www.thedollarbusiness.com
Vol.5
Issue 01
January 2018
100
$2
EXCLUS IVE IN TE RV IEW S H.E. VITALY A. PRIMA Ambassador of Belarus to India MERRILL JOSEPH FERNANDO Chairman & Founder, Dilmah Tea KATHERINE B. HADDA US Consulate General, Hyderabad RAHUL SHUKLA Executive Director – Indirect Tax, PricewaterhouseCoopers ANIL K. TRIGUNAYAT Former Ambassador of India to Jordan, Libya & Malta ...AND MANY MORE!
FTP MID-TERM REVIEW
JUST A TEMPORARY
FIX?
The mid-term review of the current Foreign Trade Policy was welcomed by the industry. It followed a long wait in the backdrop of declining exports as a result of the global slowdown, domestic policies like demonetisation and various structural problems of GST. While the initial enthusiasm of the release has dimmed, the question now being asked is whether it truly meets the expectations of the industry and exports goal of the nation?
Menthol
Mint(ing) some money
Rising global demand for menthol-based products is the secret
Cassia
Spicy business
Cheaper cousin of cinnamon that’s popular amongst importers
THEA SOAPS WE STAND FOR QUALITY
A genuine natural product, Thea Soaps, knows how to nurture your skin.
Free from all chemicals, whether it’s a moisturiser, body wash, face pack, or a simple soap bar, our products are carefully handcrafted using only natural ingredients sourced from different parts of the world.
Behind every stylish Beard there is always Beard Butter! Beard Butter is a mix of oils and butters like Shea and Cocoa etc. The natural butters used in beard butters are used to help lock in moisture whilst making sure the beard remains soft and manageable. Butters also provide a light hold so that you can tame and style your beard.
*All our products are 100% vegan / * All our products are 100% herbal extracts
THEA SOAPS
3-15-156, 2nd floor, Venkataramana Colony, Mallapur, Nacharam, Hyderabad-500076, Telangana. India Mobile: +91-9949896254 / +91-9542786627 . Email: theasoaps@gmail.com, info@theasoaps.com, bulkorders@theasoaps.com w w w . t h e a s o a p s . c o m
LETTER FROM THE EDITOR–IN–CHIEF
FROM 'HURRIED CHANGES' TO 'STABLE HOPES'
A
cursory look at India’s exports numbers in the past 17 months, and a casual observer could well brand it a ‘mini golden age’ of India’s performance at the ports. India’s unusually vast tribe which thrives at convincing foreign buyers with its produce is seemingly convinced about its nation being a frontrunner to nudge past the $300 billion finish line this fiscal. It's impressive that despite the multi-textured troubles (like demonetisation, a hurried GST implementation, lack of digitisation, failure to implement 24x7 clearance facilities at ports, delayed FTP revision, etc.), the anxieties are washed away by numbers that indicate a bounceback to the 2013-14 days for India’s exports. But a New Year presents newer challenges. We saw some encouraging revisions to MEIS and SEIS announced in the month of December last. WTO could have a problem with that, given its rules that allow a nation to give direct incentives to its exporters. This year itself, think tanks in the government ranks should start formulating various ‘adjusted, indirect and yet transferable’ incentives schemes that are (a) industry specific to avoid a one-sizefits-all assumption, (b) as flexibile in terms of utility to the EXIM community as the current ones, including transferability and usability, and (c) effective enough to replace the ‘on-the-face’ incentives when the WTO comes knocking. We have to get rid of the GST refund menace. A new year, but the same old problem won’t do. As per some estimates, India’s exports community has begun the year with a backlog of about Rs.1.85 lakh crore in pending IGST and ITC refunds. Of these two, ITC refunds account for about 85% of the total backlog, and it is shocking that one significant reason why the refunds have not been processed is the very ‘conflicting criteria for calculation of ITC refunds’. Such an inefficient, unsure mechanism jeopardises the present of India’s exporters, especially those lakhs for whom these refund delay mean blockages of precious working capital. Next come the states. For years now, we’ve witnessed a flurry of opinions and announcements to make Indian states responsible for national exports. The states were even advised to conclude on state-level export policies. So far, only 14 states have prepared their drafts. The Niti Aayog must discuss and decide on a blueprint for incentivising states that indulge proactively in growth of India’s exports. Special subsidies can be offered to states who meet a minimum performance criteria. But the question here is – who decides what criteria? Hopefully, the Centre has this question sorted in its head. Recent months have got the Indian exporters hopeful. The numbers – both performance and revised FTP-related – have given them enough reasons to pin their expectations on the Union Budget. It’s time for the Centre to shift focus slightly away from fiscal prudence and provide tax sops and alternative incentives for exporters through technological upgradation and modernisation schemes. While the government has unleashed a battery of measures to aid India’s exporters and manufacturers in the past year, there is no denying the fact that 2017 has been about a rise in exports despite scuttled plans and unexpected new realities. Our exporters are paying the price of 'hurried changes' last year. 2018 will bring in more 'stable hopes'. And with more hope comes more expectations. Doubt you not – 2018 will be a consequential year for India’s foreign trade. A government, chosen by popular vote five years back, has an opportunity to become the popular champion of the common Indian exporter. www.thedollarbusiness/blogs/steven
@SPWarner
Recent months have got the Indian exporters hopeful. The numbers – performance and FTP-related – have given them reasons to pin their expectations on the Union Budget.
Steven Philip Warner
President (VMPL) & Editor-in-Chief, The Dollar Business steven@thedollarbusiness.com www.tumblr.com/blog/steven-p-warner JANUARY 2018 II THE DOLLAR BUSINESS 3
Volume: 5 Issue: 01 January 2018 www.thedollarbusiness.com facebook.com/tdbIndia twitter.com/TheDollarBiz in.linkedin.com/in/thedollarbusiness/ President (VMPL) & Editor-in-Chief EDITORIAL & RESEARCH Editor Executive Editor Senior Editor Assistant Editors
: Steven Philip Warner
: Manish K. Pandey : Indranil Das : Niladri S. Nath : Ahmad Shariq Khan, Anishaa Kumar, Aamir Hussain Kaki
14 COVER STORY
EDITORIAL CONSULTING BOARD Founder & Editor : Anil Goyal Publisher : Avnish Goyal Chief Consulting Editor : Dr. A. K. Sengupta
The long-delayed mid-term review of the Foreign Trade Policy (FTP) 2015-2020, released recently, has been welcomed by the industry. As the initial enthusiasm about enhanced rewards wanes FTP MID-TERM REVIEW down, the question now being raised is if the policymakers have done enough to give exports the much-needed boost?
ADVERTISEMENT SALES & MARKETING Deputy Managers : Payal Kapoor, Rahul Jain Senior Executive : Ayesha Fatima, Ankit Kharbanda International Representatives Seoul (South Korea) London (UK)
: Justin Yoon : S. Puri
ART & PHOTOGRAPHY Art Director Senior Designer Photographer
: Sujesh Kumar G. : Jayaprakash Reddy : Dileep Kumar
THE DOLLAR BUSINESS ONLINE & RESEARCH Project Managers : Sridhar Bodla, Omar Larzi Web Designer : Purushothama Chary SEO Specialist : Y. Lakshman Varma Deputy Manager (EXIM Opp.): Lakshmi Kondaveeti Asst. Managers (EXIM Opp.) : G Bhanu Prasad, Priyanka Bhandekar, Sravanthi Bandhla Senior Executive (EXIM Opp.) : Neetu Hotkar, A.V. Divya Madhuri, Ravali Gali, Gunna Kavya Reddy Executive (EXIM Opp.) : Vijayalakshmi Chittari, Radhika Nalluri, Relangi Yamuna Santosh Kumari, Habeeb Unnisa, N Lavanya, Keerthi Sulakhe Asst. Managers (Data & Metrics) : Sharath Chandra Murthy Macha, Ramesh Babu Lalam
WORK IN PROGRESS?
28 H.E. VITALY A. PRIMA
AMBASSADOR OF BELARUS TO INDIA
Discusses the untapped potential of India-Belarus bilateral trade.
CIRCULATION, SUBSCRIPTION & DISTRIBUTION Manager : M. Vinay Kumar
38 KATHERINE HADDA
ALLIANCES & COMMUNICATIONS Sr. Manager : Rasanpreet Kaur Asst. Managers : Sravya Palakuru, Aishwarya Ramarajan FINANCE & ADMIN Manager Executive
US COUNCIL GENERAL IN HYDERABAD
On the enormous bilateral trade and investment opportunities when it comes to Indo-US ties.
: V. Srikanth Tumati : Chandrakant Nawande
PRINTER Rudra Graphic Designers 8-3-949/3, Beside Gold Spot Company, Punjagutta, Hyderabad 500073, Telangana, IN PUBLISHED AT 5-2-198/4, Distillery Road, Ranigunj, Secunderabad, Telangana 500003, IN
© Copyright 2017 No part of this magazine may be reproduced in whole or in part without an expressed permission of the publisher. The information on this magazine is for information purpose only. Manish K. Pandey, Editor, The Dollar Business, is responsible for the selection of news and content under PRB Act. Vimbri Media Pvt. Ltd. assumes no liability or responsibility for any inaccurate, delayed or incomplete information, or for any actions taken in reliance thereon. The information contained about each individual, event or organisation has been provided by such individual, event organisers or organisation without verification by us. All disputes are subject to exclusive jurisdiction of competent courts and forums in Hyderabad, Telangana. Printed and published by Avnish Goyal for Vimbri Media Pvt. Ltd. Published at : 5-2-198/4, Distillery Road, Ranigunj, Secunderabad - 500 003, Telangana. Printed at: Rudra Graphic Designers, 8-3-949/3, Beside Gold Spot Company, Punjagutta, Hyderabad - 500 073, Telangana.
06
08
10 30
FOR EDITORIAL/CONTENT Email: editorial@thedollarbusiness.com FOR ADVERTISEMENT Email: ads@thedollarbusiness.com FOR SUBSCRIPTION Email: subscription@thedollarbusiness.com . +91-40-67609999 For queries / comments you can send us an SMS at +91-888-633-1947
4 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
32
INBOX LETTERS TO THE EDITOR Readers’ feedback that hit our mailbox in December. MONOLOGUE PEOPLE SPEAK Prabhu on the WTO, Theresa May on UK’s future and more. TRADE WRAP India’s rise in PMI Index, US Federal Tax cuts and more. EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW ANIL KUMAR TRIGUNAYAT Former Ambassador to Jordan, Malta & Libya on the future of India’s trade. IMPORT’ONOMICS CASSIA Lifestyle changes are driving
imports of this pungent spice.
36
GLOBAL MANAGER MERRILL J. FERNANDO Founder of Dilmah, discusses the brand’s journey so far.
40
SECRET INGREDIENT MENTHOL Can natural menthol compete against synthetic menthol?
44
POLICY MONITOR SRTEPC Narain Aggarwal, Chairman, on the challenges exporters face.
46
TDB FORUM Questions about foreign trade that hit our mail box in Dec. 2017.
50
BORDERLINE Editor’s Column
GOEL ENTERPRISES
MEIS SEIS DFIA CELEBRATING 50 GLORIOUS YEARS OF SERVING THE INDIAN EXIM COMMUNITY! BUY & SELL MEIS, SEIS AND OTHER TRANSFERABLE SCRIPS ONLINE EMAIL US ON purchase@scripbazaar.com or buy@scripbazaar.com DIAL +91-9885361000, +91-40-66323310, +91-40-27543312 or +91-40-27544008
ADDRESS 5-2-198/4, Distillery Road, Ranigunj, Secunderabad, Telangana - 500003
om cripbazaar.c www.s
inbox
editorial@thedollarbusiness.com SMS your views to +91-7680-80-7111
WE VALUE YOUR FEEDBACK, WHETHER CRITICISM OR APPRECIATION. AND HERE ARE A FEW THAT HIT OUR MAILBOXES IN DECEMBER 2017
A
few months ago, I was lucky to come across The Dollar Business magazine. I must say, I was impressed with the quality of the content. I believe that it is a first of its kind endeavour in India. In my opinion, such a publication can play a really constructive role in enhancing India’s trade engagements with the rest of the world, of course including my country, Holland. All the very best! H.E. ALPHONSUS STOELINGA Ambassador of Netherlands to India
O
www.thed ollarbusine ss.com
December 2017
100
INTE RVIE
India’s ran k in the Wo from 201 rld Bank’s 7 to reac Doing Bus h 100. Wh lags beh iness ile this is ind a remarka 2018 report jumped enforcing its peers on man ble 30 places y importa contracts. nt parame achievement, the too early? Is country still ters The Dollar India really on its path to star like cross-border Business trade analyses dom or are India’s new we celebra and -found stat ting us.
The fish is
Ribbon fish
The prize
highly in dem (by)catch and amongst Chinese
buyers
Paper & pap
T
he story on paper imports “Rolling in the Money” in the December 2017 issue was very informative. The point of view of the industry was presented in a very elaborate manner. It’s great to see someone highlighting the concerns of paper industry. I look forward to reading such stories in the future. TUSHAR GUPTA Proprietor, Om Shiv Packaging +91-9873185XXX
$2
WS
Managin R. S. SODHI g Director, Amul HONSUS STOELIN GA Ambassa Netherlan dor of the ds to India CHARLO Developm TTE NAN JIAN G ent Spec ialist Business Group, Worl , Doing d Bank Associate JULIUS SEN London Scho Director – ITPU , ol of Econ omics Chief Econ MADAN SABNAV omist, CAR IS E Ratings ...AND MAN Y MORE! H.E. ALP
ver since I got my hands on one of the issues of The Dollar Business at one of the industry business meets, I have become an avid reader. True to its tagline, India’s only magazine on foreign trade, this publication, each month, showcases stories related to Indian foreign trade that are both well researched and insightful, not to mention extremely well written. A must-read publication for anyone interested in making a mark in the world of foreign trade. DR. SAURABH AGARWAL Professor, Indian Institute of Finance +91-120-6471XXX sa@iif.edu
6 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
Issue 12
EXC LUS IVE
ne of our main aims at Indian Importers Chambers of Commerce and Industries (IICCI) is to help foreign manufacturers and investors find reliable partners in India. In this regard The Dollar Business does a wonderful job. The magazine, in my view, is an excellent publication that fills a critical space and offers cutting-edge insights on multiple sectors related to foreign trade. It caters excellently to the informational needs of wide-ranging stakeholders representing the trading fraternity of the country. I wish the publication all the success. ATUL SAXENA President, Indian Importers Chambers of Commerce and Industries, +91-11-26963XXX iicci@indianimporterschambers.com
E
Vol.4
W
e are a manufacturer and exporter of natural perfumery compounds, floral waters, Indian vegetable seeds oils and other products. It is good to see a magazine dedicated to exports and imports. The content is well-researched and informative. The articles are interesting and insightful. RAJAT MEHROTRA Proprietor, Meena Perfumery +91-9839739XXX
erboar
ds Rolli Growth in diverse appling in profits cations is driving their imports
I
came across the December issue of The Dollar Business and it was very informative. Keep up the good work. Could you send across a copy of the November issue? RAJARAM SANGLE Director, Sangle Agro Processing Pvt. Ltd., +91-2532592XXX sangle@alcomp.in
I
have been a regular reader since 2015. Also, almost every day, I browse the website. I recently noticed major changes in the website, with new schemes for exporters. I congratulate the team for introducing these initiatives. I have recommended TDB to my colleagues and counterparts. I hope it will grow manifold in the future. SAMAPIKA SANYAL Officer – International Operations, Kokuyo Camlin Ltd. +91-9967893XXX samapikasanyal8989@gmail.com
monologue
T
hriving two-way trade and investment is an integral part of our vision for a strong partnership. NARENDRA MODI INDIAN PRIME MINISTER On the role of trade in India-Israel relations Source: Ministry of External Affairs, GoI
I
f we only discuss issues of interest to a handful of developed countries, then a multilateral body like the WTO, with a majority of developing countries, will become irrelevant. SURESH PRABHU INDIAN MINISTER FOR TRADE & COMMERCE ON THE WTO STALEMATE Source: IANS
T
he EU and Japan share a common vision for an open and rules-based world economy that guarantees the highest standards. Today, we are sending a message to other countries about the importance of free and fair trade, and of shaping globalisation.
W
e will deliver on the will of the British people and get the best Brexit deal for our country – securing the greatest possible access to European markets, boosting free trade with countries across the world, and delivering control over our borders, laws and money.
CECILIA MALMSTRÖM EU COMMISSIONER FOR TRADE ON EU-JAPAN TRADE DEAL
THERESA MAY BRITISH PRIME MINISTER ON BRITAIN’S TRADE FUTURE
Source: European Commission
Source: Reuters
W
e’ve been working on deepening our trade ties, opportunities for small businesses, for Canadians to benefit from better access to the Chinese market while standing up for our interests and jobs back home. JUSTIN TRUDEAU CANADIAN PRIME MINISTER ON TRADE WITH CHINA Source: AP
8 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
I
t calls for trade based on the principles of fairness and reciprocity. It calls for firm action against unfair trade practices and intellectual property theft. And it calls for new steps to protect our national security industrial and innovation base. DONALD TRUMP US PRESIDENT EMPHASISING THE ROLE OF TRADE IN THE US NATIONAL SECURITY STRATEGY Source: The White House
PAKISTAN-CHINA
Welcome to powerplay! After years of trading in US dollars, Pakistan and China have decided to make the Chinese Yuan the official currency for bilateral trade. The decision comes at a time when the two nations are working towards strengthening their economic and political ties. China’s major investments in Pakistan is in the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), which includes the much hyped and controversial Gwadar Port Complex. China is Pakistan’s largest source for imports and its second-largest export destination. In the past decade, bilateral trade between the two countries has increased from $2.2 billion to $13.8 billion. However, imports from China and not Pakistani exports has driven this growth. China is expected to invest $57 billion in Pakistan as a part of CPEC. This skewed power dynamics is expected to help China gain a major leverage in south Asia. SOUTH AFRICA
Not so sweet… Taking the fizz out of sugar-based drinks in South Africa is a newly introduced tax. The tax on sugar-based drinks, including sodas, is expected to reduce consumption of these beverages. This tax is part of South Africa’s plan to fight the growing epidemic of obesity and diabetes in the country. Beverage giants such as Coca-Cola and PepsiCo have spent considerable resources lobbying against taxes like these. Their efforts came to nought as the South African Revenue Service announced that the Sugary Beverages Levy would be collected from April 2018. The levy has been fixed at 2.1 cents per gram of sugar on drinks with sugar content above 4 grams per 100 ml. No levy will be charged on 100% fruit juices. The increased costs of these beverages is expected to further reduce the already declining consumption in South Africa. In the past, similar taxes have been introduced in Thailand and Mexico to encourage people to adopt more nutritious food habits. 10 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
US-TAX REFORM
‘Tax’ing days?
