Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan - EXIGO Architecture

CHRIST THE SAVIOR CATHOLIC CHURCH

MASTER PLAN

MASTER PLAN CHRIST THE SAVIOR CATHOLIC CHURCH

MASTER PLAN

-05

CONTENTS 06

Cover Letter

08

Executive Summary of Findings

10

History of Christ the Savior Catholic Church

14

Process

Survey Walk-Through Community Meetings

16

The Plan

Phase I: New Sanctuary, Parking, Re-Roofing Phase II: New Rectory Phase III: Renovation of Classrooms + Offices Phase IV: Renovation of Community Hall

36

Preliminary Budget Hard Costs Soft Costs

38

Appendix

Survey (Questionnaire) (pg. 38) Topographic Survey (pg. 46) Photos of Existing Conditions (pg. 48) EXIGO Community Meeting Minutes (pg. 58)

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

COVER LETTER

COVER LETTER

-07

August 25, 2023 Christ the Savior Catholic Church Attn: Father Gleen Carpe Re: Master Plan for Christ the Savior Catholic Church Dear Father Gleen Carpe, EXIGO Architecture is pleased to present the Master Plan for the Christ the Savior Catholic Church. This report depicts the discoveries and priorities made by the Community to define the scope of work, which will allow a future design team to develop the rehabilitation of the existing facilities, and creation of the new Sanctuary and new Rectory.

We are thankful for Father Gleen Carpe, the Building Committee, and the Christ the Savior Parish Community for their cooperation during the process of creating the Master Plan. During the last three months, we have had positive meetings and extensive community participation, full of helpful conversation and feedback to best understand the Parish and its vision for the future.

The Master Plan for Christ the Savior Catholic Church is a compilation of our findings and recommendations to address the priorities and needs of the community. The intent is to ultimately expand and serve the existing community through new inspiring architectural spaces that promote spiritual learning and worship.

Thank you for this opportunity to express our interest in partnering with the Christ the Savior Catholic Church to provide master planning and architectural services. We appreciate your consideration and look forward to the continuation of our working relationship.

Respectfully submitted,

Eugenio “Pacelli” Mesta, AIA, CNU-A, GGP Principal, EXIGO Architecture

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY MASTER PLAN FINDINGS

On July 28, 2023 and August 10, 2023,

the campus. The Parish currently has six

EXIGO Architecture hosted two community

classrooms (the Angel’s Inn in the Office

meetings and released a questionnaire to

Building and five classrooms in the classrooms

understand the community needs, priorities,

buildings). These classroom spaces are

and vision. The questionnaire and community

small and are not able to house the number

meetings revealed the following pressing

of Catechism students, and other Religious

needs (in descending order): new Sanctuary,

Formation classes, Ministries meetings, etc.

new Rectory, additional classroom space, additional storage, and deferred maintenance

The site currently has five storage sheds, one

issues.

of which is used as St. Joseph’s Wood Shop.

As it can be observed in the photos of the

A new Sanctuary is the most pressing need.

existing conditions in the Appendix, there is

Since its establishment in 1982, mass and

a lack of sufficient storage and maintenance

other community events have been held at

space, as well as designated space for the St.

Fannin Elementary School auditorium, the

Joseph’s Wood Shop, and other ministries.

North Bend Recreation Center at Veterans Park, and now the Community Hall. Christ the

Ultimately, there is an accumulation of

Savior Parish has never had an appropriate

deferred maintenance issues to address from

worshiping space.

the last 40 operating years of the Parish.

This deferred maintenance includes the lack

The Rectory is currently located in the Office

of parking space and ADA accessible areas,

Building, which does not offer adequate

efficient mechanical, electrical, and plumbing

living space, privacy, and it goes against the

systems, water leaks and ceiling stains due to

Diocese regulations of the Rectory being

roofing damage, and lack of insulation.

separate from the Church but still within

Once the Parish’s spatial and programmatic

-09

needs were established, Exigo Architecture produced conceptual recommendations for the new and existing facilities. These conceptual recommendations can be found in the section “The Plan.”

The Appendix section of the report includes the questionnaire example, the topographic survey, photos of the existing conditions, and Exigo Architecture meeting minutes.

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

HISTORY

HISTORY “Christ the Savior Parish was established on February 1982.”

“[The Church] was created in order to relieve

Daily mass, and meetings were held in the

the overcrowding at Most Holy Trinity and

Rectory. The growth in the parish and the

to provide services for Spanish speakers of

resulting funds that were raised allowed

the area. Msgr. Robert Getz was named the

for the groundbreaking of the Parish plan

first pastor. Since there was no building, and

on February 10, 1984. It took 22 months to

only the land, arrangements were made with

complete construction.

the El Paso Independent School District to rent the auditorium of Fannin Elementary

On December 14, 1985, Bishop Raymundo

School for Sunday services.

Pena dedicated the parish hall. The hall was used for services as well as social functions.

With the arrangement in place, the first

The other two buildings were not completed

parish mass and baptism were celebrated

at the time because of financial issues.

on the 19th of February 1982. Religious

A year after the dedication, Reverend

education classes were held at the North

Calderon took a leave of absence. Reverend

Bend Recreation Center in Veterans Park.

