The Chronicle
See Inside Duke set for top 5 showdown Page 4
T H E I N D E P E N D E N T D A I LY AT D U K E U N I V E R S I T Y
FRIDAY, JANUARY 26, 2018 DUKECHRONICLE.COM
LOCAL AND NATIONAL
Poll: Trump voters prefer Duke, Clinton voters like UNC
ONE HUNDRED AND THIRTEENTH YEAR, ISSUE 48
DUKE PSYCHIATRISTS SPEAK OUT Despite talk about President Donald Trump’s mental fitness, two psychiatrists maintain speculation is inappropriate By Sarah Kerman Senior News Reporter
By Lexi Kadis Senior News Reporter
North Carolina is just as divided during basketball season as it is during election season, according to a new poll by Public Policy Polling, a Democratic polling firm based in Raleigh. The poll surveyed 839 voters from Jan. 19 to Jan. 21 to sample the state’s current political climate. In contrast to previous years, it found that 46 percent of state voters would choose the Democratic candidate compared to the 41 percent who would vote for the Republican candidate. The press release added that North Carolinians are pleased with Democratic Gov. Roy Cooper but unhappy with the progress made by Republican President Donald Trump. “With new maps, a popular Governor, and the energy of the voters on their side Democrats are almost certain to make gains in the legislature See POLL on Page 3
Courtesy of Duke Photography Marvin Swartz, professor in psychiatry and behavioral sciences, said that inappropriate dialouge surrounding the president’s fitness could further stigmatize mental health.
Duke alum, FBI leader faces ongoing drama
Two Duke psychiatrists caution that we may not have enough information to make judgments about President Donald Trump’s fitness despite national conversation centered around his mental and physical fitness to serve. Recent discussions around the president’s mental fitness was at its peak last week when his doctor spent almost an hour taking reporters’ questions about his mental and physical health. Marvin Swartz, professor in psychiatry and behavioral sciences, co-authored a paper twelve years ago which found that 18 of the United States’ first 37 presidents met the criteria for a serious psychiatric disorder. But why the recent emphasis on the current president’s mental health? Swartz explained that one reason people may call Trump’s fitness into question is because his behavior has not generally followed decorum set by past presidents. “I think his behavior in general decorum has been such that people are questioning his judgment and his impulsivity,” he said. “So I think it has to do with the fact that he seems to be kind of erratic and says things that seem to lack the kind of judgment
Fitness to be president is on a different axis or domain than whether one is ill or not. MARVIN SWARTZ
By Bill McCarthy Staff Reporter
Deputy FBI Director Andrew McCabe, Trinity ’90, has for months been stuck at the center of a political crusade concerning alleged anti-Trump bias within the bureau. This week, he found himself wrapped up in the headlines again. On Tuesday, The Washington Post reported a May 2017 exchange in which President Donald Trump asked McCabe—who was acting FBI director at the time—whom he voted for in the 2016 presidential election. The exchange occurred shortly after Trump fired former FBI Director James Comey on May 9. The report noted that Trump also scolded McCabe about the hundreds of thousands of dollars in donations that his wife Jill had received
during her failed Virginia state senate bid in 2015. The Post’s article was the latest in a series of pieces highlighting McCabe’s strained relationship with Trump and other leading conservatives. The Chronicle dug into several earlier reports to produce a timeline of events surrounding the increasingly embattled Duke alum’s fateful few months. Jill McCabe’s state senate bid In a July 2017 Twitter storm, Trump questioned Attorney General the decision of Jeff Sessions not to replace McCabe with another acting FBI director. He wrote that McCabe was a “Comey friend” and that his wife’s political ties to Hillary Clinton were compromising. The tweets referred to Jill McCabe’s unsuccessful 2015 Virginia state
PROFESSOR IN PSYCHIATRY AND BEHAVIORAL SCIENCES
senate bid. A Democrat, she received $207,788 from the state’s Democratic party and $467,500 from a political action committee associated with former Virginia Gov. Terry McAuliffe, a political ally and close friend of Bill and Hillary Clinton. The donations caused a headache for McCabe when they were unveiled in a October 2016 Wall Street Journal report. At the time of the report, McCabe was tasked with overseeing the investigation into Clinton’s controversial private email server. But his own emails indicated that his wife’s campaign had ended three months prior to his promotion to deputy director, when he began oversight of the investigation. Nonetheless, the Trump camp hollered bias, and has been making
and decorum you’d expect from a president.” Jonathan Davidson, professor emeritus of psychiatry and behavioral sciences, co-authored a paper in 2009, which found that seven of the 18 United States presidents in office since 1908 showed hubristic traits. The paper notes that several past presidents have suffered from documented mental health issues—Roosevelt and Johnson had bipolar disorder and Kennedy suffered from Addison’s disease and amphetamine abuse. Swartz showed similar findings in his case study regarding past presidents and their mental health. He said that Abraham Lincoln had serious depression during his presidency and that Richard Nixon suffered from alcohol abuse to the extent that his staff tried to keep him away from decision making in the evenings when he was drinking.
See FBI on Page 3
See FITNESS on Page 3
Duke 2018 Off-Campus Housing Fair Tuesday, February 6 • 11 am-2 pm • Penn Pavilion Apartment Complexes • Rental Companies • Resources • Info and Goodies! Brought to you by Duke Off Campus Housing Deptartment and The Chronicle