B
eing touted by the Trump Administration as a much-needed lifeline for the American economy, in December 2017, the highly-debated Trump Tax Bill was passed by the US Senate. It is expected to come into effect in the coming days. The Trump Administration has hailed this move as revolutionary. They say it will increase the spending power of the average American. Economists, statisticians and pretty much anyone with a calculator say otherwise. Middle-class Americans will be paying more taxes than ever by 2027. The $1.5-trillion tax overhaul is expected to expand the US economy by 0.8% over the next decade, according to a report by the Joint Tax Committee. Trump also hopes to realise his oft-stated intention of bringing jobs back to America by lowering the corporate tax rate as a part of his far-reaching tax policy, a move which is expected to make outsourced units in countries like India uncompetitive. The US Administration has reduced corporate tax rate in US to 21% from the previous 35%, much lower than the Indian rate of 30%. While most experts across the globe believe that it is unlikely that these reforms can deliver the growth that Trump has predicted, it has set off a global race to cut corporate taxes. China and Japan have already announced tax cuts and Australia too is expected to follow suit. In 2017 alone seven OECD countries have cut tax rates. Will Mr. Jaitley keep the trend going? UAE-VAT
Turning over a new leaf In a move that is expected to help increase revenues for the country, United Arab Emirates (UAE) has introduced a 5% value-added tax (VAT) from January 1, 2018 on most goods and services that were previously tax-free. The suggestion was made by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) for oil-exporting countries as a means to increase non-oil revenue. In early 2017, UAE had announced 100% tax on energy drinks, tobacco as well as 50% tax on soft drinks. The latest 5% tax is levied on almost all products and services barring a few essential needs such as transportation, rent, schooling (excluding higher education) and healthcare. While UAE is the first middle-eastern country to introduce a VAT, several other countries are also expected to introduce similar taxes in the coming days. India, for which UAE is a popular export destination, might see some choppy weather in the coming days. Foreign companies with units in UAE are also expected to see an increase in their overall expenses. Most reports though predict a minimal impact of the tax on UAE’s overall economy. Experts believe that the 5% VAT will not cause any problems as it is far lower than the average 20% in European countries. Living costs though are expected to rise by 2.5%.
INDIA-RUSSIA
Planning a win-win During a recent meeting of the India-Russia Inter-Governmental Commission on Trade, Economic, Technological and Cultural Cooperation (IRGC-TEC), India and Russia reviewed areas of economic cooperation, including investments, energy and trade. As a part of the meeting, working groups were set up for removing barriers for trade and increasing investments. In FY2017, bilateral trade reached $7.4 billion. During Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s visit to Russia, the two nations further spoke about advancing discussions on an Indo-Eurasia FTA which is expected to provide India with a trade potential of as high as $62 billion.
GST
New Year cheer
A
fter concerns about the long-term impact of the government reforms and policies on India’s foreign trade, good news came in the form of trade data. In November 2017, India’s exports grew by 30.55% to $26.19 billion against $20.06 billion in November 2016. Exports rose by 13.4% from October 2017. A y-o-y decline was seen in October 2017, when exports fell to $23.09 billion from $23.36 billion in October 2016. The growth in exports, according to reports, has been due to the increase in global demand and a simplification in taxation with the introduction of GST. Some sectors that have shown improvements include engineering, gems and jewellery, petroleum, pharmaceuticals, chemicals, etc. For the period from April to November 2017, the cumulative exports increased by 12% y-o-y to $196.64 billion. Despite the growth in exports, the country’s trade deficit continued to rise as imports saw a y-o-y increase of 19.61% to $40 billion in November 2017. With the government having announced higher incentives for exporters in the midterm FTP review, will the trade deficit now narrow down? Only time will tell. METHANOL
Saving the environment
PMI
Back on track? According to the Nikkei Purchasing Manager’s Index (PMI) for December 2017, Indian manufacturing rose to a five-year high of 54.7 from 52.6 in November 2017. The index measures the strength of a country’s “economic health”. A reading above 50 on the index hints at economic expansion while one below 50 indicates contraction. In July 2017 the PMI saw a decline to 47.9 from 50.9 in June 2017. The introduction of GST and the demonetisation initiative, which resulted in a slowdown in factory outputs, were factored to be the main reason. The report findings indicate that India is recovering from the recent economic reforms and is getting back on track to being one of the fastest growing economies in the world.
In a move to help reduce India’s dependency on crude oil imports, NITI Aayog is working on a ‘methanol policy’. By promoting methanol as an eco-friendly alternative to carbon fuels, by 2030 the policy aims to reduce imports of crude oil by $100 billion. The government is reportedly planning to set up a methanol economy fund worth Rs.4,000-5,000 crore in order to promote domestic methanol production. Under the plan, Coal India is expected to set up facilities to convert high ash coal into fuel. Mixing methanol with petroleum reduces the cost of fuel by 10%. This will go a long way in making transportation cheaper in the country as Indian railways and ports are highly dependent on petroleum. Speaking during a Parliament session, Union Minister for Transport Nitin Gadkari said that around 50 ports and vessels will be refitted to use methanol in the coming days. Methanol use can also help reduce fuel costs for railways which currently spends Rs.15,000 crore per annum on diesel. It is worth noting that India is currently the third-largest importer of petroleum in the world.
JANUARY 2018 II THE DOLLAR BUSINESS 11
COVER STORY
FTP 2015-2020 MID-TERM REVIEW
FTP MIDTERM REVIEW
BULLISHLY SERIOUS. BARELY SUFFICIENT.
14 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
The long-awaited and much-delayed mid-term review of the Foreign Trade Policy (FTP) 2015-2020, was released by the Ministry of Commerce in December last. While the government enhanced rewards under its flagship export promotion schemes and addressed some issues that had come into play after the implementation of GST, there wasn't anything that exceeded expectations of India's EXIM community. In its zeal for ticking the right boxes, the review seems to have given radical structural reforms a miss. Will the revised FTP help deliver a 'sustained' export growth? The Dollar Business takes stock. BY AAMIR H. KAKI
T
he year 2017 ended on a happy note for the Indian exim community as the much-awaited mid-term review of the Foreign Trade Policy (FTP) 2015-20 was released by Minister of Commerce and Industry, Suresh P. Prabhu on December 5, 2017. The review comes at a time when the Indian EXIM community has been struggling with internal issues such as the impact of demonetisation and structural problems post-GST as well as other (including external) factors like appreciating rupee, lack of dollars amongst LatAm and African nations, a sluggish global market, etc. The mid-term review of FTP, which aims to promote and boost merchandise and services exports from the country was long overdue. In May 2017, the then Commerce Minister Nirmala Sitharaman had sown the seeds of hope when she announced that the review of the FTP would be released before the implementation of the Goods and Services Tax
(GST). That wasn't to be. The review was delayed in order to include changes required post GST implementation. The mid-term review at first sight looks to be one that the industry needs at this hour, but is it one the industry deserves? Will the announcements have a long-term impact on Indian exports? Will the measures announced be able to take Indian exporters up the value chain and increase the popularity of Indian products in the global market or are these just temporary fixes for the visible damages from GST implementation?
TICKING THE BOXES
FTP 2015-2020 had set an ambitious tar-
THE FTP REVIEW WAS INTRODUCED WITH A PROMISE TO GIVE A FILLIP TO THE MSME SECTOR JANUARY 2018 II THE DOLLAR BUSINESS 15
COVER STORY
FTP 2015-2020 MID-TERM REVIEW
get of $900 billion in exports by FY2020. With the target looking extremely unrealistic half-way through the term, and the implementation of GST throwing a spanner into the works, the government had its work cut out. With the review, it has tried to tick most of the boxes to alleviate the concerns of exporters. The focus of the mid-term review has been on labour-intensive sectors and mi-
cro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs), which contribute 45% of India's manufacturing output, over 40% of total exports and 8% of GDP. The segment has faced the maximum brunt of the GST implementation and demonetisation drive. And, it was about time that their issues were addressed and alleviated. The major benefits for MSMEs (and larger companies) came in the form of
FTP mid-term review highlights
Overall annual incentives increased by Rs.8,450 crore (a 33.8% increase). The FTP would focus on micro, small and medium enterprises, labour-intensive segments and the agriculture sector. FTP incentives now cover 8,000 of the total 12,000 lines of items. Incentives for goods exports is Rs.4,567 crore, and for services exports is Rs.1,140 crore. This is in addition to the recently announced incentives for ready-made garments. Self-certification scheme for duty-free imports. FTP is a dynamic document and regular changes are made to increase value addition in the country, generate more employment and boost exports. The review includes a 2% increase each in incentive rates of the Merchandise Exports from India Scheme (MEIS) and Services Export from India Scheme (SEIS). Of these incentives, Rs.749 crore is for leather and footwear, Rs.1,354 crore for agriculture and related items, Rs.759 crore for marine exports, Rs.369 crore for telecom and electronic items, Rs.921 crore for handmade carpets, Rs.193 crore for medical and surgical equipment and Rs.1,140 crore is for textiles and readymade garments. A new trade data analytics division under the Directorate General of Foreign Trade (DGFT) will be created to analyse real time data to help fine-tune policy.
Leather and footwear industry is of the opinion that the increase in MEIS scrip value will help in promoting innovation and improving price competitiveness of Indian exports. 16 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
enhancement of duty credit scrips by 2% across all sectors, under the flagship schemes of Merchandise Exports from India Scheme (MEIS) and Services Exports from India Scheme (SEIS). Overall, the incentives under the two schemes have been increased by Rs.8,450 crore, which represent a 33.8% annual rise from the prevailing Rs.25,000 crore. The biggest beneficiary of this increase in incentives seems to be the ready-made garments and made-ups sector. The potential additional annual cost to the government because of the increased rewards on exports of ready-made garments and made-ups is expected to be Rs.2,743 crore. Similarly, the increased benefits for exports by MSMEs and labour-incentive industries such as agriculture, carpets, leather, marine products, hand tools, rubber products, sports goods, ceramics, scientific and medical products and electronic and telecom components will cost the exchequer Rs.4,567 crore, annually. Under SEIS, higher incentives for services such as software services, architecture, legal accounting, hospital, engineering, education, hotels and restaurants will cost the government around Rs.1,140 crore a year. In addition, based on feedback from the foreign trade community, the government has increased the validity of the duty credit scrips from 18 months to 24 months in order to augment their utility in the GST regime. The GST rate for the transfer and sale of scrips has also been cut down to zero from the earlier 12%. While the increase in the rate of rewards is expected to directly add to the bottomline of exporters or at least defray the monetary impact of GST implementation, the revision has also taken measures towards improving existing policies by easing re-export of goods that are freely importable. In the same vein, procedures have been simplified under the Export Promotion Capital Goods (EPCG) Scheme for extension of export obligation (EO) period and shifting of capital goods. Similarly, the government has allowed the import of second-hand goods for repairing or refurbishing purpose, in order to facilitate employment generation in repair services sector. In addition, bene-
“NOT MUCH WAS DONE TO ADDRESS THE STRUCTURAL ISSUES” DR. VINAY SHARMA, OFFICIATING CHAIRMAN, EXPORT PROMOTION COUNCIL FOR EOUs & SEZs (EPCES)
TDB: Will the additional 2% incentives provided under MEIS effectively help Indian exporters become more competitive in the international market? VS: This is undoubtedly a positive development. We believe that such measures will help Indian exporters become more competitive. Equally laudable is the extension of validity of scrips from 18 months to 24 months along with the provision of zero GST on the sale of scrips. Sectors such as textiles and garments have been demanding the increase in rates of MEIS reward along with RoSL and duty drawback for a long time. Now, since the DGFT has enhanced the rates for garments and made-ups to 4% of the value of exports under MEIS, many other sectors will ask for similar incentives. With regards to whether these additional incentives serve the need, I think, the benefits are in the acceptable range. As a practice, dishing out too many doles is not a good idea. The ultimate intention should be to make exports self-sustaining. TDB: GST refunds have been a cause for concern amongst traders and exporters. Your comments. VS: Ever since the GST has been enforced, yet-to-be-disbursed GST refunds is an issue that has been the Achilles heel of the SEZs and EOUs community. Look at one paradox here. For tax purposes, SEZ supplies are now treated as zero-rated. So, say, if you bring material inside conclave, there is no GST applicable. But then, operating out of an SEZ, if you offer a service, you need to pay GST on it. Activities such as services exported from SEZs paid in foreign currency to the foreign party are not considered tax free. This paradox affects the gems and jewellery segment which is certainly a big segment for us. There are many players within SEZs who are entitled to input credits (IC)
if they get an order, say for diamond polishing. But then the moment this 18% service tax is brought to the notice of the foreign client, he starts looking for options (other cost-effective destinations) – and we lose business. Likewise, the warehouse industry is also being impacted by such an anomaly. I would also like to add that the majority of Indian businessmen are not averse to paying taxes, but it’s the inbuilt compliance cost in the tax mechanism that scares them. For instance, while supplying goods, a supplier needs to have letter of undertaking (LuT), which is system based. For this, one needs to go to GST website and request an LuT and wait for its approval. That eventually leaves him with two options: Either he should pay tax and claim refunds himself or the other party applies for input credit. Now being zero-rated, I cannot avail input credits and the mentality of a regular supplier is such that unless they have a volume business, they don’t bother about LuT as it not only increases paperwork but ends up multiplying their tax compliance cost. Such anomalies need to be fixed soon. TDB: Can initiatives such as a trust-based, self-rectification scheme for duty-free imports and creation of a new logistic division prove to be a gamechanger for the sector? VS: Yes, I think, the trust-based, self-rectification scheme for duty-free imports and initiatives like the doing away with testing of samples for drawback purpose as well as the introduction of e-sealing facility for exporters will help accelerate cargo movement and lead to quick clearances of consignments. With regards to self-certification, I would like to add that the SEZ industry has already been following this norm all along. Operating within a designated, regulated premise with a specified inlet and outlet gate, I believe that the majority of business owners within SEZs are law-abiding people. The creation of a logistics division is a good step as logistics costs certainly take the sheen off our cost competitiveness in many world markets. It’s too high at the moment and in fact, it is higher than what the government agencies tell us. The current on-the-road consignment movement is a serious nightmare. Our ports such as JNPT are no better. The facilities there are extremely overstretched. We need to emulate the best of industry practices in this regard. We can learn a lot from China here. They have manged to create a great mechanism for last mile connectivity. In countries, smaller than ours, they have no shortage of ports. Some big factories have their own ports there. I do not understand why Indian law stipulates that a port should be at least 50 km away from another. What if one of them is inefficient to cater to our requirements? JANUARY 2018 II THE DOLLAR BUSINESS 17
Interview by Ahmad Shariq Khan
TDB: What is your take on the FTP mid-term review? Has the government rightly identified policy gaps that have been affecting the growth of the EoUs and SEZs this time around? Dr. Vinay Sharma (VS): In many ways, the changes are welcome. However, structural loopholes that continue to plague our sector need to be urgently addressed. There are many areas where despite repeated reminders to concerned policymakers, things have not moved at the desired pace. Isn’t it a fact that we are responsible for 38-40% of country’s outward shipments? And does that not show we must be doing something right for the country’s economy? The government needs to play a more proactive role for our cause. Policy unpredictability, the return of cumbersome procedures and delays in decision-making have marred the image of SEZs as investor-friendly hotspots.
COVER STORY
FTP 2015-2020 MID-TERM REVIEW
fits have been restored under the export promotion schemes of duty free imports under Advanced Authorisation (AA), Export Promotion Capital Goods (EPCG) and 100% Export Oriented Units (EOUs) schemes, thus resolving the problem of blocked working capital for exporters following the roll-out of GST. To address the liquidity problem faced by exporters after GST rollout, an ‘e-wallet’ system is likely to be operational from April 1, 2018. Taking cognizance of the fact that one of the major factors that impact the competitiveness of Indian products is our high cost of logistics, a new Logistics Division will be set up in the Department of Commerce for promoting the integrated development of logistics sector. The other long-awaited announcement has been that an advanced trade analytics division will be created in the Directorate General of Foreign Trade (DGFT) to help them take data-based policy actions. Together with this, the Contact@DGFT service has been launched on the DGFT website as a single window contact point for exporters and importers. The service is expected to be a touch point that exporters can access to resolve their issues as well as give suggestions to the DGFT.
AN AGRICULTURE POLICY TO BOOST VALUE-ADDED AGRI PRODUCT EXPORTS IS BEING DRAFTED
The Commerce Ministry is also in the process of drafting a new agricultural export policy in order to boost exports of value-added agri products. A new services division too will be created in DGFT to assess EXIM policies and procedures to drive services exports. With regards to policy direction, a major emphasis will be put on exploring new markets and products in addition to increasing share in traditional markets and products.
THE ACCOLADES
As we said earlier, the government has managed to tick most boxes. Naturally exporters, especially those from the MSME sector, have welcomed the policy changes, specifically the increase in incentives under MEIS and SEIS. Ajay Sahai, Director General & CEO, Federation of Indian Export Organisations (FIEO), says, “The review has taken a two-pronged approach and focusses on sunrise sectors of exports as well as on the employment-intensive traditional sectors. In line with that, the review provides additional incentives to sectors such as electronics, pharmaceuticals, medical and diagnostic equipment and high-technology sectors as well as leather, marine, food processing, sports goods, textiles, carpets and handicrafts. The policy statement to a large extent has identified the issues affecting exports.” The MSME sector believes that the increase in MEIS rewards will definitely have a positive impact on exports. Representing the handicrafts exporters, and a sector that mostly comprises MSMEs,
Rakesh Kumar, Executive Director, Export Promotion Council for Handicrafts (EPCH), puts in, “Increase in MEIS rates will certainly result in increasing exports from MSMEs and labour-intensive industries including the handicrafts sector.” Mukhtarul Amin, Chairman, Council for Leather Exports (CLE), believes that this increase in rewards will also significantly benefit leather and footwear exports, a sector which has seen a decline in exports over the last few months. The increase, according to Amin, will play an important role in promoting innovation in the sector which will ultimately help improve its position on the global stage. “As the leather and footwear sectors are fashion and consumer-oriented, there is a need for continuous innovation leading to the creation of new products. For this, the industry is required to procure many critical inputs and components, for which the MEIS scrip is very useful. Hence, increase of MEIS scrip value will help in increasing price competitiveness of the sector,” explains Amin. H. K. L. Magu, Chairman of Apparel Export Promotion Council (AEPC), too believes that the FTP review has addressed several concerns of the sector. “I believe the mid-term review of FTP has covered many issues like enhancement of MEIS, increase in validity of scrips, zero duty on scrips, 24X7 facility to more seaports, etc. The enhancement in MEIS rates is a positive step. Besides this, the other critical area that FTP review has dealt with is trade facilitation and easing our capital blockage,” says Magu.
