Farmers Guardian 15th December 2023

Page 1

CHRISTMAS BOOST

RECORD SALE PRICES – P23

December 15 2023 | £4.10 | Become a member from £2.09 | farmersguardian.com

RATION: NEXT GENE ERLAND OND WINTER W

SEE P84

THE HEART OF AGRICULTURE MACHINERY

ARABLE

FARM PROFILE

Robotic scraper boosts productivity

Carbon audit offers whole farm improvements

Business overhaul streamlines efficiency

PAGE 62

PAGE 19

PAGE 16

NE FAILURES ● Dartmoor commoners’ critical role ● Concerns remain on destocking By Jane Thynne and Chris Brayford

p1 Dec15 AB OM KH.indd 2

PICTURE: ALAMY

NATURAL England has been ordered to change its attitude towards Dartmoor farmers after a new report painted a ‘damning picture’ of its ‘failing policies’. The Defra-commissioned study, led by chair of the Institute for Agricultural and Horticulture David Fursdon, has recommended a series of measures to back farming following rows over grazing rights, flock numbers and accusations of ‘rewilding by the back door’. These include: the creation of an independently chaired Dartmoor Land-Use Management Group; actions to support vegetation management, including conservation grazing by cattle and ponies and controlled burning, alongside exploring the management of sheep over winter and increasing Natural England staffing resource and the creation of partnerships to help rebuild trust. Mr Fursdon said it was a time for those involved to come together, with commoners playing a ‘vital role’ in the protection of the Devon moor.

David Fursdon said it was time for those involved to come together, with commoners playing a ‘vital role’ in the protection of the Devon moor.

Dave Slater, Natural England regional director for the South West, welcomed the review, stating the body’s priority had always been to work in the ‘combined best interests of nature and farmers on Dartmoor’. But he acknowledged it was now clear it needed to work on its communication strategies and that the current approach was ‘not working for any party’. The review also reiterated the need for careful management of a fresh round of Higher Level Stewardship extension negotiations, given one-year

extensions will in some cases expire in the first few months of 2024. Tenant Farmers Association (TFA) chief executive George Dunn said it was vital not to lose traction. He said the report painted a ‘damning picture’ of the impact of past ‘failing policies’ and that ‘changing the balance of grazing and removing sheep has reduced biodiversity on Dartmoor’. “The key now is how we move forward,” he said. TFA junior vice-chair and Dart-

moor farmer, Helen Radmore, said she finally felt like farmers were being listened to, with the ‘us and them’ approach of Natural England being particularly criticised. But Layland Branfield, a Dartmoor Common Councillor and hill farmer, said the review was ‘an utter kick in the teeth’ as farmers did not feel they were being listened to and with more than 40 recommendations made, it showed the panel ‘still do not know what to do’. “What the review says it intends to do and the actual actions taken from it will be two different things,” he said. Robin Milton, an Exmoor farmer and NFU Uplands Committee Forum member, said he was pleased to see a change in attitude from Natural England but pointed out commoners were still not guaranteed autonomy on the land. “The main back stop... is whose voice will be heard loudest in knowing what is best for Dartmoor,” he said, adding removing stock and limiting farmers’ independence’ could be ‘absolutely devastating to the cultural heritage’.

13/12/2023 17:01


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.