CHRONICLE the harvard-westlake
Los Angeles • Volume 26 • Issue 7 • April 26, 2017 • hwchronicle.com
Students violate trip policy By Katie Plotkin and Jean Sanders
ELLIS BECKER/CHRONICLE
Lacrosse defeats Westlake 11-7
CHILLAX: Midfielder Jared Goldman ’18 reaches to pick up a loose ball as he leads an attack forward in a home game against Westlake. The lacrosse team is currently undefeated for the season, with a 14-0 record as of press time. The perfect record includes a 13-12 win over rival Loyola at home.
Prefect Council adjusts method of disclosing Honor Board case summaries
By Emily Rahhal
Prefect Council began posting anonymous Honor Board case summaries on the Hub on April 18. The summaries, which will be placed on class pages under the label “Communiques,” are part of an effort to increase Honor Board transparency and allow the community to learn from each others’ mistakes, Head Prefect Cate Wolfen ’17 said. The Prefect Council and administration have made similar efforts in the past to increase Honor Board transparency and make Honor Board case decisions available to students. Honor Board case reports were initially sent to students via email, and in an effort to create communication throughout the community Honor Board cases were discussed in “town hall” break-
out groups beginning informally in 2012. This system eventually changed due to poor attendance in 2014, when deans began reading anonymous Honor Board case summaries in class meetings. The large venues of class meetings weren’t personal enough and lent themselves to inconsistencies in the details and interpretation of the cases, Wolfen said. “The Hub statements are a version of the emails, they essentially say the same exact thing as would be emailed to the student body with name changes, gender changes,” Wolfen said. “But this way they are password protected. Since they are on the hub, only members of the HarvardWestlake community can see them.” The Prefect Council intends to anonymously release
a summary for every Honor Board case on the Hub, Chaplain James Young said. “I think that the practice of communicating what has taken place anonymously is a good practice,” President Rick Commons said. “There are going to be times in the arch of the school’s history, nearterm history, where privacy concerns lead us to make an exception to that practice. So I would prefer to call it a practice rather than a policy.” Some students feel this new system of disclosing case summaries serves as unnecessary punishment. “You get punished for what you did but then there [is] the lasting punishment of what people are saying about it,” Colin Shannon ’17 said. According to a Chronicle poll of 385 students, 60 percent said the Hub is an effective way to communicate Hon-
or Board case summaries. Some students fear this won’t bring much change. “I think it could be affective, but the first post used incredibly vague language, to the point where I don’t believe a student could read it and learn a lesson for how to act responsibly themselves,” Jack Hogan ’17 responded to the poll. The Prefect Council has had the opportunity to grow and learn from sitting on Honor Board cases, Wolfen said, and they want to find the most efficient way for the entire community to have this opportunity. “What we have now is an improvement,” Head Prefectelect Wilder Short ’18 said. “We will keep trying next year to find an efficient way to keep this transparency between the [Prefect] Council and the student body.”
Roughly half a dozen students violated the Drugs, Alcohol and Smoking Policy on school trips over spring break, President Rick Commons said. The school’s policy as written in the Student Parent Handbook states that “it is forbidden to use, sell, or possess drugs or alcohol on campus, when traveling to or from campus, or at any school function, including school-sponsored trips and occasions when one is representing the school, even during vacation time.” A junior on the Spider College Tour said that two students used illicit substances on the trip. “After a kid was suspected of having purchased marijuana, [Upper School Dean Celso] Cardenas said on the bus, ‘Hey guys, we heard about some stuff going on. Just don’t do anything stupid in the next five days,’” the junior said. “He was very straight with us. On top of all the stuff we already knew about not doing stuff in past cases, he even said ‘For those of you who I know have done this,’ even though they didn’t know who it was, ‘just stop it.’ They were very lenient with it in the beginning, and then after they got confirmed evidence, they had no choice but to pursue it.” Commons said that typically, when a student violates the Drug, Alcohol and Smoking Policy, the punishment is a suspension. “I think that it’s part of the responsibility of the school to try to respond clearly and make both the individuals involved and the community more broadly understand that this isn’t allowed and there are very good reasons for why it’s not allowed, beginning with health and safety and secondly, the law,” Commons said. Upper School Dean Jamie Chan said that the students were sent home from the college tour. “There was an incident on • Continued on page A7
Conservative students request a speaker to INSIDE better represent their political interests C8 By Noa Schwartz
Saying she feels overwhelmed and judged in a community that is predominantly liberal, a sophomore girl, who identifies as conservative, is attempting to bring a conservative guest speaker to the school. The student, who wished to remain anonymous because she was uncomfortable publi-
cizing her political views, said hosting a conservative speaker would be a logical addition to the school’s agenda for diversity, equity and inclusivity. “I believe that a school should be relatively apolitical or at least bipartisan, and with the school doing things like giving community service to those who attended the Women’s March, I think that they made their motives and who
they supported in the election very clear,” the student said. The student also said recent speakers such as Democratic CNN political commentator Bakari Sellers motivated her to push for a conservative speaker. She referenced recent controversies, such as Milo Yiannoupolis planning to speak at the University of California, Berkeley, as inspiration. “I think that once [the
school] involves themselves by bringing in people like Bakari Sellers, they then have an obligation to tell both sides of the story in a non-biased way,” the student said. She said a recent exchange in the sophomore class Facebook group made this eagerness to express differing political opinions more evident. • Continued on page A2
CARBON FOOTPRINTS: An examination of the steps the school has taken to adjust its ecological impact.