Leonardo Rivera replaced him in December

Shortly after this date, Msgr. Getz moved to

of 1986.”

Las Cruces. In September of 1982, he was replaced by Reverend Vicente Calderon him

“Father Leo guided the parish for the

as pastor.

next four years. This included welcoming the Korean Catholic Community to the

Due to the growing size of the community,

parish. The evangelization program was

arrangements were made with the City to

encouraged, and other current ministries

use the Recreation Center for masses,

of the parish were set in place. Father Leo

-011

was also responsible for working the parish

Evangelization, Knights of Columbus, and

debt so that other work could continue. The

Korean activities. In 1994, Bishop Michael

religious education building was used for

Park from Korea dedicated the altar in the

classes at this time.

daily Chapel.

On July 5, 1990, Father Bob Kobe

In 1996, the rectory and parish offices

became the fourth pastor. Because of the

were completed. This allowed the pastor

foundation laid by his predecessors, the

to live at the church. Besides the regular

ministries continued. A strong ministry to

ministries, the parish hosted Diocesan

military families was also developed at the

workshops, Tepeyac classes, and both Boy

encouragement of Bishop Pena. In 1992,

and Girl Scout troop activity. [Christ the

the religious education building was closed

Savior Parish] has also provided room for

because of structural problems. There was

Head Start, juvenile and adult probation,

no heat, running water or bathrooms. This

counseling, citizenship and other civic

showed the dedication of [Christ the Savior

activities.

Parish] people, that they came, without luxuries, to grow in their faith.

[...] Ministries are provided in English, Spanish, and Korean on a daily basis. About

The Diocese helped [Christ the Savior

40% of the Parish practices Stewardship of

Parish] complete the religious education

time, talent, and their treasures.”

building in 1992. The loan has since been paid back to the Diocese. This building houses most of the Religious Education,

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

HISTORY

As per the Diocese direction, Christ the Savior Catholic Church Parish serves the delineated area in the map to the right.

This area contains a population density of 4,824 people per square mile. There are approximately 10,000 households with a population of approximately 30,000 people. As we learned through the questionnaires, there are 230 registered families with a total of 500 parishioners.

There is an opportunity to expand the amount of parishioners.

-013

CTS

MHT Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

PROCESS

PROCESS SURVEY WALK-THROUGH COMMUNITY MEETINGS

EXIGO Architecture conducted a survey (in English and Spanish) to better understand the community needs, priorities, and vision of its future. See Survey on page 33.

Simultaneously, EXIGO Architecture conducted a walkthrough with Building Committee members to document the site and building existing conditions (see pages 42 51).

EXIGO Architecture also conducted two community meetings (July 28, 2023 and August 10, 2023). The first community meeting was to collect the surveys and conduct an open conversation based on the survey questions. The second community meeting was to present the conceptual master plan recommendations addressing the needs and priorities stated by the community.

Based on the survey and community meeting comments, these are the priorities (in descending order): (1) New Sanctuary; (2) Fix Roof; (3) Fix Parking and Community Hall; (4) Fix Classrooms.

-015

Q U E S T I O N N A I R E R E S U LT S

46 surveys were returned from the CTS community. The tabulated results guided us in the development of the Master Plan.

What are the most pressing needs? (Comment based) — New Church Kneeling pews Tabernacle Adoration Chapel (exterior accessibility) Daily Chapel New Confessionals Crying room Choir storage — Site Improvements Landscaping Signage/Way-finding Exterior cooking space — Deferred Maintenance Updated parking Utilities (HVAC, electricity, plumbing) Security Roof Repair Storage Areas — Rectory Chapel — Meeting Spaces + Classrooms Additional storage for Ministries — Renovation of Community Hall ADA accessible restrooms Lighting Ceiling Smell Kitchen (commercial grade) Dedicated gift shop — Retreat center — Sports center for kids — Expand Parish

Rank the priorities.

Rank 1 2 3 4 5

New Sanctuary 24 7 8 2 1

Fix Roof 12 21 3 3 1

Fix Parking 7 9 12 3 7

Classrooms 1 2 5 12 13

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

Community Hall 0 3 12 9 7

THE PLAN

THE PLAN EXISTING CONDITIONS PROPOSED PLAN

EXISTING CONDITIONS

THE SITE:

Christ the Savior Catholic Church is

PHYSICAL DEFICIENCIES

located at 5301 Wadsworth Avenue, El

The paved parking has not been addressed

Paso TX 79924. The campus is 10.9657

since the construction of the campus. The

acres and contains the following buildings:

paved parking has pot holes, and much of

Community Hall used as the Sanctuary; an

the space where parishioners park is not

Office building that includes the Rectory; a

paved. Another deficiency is the scattering

Classroom building that includes the Daily

of the storage sheds around the campus.

