Scoring Rubric – Story Telling ECEF 2020 Nama Juri : Nomor Peserta : 19 Topic / Judul : Sangkuriang
Category
Poor
Fair
Good
Excellent
Score
Comment
Interpretation of manuscripts
Points: 0 – 3 Does not know story, reads from notes, so many errors that create confusion
Points: 4 – 7 Knows some of the story, has not practiced, relies on notes (unnatural), small errors, appears uncomfortable
Points: 8 – 11 Knows the story pretty well, some practice, almost no error, flow of the story is understandable, fairly confident
Points: 12 – 15 Knows the story well, has obviously practiced telling the story, the flow of the story is natural, speaks with confident
4
He seem to understand the story but unfortunately the music background is distracting making his story is unclear.
Vocal
Points: 0 – 3 Speaks too softly or too rapidly, mumbles, no tone difference to differ parts of the story, incorrect pronunciation
Points: 4 – 7 May speak too softly or too rapidly, mumbles occasionally, intonation is used but not so correctly, incorrect pronunciation of some words
Points: 8 – 11 Usually speaks loudly and slowly, clear articulation, intonation is used fairly, correct pronunciation
Points: 12 – 15 Always speaks loudly with the right speed, clear articulation, intonations is wellused, perfect pronunciation
3
Speaks too softly ,mumbles,monotones and many pronunciation errors.
Gesture
Points: 0 - 2,5 Contained little to no facial expression, gesture or movement – no acting, just reading
Points: 2,6 – 5 Needed more facial expressions, gesture and movement
Points: 5,1 – 7,5 Contained enough facial expressions, gesture, and body movement but not so accurate for the setting
Points: 7,6 – 10 Great use of facial expressions, gestures, and body movement, accurate with the setting – the characters are truly embodied
3
Almost no gesture and body movement
Creativity
Points: 2 Poor to no use of props or inappropriate props
Points: 3 Uses props some of the time, some props are not appropriate or are distracting
Points: 4 Good use of props, props are appropriate but can be done better
Points: 5 Outstanding use of props, props are appropriate
2
Do not use of props
Unity
Points : 2 Not communicative, flat or not engaging delivery, the story is unclear
Points: 3 Quite communicative, builds small engagement to the audience, the story is not so understood because of many errors
Points: 4
Points: 5 Very communicative, great engagement, the story is welldelivered, beyond expectation
2
Less communicative, monotone delivery, the story is unclear , visual effect and music background even making harder to observe his speech.
TOTAL ( MAX=50)
14
Additional Rules: Editing is prohibited in the video. The video must be a one take video, with no editing including but not limited to trimming, cutting, adding sound effect, using digital property, etc; should there be any kind of editing in the video, the score will be deducted: -
1-3 editing, minus 5 points. >3 editing, minus 10 points.
NOTES! Alur penilaian untuk lomba Story Telling: 1. Download rubrik penilaian (file ini) 2. Isi rubrik sesuai dengan peserta yang dinilai 3. Save dengan file name : Story Telling nomor urut peserta_nama juri *cth : Story Telling 001_David Dobrik 4. Upload rubrik yg sudah terisi (dalam bentuk .pdf) ke folder peserta yang dinilai
*utk menilai peserta lainnya, silahkan download kembali rubrik penilaian atau download -> copy sesuai dengan total pesertanya. *diharapkan untuk tidak mengedit di Google Docs karena akan menghambat penilaian juri lainnya. Terima kasih.