India's exports, pre and post FTP-2015-2020 introduction, vis-à-vis China's exports India still has a lot of catching up to do with its neighbour when it come to merchandise exports 700 600 500 400 300 200 100 0
2014 Q-1
2014 Q-2
2014 Q-3
China's exports to the world
2014 Q-4
2015 Q-1
2015 Q-2
2015 Q-3
2015 Q-4
2016 Q-1
2016 Q-2
2016 Q-3
2016 Q-4
2017 Q-1
2017 Q-2
India's exports to the world Source: TDB Intelligence Unit and UN Comtrade; figures in $ billion
18 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
“A MORE FOCUSED APPROACH TO INTERNATIONAL MARKETING IS REQUIRED” AJAY SAHAI, DIRECTOR GENERAL & CEO – FEDERATION OF INDIAN EXPORTS ORGANISATION (FIEO)
TDB: Do you think the additional 2% reward provided under MEIS and SEIS will help exports grow? AS: One of the challenges faced by the Indian export sector is price sensitivity. The volatility in the exchange rate affects Indian exports. The additional incentive will return some of the competitive edge which was lost as the rupee strengthened against foreign currencies while our competitors’ currencies weakened against the US dollar and other major currencies. TDB: Is the government's decision to focus on labour-intensive industries and MSMEs in the right direction when the world is moving up the value chain? AS: The biggest challenge facing the economy is job creation. The focus of the government therefore rightly is on MSMEs as employment to capital ratio in the sector is extremely high. MSMEs have the capability and flexibility to create jobs in the short to medium-term. Labour-intensive sectors also assume significance as they provide seasonal employment to the large workforce traditionally engaged in agriculture. ‘Make in India’ may be led by large companies, but this initiative will create huge opportunities for ancillaries in the MSME sector. Therefore, I feel, government is right in adopting a strategy which is a mix of focus on large companies and MSMEs. Moreover, large industries are quite capable and already have their own proactive ecosystem, while MSMEs may require some fiscal support. TDB: What is your view on the new trust-based, self-rectification scheme and the creation of a new logistics division? Can these prove to be game-changers for the sector? AS: We have to gradually move away from physical control to a
trust-based system. The FTP has encouraged this by introducing such a system for categories of exporters who have been recognised as Authorised Economic Operators (AEO). Such a recognition will also encourage exporters to opt for the AEO Scheme which unfortunately has not received an enthusiastic response. However, this is not enough, and the government should aggressively market its new schemes and address procedural constraints, if any. The creation of a Logistics Division, for the first time, will provide a holistic view of the state of affairs of logistics. Unfortunately, logistics comes within the purview of different ministries and each pursues its own policies and goals without looking into the initiatives undertaken by the other ministries. The Logistics Division will help in reducing the cost of logistics in the country. This has been supplemented by giving infrastructure status to logistics and implementation of GST which entails e-way bills. All these initiatives will help the exports and manufacturing sector. The creation of a single platform for all logistics service providers will also provide competitive logistics rates, transparency and predictability. TDB: How has the implementation of GST affected the exports fraternity? What are the challenges that you are facing? How satisfied are you with the solutions proposed? AS: Most of the challenges faced by the exporters in the GST regime are procedural in nature. The technical glitches in the GSTN, lack of awareness of the tax authorities towards export refund, grey areas in the filing of regular returns have compounded the problems of exporters. However, these are the teething challenges. We are hopeful that these issues will be addressed by March 2018. We also expect that the government will continue to provide an exemption from IGST on inputs required for exports production and introduce a comprehensive drawback scheme which provides a refund of both basic customs duty and GST. Once the GST regime stabilises, the sector will surely gain from this tax reform. TDB: In terms of a pro-trade FTP policy, what policy changes would help improve India’s export competitiveness? AS: A more focussed approach to international marketing is required. The fund available, under Market Access Initiative (MAI) Scheme, is insufficient. Moreover, no tax advantage has been given for marketing to exporters. This is a benefit that exporters from some developed countries get. There is also a need to create an Export Development Fund with a corpus of at least 0.5% of our exports. JANUARY 2018 II THE DOLLAR BUSINESS 19
Interview by Ahmad Shariq Khan
TDB: Are you satisfied with the FTP mid-term review? Ajay Sahai (AS): The mid-term review reassured the exports sector that intervention in the dynamic sector of international trade would be initiated as and when required without waiting for an annual or end-term correction. The review has taken a two-pronged approach – it focusses both on sunrise sectors of exports as well as on the employment-intensive traditional sectors. In line with that, the review provides additional incentives to sectors such as electronics, pharmaceuticals, medical and diagnostic equipment and high-technology sectors as well as leather, marine, food processing, sports goods, textiles, carpets and handicrafts. The policy statement to a large extent has identified the issues affecting exports and I am sure that corrective actions will be taken in the short, medium and long-term, depending on the nature of the issue.
COVER STORY
FTP 2015-2020 MID-TERM REVIEW
Exporters from sectors like electronics manufacturing also believe that the increase in MEIS rates will be helpful for the industry. “It is noteworthy that several components and products, which are of interest to electronics manufacturers, are covered under the revised MEIS rates,” says Rajoo Goel, Secretary General, ELCINA, an industry association of electronics hardware manufacturers. Further, it's not only the increase in MEIS rates that the exporters are excit-
ed about. Other policy changes are also a source of optimism for the community. D. K. Sareen, Executive Director, Electronics & Computer Software Export Promotion Council (ESC), says, “The recently announced review contains many policy incentives, particularly those that boost exports of electronics and services like healthcare, legal outsourcing, etc. The focus on finding new markets and new products as well as increasing India’s share in the traditional markets and
products is also noteworthy.” According to Sareen, steps such as increase in MEIS and SEIS incentive rates, focus on ‘ease of trading’ across borders, and additional annual incentive of Rs. 369 crore for telecom, electronic components, will definitely help in boosting exports from the country. The renewed focus of the government on agriculture-based products has also recieved acclaim. Former Indian Oilseeds and Produce Export Promotion
“WE WERE EXPECTING MORE THAN WHAT HAS BEEN OFFERED” RAKESH KUMAR, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, EXPORT PROMOTION COUNCIL FOR HANDICRAFTS (EPCH)
TDB: How will the increase in MEIS and other incentives affect exports from your industry? Are they sufficient? RK: Increase in reward rates under MEIS will result in increasing exports from MSMEs and labour-intensive industries including handicrafts which can be categorised as both MSME and labour-intensive. MEIS rates of 121 handicraft items have been increased. But we expected more than what has been offered to the handicrafts sector which is a major foreign exchange earning sector of the economy. TDB: The exports of handicrafts from India has declined over the last few months. Will exports from the sector achieve the desired growth in coming months? RK: As far as the exports of handicrafts during the April-November FY2018 period is concerned, exports has declined by over 9% y-o-y and stand at Rs.15,277 crore. We expect that with the complete transition of exporters into the GST regime 20 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
and the addressal of concerns of exporters by the government, the handicrafts sector will be able to achieve some growth by the end of this financial year. TDB: What challenges are the Indian handicrafts exporters facing after the GST implementation? Is the GST Council actively trying to address these issues? RK: GST has been the biggest taxation reform undertaken in the country since Independence. EPCH has made representations to the GST Council on various issues which affect the sector. The issues include the GST rate concessions on various handicrafts items, blockage of working capital funds, issues pertaining to stock in hand, utilisation of duty credit scrips, GST on trade fair participation, GST on foreign agency commission and freight charges paid by exporters, etc. The GST rates on handicrafts sector are being rationalised and are being given due consideration by the GST Council in its meetings. The other issues are also being addressed on a regular basis. TDB: What has been done to promote Indian handicrafts export and deepen engagements with new markets? RK: The concept of new markets and new products is of great importance to EPCH. Working in this direction, the markets of Latin America and CIS member states have been explored by organising various export promotion activities in these markets. Numerous common facility centres have been setup by EPCH at major craft clusters wherein technological and design development support is given to the exporters so as to develop handicraft items as per the designs, patterns and colours sought by overseas buyers.
Interview by Aamir H. Kaki
TDB: What is your take on the mid-term review of the FTP? Rakesh Kumar (RK): The mid-term review happened after the implementation of GST and the sector was expecting a relief from the government to offset the reduced duty drawback rates, increased GST rates and the blocking of working capital. The government has tried to compensate by enhancing the rate of duty credit scrip under MEIS by 2% but that is not quite enough. Other gains of the review are that the conditions of the pre-payment of IGST in Advance Authorisation Scheme and EPCG Scheme have been waived till March 31, 2018. Also, the GST rate for transfer/sale of scrips has been reduced to zero from the earlier 12%.
Council (IOPEPC) Chairman Sanjiv Sawla states, “We are happy to see that the government is now specifically focussing on exports of agri products. We are facing many challenges such as non-tariff barriers. Therefore, a strong agricultural trade policy will be of great benefit.”
AND THE BRICKBATS
Even with all the positives steps in the FTP mid-term review, in the wake of the subdued export market, many feel
that the review fell short on the expectations of the industry. Many believe that while short-term issues may have been addressed, painting all sectors with the same brush by enhancing rewards by 2% could mean that the government did not analyse sectoral problems. Being a representative of a sector which comprises mostly MSMEs, Magu says that the AEPC was expecting much more emphasis on their sector. “The sector was expecting enhanced duty draw-
back and rebate of state levies (RoSL) on account of many embedded and blocked taxes. The sector was also hoping for a phased-out approach towards policy support rationalisation, post-GST. But that didn't happen,” he adds. Amin from CLE also says that the leather industry was expecting a little more. “The enhanced scrip will be available for exports made from November 1, 2017 to June 30, 2018. This enhanced scrip should be made available for the
“WE ARE HAPPY TO SEE INCREASED FOCUS ON AGRI EXPORTS”
TDB: The mid-term review focusses on exports of agri products and the Council must be happy about that. Are there any areas of concern that need to be addressed? Sanjiv Sawla (SS): We are happy to see that the government wants to have a specific focus on exports of agri products. We are facing many challenges in the form of non-tariff barriers. Therefore, a strong agricultural trade policy will be of great benefit. The point is that what is being discussed should be implemented. We all need to work together to ensure that the policy implementation takes place. It needs to be done in the right spirit because the policy is made at the Centre but is implemented at the state level. Sometimes, the Centre and state are not in sync because of political motivations or other reasons. TDB: Outdated infrastructure and logistical issues affect every sector. Is the government doing enough in this respect? SS: When you talk about infrastructure, there are a lot of factors. Infrastructure cannot be developed overnight. That is something that the government is working on. For example, many times we see that at ports like Nhava Sheva, shipments take 3-4 days to enter the port because of logistics issues. Today, it costs much more to transport goods from New Delhi to Mumbai than to move cargo from Mumbai to New York or anywhere else in the world. It is a big challenge. Secondly, shipping companies tend to levy very high charges. This needs to be streamlined. Even though you are in India, they tend to quote you in dollars. You have to pay in rupees with an exchange rate that is even higher than the prevailing rate. However, the government is trying to streamline things with measures like e-sealing of containers, etc.
TDB: The FTP review talks about the importance of entering new markets. What needs to be done to promote exports and deepen engagements with new markets? SS: When you say new markets you have to remember that we are talking about Africa and large parts of Latin America. Going into markets that already have sufficient production is difficult. What we have to do is go into those markets where they have American and European suppliers, who are supplying high-end products. The challenge is that you have to take over their market share by being extremely competitive on price but at the same time offering the same quality that an American supplier is offering. This would give an incentive for buyers to shift to an Indian supplier. For that we need to have proper infrastructure in place where people are incentivised to produce absolutely top-notch products that can compete with products from any other country in the world. What happens though is that our products are sometimes not completely homogeneous. Also, we have problems of rejection when shipping to EU, which has ripple effects. The government should listen to the word of the exporter. Whenever we try to enter a new market and there is a problem, we are penalised. There is a huge disincentive to ship to countries in the EU. The mindset of the government needs to change with time regarding this. Because, if we are talking about agri policy, when it comes to the product there is going to be an occasional variation which should be accepted not only by our government but also by the overseas buyer. However, that does not give exporters the right to ship sub-par products. First impressions matter when entering a new market. JANUARY 2018 II THE DOLLAR BUSINESS 21
Interview by Anishaa Kumar
SANJIV SAWLA, FORMER CHAIRMAN, INDIAN OILSEEDS & PRODUCE EXPORT PROMOTION COUNCIL
COVER STORY
FTP 2015-2020 MID-TERM REVIEW
entire policy period, i.e. till 2020, as this is extremely important to reverse the current downtrend in exports and achieve the envisaged 10% growth in exports.” As far as textiles are concerned, Ujwal R. Lahoti, Chairman, TEXPROCIL, is of the opinion that while the review has increased incentives under the MEIS for some sectors, other sectors in need of attention have been overlooked.
“The sectors that have been excluded are cotton yarn and cotton fabrics. MEIS and interest equalisation schemes have not been extended to cotton yarn. This industry is struggling with issues like international prices not being in line with Indian prices, problems associated with price instability, etc. Therefore, there is a need to extend some kind of benefit to this sector,” says Lahoti. However, he is
hopeful that the government will reconsider these sectors in the coming days. While Goel from ELCINA welcomes the policy initiatives, he is not happy with the fact that many sector-specific challenges remain unattended. “While we welcome the additional 2% incentive under MEIS, the disabilities faced by Indian electronics manufacturers range from 8-10%, based on the level of value
“WE EXPECTED SOME ADDITIONAL INCENTIVES FOR EOUs” RAHUL SHUKLA, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR – INDIRECT TAX, PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS
TDB: The review introduced a new logistics policy. What are the areas that need to be focused on to reduce logistics cost? RS: There are many issues at play with regards to logistics. The Customs Act is being rewritten. There are also deliberations happening at the ministry level with the stakeholders and CBEC. A great idea is the concept of authorised economic operators (AEO) and our logistics operators can also given a similar status. However, the current benefits to AEOs like ease of obtaining warehouse licensing, bond waiver or reduction in transit bond norms, etc., are minimal. There are no significant advantages. Additional incentives must be looked into for this 22 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
scheme to succeed. For example, facility of E-wallet, lower or priority examination norms, faster transit clearances, priority amendment in Import General Manifest (IGM) and provisional release of goods, etc., can help. Increasing connectivity with infrastructure development, usage of IT tools and data analytics, and establishment of a single window logistics hub for users will also be a step in the right direction. TDB: Do you believe that the measures introduced in the FTP review will be successful in achieving the goals? Is the thinking of the government in sync with that of traders? RS: The revisions in Foreign Trade Policy 2015-2020 have recognised the need to go beyond taxes and incentives and look at trade facilitation and promotion as a whole in terms of processes, documentation, and support from state governments. We are hopeful that a positive trade partnership outlook is being adopted by the government. However, change takes time and requires continuous efforts. Significant procedural changes have been brought about since 2015 by the government and the shift is towards data analytics and smart tools. The government is committed to keep on working at improving ease of doing business and trade facilitation parameters within the country. Effects of the efforts are already visible in the “whole government” approach. Hopefully, the issues, as they arise, will be looked into constantly and resolved in partnership with trade and industry in a positive manner. There are bound to be challenges of mindset and practices which with commitment can always be overcome. The government as well as traders realise the need to be competitive in global trade, hence, a continuous partnership with proactive addressal of issues will help in achieving the goals that have been set.
Interview by Anishaa Kumar
TDB: The mid-term review was delayed to include solutions to post-GST grievances. How far have they been provided? Rahul Shukla (RS): In the review, they have tried to address GST issues by raising MEIS and SEIS rates. They have tried to address the drawback loss as people were concerned that the drop in drawback benefit after the implementation of GST was impacting exports. Further, drop in exports in October due to cash flow challenges and delayed refunds was an issue as well. Hopefully, with the incremental rates, benefit will now accrue to exporters including service exporters. It is expected to offset the challenges in refunds of GST and lower drawback rate. While EOUs have been given some procedural relief, we expected additional incentives for EOUs which have been contributing to exports significantly and have been on par with SEZs. Extension of SEIS benefit to STP units, as allowed to SEZ units, could have been looked into. Further, to address the cash flow issue, option of E-wallet for imports should be considered. However, in the short-term, retaining status quo for scrips under MEIS/SEIS, as was done in case of Advance Authorisation and EPCG, would have been helpful, especially for exporters who rely on post-export benefits.
addition. To restore our export competitiveness, MEIS should be in the range of 5-9%, with 5% for finished products and PCB assemblies and 7-9% for components and semiconductors,” says Goel. Having that said, Goel believes that incentive is just one way of supporting exports. The government needs to work on creating a conducive ecosystem for exporters. There are bottlenecks, in terms
of infrastructure, shipping delays, erratic power supply, archaic labour laws, etc, which act as a drag on Indian exports. "These are the areas that require more government attention,” adds Goel. Ecohing similar sentiments, Sareen of ESC India says, “Regarding services exports, such as software and solutions, the facilities extended are skewed. For instance, only units located in SEZs can
avail the zero-rating of GST for supplies. This should be extended to all units, irrespective of their location, since setting up units in SEZs is costlier in terms of rentals and other costs.” Dr. Vinay Sharma, Officiating Chairman, Export Promotion Council for EOUs & SEZs (EPCES), believes that the changes in the review are cosmetic. “In many ways, the changes introduced this
“FTP REVIEW HAS NOT REALLY SOLVED ANY ISSUE ARISING DUE TO GST” UJWAL R. LAHOTI, CHAIRMAN, TEXPROXCIL
TDB: Has the FTP review been able to tackle problems that are procedural in nature like those arising out of GST? URL: GST is definitely beneficial in the long-run. However, there have been many operational problems and financial obstacles for exporters since its implementation. The FTP review
has not really solved any of the issues. Overall, we understand that the government has started looking into solving issues but we need faster resolution. Many exporters have still not gotten refunds of GST paid in the month of July. TDB: In the review, the focus is on exploring new markets. What needs to be done to promote textile exports in new and untapped markets? URL: The textile sector is trying to increase efforts to reach new markets such as Africa and Latin America. Exporters are working very hard to get more orders from these countries, but the competitiveness of Indian products is lacking in terms of price stability, quality, etc., when it comes to making inroads into these markets. The Textile Upgradation Fund Scheme (TUFS) has been introduced by the government. Many exporters have put in investments under TUFS, but due to technological issues many of them are not getting the benefits which were promised in the policy. This issue requires immediate attention. When it comes to raw material, we would like a policy change such that the Indian cotton prices can be brought in line with the international cotton prices. As our prices are volatile, it is hard for exporters to be competitive. TDB: The policy review also talks about increased focus on digitisation. According to you, how important is digitisation and what is the Council doing in this regard? URL: The increase in digitisation is definitely in favour of exporters. This helps in increasing awareness and helps all exporters get the same and correct benefits. Of course, there are many people who are not aware of the skill development schemes being offered by the government towards digitisation, but the Council is helping in creating awareness. JANUARY 2018 II THE DOLLAR BUSINESS 23
Interview by Anishaa Kumar
TDB: What is your take on the recently released FTP midterm review? Are the incentives provided in the FTP review in line with the industry’s expectations? Ujwal R. Lahoti (URL): As far as the textile industry is concerned, the government has increased incentives under MEIS for most sectors which will no doubt be useful in increasing exports, but some sectors have been overlooked and they require immediate attention. We are expecting reconsideration of benefits for some sectors. The overlooked sectors are cotton yarn and cotton fabrics. MEIS and interest equalisation schemes have not been extended to cotton yarn. This sector is plagued by several issues such as international prices not being in line with Indian prices, problems associated with instability, etc. Therefore, there is a need to extend some kind of benefit to this sector. Similarly, the cotton fabrics sector also deserves some benefits in line with those enjoyed by the home textiles and the garment industry. These sectors should be given the benefit of refund of state levies the way it's provided to the garments sector and should be incentivised under MEIS at the same rate. This will help the industry get on track and increase exports. We have already flagged this issue and are hopeful that the government will reconsider this in the coming days. Of course, whatever benefits are given, they are welcome and we expect them to definitely boost exports. But some of the issues which were not addressed, if they are looked into, then the cotton industry will definitely benefit.