Chapel, and a Confessional. There are currently 78 parking spaces, six indicated

FUNCTIONAL DEFICIENCIES

as “ADA accessible.” There are five exterior

The attendance of mass ranges from 100 to

sheds, four used as storage and one

500 parishioners (especially during religious

assigned for the St. Joseph’s Wood Shop.

holidays, such as Christmas, Easter, and

The site also contains a 40 x 40’ lease area

New Year’s). The paved parking lot does not

to a cellular provider.

meet code requirements by square footage and occupancy load. There is also a need

Based on the site walk-through and

for landscaping and on-site ponding. Many

community meetings conducted by EXIGO

parishioners park in unpaved areas around

Architecture and the Building Committee, it

the campus. The existing storage sheds do

is clear that the facilities and site design

not provide sufficient storage space needs

do not meet expectations, physically and

for the campus and ministries.

spiritually.

PROPOSAL The new site will contain 245 parking

-017

spaces. There will be 16 ADA parking

events the Parish hosts; the Dish Wash

spaces strategically placed around the site

station is used as storage. Other utility

for ease of use. The new design will also

rooms in the Community Hall, including the

include landscaping and ponding.

janitor closet and electrical room are small.

COMMUNITY HALL:

PROPOSAL

PHYSICAL DEFICIENCIES

To reflect the spirituality and devotion the

The existing facilities are outdated and

parishioners over the last 40 years, the

need to be updated. The Parishioners have

parish requires a new Sanctuary. The new

expressed concern over the roof condition,

Sanctuary will include a 600 seat Nave, a

as it has leaks. Besides roof leaks, there

Narthex, two Sacristies, two confessionals,

is water infiltration on walls demonstrated

a Baptismal font, and a daily Chapel. Based

in photos (page 47 to 49). The restrooms

on the feedback, there will be an assigned

do not have adequate fixture counts for

Choir seating area and storage.

the occupant load, and do not meet ADA standards. The Community Hall does not

The Community Hall building will receive

have air conditioning, proper ventilation,

a full renovation to address the physical

and the units are undersized for the

and functional deficiencies. Once the new

occupant load. There is a lack of current

Sanctuary is built, the Tabernacle, Sacristy,

electrical, lighting, and telecommunication

and Gift Shop rooms will be available for

infrastructure for today’s standards and

storage and relieve the Stage area. The

to meet the programmatic needs of the

Dish Wash Station, Pantry, and the Storage

Community Halls for functions and events.

Closet will be demolished to create a bigger

There is a lack of storage space, the Stage

Kitchen area. The walls at the former

is used as temporary storage for Holiday

Dish Wash Station will be extended to

decorations and other Religious Artifacts

accommodate a new walk-in freezer/cooler

used for Mass. The Kitchen does not have

combo, and pantry. The existing restrooms

proper hood ventilation.

will be renovated and meet ADA standards.

FUNCTIONAL DEFICIENCIES

CLASSROOM BUILDING:

The Community Hall has been used as

PHYSICAL DEFICIENCIES

a Sanctuary since the 1980’s. Spaces

Several rooms in the Classroom building

that would be typically used for storage

need air conditioning and proper ventilation.

or utilities function as the Sacristy and

Other classrooms do have HVAC units

Tabernacle. The Kitchen does not have the

but are undersized for the occupant

spatial capacity for food preparation for the

load. Similarly, classrooms lack current

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

THE PLAN

electrical, lighting, and telecommunication

OFFICE BUILDING:

infrastructure for today’s classroom

PHYSICAL DEFICIENCIES

standards. Existing restrooms have

Similarly to the Classroom Building, the

adequate fixture counts for the occupant

Office Building also has water infiltration

load, however they do not meet ADA

issues on the walls and ceilings; do not

standards.

have air conditioning or proper ventilation; and it lacks current electrical and lighting

FUNCTIONAL DEFICIENCIES

infrastructure for today’s standards.

There are five classrooms in the Classroom Building. One of the classroom spaces

FUNCTIONAL DEFICIENCIES

is used as the Daily Chapel, and another

There are five offices (including the Pastor’s

meeting area is used at the Sacristy and

Study), one classroom (Angel’s Inn), and

storage for the Daily Chapel. The Classroom

three restrooms, along with the Rectory

building also has one room that is used

living spaces. As per the Diocese direction,

as a Confessional. The questionnaire

the Rectory should be separate from

results demonstrate there are not enough

the Church but still be located within the

classrooms to meet Catechism and Ministry

campus. Since the Rectory is in the Office

demand. Functionally, the Daily Chapel,

Building, there is no privacy for the Priest

the Sacristy, and Confessional should be

and visiting guests. It has been expressed

separate from the Classrooms. When the

that Religious Formation does not have

new Sanctuary is built, the Daily Chapel,

sufficient meeting and storage space in their

Sacristy, and Confessional will be converted

current office.

into Classroom and Storage.

PROPOSAL PROPOSAL

The Office Building will receive a full

The Classroom building will receive a full

renovation to address the physical and

renovation to address the physical and

functional deficiencies. A new Rectory for

functional deficiencies. The interior will be

the Priest will be built within the campus,

retrofitted to create a total of 8 classrooms

separate from the Church. With the removal

of varying sizes to address Catechism and

of the Rectory from the Office Building

Ministry needs. The existing three restrooms

and retrofitting the interior walls, five new

will be converted into two ADA restrooms,

classrooms and five offices will be created.

and the former Confessional will be used as

This will complement the need for additional

classroom storage space.

