Thursday, Aug. 27, 2015 | Volume 211 | Number 4 | 40 cents | iowastatedaily.com | An independent student newspaper serving Iowa State since 1890.
Lani Tons/Iowa State Daily
Sen. Cole Button discusses whether the Senate should pass a bill that will take away presidents’ power to appoint Supreme Court justices.
Senate funds loan office Despite setback, office continues to educate students
Quentin Bangston/Iowa State Daily
ISU athletic director Jamie Pollard said he was surprised by the Review Board’s decision, but is glad it did not add more confusion to an “already confused marketplace.”
No unions for college athletes
NLRB buries unionization at Northwestern, decides not to assert jurisdiction By Max.Dible @iowastatedaily.com Per a decision by the National Labor Relations (NLRB) Review Board, Northwestern will not serve as the formative grounds for unionization in college sports, and it appears that the issue has been essentially laid to rest. Last year, the College Athletes Players Association (CAPA), in conjunction with Northwestern football players, delivered the first blow to the NCAA and its member universities in what had potential to evolve into a multi-year power struggle — one that could have reshaped college athletics forever. The NLRB regional director on May 26, 2014, deemed Wildcat football players as employees of the private university who had the right to unionize, an unprecedented decision. But on Aug. 17, 2015, the NLRB Review Board, which handled Northwestern’s appeal of the director’s ruling, chose not to assert jurisdiction. The fivemember panel’s unanimous decision amounted to anything but, as it declined to support or overturn the ruling, instead opting to do nothing at all. The consequences? That the paradigm and power structure of the NCAA will remain the same as they have always been for student athletes at universities public or private. “In the decision, the Board held that asserting jurisdiction
would not promote labor stability due to the nature and structure of NCAA Division I Football Bowl Subdivision (FBS),” the NLRB wrote in its decision. “By statute the Board does not have jurisdiction over state-run colleges and universities, which constitute 108 of the roughly 125 FBS teams. The Board held that asserting jurisdiction over a single team would not promote stability in labor relations across the league.” The Board touched several times on the idea of “labor stability.” A cornerstone element of that notion is competitive balance — creating a fair and competitive atmosphere to promote fan interest. “Competitive equality doesn’t exist right now, and we have data to support that,” Ramogi Human, CAPA president and a former linebacker at UCLA, told ESPN’s Outside the Lines. “To use a hollow argument to deny players equal protection under the law is disappointing.” Revenue generated from athletics ranges sharply from one university to the next. Per a USA Today financial report, Texas generated nearly $93 million more in revenue than Iowa State last year. “I think you have to define competitive balance. Life is not perfect and life will never be equal. You hope life is fair,” said ISU athletic director Jamie Pollard. “I’m not ready to say (unionization) would have been an advantage because it would
have been a mess trying to figure it out.” Ramifications Had the Board upheld its director’s initial ruling, the argument would likely have made its way into the legal system and from there, the ruling would have been appealed up the chain. Had the decision held through that legal process, the end game — allowing student athletes at private universities a vote on whether or not to unionize — would have become reality. The Board did add that its decision not to assert jurisdiction on the matter does not preclude its revisiting of the issue in the future. Even if the Board had ruled in support of the director, the result would not necessarily have manifested in changes for players at public universities like Iowa State. State institutions are subject to the labor legislation enacted by their home state, vastly complicating the issue of the unionization of college athletes and making it an unlikely proposition. But that doesn’t mean athletic directors of state schools weren’t keenly interested parties to a debate that has in large part defined a generation of college sport in social and political contexts. “I don’t know if anything is ever put to rest. It’s an area right now that just has a lot of tentacles for people to get in under the hood and cause problems,” Pollard said.
