NEWSPAPER OF RECORD SINCE 1885
VOL. CXXXIV NO. 36
THURSDAY, MARCH 19, 2020
COURTS
COVID-19 Tightens Grip On South Fork
Tennant’s Trial Nears The End It’s he said, she said in attempted murder case BY TAYLOR K. VECSEY Courthouses throughout Suffolk County are closed amid the spread of COVID-19, but the trial of Patchita Tennant, a longtime manager at the East Hampton CVS pharmacy who is charged with attempted murder, continues. The jury has heard from both Ms. Tennant, 43, and her former boyfriend, Andrew Mitchell, 47, who, after living together for nearly 20 years, presented two very different accounts of what happened in their Flanders house on the evening of Sept. 5, 2019. It seems likely that the outcome of the case will hinge upon which of their stories the jury believes. Mr. Mitchell took the stand on Friday morning, acknowledging that he was often unfaithful and went about his own life while Ms. Tennant cared for their young daughter and worked long hours at what is said to be the busiest CVS on Long Island, in the top 10 in the country among 7,000 stores. The prosecutor, Eric Aboulafia, an assistant county district attorney, anticipated the questions that Mr. Mitchell’s past would raise. He questioned Mr.
Global pandemic has ‘changed life as we know it’
With restaurants ordered to close their dining rooms and transition to takeout and delivery only on Monday as the fight against COVID-19 ramps up, Paul Novack, a bartender at the American Hotel in Sag Harbor, locked the door after the last customer departed. Doug Kuntz
Continued on A7
At Precipice of Peril Fight against virus brings economy to sudden halt BY JAMIE BUFALINO Businesses of all sorts in New York State ground to a screeching halt this week, as the COVID-19 pandemic forced a near-total shutdown of commercial activity and ordinary life. As the federal government struggles to catch up to the fast-evolving pandemic — President Trump declared on Monday that the crisis could last into July, August, or beyond — the 2020 tourist season, the most critical weeks for so many South Fork residents’ financial well-being, is suddenly uncertain. Restaurants, which were still doing a brisk business over the weekend with an influx of second-home owners fleeing the increasingly locked down New York City area, were ordered on Monday to offer takeout and delivery only. The state also ordered theaters, gyms, fitness studios, and other businesses deemed non-essential to close. Grocery stores, gas stations, pharmacies, medical facilities, and media outlets may remain open. The economic impacts of the closures and curtailing of regular operations will be massive by all estimations. To assess the extent of the damage the pandemic has had on business, Suffolk Executive Steve Bellone announced on Tuesday that the county’s Labor Department will begin collecting data to “find out what is happening on the ground and what is happening with
the workforce.” The Labor Department will then use that information to advocate for funding and other support from the state and federal governments. “What we’ve seen over the last week has been stunning in terms of how quickly this has impacted the economy,” said Mr. Bellone. The county has already formed a business resource center that can be reached by calling 311, Suffolk Legislator Bridget Fleming said in a video posted on her Facebook page on Tuesday. “It’s important that we hear from businesses, not-for-profits, and art institutions so we can advocate for you at the state and federal level and help you get those funds.” Earlier that day, she said, she had proposed legislation that would allow the county to waive certain fees and taxes for small businesses. East Hampton Village Mayor Richard Lawler wrote to State Assemblyman Fred W. Thiele Jr. and State Senator Kenneth P. LaValle on Tuesday to request assistance for the village’s small businesses to offset the “detrimental financial effects” of the coronavirus pandemic. The voluntary order for people to remain at home and for restaurants to shut their dining rooms, have turned the village into “pretty much a ghost town,” Mr. Lawler said yesterday. “We’ve had 100 percent compliance from restauContinued on A4
VILLAGE HALL
Tiger Roars Into Race Graham to challenge Borsack, Larsen for mayor BY JAMIE BUFALINO Arthur Graham, an East Hampton Village trustee since 2017, declared his candidacy for mayor in June’s election on Monday. He joins Barbara Borsack, the deputy mayor, and Jerry Larsen, a former East Hampton Village police chief, in the village’s first contested mayoral election since 1992. Mr. Graham, who is known as Tiger, was first elected to the village board to serve out the final year of the late Elbert Edwards?s term. In 2018, he was reelected to a four-year term after campaigning as “an activist who wants to take on new stuff,” and arguing for a sewage treatment plant in the village. Last fall, the village board hired Nelson and Pope, an engineering firm, to develop a plan for a sewage treatment plant. “I brought that idea to the board,” Mr. Graham said in an interview. “If we can get sewage treatment, we can increase density, which means we can use second-floor apartments [for work-force housing]. And, to revitalize the village core, one of the things we need is more restaurants, because nobody comes to the village on Saturday to go to a real estate office.” He has proposed that a sewer district
SINGLE COPY $1