COVER STORY
FTP 2015-2020 MID-TERM REVIEW
time are good for our sector – that’s my honest opinion. However, I must add, structural loopholes continue to plague the sector. We need to do more than just fix a few issues here and there. Definitely, the sector was expecting more,” he says.
SURPRISING ABSENCE
Talking about disappointments, the most striking part about the mid-term review of the FTP is the silence on the export target. The FTP 2015-20, when released on April 1, 2015, had set an ambitious target of doubling the country’s exports of goods and services from $465 billion to $900 billion by 2020, and also talked about enhancing India’s exports share in global trade to 3.5% from 2%. However, things did not go as planned due to a combination of factors such as global slowdown and commodity price fluctuations that ensured India was nowhere close to meeting that ambitious target. Taking in consideration the trends since then, it seems India may not even retain its 2% share in the global trade.
INDIA NEEDS TO WEAN EXPORTERS FROM REWARDS AND FOCUS ON INFRASTRUCTURE
No doubt, since CY2012 world trade has grown at an annual rate of just 3.1%. But then, India’s continuous under-performance cannot be attributed only to the global slowdown. While India's share in global merchandise exports declined in CY2015 and CY2016, exports from competing countries like China, Bangladesh and Vietnam edged up. And that's not a good sign at all! India’s merchandise exports had recorded an anaemic y-o-y growth of 4.7% in FY2017. According to Reserve Bank of India (RBI), India’s merchandise exports having reached a record 17% of the GDP in FY2014 fell to nearly 12% in FY2017, the lowest share since FY2006. Even within sectors, which are dominated by MSMEs, the numbers do not bode well. India has less than 5% share in global textile exports, and a mere 2% in apparel as compared to China, which has 33% and 38% share, respectively. In fact, India’s total of around $13 billion in the global $450-billion garments exports is lower that even Vietnam and Bangladesh, let alone China. Looking at the ongoing trends, it seems impossible for India to reach the goal of $900 billion in exports by FY2020. So, is there any new target the government is looking for? The purpose of any review exercise should be to set new goals, but the recently released FTP review document is silent on that. Clarifying the
The FTP 2015-2020, when released on April 1, 2015, had set an ambitious target of doubling the country’s exports of goods and services from $465 billion to $900 billion by 2020. 24 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
absence, Commerce Minister Suresh Prabhu indicated in his speech that the government is not working towards any target. “This is a strategy paper, not necessarily spelling out the quantity of foreign trade we will achieve because strategy would result in quantity,” he said. However, Sahai is optimistic about the target. “The target of $900 billion was fixed assuming a certain growth rate in global trade. Unfortunately, global trade has been subdued since FY2012. This has adversely impacted our exports as well. I have always maintained that Indian exports are more tuned to the growth in global trade than any other factor. However, the forecast for FY2018 is much better. We should look at doubling our exports by 2022 so as to take it to about $900-1,000 billion,” he says.
THE WTO FACTOR
While exporters may be optimistic about growth in the shorter term, sustainable growth cannot happen if we keep riding on the coattails of incentives and subsidies. And the sooner we understand that the better, because export subsidies will need to be phased out. According to the WTO Subsidies and Countervailing Measures (SCM) Agreement, a member is no longer eligible to give export subsidies if its per capita gross national income (GNI) crosses the threshold of $1,000 consecutively for three years. The WTO Secretariat’s most recent calculations revealed that India’s per capita GNP has been above $1,000 for the three consecutive years – CY2013, CY2014 and CY2015. This means that India will technically not be eligible for any more flexibilities and be prohibited from giving export subsidies. However, the agreement also provides that the prohibition on export subsidies was not to apply to advanced developing countries “for a period of eight years from the date of entry into force of the WTO Agreement.” In this regard, some members, including India, have argued (and have submitted a corresponding negotiating proposal) that graduating members be given an additional eightyear transition period, and then the right to seek further extensions pursuant to SCM Agreement. If India has to dis-
“INCREASE IN MEIS INCENTIVES WILL BE EXTREMELY BENEFICIAL” MUKHTARUL AMIN, CHAIRMAN, COUNCIL FOR LEATHER EXPORTS (CLE)
TDB: Has the FTP review been able to effectively resolve the issues rising out of the implementation of the GST such as the blockage of working capital? MA: Prior to GST, the leather and footwear industry was able to avail benefits like Central Excise exemption for production units with up to Rs.1.5 crore in turnover, Service Tax exemption for CETPs (Combined Effluent Treatment Plants), job work units, etc., which are now not available under GST. Further, CETPs and job work for procuring leather products and footwear are now subject to 18% GST. CLE has submitted representations to the government to reduce this to 5%. The leather industry is grateful that the government recently reduced GST rates of several leather items. The rate cut on finished leather and composition leather from 12% to 5%, and on leather goods, leather garments and leather chemicals from 28% to 18% will benefit exporters tremendously.
Working capital blockage on account of requirement of payment of GST and delays in refunds are still major concerns. More than 80% of the industry is concentrated in the MSME segment and hence are unable to generate the huge requirement of funds for GST payment. An announcement has been made in the mid-term review of FTP about the implementation of the E-wallet scheme, which I hope will eliminate upfront payment of GST. TDB: What policy measures will help promote and increase the scope of MSMEs? MA: The Union Cabinet recently approved a special package for leather and footwear sectors. The package involves implementation of Central Sector Scheme – Indian Footwear, Leather and Accessories Development Programme (ILDP) – with an approved expenditure of Rs.2,600 crore between FY2018 and FY2020. The major objective of ILDP is to augment raw material base, enhance capacity, modernisation and up-gradation of leather units, address environmental concerns, human resource development, support to traditional leather artisans, address infrastructure constraints and establish institutional facilities. ILDP consists of six sub-schemes namely: Human Resource Development (HRD); Mega Leather Cluster; Integrated Development of Leather Sector (IDLS); Leather Technology, Innovation & Environmental Issues; Establishment of Institutional Facilities; Support to Artisan. The scheme will play a crucial role in achieving sustainable growth in the leather and footwear sector and will immensely benefit the MSMEs. TDB: Logistics sector has received a special focus in this review. What, according to you, are areas that the government needs to focus on to achieve logistics operational excellence? MA: A major initiative by the government has been the development of International North South Transport Corridor (INSTC), which provides an alternate and shorter route for shipments to Russia and other CIS countries. This is a project which will help in increasing our exports to these regions. There is currently a need to further develop the port and airport infrastructure and road connectivity in India in order to enable faster transport of export/import cargo. Buyers now expect delivery at short notice and hence for India, developing logistics is very important. We also need to have direct shipment facilities to the Far-East in order to help reduce the time taken for product delivery and to help lower the shipment charges to Europe as the charges from China are lower when compared to the charges from Indian shores. JANUARY 2018 II THE DOLLAR BUSINESS 25
Interview by Anishaa Kumar
TDB: Has the review met your industry’s expectations? Mukhtarul Amin (MA): CLE has been requesting the government to enhance the rate of reward under MEIS, in order to increase price competitiveness and boost exports from the sector which, at the moment, is facing intense global competition. As far as the review is concerned, a major announcement made for the leather sector was an across-the-board increase of 2% in MEIS reward rates. However, this enhanced scrip will be available for exports made from November 1, 2017 to June 30, 2018. It is our request that this enhanced rate should be made available for the entire policy period, i.e. till 2020, as this is extremely important to reduce the current downtrend in exports and achieve the envisaged 10% growth in exports. As the leather and footwear sectors are fashion and consumer-oriented, there is a need for continuous innovation leading to the creation of new products. For this, the industry is required to procure many critical inputs and components, for which the MEIS scrip is very useful. Increase of MEIS scrip value will help in increasing price competitiveness of the sector. But here again, procurement under MEIS should be exempted from Goods and Services Tax (GST). Additionally, the new trust-based, self-ratification scheme introduced to allow duty-free inputs for export production under duty exemption schemes with a self-declaration will also reduce the transaction costs for exporters. The mid-term review document also mentions an increase in the validity period of duty scrips (including MEIS) to 24 months and implementation of the E-wallet scheme from April 1, 2018, which will eliminate upfront payment of GST. These are welcome steps.
COVER STORY
FTP 2015-2020 MID-TERM REVIEW
continue the export promotion schemes such as MEIS, SEIS, Advance Authorisation and EPCG, it should look at phasing them out eventually while simultaneously replacing them with WTO compatible, aternative schemes. Clarifying WTO's rules, Sahai says, “The special and differential treatment available under Annex-VII will no longer be available to us. However, this is something which we should not regret as we are on our course to become a developed economy. Moreover, even after graduating out of the threshold limit so as to continue with a subsidy, WTO does allow countries to give subsidies for R&D, adhering to the environmental norms
and promoting backward areas.” Let us keep in mind that most subsidies have been provided to do away with the cost disability factor. The high cost of credit, high logistics cost, increasing transaction cost, infrastructure inadequacies, adversely affects India's exporters. The subsidy given by the government to some extent offset these losses. "If the government is in a position to address these challenges in medium-term, Indian exports may not require any subsidy,” adds Sahai. He believes that it will work in everyone's favour if the government starts distancing exporters from rewards and work towards structural reforms to create a conducive business environment.
AN ONGOING EFFORT
The FTP 2015-2020 review was refreshing to the extent that it has acknowledged that the major hurdles to India’s competitiveness were domestic, like infrastructure bottlenecks, complex procedures, high logistics costs, etc. The government has said that it will adopt a ‘whole of government’ approach to deal with these issues. In fact, measures that have been taken by the government to address these issues, like setting up of a logistics division, a National Trade Facilitation Committee under the Cabinet Secretary, formulating a National Trade Facilitation Action Plan, and launch of a Trade Infrastructure for Export Scheme (TIES) are
“TRUST-BASED CERTIFICATION IS A BIG STEP IN THE RIGHT DIRECTION” H. K. L. MAGU, CHAIRMAN, APPAREL EXPORT PROMOTION COUNCIL (AEPC)
TDB: Would you say that the mid-term review has addressed most concerns raised by exporters ? HKLM: I believe that the mid-term review of FTP has covered many issues like enhancement of MEIS, increased validity of scrips, zero duty on scrips, 24x7 facility to more seaports, no norms fixation, etc. These steps will positively impact the industry. However, enhanced duty drawback, RoSL and wider usage of MEIS scrips are the need of the hour to boost exports and increase India’s competitiveness in international markets. The trust-based certification is a big step forward and I hope this is the start of a new era in ease of doing business. TDB: India is nearing the WTO threshold which would require it to end direct subsidies on exports. Subsequently, schemes such as the MEIS, EPCG and interest equalisation scheme, as envisioned under the FTP, are likely to get im26 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
pacted. How do you plan to safeguard your sector’s interests? HKLM: We have already submitted a proposal to the government regarding alternative schemes that can be implemented after the phase-out of subsidies. Both Drawback and RoSL are WTO compatible schemes. Therefore, enhanced drawback and RoSL will surely help the industry to retain the positive growth. TDB: While the government’s focus is on MSMEs and assisting the Make in India campaign, it however, did not accept garments exporters’ demand for measures to improve market access and cost competitiveness. Your comments. HKLM: The garment industry was expecting enhanced duty drawback and RoSL. It was hoping for a phased-out approach towards policy support rationalisation, post-GST. The sudden reduction in drawback and other support has detrimentally impacted business planning and order book positions. TDB: In a recent meeting with the Chief Economic Advisor Dr. Arvind Subramanian, AEPC had expressed concerns over decline in apparel exports due to capital blockage and a sharp reduction in drawback rates post GST. Has any solution been proposed in the review? HKLM: Yes, the Council has been proposing various alternatives for easing the problems being faced due to capital blockage and sudden reduction in drawback rates. We are hopeful of a positive response in this matter.
Interview by Ahmad Shariq Khan
TDB: What are your initial thoughts on the FTP mid-term review document? H. K. L. Magu (HKLM): The increase in the MEIS rates has been a positive step. Besides this, the other critical areas that the FTP review has dealt with is trade facilitation and easing capital blockage. However, exporters presently need a level playing field while competing with other countries. The postGST dilution of duty drawbacks and FTP benefits needs to be looked into urgently.
welcome steps too. However, all these initiatives need to be implemented at a faster pace than they are presently being actualised. It is probably time for the 'whole of government' to look at the 'whole of exports'. As emphasised in the review document, identifying new markets and products is vital for the growth of exports but with sharp competition in the global market, the emphasis should be on improving competitiveness and that will take long and sustained effort on part of both exporters and the government. Even the Commerce Minister in his statement said, “It is not a one-time exercise but an ongoing effort. We will continuously
revisit issues, identify challenges and address them on a real-time basis.” No doubt, policy review is an ongoing process and the industry too is of the opinion that the government needs to take continuous measures and introduce new initiatives without waiting for a year or mid-term correction in order to bring about long-term impactful change. One question that however remains is, will the tweaks in policy and enhancement in rewards be able to boost India's exports? The answer is: Perhaps yes. If nothing, the mid-term review has come at a time when prospects for world trade are starting to brighten. In September 2017, the WTO upgraded
its trade growth projection to 3.6% from the earlier estimate of 2.4%. Though the estimate for 2018 has been pegged a little lower at 3.2%, it is still higher when compared to the stagnant growth of the last few years. In this scenario, India is in a better position to take benefit of the measures announced in the mid-term review than it was in 2015, when the FTP was released. Reality suggests that India has not utilised the breathing space (in the form of lowered trade activity) the global slowdown provided to set the framework right. Perhaps we as a nation are at our best when the heat is on. At least we hope that's the case.
“REWARD RATES UNDER MEIS SHOULD BE IN THE RANGE OF 5-9%” RAJOO GOEL, SECRETARY GENERAL, ELCINA
TDB: Is an increase of 2% in rewards under MEIS enough to make our electronics manufacturing industry competitive
in the global markets? RG: While we welcome the increase of 2% incentive under the Merchandise Exports from India Scheme (MEIS), the disabilities faced by Indian electronics manufacturers range from 8-10%, based on the level of value addition. Thus, to restore our export competitiveness, the MEIS should be in the range of 5-9% with 5% for finished products and PCB assemblies and 7-9% for components and semiconductors. TDB: Exports of electronics would need to grow significantly to realise the overall growth targets. What needs to be done to improve the sector's export competitiveness? RG: In response to the increase in BCD on eight electronic items of mass consumption, the industry must rise to the occasion by not succumbing to the temptation of raising domestic prices of these products and instead invest in additional manufacturing capacities to increase local value addition and become globally competitive. In the process, even as we engage more deeply with global electronics supply chains, the caveat is that we need to guard against the existing FTAs from being misused to evade the increased BCD and import these product lines as finished products. This challenge exists especially in case of set top boxes, which are included in the ASEAN FTA. Due to this threat from FTAs, the electronics industry has made a strong plea to exclude electronics from the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP). JANUARY 2018 II THE DOLLAR BUSINESS 27
Interview by Aamir H. Kaki
TDB: What is your take on the recently released review? Rajoo Goel (RG): It is noteworthy that most components and products which are of interest to electronics manufacturers are covered under the revised MEIS rates. ELCINA believes that this is an overdue and positive step as it will largely reverse the damage caused by the reduction of MEIS rates across the board. Another positive is the focus on MSMEs and manufacturing. This is important as benefits should accrue to value-added manufacturers. The industry is also enthused by measures which will release blocked working capital and reduce costs. India’s FTP is geared towards promoting exports very aggressively with a target of $900 billion by 2020 and there was a need to support manufacturing with a focus on MSME and labour-intensive sectors. The FTP review has also taken several measures to simplify procedures for exporters. Some other industry-friendly changes include zero rating under GST of supplies of goods and services to SEZs, import of second-hand goods for repair/refurbishing/re-conditioning/ re-engineering being made free, making the transfer and sale of duty scrips effectively GST exempt, round-the-clock customs clearance facility being extended to 19 seaports and 17 air cargo complexes and self-declaration of duty free inputs for export production under duty free exemption scheme.
