Great QB Debate Continued from page 14 journalists old enough to judge, not indicating whether I agreed or not. Ben's better than Brad either got minimal resistance or solid support, though not always for attribution. Only Art Rooney Jr., who scouted Bradshaw and most of his Hall of Fame entourage, offered nominal caution, but nothing that achieved the level of flat disagreement. "Ben is a work in progress," Rooney said. "Bradshaw was just an outstanding athlete. He was a champion javelin thrower, which takes a lot of coordination. In those days, guys took physicals on the treadmill. He was among our top four or five guys with his capacity on that. Toward the second half of his career, the rules in the league changed (to benefit the passing game) and he kind of blossomed into the new rules. I saw him on TV one time and they were asking him about his career and he just held up four fingers. 'That's all I have to say,' he said. I kind of liked that." Bradshaw won four Super Bowls, which is his signature statistic, not only because it's the most important statistic, but also because the balance of Terry's numerological profile, though distinguished, is hardly sensational. He threw almost as many interceptions (210) as touchdown passes (212) in his 14 years with the Steelers. In his first five seasons, he threw 48 touchdown passes and 81 interceptions. In Roethlisberger's five years, the corresponding numbers are 101 and 69. But it has to be more complicated than that, right? Is Ben better than Brad? "He's on his way," said offensive coordinator Bruce Arians, who put more responsibility on Roethlisberger than ever before last year, with the result being Ben's second Super Bowl victory. "Terry's record stands for itself, and it's not like there aren't Hall of Famers on this team. Hines Ward is probably headed there. And Troy (Polamalu) too. James Harrison, if he has a couple more years like last year. Terry won four Super Bowls." But there were likely more Hall of Famers in Bradshaw's huddle -- Lynn Swann, John Stallworth, Franco Harris, Mike Webster, and Terry Bradshaw -- than there might be on all the Steeler rosters of which Ben will part. "I've thought for a long time that Ben was better, but I never wanted it attributed to me," said one former club executive whose career coincided with Bradshaw. "What Ben's done is amazing and he's done it from
Day 1. Bradshaw, as a rookie, threw six touchdowns and 24 interceptions. Plus I think Ben is a better leader. He gets things done in all kinds of adverse situations. Terry was not that confident. He was fragile in his relationship with Chuck Noll. Rarely did he bring the Steelers from behind." Statistical guidelines on what exactly constitutes a come-from-behind win are not always uniform, but it's instructive to note that the Steelers list 19 comebacks as authored by Roethlisberger in his five seasons, the 19th of which won Super Bowl XLIII, where most sources credit Bradshaw with 19 for his entire career. Ben's won more games (51) in his first five years than any NFL quarterback ever, and the club records for touchdown passes in a season (32), passer rating in a season (104.1), career completion percentage (62.4) all belong to him. But while the top
three seasonal passer ratings in Steeler history all belong to Ben as well, there are a myriad of additional stats that appear to favor Ben when they probably really don't. It's not terribly relevant, for example, that Ben has seven 300-yard performances in his career while Bradshaw had only four, because the nature of offensive football has evolved so dramatically toward the passing game in 35 years. Remember as well that Bradshaw called his own plays, was the MVP of two Super Bowls (two more than Ben) and was the league's MVP in 1978 (once more than Ben). All that said, and staring blasphemy in the face, I think I agree with Mr. Bloom. (Contact Gene Collier at gcollier@postgazette.com.) (Distributed by Scripps Howard News Service, www.scrippsnews.com.) •••
Ken’S Auto RepAiR pA StAte inSpeCtionS 1123 Canoe Ridge Rd., Rossiter
(724) 286-9538 Owner: KEN TIMBLIN
Full-Color
restaurant Placemats Your Business Ad Can run on our Full-Color restaurant Placemats For As low As $63.
Why Pay More? CoMPArE!
Call Mary, Tracey or Melissa at 938-0312 or 938-9141 to Schedule Your Placemat Ad in Area restaurants!
EAST AMErICAN MOTOrSPOrT
2 miles south of Punxsutawney on Rt. 119
814-938-4230
www.eastamericanmotorsport.com
Offers good on new and unregistered units purchased between 7/22/09 and 9/30/09. Offers only available at participating Polaris dealers. *Polaristar Payment Protection provided by cynoSure Financial, Inc. Must purchase and take delivery by 9/30/09. Other restrictions apply. See your participating Polaris dealer for details. Void where prohibited by law. Polaris reserves the right to terminate the program at any time. **Rebates vary by model and are only available on select ATV and RANGER® vehicles. ***Offer is good at participating U.S. Polaris dealers and subject to product availability. On approved Polaris StarCard® qualified consumer purchases. Reduced Rate 9.99% APR and the following payments are effective if your Account is kept current: $59 for purchases financed up to $5,000 (ATV only). Specified payments may be increased due to debt-cancellation fees or any late fees (if applicable). After the promotional period, the standard minimum monthly payment and Standard Rate 21.99% APR will apply. For Accounts not kept current, the promotion will be canceled and the Default Rate 21.99% APR and standard monthly payments will apply. Paying only the amount advertised will not pay off the purchase during the promotional period. Minimum Finance Charge: $1. Certain rules apply to the allocation of payments and Finance Charges on your promotional purchase if you make more than one purchase on your Polaris StarCard. Call 1-888-367-4310 or review your cardholder agreement for information. Warning: ATVs can be hazardous to operate. For your safety, avoid operating Polaris ATVs or RANGERs on paved surfaces or public roads. Riders and passengers should always wear a helmet, eye protection, protective clothing, and a seat belt on RANGER vehicles. Riding and alcohol/drugs don’t mix. Polaris adult ATV models are for riders aged 16 and older. 90cc ATV models and RANGER RZR® 170 models are intended for riders aged 12 and over, and 50cc ATV models are only intended for riders aged 6 and over. Drivers of RANGER vehicles must be at least 16 years old with a valid driver’s license. All ATV riders should take a safety training course. For ATV safety and training information in the U.S., call the SVIA at (800) 887-2887, see your dealer, or call Polaris at (800) 342-3764. Vehicle is shown with optional equipment. ©2009 Polaris Industries Inc.
Punxsutawney Hometown – August 2009 – 19