История повторяется? Вопрос к россиянам

ab\`Sq ]\,b\`q1baqH \]`\a V `\aaSqZ*Y

w 1-\/Zq P ˙1Zn ]*YqbS 31`b, ]\WSbSh1O aVSf `1]`1aaSyD DDD 1,\4Y\3Z\ ]`1/ab*,Sbn a1+1 `*4Y*f b1``\`*E \b V\b\`\-\ ]\ab`*/*O WS ,a1 Z*`\/m ab`*ZmD DDD DDD'b\ ˙1Zn ]*YqO bS \ YSWWS\Z*f SaV*W1h1ZZmf ad/1+D WpO /qfE `*aab`1WqZZmf +14 ad/* S +14 aW1/ab,SqE \ Wp/qfE \b]`*,W1ZZmf , W*-1`q S aamWVSE WSO j1ZZmf -`*3/*ZaVSf ]`*, 4* tZ1 b\br `\/ 4*O ZqbSy SWS 4* ]`1aW\,db\1 ta\gS*WnZ\1 ]`\O Saf\3/1ZS1rD DDD ˙*,*yb1 b\WnV\ ,/dY*1YaqB YSWWS\Zm Wp/1y ]\-S+WS , `14dWnb*b1 b1`O `\`* S W\3Zmf \+,SZ1ZSy P YSWWS\ZmD mWS WSj1Zm ,a1f ]`*,D ˙*31 ]`*,* Z* /\ab\yZ\1 h1W\,1h1aV\1 ]\-`1+1ZS1E * /\W-S1 -\/m Sf SY1Z* +mWS ]`\ab\ ,mh1`VZdbm S4 Sab\`SSx L]`14S/1Zb ˙YSb`Sy 1/,1/1,E 7> \Vbq+`q 6>>= -\/*E http://blog.kremlin.ru/post/35 http://blog.kremlin.ru/post/35MD ' aW\,*YS ]`14S/1Zb ˙YSb`Sy 1/,1/1, ]`S4,*W ,a1f Z*a a1`n14Z\ 4*/dY*bnaq \ b\YE hb\ ]`\S4\jW\ , \/SZ S4 a*Ymf Y`*hZmf ]1`S\/\, Z*O j1y Sab\`SSE V\-/* YSWWS\Zm Z*jSf a\\b1h1ab,1ZO ZSV\, ]\/,1`-WSan 31ab\h*yjSY `1]`1aaSqYD W\,* `14S/1Zb*E V*V S a*Y* S/1q ˙Zq ]*YqbSE \b`*3*O pb +W*-\`\/Zdp g1WnB Zd3Z\ ]\YZSbn \+ \jS+V*f ]`\jW\-\E hb\+m Z1 ]\,b\`qbn Sf , +d/dk1YD

