PORTFOLIO OF U HAOYUAN
RESPONSES TO RAPID URBANIZATION IN 4 DIMENSIONS
ARCHITECTURE | VILLAGE | BLOCK | REGION
Xu Haoyuan
Application number: 23179313
Programme: MArch Urban Design
Bachelor of Engineering in Urban and Rural Planning
Nanjing Tech University, P.R.China
Contact: haoyuanxu1998@outlook.com; (+86)139-2144-4204
@ Gongzijiang PHOTO
Until recently, China's rapid urbanization has entered a fairly stable phase, while various contradictions have been fully exposed.
As an urban designer, the most important role is to play games among all parties and try to coordinate them , in further, to maintain the steady development of cities through the way.
How long will it take? I don't know.
What I know is I will never stop trying, even though it's still long and tortuous.
Contents 01 URBAN COMMUNICATING VESSEL 01 05 12 17 02 A GUIDE FOR LANDLESS FARMERS 03 REVIVAL OF HISTORICAL QUARTER 04 EXAMINING SOCIAL VULNERABILITY TO FLOOD OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING COMMUNITIES Qinhuai Museum of Contemporary Art Design New Rural-urban Mode and Rethinking Regroupment of Public Spaces Building Long-term Disaster Resilience of Low-income Communities
URBAN COMMUNICATING VESSEL
Qinhuai Museum of Contemporary Art Design
Course: Architectural Design(2) (Spring term 2018)
Course Instructor: Zhao Ye, Wen Zhao and Xi Jiaoru
Site Location: Nanjing, Jiangsu, China
Team Work: Xu Haoyuan, Cheng Huinan
Contribution: Field Visits(50%), Design(40%), Drawing(50%)
Site Area: 0.5ha
In the Chinese rapid urbanization, fragmented development has severed the links between the city, its buildings and environment, as well as the link between citizens and the history and culture of the land.
The project site is located in the scenic area of Fuzi Temple on the Qinhuai River in Nanjing, between the former site of the ancient Taoye Ferry and the residential area of the old city, and is of great historical and cultural value. But due to the fragmentation of the urban built environment, the Taoye Ferry constructed in 350 is little known.
Therefore, the proposal uses the architectural space to connect the historical places, through the combing and reorganization of urban space and user flow, to connect the anchors, so that the surrounding built environment, the urban life and the historical culture can be reconnected, while the missing sense of spatial belonging can be recovered.
The building connects all functional spaces with a strong social attribute of flowing space, while responds to the surrounding built environment, to revive the forgotten history and repair the fragmented city.
01
1
SITE LOCATION | CENTER OF HISTORY AND CULTURE IN NANJING
THE ANCHORS OF HISTORICAL SITE
STRATEGY | COMMUNICATE BETWEEN HISTORICAL PLACES
CHRONOLOGY
DYNASTY Song Yuan Ming Qing Today
ORIGINAL BLOCK
CONNECTING URBAN FABRIC
CONNECTING HISTORIC SITES
CONNECTING PEOPLE FLOWS
CONNECTING LANDSCAPES
COMMUNICATING VESSEL
Fuzi Temple
Jiangnan Gongyuan
SITE
Ancient Taoye Ferry
The farewell ferry of Nanjing The place in the poems.
The biggest national examination court during more than 700 years.
Confucian Temple, a place monumentalizing Confucius.
Jin 320 960 1271 1368 1636
A historical site of inheriting Confucian culture.
2018
2
AXONOMETRIC DRAWING OF GROUND FLOOR
1 Service Center 2 Baggage Storage 3 Gift shop 4 Coffee shop 5 Guided 6 Exhibition Hall 7 Viewing platform 8 Tea room 9 Meeting room 10 Office 11 Outside seating 12 Outside areas 13 Waterfront Deck 14 Boat dock 15 Bike parking A-A SECTION B-B SECTION C-C SECTION D-D SECTION FIRST FLOOR UNDERGROUND PLAN | 1:1200 SECOND FLOOR PLAN | 1:1200
OF URBAN ENVIRONMENT 3
SECTIONS
E E
ANALYTICAL DIAGRAMS
SPACE ANNOTATIONS
MAIN
STREAMLINE
E-E SECTION | 1:450
ENTRANCE CORRIDOR
PLATFORM GUIDED
VIEWING
Service Center Vistor Entrance Exhibit Entrance Staff Entrance Lecture Hall Permanent Exhibition Living Room of The City Souvenir Shop Visit Streamline Exhibit Arrangement Streamline Staff Streamline Art Warehouse Basement Parking Office Temporary Exhibition
SPACIAL FUNCTIONS
ORGANIZATION 4
A GUIDE FOR LANDLESS FARMERS
New Rural-urban Mode and Rethinking
Competition: UIA-HYP CUP 2021
Instructor: Lin Lifeng
Site Location: Fuzhou, Fujian, China
Team Work: Xu Haoyuan, Lu Kaiyu
Contribution: Field Visits(50%), Design(50%) , Drawing(70%)
Site Area: 50ha
Land-owning represents the most fundamental aspiration of Chinese peasants.