Catechism classrooms and Ministry meeting spaces. The three existing restrooms will be reconfigured to four new ADA restrooms.

-019

CONCLUSION The new site design addresses the feedback and analysis learned through our process.

The campus will include new parking, a new Sanctuary, a new Rectory, full renovation of the existing Community Hall, Classroom building, and Office building, and the consolidation of the existing storage units into two storage buildings to address the lack of storage, maintenance space, and St. Joseph’s Wood Shop.

The Master Plan has been designed in Phases to address the priorities efficiently.

The community recommended the following phases based on their priorities: Phase I addresses the Re-Roofing, Parking, and New Sanctuary. Phase II is the construction the new Rectory. Phase III is the full renovation of the Classroom and Office buildings. Phase IV is the full renovation of the Community Hall. Please see the following pages (20 to 33) for additional details and floor plans.

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

THE PLAN

OPTION A

POND

NEW STORAGE

POND NEW RECTORY

FUTURE STORAGE

POND

POND

POND

CLASSROOM BLDG COMMUNITY HALL

POND

POND POND

NEW SANCTUARY

OFFICE BLDG

POND POND

POND

The new site design includes a new Sanctuary, new Rectory, new Storage buildings, 245 parking spaces, 16 of which are ADA accessible.

-021

OPTION B

POND

NEW STORAGE

POND

NEW RECTORY

FUTURE STORAGE

POND

POND POND

CLASSROOM BLDG COMMUNITY HALL

POND

POND POND NEW SANCTUARY

OFFICE BLDG

POND

POND

POND

Option: The new site design allows for the configuration of 34 residential lots to sell for additional funds.

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

PHASE I

PHASE I RE-ROOFING NEW SANCTUARY N E W PA R K I N G

Since there is water infiltration, the most pressing issue is the existing buildings’ re-roofing, as depicted in existing conditions photos, see Appendix.

Phase I will also include the design and construction of the new Sanctuary, and the new parking. The new Sanctuary will include a 600 seat Nave; Narthex; Sacristy for the Altar servers and extraordinary ministers and a more private Sacristy for the Priest; two confessionals; Baptismal font; and a separate daily Chapel with exterior access.

The phase will include the upgrade of the parking lot to include 245 parking spaces, with 16 strategically placed ADA accessible parking spaces.

-023

POND POND

NEW RECTORY

NEW STORAGE

NEW STORAGE

POND PARKING

POND

RE-ROOFING POND

POND POND

NEW SANCTUARY

POND POND

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

POND

PHASE II

PHASE II NEW RECTORY

Phase II includes the design and construction of the new Rectory. The new Rectory will include the Priest’s bedroom, two visiting Priest (guest) bedrooms, one will have exterior access, and a Chapel in addition to other living spaces.

The Rectory will be designed to have a private entrance and garage access from Wadsworth Avenue.

-025

POND

NEW STORAGE

POND

NEW RECTORY

NEW STORAGE POND

POND

POND CLASSROOM BLDG COMMUNITY HALL POND

POND POND NEW SANCTUARY

OFFICE BLDG

POND

POND

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

POND

PHASE III

PHASE III CLASSROOM BUILDING OFFICE BUILDING R E N O VAT I O N A N D D E F E R R E D M A I N T E N A N C E

Phase III includes the renovation and deferred maintenance of the existing Classroom and Office (former Rectory) buildings. The design and construction of the Rectory in Phase II allows for the Office building to be vacated for the expansion of additional Catechism classrooms and offices.

This phase will result in five offices, and 13 classrooms which can also be used for meeting rooms. The Gift Shop will be located in the Office Building.

A complete renovation of the existing Classroom and Office buildings will include the necessary upgrades to the exterior finishes; interior finishes; and electrical, mechanical, and plumbing system upgrades to meet current code standards.

-027

POND

NEW STORAGE

POND

NEW RECTORY

NEW STORAGE POND

POND

CLASSROOM BLDG

POND

COMMUNITY HALL

POND

POND POND OFFICE BLDG

NEW SANCTUARY

POND

POND

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

POND

PHASE III

-029

CLASSROOM BUILDING New

PANTRY NEW SPACES CLASSROOM CLASSROOM

CLASSROOM

RESTROOM

RESTROOM

CLASSROOM

RESTROOM

MECH.

CLASSROOM

JAN.

CLASSROOM

CLASSROOM

CLASSROOM

Existing DEMOLISHED

CLASSROOM

CLASSROOM CLASSROOM

CLASSROOM CONFESSIONAL

RESTROOM RR

MECH. PANTRY

RR

JAN.

DAILY CHAPEL

CLASSROOM

COURTYARD

The daily Chapel will become two classrooms, the Confessional will become an additional ADA accessible restroom. Extending walls and closing the existing courtyard will allow for 8 classrooms.

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

PHASE III

-031

OFFICE BUILDING New

COURTYARD NEW SPACES

CLASSROOM

CLASSROOM MEETING SPACE

STORAGE MECH KITCHEN

RESTROOM

CLASSROOM

RESTROOM

OFFICE RESTROOM RESTROOM

OFFICE

OFFICE OFFICE OFFICE GIFT SHOP

Existing DEMOLISHED

COURTYARD

PASTOR’S STUDY KITCHEN FATHER’S LIVING QUARTERS

PANTRY STORAGE KITCHEN

BATH

MECH.