'b\b b`*Vb*b S4/*Z /Wq b\-\E hb\+m ]\4Z*V\YSbn *a a b\y ab`*ZSg1y Sab\`SSE V\b\`*qE ,\4Y\3Z\E +mW* /Wq *a 4*V`mb*E S ]`1/d]`1/Sbn \ `1*WnZ\y \]*aZ\abSB Sab\`Sq Y\31b ]\,b\`SbnaqD \ adbSE d31 1abn ]`S4Z*VS Z*h*W* ob\-\ ]`\g1aa*D `q/ WS , ˙1Zn ]*YqbS Vb\Ob\ ,a]\YZSW \+ \/Z\y `1WS-S\4Z\y -`d]]1E V\b\`*q adk1ab,d1b , \aaSS d31 +\W11 5>> W1bD ˙\W-S1 -\/m /1aqbVS bmaqh ,1`dO pkSf ]\/,1`-*WSan ]`1aW1/\,*ZSqY 4* a,\p ,1`dD 1,SZ\,Zmf Wp/1y ,ma1WqWS S4 a\+ab,1ZZmf /\Y\, S \b]`*,WqWS , bp`nYm S b`d/\,m1 W*-1`q Z* /WSO b1WnZm1 a`\VSD *YmY +143*W\abZmY \+`*4\Y YdO 31y `*4Wdh*WS a 31Z*YSE `\/Sb1W1y P a /1bnYSE +*O +dj1V S /1/dj1V P a ,ZdV*YSD Z\-S1 S4 ZSf Z*,a1-/* ]\b1`qWS /`d- /`d-*D -`\YZ*q b`*-1/Sq Z*hSZ*W*an a Y*W\-\B a dY1O W\y Y*ZS]dWqgSS aWdf*YSE Z*Y1V\, S \-dWnZmf \+\+k1ZSyD SV1Y Z1 a/1`3S,*1Ym1E obS 4W\+Zm1 aW\,* ]1`1`*ab*WS , W\3n S \bV`\,1ZZdp VW1,1O bdD ˛*b1Y ]\aW1/\,*WS 4*]`1bmE \+maVSE *`1abmE ]\V*4*b1WnZm1 ad/mE aamWVS S bp`1YZm1 4*VWph1O ZSqD p/SE V\b\`m1 ]1`13SWS b1 V\jY*`Zm1 -\/m S d,S/1WS WdhjS1 ,`1Y1Z*E a1yh*a Z*+Wp/*pbE V*V Z* -\`S4\Zb1 aZ\,* a-dk*pbaq -`\4\,m1 bdhSD f ,Z\,n -\b\,* 4*fW1abZdbn ,\WZ* W\3Zmf \+,SZ1ZSy S ]`1aO W1/\,*ZSyD *V hb\ 31 ]`\Saf\/SbH 1d31WS Sab\O `Sq ]\,b\`q1baqH

SVb\` dbjYS/b a\ a,\1y a1Yn1y 4* Y1aqg /\ *`1ab*D ˛* ,1`d \Z ]`\,1W , bp`nY1 5> W1bE S4 ZSf 7 -\/* P , V*`g1`1

\eSgS*WnZ\ 4*`1-Sab`S`\,*Z* SZSab1`ab,\Y pabSO gSS , 5==5OY S ]1`1`1-Sab`S`\,*Z* , 5=== -\/dD 1-\/Zq , \aaSS +\W11 59; >>> ,S/1b1W1y 1-\,mE V\b\`m1 \+l1/SZ1Zm +\W11 h1Y , 6 >>> a\+`*ZSyD ˚k1 569 >>> h1W\,1V , Z*j1y ab`*Z1 S4dh*pb S+WSp ,Y1O ab1 a\ ,S/1b1WqYSD \4Y\3Z\E m b\31 ,ab`1h*O WSan a obSYS Wp/nYSE ,1/n a`1/S ZSf 1abn ]`1/ab*,Sb1O WS a*Ymf `*4Zmf aW\1, \+k1ab,*D 'b\ \+mhZm1 Wp/SE b`d/\Wp+S,m1 S h1abZm1D \31bE ob\ Vb\Ob\ S4 *O jSf `\/ab,1ZZSV\,E a\a1/1yE V\WW1- ]\ `*+\b1 SWS /`d41yD /Z*V\ , ]\aW1/Z11 ,`1Yq , ]\q,SWSan j\VSO `dpkS1 4*q,W1ZSq \ b\YE hb\ ,S/1b1WS 1-\,m P woVab`1YSabmxD Y b*V31 ]`SVW1S,*pb q`WmVS w\]*aO Z*q a1Vb*x S w*Y1`SV*ZaVS1 j]S\ZmxD *VS1 q`WmVSE V*V S VW1yY\ w,`*-S Z*`\/*xE Y\-db /*bn b\Wh\V Z\,mY ]`1aW1/\,*ZSqYD \/dY*yb1 ,\b \ h1YB ˙ \WnV\ , e1,`*W1 6>>= -\/* ]\ ,a1y ab`*Z1 +mW\ ]`\O ,1/1Z\ +\W11 9>> ]`\Vd`\`aVSf ]`\,1`\V `1WS-S\4Z\y /1qb1WnZ\abS ,S/1b1W1y 1-\,mD ˙ 14*V\ZZmY \+`*4\Y +mWS ]\Wdh1Zm a,1/1ZSq \ ]*O gS1Zb*fO ,S/1b1WqfE a\/1`3*kS1 ,`*h1+Zdp b*yZdD ˙ `m,*WSan +\-\aWd31ZSq , `1WS-S\4Zmf 4/*ZSqf S h*abZmf /\Y*fD ˙ `d+mY \+`*4\Y Z*`dj*WSan ]`*,* */,\V*b\,E ]mO b*,jSfaq \V*4*bn ]`*,\,dp ]\Y\kn ,S/1b1WqY 1-\O ,mE * b*V31 hSZSWSan ]`1]qbab,Sq Sf dh*abSp , ad/1+O Zmf 4*a1/*ZSqfD ˙ `*4WShZmf `1-S\Z*f ad/1+Zm1 SZab*ZgSS ]`1/]`SO ZSY*WS ]\]mbVS ]`S4Z*bn /1qb1WnZ\abn ,S/1b1W1y 1-\,m Z14*V\ZZ\y S WSV,S/S`\,*bn Sf Y1abZm1 `1WSO -S\4Zm1 \`-*ZS4*gSSD \4Y\3Z\E d *a ,\4ZSV*1b ,\]`\aB \+\aZ\,*ZZm WS b*VS1 \+,SZ1ZSq ]`\bS, ,S/1b1W1y 1-\,mH