In China, rapid urbanization has brought a series of urban-rural contradictions, one of which is the occupation of rural land. In Fuzhou, the city expands constantly, producing many landless peasants who were vulnerable in society. Inadequate compensation made evicted farmers not only can not survive in the city, but also lose their essential means of production — arable land.
Our guide starts with this background,
intending to discuss a sustainable developing pattern of urban-rural relationship. On the basis of land-lost farmers' allowance from the government, attracting investment of social capital to construct the new rural community and maintain the operation. According to the traditional pattern of village in Fuzhou— Tulou, we reconstruct the structure of new countryside, while making it play a crucial role in relieving urban pressure.
This program focuses on the survival of landless farmers, the operation of new agricultural community and the translation of the local village.
02
5
VILLAGES
Discovery
Horizontal
Where will they Go?
The villager are forced to leave their homeland because of urbanism or development of tourism.
Buy
Not Enough! Compensation is not enough Go gambling! Go lottery!
What They Want?
So how to use it?
the
The News interviewed with 3 typical type of farmers and collected their will. Slide to learn more.
bottom-up
Future?
Policy Phaes II
Cancel of Agricultural Taxes Market Economy, 1991
'Eradicate The Poor', 2020
Demolished bottom-up urbanism in 1958 , turned into government-dominated urbanism in 1978. Now China calls for a new sustainable rural social structure model.
Fuzhou's Native Rural Typology: Tulou Community
bedroom servant school Ownership: Power core: private patriarch clan kitchen storage 'No-taxed Autonomy', 2001 ? 11.2% 17.9% 27.6% 36.2% 58.6% 78.4% Plan Function Out clan hall LEARN MORE historic events historic events historic total land productivity grow mechnical colonism landlost slavery time time time price contorl colonism industry need war pirce right land trading 'Enclosure' land-circulation industry Mechanical technical training
WORLDWIDE
FUZHOU VILLAGE NEWS
Rural Urban
Comparison between the agricultural advanced countries& China
Land Landless Peasants Ancestral Community Influential Manage Engagement Rural Life-quality Urbanization Rate
urbanism call for a new social structure
Agriculture Mode: Big quantum& Family Farm High Value& Price Association Added Value& Farmer Corporations Agriculture Mode: Agriculture Mode:
United States Japan
Kingdom of Denmark
urbanism Agriculture
government-dominated
China
The
The
Development
1: Phase 2: Phase 3: Spatial
Each 'Tulou'
Migration 'Great Forward' Policy, 1958 'Opening-up'
Rural Structure:
Pattern: Phase
structure is related to the function of the social system in the Tulou.
was owned by a family. One family Density increase
6 where will they go?
REVIEW PUBLIC COMMENTS
HISTORY
TULOU will be used for tourism
urban house?
