A Tale of Two Mensches:
Why (and How) Donald Margulies wrote a Christmas play by amy levinson
Geffen Playhouse founder Gil Cates and Playwright Donald Margulies
ACT I The birth of an idea Often when I speak to writers about the genesis of their plays, I am surprised at what inspires their ideas. But this idea, to have one of America’s preeminent Jewish playwrights — a writer who often explores Jewish themes in his work — write a Christmas play, was an idea that started with our late founder and producing director Gil Cates. Of course, the seeds for this unlikely commission were planted long ago, when Cates directed Margulies’ play P4 PERFORMANCES MAGAZINe
Collected Stories. This production, which went on to become a film for PBS, marked the first of many collaborations and the beginning of a profound friendship between the two men. Following the extraordinary success of that play, the theater produced Dinner with Friends, Shipwrecked! An Entertainment: The Amazing Adventures of Louis de Rougemont and Time Stands Still, which was commissioned by the Geffen and had its world premiere here before opening on Broadway. The question Margulies couldn’t help but ask in regards to a Christmas commission, though, was, “Why me?” And for Gil and the Geffen, that answer was crystal clear. The idea arose during the run of Margulies’ play Shipwrecked! The play was originally commissioned by South Coast Repertory to be