By Michaela.Ramm @iowastatedaily.com
“The decision surprised me, but I’m glad they did it, because I think (unionization) would have just caused more confusion in an already confused marketplace.” State of the student-athlete Pollard said he hasn’t sensed “a growing angst” among student athletes that they’re being taken advantage of, even despite being denied any financial gain beyond a scholarship from the multi-billion dollar business constructed atop the foundation of their athletic prowess. A recent ISU football transfer agreed. “I think Division I players today get a little beside themselves and don’t realize what we really got that other people don’t have,” said linebacker Jordan Harris, who arrived at Iowa State in advance of last season by way of Copiah-Lincoln Community College in Mississippi. An argument can be made that players like Harris may fear speaking out on the topic, stigmatizing themselves with coaches and administrators as ungrateful or petulant. To do so could theoretically damage their prospects on the only platform that exists for them to showcase their talent to professional leagues. But Pollard doesn’t believe fear plays as a motivator whatsoever in the relative silence he’s observed on the topic. “We have anonymous evaluations,” Pollard said. “There are some wild things that get said in
Student Government approved a bill that funded more than $100,000 to Iowa State University’s Student Loan Education Office during Wednesday’s Senate meeting. With a vote of 32 to 0, the Senate passed a bill that funded $116,821.87 to the Student Loan Education Office. The bill, which was waved through readings and immediately into a discussion and vote, provided funding for the Student Loan Education Office on campus. The office provides information and services on all things loan related for students at ISU, due to the increasing student debt in the country. Speaker of the Senate Ben Crawford said the office was funded last year and previous administration was to create a three-year contract. However, President Dan Breitbarth said the order to fund the office was missed sometime in the transition period from last year to this year. “[The] university put us between a rock and a hard place because their lack of efficiency fell until the middle of the summer,” Breitbarth said. Breitbarth said he had been notified of the situation on June 30. Despite the setback, the office was operational and will continue to operate as the semester begins. The funding for the education office also included funding employee salaries. Breitbarth said the bill was urgent because people were relying on that legislation for their livelihood. “Over the next month and a half, we’ll be working diligently to figure out long-term plans,” Breitbarth said. “We’re student senators discussing this. As students, should we really fund people’s livelihoods?” Sen. Danielle Nygard expressed concern as to why the bill hadn’t gone through Finance Committee. “I would love to have Finance Committee to have an official recommendation on this,” Nygard said. Vice Speaker Michael Snook said this had been discussed by Finance Committee previously. “My understanding, we did account for this amount of money in the recurring obligations account,” Snook said. “There’s no need to go through Finance Committee.” The Senate also made an amendment to the constitution, which states “the president of
UNIONS p8
Cyclones for O’Malley rally in Ames By Shannon.McCarty @iowastatedaily.com Cyclones for Martin O’Malley gathered at Stomping Grounds to encourage students to caucus for the former Maryland governor, and to come back on Saturday to attend a meet and greet with the presidential candidate. O’Malley announced his candidacy back in May, and is one of five 2016 presidential candidates for the Democratic party. Former Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton, has been the frontrunner for Democrats in various polls with Vermont Senator, Bernie Sanders, in second. The event was one of thirty statewide house parties in support of O’Malley. The focus of the meetings was the candidate’s 15 goals to rebuild the American
dream. Although O’Malley was not present, he called into the 30 parties to encourage supporters to attend the caucus, and to thank them for helping his campaign. “Together we can pursue the rebuilding of the American Dream,” O’Malley said. Some of O’Malley’s goals to help rebuild the American dream include: reform the criminal justice system, ensure college students can graduate debt free within five years, and cut youth unemployment by 50 percent in three years. Evan Abramsky, junior in political science, hosted the event. Abramsky is the president of Cyclones for Martin O’Malley. Abramsky said he was originally a Sanders supporter, but after working for his campaign for about two weeks he changed
his mind. “He was making a lot of promises,” Abramsky said. Abramsky said Sanders’s didn’t have any plans to fulfill his promises, and his plans were unrealistic. “Students need to really think about who they’re voting for,” Abramsky said. He said O’Malley’s goals on education are much more feasible than Sanders’s free college proposal. Abramsky is confident once the caucus and election get closer students will become more and more involved. “We got six months till the caucus, and more than a year till the election,” Abramsky said. College students have been known to not show up at voting booths. According to The
O’MALLEY p4
4 4 $
4518 Mortensen Rd Ames | 515.292.4555
Irish THURSDAY westtownepub.com
$
Josh Newell/Iowa State Daily
Cyclones for O’Malley Club President Evan Abramsky, junior in political science, listens to questions during an informational meeting Wednesday at Stomping Grounds in Ames. Presidential candidate Martin O’Malley will visit Ames on Saturday.
JAMESON
& GINGER ALE 7PM-1AM
SOUR IRISHMAN 7PM-1AM
SENATE p4
4 6 $
$
IRISH CAR BOMBS 7PM-1AM
CORNED BEEF & CABBAGE 7PM-10PM WHILE SUPPLIES LAST