OVERSEAS TALK
H.E. VITALY A. PRIMA, AMBASSADOR OF BELARUS TO INDIA
“CONSIDER BELARUS A RELIABLE PARTNER” Despite having strategic synergies, bilateral trade between India and Belarus hasn’t reached its potential. The Dollar Business caught up with H.E. Vitaly A. Prima, Ambassador of the Republic of Belarus to India, to understand the opportunities that the two countries can leverage on to strengthen the bilateral relations. INTERVIEW BY NILADRI S. NATH
TDB: How would you describe the socio-economic relationship between Belarus and India? H.E. Vitaly A. Prima (VAP): India and Belarus share a cordial relationship based on mutual trust and support. The state visit of the President of the Republic of Belarus to India, in September 2017, has strengthened our ties. During the visit, Belarusian and Indian companies signed a number of mutually beneficial contracts and memorandums of understandings (MoUs). I believe that this strong bond will positively influence the dynamics of bilateral trade. I also believe that a close relationship between India and Belarus will generate benefits not only in areas of trade and economy, but also in areas like science & technology and culture & tourism. TDB: Despite close relations, bilateral trade remains modest. What opportunities remain untapped? VAP: Belarus-India trade and economic cooperation is progressing steadily. Bilateral trade turnover rose to $445.5 million in CY2015 from $55.4 million in CY2000. However, in CY2016, there was a slight decrease in trade, in value terms ($402.2 million), due to a fall in prices. 28 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
This year, exports from Belarus to India comprised 97 commodities which included potash fertilisers as well as other chemical and petrochemical products. Meanwhile, exports from India to Belarus are mainly pharmaceuticals, agricultural & chemical products and light industrial products. The decrease in bilateral trade in CY2016 was a temporary phenomenon. Trade partners on both sides will definitely find ways to overcome the setback. Having said that, I agree that we are yet to leverage trade opportunities to the fullest. Large-scale diversification of exports from Belarus can be achieved by focussing on the export of unique technologies and products. We hope there will be an increase in supplies of potash fertilisers, industrial and technological equipment and petrochemical products to India. Belarus is also willing to purchase high-quality pharmaceuticals, chemical products and other goods from India. Belarus, as a matter of fact, possesses an advantageous geographical position, developed infrastructure and highly skilled manpower that India can benefit from. Our membership of the Eurasian Economic Union (EEU) also opens up avenues for
Indian investors and traders. TDB: What facilities does Belarus offer India investors? VAP: Belarus offers a globally-acknowledged favourable investment climate. In the World Bank Doing Business 2017 Report, Belarus ranks 37 (out of 190). In Belarus, there are six free economic zones (FEZs) with special tax and customs duty exemptions. The companies setting up units in the free economic zones will get exemption from tax for five years from the year they turn profitable. Once the exemption period is over, the companies can pay profit tax at a reduced rate of 50%. In addition, companies having units in FEZs will be exempt from paying property tax on buildings and facilities. We assure you that the Belarusian government will provide all possible assistance to companies from other countries with specific and detailed business plans. Recently, we have proposed, to the Government of India, a Belarus-India investment cluster of innovations in the free economic zone at Vitebsk. Our government is interested in developing world-class drug manufacturing facilities there. We also aim to create modern enterprises to attract knowledge and investments from India. TDB: Recently, Belarus and India signed 10 agreements to expand cooperation. Please give us more insight into those agreements? VAP: During the President of Belarus’ recent visit to India, about 10 inter-governmental agreements and MoUs were signed. They cover areas like science and technology, education, agriculture, etc. In addition, a number of commercial agreements and memorandums of intentions for joint-development and manufacturing in oil and gas, defence, tourism, pharmaceuticals, etc., have also been signed. These MoUs will help create the necessary framework for Belarus-India engagements. Alongside, a trial batch of Belarusian harvesters and heavy-duty trucks of different cargo carrying capacities will be exported to India. We hope to see a new wave of cooperation leveraging the Belarusian tractor brand, Belarus.
contribute to the further development of trade and economic cooperation between India and EEU members. The FTA with EEU will facilitate free movement of goods, services, capital and labour as well as pursue a harmonised and unified policy in the sectors determined by the treaty and international agreements within the Union. Nowadays, every country needs to diversify into new markets and EEU will give India opportunities for profitable placement of capital and seamless supply of manufactured goods to the vast market of the five-member states – Armenia, Belarus, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan and Russia – with a trade potential of up to $62 billion and a large number of consumers.
BILATERAL TRADE JUMPED TO $445.5 MILLION IN CY2015 FROM $55.4 MILLION IN CY2000 Moreover, Belarus is keen to contribute to the Skill India initiative. We believe that the extensive experience Belarus has will be instrumental in supporting various initiatives of the Indian government in reducing unemployment and upskilling workers. We are working on several projects to open Centres of Excellence in several states in India for some cutting-edge industries. MoUs have also been signed between the Belarusian State Concern of Oil and Chemistry and the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas of the Government of India, which will facilitate setting up large-scale collaborative projects. Belarus is ready to offer Indian compa-
nies the most advanced technologies for oil enhancement. The MoU signed between Belarus and India’s NBCC, opens broad prospects for mutually-beneficial cooperation and engagement in infrastructure projects in Belarus and India, as well as in other countries. The cooperation in defence sector has been initiated through the Joint Belarusian-Indian Commission on Military-Technical Cooperation. We also have regular exchange of delegations in specialised exhibitions like MILEX and DEFEXPO. Such exhibitions not only maintain a constant exchange of information, but also open up opportunities for new areas of interaction. TDB: India is currently negotiating a free trade agreement (FTA) with EEU. What kind of trade potential does the FTA hold for India and Belarus ? VAP: We welcome the progress in the preparation of the draft FTA between the Eurasian Economic Union (EEU) and India. The agreement is intended to
TDB: Together, both countries are considering a technology demonstration centre to showcase Belarusian technology. What’s the latest on that front? VAP: In cooperation with the Department of Science and Technology and the International Advanced Research Centre for Powder Metallurgy and New Materials (ARCI), we are creating a technology demonstration centre in Hyderabad where Belarus will showcase its latest technologies. The selection of technologies is based on the demand of the Indian businesses and is aimed at giving them the necessary edge in the highly-competitive domestic and international markets. We expect details of this project to be finalised this year. The project is likely to materialise soon. TDB: What would you like to convey to Indian policymakers and companies? VAP: Indian policymakers are doing a great job by creating an extremely attractive environment in India for businesses from all across the world. We appreciate the thoughtful and constructive attitude of the government and private bodies. There are close links between the Belarusian Chamber of Commerce and Industry and the Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce & Industry (FICCI). We want Indian companies to be more active and aggressive in promoting innovative ideas and projects in Belarus. They should consider us a reliable partner and friend. JANUARY 2018 II THE DOLLAR BUSINESS 29
EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW
ANIL K. TRIGUNAYAT, FMR. AMBASSADOR OF INDIA TO JORDAN, LIBYA & MALTA
“WE NEED TO GROW AT 8-9% TO MAINTAIN THE EDGE”
He has served as an Ambassador of India to Jordan, Libya and Malta and is currently on the advisory boards of BRICS Chamber of Commerce and IndoLatin American Chamber of Commerce. In a freewheeling interaction with The Dollar Business, Anil Kumar Trigunayat talks about the possible trade impacts of the conflicts in the Middle East on India apart from discussing the opportunities that exists in the region for the Indian EXIM community. INTERVIEW BY AHMAD SHARIQ KHAN
TDB: India has had friendly relations with Qatar as well as the GCC countries that have imposed a blockade on Qatar. Do you envision the blockade hampering India-GCC trade? Anil Kumar Trigunayat (AKT): Gulf countries are part of our extended neighbourhood and are extremely important for our energy security. Our relationship with Qatar is specially important because Qatar fulfils a major part of India’s LNG requirements. We have a large Indian diaspora in the region and their welfare is also important to us. These countries are also a significant source of foreign exchange remittances. It is estimated that almost eight million Indians in the GCC remit over $35 billion annually. The Middle Eastern countries are also important trading partners and India has had excellent bilateral relations with all of them. The recent blockade of Qatar by Saudi Arabia, UAE and Bahrain is very unfortunate. Extremism and support for it directly or indirectly by various regimes in the region through non-State actors have often been talked about and referred to in international discourses and is a real 30 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
threat. But the blockade may not solve the problem. All regimes in the region, while pursuing their own interests, are also overtly committed to fighting terrorism. Hopefully, in the near future, the international community will be able to do something to provide guidance and clarity on the road ahead. GCC and other Middle Eastern countries are our key trading partners, and both our trade and investments have been on the upswing in this region. Currently, there are dozens of Indian companies that have expanded their footprints in Qatar and other countries. Although the difficult situation in the region combined with low petroleum prices may depress the demand for products and services in these countries in the short run, the scenario would not be India specific. TDB: As a spillover of the blockade, what newer challenges do you foresee for Indian businesses in Qatar? AKT: Many major Indian companies have undertaken several crucial turnkey projects in Qatar as well as other GCC countries and are well entrenched there. However, to hedge against the unstable situation, it is imperative for Indian companies that have acquired adequate expertise in doing business in the Arab world to also explore markets beyond GCC. For example, Jordan has a number of free trade agreements (FTAs), including FTAs with US, EU, Greater Arab Free Trade Area (GAFTA), and Indian companies should explore export opportunities in markets like Jordan. The textile sector has been aggressively seeking newer markets in the Middle-East, and other sectors should also follow suit. Soon, we will see massive reconstruction efforts in war-ravaged Iraq and Syria and it is the right time for Indian businesses to position themselves strategically to make the most of this opportunity. TDB: What opportunities does the MENA region offer our exporters? AKT: The Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region is our major trade and transit partner. It is also a region in flux. The governments of these countries have begun to understand the limitations of a hydrocarbon-driven economy
and as such are rapidly diversifying their economies. This is where Indian firms can join hands with these regimes with a long-term perspective. Renewable energy holds great potential for collaboration and so does information technology. Country-to-country collaborations, especially in the agricultural sector, too have immense potential. I believe, the traditional buyer-seller relationship has to be converted into a long-term strategic partnership. GCC and Middle Eastern companies can also diversify their investments portfolios to cater to India’s infrastructure development. TDB: Was India ready for reforms like GST and demonetisation at the time of implementation? AKT: The far-reaching economic reforms introduced by Prime Minister Narendra Modi will have a lasting impact in the long run. When and how to introduce reforms is the prerogative of the government and depends on several factors. In some cases, one has to take the bull by the horns and that is exactly what the government did. Evidently, these reforms caused some pains but that is true for all evolutionary policies. India is one of the fastest growing major economies in the world. Even though there has been some deceleration in GDP numbers of late, our fundamentals are strong. One should not judge the impact of such far-reaching reforms by looking at data for just a few quarters. I am quite confident that once the structural infirmities are rectified, the economy will bounce back. Going forward, we have to grow at 8-9% per annum to maintain the edge and to provide for our billion plus population. I believe both GST and demonetisation were good policy decisions, but the implementation could have been better and smoother to avoid the disruption and discomfort caused to ordinary people and businesses. TDB: What is your take on schemes like ‘Make in India’ and ‘Digital India’? AKT: These government schemes are ambitious and are aimed at harnessing India’s potential to its maximum. Every year, over 12 million graduates join the Indian workforce and both these
INDIA NEEDS TO MOVE FURTHER UP THE LADDER IN THE EASE OF DOING BUSINESS RANKING schemes can help generate employment. ‘Digital India’ will give a boost to the services sector which is currently integral to the well being of our economy. It will also certainly contribute in bringing an attitudinal change in the mindset of the public. The manufacturing and agriculture sectors are the real job providers. And this is where iconic schemes like ‘Make in India’ can help create employment for the masses. I think the success and efficacy of ‘Make in India’, both in terms of employment and manufacturing growth, can only be judged after a few years as the gestation period in manufacturing is long. However, the concerned government departments and agencies should keep reviewing the schemes after taking feedback from the ground and tweak them to make them more efficient. TDB: India’s ease of doing business rank has gone up significantly this year. Do these ranks matter when it comes to attracting foreign direct investments and increasing exports? AKT: India is an economic powerhouse and an engine for global growth – there is no doubting that. Since the economic reforms in 1991, India has evolved a lot and the perception about the Indian market has also changed. Today, the world perceives India as a huge consumer market, a reliable sourcing destination and a behemoth when it comes to IT services and talent. But, to attract investments we need to maintain our edge at all times as many countries are vying for the same limited pool of FDI. Policies and their implementation have to be smooth and transparent. We have come a long way from the red-tapism of the past, but we can definitely do much better. I believe that while our ease of doing business ranking has improved significantly, we need to go further up the ladder in this competitive global economy. JANUARY 2018 II THE DOLLAR BUSINESS 31
IMPORT’ONOMICS
CASSIA (BARK)
SPICY BUSINESS, SWEET STORY Cassia, a pungent spice used in many cuisines, has seen a surge in its imports over the last few years. The facts that it is cheaper than cinnamon, a similar spice, and that more and more consumables are using cassia as an ingredient are only driving the demand for the spice forward. Despite controversies surrounding its usage in certain medicaments, it continues to be a favourite amongst India’s spice importers. BY ANISHAA KUMAR
F
rom turmeric to cinnamon, from cumin to fennel, India is known the world over for its spices that find use across cuisines as well as several home remedies. Surprisingly, despite its ubiquitous presence in almost all Indian households, cassia, better known as taj in India, is hardly grown in India and is almost entirely imported. Cassia, whose bark is used as a spice, is many a time mistaken for the cinnamon bark. The two spices are however derived from two different plants of the same genus. With their similar appearance, you may ask what is in a name? Well, there is a lot that differentiates the two. While cinnamon, (often referred to as Ceylon Cinnamon) found in Sri Lanka, is derived from the branches or bark of Cinnamomum Zeylanicum, cassia is derived from the bark of Cinnamomum 32 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
Cassia. Cassia is also known as Chinese, Vietnamese or Indonesian Cinnamon, depending on its origin. The other difference is that cassia is more pungent and preferred in Indian curries and bakery items. Cinnamon, on the other hand, has both a sweeter taste and aroma than its cousin. Cinnamon finds use in several desserts as well as
pharmaceutical products. Another difference between the two is the controversial coumarin content. Coumarin, according to Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI), is a natural flavouring compound whose high dose is believed to be harmful. While cinnamon or ‘Ceylon Cinnamon’, contains little to no trace of coumarin, cassia contains high doses of the same. Despite health concerns being raised, there is still a large demand for cassia. So, what makes the product popular in the market and does the increasing demand make importing it a lucrative business?
IT’S GETTING SPICIER
Cassia is many a times mistaken for cinnamon as they look very similar.
Globalisation has meant that there is much more intermingling of cultures now than in the past and that has meant that people are more open to trying rec-
India’s sourcing destinations
Almost all of it is coming from Vietnam
World’s biggest importers of cassia
India boast of a 30% share in world imports
Profit estimates for cassia (bark) imports
Though import volumes are high, margin in this business is usually low 1%
4%
10%
4%
Vietnam China Indonesia Madagascar
85%
Source: TDB Intelligence Unit & Ministry of Commerce, GoI; break-up for FY2017; HS code: 09061910
ipes from other countries. That has in tandem meant that import of spices has increased across the globe. According to a study by P&S Market Research, the global demand for seasonings and spices is expected to grow at a CAGR of 4.9% between FY2015 and FY2020. The imports of cassia by India has also kept pace with the global trend and grown by almost 110.3% to $45.32 million between FY2012 and FY2017. The volume of cassia imported by India has also increased by 20.07% during the same period. Even when it comes to the total world imports of cassia, imports by volume has increased by over 80% between CY2012 and CY2016. Some big numbers, indeed! Talking about the reasons behind the increase in imports, Prashant Sethi of Jaipur-based August Industries, an importer of cassia, says, “There is a bit of cassia being grown in India in the southern part of the country, but the production is not enough to fulfil the growing domestic demand. As the usage increases, we expect imports to grow further.” Cassia, according to some, has also benefitted from the confusion between cinnamon and cassia. Cinnamon is used in a variety of ayurvedic preparations to lower blood pressure and control cholesterol. But the cinnamon being referred to here is Ceylon Cinnamon and not cassia. The low price of cassia and the lack of awareness about the difference between both spices has allowed some unscrupulous manufacturers to substitute cinnamon by cassia in ayurvedic products. In reality, while cassia finds use in cooking and baking, it does not possess the
India US Bangladesh Japan Other
41%
31%
9% 15%
Source: TDB Intelligence Unit & UN Comtrade; break-up for CY2016; HS code: 09061910
healing properties that are characteristic of cinnamon. As smaller quantities of cassia are used in cooking, the harmful effects of coumarin are not an issue. Cassia and cinnamon have long been under the watch of the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI). In fact, in November 2016, FSSAI released a document highlighting the differences between the two to avoid the confusion amongst their users. According to the document, to be classified as cinnamon the coumarin content should not be more than 0.3% by weight.
Cost ($/MT)* 1,700.0 Freight & Insurance ($/MT)** 72.0 CIF ($/MT) 1,772.0 CIF (Rs./MT)*** 1,16,012.8 BD (0%) 0 CIF + BD 1,16,012.8 Cess (0%) 0 CIF + BD + Cess 1,16,012.8 IGST (5%) 5,800.6 Final Cost 1,21,813.4 Selling Price in India# 1,29,000.0 Profit 7,186.6 Profit Margin 5.57% * Split cassia in bundles; HS Code: 09061910; ** Freight and insurance cost from Ho Chi Minh City in Vietnam to Mumbai in India; Minimum order quantity (MOQ): 1MT; *** Assuming USDINR at 65.47; # Wholesale price (TDB Intelligence Unit); Note: Profitabilty ignores brand equity; No Cess and BD is applicable on imports from Vietnam under the India-ASEAN FTA. Important disclaimer: Profitability has been calculated based on time-bound indicative prices (prevalent during the third week of December 2017). Prices may vary during a different time period, resulting in profit fluctuation. Factors like brand value, supply chain-related costs like warehousing and logistics, administrative costs, sales and advertising costs, etc., have not been included in the cost of procurement. Margins have been calculated considering government policies (announcements, notifications, etc.) as on December 20, 2017. Risk factors and currency fluctuations have to be considered while importing. Calculations have been provided for informational purposes only; The Dollar Business takes no responsibility for any loss resulting from investments in the said commodity/product. Though all efforts have been made to ensure the accuracy of the content stated herewith, the same should not be considered a statement of law or used for any legal purposes. Prior permission is required before calculations stated herein are published or quoted in a third party web or print property.
THE QUALITY CHALLENGE
India is currently the leading importer of cassia in the world with a 30% share in world imports followed by US, Bangladesh and Japan. The biggest source of imported cassia for India is Vietnam – the country currently fulfils about 86% of India’s total import requirement – followed by China and Indonesia. Even though there are large quantities of cassia being imported into India, importers like Gopaal Ahuja, Chairman of the Mumbai-based Komal Exotic Spices, says that finding exporters who follow proper quality standards is a challenge. He explains, “As an importer, I face the challenge of getting my cassia cleared by the FSSAI, as cassia are not completely dried by some Chinese exporters before shipping. And by the time the shipment reaches us, the moisture from the products evaporates and recondenses on the goods in the container, leading to the formation of fungus. Fungus on vegetable products leads to the formation
CASSIA IMPORT, BY VOLUME, INCREASED BY 20.07% BETWEEN FY2012 AND FY2017 of aflatoxin which is a harmful carcinogen.” This is one of the reasons, Ahuja says, why many importers like him do not prefer to import the commodity from China. Exporters, he says, need to adhere to the rules and regulations and not resort to shortcuts. It is also difficult to make out the quality in the consignments that come from China as they are bundled, pressed under a hydraulic press and tied together with a belt. Many a time, exporters say, they have found various impurities including pieces of plastic within the cassia consignment. Imports from Vietnam, on the other hand, do not have such issues as they JANUARY 2018 II THE DOLLAR BUSINESS 33
IMPORT’ONOMICS
CASSIA (BARK)
are packed in a transparent box and not pressed into a bundle making it is easy to inspect for impurities. He however adds, “If Vietnam starts following China’s example, we may be forced to find a new supplier from Indonesia or may even reduce our imports.” Rajiv Jaiswal, Head – Exports and Imports, Raj Exports, differs and says that when it comes to quality, there is not much difference between the Vietnamese and the Chinese products. Any difference in quality, he says, has to do with the supplier, as at the end of the day the climate and geographical location of both countries are similar. Another reason why Vietnam is preferred over China has been the absence of an import duty on imports from Vietnam. Under the FTA with the ASEAN nations, Indian importers do not have
to pay an import duty while importing from Vietnam and Indonesia which are both members of ASEAN. Importing from non-FTA countries like China on the other hand means that the product suffers a total duty of about 36%, making Chinese variety of cassia uncompetitive in the domestic market.
