Historical Buildings

Big Springs Historical Society And Museum

3095 Main Street, Caledonia

The mission of the Big Springs Museum is to promote an appreciation of local history, heritage, and culture. Through research, discovery, collection, display, and preservation of relevant materials and through programming and dialogue, the Big Springs Museum will interpret the continuing story of the Caledonia-Mumford community, connecting history to contemporary life.

District No 4 One Room School House

13 Beckwith Avenue, Scottsville

The Wheatland District No. 4 School was one of nine “district schools” built during the 1800s in the Town of Wheatland. District No. 4, also known as the Quaker School or the South Road School, was built in the 1850s. The building was continuously in use as a school until 1947 when it closed. The No. 4 schoolhouse originally stood on South Road near the present Stokoe Farm. In early 2003, the building was donated to the Wheatland-Chili School District for historic preservation and educational usage. On September 15, 2004, the schoolhouse made its grand journey through the Village of Scottsville and was greeted by hundreds of students as it reached its new location on the campus of TJ Connor Elementary School. The schoolhouse then underwent an extensive renovation, and when complete was furnished with artifacts from the early twentieth century, some of which were original to the building when it first served as a school.

First Presbyterian Church Of Mumford

893 George Street, Mumford

The First Presbyterian Church of Mumford is a historic Church located in the Hamlet of Mumford in the Town of Wheatland. It has a High Victorian Gothic–style edifice built from 1869 to 1883 of bog limestone quarried from a rare fossilized deposit on the Oliver Allen farm east of Mumford. The Church was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 2002.

Genesee Country Village And Museum

1410 Flint Hill Road, Mumford

Genesee Country Village & Museum interprets

19th-century American life for the education and enjoyment of the public. Through preservation and stewardship, the Museum uses its historic buildings and gardens, landscapes, collections, and works of art to create experiences that foster a deeper understanding of the past and its relevance to the contemporary world.

Rochester Street Historic District

Rochester Street, Scottsville

41 residences form the Rochester Street Historic District, listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1973. Over half the houses in the Rochester Street Historic District date from the 1830s to the 1850s, stamping the village with an overall “Greek Revival” character. Consistency in scale, rhythm, and use successfully harmonizes the earliest building and the most recent newcomer to the street. The Rochester Street Historic District is a remarkably insulated village environment which historically and architecturally records the lives, skills, and prosperity of its nineteenth century inhabitants.

SAGE-MARLOW HOUSE

69 Main Street, Scottsville

The Sage-Marlowe House is a small one and a half story “vernacular” style, or working man’s house, at 69 Main Street in Scottsville. It was built around 1830 by Simeon Sage and was one of Scottsville’s earliest houses. There have been a total of fourteen owners in the house’s history. The Marlowe family owned it for sixty years before it was purchased by the Wheatland Historical Association (WHA) in 1985. The WHA has restored and furnished the house to represent the 1830-1850 time period. One room of the house was especially designed to house the George Skivington collection of historical materials. It consists of books, scrapbooks, and original documents collected by Mr. Skivington and donated to the WHA. In 2000 a room was added to the back of the house used for educational purposes and group activities. A Christmas sale and a geranium sale have been held at the house annually for several years.

SCOTTSVILLE FREE LIBRARY 28 Main Street, Scottsville

The Scottsville Free Library, formerly known as Windom Hall, is one of the most historically significant and prominent structures in the Village of Scottsville. Designed by distinguished architect Charles H. Ellis, the building officially opened on February 17, 1892 as a community hall and theater. For decades, Windom Hall was used for “a variety of social and cultural purposes before coming into the possession of Scottsville Free Library in 1935.” Today, the Scottsville Free Library remains a cornerstone of the community, providing residents and patrons with access to an expansive collection of literature, the latest in technological research, video and audio offerings, and enriching programming for all ages. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places, Scottsville Free Library is a great source of pride and pleasure for the entire community.

Scottsville

Ebenezer Allen, one of the first white settlers west of the Genesee River, came to the Genesee country in 1782 following the Sullivan campaigns. Allen left Mt. Morris and settled on Oatka Creek in 1786, near what is now the Village of Scottsville. In 1789, he sold to Peter Sheffer. Allan established a gristmill at the falls of the Genesee and thus founded the first Rochester industry. In 1790, settler Jacob Schoonover arrived in the Genesee country. His daughter, in the same year, met and was married to Peter Sheffer’s son. This was the first marriage between white people west of the Genesee River. Isaac Scotts, after whom the Village is named, came in the same year and purchased 150 acres of land, which covered most of present-day Scottsville. His log house stood at the southwest corner of Main and Rochester Streets.

In the 1830s and 1840s, wheat was “king” in Monroe County and the wheat and flour from Wheatland were second to none. New York and Boston merchants often paid premium prices for a barrel of flour made from the wheat grown and ground here. Farmers and merchants became wealthy and built beautiful homes to replace the log cabins and simple houses that had been hastily erected. Most of the beautiful PostColonial, Greek Revival, and cobblestone houses were built during these two decades.

The Checkered Tavern

Your Craft Food & Beverage Specialist

Nestled between the 9th and 10th holes on the picturesque Morgan’s Crossing Golf Course, The Checkered Tavern is more than just a golf course bar; it’s a haven for those seeking a delightful culinary and craft beverage experience. Co-owned by Wheatland natives, Todd Rath and Mark Hallock, known for their Blue Toad Hard Cider, The Checkered Tavern offers a unique blend of delectable golf-themed dishes and an extensive selection of local craft beers and ciders.

With its expansive patio boasting stunning views, The Checkered Tavern is the perfect spot to unwind with friends and enjoy a relaxing meal. Whether you’re a golfer seeking a quick bite before continuing your game or an outside visitor wanting to soak up the beautiful surroundings, The Checkered Tavern welcomes all. Opportunities abound in their new 50x20 foot pavilion.

The Checkered Tavern maintains 13 taps, featuring a mix of ciders and craft beers, including local favorites like K2, Brindle Haus, No BS, and Dublin Corners, which are always on tap. Hallock highly recommends his favorites: the BILLievable and Blue Raspberry ciders, and Light Cider Done Right. Blue Toad’s impressive collection of 65 brand labels makes the tavern a paradise for craft beverage enthusiasts.

Experience the tavern’s golf-themed specialties with tantalizing “On the Range” starters – nachos, tachos, fries, onion rings, chicken fingers, and mozzarella sticks. Indulge in scrumptious burgers, chicken sandwiches, wraps, or the tavern’s Hole in One Plate. Don’t miss the “Off the Tee” handhelds – try their fried bologna and cheese on thick-cut Texas toast, Amen’ Corner Grilled Cheese with house-made pimento cheese, or a classic Nathan’s or Zweigle’s hot dog. “Go for the Green” salads and kids’ meals ensure all in your party satisfy their tastebuds.

If you haven’t visited The Checkered Tavern since its transformation under Rath and Hallock’s leadership, stop by and experience the new fun and flavors it offers. Embrace the charm of Wheatland, and savor the delightful fusion of craft food, cider, and community at The Checkered Tavern. Whether you’re a golfer, a local resident, or just passing through, this vibrant spot promises an unforgettable experience for everyone.