No Farmland? Want Farming Do Not Know Either URBANIZATION PHASE 1 PHASE 1 PHASE 2 PHASE 2 PHASE 3 PHASE 3 FUTURE AGRICULTURURAL
lost-landed farmers' home red guard businessman factory worker lost-landed farmers PHASE 4 PHASE 4 1 3 5 1 2 4 4 3 compulsory commune Break It clan fishing town fishing town 'Great
Cultural Revolution + 'Opening-up' policy Experimental
peasant economy household contract collective enterprise clan clan clan local govrnment local govrnment local govrnment local govrnment
Buy urban house? Find Relatives? Relatives? Factory? Find job in
factory? Stay Where? Farming Homeland Am Too Old Prefer Homeland
UTOPIA
Forward'
field Moderate Society 'The Most Rapid Urbanization'
Just Rent
POLICY STRATEGY | THE OPERATION METHOD OF A NWE CLAN COMMUNITY
SPACE STRATEGY | THE OPERATION METHOD OF A NWE CLAN COMMUNITY
SOCIAL STRUCTURE
DOMINANT
SEPERATED
COLLECTIVISM
AUTONOMY INTEGRATED JOINT SHARED SPACE OPEN-BOUNDARY VILLAGE ECONOMIC AFFORDABLE MUTURAL ASSISTANCE COMMEMORATIVE SPACE DEFENCIVE HOUSING SPATIAL STRUCTURE LIFE STRUCTURE patriarchal tree structure new family network structure the only public space ancestral temple Interconnected public systems pure agriculture productive life clan field community field work space work space collective space rental resident space public space resident space self field Ancestral temple& Office economic element provide more choices PHASE 3 PHASE 2 PHASE 1 FUTURE CLAN AGRICULTURE COMMUNITY in: rental elements in: rental field, debts in: demolition fund technician tourist young worker out: joint economy out: rental elements out: farmers’ housing self-house wide road eldly centre factory public space joint tourism apartment poor youngster designer labourer landless peasant elderly CLAN ECONOMY COMMUNITY 'FUJIAN' CLAN GOVERNMENT CASH OUT CASH IN JOINT VILLAGE CLAN COMMITEE industrial upgrading& integration private residence elderly&childcare rental agricultrue infrastructure investment new peasants rental land appreciation bond land tax lease farming technical weekend farm factory apartment canteen public space road&square extension dividences allowance debt land properties patriarch farming gambling regulation ancestral temple centre private land self- autonomy homeside land factory worker service worker library public participation subsistence allowance& field INFRASTRUCTURE WELFARE ACCOUNT AUTONOMY POLICY phase3 phase1 phase 2 ancestral temple LAND USAGE PEASANT COMPOSITION DEMOLITION FUND
7
LANDLESS PEASANTS’ QUSTIONAIRE ECONOMIC CIRCULATION ELEMENTS
LIVING PATTERNS DATABASE
CENSUS, RELATION PREDICTION: FAMILY LIVING MODELS : PRIVATE LIVING 1.1 2.1 1.2 2.2 FAMILY LIVING MODELS : COMBINED LIVING
CLAN-CENSUS bedroom unit lliving unit kitchen&toilet unit recreation unit life-improvement unit bottom-up construct unit independent entry gathering space changable modules children& parent eye contact wine cellar wind ventilate yard joint usage room sunlight yard wind ventilation atrium X-reading lab extra modules family -joint yard family-joint handicraft family -joint living room family -joint retail cool cool read read alone dry socks big TV tree big family living together family public space + ‘X’ commercial retrofit SPATIAL ORGANIZATION FAMILY NUMBER PREFERENCE sustainable design cellar-ventilation atrium sunlight yard mix-used spaced design children’s lab bottom up construction modules generation combined private credit by: credit by: clan community& fujian architect union 2020. 03. 10 2020. 03. 10 elder middle-age son grandson CLAN-RELATION OF FAMILY NEW PEASANTS 90% shared factory shared apartment weekend farm child-care elderly-care 60% shared market 60% shared canteen research office LOW-FINANCE RESIDENT MID-FINANCE RESIDENT HIGH-FINANCE RESIDENT WELLFARE SYSTEM AND FACILITIES URBAN DESIGNER CLAN COMMUNITY LANDLESS PEASANTS GOVERNOR CLAN SYSTEM INTRO CROP PRODUCTION TOURISM
8
9
Communal Parking Rental Space
Experimental Field Barn
Agro-forestrial System Agricultural Production Road
Camping Area Rental Farmlands
Family Squares Family Enclave
Communal Agricultural Factory Ancestral Temple
Fitness
Trails Rural
Implement Sheds Senior Activity Center
CONSTRUCTION SEQUENCE
peasants' real estate
designers' studio
governers' consultant
PHASE 1:
Resident settlement, land allocation, basic living facilities, ancestral temple
lease land
peasants' real estate
designers' studio eldly centre childcare centre research factory
PHASE 2: PHASE 3:
road expansion, squre, basic economic elements& welfare facilities
bottom-up commercial, advanced economic elements& welfare facilities, joint economy
N 10 20 M 2 0
A B D D C C A B 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 18 19 20 21 22 22 17 1 5 2 6 9 3 7 10 12 18 11 13 19 14 20 15 21 16 22 17 4 8
Footpaths Between Fields Agricultural Square Public Toilet Reserved Farmland Nursing Home Rural Market Rural Main Entrance
Diffrent ownership of rural land define the boundary of clan village.
