Issue 7 of The Observer. May 4, 2017

Page 1

Observer the

MAY 4, 2017 VOLUME XXXVIII, ISSUE 7

www.fordhamobserver.com

Student Protesters Clash with Public Safety

Fourteen Charged After Rose Hill Skirmish

By STEPHAN KOZUB News Editor

The Fordham community’s social media was lit up Thursday afternoon with videos showing physical altercations between members of the Office of Public Safety and two Fordham students during a protest outside the office of University President Rev. Joseph M. McShane, S.J. Two Public Safety supervisors were later treated for injuries. In the live stream uploaded by Fordham Students United (FSU), a suited man, identified by FSU as Security Services Investigator William J. McSorley, and a female student who declined to be identified appear to be locked in a physical battle against the wall of the hallway at Cunniffe House at Fordham Rose Hill (FRH) at the start of the video. “You’re hurting me!” Sorley repeatedly yells. “Ow, my leg, you’re pulling on my leg!” He appears to be blocking the movement of the student with his body, as she shouts “It’s honestly getting hard to breathe back here.” “Then get off me,” he replies. “I’m not on you!” she screams back. In the original live streamed video that was published to the FSU Facebook page, another student could be seen allegedly shoving a public safety officer and grabbing his collar. The video has since been taken down and replaced with an edited version that omits this part of the altercation. The person holding the recording phone at one point falls to the ground, and after a few moments is asked to leave the area. The FSU protest, the latest in what has become a string of rallies in favor of Fordham Faculty United (FFU)’s push to unionize, met on the steps of Walsh Library around 1 p.m. Participants marched to Cunniffe House, where last week they say they were told that McShane “had more important things to do” than respond to their requests for conversation. According to the University statement, a group of student protesters forced their way into the foyer of the president’s office. Public Safety supervisors blocked the entrance, the statement reads, and “demonstrators vigorously attempted to physically remove a supervisor from in front of the door,” refusing “multiple commands…to leave the entrance.” Student organizer Sapphira Lurie, Fordham College at Lincoln Center (FCLC) ’17, said the supervisor who “pinned” a student against the wall, seen in the video, “ran ahead of” the protesters to block the door. “[The student] was kind of trapped behind him and eventually he started to crush her…Eventually she was allowed to get out but only after protesters were chanting ‘Let her go,’ ‘She can’t breathe,’ because she was saying that she was having difficulty breathing as he was see CLASH pg. 2

