Skip to main content

Monday, Sept. 16, 2024

Page 1

www.alligator.org

We Inform. You Decide.

MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 16, 2024

VOLUME 119 - ISSUE 5 Not officially associated with the University of Florida

Published by Campus Communications, Inc. of Gainesville, Florida

College rankings explained: why UF lands where it does

Different methodologies alter UF’s score By Delia Rose Sauer Alligator Staff Writer

UF’s fall from the No. 1 public university to No. 34 in the Wall Street Journal’s most recent listing shocked students and alumni. No longer able to sport the “Top 5” banners, students and alumni took to social media to question why a top university’s score changed so drastically. The methodologies for each ranking list are constantly evolving. The 2024 and 2025 rankings across U.S. News & World Report and the Journal saw a change in methodology to better score universities. James Walter, a 20-year-old UF accounting junior, was shocked when he saw how the university’s ranking dropped in the Journal’s report. Walter thinks the new score doesn’t best represent UF, he said. While he didn’t rely on rankings when making his decision to apply, he hopes the new ranking won’t stop students from seeing the value in attending UF. Walter said he’d be interested in seeing if the methodology for rankings changes in the future. He believed that the Journal’s methodology made sense overall. However, he found some areas odd. The change in the Journal’s rankings may come from its change in methodology. The biggest change in UF’s score was under salary impact, where UF’s 2024 score was 84, while its 2025 score dropped to 55. In 2024, salary impact was calculated using a graduate’s estimated salary based on their demographic profile. The Journal then integrated the state’s cost of living into its 2025 report. “They said they used statistical modeling, which can be very

vague,” Walter said. “That wasn’t exactly easy to understand.” He admitted he didn’t pay attention to the Journal’s rankings until UF ranked No. 1 in the 2024 report. Before that, he focused on rankings from U.S. News & World Report, which is nationally recognized for its various college and university rankings. He wants to understand what led to such a drastic change, he said. However, he believes that UF shouldn’t only take the Journal’s ranking to heart. “It’s best interest to count whatever sources gives them [UF] the highest ranking, but I feel like it is important to consider a wide variety of sources when looking at school rankings,” he said. Last year, when UF lost its top five public university placement in U.S. News and World Report, its social media and marketing turned to the Journal, which last year ranked UF as the No. 1 public university in the nation. Despite dropping to No. 34 in the Journal’s 2024 rankings, UF still brands itself as the No. 1 public university in the nation on its official X account. Each major college ranking publication the university has followed — U.S. News, The Journal and Forbes — follows different methodologies that fluctuate each year. Here is a rundown of how each ranking works. Forbes

UF ranked No. 4 among the nation’s public universities in Forbes’ Sept. 4 report. The first criteria Forbes considered was alumni salary (20%). Forbes gathered earnings data to see which universities had the highestpaid graduates after graduating. The

SPORTS/SPECIAL/CUTOUT

Tennis Story description finish with comma, pg#

Freshmen have international experience. Read more on pg. 12.

SEE RANKINGS, PAGE 3

Gabriella Aulisio // Alligator Staff

Florida quarterbacks Graham Mertz and DJ Lagway high five one another before the start of the Gator game against Texas A&M on Saturday, Sept. 14, 2024. Read more in Sports on pg. 12.

A Florida composting company has a checkered past. Alachua County chose it anyway. A PROPOSED COMPOSTING FACILITY INVOLVES A COMPANY WITH A HISTORY OF STATE SCRUTINY, DEBT AND ARRESTS

By Rylan DiGiacomo-Rapp Alligator Staff Writer

Alachua County seeks to fulfill its promise of organic waste sustainability. But it may not be all sunshine within its chosen compost company. The county began negotiations with Jacksonvillebased Sunshine Organics & Compost June 11 to lay the groundwork for a local compost program, a pointed effort toward the joint city and county Zero Waste Strategic Plan. While the project could solve the county’s organic waste problem, the company and its co-owner come attached to a checkered past of inspection violations, debt and theft. Sunshine Organics & Compost, co-owned by Mi-

Taxes

Residents react to presidential proposal, pg. 5

The Avenue: Meal plan

Option outside dining halls, pg. 10

chael and Christina Kelcourse, specializes in converting organic waste to either compost or biochar, a solid substance used to improve soil health and absorb carbon emissions. “Our priorities have stayed the same with wanting to divert food waste from the landfill because of the emission problem but also have now increased to focus on the quality of soil in our country,” Christina Kelcourse said. And when the county launched a search for someone to take on organic waste management, Michael and Christina Kelcourse answered its call. The investigation

Founded in 2020, Sunshine Organics & Compost has encountered several roadblocks in an effort to adhere to Florida statutes. Michael Kelcourse received a Jacksonville solid

SEE COMPOSTING, PAGE 3

FOLLOW US ONLINE FOR UPDATES @FloridaAlligator

@TheAlligator_

@TheAlligator

@thefloridaalligator


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Monday, Sept. 16, 2024 by The Independent Florida Alligator - Issuu