March 21, 2018

Page 1

The Chronicle

See Inside Wang leads Duke to second-place finish Page 8

T H E I N D E P E N D E N T D A I LY AT D U K E U N I V E R S I T Y

WEDNESDAY, MARCH 21, 2018 DUKECHRONICLE.COM

ONE HUNDRED AND THIRTEENTH YEAR, ISSUE 69

DSG Judiciary rules in favor of candidate Kristina Smith The matter will be remanded to the attorney general for further review By Isabelle Doan University News Editor

Undergraduates will have to wait a little bit longer to find out who their next Duke Student Government president is. After hearing DSG presidential candidate Kristina Smith’s appeal at a hearing Tuesday night, the Judiciary decided that the election rule that penalized Smith by 200 votes was unconstitutional. The rule in question was Section 6 of the Election Rules and Procedures 2017-2018, which states that students cannot solicit votes “while possessing any laptop, tablet, or similar electronic device that can access the ballot.” Based on this rule, the Board of Elections and Attorney General Shreya Bhatia, a sophomore, decided to dock Smith 200 votes from the tally of voters who ranked her first because campaign members were playing music on an iPad outside Marketplace. The petitioners—Smith and junior Luke Farrell, Smith’s advocate and co-campaign manager—contested this decision in front of the Judiciary. Chief Justice Dev Dabke, a junior, said that the Judiciary found the election rule to be unconstitutional because it is “overly broad.” However, it remanded the matter to Bhatia who has 168 hours to decide if Smith violated any other rules. The Judiciary also decided that the 200 vote penalty was “arbitrary and capricious,” violating the due process and cruel and unusual punishment clauses of the DSG Bill of Rights. Farrell presented four claims in his opening argument, claiming that there was

a violation of due process, that Section 6 was misinterpreted and also unconstitutional and that the 200 vote calculation was baselessly severe. In his closing statement, he later dropped his claim that Section 6 was misinterpreted. “Before this punishment was voted on and decided by the Board of Elections, the

Smith campaign was given no opportunity to have a hearing, violating Section 8, Number 5 of the Election Rules and Procedures, that an in-person hearing shall be automatic for a possible deduction of 50 votes or more,” Farrell said. Bhatia stated that in one phone call to Smith the night of the violation, she

Bre Bradham | Associate Photography Editor The Duke Student Government Judiciary heard arguments from junior Luke Farell, advocate for junior Kristina Smith, and Attorney General Shreya Bhatia, a sophomore.

informed the presidential candidate of the Board of Elections’ decision to dock her 200 docked votes and give her a guaranteed hearing. “After informing her that we agreed upon 200 votes, I began to tell her that she had the right to a guaranteed in-person hearing, but she surprisingly hung up the phone abruptly,” Bhatia claimed in her opening statement. Smith later clarified Bhatia’s account with Chief Justice Dev Dabke, a senior. “I absolutely did not hang up,” Smith said. “The phone call ended.” Later, Farrell called upon a witness to this phone call, junior Maggie Haas, who was part of Smith’s campaign. Haas noted that Smith did not hang up abruptly. Bhatia also raised the concern that Smith was aware of the rules, as candidates were clearly made aware of Section 6 during a meeting with all presidential candidates. In her opening argument, Bhatia also said that Smith informed her that “she is very familiar with the rules.” “This statement in itself is concerning,” Bhatia said. “Because this violation did not take place due to ignorance or not realizing that Section 6 was a rule in place, but rather by someone who had heard this exact rule discussed in the candidates’ meeting, and who also claims to be very familiar with the rules and procedures.” But Farrell claimed that the rule itself was unconstitutional on the grounds that Section 6 restricts free speech. He also noted that it’s a narrowly defined rule. He cited precedent and See SMITH on Page 4

DUU: Rapper Duke shuts down Georgia offense to advance Lupe Fiasco to Sweet 16, set up meeting with Connecticut set to headline Old Duke WOMEN’S BASKETBALL

By Dani Schneider Staff Reporter

Bre Bradham | Associate Photography Editor Leaonna Odom led the Blue Devils in scoring in both of the first two rounds, knocking down midrange jumpers at an efficient clip.

After an impressive first-round performance, the Blue Devils took to the court at Stegeman Coliseum and shocked the hosts with a blowout win. No. 5 seed Duke routed fourth-seeded and 18th-ranked Georgia 66-40 in the second round of the NCAA tournament in Athens, Ga., to advance to the Sweet 16 and a showdown with DUKE 66 top-seeded Connecticut. Four Blue Devils in double figures, and they outscored 40 scored UGA the Bulldogs 20-2 in the second quarter to effectively put the game out of reach by halftime. It was Duke’s first true road win against a ranked opponent since January 2014. Although the Blue Devils kept a comfortable lead throughout the last three quarters of the game, they were short of their usual performance with 15 turnovers in the first half alone. Graduate student Lexie Brown was responsible for four of them, including three early in the first quarter. Brown also forced giveaways with seven steals on the defensive

INSIDE — News 2 | Recess 5 | Sports 8 | Opinion 10 | Serving the University since 1905 |

See W. BASKETBALL on Page 8 @dukechronicle @dukebasketball |

Staff Reports The Chronicle

This year’s Old Duke concert will be headlined by rapper Lupe Fiasco, Duke University Union announced Tuesday. The Grammy-nominated artist is best known for songs including “The Show Goes On,” and “Superstar.” The concert will take place on Abele Quad April 6 from 7 p.m. to 11 p.m. Duke IDs are required for admittance. The Facebook event for the concert states that the opening act will be announced “soon.” Past acts have included singer Vanessa Carlton and and rapper Sean Kingston. Last year, rapper Lil Jon was slated to perform but had to cancel due to weather. @thedukechronicle | © 2018 The Chronicle


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
March 21, 2018 by Duke Chronicle - Issuu