2025 Holiday Gift Guide

ELLSWORTH CREAMERY

Holiday Gift Guide

Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery The Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery is based in the Heart of Wisconsin’s Dairyland in the town of Ellsworth. Our cooperative is 180 patron families strong, with each of our member farms dedicated to producing the highest quality milk for our cheeses.

Our all-natural Cheddar Cheese Curds are our specialty product. They’re so delicious that we’ve earned the title of “Cheese Curd Capital”.

But we’re known for more than our cheese curds! Our Menomonie, Wisconsin, facility manufactures over 70 varieties of artisan cheese, many of which are award winners. You may recognize our brands from your favorite specialty cheese shop or grocery store: Antonella and Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery’s Premium Block Cheese.

Why Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery • A tradition of excellence since 1910 • Each purchase supports our cooperative’s farm families • Award-winning cheeses of the highest quality • A wholesome edible gift from Wisconsin is perfect for any occasion

A Gift That Brings People Together When it comes to finding the perfect gift, we’ve got a little secret: Nothing beats a gift made from the heart! Our farm families and production staff take great pride in our cheeses, making the Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery name synonymous with wholesomeness and quality.

Our gift boxes are available for purchase at either of our retail locations and online. We can ship anywhere in the United States!

Scan this QR code to order online today or visit our website at EllsworthCheese.com/ holiday

ELLSWORTH COOPERATIVE CREAMERY 3

This year with a

NEW LOOK Freshness Guaranteed

Gift box pricing does not include shipping. In addition, a $10 packaging fee is added to each shipped gift box order. This charge covers freshness shipping materials, such as ice-packs and insulated packaging, ensuring your order arrives in premium condition.

On Time Delivery Guaranteed holiday delivery when you order by these dates, per ship method.

Order cutoff is 4pm CST. Thanksgiving 11/27 Standard 11/20 | Rush 11/24 Christmas 12/25 Standard 12/15 | Rush 12/22 New Years Day Standard 12/26 | Rush 12/29

4 ELLSWORTH COOPERATIVE CREAMERY

*Mock-up image is for illustrative purposes only. Final product details may vary.

Cheese GIFT BOXES

Happy Holstein

Great Guernsey

Includes 16oz Natural Curds, 7.5oz White Includes 16oz Natural Curds, 5oz Garlic Curds, 5oz Ranch Curds, 7.5oz Muenster, Cheddar, 7.5oz Bacon Cheddar, 7.5oz 7.5oz Sharp Cheddar, 7.5oz Pepper Jack, Montico, and Sailer’s Beef Sticks. $25 and Sailer’s Beef Sticks. $30

Whole Herd

Ellsworth Family Tradition

Includes 16oz Natural Curds, 16oz Garlic Curds, 16oz Ranch Curds, 5oz Cajun Curds, 5oz Dill Curds, 5oz Hot Buffalo Curds, 5oz Hickory Bacon Curds, and 5oz Taco Curds. $40

Includes 16oz Natural Curds, 7.5oz White Cheddar, 7.5 Salami Colby, 7.5 Pepper Jack, 15.5 Sharp Cheddar, Sailer’s Regular Summer Sausage, and Seaquist Chocolate Cherries. $45

6 ELLSWORTH COOPERATIVE CREAMERY

Ellsworth Farmer’s Market Includes 5oz Natural Curds, 5oz Ranch Curds, 7.5oz Medium Cheddar, 7.5oz Sharp Cheddar, 7.5oz Montico, 7.5oz Pepper Jack, 7.5oz Muenster, Sailer’s Regular Summer Sausage, and Seaquist Chocolate Cherries.

Price: $50

ORDER IN-STORE OR ONLINE AT: EllsworthCheese.com/ 8 ELLSWORTH COOPERATIVE CREAMERY holiday

Gourmet Grazer Includes 16oz Natural Curds, 8oz 1885 Aged Cheddar, 8oz Antonella Garden Vegetable, 8oz Antonella Roasted Garlic, 8oz Antonella Pepperoni, North Country Port Wine Spread, Seaquist Chocolate Cherries, Sailer’s Beef Sticks, and a Cheese Knife.