wDDD ZShb\3*WSan g1Wm1 aW\S S a\aW\,Sq Z*O j1-\ Z*`\/*D DDD \/,1`-WSan ]`1aW1/\,*O ZSqY ]`1/ab*,Sb1WS *+a\WpbZ\ ,a1f `1WSO -S\4Zmf V\Ze1aaSyD DDD W1yY\ t,`*-\, Z*O `\/*r S Sf t]\a\+ZSV\,r W1-W\ b\-/* Z* g1O Wm1 a1YnSx L]`14S/1Zb ˙YSb`Sy 1/,1/1,E 7> \Vbq+`q 6>>= -\/*MD

\4\+Z\,qbaq WS ]`1aW1/\,*ZSqH ˚ ˚˙ ) f\`\j\ 4Z*V\Ym ,S/1b1WqY 1O -\,mD 1YS\Z \4WSgVSy +mW ]1`,mY , \aaSyaV\y SY]1`SSE Vb\ , 5<=5 -\/d ]`SZqW obd ,1`dD Z ab*W /1WSbnaq a,\SYS d+13/1ZSqYS a /`d-SYSE S 4* ob\ 1-\ a`*4d 31 a\aW*WS , S+S`nD 5=6>O1 S 5=7>O1 -\O /m aaW1/\,*b1W1y S+WSS LV*V b\-/* Z*4m,*WSan ,SO /1b1WS 1-\,mM , Z*j1y ab`*Z1 +mW\ a\,a1Y Z1YZ\-\E Z\ Sf d31 ]`1aW1/\,*WSD \aW1 b\`\y YS`\,\y ,\yO Zm ,S/1b1WS , b1h1ZS1 /1aqbSW1bSy ]\/,1`-*WSan `1O ]`1aaSqYD \b WSjn Z1V\b\`m1 e*VbmB ˙ a1 Z*h*W\an a ]`\]*-*Z/mD C,S/1b1W1y 4*VW1yYSWS V*V w*ZbSa\,1bhSV\,xE w*Y1`SV*ZaVSf j]S\Z\,x S w,`*O -\, Z*`\/*xD ˙ 5=8= ]\ 5=95 -\/ +\W11 = >>> ,S/1b1W1y 1-\,m +mWS ,maW*Zm 4* a,\p ,1`d , S+S`nD ˙ \aW1/ZS1 S4 4*VWph1ZZmf ,S/1b1W1y ]\WdhSO WS a,\+\/d , 5==> -\/dD maqhS ,S/1b1W1y 1-\,m +mWS ah*abWS,mB Sf `1*+SWSbS`\,*WS V*V Z1,SZZmf 31`b, `1]`1aaSyE aZq, a ZSf VW1yY\ w,`*-S Z*`\/*xD ˙1qb1WnZ\abn ,S/1b1W1y 1-\,m , \aaSS +mW* *V ,S/1b1WS 1-\,mE ]qbn hW1Z\, a1YnS WSYV\ +mWS ]`S-\,\`1Zm , \+k1y aW\3Z\abS V 56> -\/*Y 4*VWph1ZSq S ]`\,1WS , bp`nY*f S W*-1`qf 95 -\/