MASTER PLAN
THE SCENE OF NEW AGRICULTURAL COMMUNITY
Landless peasants& Tenent Agriculture Land:
Tenent Farmer& Welfare Careness:
Enterprise& Joint Factory: B-B SECTION D-D SECTION 10
Tourists& Weekend Farm: A-A SECTION C-C SECTION
ENLARGED PLAN
The rental apartment and the 2 residential blocks together enclose an introverted farmers’ exclusive farming fields.
11
REVIVAL OF HISTORICAL QUARTER Regroupment of Public Spaces
Working Program (2021 WINTER)
Immediate Leader: Song Han
Site Location: Suzhou, Jiangsu, China Individual Work (A node design in urban design of Wusa road)
Site Area: 1.35 ha
Historical districts are preserved because of their cultural value, but the internal built environment is deteriorating day by day. Problems such as occupying public space, obstructed roads, chaotic pedestrian route and so on are full of historical blocks. What is worse is that in the process of rapid urbanization in China, in order to maximize profits, the government takes the method of demolition, and building new ones.
How to retain the spatial memory of historic districts?
How to revive the spatial vitality of historic districts?
How to keep the residents in the historic districts from being relocated, while having a better quality of life, and preserve urban spatial justice?
I try to figure out these answers in the design process of this project.
03
12
SITE
Suzhou, the capital of the State of Wu during the Spring and Autumn Period, is one of the most famous ancient cities in China. In terms of general urban structure, Suzhou is surrounded by two rivers, and the Ancient Suzhou City is the core.
The site, the historical block of Tongdeli, is located in the center of Ancient Suzhou City protected by the Acient City Moat. The north and west of the site is adjacent to the main two roads (Ganjiang Road and Renmin Road respectively) .
CHRONOLOGY | ROYAL PALACE ➡ FEUDAL GOVERNMENT ➡ DWELLINGS AND OFFICES
Before 2500 years ago, there was the royal palace of the State of Wu.
After the State of Wu perishing,the site was always booming as the regional administrative center under the background of feudalism.
The east of base is connected with Wusa Road, the history axis of Ancient Suzhou city.What is more, many historical and curtural sites born in chinese different historical phases have been distributed at both side along the history axis.
After the overthrow of feudal dynasty, a large number of dwellings and offices have built here. Tongdeli is the product of this era.
PALACE
REGION ANALYSIS | THE CENTER OF SUZHOU SINCE TIME IMMEMORIAL
IN SUZHOU
ADMINISTRATION
GOVERNMENT
PARLIAMENT
GOVERNMENT OFFICES
OFFICES HISTORICAL SITE 514 BC 225 BC 221 BC 1911 TODAY 1930 SPRING AND AUTUMN PERIOD UNITY WAR QIN DYNASTY THE REVOLUTION OF 1911 THE CENTER OF LIFE THE SITE WAS BUILT
WARS FEUDAL
INTERIM
DWELLINGS
DWELLINGS
SITE IN ANCIENT SUZHOU CITY
13
SITE IN THE HISTORY AXIS
OCCUPIED PUBLIC AREA
Private Fences Wastes Private Cars
CLOSEDE BLOCKFACADE ALONGE STREET
Only Two Entrances Inefficient Shops Brick Walls
DEAD END ROADS
A Road Mixed People And Vehicles Narrow and Dead-end Alleys
Temporary Huts Aging Buildings Idle Houses
VALUE OF BUILDINGS
Cultural heritage sites
Historical buildings
Neutral buildings
The majority of buildings have been constructed in the beginning Minguo Period . It is lucky that them have been prevented from the damage of the Anti-Japanese war and Liberation War.
BUILDING TYPES
Red-brick buildings
White painted buildings
Dilapidated buildings
Temporary buildings and annexes
The site is dominated by red-brick buildings while all the dwellings have been painted by white coating. The most of temporary buildings have been built by color steel tiles.
FUNCTIONAL ZONING
Administrative buildings
Commercial buildings
Temporary dormitories
Dwellings
In the block of Tongdeli, the building's functions are primarily dwellings and a group of administrative buildings are located in its center. A few commercial buildings are distributed along Wusa Road.