BEDROOM CLOSET

STORAGE T SE

O CL

RESTROOM

OFFICE

BATHROOM

T

SE O CL

STORAGE

RESTROOM

BEDROOM

BATHROOM

OFFICE + STORAGE

CLASSROOM

GARAGE

RECEPTION STOR.

RELIGIOUS FORMATION

OFFICE LAUNDRY

STOR.

Existing bedrooms will become classrooms and offices. The new floor plan consists of four new classrooms, one new office, and the gift shop.

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

PHASE IV

PHASE IV COMMUNITY HALL R E N O VAT I O N A N D D E F E R R E D M A I N T E N A N C E

Phase IV is the complete renovation of the Community Hall building. The Community Hall will have restroom upgrades to meet code requirements and ADA accessibility; expansion of the kitchen, addition of a commercial grade walk-in cooler/freezer combo unit, a spacious pantry, and a storage addition for event tables, chairs, and other equipment. The rooms formerly used as the Sacristy, Tabernacle, and Gift Shop will be used as storage. The Lobby will be redesigned and fully renovated.

The upgrades will also include exterior finishes; roof installation; interior finishes; and electrical, mechanical, and plumbing system upgrades to meet current standards and code.

-033

POND

NEW STORAGE

POND

NEW RECTORY

NEW STORAGE

POND

POND

POND

CLASSROOMS COMMUNITY HALL POND

POND POND NEW SANCTUARY

OFFICES

POND

POND

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

POND

PHASE IV

-035

COMMUNITY HALL New

ELEC.

WOMEN RESTROOM

MEN RESTROOM

STORAGE

STORAGE

UTILITY

NEW SPACES

JAN.

STAGE STORAGE

EXTERIOR STORAGE + WATER HEATER

KITCHEN

HALL

STAGE

WALK-IN COOLER + FREEZER

PANTRY MECH.

MECH.

HALL STORAGE

MECH.

MECH.

Existing DEMOLISHED

ELEC.

MEN RESTROOM

SACRISTY

LOBBY

WOMEN RESTROOM

TABERNACLE

UTILITY

JAN. STOR. GIFT SHOP PANTRY EXTERIOR STORAGE + WATER HEATER

STORAGE SANCTUARY

STOR.

KITCHEN STAGE

DISH WASH

MECH.

MECH.

MECH.

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

MECH.

PHASE IV

-037

PRELIMINARY BUDGET HARD COSTS Phase I Sanctuary (New) Parking (New) Landscaping (New) Re-Roofing (Existing) Phase I Total

Quantity 10,000 SF 245 Parking Spaces 77,500 SF 28,400 SF

Rate ($) 275 5,000 5.50

Total $2,750,000 $1,225,000 $426,250 $299,835 $4,701,085

Phase II Rectory (New) Storage (New) Phase II Total

2,000 SF 4,800 SF

175 75

$350,000 $360,000 $710,000

Phase III + IV Existing Buildings (Full Renovation)

21,400 SF

150

$3,210,000

600 Seats

107 (per seat)

$64,200 $100,000 $164,200

FF+E Church Pews Artifacts (Allowance) FF+E Total Construction Cost Total

$8,785,285

SOFT COSTS Service A+E Geo-technical Material Testing Project Management Soft Costs Grand Total

Percentage of Construction Cost 0.065

0.03

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

Total $571,044 $5,000 $15,000 $263,559 $854,603

APPENDIX

APPENDIX SURVEY (QUESTIONNAIRE) TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY PHOTOS OF EXISTING CONDITIONS EXIGO MEETING MINUTES

-039

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan Survey Ques�onnaire

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Survey Ques�onnaire El Paso Diocese has requested Christ the Savior Catholic Church to prepare a Master Plan for the next 10 years addressing the most signicant building needs and assessing the future Parish growth. Christ the Savior has retained Exigo Architects to prepare the Master Plan that will set the path for the Parish’s future and has prepared the following ques�onnaire to assist in the plan development.

Thank you for your coopera�on.

Name_______________________

Age _____________________________________ Are you involved in a Ministry? _______________ Name Ministry ____________________________ If you are not involved in a Ministry, would you like to get involved? If so, in which Ministry? _________________________________________ What do you like most about Christ the Savior Catholic Church? __________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________ What do you think are the most pressing needs at Christ the Savior Catholic Church? __________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________ List from 1 (most important) to 5(least important) priori�es at Christ the Savior Catholic Church.

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

____________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________

Rank 1 (Most Important) to 5 (least important) facility needs at Christ the Savior Catholic Church. a). New Sanctuary b). Fix Roof c). Fix Parking d). Classrooms e). Community Hall 1. ______________________________________________________________________ 2. ______________________________________________________________________ 3. ______________________________________________________________________ 1 OF 7

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

APPENDIX

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan Survey Ques�onnaire 4. ______________________________________________________________________ 5. ______________________________________________________________________ Please respond to the following ques�ons:

A. Church:

B. How many members are currently registered?

C. How many Masses are per day? Is this to con�nue as shown on the Website?

Daily Mass: Tuesday 5:00 PM Saturday Mass: 5:00 PM Sunday Mass: 8:00 AM 9:30 AM 11:00 AM D. How Many A�endees per Mass?

