Vol. 11, No. 6, June 2011
ISSN 0971-880X
Single Copy Rs. 100/-
Pages 12
Dr KK Aggarwal Gr. Editor-in-Chief, IJCP Group
E
Member The Indian Newspaper Society
Official Voice of Doctors of India
d i t o r i a l
Medical Ethics: Lessons from Vaidya Sushena
A
medical doctor is accorded a status next to God as he or she has a duty to heal the sick irrespective of their caste, creed, race or financial status. The classical description of the duty of a doctor was depicted in the Hindi film ‘Achanak’ by Gulzar in 1973.
Dr KK Aggarwal Padma Shri and Dr BC Roy National Awardee Sr Physician and Cardiologist, Moolchand Medcity President, Heart Care Foundation of India Group Editor-in-Chief, IJCP Group Group Editor-in-Chief, eMedinewS Chairman Ethical Committee, Delhi Medical Council Director, IMA AKN Sinha Institute (08-09) Hony. Finance Secretary, IMA (07-08) Chairman, IMA AMS (06-07) President, Delhi Medical Association (05-06) emedinews@gmail.com http//twitter.com/DrKKAggarwal Krishan Kumar Aggarwal (Facebook)
In the movie, Vinod Khanna plays the character of an army man who loves his wife intensely. He returns home after the 1971 war to find his wife, actress Lily Chakravarti, involved with his close friend. In a fit of emotion, he kills his wife and her lover. He is sentenced to death but is wounded in an attempt to escape the police. At the hospital he is looked after by a team of doctors (Om Shivpuri, Asrani) and a nurse (Farida Jalal). They work hard day in and day out to save him from the lethal injury only to hand him over to the police chief (Iftikhar) for the due capital punishment. The story ends with the message that the duty of the doctor is to save the dying man and the duty of the policeman is to award the due deserved capital punishment. Historically, the first known example of medical ethics comes from the story of Ramayana. During the war between Lord Rama and Ravana, Meghnath shot a Brahmastra shakti baan (arrow) that hit Laxmana and he became unconscious.
Vibhishana informed Sri Rama about a physician, Sushena, who lived in Lanka. Hanumana was asked to bring him. He brought Vaidya Sushena along with his house. Vaidya Sushena, well aware that he was a physician attached to the kingdom of Ravana, and that treating Lakshmana could end up annoying Ravana, took a conscious ethical decision of treating the wounded Lakshmana. He said that only the ‘Sanjivani Booti’ (a herb found only on Sumeru Hill) could save Laxmana. But that herb grew on Himalayas at a great height and needed to be brought before the day break. Then Jambavanta reminded Hanumana that only he could bring back the ‘booti’ before sunrise. He said, “Fly across the ocean to Himalaya Mountains and bring back herbs Mritha Sanjivani, Vishalya karani, Savamakarani and Sandhanakarani.”
Both the above depictions relate to the true message later described in the classical Hippocratic Oath, traditionally taken by physicians pertaining to the ethical practice of medicine. But today many doctors are ruining the image of the medical profession. They indulge in indiscriminate sex determination, killing the child in the womb, making people beggars by cutting their hands, making males eunuchs by castrating their private parts, illegal organ trade or getting involved with the criminals and helping them in torturing their captive persons. The classical example is what happened in Iraq. We should take lessons from the movie ‘Achanak’ and from Vaidya Sushena who stood by his professional duty and acted according to what was right and ethical.
Make Sure
I
During Medical Practice A patient who had blood in the urine one month back was found to have a large bladder cancer. Oh my God! Why was he not investigated one month back?
© IJCP Academy
Hanuman went to Sumeru Hill, which was far, far away from the battlefield. There he found several herbs that looked similar to the ‘Sanjivani Booti’. Confused, Hanumana immediately lifted Sumeru Hill in his right hand and flew back to the battlefield in Lanka. Thus, Laxmana was saved by Vaidya Sushena who waited by Lakshaman’s side till Hanuman returned with the remedy.
Make sure: All painless bleeding in the urine should be investigated for cancer at the first presentation. KK Aggarwal
n
s
i
d
e
News & Views
3
Fitness Update
4
Expert Views
5
Clinical Algorithm
6
Photo Quiz
7
Legal Column
8
Clinical Tips
10