\Zab*ZbSZ V`S]hdVE ,S/1b1Wn 1-\,mE \baS/1W , bp`nY1 4* ,1`d 69 W1b

2

,S/1b1Wnab,\ \ `1*+SWSb*gSSE ,m/*,*,j11aq ,S/1b1WqY

+\aZ\,*ZZm WS \+,SZ1ZSqH ˚˙ & ˚E hb\ *a ]d+WShZ\ \+lq,SWS oVO ab`1YSab\Y SWS \]*aZmY ]`1abd]ZSV\YD *YS obS aW\,* 4*ab*,Wqpb a\/`\-ZdbnaqE Z*]\YSZ*q \ hd/\O ,SkZmf ]`1abd]W1ZSqf S a1`n14Z1yjSf ]`\+W1Y*f Z*j1-\ ,`1Y1ZSD h1Y h*k1 b*VS1 aW\,* ]\,b\`qpbO aqE b1Y +\Wnj1 SY ,1`qbD \ ab*Z\,qbaq WS \b ob\-\ ]\/\+Zm1 \+,SZ1ZSq a]`*,1/WS,mYSH ,S/1b1WS 1-\,m ]`1/W*-*pb *Y a*YSY \b,1bSbn Z* ob\b ,\]`\aD `S-W*j*1Y *a ]`SybS Z* Z*jS ,ab`1hS SWS ]\4Z*V\YSbnaq a Z*YSE V\-/* Ym ]`SO f\/SY V *YE hb\+m ]\/1WSbnaq a,\1y ,1`\yD \O ]`\+dyb1 d4Z*bn Z*a ]\+WS31E 1aWS m `*+\b*1b1E dhSO b1an a Z*YS SWS 3S,1b1 ]\ a\a1/ab,dD m d,1`1ZmB m SaV`1ZZ1 d/S,Sb1anE hb\ Z*a Z*4m,*pb oVab`1YSab*YS SWS \]*aZmYS /Wq \+k1ab,* Wp/nYSD 1Y ,m4,*Zm b*VS1 \+,SZ1ZSqH ˙*,*yb1 `*aaY\b`SY b`S \+,SZ1ZSqE ,m/,S-*1Ym1 ]`\bS, ,S/1b1W1y 1O -\,mE S V`*bVS1 \b,1bm Z* ZSfD

\+`*ZS1 ,S/1b1W1y 1-\,m , *-*Z`\-1 Sb WS ,SZSbn , ob\Y `*,\aW*,Zdp g1`V\,nH \Z1hZ\ 31E Z1bI %B \gS\W\-Sh1aV\1 SaaW1/\,*ZS1E ]`\,1/1ZZ\1 , 6>>5 -\/dE ]\V*4*W\E hb\ a1YnS ,S/1b1W1y 1-\,m `*aO ]*/*pbaq V`*yZ1 `1/V\D Z1Y -\,\`SW\anB w Z*WS4 /*ZZmf \]`\a* ]\V*4m,*1b \badbab,S1 V*V\-\OWS+\ Z1-*bS,Z\-\ ,\4/1yab,Sq ,1`\dh1ZSq S `1WS-S\4Z\y /1qb1WnZ\abS ,SO /1b1W1y 1-\,m Z* ,Zdb`Sa1Y1yZm1 \bZ\j1ZSqE Z* ,4*SY\O \bZ\j1ZSq Yd31y S 31ZE `\/Sb1W1y S /1b1yxD aaW1/\,*O ZS1 ,mq,SW\E hb\ ,\ YZ\-Sf \bZ\j1ZSqf +mW\ w\+Z*`d31Z\ ]\W\3Sb1WnZ\1 ,WSqZS1 ]`SZ*/W13Z\abS V ,S/1b1WqY 1-\,m x1D