Daily Saturday Sunday E. Do you have a Daily Mass Chapel? Capacity?

F. Do you have an adora�on, Chapel? Capacity?

G. Confessions: Tue‐Fri: 4:30 PM?

H. How many confessions are given per day?

I.

How many confessionaires are in the Facility? Do we need more?

J.

If there was a new church, would we keep the exis�ng confessionaires or build new ones in the church?

K. Choirs: a) Is there a Choir in every Mass? b) How many members are in the largest Choir?

2 OF 7

-041

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan Survey Ques�onnaire c) Do they bring their own instruments, or do we need storage? d) Do they bring their own stand/chairs, or do we need to store it? e) Can we leave the chairs and stand permanently? f)

Do they have a prac�ce room? With Storage?

L. What size of Bap�smal Font do you prefer? Full body?

M. Where do you celebrate the Ceremony of the Light?

N. Where do you conduct the Easter Vigil?

O. Do you conduct a Live Via Crusis on Good Friday? If so, inside or outside?

P. Other….. ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________

B. Community Hall 1. How many events (other than Mass) do you have in the community hall?

2. Please name the event and a�endance.

3. In these events do you do performances? (Other than Mass)

4. Need sound and special ligh�ng?

3 OF 7

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

APPENDIX

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan Survey Ques�onnaire 5. What size of storage do you need. ?

6. How much is temporary storage vs. permanent storage?

7. Do you conduct Sta�ons of the Cross inside the Community Hall/Church?

8. Do you conduct Sta�ons of the Cross outside?

9. Do you cook on‐site?

10. How o�en?

11. For how many people?

12. Other… _________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________

C. Offices: 1. Please name and number full �me staff 2. Please name and number volunteer staff 3. How many mee�ng spaces do you need?

4. How many ministries do you have?

5. Would you like to add new ministries?

6. How many people belong to each Ministry?

7. How o�en do they meet and what facility do they use?

4 OF 7

-043

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan Survey Ques�onnaire 8. Does each ministry have its own materials? Storage?

9. What are the office hours?

10. How do you provide security?

11. How do you provide maintenance?

12. Other….. _________________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________________

_________________________________________________________________

IV. Rectory: 1. How many priests should be housed in the Rectory?

2. Room for Guests?

3. Do we need a Chapel?

4. Dining Hall for how many people?

5. Other….. ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________

V. Catechism: 1. How many Catechism classes?

2. List the name and size of classes given.

5 OF 7

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

APPENDIX

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan Survey Ques�onnaire 3. How many students in each class?

4. Do you provide evening classes?

5. How do you provide security/access?

6. What are the classes hours?

7. How o�en do you provide retreats?

8. For how many people?

9. Do you conduct it in Classrooms or Community Hall?

10. Other…. _________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________

_______________________________________ V. Grounds: 1. How many parking spaces do you have now?

2. How many parking spaces do you believe are short?

3. What do you have in outside storage?

4. Where do you store the maintenance/Yard equipment?

5. Other….. ______________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________________

6 OF 7

-045

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan Survey Ques�onnaire Comments: _____________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________

7 OF 7

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

APPENDIX

-047

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

APPENDIX

PHOTOS COMMUNITY HALL OFFICE BUILDING AND RECTORY CLASSROOM BUILDING SITE

-049

11 9

8

3 6

COMMUNITY HALL 1

4

5 2 10

2 Tabernacle

7

1 Community Hall

Used as the Sanctuary

3 Sacristy Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

APPENDIX

4 Lobby

5 Women Restroom

6 Men Restroom

7 Gift Shop

-051

8 Kitchen

9 Dish Wash Area

10 Stage

11 Exterior Storage

Used as temporary storage

Used as Kitchen storage

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

APPENDIX

6

7 4 5

1

3 2 1 Religious Formation Office

OFFICE BUILDING AND RECTORY

2 Classroom “Angel’s Inn”

3 Kitchen adjoining Classroom “Angel’s Inn”

-053

4 Mechanical Units in Patio

5 Rectory Kitchen

6 Rectory Bedroom

7 Father’s Living Quarters

Water ponding and infiltration issues

Water damage due to roofing issues Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

APPENDIX

3 4

2

1 5 1 Classroom

Used as Daily Chapel

CLASSROOM BUILDING

2 Classroom

Used as Sacristy

3 Catechism Classroom

-055

4 Pantry for St. Vincent de Paul Ministry

5 Classroom

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

APPENDIX

SITE

7

5

10 4

9

6 11

1

2

3

8

-057

SITE

1 Inner Courtyard looking towards Community Hall

2 Exterior Stage

3 Site Parking

4 Rosary Garden outside of Classroom Building Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

APPENDIX

5 Storage shed used as St. Joseph’s Wood Shop

6 Storage

7 Storage

8 Stations of the Cross

-059

9 Looking towards Classroom building

10 Looking towards Community Hall

11 Looking towards parking lot Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

APPENDIX

MEETING MINUTES J U LY 2 8 , 2 0 2 3 C O M M U N I T Y M E E T I N G

–

Christ the Savior Parish have an additional mass at 10:00am for Korean

the Community Hall.

