The Great North Arrow $2.85 + .15 Tax
$3.00
Written by Our People...For Our People....est. 20107
Issue 6- Volume : 12
Small towns & proud ... connecting communities
88364
07204
7
March 15th-2025
Servicing the Almaguin & Parry Sound Districts Lots of exciting things going on at Magnetawan Building Centre. We’ve add Leadbetters products to our store. Come check out the selection of frozen meats. Also don’t forget to grab something from our M&M Express Freezers. We’ve added a few new items. Get those seeds started, before you know it we’ll be able to put them outside. Thinking of a project? Let our knowledgeable staff help you find what you need!
5 Burrows St Magnetawan, ON, Canada P0A 1P0 1 705-387-3988
WHY? ARMOUR WHY?
BESS- A DISASTER IN THE MAKING? (internet photo) ALMAGUIN: CYNDI CULBERT Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS) are being proposed in various locations across Ontario, including Armour Township. However, there is growing concern over the risks associated with lithium-ion batteries, which are known for their potential to cause thermal runaway, fires, and explosions. These risks raise serious questions about the community’s ability to effectively manage emergencies and protect residents, first responders, and the environment. The environmental impact of lithium battery fires is significant. Incidents like the Moss Landing fire have demonstrated the dangers of toxic chemical release, air pollution, and water contamination. Armour Township’s pristine natural environment, particularly its connection to the Magnetawan River Watershed, faces serious threats should a fire or chemical leak occur. Lithium battery fires are extremely difficult, if not impossible, to extinguish. A fire could spread rapidly, especially in summer months, affecting homes, wildlife, and air quality for generations. Lithium battery fires cannot be put out with traditional methods, requiring specialized training
and equipment for firefighters. Armour Township’s emergency response capabilities are already stretched thin. The facility is located within the Magnetawan River Watershed, increasing the risk of hazardous runoff into local water systems. Toxic chemicals released in a fire could pose serious health risks to residents and wildlife. The risks associated with BESS facilities could significantly impact home values, especially in the event of an environmental disaster. The company behind
the proposal, SOLARBANK , plans to monitor the facility remotely, meaning few, if any, local jobs would be created. Many businesses in the area rely on tourism. Environmental damage could have long-term consequences for hunting, fishing, and other outdoor industries. The company has only set aside $60,000 for property remediation in 2047, a significantly inadequate amount given the potential risks. A meeting was held at the Katrine Community Center in
November 2022, introducing the project. However, community awareness appears to have been limited, with few residents informed about the meeting or the proposal. A Facebook group, “Armour Township: Say NO to Lithium Battery Storage In Our Community,” was created on February 10, 2025, to rally opposition and share concerns. Records indicate that only three residents attended a December 2022 meeting regarding community engagement. Additionally, official
documents from September and December 2024 claim that community consultations took place, but many residents remain unaware. A similar BESS proposal in Gravenhurst was ultimately scrapped due to public opposition and logistical challenges. Many residents are hoping for the same outcome in Armour Township, emphasizing the importance of public engagement and government accountability. Local officials have been contacted, but responses have been limited. The Armour Township Mayor’s office has acknowledged concerns, and PPC Federal candidate Isabel Pereira has engaged with opposition organizers. However, the Ontario government holds the power to override local decisions, making it critical for residents to present a united front. Contact Graydon Smith, MPP, to express opposition. Attend upcoming council meetings (dates TBD) and ensure strong community representation. Sign the petition at Change.org. Email Armour Township Clerk, Charlene Watt, at clerk@armourtownship. ca to formally submit concerns. Stay updated through community BESS Continued on Pg B11
SPLASH OR BELLY FLOP THE POOL IN PARRY SOUND ROBIN PLUMB PARRY SOUND: Here's some more pool information that has not been disclosed publicly by the Pool Board. For the past year at least, the Project has been facing a funding gap that places it at high risk of insolvency. Last summer a few of the municipalities provided an emergency loan of $1.3MM to pay invoices to avoid defaulting on those contracts. According to Carling's representative, the critical $13.5MM loan is still not in place. The Board has been working on that for at least a year. Since construction has ramped up, the insolvency risk not only remains but is now significantly higher. There is almost no
chance that any lender would knowingly agree to lend into an almost certain default situation. By the Board's own estimates of remaining costs, the Project is short $8MM. This depends upon every contract being done within budget, which is almost impossible. With a modest and reasonable 10% overage, the funding
shortfall would be $13MM--about the same as the loan, no coincidence. It would appear that the Board knows the true most likely funding shortfall. The Board has got itself into a serious bind that seems to have only two solutions: going back to the ratepayers for $13.5MM or cancelling the project, which would save $50MM
over 10 years (the remaining $20MM in project costs net of penalties and the $3MM in annual operating subsidies). The municipalities were told it would only cost ratepayers $8.5MM, and unwisely they paid it all upfront in 2022. Seguin Mayor, Ann MacDiarmid, promised in 2022 that she would raise $10MM by Septem-
Elbows Up!
ber 2023 to convince the Board to increase the size of the project, changing from the more affordable 4-lane recreational pool to a 6-lane competition pool. Only $1.2MM in commitments have been raised to date. MacDiarmid recently was quoted in the paper as saying that ratepayers have already provided sufficient contributions. So, the Board apparently believes that it cannot ask the municipalities to contribute the $13.5MM (which equates to another tax increase of about 3-5%, depending on the municipality). The Board has pinned its ability to avoid insolvency on a large loan. But with no source of repayment, PS Pool Continued on Page A2
David Sheepway / Realtor / Port Loring Branch Manager
Working For You! www.loringrestoulerealestate.com
705-757-1421 / team.sheepway@gmail.com / Parry Sound / Muskoka Realty Ltd. / Port Loring Branch