˚ ˚B ,S/1b1WS 1-\,m \]*aZm /Wq -\ad/*`ab,*E b*V V*V ,\4+d3/*pb `1WS-S\4Zdp `\4ZnE db,1`3/*qE hb\ b\WnV\ Sf `1WS-Sq SabSZZ*qD ˙ • ˚B ˛Z*1b1 WS m `1WS-SpE V\b\`*q Z1 dbO ,1`3/*W* +mE hb\ b\WnV\ \Z* SabSZZ*qH *4,1 +d/1b h1O W\,1V Sa]\,1/\,*bn V*VdpOWS+\ `1WS-SpE 1aWS \Z Z1 ,1`SbE hb\ 11 dh1ZSq SabSZZmH \Wdh*1baqE hb\ ]\/\+Z\1 \+,SO Z1ZS1 Y\3Z\ , `*,Z\y ab1]1ZS ]`1/lq,Sbn V\ ,a1Y `1WSO -SqYD \4Y\3Z\E ]`*,SWnZ11 +mW\ +m a]`\aSbnB w *V ]`1/O ab*,Sb1W1y b\y SWS SZ\y `1WS-SS dh*b \bZ\aSbnaq V Wp/qYE d V\b\`mf /`d-S1 d+13/1ZSqHx %B ,S/1b1WS 1-\,m ZS /Wq V\-\ Z1 ]`1/ab*,O Wqpb \]*aZ\abSD ZS f\`\j\ S4,1abZm b1YE hb\ ab*`*pbO aq 3Sbn ]\ +S+W1yaVSY ]`SZgS]*YD \ob\Yd \ZS \b,1`-*O pb ,a1 e\`Ym Z*aSWSq L *be1q 6:B96MD ZS ]\/hSZqpbaq a,1baVSY 4*V\Z*Y L5 1b`* 6B57E 58MD ZS ab`1Yqbaq V YSO `d ,\ ,a1f \+W*abqf 3S4ZS L SYWqZ*Y 56B5<MD \/Z\Y b`d/1E ,m]dk1ZZ\Y ]\/ `1/*VgS1y D D h1/W\,*E 4*ZSO Y*,j1-\ ]\ab ]`1/a1/*b1Wq 'Va]1`bZ\-\ a\,1b* /Wq ]`\O ,1/1ZSq -\ad/*`ab,1ZZ\y `1WS-S\,1/h1aV\y oVa]1`bS4m ]`S SZSab1`ab,1 pabSgSS E \bY1h*1baqB w \ad/*`ab,1ZO Z*q ,W*abn `*aaY*b`S,*1baq ,S/1b1WqYS 1-\,m V*V dab`\yab,\E adk1ab,dpk11 a ]\4,\W1ZSq \-*D ZS Z1 ,abdO ]*pb , V\ZeWSVb a 4*V\Z\YE d,*3*pb ]\`q/\V S 4*V\Z\]\O aWdj*ZS1x1D