run along Montauk Highway from Egypt Lane to the Hedges Inn, and on Newtown Lane from Main Street to the Middle School. A portion of East Hampton Town would be included, he said, to provide sewage treatment for high-density developments such as the Windmill Village housing complex. To help pay for the system, he said, residents of the district would be taxed for its use, and “everyone else in the village will pay a smaller tax, because they’ll be getting the benefit of the improved downtown.” “The consultants may come back and have a different vision,” Mr. Graham said. “We’ll find out in a couple of weeks.” In the 2018 trustee election, he and Rose Brown, the highest vote-getter that year, were running mates. They had pledged, among other things, to restore vitality to the commercial district, improve Herrick Park and parking, and update the village’s comprehensive plan. “I think people realize that Rose and I are pretty much a team, and we are forward-looking,” Mr. Graham said Monday. “When Rose and I ran, we put out a series of new initiatives. We’ve taken them on, and we’ve gotten some traction on them.” Continued on A3
Dialing For Dinner Eateries aplenty transition to takeout BY BESS RATTRAY Restaurants were ordered to shut down their dining rooms, effective Monday evening, though many had already transitioned to takeout and delivery services in order to comply with social distancing recommendations. Here are some late-breaking announcements. The list will be updated online as information becomes available. Almond The Bridgehampton bistro at 1 Ocean Road is offering delivery to Sag Harbor, Bridgehampton, Sagaponack, and Wainscott. The regular menu is still available, either for delivery or for curbside pickup (“no need to leave your car,” the owners said.) They will give you a pickup time when you call. 631-537-5665. Next door, Almond’s partner food shop, L&W Market, has extended its hours. At last check, the market was reported full of specialty groceries, pastries, prepared foods, sandwiches, meats, cheeses, and pickles. The owners are working on deliveries -- stay tuned. Babette’s Always a destination for healthful meals, Babette’s, at 66 Newtown Lane in East Hampton, is taking orders for curbside pickup from Thursdays through Sundays. In addition to a juice-and-smoothie bar, with creative combinations for $12.95 a cup, breakfast and lunch offerings include vegan and glutenfree soups, goat cheese dumplings, salads, tofu-and-tempeh-centered items, and omelettes. Dinners are available Friday and Saturday nights only. Full menus are online at babettesrestaurant.com. 631329-5733. The Bell and Anchor Management announced reduced prices for “some of our best dishes at reduced prices” on Monday. The Bell’s new takeout service, including bottled beer and wine, is pickup only, Tuesdays to Sundays. Orders can be placed with a credit card by phone from 3:30 to 7 p.m.; pickup at 3253 Noyac Road in Noyac is from 5 to 7:30. To order earlier, email info@bellandanchor.com, inContinued on A4
BY CHRISTOPHER WALSH The South Fork is caught up in a rapidly accelerating public health emergency as the COVID-19 pandemic moved from dire warnings two weeks ago to declarations of states of emergency in all of the towns and villages on the North and South Forks this week. As of yesterday, New York State was reporting that nearly 2,400 had tested positive for the virus, a jump of more than 1,000 from the day before. Two cases had been reported in East Hampton Town (one of them in East Hampton Village), three had been reported in Southampton, 33 in Southold, and none on Shelter Island. At the current trajectory, Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo said yesterday, the state could have 110,000 cases within 45 days, outpacing its current hospital bed count of 53,000 regular beds and 3,000 intensive care beds. Government offices, schools, museums, and many businesses have been ordered to close. East Hampton Town declared a state of emergency on Friday, authorizing Supervisor Peter Van Scoyoc, in conjunction with Bruce Bates, the town’s emergency preparedness coordinator, and Town Police Chief Michael Sarlo to “take whatever actions are deemed nec-
essary to protect public health and safety,” according to a statement issued by the town on Friday afternoon. Most of East Hampton government meetings have been canceled until further notice. Essential departments like police, highway, buildings and grounds, and sanitation continue to operate. A separate story on police and other emergency responders appears elsewhere in today’s paper. At the town board’s abbreviated work session on Tuesday, Mr. Van Scoyoc announced a 50-percent reduction of personnel in many government departments starting yesterday, with some employees working from home if possible. The board’s meeting scheduled for this evening was canceled. Groups wishing to arrange meetings by teleconference have been asked to contact the supervisor’s office. Any town government meetings that do take place will be broadcast live on LTV’s channel 22 and archived at ltveh.org. With the exception of the Police Department and the recycling centers in East Hampton and Montauk, town-operated facilities were closed to the public as of Monday, and all programs were Continued on A8
