november 1, 2017 volume 53, issue 2
the Everything Greenhill
evergreengreenhill.org
A Star-Spangled Controversy
Exploring the National Anthem Debate at Greenhill
Photo by Alice Zhang
A TEAM UNITED: On Friday, Oct. 20, the Greenhill Football team played against Fort Worth Christian School. At the game, players and coaches lined up to face the American flag at the end of Brinkmann Field. With hands on their teammates shoulders, they all stood in unity while the anthem was played.
Joseph Weinberg Editor-in-Chief
Hayden Jacobs Sports Editor
Jeffrey Harberg News Editor
Assistant Head of School Tom Perryman’s voice echoed across Brinkmann Field before the start of Greenhill’s home football game on Thursday, Sept. 28, just like it has for over 20 years. “Please rise, remove your hats, and join us in the singing of our national anthem,” he told the crowd. Almost all in attendance at Brinkmann Field that night –players, coaches, fans, and officials– obliged, rising from the bleachers to stand as they’ve grown accustomed to doing all their lives. Ten Greenhill cheerleaders did not oblige. They instead chose to kneel during the anthem, joining a growing number of athletes from across the country who, inspired by former NFL quarterback Colin Kaepernick, have chosen to kneel during the anthem. Kaepernick drew national attention last year when a photo of him sitting during the national anthem of the San Francisco 49ers third preseason game went viral. Kaepernick explained his decision to sit in an interview following the game. “I am not going to stand up to show pride in a flag for a country that oppresses black people and people of color,” Kaepernick said. “To me, this is bigger than football, and it would be selfish on my part to look the other way. There are bodies in the street and people getting paid leave and getting away with murder.”
Views
A staff editorial on honest conversations p. 2
News
After Kaepernick spoke with Nate Boyer, a Seattle Seahawks player and military veteran, he switched his form of protest from sitting during the anthem to kneeling. Boyer told Kaepernick that he thought kneeling would be a more respectful gesture to the flag than sitting. The protests have ignited a nationwide debate, with athletes, celebrities and politicians weighing in on the controversy. President Donald Trump has criticized those who have kneeled for the anthem. At a political rally in September, he referred to NFL players who knelt during the anthem using vulgar language. Vice President Mike Pence has shown strong support for standing during the anthem as well. On October 8, Pence walked out of an NFL game after kickoff when several San Francisco 49ers players took a knee during the pregame signing of “The StarSpangled Banner.” Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones has said players who disrespect the flag during the anthem will not play for the team. Still, many NFL players continue to kneel or sit for the anthem before games. Colin Kaepernick remains a free agent, leaving people questioning if he would have a job had he refrained from protestesting. The simple request, “please rise” by the announcer of a big sporting event or leader of an assembly has long been accepted by the public. The anthem, meant to be a national unifying source of patriotism, is now mired in controversy. cont’d on pages10-11
An op-ed on a human rights controversy p. 5
Informing Greenhill since 1966
Features
A profile of Greenhill’s student astronomer p. 7
“I am not going to stand up to show pride in a flag for a country that oppresses black people and people of color.” -Colin Kaepernick August 2016
Arts
Alan Michnoff ‘09 works in the film industry p. 13
Sports
Boys volleyball aims to capture SPC title p.16
4141 Spring Valley Road, Addison, TX 75001