˚ ˚B ,S/1b1WS 1-\,m \bV*4m,*pbaq \b Y1/SgSZaV\-\ W1h1ZSqD ˙ • ˚B ˚aWS +m ,S/1b1WS 1-\,m \bV*4m,*WSan \b W1h1ZSqE b\ \ZS Z1 \+`*k*WSan +m 4* Y1/SgSZaV\y ]\Y\O knp S Z1 `*+\b*WS +m Y1/a1ab`*YS S ,`*h*YSD * a*O Y\Y /1W1 \ZS f\bqb ]\Wdh*bn Z*SWdhj11 W1h1ZS1 /Wq a1+q S a,\Sf /1b1yD ZS g1Zqb 3S4Zn S Wp+qb a,\Sf /1b1yD ZS WSjn ]`\aqbE hb\+m Sf W1hSWS +14 Sa]\Wn4\,*ZSq V`\,SD %B a1 +\Wnj1 Y1/SgSZaVSf dh`13/1ZSy ,\ ,a1Y YS`1 ]`1/W*-*pb +1aV`\,Zm1 Y1b\/m W1h1ZSqD \h1O YdH \b\Yd hb\ YZ\-S1 ,`*hS ahSb*pb +1aV`\,Zdp Y1/SO gSZd +\W11 ,ma\VSY ab*Z/*`b\Y W1h1ZSqD 6>>8 -\/d -W*,Zmy b`*Zaed4S\W\- SZSab1`ab,* 4/`*,\\f`*Z1ZSq aV*4*WE hb\ w\bV*4 \b \]1`*gSS ]1`1WS,*ZSq \aZ\,Zmf V\YO ]\Z1Zb\, /\Z\`aV\y V`\,S Z1 `*,Z\4Z*h1Z \bV*4d \b Y1/SO gSZaV\y ]\Y\kS , g1W\Yx2D 1 *dhZ\1 4*VWph1ZS1 ]\ `14dWnb*b*Y a\gS\W\-Sh1aV\-\ SaaW1/\O ,*ZSq `1WS-S\4Z\y \+kSZm ,S/1b1W1y 1-\,m -D \aV,mE a\ab*,W1ZZ\1 ]`\e1aa\`\Y D D Zb\Z\,mY S /\g1Zb\Y D D 1/V\,mY LV*e1/`* a\O gS\W\-SS S /1Y\-`*eSS a1YnS \gS\W\-Sh1aV\-\ e*VdWnb1b* \aV\,aV\O -\ -\ad/*`ab,1ZZ\-\ dZS,1`aSb1b* SY1ZS D D \Y\Z\a\,*MD 2 b,1b /S`1Vb\`* -1Y*b\W\-SS S b`*Zaed4S\W\-SS SZ4/`*,* 1WS,*Z\,* ˚D D \b 56D>6D6>>8 -\/* Š 6> Z* 4*]`\a */,\V*b* 13O /dZ*`\/Z\y V\WW1-SS */,\V*b\, w *ZVbO 1b1`+d`-x 1\Zbn1,* D ˚D

˚ ˚B ,S/1b1WS 1-\,m P ob\ /1ab`dVbS,Z*q a1Vb*E b*V V*V \ZS `*4`dj*pb a1YnSD ˙ • ˚B \]`\a `1WS-SS Y\31b ab*bn k1V\bWS,\y b1Y\y , Wp+\y a1Yn1E \a\+1ZZ\ V\-/* \/SZ S4 11 hW1O Z\, ]`SZSY*1b /`d-dp ,1`dD \ 1aWS S4O4* ob\-\ , a1Yn1 ,\4ZSV*pb `*4Z\-W*aSqE b\ ,SZ\,*b* WS , ZSf `1WS-SqH WS 31 a*YS Wp/S \b,1h*pb 4* b\E V*V \ZS ]`1\/\W1,*pb `*af\3/1ZSq ,\ ,4-Wq/*fH *]`SY1`E 1aWS , a1Yn1 ,\4ZSV V\ZeWSVb S4O4* b\-\E hb\ \/SZ S4 11 hW1Z\, ]1`1j1W , ]`*O ,\aW*,S1 SWS ab*W YZ\-\ ,`1Y1ZS ]`\,\/Sbn , g1`V,SE ab\O

˚aWS d *a 1abn ,\]`\amE a,q4*ZZm1 a ,1`\dh1ZS1Y S /1qb1WnZ\abnp ,S/1b1W1y 1-\,mE ]\3*Wdyab*E \+`*k*yb1an V Z*Y WShZ\D \Wnj1 SZe\`Y*gSS Y\3Z\ Z*ybS Z* Z*j1Y ,1+Oa*yb1 www.jw-russia.org.

