May 1993 GHPA Newsletter

Page 1

For Preservation NewsCetter of tfie Greater Mouston J'reser\1ation AC(iance

I V0i..UME9.NUMBER2

M-\y, 1993

Bill by Congressman Andrews may revive historic tax credits

Market Square Historic District: case study in preservation perseverance

{I

u" .~

U ~

~ 0

:I: ':"': L ' ''--

----.

90 "B.

GHPA took U.S. Congressman Mike Andrews on a walking tour in downtown Houston on April 7 to look at some of the many examples of historic buildings in need of improved economic incentives to spur their preservation and rehabilitation. Andrews is co-sponsoring a bill in Washington that will partially restore tax credits for certified rehabilitation of historic buildings. Renovations dropped by about 80 percent after passage of the 1986 Tax Reform Act, which severely restricted the use of the historic tax credits.

GHCVB moves to historic district

Turn-Verein building headed for demolition After years of neglect and vandalism, the National Registerlisted Houston Turn-Verein Clubhouse appears headed for demolition to make way for a new Walgreen drug store. Located at 5202 Almeda, the Houston Turn-Verein Clubhouse is a 2-story, white building of reinforced concrete, hollow tile, brick and stucco. This fourth building of the Houston Turn-Verein Association

Modern Movement. Details of the panels above door openings depict bowlers and bowling pins, a hint of the activities inside. Joseph Finger (1887-1953) was one of the first architects in Houston to design in the Moderne manner. Several redevelopment schemes have been proposed during the past decade, but none of the re-use projects has materialized. In June 1991, a hearing by the City of Hous-

by Eddie Webster As the new president of the Greater Houston Convention and Visitors Bureau, I'm delighted at the numerous changes we are making on behalf of Houston's hospitality community. Our first-and most encouraging change-was our recent relocation to Houston's historic Market Square. Finally our offices are in a more accessible location to visitors and, more importantly, in an area of which we can be proud. The tens of thousands of visitors who come through our offices each year will now be in the heart of one of Houston's historic districts. I believe this will help call attention to the Market Square area and its unique and historic architecture. The contrast between our gleaming skyline and eclectic historic buildings appeals greatly to tourists as evidenced in our downtown walking tours which continue to be popular with visitors. It is my hope that the Bureau's move to this area will provide the catalyst needed for new business development as well as future renovations of these buildings. continued inside

Persistence is finally paying off in Houston 's Market Square Historic District as recent preservation successes rejuvenate the area. As the Greater Houston Preservation Alliance celebrates its 15th anniversary this year, we can all be proud of GHPA's role in the revitalization of our city's birthplace. When the Alliance was incorporated in 1978, one of its prime concerns was the deteriorating condition of the Market Square area. While the Market Square Association and the Old Town Development Corporation were already working to promote the area as an entertainment and tourist center for Houston, the Alliance, under the leadership of two of its presidents Beverly Pennington and Bart Truxillo, adopted an approach to protecting the district that combined education and activism. In 1981, with partial funding from the Cultural Arts Council of Houston, the Alliance published Last o/the Past: Houston Architecture 1847 to 1915, by William Scott Field. Public walking tours were initiated. A 1982 calendar illustrated important buildings in watercolor renderings. Although the District was nominated to the National Register of Historic Places in ) 982, on the initiative of the Old Town group, the absence of specific legal protections and economic incentives to stimulate preservation and rehabilitation resulted in the loss of many historic buildings. The Zindler Building, South Texas National Bank, Warren's Inn, the RadoffBuilding and many others fell to the wrecking ball, sometimes in the middle of the night. And as Houston real estate values skyrocketed in the early 80s, newly constructed office towers loomed like a relentless host of titans threatening the fragile historic district in downtown 's north end. In one hold-out transaction at the corner of Congress and Main, the historic B.A. Shepherd Building, which soon after was demolished, sold for $600 per square foot based on land! Fortunately, the sweeping federal economic incentives afforded by the 1976 Tax Reform Act and the 1981 Economic Recovery Tax Act (ERTA) helped to mitigate the otherwise unremitting destruction of historic structures. ERT A provided a 25% investment tax credit (ITC) on the rehabilitation costs of income-