Price: $75

8 ELLSWORTH COOPERATIVE CREAMERY

Ellsworth Creamery Select Includes 16oz Natural Curds, 16oz Dill Curds, 16oz Ranch Curds, 5oz Cajun Curds, 5oz Hickory Bacon Curds, 5oz Taco Curds, 8oz 1885 Aged Cheddar, 15.5oz Bacon Cheddar, 15.5oz Muenster, 7.5oz Salami Colby, 7.5oz Medium Cheddar, 7.5oz Extra Sharp, 7.5oz Pepper Jack, Sailer’s Regular Summer Sausage, Seaquist Chocolate Cherries, and Thick N Thin Slicer.

Price: $100

ORDER IN-STORE OR ONLINE AT: EllsworthCheese.com/ 8 ELLSWORTH COOPERATIVE CREAMERY holiday

Reserve Grand Champion Includes 16oz Natural Curds, 16oz Garlic Curds, 16oz Ranch Curds, 16oz Dill Curds, 5oz Hot Buffalo Curds, 5oz Hickory Bacon Curds, 5oz Taco Curds, 8oz 1885 Aged Cheddar, 8oz Antonella Roasted Garlic, 8oz Antonella Pepperoni, 8oz Antonella Garden Vegetable, 15.5oz Sharp Cheddar, 15.5oz Muenster, 15.5oz Colby, 15.5oz Salami Colby, 7.5oz Pepper Jack, 7.5oz Montico, 7.5oz White Cheddar, 7.5oz Bacon Cheddar, North Country Port Wine Spread, North Country Sharp Cheddar Spread, Sailer’s Beef Sticks, Sailer’s Cranberry Summer Sausage, Sailer’s Regular Summer Sausage, Seaquist Chocolate Cherries, and a Beechwood Slicer.

Price: $200

ORDER IN-STORE OR ONLINE AT: 10 ELLSWORTH COOPERATIVE CREAMERY

EllsworthCheese.com/ holiday

Recipes WITH OUR CHEESE CHEESY MASHED POTATOES 6 large potatoes 1 package (8 oz) cream cheese, softened 1 cup Ellsworth Smoke & Bacon Cheddar Cheese, softened 1/2 cup sour cream 1/3 cup onion, chopped 1 egg 2 tsp salt 1/2 tsp pepper Instructions 1. Place potatoes in a large saucepan; cover with water. Cover and bring to a boil. Cook for 20-25 minutes or until very tender; drain well.

2. In a bowl, mash potatoes. Add cream cheese, cheddar cheese, sour cream, onion, egg, salt and pepper; beat until fluffy. Transfer to a greased 2-qt. baking dish. Cover and bake at 350° for 40-45 minutes or until heated through. Sprinkle with additional cheese if desired.

10

ELLSWORTH COOPERATIVE CREAMERY

ORDER IN-STORE OR ONLINE AT: EllsworthCheese.com/holiday

Two retail locations!

Open 7 days a week - 8am-6pm Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery - Ellsworth 232 North Wallace Ellsworth, WI 715-273-4311

@ellsworthcreamery

Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery - Menomonie 3001 County Road B Menomonie, WI 715-430-5311

/EllsworthCheese

Our Shipping Guidelines Gift box pricing does not include shipping charges. All shipping addresses must include a street address; unfortunately, no PO Box addresses can be accepted.

Our staff does their absolute best to see that your package arrives in great condition.

However, we can’t be responsible for weather damage or damage due to actions/neglect by the shipping company or receiver. We are not responsible for delivery failures or additional charges due to incorrect or incomplete addresses. Products may be room temperature when they arrive, but their condition will be fine if refrigerated upon arrival.

To ensure your cheese retains its quality on its journey, a $10 packaging fee is added to each shipped gift box order. This charge covers freshness shipping materials, such as ice-packs and insulated packaging, which ensure your order arrives in premium condition.

Christmas is our busiest season; we recommend you order early. We appreciate at least 14 days to make sure your gifts from the Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery arrive on time. In the rare event we sell out of a product, we reserve the right to substitute products of equal or greater value in gift assortments, if necessary. This allows us to ship without delay.