E\ VWHSKHQ SDODKDFK $QLPDO 3ROLWLFV $QLPDO 3ROLWLFV Animal Politics
HiZe]Zc EVaV]VX] [ 12 ] 6c^bVa Eda^i^Xh
E\ 6WHSKHQ 3DODKDFK
I]ZgZ lVh cd egZh^YZci ZaZXiZY i]^h nZVg! h^cXZ Vaa d[ i]Z XVcY^YViZh lZgZ bVjaZY Wn a^dch# >chiZVY! lZ YZX^YZY id ^ckVYZ V Y^hiVci Xdjcign# Djg ZnZh lZgZ hZi dc IjoZ`^hiVc! V cVi^dc [djcY dc i]Z di]Zg h^YZ d[ i]Z \adWZ# I]Zn dkZgi]gZl i]Z^g Y^XiVidgh]^e gjaZ VcY _d^cZY i]Z J#C#! lVhi^c\ cd i^bZ ^c ZhiVWa^h]^c\ ZbWVhh^Zh ^c Vaa &.& Vaa^ZY Xdjcig^Zh# IjoZ`^hiVc ]VeeZcZY id WZ hbVaa! V e^c]ZVY dc V lVaa"h^oZY ldgaY bVe# LZ Zhi^bViZY i]Z edejaVi^dc Vi lZaa jcYZg V i]djhVcY# I]^h lVh cd XVjhZ [dg XdcXZgc0 i]Z Zci^gZ edejaVi^dc lVh cZZYZY id `ZZe ZVX] ZbWVhhn gjcc^c\ Z[ÒX^Zcian# IjoZ`^hiVc lVh Vc jcYZghiVcYVWan ZVhn iVg\Zi h^cXZ ^i lVh bdgZ dg aZhh jc^c]VW^iZY# L]^aZ i]Z cVi^kZh d[ IjoZ`^hiVc hdj\]i ]Veen a^kZh ldg`^c\ djih^YZ d[ i]Z^g Xdjcign! lZ [djcY djghZakZh aVX`^c\ V cVi^dcVa ^YZci^in# I]Z ^cY^k^YjVah d[ i]Z aVcY XVbZ [dgi] VcY jcVc^bdjhan [dgbZY I]Z 6c\gn BdW d[ i]Z LZhi# Djg ^c^i^Va eaVc ^ckdakZY hidgb^c\ i]Z egZh^YZciÉh eVaVXZ l^i] \jch WaVo^c\! Wji ^i lVh kVXVci l]Zc lZ ]VY Vgg^kZY# :kZgn bZbWZg d[ i]Z 6c\gn BdW \gVWWZY i]Z^g eVgVX]jiZh VcY \jch! Ygdee^c\ dc i]Z XVe^iVa X^in d[ IjoZ`^hiVc a^`Z i]Z Vc\gn dbZch lZ lZgZ# I]Z X^in ^ihZa[ lVh hi^aa jcYZg XdchigjXi^dc! heZX`aZY l^i] bjYYn Y^iX]Zh VcY VY_VXZci ÆBZc ldg`^c\Ç h^\ch# 9ZVY h^aZcXZ hlZei dkZg i]Z higZZih Vh djg hiZZa"i^eeZY Wddih higjX` i]Z Y^gi# I]Z idgc! l]^iZ h]^gi ]Vc\^c\ dkZg i]Z eVaVXZ bVgfjZZ lVh V XaZVg ^cY^XVi^dc i]Vi IjoZ`^hiVc ]VY hjggZcYZgZY# 6i i]^h ed^ci > lVh gZb^cYZY d[ bn Òghi ZmeZg^ZcXZ ^c k^Zl^c\ i]Z YZbdXgVi^X ZaZXidgVa egdXZhh#
:kZgn nZVg i]Z ZkZci lVh ]ZVk^an Vci^X^eViZY VcY iZaZk^hZY dc Vaa i]gZZ cZildg`h# I]Z egdXZhh lVh iZgg^Wan XaZkZg VcY h^beaZ# >i idd` VlVn bVcn d[ i]Z ^c]ZgZci egdWaZbh ^ckdakZY l^i] VgX]V^X kdi^c\ bZi]dYh# I]ZgZ lVh cd [jhh dkZg XdcigVhi^c\ hdX^Va ^hhjZh dg Xdc[jh^c\ eda^i^XVa V\ZcYVh# I]^h idd` V adi d[ lZ^\]i d[[ V X^i^oZcÉh h]djaYZgh# >i Vahd egdkZY id WZ ZmX^i^c\! h^cXZ ZVX] ZaZXi^dc ijgcZY dji id WZ V
idiVa hjgeg^hZ! ^c VYY^i^dc id i]Z ^bbZchZ hZchZ d[ ZciZgiV^cbZci i]Z \gZVi heZXiVXaZ egdk^YZY# >i ]VY WZZc ZmeaV^cZY ^c \gVYZ hX]dda/ :VX] d[ i]Z i]gZZ XVcY^YViZh ldjaY WdVgY ]^h gZheZXi^kZ eaVi[dgb! ZVX] ^YZci^XVa! Wji V Xdch^YZgVWaZ Y^hiVcXZ d[ ZVX] di]Zg# I]^h idd` eaVXZ ^c i]Z ÒZaY d[ V bVhh^kZ Xda^hZjb! l]ZgZ ]jcYgZYh d[ i]djhVcYh d[ heZXiVidgh \aZZ[jaan X]ZZgZY dc i]Z^g bVc d[ X]d^XZ# I]Zc i]Zn
ldjaY gZaZVhZ i]Z a^dch# L]Vi ZchjZY lVh ajX^Y ZciZgiV^cbZci VcY jiiZgan YZa^\]i[ja# I]Z gdVg^c\ XgdlYh YgdlcZY dji i]Z i]^ghin hcVgah d[ i]Z a^dch! l]d odcZY ^c dc i]Z iVg\Zih eV^ciZY dc i]Z XVcY^YViZhÉ cVkn WaVoZgh! X^gXaZ Wn X^gXaZ# IVg\Zih lZgZ V [Vb^a^Vg h^\]i WVX` i]Zc# >c i]Z [VXZ d[ ^cZk^iVWaZ lVg!