1 1WS-SS Z*`\/\, a\,`1Y1ZZ\y \aaSS N \/ `1/D D D h1/W\,*E DE 5===D D 8:7D

3

b\ ]`SZ1a1b +d/dk11H

W*YSxD *V +d/1b WS \aaSq ab`1YSbnaq V +W*-\`\/Z\y g1WSE ,m`*31ZZ\y , ]`\gSbS`\,*ZZmf ,mj1 aW\,*f ]`14S/1Zb* 1/,1/1,*E SWS 31 \]dabSbaq /\ `*a]`\O ab`*Z1ZSq VW1,1bm S ]`1aW1/\,*ZSq `1WS-S\4Z\-\ Y1ZnjSZab,*H 'b\ ]\V*31b WSjn ,`1YqD \ \ /,df ,1k*f Y\3Z\ a d,1`1ZZ\abnp aV*4*bn d31 a1yh*aD \O]1`,mfE `1]`1aaSS Z1 ]`SZ1adb da]1f*D m Z1 ]`1V`*bSY b*VbShZ\ S d,*3Sb1WnZ\ -\,\`Sbn \ \O -1 1-\,1 S 1-\ W\,1E S+WSS L5 1b`* 7B59MD m Z1 ]`1V`*bSWS -\,\`Sbn ]\/ /*,W1ZS1Y Z*gSabaV\y 1`O Y*ZSSD m Z1 ]`1V`*bSWS -\,\`Sbn , a*Ym1 Y`*hZm1 -\/m `1]`1aaSy , Z*j1y ab`*Z1D m Z1 ]`1V`*bSY -\O ,\`Sbn S a1yh*a L˙1qZSq 8B5<P6>MD \O,b\`mfE b*VS1 ab`*jZm1 aW\,*E V*V w\]*aZ*q a1VO b*xE w,`*-S Z*`\/*x S woVab`1YSabmxE aSWnZm WSjn /\ b1f ]\`E ]\V* Sf +14/dYZ\ ]\,b\`qpbD 1b\/ SaO ]\Wn4\,*ZSq Z*Y1V\, S VW1,1bm Z1 /\W31Z a`*+\b*bn Z* *aD m Z*/11YaqE hb\ m Z1 ab*Z1b1 ]`SZSY*bn Z* ,1`d ]dabm1 aW\,*E * ]\ab*`*1b1an ,ZSVZdbn , adbn /1W*D

w 1]`1aaSqY Z1b \]`*,/*ZSyx L]`14S/1Zb ˙YSb`Sy 1/,1/1,E 7> \Vbq+`q 6>>= -\/*MD ' aW\,* ,a1Wqpb Z*/13/dD ,S/1b1WS 1-\,m +W*O -\/*`Zm /\W3Z\abZmY WSg*YE V\b\`m1 ]`SW*-*pb ,a1 daSWSqE hb\+m ]`1b,\`Sbn Sf , 3S4ZnD *VS1 Wp/S SaO V`1ZZ1 ab*`*pbaq ]\Zqbn ,S/1b1W1y S 4*kSbSbn Sf ]`*,\ Z* a,\+\/d ,1`\Sa]\,1/*ZSqD