–

speaking parishioners.

–

– –

Saturday evening mass at 5:00pm and

–

the hall.

–

There has only been one instance when

7:00pm in Korean, approximately 40 to

there was more than 500 parishioners

45 parishioners attend.

attending a mass.

Regular mass attendance ranges from

–

They Christ the Savior community has

90 to 100 parishioners.

expressed that they have a vision of the

Sunday mass at 8:00am has an

parish they have been waiting for 40

attendance of 100 parishioners; 9:30am

years.

mass has 150; 11:00am mass has

–

Thursday night, they build a stage inside

–

They want to maintain the present

180; and the 5:00pm mass has 280 to

community, the same size and not come

300 parishioners. There is a Korean

with new or shared with other activities.

mass at 11:00am and approximately 45

–

The community wants a new church.

parishioners attend.

–

Parishioners have expressed that

Holidays and Christmas has 500

Christ the Savior is a small community

attendees; New Year’s, Ash Wednesday,

which feels like extended family. The

and Midnight mass has 150 attendees.

parishioners are multicultural, who speak

During Holy Week, Palm Sunday has a

English, Spanish, and Korean.

full capacity. Easter Vigil occurs in the

–

The community feels that due to their

interior courtyard. Friday Stations of the

location on the Northeast, the parish

Cross takes place in the corner garden

should be growing.

and is active walk. The Ceremony of

–

Due to their close proximity to the park,

Light on Saturday evening takes place

the community feels that it needs to

both in the exterior courtyard and inside

become clear (architecturally) that it is

-061

–

not a recreation center. It needs to be

addressed and upgraded, such as the

clear that it is a Catholic Church.

mechanical systems (AC units are not

Other priority needs besides a new

adequate).

Sanctuary is the need for an Adoration

–

Chapel. Something accessible and small so parishioners can go to pray.

–

–

–

–

they are provided more space.

–

The community has expressed that the

The community requests a Blessed

property does not have enough lighting

Sacrament to be visible from the outside

and the parking lot is not proper. The

(such as during the Pandemic).

campus needs 250 or so parking spaces

There is a need for adequate storage for

(they currently have less than 80). Since

all the needs (for maintenance, holiday

there are more older aged parishioners,

decorations, ministries, etc).

there is a need for more ADA accessible

The church itself needs storage for the

parking spaces.

Choir.

–

St. Joseph’s Wood Shop requests that

–

The parishioners have requested a

The community feels the pressing need

“sick ministry area,” a space where sick

to bring younger people into the church.

parishioners can attend.

It has been expressed that the current

–

The community requests covered

catechism classroom are not adequate.

parking for the ADA accessible parking

They use these classrooms everyday,

spaces; parking lights with solar panels

and some are used as pantry, storage.

with increasing intensity with proximity.

Due to a lack of a big classroom space,

–

The community discussed what can be

they currently hold the confirmation class

done with the rest of the property. Some

(of 50-60 students of varying ages) that

options could be to sell the undeveloped

is held in the Community Hall.

land.

–

The Rectory requires a daily Chapel.

–

Religious Formation requires a lot of

Action Items:

storage space.

Fernando will provide a list of all ministries

Other deferred maintenance needs to be

and their meeting and storage space needs.

–

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

APPENDIX

MEETING MINUTES AUGUST 10, 2023 COMMUNITY MEETING

–

–

EXIGO Architecture presented the

of the guest bedrooms to have exterior

the Board Committee.

access and be separate from the

The Committee requested 16 ADA

Rectory.

–

for two kitchens. The residential kitchen

residential lots to sell for additional

used for the Rectory will become a

funds was discussed, there was concern

Classroom. The kitchen adjacent to the

about the existing antenna on the site.

“Angel’s Inn” will remain.

–

Code of Ordinances on TV and radio broadcasting antennae requirements.

–

–

The Office building restrooms will be upgraded to meet ADA standards.

–

For the Classroom building, St. Vincent

The Committee expressed the urgency

de Paul Ministry requested the Pantry

of water infiltration, therefore re-roofing

to be moved from between classroom

is prioritized for Phase I.

spaces. The Pantry will now be in the left

The importance of a location for Kermes

wing classroom so that it can used as an

was expressed. It may continue being

interview space when it is needed.

celebrated in the inner courtyard.

–

For the Office Building, there is no need

A Site option of configuring 34

See page 63 and 64 for the El Paso

–

Father Gleen Carpe requested for one

Master Plan to Father Gleen Carpe and

parking spaces.

–

–

–

For additional classroom space, the

The Community Hall restrooms will be

former Daily Chapel will be converted to

upgraded to meet ADA standards.

two smaller Classrooms.

The Committee agreed to making the

–

The Classroom building restrooms

existing Gift Shop into storage to relieve

will also be upgraded to meet ADA

the Stage area. The new Gift Shop will

standards. And the former Confessional

be located in the Office Building, with

will become an additional restroom.

exterior access.