SPREADING AROMA
Despite the challenges arising out of customs clearances and food safety regulations, importers are upbeat about the future of the business. Ahuja says that expectations for a growth in demand in the future has a lot to do with the rise in incomes and changing food habits of people. The upwardly-mobile population has taken to consuming a number of sweet and savoury items that require the use of cassia. Cassia is also a part of
many Chinese recipes that have found favour with Indians. Scant domestic availability, absence of import duties, and ease of import in addition to good marketing by Vietnam has attracted more importers towards cassia. “Many Indian traders, who were earlier my clients, have started to import cassia by themselves,” says Ahuja. Currently, importers have to pay a 5% IGST. Ahuja says that IGST has impacted their working capital and hopes that the government is able to introduce an e-wallet scheme similar to the one that is being introduced for exporters. He explains, “The way the finance minister has declared the creation of the e-wallet for exporters, an e-wallet can be created for importers as well. This way, the GST credit, that we have, can be used to pay IGST when we import the next consign-
“GETTING FSSAI CLEARANCE IS A BIG CHALLENGE” TDB: Are there any challenges that you face while importing cassia into India? Gopaal Ahuja (GA): Yes, as an importer, I face the challenge of getting our goods cleared by the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI). The other challenge is that many a times, the cassia are not completely dried by exporters before shipping, and by the time they reach us, the moisture from the products evaporates and recondenses on the cassia in the container, leading to the formation of fungus. Fungus on vegetable products lead to the formation of aflatoxin, which is a harmful carcinogen. So, this process of drying by the packers has to be thorough, but many Chinese exporters do not follow this norm. It is because of these reasons that China has lost ground to Vietnam. Vietnam is presently our preferred sourcing destination because of the quality of their product. In order to build a good reputation exporters should adhere to better quality standards. Now, if Vietnamese exporters too start flouting norms, maybe we will have to find a new supplier from Indonesia or even reduce our imports. 34 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
TDB: Has GST impacted your imports? Has it affected the pricing? GA: GST has made my work a little more difficult because I have to pay IGST at the time of import. Earlier, I had to pay VAT after selling the goods. So, I used to literally get the tax from the customers, but now a part of my working capital goes toward IGST. So, my funds are constrained. Ever since GST has been implemented, my books are always in the credit of GST. I am having to carry this credit. Instead of doing that, the way the finance minister has declared the creation of the E-wallet for exporters, an E-wallet can be created for importers as well. This way, the GST credit that we have, can be used to pay the IGST when we import the next round of goods. TDB: Apart from quality, what makes Vietnam the preferred sourcing market? GA: We have been importing cassia for almost 30 years now. Earlier, we used to import from China. Subsequently, the Indo-ASEAN FTA was signed. So, cassia from Vietnam became duty free. That is one more reason to buy from Vietnam.
Gopaal Ahuja
CHAIRMAN, KOMAL EXOTIC SPICES
Chinese cassia is more pungent and all things being equal we would have preferred to import Chinese cassia. But the import duty from China is a deal-breaker. Also, Chinese packers and exporters are less reliable as far as genuineness of the material is concerned. Vietnamese exporters are more reliable and their cassia is packed loosely in boxes. So, detecting adulteration is easy. Chinese cassia, on the other hand, is pressed under a hydraulic press and then bundled up, making detection of adulteration difficult. Often, we have found pieces of plastic in their packets.
ment of goods.” Sethi however believes that the introduction of GST has been beneficial as it has reduced paperwork. While profit margins are typically low, importers believe that higher margins can be garnered if the right product is sold. Ahuja explains, “If I am selling to a quality-conscious customer, then I do an inspection and quality check even after receiving the product in India. We also grade the cassia and sell the better grades to the more conscious client who is willing to pay a higher price for better quality, thus yielding better margins. But if I am selling to traders who are not bothered by impurities or minor issues in quality, then the margins are obviously lower.” Currently the domestic price of split cassia hovers around $2,000-2,200 per MT and broken cassia around $1,700 per MT. As the product is imported in
Vietnam, Indonesia and China are some of the biggest producers of cassia.
bulk, importers say that they are okay with profit margins as low as 5%. Jaiswal adds that cassia is one of the products that needs to be stocked, even though the profits may not be too high. Sethi is confident of seeing a growth in demand and says market trends suggest that future is bright for cassia in India. But he cautions that in order to be successful one needs to keep a regular sup-
ply to earn the loyalty of clients even if one makes a loss at times. With India’s love for spices being a constant and new cassia products being introduced, the demand for cassia is bound to only grow in the near future. If importers are able to secure reliable suppliers and maintain quality, this pungent smelling spice can offer sweet profits!
“THE INDO-ASEAN FTA ALLOWS DUTY-FREE IMPORTS” TDB: Where do you import cassia from? Prashant Sethi (PS): We import from Vietnam, and also from Indonesia. There is a small quantity of cassia being grown in the southern part of India, but the production is not enough to fulfil the needs of the population here. That is the reason India imports from China and Vietnam. Indonesia is also gradually becoming an important sourcing market. TDB: Many say that the quality from China tends to be inferior. Your take? PS: I have not imported directly from China, but I have seen the quality in the market. The quality depends more on the exporter than the country. There can be inferior quality from Vietnam too. All types are available in the Indian markets. You also get good quality from China but the problem with China is that we have to pay an import duty. For Vietnam and Indonesia, there is no import duty and cess because of the India-ASEAN FTA. TDB: Do you face any problem while importing cassia? PS: The import of cassia is relatively eas-
ier if you have a good quality product. The main issue is plant quarantine and customs. Otherwise, it is a rather smooth process. If you have fully paid values and are not under-invoicing, there are no hassles. When it comes to plant quarantine, they take out the samples and if they are as per regulations then there is no issue. Earlier it used to take 10-15 days for clearance, but now the process is much quicker and more streamlined. TDB: What factors influence the price and demand of the product? PS: The consumption is increasing every year. We are also seeing an increase in price. A lot depends on the environmental conditions in China and Vietnam. When there is heavy rain in Vietnam it may impact the product quality and price. A lot of shipments get held up due to various factors and this also impacts the quality and price. The Indian market closely follows international trends – and the supply and demand situation impacts prices, as is the norm. The prices of cassia also depend on the variety of cassia that one is importing –
Prashant Sethi
OWNER, AUGUST INDUSTRIES
broken, split, smashed, etc. The selling price in the domestic market starts from Rs.140 a kilo and there is a year-round demand. TDB: Do you expect demand to change? PS: We expect to see a growth in demand and in our sales. You have to keep working in the business – and be on your toes. Sometimes an importer may make losses, but it is important to continue with the business. That is how you build a reputation and gain loyal customers. If you stay on course, you will make profits and see your business grow. JANUARY 2018 II THE DOLLAR BUSINESS 35
GLOBAL MANAGER
MERRILL JOSEPH FERNANDO, CHAIRMAN & FOUNDER, DILMAH TEA
“WE WANT TO BE AT THE TOP END OF THE MARKET” When it comes to tea, one of the biggest names in international markets is the Sri Lanka-based Dilmah Tea. With a footprint in around 104 countries, Dilmah Tea has in the last 32 years established itself as a name to reckon with when it comes to authentic Ceylon tea. In an exclusive interaction with The Dollar Business, Merrill Joseph Fernando, the Founder & Chairman of Dilmah Tea, talks about entering the Indian market, the importance of quality and innovation and the need for combining business with social welfare. INTERVIEW BY ANISHAA KUMAR
TDB: What was your inspiration behind entering the tea business? Merrill Joseph Fernando (MJF): Sri Lanka, formally known as Ceylon, produces some of the world’s best varieties of tea. World over, colonial powers would bring crops and agricultural products to their colonies. They would then take the produce as raw material to their countries – in the case of Sri Lanka during the British empire it was mostly tea − to blend, mix, package, brand and market. Producers of the raw material − farmers and workers in Sri Lanka – would put in the hard work and produce the world’s finest cup of tea but they would remain poor while watching their labour enrich foreign companies, making their own36 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
ers millionaires and billionaires. This is because blending, mixing and packaging are the most profitable segments of the tea business. As a young student, I saw the exploitation of the tea workers in my country. I witnessed in countries like England the raw material, which was brought at what would currently be around 50 cents a kilo from the producers in Sri Lanka, generating 4 to 6 times the revenue as the processed product. However, none of these profits came back to the farmers and workers. It was then that I decided that some day I would start my own brand of tea, for which profits would come back to Sri Lanka and help farmers and workers access a better life and a secure future. When I started off
I received much ridicule from the people of my own country, but I pursued my dream regardless. TDB: Dilmah has made a name for itself as a premium tea brand not only in South Asia, but the world over. Could you tell us about Dilmah’s journey? MJF: Today, Dilmah tea is exported to nearly 104 countries. I initially started exporting bulk tea, 66 years ago, which foreign companies then branded and marketed. I started my own brand, Dilmah, 32 years ago. When I started exporting 66 years ago, every country in the world was already drinking Ceylon tea. So, I was selling to almost all countries. In fact, at some point in time,
presence felt at the top end.
I must have sold bulk Ceylon tea to every international and multi-national tea company. When I began exporting in 1988 under the Dilmah brand name, my first market was Australia, as I had been a supplier of bulk tea to Australia for many years before I launched the brand. TDB: What has been the driving force behind Dilmah’s growing popularity in the international market and is there any difference in your marketing strategy across countries? MJF: Our primary strategy has been to market the finest quality Ceylon tea – grown, packaged, branded and marketed by my family. Having our own tea gardens and the required facilities for packaging in our control gives us absolute control on the quality and freshness of our tea. This is the reason we are able to sell our tea at relatively higher prices. TDB: India is one of the largest tea-drinking and tea-producing nations in the world. How has Dilmah’s journey in India been so far? MJF: When we started our journey in India, we partnered with Dabur as we were an unknown brand then. But today, we work in partnership with Amalgamation Group, to pack and market our tea in India. We have started distribution in certain parts of the country. Understandably, our tea is priced higher than most Indian brands. But, the people of India appreciate the quality and the wide variety of teas we offer. And this is the reason our business is growing in India. We know we cannot be a big brand in India because there are already many big tea producers, but we do want to make our
TDB: Did you face any regulatory challenges in entering India? MJF: Yes! The government created many problems because they did not want tea, as a product, to be imported into India. We had problems and issues with various government bodies. These bodies should actually support imports from Sri Lanka, because in Sri Lanka we support imports from India in a big way. We do not receive that cooperation for our exports from the Indian side. But, slowly things are changing for the better now. TDB: Where does the brand stand when it comes to Sri Lankan market? MJF: I initially didn’t intend to get into the domestic market because there were too many small players and I didn’t wanted to compete with them. I wanted them to keep their market share. However, it was only when Dilmah started promoting Sri Lankan cricket – we sponsored the Sri Lankan cricket team for eight years – we realised that while people abroad knew what Dilmah was, in Sri Lanka not many had heard of the tea brand. So, we were forced to launch the brand in the domestic market too. There are three or four other brands in the domestic market, but we sell at the highest prices. We now have a very good market share. Like India has its own variety of tea, so does Sri Lanka. Our countrymen respect the Dilmah brand of tea. People also respect the brand for its philosophy of caring and sharing. Today, we have a very big market share and we must be the second largest player in the domestic market. Of course, there is a lot of difference between the number one and number two brand in quality and price. TDB: Dilmah has been actively working towards assisting and uplifting tea growers. How important has this involvement been for the company? MJF: We, at Dilmah, are farmers. We grow our product with love and care. We want to give the consumers the best deal for their money while caring for our farmers. Our MJF Foundation does a lot of work for the workers, their children
AT DILMAH, OUR PRIMARY STRATEGY HAS ALWAYS BEEN TO EXPORT THE FINEST QUALITY CEYLON TEA and the wider community. We can do this because we market our own tea and the profits come back to Sri Lanka. TDB: When it comes to tea, innovations, in terms of flavour and packaging to cater to different markets and consumers – from high-end hotels to households, have become almost an essential. How is Dilmah innovating? MJF: When it was launched, Dilmah brought a revolution to the tea sector. Over the last 10 years, Dilmah has been at the forefront of innovation. For instance, we introduced the concept of serving tea with food at a global event in Sri Lanka. We have also set up Dilmah Tea lounges around the world, where we serve everything made from tea. These lounges are very popular. Many others are now adopting these concepts. Though people can copy the concept, they cannot copy our heart and soul. No one can copy my love and passion for tea. And this is the reason we stand way ahead of everyone else when it comes to tea. TDB: Would Dilmah ever look into expanding into other products like spices or any other agricultural product? MJF: We are producers of tea and would like to continue to concentrate on the production, branding and marketing of tea. We have our hands full at the moment. But, my son Malik runs the leisure department in our company. We have three villa concept hotels in Sri Lanka. That is a speciality business he looks after. Then we also have the best packaging and printing company in Sri Lanka. We also have other manufacturing facilities that make products related to tea exports like wooden boxes etc. Like Dilmah Tea, each of those companies contribute 10% of their profits (before taxes) to the MJF Charitable Foundation. JANUARY 2018 II THE DOLLAR BUSINESS 37
FACE2FACE
KATHERINE B. HADDA, US CONSUL GENERAL (HYDERABAD)
“INDIA AND US ARE NATURAL ALLIES” The engagement between US and India, both at government and business levels, has grown significantly over the last few years. In fact, the US Administration under President Donald Trump has recognised India as a foremost foreign policy priority. The Dollar Business caught up with Katherine B. Hadda, Consul General at the US Consulate General in Hyderabad, to understand the dynamics of the ever-evolving relationship between the two largest democracies of the world. INTERVIEW BY AHMAD SHARIQ KHAN
TDB: How would you define the current state of US-India ties? Katherine B. Hadda (KBH): During his recent visit to New Delhi, US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson described US and India as natural allies. And that’s exactly what I see on the ground, here in Hyderabad, especially in terms of our expanding trade relationship and people-to-people ties. Over 130 American companies are doing business in Hyderabad alone and most of the Indians I meet here have a meaningful connection with US. We continue to see incredible visa demand and enthusiasm on both sides. All this growth seems natural and there’s even more that we can do to realise the full potential of our strategic partnership. Given India’s size, diversity, entrepreneurial spirit, and powerful democratic system, US sees India as a great economic partner and strategic ally in the years to come. TDB: What is the current level of bilateral investment between the state of Telangana and the United States? KBH: Given the sheer scope and rapid growth of the investment flows between the US and India, it’s difficult to get a precise handle on the numbers. But we can safely say that about $3-4 billion in investments has come from the United States into Telangana, specifically. On the other side, India is one of the fastest growing sources of FDI into the United States in terms of the number of projects 38 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
and employment generated. I believe that the total amount of FDI from across India into the US is now more than $11 billion. Some leading companies from the states of Telangana and Andhra Pradesh – including Cyient, Aurobindo and Dr. Reddy’s – have grown rapidly in US. I am excited to see that Mahindra plans to open manufacturing facilities in Detroit. I believe that these two-way investments will grow, given the commitments at the national and local levels to encourage investment and entrepreneurship.
HEALTHCARE, TRAVEL AND AGRIBUSINESS ARE RIPE FOR GREATER COLLABORATION
ture of startups in India? How can both sides collaborate on mutually beneficial propositions? KBH: I’m fortunate to be in a part of India that has set a standard for how to faTDB: What are your thoughts on In- cilitate and incubate a startup culture. It dia’s pro-FDI stance and improved ease seems almost every day I meet an entreof doing business ranking? preneur with a big idea and the structurKBH: Based on the enthusiasm from al support to make it happen. Obviously, American companies opening and ex- the biggest sign of how closely aligned panding operations in Hyderabad, the our two governments are on support effects of business-friendly national and for entrepreneurship is the recently state-level policies are definitely being held Global Entrepreneurship Summit felt. This is something that the World (GES). And, my team at the ConsulBank agrees with and has thus elevated ate and I know that the governments of India’s place in their ease of doing busi- India and Telangana are committed to ness rankings. Today, more than 600 ensuring that we all harness the energy American companies operate in India. that the GES brought in, now even after It’s remarkable to think that not even 20 the Summit has ended, to keep the moyears ago, two-way trade between our mentum going with events that promote nations was less than $20 billion per year. entrepreneurship, especially for women, By the end of 2016, it had grown by more and highlight both US and India as ideal than 500% to an annual $115 billion. I environments to grow businesses. think the number of American businesses that are taking to increase their foot- TDB: Other than information technolprint in India speaks for itself. ogy, R&D and defence, what sectors offer potential for collaboration? TDB: How do you see the growing cul- KBH: The sheer size and diversity of
trade surplus with any country. TDB: The latest developments in the H1-B US work visa system suggest that it is being made a merit-based one. What is the latest on this? KBH: There are no immediate changes to the H1-B visa programme and individuals with valid H1-B visa are free to travel to the United States. The Executive Order calls for proposals of reforms to the H1-B visa programme. We are not in a position to prejudge the outcome of the review or speculate on any future changes. This review is comprehensive and not targeted to a specific country or sector. TDB: What, as per you, are the tariff and non-tariff barriers that impede seamless cross-border flow of services? KH: United States and India are looking at working together to improve the ease of doing business and increasing bilateral trade. Services trade is incredibly important to both our nations. NASSCOM estimates that US purchases over 60% of India’s services exports. In fact, in 2016 alone, this amounted to nearly $15 billion. India has proposed a broader agreement on services trade in WTO in Geneva, and the US and others are looking at how we might engage in a substantive dialogue to improve this on a global level. our two economies demand that we do more to realise the full potential of our commercial partnership. There are many sectors that we believe offer promising opportunities for growth and synergies. One of these is energy. Last year, in early October, I was fortunate to witness the arrival of shipments of US crude oil to India at Paradip Port in the state of Odisha. This was the first such shipment to India since the United States stopped oil exports in 1975, and follows recent commitments to US oil purchases by Indian Oil Corporation and Bharat Petroleum. This was a significant milestone in the growing partnership between the United States and India in the oil and gas sector, and it will enable India to diversify its suppliers and bring down oil prices for businesses and consumers. Beyond energy – including fossil fuels, renewable, and nuclear energy – other sectors ripe
for expanded collaboration include environmental technologies, travel and tourism, healthcare and agribusiness. TDB: President Trump’s ‘America First’ stance has been a cause of concern for many major economies. How do you expect it to impact India? KBH: It is important to remember that the US maintains one of the lowest average applied tariff rates in the world and is one of India’s biggest trading partners, purchasing close to 20% of India’s total goods and services exports. President Trump’s focus on free, fair, and mutually beneficial trade aims to highlight areas in which the United States commitments to free trade and open markets have not been reciprocated by some of our trading partners. It is also worth noting that India’s nearly $30 billion-dollar trade surplus with the United States is its largest
TDB: President Trump has gone all out to promote brand America. What makes US an attractive investment destination for Indian businesses? KBH: We are proud that we have expanded bilateral trade to a record $115 billion, and two-way investment to $40 billion. For Indian companies, the United States offers a unified, highly-developed and prosperous consumer and business market of some 320 million people and hundreds of thousands of companies, with many more markets and consumers accessible from the US through free trade agreements. We have a highly-educated workforce and excellent infrastructure. Add to this, there is the advantage of low-energy costs and a predictable legal and regulatory environment. We welcome the interest and investment by Indian companies, which creates jobs and prosperity for both. JANUARY 2018 II THE DOLLAR BUSINESS 39
THE SECRET INGREDIENT
MENTHOL
HOW ABOUT ‘MINT’ING SOME MONEY?