Crash Course in Distance Learning Routines upended, schools and parents find solutions amid mandatory closure BY CHRISTINE SAMPSON Alexandra McCourt of East Hampton is keeping her 8-year-old son, Stefano McCourt-Rodas, busy with reading and math activities while school’s out. Gym class looks like walking the dog, hiking, and doing pushups. They wake up at the usual time each day and eat breakfast together. But she admits to being concerned about her kids — though not Stefano. Ms. McCourt happens to be a teacher, so she’s not worried about her own son keeping up with his studies. She’s more focused on her students at the East Hampton Middle School, where she teaches English as a new language. “I have students who have checked in online, but then I have kids who haven’t, and I can’t be there to force them to do that,” Ms. McCourt said by phone yesterday morning. “I think those that put the time in will be okay, but if people are not there helping their children and ensuring they are doing the work, those kids are going to fall behind.” Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo this week ordered schools statewide to close through March 31 because of the COVID-19 pandemic. Some districts here had already announced plans to close for two weeks, but the governor made it official. Many administrators believe the closure will be extended. While remote learning hasn’t officially started yet in East Hampton or Bridgehampton, among others — this week is technically being taken as unused snow days, and spring break has been moved up to next week in most cases — teachers across the region have already begun
Meals for all children 18 and under are available on a grab-and-go basis at the East Hampton School District office on Long Lane, next to the East Hampton High School. Doug Kuntz engaging with their students in some fashion. On Tuesday, Ms. McCourt suggested that her kids send silly photos of themselves wearing green for St. Patrick’s Day. And at Sag Harbor Elementary School, there’s an all-hands-on-deck approach to pulling off morning program, the popular daily tradition in which students gather in the school gym to start the day with songs, presentations, announcements, birthday celebrations,
and other activities. Matt Malone, the school’s principal, and his faculty are putting together online versions of the program, which starts out with the Pledge of Allegiance. “We’ve had a great year, and now we face a challenge,” Mr. Malone said during Monday’s video. “Our learning journey looks a little different now. Things are going to be okay because Sag Harbor sticks together.” Continued on A6
911
On Front Lines in Uncertain Times While others shelter in place, East End’s first responders face virus head on BY TAYLOR K. VECSEY While most people have been told to stay home to stop the spread of COVID19, first responders who are on the front lines do not have the luxury of closing up shop. “Our main focus is to maintain services while offering limited close contacts with the public, and reducing the need for foot traffic at our public facilities,” said East Hampton Town Police Chief Michael Sarlo. “We need to keep our officers healthy so they can continue to perform the essential duties of emergency response and criminal investigations.” At the Montauk precinct as of Monday, officers will use the building, but it will no longer be open to the public. Walk-in complaints at headquarters in Wainscott are screened through a glass partition. Emergencies should be phoned in to 911; non-emergencies should be called in to 631-537-7575. On Facebook over the weekend, Chief Sarlo posted a request that the public use the department website and
certain emails for reporting lost or found property and requesting copies of reports, rather than doing so in person with an officer. “Basically, we need support from the public to prioritize their needs, and understand that certain things they may want to take care of right now can and should wait, and thus should be pushed off until we have a better handle on the community spread concerns with this virus.” “I think we are doing well locally, as best as can be expected,” East Hampton Village Police Chief Michael Tracey said, adding that all fire, emergency medical service, police, and dispatchers are “really stepping up to the plate.” Chief Tracey, who oversees the village’s Emergency Communications Center, which dispatches for fire and E.M.S. agencies throughout East Hampton Town, including Sag Harbor, said that there had been four calls in which patients reported fever and/or coughs since the COVID-19 outbreak. There was one reported in Bridgehampton.
Any time police, E.M.S., and firefighters are sent out, dispatchers are screening callers for potential symptoms. Addresses known to have people who have tested positive or who are in quarantine are flagged for notification to the responding officers. Emergency medical service agencies all over the South Fork held emergency training to review how volunteers and paid staff could protect themselves from the virus while still answering calls for help. With the N95 protective masks used by first responders and gowns flying off the shelves nationwide, Suffolk County E.M.S. issued bulletins and held conference calls late last week in an attempt to address concerns over a lack of supplies. On Tuesday, the county notified agencies that it would be supplying surgical masks for patients this week. In Sag Harbor Village, Police Chief Austin McGuire asked that those who do not have true emergencies and those who can wait for a response call 631-725-0058. Continued on A7