Healthy Land. Healthy Food. Healthy Lives.
JANUARY / FEBRUARY 2018
In Practice a publication of Holistic Management International
NUMBER 177
W W W. H O L I S T I C M A N A G E M E N T. O R G
Soil, Food, and Hope for Our Future BY ANN ADAMS
T
here has been a flurry of online articles recently about the role of meat in our diet and its effect on planetary health. We have people, like George Monbiot of the Guardian who are eagerly awaiting the viability of the artificial meat industry to address what he perceives the tremendous waste of grazing. Then there is the “Grazed and Confused” article on the Oxford Martin School website that highlights the findings of a new report by Food Climate Research network that notes all livestock are clear net contributors to GHG (greenhouse gases) and, therefore, not “climate saviors.” In response to the “Grazed and Confused” study is an article, “Beef Isn’t to Blame,” on the Sustainable Dish website, which references numerous counter studies to the “Grazed and Confused” study (many of which we have also noted on our website). While the question of what is the right diet for planetary health has led many to look at what they choose to eat, we know that the majority of the world’s population is often just thankful when they have something to eat. This particular challenge seems to me the greatest need right now as we look to help people feed themselves on resilient landscapes rather than having their hopes pinned only on humanitarian aid. At HMI we work from the premise that nature functions in wholes. Nature has been engaged in symbiotic relationships long before humans walked the earth. As a keystone species, humans have demanded more than our fair share of resources. We have also fixated on technology as our “climate savior.” And, we know that there have been many unintended consequences from our playing with all the tools at our disposal—fire, technology, rest, and living organisms (including animal impact and grazing). Yet, there are incredible examples of people working in partnership with nature to create long-term solutions that don’t have dangerous
unintended consequences because they have learned how nature functions and worked with those key principles. The stories of these regenerative agriculture heroes are always inspiring to me. Do I think that domestic livestock are “climate saviors?” I think that question is a red herring. Do I think domestic livestock can be used to increase organic matter? Absolutely. I’ve seen it happen on my property and talked to hundreds of people who have experienced the same thing. It’s not rocket science—it’s soil biology. Provide more food and habitat for micro-organisms and you can support more micro-organisms that do all the work of carbon sequestration and growing plants that are the conduit for that exchange. Ultimately, I trust natural processes over artificial products made by humans any day. Humans can attempt to control nature, but ultimately natural law and processes prevail. Since we depend on nature, I’d rather work in a food system that attempts to partner with nature and reap the symbiotic benefits than one that is propped up on technology and companies we must trust to do what is right for us. I also think many consumers have this conception that because the livestock industry requires the taking of lives (particularly mammalian lives) that it is somehow more vicious and questionable than crop farming which only requires the harvesting of vegetables, grains, and fruits. But anyone who has farmed knows that it is far more in the “how” than the “what.” I feel far better about eating a locally raised and slaughtered grassfed animal from a producer I know than I do about some commercially grown strawberries from a company in California whose workers are struggling with health issues because of the pesticide use on that farm (not to mention the impact on numerous other sentient beings because of those practices). I have used the holistic decision-making process as a way to help me make decisions about my food choices and how I can contribute to the health of the planet. People may say my decisionmaking is faulty because they have decided to believe one study over another. I know that these natural processes—the ecosystem processes—have been functioning quite well without human CONTINUED ON PAGE 19
INSIDE THIS ISSUE Holistic Management focuses on the triple bottom line— looking at the social, environmental and economic issues of each decision. Learn about how Ranchlands LLC is working to educate the next generation of conservation ranchers on page 2 or learn about how the Feiring Cattle Company is working to create a sustainable quality of life on page 7.
The People Part