TRAFFIC PATTERN
Roads mixed people and vehicle
Footwalk
Pedestrian entrances
Vehicle entrances
Parking P
There is only one road provided for vehicles and one unorganized parking. Other paths are impeded by fences
CONDITION
N N N N N 14
ANNEXES DILAPIDATED BUILDINGS SITE ANALYSIS | EXISTING PROBLEMS
ANALYSIS
STRATEGY | DEBRIDEMENT & SWE UP MASTER PLAN | A NEW SYSTEM OF PUBLIC AREA CLEAR
THE SYSTEM OF INNER PUBLIC REAE THE SYSTEM OF URBAN PLAZA THE SYSTEM OF TRAFFIC
INCLUDING:
INCLUDING:
INCLUDING:
N 2 5 10 M 0
THE ANNEXES
THE CHANNELS
THE ANCHORS SEW UP THE PUBLIC SPACES TYPE 1 CORRIDOR TYPE 1 CORRIDOR TYPE 2 TYPE 2 1 1 2 3 5 4 4 6 7 10 10 10 12 11 11 11 11 8 9 5 2 6 9 3 7 10 11 12 4 8 Communal Parking Roof Garden Teahouse Community Internal Public Shared Book Bar Outdoor Bar Community Exhibition Hall Entrance Square Outdoor Theater Spiral Stair Urban Public Plaza Cafe
DREDGE
IDENTIFY
The corridor provides a link between the three public roof spaces for people and is connected with the ground by a spiral stair.
The corridor regroups the internal public spaces and provides a shelter.
Corridor
Leisure Facilities Individual Houses
2
Corridor
Roof Garden Leisure And Commercial Buildings
1
Emergency One-way
Regular One-way
Traffic
Traffic
15
PERSPECTIVE | ACTIVITIES REORGANIZATION
OUTDOOR THEATER COMMUNITY INTERNAL PUBLIC SPACE
CORRIDOR DETAIL DRAWING
1 1 10mm weathering steel ribs with anti-corrosion coverage, painted in matte deep gray paint
2 40mm black sandalwood frame filled with gravels
3 Profiled steel plate composite floor
4 H beam
5 Weathering steel trimmings and drippings
6 10mm weathering steel iron plate
7 I-beam topped with light
8 Wooden bamboo strips
9 Wooden bamboo benches
10 40mm calcite overhead
11 5mm weathering steel plate
12 40*80mm steel keel
13 8mm steel ribs
14 Broken gravel bricks backfill and ballast
15 Steel ground beam
16 Embedded pipelines
17 Gravel ground
18 Drain hole
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 16
EXAMINING SOCIAL VULNERABILITY TO FLOOD OF AFFORDABLE HOUSING COMMUNITIES
Building Long-term Disaster Resilience of Low-income Communities (Contents lists available at ScienceDirect)
Course: Social Investigation Methods(2) (2019 SPRING)
Course Instructor: Chen Yi and Wen Zhao
Site Location: Nanjing, Jiangsu, China
Team Work: Xu Haoyuan, Xia Song, Li Wanrong, Yuan Yu
Contribution: Field Visits(25%), Research(40%), Drawing(90%)
BEFORE of the flood in the site (Yin long ya yuan, Nanjing)
AFTER of the flood in the site (Yin long ya yuan, Nanjing)
In the context of rapid urbanization and climate change, urban floods disasters occur frequently across the globe, and social vulnerability has become an important theoretical perspective for understanding the occurrence and response of flooding disasters. This research takes Nanjing as an example to investigate flooding disasters and social vulnerability in development countries. It develops an analysis framework and evaluation index system of social vulnerability from three dimensions of exposure, sensitivity and adaptability. Ten typical affordable housing communities (four main areas
of affordable housing in Nanjing) were selected and individual-level survey data were collected to explore the influencing factors of social vulnerability.
The results show that social vulnerability is simultaneously affected by exposure, sensitivity and adaptability.
Communities with new construction ages and good built environments have lower levels of risk exposure. Those with residents having higher levels of education and social capital have lower sensitivity. The government's emergency operations and residents' response capabilities can both improve the adaptability of communities to floods.
04
17
The article has been published.