GEORGE HORIHAN/THE OBSERVER

Protesters for Fordham Students United were stopped from entering Cunniffe House by Public Safety. until 5 p.m. on April 30 on an InterStudent and veteran Kyle Prütz, By ELIZABETH LANDRY & im Suspension from Housing and FCRH ’17, who stood near the door COLIN SHEELEY Access Restriction. In some cases, during the physical altercation News Editor Emerita & the letters also barred students from was also confronted by three PubNews Editor Rose Hill campus entirely, and offi- lic Safety officers when he tried to cially warned that another violation leave the area. After other protestAt least 14 students have been of the University Code of Conduct ers questioned why he was being brought under sanctions by Dean and University Regulations may re- physically held and asked to provide of Fordham Rose Hill (FRH) Chris- sult in action “up to and including identification, the officers let him topher Rodgers for last Thursday’s suspension from the University.” go. He said his glasses were broken altercation at Cunniffe House beThe full statement from the uni- in the incident and that he received tween Fordham Students United versity says that after “demonstra- a disciplinary email the next day. (FSU) protesters and Public Safety tors refused multiple requests from The new university statement officers. Public Safety supervisors to leave also called protesters’ claims “spuWhen a protest to get Univer- the entrance[,] Public Safety even- rious” and stated “[Several] videos sity President Joseph M. McShane, tually cleared the protesters from have been selectively (and decepS.J. to respond to unionizing efforts the foyer to the porch of Cunniffe tively) edited to give the impression moved into the building’s foyer, House, where they were allowed to that Public Safety supervisors used Public Safety supervisors blocked continue their protest. No protest- undue force against the protesters.” access to the reception area. Vid- ers were injured.” However, the It references the original livestream eo footage posted online by FSU, university maintained that because video which was taken down within The Fordham Observer, the paper of the “seriousness” of the students’ two hours of posting, saying that and The Fordham Ram depicted a actions, the students would not it “shows protesters using physical physical altercation in which a su- be allowed on campus during the force against Public Safety staff to pervisor identified by FSU as Secu- weekend with the exception of aca- gain entrance to Cuniffe House.” rity Services Investigator William demically required activities. In a “In the intervening days, the McSorley appeared to be pressing follow-up statement issued May 2, University reviewed all the video Sarah Lopez, Fordham College at the university announced that the and eyewitness evidence of the proRose Hill (FCRH) ’18, into a wall. Office of Student Affairs received tests,” the statement reads. “Taken This incident turned into a hos- confirmation that all of those who together, it is clear that the Public tile conflict between Public Safety were evicted “had family or friends Safety staff showed maximum reand a number of protesters attempt- to stay with.” straint in the face of the protesters’ ing to go through the door. A segIn public Facebook posts, FSU physical force....[Some of the proment of the livestream posted by has called the officers’ actions to- testers] could have been charged FSU that was taken down and later ward the students “assault” and with assault had the demonstration edited out showed one student at- “racist brutality.” taken place off campus.” tempting to grab McSorley’s collar, Lopez, who is Latina, said in FSU directly refutes many and a number of students appearing an email that when she tried to get points of the university statement. to attempt to move him away from past the guard, McSorley’s actions In an email sent to Fordham faculty the door before a group of Public caused her to hyperventilate and colleagues on April 30, FSU alleged Safety officers came between them. cry in what seemed like a panic at- that injuries were sustained on both Director of Public Safety at Rose tack as he “wrapped his leg around sides. The letter states that the varyHill Dan Kiely sustained a gash [hers],” causing her to lose her bal- ing punishments imposed on the on his left hand and was treated at ance as she could not release the 14 students were “disturbing” and Montefiore Hospital, while another door handle. “vindictive,” claiming that those Public Safety supervisor received a “I was alone in this room, sur- facing penalties produced no threat cut to his forearm and was treated rounded by public safety, but I nev- to the health or safety of the Fordat the University Health Center, ac- er felt more scared or endangered in ham community and its student cording to the university statement my entire life,” she said. “No matter body. issued on May 2. how much my friends demanded it, They have also alleged on FaceOf the students who received they were shoved aside, even though book that contrary to the univeremails informing them of disciplin- I was so scared I could not move.” sity statement, no students who had ary measures against them on the Eventually Lopez was allowed to their campus privileges revoked afternoon of April 28, at least five return to the protest, which contin- were contacted to ensure a close were Rose Hill residents who were ued on the front steps for about a proximity of family or friends for barred from campus that evening half an hour. lodging. They say that at least one of

THE STUDENT VOICE OF FORDHAM LINCOLN CENTER

those is a member of FSU who was not present at the incident while another only observed the altercation at a distance, “indicat[ing] the broad brush with which Dean Rodgers is painting.” A petition asking McShane to “immediately reverse” Rodgers’ disciplinary decisions was signed by more than 1,400 members of the Fordham community over the course of a day. Though the petition “takes no position on the truth of the different accusations,” it accuses Rodgers of acting without adherence to the established university judicial process, asserting as FSU did, that “there is no vaguely plausible interpretation under which the students are a threat to the well-being, health, or safety of themselves or the community.” “It is highly inappropriate to enact sanctions before [a fair process to adjudicate charges] even begins,” it concludes. The university statement said that the disciplinary measures used are “routine for the level of disciplinary charges the students will likely face, and are part of the University’s long-established policy.” It states that in the last year 11 students were “temporarily denied access to campus in advance of formal conduct proceedings.” It also says that the “normal conduct proceedings” will take place in the coming week. Fordham College at Lincoln Center (FCLC) Dean of Students Keith Eldredge said, “In a situation like this, because of the laws and regulations that protect student privacy and confidentiality in the student conduct process, we are not able to provide complete details.” “Peaceful demonstrations are certainly part of the normal discourse the University expects and encourages on campus, but using physical force against any person is counter to Fordham’s academic and Jesuit values,” repeat the University’s statements. “Thursday’s actions by protesters mark a regrettable departure from the civility and care for one another that is a deeply ingrained characteristic of Fordham culture.” FSU has noted that the university statement did not address the cause behind the protest.

OPINONS

NO CONFIDENCE Standing with the faculty vote.

PAGE 7 ARTS & CULTURE

Virtual Reality New Yorkers at Tribeca Film Fest.

PAGE 17 FEATURES

Seniors of Fordham

Memories from our latest grads.

PAGE 19 SPORTS & HEALTH

Depression

Tips for keeping your head up.

PAGE 23


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.