/Wq ob\-\ 1abn ,1aVS1 \aZ\,*ZSqD \]`1VS ,a1Y aWdO f*YE ,S/1b1WS Z1 4*]`1k1Zm ZS , \/Z\y S4 ab`*Z ˚,`\O ]mE 1,1`Z\y S (3Z\y Y1`SVSD ˙1qb1WnZ\abn ,S/1O b1W1y \-`*ZSh1Z* , Z1V\b\`mf ab`*Z*f 4SS S e`SVSE -/1 f`SabS*Zab,\ Z1 q,Wq1baq b`*/SgS\ZZ\y `1WS-S1y S ]`*,Sb1Wnab,* \-`*ZShS,*pb ]`*VbSh1aVS Wp+dp f`SabSO *ZaVdp `1WS-S\4Zdp /1qb1WnZ\abnD \ ,a1Y YS`1 ,S/1O b1WS 1-\,m ]\Wn4dpbaq jS`\VSYS ]`*,*YSE , b\Y hSaO W1 ]`*,\Y Z* 4*kSbd \b ]`1aW1/\,*ZSyD 1yh*a \ZS ]`\]\,1/dpb , 67: ab`*Z*f S b1``Sb\`SqfE S Sf hSaW\ ]`1,mj*1b a1Yn YSWWS\Z\,D

m a\,1bd1Y *Y a*YSY d4Z*bn ]`*,/d \ ,S/1b1Wqf 1-\,mD *j 3d`Z*W w b\`\31,*q +*jZqx S4/*1baq Z* 5<> q4mV*f S ]1h*b*1baq Z1]`1`m,Z\ d31 57> W1bD S`*3 V*3/\-\ ,m]daV* ]`1,mj*1b 7> YSWWS\Z\, oV41Y]Wq`\,D `S-W*j*1Y *a ]`\hSb*bn \/SZ S4 ,m]daV\, ob\-\ 3d`Z*W*E \bV`m,*q , a,\1y S+WSS ]`S,\/SYm1 , Z1Y +S+W1yaVS1 abSfSD d/1Y \h1Zn `*/m d4Z*bn *j1 YZ1ZS1D

,a1 31 \4Z*h*pb WS ]\/\+Zm1 /\abS31ZSq , ae1`1 ]`*, h1W\,1V*E hb\ , \aaSS +\Wnj1 Z1 Z*abdO ]Sb Y`*hZ\1 ,`1Yq `1]`1aaSy S ]`1aW1/\,*ZSyH a1E Vb\ g1Zqb a,\+\/dE SaV`1ZZ1 Z* ob\ Z*/1pbaqD 1Y Z1 Y1Z11 f\h1baq a]`\aSbnB ˚ ]`\/\W3*pbaq +14\aZ\,*b1WnZm1 ]`\,1`VSE f\bq aZ\,* S aZ\,* Z1 \+Z*`d3S,*1baq ZSV*VSf /\V*4*b1Wnab, ]`*,\Z*`dj1ZSyH ˚ ,S/1b1WqY 1-\,m Y1j*pb YS`Z\ a\O +S`*bnaq ,Y1ab1E hb\+m , a]\V\yZ\y \+ab*Z\,V1 S4dh*bn S+WSpE b1Y a*YmY WSj*q Sf ]`*,*E -*`*ZbS`\,*ZZ\-\ \ZabSbdgS1y S Y13/dZ*O `\/ZmYS V\Z,1ZgSqYSH ˚ ,S/1b1WS Z1 Y\-db a,\+\/Z\ ,,\4Sbn , a,\p ab`*Zd WSb1`*bd`dE V\b\`*q ]\Wn4d1baq Y13/dZ*`\/ZmY ]`S4Z*ZS1YE S ]`1/W*-*bn 11 /`d-SYH

< /1V*+`q 6>>= -\/* 1`f\,Zmy ad/ ]`S4Z*W `q/ Z*jSf ]d+WSV*gSy woVab`1YSabaVSYS Y*b1`S*O

www.jw-russia.org ,S/1b1WqY 1-\,mE *Nq 5<6E *ZVbO 1b1`+d`-E 5=>>>>D ˘ 2009 Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania. a1 ]`*,* a\f`*ZqpbaqD T-83-U Druck und Verlag: Wachtturm, Selters/Taunus Printed in Germany, 2010 4