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Theoretical foundation
Sustainable cities and society
Journals: Journals homepage:
www.elsevier.com/locate/scs
DOI: Published time:
10.1016/j.scs.2021.102939 AUG 2021
Contents lists available at:
ScienceDirect
VULNERABILITY: The degree of damage that the system may suffer from exposure to risk, disturbance or pressure, which is composed of three dimensions: exposure, sensitivity and adaptability.
Sensitivity: The degree whether a social system is disturbed easily.
Exposure: The degree to which a social system is disturbed by outside condition.
Adaptability : The ability of a social system to cope, adjust, and adapt to external disturbances.
2. CHARACTERISTICS
OF
VULNERABILITY
2.1 The characteristic of sensitivity
2.1.1 Individual social economy attribution: Aging,low income,agricultural accounts for less
1.2 Object of study
2.1.2 State of health: Good self-evaluation, high medical expenditure
The following report is an original data of the paper.
2.2 The characteristic of exposure
2.2.1 Geographic context:
High relative relief; The closer to river, the easier to waterlog
2.3
The
characterisitic of adaptability
The range of relief degree of land surface in Daishan shows that the terrain inside this area is rugged and easy to form waterlogging.
Shangfang and Huagang are close to the main river and are vulnerable to the threat of river backflow.
2.2.2 Social fabric:
The lower the floor the easier to waterlog; Different social fabric, different flood situation
2.3.1 Individual: Low education degree; Information capturing ability
The residents of the affordable housing areas are generally not well educated, with the majority of them being junior middle school or lower than primary school, but they pay more attention to rainstorm disaster informations.
2.3.1 Social: The government provides medical facilities and assistance
The peak of flooding severity in Huagang and Shangfang is 'Serious'. It can be seen from the figure that the severity of waterlogging is in the order of Granite area > Shangfang area > Daishan area > Dingjiazhuang area.
61% 10% 78% 13% 23% 35% 23% 19% 56% 39% 11% 33% 44% 13% 65% 22% 43% 27% 20% 10% 48% 23% 28% 44% 38% 35% 34% 34% 19% 56% 42% 39% 41% 11% 67% 22% 30% 34% 34% 38% 24% 30% 37% 37% 23% 37% 40% 34% 59% 7% 24% 12% 48% 59% 10% 42% 26% 34% 54% 12% 12% 12% 34% 42% 11% 74% 26% 63%
DJZ DJZ DJZ DJZ DJZ DJZ DJZ SF SF DS DS HG very healthy Male The structure of gender Relief degree of land surface Distance from the river Severity and frequency of flooding in each area The structure of age Household income Place-risk model of social vulnerability (Cutter , 2003) Survey points in Nanjing city Self- evaluation health Education level and information capturing ability Distance from the medical facilities Frequency of government assistance Medical expenditure of families Registered residence Female Agriculture 0.00 Very serious Very good Serious degree in HG Frequency in HG degree in SF Frequency in SF degree in DS < Primary school Always Ofen Rarely Never DJZ SF DS HG Never Middle school High school Higher Frequency in DS degree in DJZ Frequency in DJZ Average Good 0.20 0.40 0.60 0.80 0% 0.0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Minor( < 18) <¥30000 ¥30000- ¥50000 ¥30000- ¥100000 >¥100000 Non-agriculture Elder( > 60)
very ill HG SF SF SF SF SF DS DS DS DS DS HG HG HG HG HG
Agriculture to Non-agriculture Young and Middle-aged(18-60)
Yangeyuan Yangeyuan Yanshenyuan Yanshenyuan Yanwuyuan Yanwuyuan Yayuan Yayuan Yinlong I Yinlong I Yinlong II Yinlong II Xiushuifang Xiushuifang Chunshuiyuan Chunshuiyuan Jiaheyuan Jiaheyuan Wanfuyuan Wanfuyuan Wanxingyuan Wanxingyuan Xiangheyuan Xiangheyuan
18
3. PROCESS OF VULNERABILITY
3.1 The vulnerability of preparedness before flooding: Lack of initiative and purpose
Extra: The travel of residents in rainstorm
(A case study of Daishan areas)
The crowds gathered together in outdoor public spaces, such as squares and gardens, presenting a multi-core mode.
3.2 The vulnerability of response in flooding: Passive response
The crowd only gathered together in a sheltered public space, presenting a single core mode.
3.3 The vulnerability of resuming after flooding: Space-time difference
Dingjiazhuang area has the strongest drainage capacity, while the waterlogging will subside after half a day in the impression of most residents. Other areas have different drainage capacity and the duration waterlogging.