People want their toothpastes, their chocolates, their detergents and even their medicines to be minty fresh – menthol has certainly found usage across product categories and industries, globally. And with India consolidating its leadership position in menthol exports, as well as several menthol-based products, many exporters are now making a shift towards this minty material. BY ANISHAA KUMAR
T
he ancient Greeks believed that the nymph Minthe was Hades’ lover. They used leaves of the mint plant to perform the last rites of their dead. An aroma that can even overpower death
is quite something. In fact, people have never quite gotten over the novelty of menthol. Today, it is ubiquitous – it is in our pastes, creams, powders, cupcakes... well, the list goes on. Derived from the plant Mentha Arvenis, menthol, is find-
Indian farmers are in desperate need of training and support to increase the yield of the plant from which natural menthol is extracted. 40 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
ing ‘f(l)avour’ the world over. Currently, India contributes to about 33% of the world’s menthol exports, followed by China. With its usage across sectors, it is not surprising to find that going forward the demand for mint and mint products is expected to increase 3-5% year-onyear [International Trade Centre report]. A study by Allied Market Research too states that the global essential oil market, of which mint oil forms a large part, is expected to grow at a CAGR of 8.7% and become a $11.5-billion market by 2022. P. Gupta of New Delhi-based JD Chem India, a producer of menthol, states that exporters are attracted towards menthol because of its many uses – from cosmetics to confectionery to pharmaceuticals. Its varied uses makes it an attractive proposition despite menthol exports being a low-margin business. Mentha is currently cultivated across northern India – from Himachal Pradesh to Haryana, from Uttar Pradesh to Bihar. According to an International Trade Centre report, in CY2015, the total production of the Mentha Arvensis crop in India was around 31,000 metric tonne (MT), which increased to around 35,500 MT in CY2016. Exports of menthol from India are currently placed under two different HS
Profit estimates for exports of natural menthol Exporters can expect a profit margin in the range of 2-5% Cost of Production (INR/kg) FOB Value (INR/kg) Operating Profit Operating Margin (%)
1,600 1,640 40 2.44
Natural menthol; HS code: 29061100; FOB Nhava Sheva Port, Mumbai; MOQ: 100 kg; Cost of production excludes government subsidies (like duty drawback of 1.5%) and incentives (like 5% reward under MEIS).
Important disclaimer: Profitability has been calculated based on time-bound indicative prices (prevalent during the third week of December 2017). Prices may vary during a different time period, resulting in profit fluctuation. Factors like brand value, supply chain-related costs like warehousing and logistics, administrative costs, sales and advertising costs, etc., have not been included in the cost of procurement. Margins have been calculated considering government policies (announcements, notifications, etc.) as on December 20, 2017. Risk factors and currency fluctuations have to be considered while exporting. Duty drawbacks have not been factored in while calculating indicative profitability. Calculations are provided for informational purposes only; The Dollar Business takes no responsibility for any loss resulting from investments in the said commodity/product. Though all efforts have been made to ensure the accuracy of the content stated herewith, the same should not be considered a statement of law or used for any legal purposes. Prior permission is required before calculations stated herein are published or quoted in a third party web or print property.
INDIA’S EXPORTS OF MENTHOL INCREASED 28.7% Y-O-Y IN FY2017 codes based on the form and grade – 29061100 and 30039021. Explaining the difference, Pankaj Somani of the New Delhi-based Agson Global, says, “Generally speaking, if it is for human consumption it is exported under HS Code 29061100. And, if it is used in the pharma industry, it can be found under HS Code 30039021. Under 2906 falls the natural form of menthol used in non-pharma consumables and under 3003 you will find the crystal form used by pharmaceutical companies. There is not much difference between these varieties. It all depends on what the end product is.” When menthol is being produced as a pharmaceutical bulk drug it can be found as Menthol IP/EP/BP/JP/USP, etc. The type of menthol and HS code used, exporters say, varies according to clients’ demands. Interestingly, exporters often are unaware of the end use of the product they sell, and the HS code is decided by the importer. That said, India is most-
ly known for natural menthol that it produces and exports in large volumes. “The demand for menthol is rising worldwide because of its growing usage in a variety of end-products,” says Himanshu Agarwal, Director of KV Aromatics, an exporter of menthol. He adds that the demand is usually in places where there are manufacturing units for the products they are used in, including China and India which are also major exporters of the end-products. Coincidentally, China is also the largest importer of menthol with India being its main sourcing destination. In fact, in FY2017, exports to China constituted 24.49% of India’s total exports of menthol under HS Code 29061100. Overall, India is currently the leader in exports under HS code 29061100 (the variety that is used in consumables) and the 10th largest exporter under HS code 30039021 (the variety that is used in pharma products).
REGAINING MOMENTUM
If one looks at the exports of menthol over the last five years, the numbers may at first appear to be quite disheartening. Since FY2013, India’s exports of menthol (under HS code: 29061100) has declined by about 52.34%. However, a closer look at the numbers reveal that in FY2017 ex-
ports witnessed a dramatic jump – from $144.44 million to $185.91 million, a y-o-y increase of 28.7%. For FY2018, exports of menthol till September 2017 stood at $114.93 million, reporting a 12.55% y-o-y growth. What’s more? The month of September itself saw a y-o-y exports growth of 74.19%. Overall, India (with 33% share in world exports) maintains its position as the world’s largest exporter of menthol, despite the fluctuations over the years. India is closely followed by China (22%), Germany (22%) and Japan (9%) as the major exporters of menthol in the world. Vaibhav Agrawal, Managing Director, Norex Flavours Pvt. Ltd., a manufacturer of natural menthol, says, “Lower cost of production and a climate suitable for menthol production in northern India, has made India a hub for production of good quality mint oil and menthol. Further, the demand for menthol is price-driven. The demand for natural menthol always depends on several factors including competition from synthetic menthol, inventories in China, etc. As there has been a shortage in the supply and production of synthetic menthol for the last few months, the demand for natural menthol is on the rise.” Somani too adds that the demand for natural menthol has been increasing for some time now because some plants that were producing synthetic menthol were shut down recently and people went back to using natural menthol. He fears that this trend may not continue for long and when the synthetic menthol plants start producing again, the demand for natural menthol is bound to decline.
SYNTHETIC VS. NATURAL
One of the main reasons for the fluctuation in exports of natural menthol over the years has been the growth in the production of synthetic menthol. According to International Trade Centre, the total global production of synthetic menthol is estimated to be around 15,000-20,000 MT per annum and is expected to rise at double-digit pace going forward. Manufacturers such as Germany-based BASF and Symrise and Japan-based Takasago too have been ramping up their production capacities to meet the rising deJANUARY 2018 II THE DOLLAR BUSINESS 41
THE SECRET INGREDIENT
mand for synthetic menthol and in the process have threatened the existence of producers of natural menthol. Further, the volatility in prices of natural menthol also has been a major challenge for the industry. “Since this is a commodity that is listed on the MCX, we see a lot of price fluctuations. Every company may have a different profit margin, based on their optimisation of production, but the change in prices play havoc with our profitability. Overall, menthol is one of the most competitive and low profit margin products,” says Agrawal. Currently, exporters say, the profit margin varies between 2% to 5%. Abhilash Pandey of Ghaziabad-based AOS Products Pvt. Ltd., a manufacturer and exporter of menthol, has a different view on the demand fluctuation of natural menthol. He believes the available supply of synthetic menthol has little to
MENTHOL
do with the demand for natural menthol as the two products are used in completely different end-products. According to him, the demand for natural menthol is witnessing an upward trend as the
India’s export of menthol
Exports are regaining momentum 450 400 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0
FY’13
FY’14
FY’15
FY’16
FY’17
Source: TDB Intelligence Unit and Ministry of Commerce, GoI; figure in $ million; HS Code: 29061100
demand for non-pharma end-products is on the rise.
NEED A HELPING HAND
Whatever be the reason for the fluctuations in demand, exporters are in agreement that the government has not been of much help when it comes to promoting menthol. Somani says, “Because we do not contribute sizeable amount of foreign exchange, the government does not listen to us. We have made many presentations to the government, but nothing has been done yet to resolve our issues.” Some requests made to the government include abolishing the mandi tax and introducing more incentives. “The Chinese government gives better incentives to their manufacturers and exporters compared to the Indian government. If incentives are increased we can survive and fight the competition
“GST HAS HAD A BIG IMPACT ON THE MENTHOL INDUSTRY” TDB: Which are your primary export markets? What factors affect the demand for menthol, the world over? Himanshu Agarwal (HA): We have been manufacturing menthol for the last 21 years and have been exporting the product since 2003. Our company exports across the globe, to almost 25 countries – including US and EU. The consumption and demand for menthol changes according to the demand for the product in which it is being used as an input. The demand also depends on the the production scenario of menthol in the importing country. After all, menthol is not an end product, it is used as a raw material in many industries. TDB: After peaking in FY2013, export revenue from menthol witnessed a decline before increasing again in FY2017. What were the reasons behind the decline in menthol exports? HA: The price of menthol has seen a change between FY2016 and FY2017. The price has actually increased by 50%, and in some cases by as much as 100%, 42 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
within this year itself. However, the volume has not changed much. After the blast at BASF (the biggest producer of synthetic menthol in the world) plant, there is now more faith in the natural product. While the prices may be higher now, in the coming year, when production rises, the prices will decline. TDB: How has Goods and Services Tax (GST) affected the industry? HA: GST has had a big impact on the industry as exporters and manufacturers now have to pay taxes prior to the sale and apply for refunds later. The menthol industry works on long-term commitments. We need to buy raw materials well in advance to be able to meet our long-term commitments. Now, after implementation of GST, when we buy Rs.100 worth of raw material to produce the final product, we have to pay an additional 12% IGST. This has increased our working capital cost as the refund is processed only after exports are done, which may be anything from six months to one year, from the time of buying materials.
Himanshu Agarwal
DIRECTOR, K. V. AROMATICS
So, our money is blocked against export orders. Of course, they have postponed the reverse charge mechanism till March 2018, but this is just a temporary relief. Once it is implemented in April, it will become a major concern for exporters. TDB: What kind of margins can one expect in menthol exports business? HA: Menthol is a very expensive product. The profit margins usually range around 2-4% like most agricultural products and depend upon factors like the raw material price, global market price, etc.
coming from synthetic menthol. If the prices of synthetic menthol and natural menthol become the same, then people will definitely prefer natural menthol. We are working with different government agencies to engineer better yields from our crop. Once the yield improves, farmers can sell their produce at a much lower rate,” adds Somani. Exporters of menthol, after the recent hike in incentives in the midterm FTP review, receive duty credit scrip of 5% under MEIS and a duty drawback of 1.5%. The introduction of Goods & Services Tax (GST), according to exporters, has also created new challenges for the industry. Earlier menthol used to attract 5% VAT, but now it’s subject to a 12% GST. Agrawal explains, “Before GST, there was no excise duty on menthol. It was only subject to 5% VAT. Being an agri-product, we were sure that it would
attract a 5% GST rate. However, we were shocked when 18% tax was announced. After much lobbying, we were provided a partial relief by bringing the product in 12% tax bracket. This rate of tax is still a burden and has had an adverse impact on the industry. Currently, all the capital that exporters have is deposited as GST with the government. As evident to everybody, the government has not been able to process refunds on time. A high GST rate and no tax refunds have hampered the growth of the industry.” Pandey concurs and says that in order to encourage the industry and boost production and exports, the government needs to speed up the process of refund. The industry also needs to focus on international food safety standards, GMP compliance, etc., to be at par with global competition. “There is a lack of awareness about the procedures amongst
EARLIER MENTHOL USED TO ATTRACT 5% VAT, BUT NOW IT SUFFERS A 12% GST MSMEs,” says Agrawal. Exporters, however, encouragingly say that menthol, compared to most other products, does not present any major challenge when it comes to clearance, certifications, etc. The demand for natural menthol is growing as it finds use in a variety of consumables and exporters are hopeful that with the right support for the domestic growers, India’s natural menthol exporters will be able to put up a fight against the producers of synthetic menthol. May be it is time for this cool business to mint some money!
“INDIA IS A SOURCING HUB FOR MINT OIL AND MENTHOL” TDB: Why is Indian menthol popular amongst global importers and what drives demand for the product? Vaibhav Agrawal (VA): The low cost of production and a climate suitable for menthol cultivation in northern India has made India a hub for production of good quality mint oil and menthol. Demand for natural menthol is price-driven as it is an agri product. The demand is also governed by several factors including competition from synthetic menthol, inventories in China, etc. A recent shortage of synthetic menthol is also the cause for the increased demand. TDB: Menthol is in the 12% GST slab. How has this affected the industry? VA: Before GST, there was no excise duty on menthol. It was only subject to 5% VAT. Being an agri-product, we were sure that it would attract a 5% GST rate. However, we were shocked when 18% tax was announced. After much lobbying, we were provided a partial relief by bringing the product in 12% tax bracket. This rate of tax is still a burden and has
had an adverse impact on the industry. Currently, all the capital that exporters have is deposited as GST with the government. As evident to everybody, the government has not been able to process refunds on time. A high GST rate and no tax refunds have hampered the growth of the industry. While the new FTP is good – an additional 2% incentive has been provided under MEIS – a lot more needs to be done to promote natural menthol. TDB: What are the compliance requirements to export menthol? VA: There are a lot of compliance requirements in this sector. Menthol is a product which is used widely as an important ingredient in food, pharma and cosmetic products. Hence, manufacturers and exporters of menthol need to focus more on international food safety standards, GMP compliance, etc., to be at par with global competition. However, there is a lack of awareness about the procedures amongst MSMEs. Unfortunately, our export promotion councils are also not doing enough in this area.
Vaibhav Agrawal
MD, NOREX FLAVOURS PVT. LTD.
TDB: What government assistance do exporters receive? What needs to be done to boost exports of menthol? VA: The Government of Uttar Pradesh provides nothing. In fact, it has made the life of menthol producers and mint farmers miserable by imposing a 1.5% mandi tax on menthol and mint sellers. The central government, as a part of the FTP, provides some incentive under MEIS. But then, that’s not enough support. We urge more assistance from the government, particularly for farmers, to increase productivity and become a competition to synthetic menthol. JANUARY 2018 II THE DOLLAR BUSINESS 43
POLICY MONITOR
NARAIN AGGARWAL, CHAIRMAN, SYNTHETIC & RAYON TEXTILES EPC
“WE ARE STILL EXPORTING TAXES” High GST slabs had put the textile exporters in a quandary, but business is normalising after a reduction in taxes. In an exclusive interaction with The Dollar Business, Narain Aggarwal, Chairman, Synthetic & Rayon Textiles Export Promotion Council, talks about the sector’s growth prospects, the role of man-made fibres in helping the sector achieve its ambitious export target and the challenges that exporters continue to face. INTERVIEW BY ANISHAA KUMAR
TDB: You took over as the Chairman of the Synthetic & Rayon Textiles Export Promotion Council (SRTEPC) in February 2017. What are your focus areas? Narain Aggarwal (NA): While there are certain matters which our Council has been looking into since formation and will continue to do so, my area of focus will be increasing exports. I want exports to increase at an average annual growth rate of 15%. The growth however has been miniscule, just about 4% y-o-y between FY2016 and FY2017. Secondly, I would like to make SRTEPC an independent and reliable organisation which will work on a self-sustainable basis. Currently, our only source of income is membership fees. This at times is not enough to complete the many functions of the Council and I would like to explore other areas of revenue generation. TDB: How would you describe the importance of the Council for the sector? NA: The Council plays a very important role. It acts as a bridge between the government and the exporters of man-made fibres (MMF), fabrics and yarns. We are the eyes and ears of the government and the government agencies are highly dependent on the Council for the feedback and suggestions to increase exports. TDB: The government recently agreed to the SRTEPC’s demand for a reduction in GST on yarns from 18% to 12%. Are you satisfied? Are there any concerns that have not been addressed? NA: Earlier, many traders were not in the 44 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
tax net: neither Excise nor VAT. But GST has brought these traders under the tax net. Because of this, traders are facing many challenges, but I believe business will normalise by March 2018. We are satisfied with the latest update with regards to reduction in GST on yarn. That will reduce, to a great extent, the accumulated tax credit problem that the weavers were facing. Due to accumulated tax credit (which is non-refundable), taxes were being indirectly exported. This was not the intention of the government and hence the tax slab was reduced from 18% to 12%. We have requested that in the entire textile chain, wherever there is a case of accumulated credit, it should be refunded. We have also requested that the government should allow weavers to get the refund of already accumulated tax credit. Despite the reduction, 2-4% accumulated tax credit is still being suffered by weavers. This tax credit should be refunded, or the entire textile chain should have a parallel tax structure.
TDB: The government recently announced an increase in basic customs duty on the import of fabrics and made-ups of man-made fibres. How will this impact the sector? NA: There was a huge reduction in duties payable on imported fabrics with the implementation of GST. The reduction was so high that the price difference between fabrics imported pre-GST and post-GST was to the tune of 13%. The import duties have now been increased by 20-25%. There has also been an increase in the floor prices – in order to keep a check on the import price – of some man-made fibres. This will prevent the product from being undervalued during invoicing. These steps will help the sector. Earlier, around Rs.5,000 crore worth of fabric was being imported, which is now expected to decline. If our fabric import is brought down to Rs.1,000 crore it will give the sector an additional revenue of at least Rs.4,000 crore. This will provide a boost to the local industry – weavers, spinners, traders and other stakeholders.
TDB: What recommendations had you made to the government before GST was implemented? NA: What we had suggested when GST was being introduced was that there should be ‘fibre neutrality’ i.e. there should be the same rate of tax irrespective of the type of fibre. The government accepted our demand in part. There was ‘fabric neutrality’ as all fabrics were taxed at 5%. Even in garments, the tax credits were the same irrespective of the type of garment. We do appreciate the government’s efforts to create a level-playing field on this issue. But, there was a major lacuna in the tax framework. In case of synthetics i.e. MMF, the tax on yarn was 18% and on fabric it was 5%, and to add to that the tax was accumulated and non-refundable. So, there was a large quantity of accumulated credit which the weavers could not use, and they had no other option but to add it to the cost of the product they were selling. In business terms, this has resulted in increased prices. We have raised the issue with the government and asked it to reduce the rate or to refund the accumulated tax credit.
