your managers the knowledge and tools necessary to correctly handle the workplace issues before they become legal problems.

Counseling

Sometimes, the best defense is avoiding the offense.

From hire to termination and everything in between, we can help you proactively identify legal risks and create solutions that not only work for your business but also protect your bottom line.

Litigation

When you have to draw the line, we’ve got your back.

We will help you identify what success looks like in a particular claim or lawsuit, then fight to help you achieve those goals.

Contact our team by calling 239-208-6500 or visiting bapfirm.com.

62 LEEBAR.ORG

SPONSOR SPOTLIGHT

IN PURSUIT OF THE “GOLDSTEIN” STANDARD

Goldstein, Buckley, Cechman, Rice, Purtz, Smith & Smith P.A., is a personal injury firm representing those injured by the wrongdoing of others in Southwest Florida since 1962.

The firm's recent name update reflects the next generation of leaders for the 62-year-old Southwest Florida law firm.

Christopher J. Smith, managing partner, along with his wife, firm partner Andrea Smith, have been the face of the firm for the past five years. “We continue to pursue the standard set by one of our founders, the late Ray Goldstein, of respect, passion and unwavering pursuit for justice, which we affectionately call the Goldstein Standard,” said Christopher Smith. “And because I know people will ask, the catchy, iconic jingle we use in our commercials continues, too.”

While the name has changed, the firm still occupies its original office at the corner of Main Street and Broadway in downtown Fort Myers where it started and has grown through the years by buying neighboring offices. Other offices are in Cape Coral, Naples, Lehigh Acres and Port Charlotte.

Christopher Smith joined the firm in 2007 after receiving his law degree from St. Thomas University School of Law in 2007. He became a partner in 2011 and a managing partner in 2018. Andrea Pleimling Smith, who graduated from Marquette University Law School, joined the firm in 2014. Christopher and Andrea initially met as opposing counsel when she was working at another firm. Andrea then joined the firm in 2014 and became a partner in 2017.

Other named partners in the firm’s name include Stephen Buckley, who has been with the firm since 1969, John Cechman, who has been with the firm since 1972, Jeffrey Rice who has been with the firm since 1976 and retired in 2023, and Managing Partner Richard Purtz, who joined the firm in 1983. Additional attorneys include partner Eve T.K. Volkmann, who joined the firm in 2019 and became partner in 2024. Attorney Kristin L. Stocks and Mark Precheur joined the firm in 2024.

AREAS OF PRACTICE PERSONAL INJURY AND ACCIDENTS | TRIP, SLIP AND FALL | PREMISES LIABILITY WRONGFUL DEATH | MOTORCYCLE AND TRUCK ACCIDENTS MEDICAL MALPRACTICE | WILLS | ESTATE PLANNING AND ADMINISTRATION

THE FIRM MAY BE REACHED BY CALLING 239-500-HURT OR VISITING JUSTICESTARTSNOW.COM. MAY & JUNE 2025 63

P.O. Box 1387 Fort Myers, FL 33902-1387

PRSRT STD U.S. POSTAGE PAID FT. MYERS, FL PERMIT NO. 147

(239) 334-0047 Fax (239) 334-0523 LEEBAR.ORG

LOCAL DECISION MAKERS. A BETTER WAY TO BORROW. Like Thomas Edison, we believe there is always “a better way.”

To us, that means being attentive, invested and involved in the efforts of our community’s business owners and residents as we provide them with lending services that empower them to reach their goals.

As a bank with a 5-Star Superior Rating from Bauer Financial, we are standing strong with money to lend. With a history of long-term stability and resilience, we are absolutely committed to remaining well-positioned to honor our promises and protect our banking customers.

Greg Blurton Vice President, Sr. Commercial Loan Officer

Michael Greenhoe Vice President, Commercial Loan Officer

Kim Nyberg Vice President,

Professional & Executive Banking

Richard Shera Vice President,

Residential & Consumer Loan Officer

We Make Banking About You!

S. Cleveland Avenue 239.466.1800

Bank of the Islands - Sanibel 239.472.7211

River District 239.334.4668

Bank of the Islands - Captiva 239.395.0248

EdisonNationalBank.com Equal Housing Lender | Member FDIC | Bank of the Islands is an office of Edison National Bank.