The crowd began to return to the outdoor public space, presenting a multi-core mode.
Extra: The map
52% 76% 29% 42% 26% 46% 54% 38% 95% 79% 100% 39% 33% 51% 33% 46% 26% 98% 81% 99% 60% 29% 60% 54% 68% 28% 57% 41% 35% 43% 32% 32% 87% 53% 70% 32% 64% 37% 37% 48% 37% 25% 79% 56% 69% 36% 39% 54% 32% 54% 20% 14% 88%
waterlogging
of
Information source: 3.2.1 Governmental aid: Narrow coverage 3.3.1 Storm water accumulated area: Inside and outside communities 3.3.2 Waterlogging situation: Community differences 3.3.3 Recovery: Most residents think that it is good 3.2.2 Estate management aid: Significant effect 3.2.3 residents travel: 3.1.1 The cognize of flood control : 3.1.1 The preparation of emergency material : Mainly TV and Internet Mainly enhanced drainage Single and deficient Affected by waterlogging DJZ DJZ DJZ Pipelines Bus station ① ① ② ③ ① Dingjiazhuang bus station ① Huagang low-lying road ② Shangfang urban main road ② Huagang basement ③ Shangfang social parking ③ Shangfang community gate ② ③ Road Road entrance Market Basement School Gates Parking Half day One day Two days Building 0% 0% 0% 50% 100% 0% 0% 0% 20% 20% 40% 40% 50% 60% 60% 80% 100% 100% 100% 50% 50% 100% Specific expenditure Building reinforcement Insurance First-aid appliances Reservoirs Sandbags Outfalls Green spaces Nothing Always Ofen Rarely Never Occasionally DJZ DJZ Location prone to waterlogging( outside the community) The duration of waterlogging Means of government assistance Information source Safety Lecture The cognize of flood control Flood control facility Preparation of flood control Aggregation degree of crowd The content of property maintenance Dealing with waterlogging The frequency of travel Adaptability of residents Community resilience Location prone to waterlogging( inside the community) Broadcast Help evacuate Drainage pump Residents Shangfang Rainy day Old-time waterlogging point Old-time waterlogging streets Old-time waterlogging buildings Road Property Dingjiazhuang Sunny day Huagang Huagang Daishan Daishan Shangfang Shangfang Dingjiazhuang Dingjiazhuang Drain pipe Roof waterproof Roof drain Other Nobody Daishan Huagang Excellent Good Average Bad Very bad Lectures Increasing facilities Internet Consolation Activities Establish flood prevention Television Allowances Yes Enhanced drainage Neighbors Disaster Drill Unaware Rubbish sorting Shangfang Huagang Low High Newspaper Building reinforcement No Increasing permeable pavement property Nothing Yes, but not in it River dredging Dingjiazhuang Daishan SF SF SF SF SF DS DS DS DS DS HG HG HG HG HG
3.1.1
Before waterlogging After waterlogging Dingjiazhuang Shangfang Daishan Huagang In waterlogging
19
4. MECHANISM OF VULNERABILITY
4.1 Evaluation index and data processing
4.1.1 Evaluation index system of social vulnerability
From 3 dimensions(exposure, sensitivity and adaptability), 18 indexes were selected to construct evaluation indexes of social vulnerability to waterlogging of affordable housing residents in Nanjing.
4.2 Influencing factors of social vulnerability
4.2.1 Sensitivity: Mainly affected by family structure and personal traits of residents
Extra: Summary of waterlogging types of each security housing
Overpass overflowed
Goal layer criterion layer index layer index weight the nature of indicators Numbers 0.0763 0.0240 0.0521
Exposure (+)
Sensitivity (+) Social vulnerability Adaptability (+)
⑧
Relief degree of land surface
0.0049 0.0424 0.0367 0.0069 0.0303 0.0445 0.1725 0.0561 0.0071 0.0072 0.0152 0.0263 0.0151 0.1907
+ + + + + + + + + + +
5.1.1 Expression
0.1836 + X8 X9 X10 X11
--
X1 X2 X3 X4 X5 X6 X7 X12 X13 X14 X15 X16 X17 X18
Note: There is a positive correlation between exposure and sensitivity and social vulnerability, and the index nature is +', indicating that the higher the exposure and sensitivity, the higher the degree of social vulnerability. There is a negative correlation between adaptive capacity and social vulnerability, and the index nature is -', indicating that the stronger the adaptive capacity, the lower the degree of social vulnerability.