producing, designated historic structures and a 20% ITC on the rehabilitation costs of non-historic income producing buildings more than 40 years of age. Buildings that benefited included the Hogg Building, which shed its aluminum slipcover; the Lancaster Hotel; Kiam's Department Store; and the genteel old State National Bank Building. The Pillot Building, Houston's oldest three-story commercial structure and only example of cast iron architectural detailing was saved largely through the advocacy of the Alliance. In 1985, Harris County, the Pillot Building's owner, was finally persuaded to lease it for 50 years to a developer who would restore it to its former prominence. Dick Knight of The City Partnership won the lease/ bid. Although the restoration was fraught with seemingly unending challenges, including the collapse of most of the exterior walls, the project was finally completed in 1990. Today the delightful Pillot Cafe, occupying the ground floor and adjacent courtyard, continues to grow in popUlarity. In 1988, the Alliance coordinated a symposium, co-sponsored with several other local organizations and chaired by Stephen Fox, to explore the possibilities for preservation through economic development in the Market Square District. Subsequently, a task force chaired by Minnette Boesel of the Downtown Houston Association, developed key recommendations for preservation in three areas: economic development, urban design, and promotion. To market the revitalization plan of the task force, the Alliance proposed publishing a promotional booklet. With grants from the Cultural Arts Council of Houston and the College of Fellows Fund of the American Architectural Foundation, supplemented with funds from the Downtown Houston Association, a brochure entitled "It's Time to Capitalize On Our Historic Assets" was published. The three major recommendations advanced were: (1) to establish a revolving/loan fund to purchase, lease or rehabilitate endangered buildings; (2) to implement a three-year historic district management program with a fulltime director; and (3) to initiate a comprehensive development strategy that would create public/private partnerships and financial incentive packages. continued inside

Rehab project under way at Cannata Houses

.;:;

째e ~

'" ~

~

t was designed by Joseph Finger in ) 929 on the 75th anniversary of the Houston Turners, at a cost of $150,000. For forty years this familiar landmark housed the activities of Houston's oldest German social and fraternal club. In 1969, this location was vacated in favor of a new suburban location near Sharpstown. The Turn-Verein Clubhouse is one of the few buildings in Houston to make extensive use of zig-zag Moderne detailing. This Moderne style, which achieved wide-spread popularity in the United States in the late I 920s, is an amalgamation of various tendencies in both American and European architecture of the

ton determined the roofless structure to be a dangerous building. The Walgreen developer lacks only a city permit to proceed with demolition. Although GHPA has been meeting over the past several weeks with representatives of Walgreen Drug Stores, the Midtown Civic Association, and Houston City Councilmember AI Calloway to explore preservation alternatives, no solution has been identified that will save the building. As a last resort, provisions are being worked out with Unicorp Asset Management, Inc., Walgreen's developer, to compile a record of the building for the local architectural archives.

As previously announced, GHPA is receiving a $5,000 grant from the Texas Historical Commission for the Cannata Houses. The objectives of the project are: (I) to restore both houses on the exterior following the Secretary of Interior's Standards for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings; (2) to bring the interior of both houses up to City of Houston Building Code; (3) to make affordable housing available for qualified low income persons. The Old Sixth Ward Community Development Corporation, with whom GHPA is working to identify potential purchasers for these two houses, has been interviewing applicants and think they are close to finding buyers who will meet the qualifications required by Texas Commerce Bank, who will be the mortgage lender. Phase I includes termite treatment, foundation repair and leveling, all part of the necessary first step to stabilize the two houses. Termite treatment is finished and appears to have been successful. In the foundation repair, existing piers and beams will be repaired where possible. Materials of comparable size and

"8 ::< ~

c

~

<C

<;

! The first phase of work for the rehabilitation of GHPA's two residential properties in the Old Sixth Ward Historic District has been initiated. strength will be used when replacement is required. GHPA is soliciting donations of items needed for the Cannata Houses, including 2000 sq. ft. of shingles, 600 sq. ft. of exterior siding, 600 sq. ft. of flooring decking, 450 linear ft. of plumbing pipe, 2 bath tubs, 2 bathroom sinks. 2 toilets, 2 kitchen sinks, 2 garbage

disposals, cabinets for kitchens and bathrooms, interior and exterior paint, 3600 sq. ft. attic and floor bat insulation, and 300 linear ft. of cedar fence. If you or someone you know may be interested in donating to this worthwhile preservation project, please call the GHPA office for a complete list of items needed.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
May 1993 GHPA Newsletter by Preservation Houston - Issuu