Invited Commentary
Commentary: Application of the OTAGO Exercise/Fall Prevention Program in the Long-Term Care Setting by Tiffany Shubert, PT, PhD Congratulations to Dr. Ecsedy, Dr. Hudlikar and Ms. Depner for the publication of “Application of the Otago Exercise/Fall Prevention Program in the Long-Term Care Setting”, published in the May 2021 issue of GeriNotes. This study is an excellent example of how the physical therapy profession should be innovating in care delivery to maximize patient outcomes. The authors may receive feedback that they did not implement the Otago Exercise Program (OEP) with fidelity. Given their thoughtful implementation model and their impressive results, I would argue this is not the case. Many evidence-based health promotion programs such as Matter Of Balance, the Chronic Disease SelfManagement Program, and Stepping On are grounded in theories of behavior change and are designed to be delivered by a “lay leader” (not a healthcare professional). These programs need to be delivered in a very specific, scripted way to maintain fidelity to the program. The OEP is also an evidence-based program; however the fidelity requirements are different. There is not a formal behavior change element in the program, no script to follow. The program works if the individual receives the appropriate type, intensity, and dose of exercise (Shubert, TE). Doing the exercises, not necessarily the delivery and the setting, is what I would argue is the fidelity requirement of the OEP. The authors have demonstrated that by keeping fidelity to the exercise intervention, this population demonstrated similar or even better outcomes than in the original OEP research. In the May 2021 issue of Gerinotes I proposed key ingredients for a successful implementation of the OEP. These ingredients were all integrated into this project. Ingredient 1 - “Grounded in the principles of exercise science” The authors developed a standard program to ensure the participants engaged in 45-60 minutes sessions of OEP exercises 3 times a week. Within those sessions the authors had the opportunity to monitor and progress each participant. They incorporated walking as part of the exercise session. More important, they engaged the appropriate participants to promote walking with– either without supervision or integrated into their daily routine. The program design met the requirements of the OEP - 3 sessions of approximately 30 minutes of strength and balance a week and 3 sessions of up to 30 minutes of walking three times a week. I want to highlight by offering this program to residents, the authors may have had an GeriNotes • August 2021 • Vol. 28 No. 4
impact not only on patients but on the interdisciplinary teams. I have been in several situations where our fellow team members in LTC observe their residents participating in an exercise program that it is safe, fun, and challenging. They see residents exercising in standing and see them getting stronger. This often results in facility-wide support of opportunities to promote more walking and movement. Ingredient 2 – Self-efficacy and Ownership of Health Given the typical clinical presentation of a patient in long term care, it is not reasonable or feasible to expect all patients to be able to participate independently in a home exercise program. In addition, these patients often benefit from the clinical expertise of a PT or PTA to ensure exercises are performed at appropriate intensity. This provides the time for the patient to safely improve their strength, endurance, and confidence to engage in exercises independently. I commend the authors for recognizing this fact and offering the OEP in a format that was tailored to the needs of this patient population. It was offered consistently, supervised, and for a long enough duration that participants would experience improvements in strength and balance and start to “own” their program. Ingredient 3 – Fidelity to Key Components The key component of the OEP is the exercise prescription. This means delivering the OEP exercises plus a walking program at a frequency of 6 sessions a week, at an intensity that challenges the patient. The authors clearly delivered the OEP exercise prescription as intended and created a program that standardized the delivery with fidelity, ensuring the participants were able to receive the appropriate dose of exercise. And guess what? It worked! The data for the 63 participants who engaged in the program for 6 months clearly shows that participation in the OEP program, as a group intervention in a LTC environment, results in improvements in functional outcome measures and fewer falls. I have a feeling that there were also outcomes that were not measured – such as patient self-efficacy, patient and family satisfaction, and staff satisfaction will have an even greater impact in the overall culture of these facilities. Offering these types of programs will ultimately demonstrate significant value to all stakeholders in this space. 14