5. VERIFICATION OF CONCLUSIONS
5.1 Evaluation model of social vulnerability
Taking social vulnerability index as the dependent variable and social vulnerability evaluation index as the independent variable, a multiple linear regression model is constructed.
Y = β0 + β1X1 + β2x2 +...+ βpXp
--
② ② ②
③ ③ ③
④ ④ ④
⑤ ⑤ ⑤
① ② ③ ④ ⑤ ⑥ ⑦
⑥ ⑥ ⑥
⑦ ⑦ ⑦
⑧ ⑧ ⑧
⑨ ⑩ ① ② ③ ④ ⑤ ⑥ ⑦
⑨ ⑨ ⑨
4.2.1 Exposure: Mainly affected by community built environment and built year
⑩ ⑩ ⑩
Green space too high ① ① ①
Community sensitivity box plot Community exposure box plot Community adaptability box plot
External road elevation Rivers flow backward
⑧
The structure of age The structure of gender The structure of gender(X2)
State of health State of health(X3)
Community sensitivity Community exposure Community adaptability
Economic income Medical expenditure ratio household registration type household registration type(X6)
Education degree Information capturing ability per capita living space Distance from medical facilities Level of public service facilities Government action
⑨ ⑩ ① ② ③ ④ ⑤ ⑥ ⑦
Statistical map of resident sensitivity Statistical map of resident exposure Statistical map of resident adaptability
Sloping entrance
Social capital
Note: Y is a dependent variable (social vulnerability index), β0 is a constant, β1β2...βp is a regression coefficient, X1X2...XP is an independent variable (impact factor of social vulnerability, i.e. evaluation index of social vulnerability), and ε is a random error.
4.2.1 Adaptability: Mainly affected by government emergency actions and coping ability of residents
ε
Greening rate Greening rate(X9)
Distance from the river Distance from the river(X10)
Built year Built year(X11)
⑨ ⑩ ② Wanfuyuan ③ Wanxingyuan ④ Xiangheyuan ⑤ Xiushuifang ⑥ Yangeyuan ⑦ Yanwuyuan ⑧ Yinlong II ⑨ Yayuan ⑩ Yinlong I
⑧
5.2 conclusion
5.1.2 Calculation Social vulnerability is affected by nine factors:
The result shows that the regression equation R = 0.887, adjusted R² = 0.787, F = 102.429 (Sig.= 0.000), the regression equation has a high degree of fitting and good effectiveness.
Among the influencing factors of social vulnerability, a total of 9 factors are entered into the regression model. Among them, gender, household registration type, education level and whether to pay attention to rainstorm information are positively correlation.
Registered permanent residence Registered permanent residence(X7) Education degree(X12) Information capturing ability(X14)
The greening rate, distance from river, construction age, health evaluation and residence location are negatively correlation.
constant Model regression coefficient 4.25 0.061 0.074 -0.072 -0.002 0.17
t sig
-0.057 -0.097 -0.002 0.111
5.553 13.295 -2.795 -6.546
16.568 6.113 -4.738 -4.002 -16.934 3.456
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.001
0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
Community nature : Greening rate(X9), Distance from the river(X10), Built year(X11) The regression coefficient of the three factors is negative, which is negatively correlated with social vulnerability.
Socioeconomic attribute : household registration type(X6), Registered permanent residence(X7), Education degree(X12)
Residents' health : The structure of gender(X2),State of health(X3)
Information capturing ability(X14) —— It also has an impact on social vulnerability
0.00 0.00 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.10 0.12 0.00 0.05 0.05 0.10 0.10 0.15 0.15 0.20 0.20 0.25 0.25 0.30 0.35 0 0 0 0.15 0.3 0.08 0.04 Type 1 Type 2 Type 3 Type 4 Type 5 Type 6
Flower bed damage ① Jiaheyuan
Y = – 0.072X1 – 0.002X2 – 0.002X3 + 0.061X4 – 0.057X5 + 0.074X6 – 0.097X7 + 0.111X8 + 0.17X9 + 4.25
+
20
Xu Haoyuan Bachelor of Engineering in Urban and Rural Planning Nanjing Tech University, P.R.China (+86)139-2144-4204 haoyuanxu1998@outlook.com