TDB: The New Textile Policy is expected to set an annual export target of $350 billion for the sector by FY2025. How much do you expect MMF exports to contribute towards achieving this? NA: Our current textile production is way below the target. We will have to raise production by at least three times. Of our total textile production, around 65% is natural fibres like cotton and the remaining 35% is MMF. In natural fibres, a three-fold growth in the next 7 to 8 years is near impossible. As it is a natural product, you cannot raise the productivity to this extent. Also, as the demand for other agricultural products is high, large tracts of land cannot be allocated for cotton production. What can increase is the yield, and I do not expect that to increase by more than 4-5%. So, the onus will be on man-made fibres and textiles. That said, we will have to more than triple their production. At present we are putting together the data and analysing it to find the best way to achieve this target. We need to define a strategic framework to achieve this ambitious target. We will also need assistance and guidance from the government.
THE GOVERNMENT HAS HELPED US BY REDUCING TAXES, BUT A LOT MORE NEEDS TO BE DONE TDB: What are the other issues restricting exports? NA: Our products are not competitive in the international market as some taxes are still being exported. In Gujarat, for example, we have 15-20% in electricity duties that account for around 2% of the FOB value. This is in addition to local taxes, charges at customs and banks, etc. These add to the costs of the exporter and make our products uncompetitive. Our rate of interest is also higher compared to the international rates. The government has tried to lower the rates for us, but a lot more needs to be done. Also, the Indian textile sector constitutes a large number of medium and small-scale entrepreneurs while in the international market the textile sector is defined by large enterprises with huge order sizes. As individual entrepreneurs, it is difficult for us to negotiate and compete with these international organisations. We need to set up large manufacturing units to be on an equal footing. We also need to pay much more attention to the processing sector. TDB: India currently exports MMF textiles to over 100 markets. Are we also exploring newer markets? NA: We are constantly exploring new markets. The Council is conducting exhibitions and trade fairs in around 8-9 new markets, every year. With the support of the government, the Council and its members are now concentrating on a few countries in Latin America and Africa. These are the continents that hold a lot of growth potential for our exporters. We aim to hold at least one exhibition every year in each of these markets. We are also looking at overcoming certain shortcomings like lack of proper data on these markets. The Council wants to equip exporters with proper tools so that they can attain the best results. JANUARY 2018 II THE DOLLAR BUSINESS 45
TDB FORUM I want to export to Scandinavian countries. Which Indian products have the best export potential in these countries. (Ashok Kumar, Proprietor, ABI Exports, +91-9500636XXX, ak@abiexports.co.in)
Ask a Question
In view of para 3.14 of the current (reviewed) Foreign Trade Policy, IGST should not be applicable on licenses/scrips issued prior to 01-07-2017 and exports effected before 01-07-2017 as that is the date on which GST was notified. Else IGST should be reimbursed as IGST has subsumed the excise duty, which was exempted earlier. This para 3.14 existed in original FTP 2015-2020 too. The transactional arrangements in para 1.05 (a) mentions the same provision. I believe if we request the DGFT to have relook on the issue, we will receive a negative response. Can a Writ Petition be filed on a negative reply from the DGFT? Please guide me. (O. P. Marda, Director, Vivid Visions Trexim Pvt. Ltd., +91-22-42440XXX, opmarda@vvtpl.com)
Dear Mr. Marda: While the intention of the transitional provision under paragraph 1.04 of the Foreign Trade Policy is to continue to provide benefits, which were available on the date of issuance of authorisation/scrips to an authorisation/ scrip holder, the same can’t apply uniformly when the tax regime undergoes a significant change as has happened due to the introduction of a new tax regime in the form of 46 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
In the world of export-import, each shipment counts. And you cannot afford to make any “uninformed investment”. So, if you have any doubt or a question, ask us. Our team of experts at The Dollar Business Intelligence Unit will be happy to answer your queries. Your question(s), if approved, will also be published on www. thedollarbusiness.com, and/ or in the forthcoming issue of The Dollar Business. Goods and Services Tax (GST). Moreover, since complete set-off of the IGST paid on imports is available as Input Tax Credit (ITC) to the importer and can be utilised for paying outward tax liabilities, the imposition of the tax, though it affects the liquidity of importer, does provide full compensation at a later stage. Since the mechanism is fair, I would not suggest that you go for a Writ Petition. However, the company so affected should take the final call on this matter. Response by: Ajay Sahai Director General & CEO, Federation of Indian Export Organisations (FIEO)
Dear Ashok: We are glad to know that you want to start exporting to Scandinavian countries. The main items of export from India to Scandinavian countries include chemical products, food products, items related to transport equipment, apparels, cotton yarn and fabrics, metals, non-metal mineral items, paper products, cashew, furniture, travel goods, leather items, coffee, tea, spices, footwear and miscellaneous manufactured and semi-manufactured articles. Of late, there has been a significant growth in economic and commercial relations between India and Scandinavian countries in sectors like oil & gas, shipping & maritime industries, renewable energy, science and technology, offshore projects and IT & IT enabled services. I believe that, in the near future, products like chemicals, handicrafts, food products, beverages, tobacco, petroleum products and minerals as well as Indian flowers, fruits and vegetables will continue to have good export potential in these countries. A word of caution from my side: It’s extremely important to ensure high product quality and timely delivery to these countries as these are highly sensitive markets and adhere to strict timelines.
Response by: Anil Kumar Trigunayat Former Ambassador of India to Jordan, Libya and Malta
>
TT DO HE
CU TT HE DO TT ED
LIN E>
TT CU << ED
<<
> E> LI N
SUBSCRIBE NOW!
SPE C O F IAL GET FER DISCUP TO 6 ! 5 O
% SUB U SCR NT ON IPTI ONS Read this exclusive platform on foreign trade and get an unbeatable edge
The Dollar Business magazine
in the business of exports-imports. Welcome to globalisation!
Print version No. of Issues Cover Price e-Magazine No. of Issues Cover Price Total Price Discount You pay
12 1,200 12 1,200 2,400 55% 1,080
INR 24 2,400 INR 24 2,400 4,800 60% 1,920
36 3,600
12 24
36 3,600 7,200 65% 2,520
12 24 48 50% 24**
USD 24 48 USD 24 48 96 55% 43**
36 72 36 72 144 60% 58**
No additional delivery charges apply to India-based subscribers. **Rates exclusive of airmail charges for all international subscribers. [Applicable annual additional charges: $50 for all international subscribers.] Issues wil be despatched using regular India Post international mail service. Vimbri Media Pvt. Ltd. is not liable for postal delays. NOTE: All approved subscriptions include both Print & e-Magazine offers. TERMS & CONDITIONS 1. This is a limited period offer. 2. The Dollar Business and Vimbri Media Pvt. Ltd. will not be held responsible in case of any postal / courier delay in delivery of any issue of the magazine. 3. The Dollar Business and Vimbri Media Pvt. Ltd. will not be held responsible in case of any production delay that leads to late delivery of any issue to its subscriber(s). 4. If for any reason, a certain issue of The Dollar Business is not published, the subscription will automatically be extended by a month. 5. The Dollar Business and Vimbri Media Pvt. Ltd. reserve the right to terminate any subscription or accept or reject any request for subscription. 6. Disputes, if any, are subject to the exclusive jurisdiction of courts in Hyderabad only. 7. Any change in periodicity of The Dollar Business magazine may apply to existing subscribers. They will continue receiving the same number of issues they had originally subscribed to. They duration between issues may however stand duly altered.
8. Any change in the cover price of The Dollar Business magazine will not apply to existing subscribers. They will continue receiving the same number of issues they had originally subscribed to. 9. It is the sole responsibility of the subscriber(s) to report delay in delivery of any issue of the magazine to the subscription department of The Dollar Business within 14 days of the issue release date. 10. It is the sole responsibility of the subscriber(s) to report non-receipt of any issue of the magazine to the subscription department of The Dollar Business within 30 days of the issue release date. 11. Terms and conditions may be altered without notice to the subscribers. 12. For Delivery, Return and Refund Policies, and for more information on Subscriptions, please log on to www.thedollarbusiness.com
For subscription-related queries, please write to us at subscription@thedollarbusiness.com or call us on +91 40 67609999. Weâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;d love to hear from you! You can also write to us at: The Dollar Business, Vimbri Media Pvt. Ltd., Level III & IV, 8-2-542/A, Road No. 7, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad 500 034, Telangana, IN
Subscription for
1 Year (12 issues) INR 1,080 / USD 24**
2 Year (24 issues) INR 1,920 / USD 43**
3 Year (36 issues) INR 2,520 / USD 58**
**Rates exclusive of airmail charges for all international subscribers. All international subscribers are requested to add applicable annual additional charges of $50 I WANT TO RECEIVE MY MAGAZINE COPY THROUGH COURIER AND AGREE TO PAY AN ADDITIONAL CHARGE OF INR 360 A YEAR TO COVER FOR THE SERVICEOVER AND ABOVE THE ABOVEMENTIONED SUBSCRIPTION PRICE (EG. FOR A 1 YR. SUBSCRIPTION, TOTAL CHARGES INCLUSIVE OF COURIER IS INR 1,440)
SIMPLY ENCLOSE YOUR BUSINESS CARD OR FILL THE BELOW-MENTIONED FIELDS TO SUBSCRIBE Mr. Ms. Name: Address:
Dr.
I am enclosing a Cheque / DD No:.................................. dated drawn on......................................... .........................................................................................
City: State:
for INR1,080 / INR1,920 / INR2,520 favouring Vimbri Media Pvt. Ltd. payable at Hyderabad
Pin code:
Telephone no.(s): Email: Date of Birth (DD/MM/YYYY): Company:
SUBSCRIBE BY LOGGING ON TO WWW.THEDOLLARBUSINESS.COM AND PAYING ONLINE (MANDATORY FOR ALL INTERNATIONAL SUBSCRIBERS) OR FILL THE BELOW-MENTIONED PARTICULARS OF PAYMENT THROUGH CHEQUE / DD MODE
Add Rs.50 for non-Hyderabad cheques (not required for At Par cheques). Please write your name and address on the reverse of the cheque/DD. Do not send cash. Please send the filled form to:
Industry:
The Dollar Business, Vimbri Media Pvt. Ltd., Level III & IV, 8-2-542/A, Road No. 7, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad 500 034, Telangana, IN
SUBSCRIPTION REQUESTS CAN BE PLACED BY LOGGING ON TO WWW.THEDOLLARBUSINESS.COM, FILLING-IN NECESSARY DETAILS IN THE APPLICATION FORM GIVEN AND MAKING PAYMENTS USING CREDIT CARDS/ DEBIT CARDS OR VIA NET BANKING
To advertise / subscribe, please call us on +91 40 67609999 or write to us directly on reachus@thedollarbusiness.com or log on to www.thedollarbusiness.com
<< CUT OUT THE DOTTED LINE >>
Please fill this form and mail it with your remittance to:
<< CUT OUT THE DOTTED LINE>>
The Dollar Business Vimbri Media Pvt. Ltd. Level III & IV, 8-2-542/A, Road No. 7, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad, Telangana – 500 034, IN Tel: +91-40-67609999 Email: subscription@thedollarbusiness.com www.thedollarbusiness.com
<<FOLD HERE>>
The Dollar Business Vimbri Media Pvt. Ltd. Level III & IV, 8-2-542/A, Road No. 7, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad, Telangana – 500 034, IN
<<FOLD HERE>>
<<FOLD HERE>>
From To:
BUSINESS REPLY MAIL AFFIX POSTAGE STAMP HERE <<
> E> LI N
<< FOLD HERE >> CU TT HE DO TT ED
ED TT DO HE
LIN E>
TT CU <<
>
TDB FORUM I want to export live goat / sheep to Dubai from India. Can you please advise me on how to go about it? Is it necessary to have an office setup and a trade license in Dubai to export? [Khurram, Co-owner, Prakash Agrotech, +91-8130716XXX, khurramimam@gmail.com]
Dear Khurram: While exports of live goat and sheep to Dubai is allowed from India, there are certain procedures that need to be followed for the same. The first step of course will be to obtain an Importer Exporter Code (IEC). This can be obtained from the Directorate General of ForI want to export surgical products and sports goods from India. I already have an Importer Exporter Code (IEC). How do I find overseas buyers of these products? (Ankit Pra-
japati, Proprietor, Oso Contractor & Suppliers, +91-9634113XXX, ankitk536@ gmail.com)
Dear Ankit: We are happy to hear of your decision to head into the world of foreign trade. You can approach your concerned associations – Pharmaceuticals Export Promotion Council (PHARMEXCIL) for pharma products and Sports Goods Export Promotion Council (SGEPC) for sports goods – for assistance or directly reach out to potential buyers by posting your product information on https://www.thedollarbusiness.com/marketplace. From discovering the best markets to source from or supply to, to overcoming statutory and procedural challenges with respect to exports-imports documentation, to identifying the right logistics partners, International Marketplace understands all your requirements and accordingly connects you with the right market and partners so that you can make a fortune out of foreign trade. Additionally, you can also explore The Dollar Business CONQUER Programme (You can read more on
eign Trade. The Dollar Business will be happy to help you in acquiring the IEC. Further, for exporting livestock to Dubai, one needs to fulfill the livestock health requirements of the Emirate of Dubai and furnish self-certified copies of health record, including vaccination record, of the animal. An Export Quarantine Certificate will be issued by the Animal Quarantine and Certification System of the Government of India after physical examination/quarantine observation of the animal 2-3 days prior to the shipment date. If required, the animal may be referred
for detailed clinical examination including testing. If the animal is not healthy/fit, certificate is not issued. The animal may be subject to testing at the entry point in Dubai. Coming to the second part of your question, you don’t need an office or license in Dubai to export from India, however the buyer will need a license to import into Dubai.
TDB CONQUER Programme on https://www.thedollarbusiness.com) that gives an in-the-making super successful exporter like you the access to TDB EXIMAPS (https:// www.thedollarbusiness.com/exim-maps), the most powerful buyer discovery and competition analysis tool for Indian exporters, which ensures you touch newer highs in global trade. In case you have further queries, do write back to us.
I want to export charcoal. What are the countries that buy acacia wood charcoal? (Rajesh, Rajesh Enterprise,
Response by: Manish K. Pandey Editor, The Dollar Business
Is there any export incentive available under Merchandise Exports from India Scheme (MEIS) for Indian Kabuli Chickpeas (HS Code: 07132000)? (Bharat Parekh, Director, Tricos Exports Pvt. Ltd., +919820034XXX, tricosexports@gmail.com)
Dear Bharat: Indian Kabuli Chickpeas (HS Code: 07132000) does not qualify for MEIS benefit or any other such benefit under the new Foreign Trade Policy FY2015-2020. Response by: Dr. A. K. Sengupta Chief Consulting Editor, The Dollar Business
Response by: Steven Philip Warner President (VMPL) & Editor-in-Chief, The Dollar Business
rajeshlakhani675@gmail.com)
Dear Rajesh: We assume you are interested in exporting wood charcoal falling under HS Code: 44029090. Industry data reveals that India is not a big exporter of wood charcoal falling under the said HS Code. In fact, India ranks 26th in the world when it comes to exports of wood charcoal and accounts for just 0.81% share in global exports of the product. India’s only significant export destination for the product falling under the said HS Code is Bhutan (the country accounts for about 96% of India’s total exports of the product), though the country is also exporting the product to Netherlands, Czech Republic and Sri Lanka in small quantities. Further, sadly, India’s exports under the HS Code: 44029090 has only been falling over the last few years. More of such pure, researched data is available to TDB license holders. (You can read more on https://www.thedollarbusiness. com/memberships). Response by: Indranil Das Executive Editor, The Dollar Business
You can log on to www.thedollarbusiness.com/tdb-forum and submit your foreign trade-related queries, or write across to our experts at editorial@thedollarbusiness.com. Every question matters – to your business, to The Dollar Business. JANUARY 2018 II THE DOLLAR BUSINESS 49
BORDERLINE
EDITOR’S COLUMN
ALL EYES ARE ON YOU, MR. FINANCE MINISTER
C
ome February 01, 2018 and all eyes would be on Finance Minister Arun Jaitley. After all, he would be presenting the current government’s first Budget post GST and probably the last before the next Lok Sabha elections. And also because this Budget would decide the fate of the various flagship programmes of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government – not to say, the most important of them all, the Make in India programme. When announced in 2014, just after the Modi-led government took over the reins of power at the Centre, Make in India seemed a timely response to a challenging situation that posed a grave danger to India’s manufacturing community. While the overall Index of Industrial Production (IIP) was pointing towards a weaker-than-ever economy (overall IIP growth was down from 8.2% in FY2011 to 1.1% and -0.9% in FY2013 and FY2014, respectively), manufacturing sector growth had slowed down to 1.3% in FY2014 from 8.9% in FY2011. With Make in India, the objective was to arrest the fall by boosting entrepreneurship (in both the manufacturing and service sectors) in India. And how? By focusing on “New Processes”, “New Infrastructure”, “New Sectors” and “New Mindset” – the four basic pillars on which the programme was based. And it did, to an extent. But has the initiative really been able to deliver what it promised is a question worth pondering. Chart 1: Manufacturing Gross Value Added (% of GDP)
Chart 2: Manufacturing Exports Trade Balance (% of GDP)
Source: Economic Survey 2018
www.thedollarbusiness/blogs/manish 50 THE DOLLAR BUSINESS II JANUARY 2018
Manish K. Pandey Editor, The Dollar Business
If the recently released Economic Survey 2018 is anything to go by, then perhaps we have an answer. We know that boosting manufacturing and enhancing the sector’s international competitiveness have been the twin goals of the Make in India programme. While the share of manufacturing in GDP has improved slightly over the last few years (Chart 1), the international competitiveness of manufacturing has not made great strides and is clearly reflected in the declining manufacturing export-GDP ratio and manufacturing trade balance (Chart 2). Even when it comes to the share of manufacturing value added (MVA) in gross domestic product (GDP), India stands nowhere close to its Asian peers. While countries like China and Thailand can boast of over 27% MVA share in GDP, India’s share of MVA in GDP is just 18.10%. Interestingly, the industries that dominate the manufacturing sector in China are the same as those in the developed nations, reflecting the dragon’s ability to displace local producers in those markets. However, that’s not the case with India, which still focuses on just a few sectors when it comes to value-addition. Interestingly, foreign direct investment (FDI) trends too give an indication that the Make in India bandwagon hasn’t jumped the track. According to ‘World Investment Report 2017’ by the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, India received $44 billion as FDI in CY2016, reporting a 29.41% rise from CY2014. Of course, India has a long way to go before it catches up with China that attracted $134 billion as FDI in CY2016. On a positive side though, according to the Economic Survey 2018, “high frequency indicators do suggest that a robust recovery is taking hold as reflected in a variety of indicators, including overall GVA, manufacturing GVA, the IIP, gross capital formation and exports.” Agreed. But not totally! While the indicators seem to be moving in the right direction, India’s manufacturing sector continues to operate below potential. And we have already discussed the numbers. Will the Budget 2018 provide the sector the much-needed push? Well, you will have the answer soon! @MK_Pandey
RNI: APENG/2014/54643; POSTAL REG. NO.: H/SD/486/17-19. Date of posting: 21st - 22nd of every month. Date of Publication: 20th of every month.