-063

Antenna: El Paso Code of Ordinances Title 20. ZONING Chapter 20.10. SUPPLEMENTAL USE REGULATIONS § 20.10.700. TV and radio broadcasting antennae.

In Residential, Apartment and Commercial Zoning Districts. Ground-mounted radio or television broadcasting antenna support structures with antennas and equipment storage facilities shall comply with the following standards: 1. The antenna support base shall be set back one foot for each one foot of height from abutting residential districts, measured from the antenna support base to the property line; 2. The radio or television broadcasting antenna support structure shall conform with FCC and FAA height regulations within a residential zone; 3. The following must accompany a request for a special permit: a. A non-ionizing electromagnetic radiation (NIER) report, in a format acceptable to the FCC, b. A structural engineering report for the antenna support, c. A detailed site development plan showing the antenna, supporting structures and appurtenant equipment in relation to the existing surroundings, d. Verification letters that an FCC application has been submitted and FAA approval has been obtained; 4. Collocation or installation of additional

antennas on an existing antenna support structure shall be permitted after review and approval by the building official of a structural recertification report, prepared and sealed by a licensed professional engineer, and an updated NIER emissions report; 5. Increase in elevation of an existing antenna support structure shall be permitted, so long as the setback and maximum height limitations are complied with, after review and approval by the building official of updated structural and NIER emissions reports; 6. Existing nonconforming antenna support structures, unable to comply with current setback limitations shall be prohibited from any increase in elevation. http://elpaso-tx.elaws.us/code/coor_title20_ ch20.10_sec20.10.700

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

APPENDIX

Use

Residential R- R- R1

2

R- R-

2A 3

Commercial

R- R- RMH A- A- A- A- A- A-

3A 4

5

1

2

3

4

O

A- C-

Manufacturing

Special Purpose

C- C- C- C- C- Q M- M- M- R- PMD**** S-

3/O M OP 1

2

3

4

5

1

2

3

F

U-

P-

D** P** R

P-R P-

P-

SRR**

II** C** I**

I**

17.00 Towers & related structures 17.01 Amateur &

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

D

D

D

D

D

D

D

D

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

D

S

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

P

D

D

D

D

D

D

D

D

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

P

P

P

P

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

D

S

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A Residential A A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

ACommercial A A A

A

AManufacturing A A A

A

A

A

A

A

A

SpecialA Purpose A A

C- C- C- C- C- Q M- M- M- R- PMD**** S-

U-

P-

P-R P-

CB radio stations (federally licensed) 17.02 Personal Wireless Service Facility (PWSF), facilitymounted 17.03 PWSF, groundmounted 17.04 PWSF, roofmounted

17.05 Radio broadcasting antenna 17.06 Radio receiving station (residentialtype) Use 17.07 Satellite receiving dish,

R- R- R-

antenna

1

2

2A 3

3A 4

5

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

17.08 Solar

R- R-

R- R- RMH A- A- A- A- A- A-

A- C-

1

2

3

4

O

3/O M OP 1

2

3

4

5

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

D** P** R

P-

SRR**

II** C** I**

1

2

3

F

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

I** A A

A

A

A

conversion 17.00 Towers system& related structures 17.09 Television

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

P

P

P

P

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

D

S

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

A

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

S

broadcasting antenna 17.10 Television receiving station (residentialtype) 17.11 Wind-driven electrical generator, pump

* In addition to the use being permitted through a Master Zoning Plan, the use is only allowed by an additional Special Permit with a detailed site plan approval in the respective zoning district obtain

(Administrative Provisions), and shall be subject to the general restrictions and performance standards found in Chapter 20.10 (Supplemental Use Regulations) and other applicable regulations of thi

-065

Supplemental Accessory Standards R-

G-

I-

Uses Permitted

NOS URD

to

MU** MU** MU**

Speci c Use

A

A

A

X

§ 20.10.010; § 20.10.020; § 20.10.070

Z

Z

Z

X

§ 20.10.010; § 20.10.020; § 20.10.455

Z*

Z*

Z*

X

§ 20.10.010; § 20.10.020; § 20.10.455

Z

Z

Z

X

§ 20.10.010; § 20.10.020; § 20.10.455

Z

Z

Z

X

§ 20.10.010; § 20.10.020; § 20.10.700

A

A

A

X

§ 20.10.010; § 20.10.020; § 20.10.710

A

A

A

X

R-

G-

I-

NOS URD

Supplemental § 20.10.010; Accessory § Standards 20.10.020;

Uses

§ 20.10.590

Permitted to

MU** MU** MU** A

A

A

X

§ 20.10.010; § 20.10.020;

Speci c Use

§ 20.10.200 Z

Z

Z

X

§ 20.10.010; § 20.10.020; § 20.10.700

A

A

A

X

§ 20.10.010; § 20.10.020; § 20.10.710

Z

Z

Z

X

§ 20.10.010; § 20.10.020; § 20.10.200

https://library.municode.com/tx/el_paso/codes/code_ of_ordinances?nodeId=TIT20ZO_APXATAPEUS

ned from the city council in accordance with Chapter 20.04

is title.

Christ the Savior Catholic Church Master Plan

APPENDIX